Is The NEW Chronicled Wish Banner A SCAM In Genshin Impact?

[@Doro44c]

I think its cool for certain people, but for most i would suggest maybe saving your primos for other banners...LIKE FOR FATHER

[@poru-kun893]

Agreed, those characters and weapons can will just comeback eventually in my opinion.

[@mischarowe]

I'll wish on it when they put Tighnari on, tbh.

[@Jev_the_fluorescent_shrimp]

Nah, "father" is easiest skip

[@lovelyprincess6543]

Im not gonna pull for FATHER I'm saving for scara

[@ImaProfessionalYapper]

I’ll only spend my life savings if father is good

[@alexoceanmeow]

Someone just said "don't do it unless you have 180 wishes on hand," and I fully agree.

[@falcon_1802]

Yes, thank you. It's actually as simple as that. I've been doing that with limited banner. I only pull went I have enough wish to lose 50 50 and hit hard pity both times. It is suck to spend 180 wishes to get what I want but it's just how gacha works. The fate point is a bummer but it doesn't feel much different with how I've been doing my pulls. 😄

[@unknownkw]

Not really, for the new banner system you may pull as long as you have 90 pulls remain, in hope of an early 5 star. The reason to keep 90 is in case you get a fate point which don't carry over to the next banner. With 90 pulls in reserve you can use that fate point and get what you aimed in case it comes early and you lose 50/50. But if no 5 star appear until your remaining pull is 90 (absolute safe) or 85 (practically safe), you should stop. You won't get the 5-star you aimed but the pity will carry over to the next banner.

[@itsmeha]

I did the mistake to pull on it cause I really wanted Albedo, I had 40 wishes and I got him at 30 pity thanks god😭

[@alexoceanmeow]

@@itsmeha the "I did the error," made me laugh 😂 and also GOOD, I'm glad you got him and so early!

[@tuoritto]

​@@unknownkw It is statistically almost impossible to actually go to the 90th pull, but otherwise you aren't wrong. I'd just stay at soft pity though

[@IAMMACABEE]

The scam is the 20 day timer. The banner should last AT LEAST 2 full patches, if not more. The fact that it barely lasts more than a phase (plus the fact that 2 meta 5*s are on the horizon and Chiori’s banner is dookie) makes me think this is just a primo trap to make people fork out their PayPal in phase 2

[@whatdadogdoin141]

Some lose their 50/50 diluc to eula💀

[@Doro44c]

lmaoo thats so funny for some reason

[@allmightytony77]

I lost my Albedo 50/50 to Eula. Now I have C1 Eula.

[@venstellar]

lmao i saw that on twitter

[@wel5457]

Well reverse psychology this banner

[@kyotheman69]

funny i rather have Diluc or anyone else on that banner, physical units are trash mihoyo has done nothing for them when game is all about elemental reactions

[@Malficious]

I understand some of the trepidation. As someone who just started playing in Jan of this year i wanted Eula pretty badly and who knows when her banner would run next, so this was a great opportunity for me. I did end up getting her.

[@sarah795lopez9]

I feel that, I started playing in December and I really want Albedo. No luck yet but Im hoping

[@Malficious]

@@sarah795lopez9best of luck. Hope you get him.

[@Jazzatic2011]

Nice! Was it early or did you have a loss?

[@hexandcube]

They shouldn't remove fate points. If they want to make this banner better, they should make fate points carry over between wish events, and not reset them when you change your selection. They should also do this for the weapon banner.

[@devolays]

Alternatively, they could also remove the "guarantee" and "pity" to make things totally random, like in many other gacha games. I understand people wanting better things, but what bothers me is the lack of appreciation for things we already have. It could've been MUCH worse.

[@neanahidden]

Agreed. That would make it instantly much better. If I remember correctly the Weapon banner has a tiny bit of mercy carrying over. That if you lost in previous banner, the 25% chance of getting a standard banner weapon is removed for the first pull. Or something like that 🤔

[@superiorbunv3111]

@@neanahidden tectones staff of homeless incident :

[@neanahidden]

@@superiorbunv3111 heh, they changed it afterwards with the fait points. But yeah, I use the weapon banner so rarely I’m definitely not an expert. Just remembered some CCs talk about it. 😅

[@jex-the-notebook-guy1002]

​@@devolaysyeah no one seems to notice this. They tell me battlebrrakers isn't gacha because there are guarentees. There are guarentees in Genshin. (It was the gachagaming subreddit)

[@ManonLcz]

In my opinion this banner should either be longer than 1 phase of the regular limited banner or have the fate point carry over like the regular banner. That being said i got Itto from the regular banner (50/50 won) and Beacon from Chronicled banner (lost to Aquila then got it, both at around 65 pity) so while i dont think its a scam it definitely has room for improvement. BUT it still was a better investment for my account to pull for Beacon give it to Navia and give Serpent Spine to Itto than risk losing twice on the weapon banner just to get Redhorn when i do not have that many wishes to spare. Also i got 1 Kaeya, 2 Amber and 1 Lisa con which is an absolute win.

[@FalconGT3]

If this is how Doro acts with over the Wolfs Gravestone, I can't imagine how Bran will act.

[@Meloy148]

I'm waiting for Bran to post something about it tbh 😅

[@Doro44c]

lmaooo

[@KyleTheMan4444]

Imagine Tectone getting Wolf's Gravestone

[@mukombradon]

​@@KyleTheMan4444 my man will just quit genshin........for the 10th time

[@AwesomeDomi1]

He said that he won’t do it cause it won’t feel good to get it after all this time by guaranteeing it

[@Ferrothorn462]

8:34 "Welcome to Genshin! Welcome to *Gotcha!"* I think it's a crazy coincidence how Gacha is almost pronounced Got ya or gotcha It makes sense too

[@zachw28]

This is why Doro is the best Genshin content creator. He just tells it like it is. He gives the pros and the cons of the game. Also remember that this is a free to play game so don't expect the gacha system to be nice to you

[@SirExpertical]

I saw someone lose their 50/50 to EULA💀

[@Maria_Banks]

That’s a win

[@FrankieOutOfIt]

Fr

[@Red-io7jg]

​@@Maria_Banksye it's a win by technicality But it still a lose if she's not the one you REALLY WANT 🤷

[@MawkiieTawkiie]

That happened to me but I wanted EULA too, I want Jean, Diluc and Eula. I am not completing the Monstadt quest

[@A-Minorrrrrrr]

But honestly... Eula is kinda ass without her signature weapon

[@Ganjau]

You can get Lisa, Kaeya and Amber off this new banner making it, in my opinion, a slightly more valuable and worthwhile banner. I’ll only be pulling on this banner for specific weapons I want and don’t have like Dehya’s or Tighnari’s.

[@petruzzi6268]

Real, the 4 star Monstadt characters are a big bonus

[@shy5873]

one of the things i don't like of this banner is that you can't try the characters in it before you pull for them

[@JadeKnightfall]

Especially bad for newer players if they pull an inazuma character. With a trial, they can get them to at least 40 cause they reward the mats they need. Without trials, they can only get em to 20 till they unlock the region.

[@MeryKeit]

as a HSR player, that was the first thing that came to my mind, cuz I've been playing for only 6 months and have NO IDEA how Albedo, Klee or Eula work

[@Mr_Hoppykwins]

I mean, you will never need to level them past 40 till you get to inazuma anyway tbh@@JadeKnightfall

[@krumi_hazuki1440]

​@@Mr_Hoppykwinsatleast, you open A1 passive(like heizhou that can make His gameplay easier)

[@ceritaminit6696]

​@@MeryKeit Yt exist for a reason.

[@sara_s1737]

Did 70 pulls, finally got my hands on Skyward Harp after 3 years of wanting it and still have enough for Father. Probably never touching the banner again but if you have the primos and no patience to wait for a rerun, I think it's not a scam to go for it.

[@mikasaackerman1290]

'I've been playing genshin for so long and I still dont have a wolf's gravestone" where did I hear that again ?

[@afonsogomesgoncalves7594]

No clue

[@Xiao_lanterns_for_xiao]

His husband bran lol

[@King.Versa97]

Seriously, I don't have WGS either....

[@shyammaitry93]

Tectone : 😡

[@pratikshinde4229]

Tectone

[@eva_mv]

7:27 if they get rid the "fate point" then the 5 star would be so random,like u want diluc but becuz there no fate point you cant chose him and becuz of that maybe u will get eula then eula sig weapon then klee then becon then albedo and never get diluc

[@nameynamd9212]

They're insisting it works on pity like the character banner(removing the fate point would require a change for weapons, otherwise it'd turn into another staff of Homa-less)

[@eva_mv]

@@nameynamd9212 that what im said,it will be like tectone if they remove fate point

[@Hebiiiii1]

I haven’t played genshin in 2 weeks, I log in, and do a wish on this banner. AND I JUST GET ALBEDO 😭 like it was a welcome back gift

[@Doro44c]

LUCKY

[@Hebiiiii1]

@@Doro44c it made me cry, because I go to the very top of dragonspine. My first 5* Zhongli and my latest 5* xianyuan and I do a pull for the fun of it. And getting albedo meant sm lol

[@nycesu]

@@Hebiiiii1 i would cry tears of sadness if i pulled albedo

[@penumbrazewolf]

1 wish???

[@Hebiiiii1]

@@penumbrazewolf yeah like my first wish on the banner I got him. 😭

[@akhil8048]

It's not a scam .... It's an option that we never had before

[@Satyr42]

Cope. By the way, have you seen the HSR 2.1 anniversary stream? We got 30 free pulls! How are your three little fates going for you? You got those three Black Tassels already?

[@akhil8048]

@Satyr42 ha ha, like genshin needs to give free stuff to attract players. The game by itself is a blessing thank hoyo for making the game free..

[@johnribon2207]

@@Satyr42HSR brainrot. Genshin gave 20 during anniversary.

[@Satyr42]

@@johnribon2207 Only after the CN community raged about the lack thereof. Meanwhile HSR gets 10 free pulls every single patch and every single QoL update under the sun. The 4.4 region only gave 27 pulls after doing all the bloated chores to 100% the damned thing. What did 4.5 give you? A scam banner and a useless character that adds nothing of value besides looking pretty. Genshin stans should be ashamed of themselves for being such obedient pay pigs. And yet here they are, utterly shameless as they gobble up whatever slop Hoyo throws at them. Meanwhile their other games are feasting on a high quality dinner every single patch.

[@Satyr42]

@@akhil8048 Coping and seething. How is that free 5 star going for you? Or the non-existent QoL updates? How about the 27 pulls you got after doing all the new region's chores and busywork while Paimon repeats every single line being said because Hoyo thinks you do not have the mental capacity to understand it the first time around.

[@thishandleisfake]

For someone that wanted Klee for so long. This was it and my first ever 10 pull for tha banner, i got her. Now saving for Nuvellete and Arlechino.

[@Doro44c]

lets goooooo

[@nishh4u]

I got Klee in 30 pulls as well 😭 Yaay the terroris- ah I mean the spark night came home 💗✨

[@InsuranceWhyhire]

I need klee 😩😫😫

[@nishh4u]

@@InsuranceWhyhire you'll get her 👍🏻

[@readhoodie5740]

I also got her in the first 10 pull haha!

[@RaymondW93]

I was able to get the weapon I wanted, as well as get some constellations for Lisa and Amber, which I don't normally get because I don't pull from standard banner.

[@vashr9703]

I got albedo! I've wanted him for so long and he's finally home!

[@Doro44c]

congrats!!!

[@tim-myton6361]

That’s awesome.

[@vashr9703]

@@tim-myton6361 Thanks!

[@thesmashdancers105]

same!! and congrats!

[@vashr9703]

@@thesmashdancers105 thanks! N congrats to u too!

[@XPCHAN]

So, here is what I understand: Weapons banner: If you are in 50/50: 33% will be one of the Standard weapons, 33% will be the other weapon in that banner, and 33% is what you want If you lost 50/50 twice: 50% will be the other weapon, and 50% will be the weapon you picked Chronicled banner: If you are 50/50: 50% will be one of the weapons in the Chronicled banner, 50% will be the weapon you picked If you lost 50/50: 100% you will get the weapon you picked P/s: Sorry for the delay, my Twitch account just got banned recently

[@v0id]

I think it's a much better way for getting certain weapons. Granted, most good weapons might take some time to come around.

[@Axterix13]

You can't really get rid of the fate point, because that's what lets you select the character, while still having the 50/50 chance to start with. But they probably could let you keep the fate point, rather than setting the count back to 0. But, well, it's Hoyoverse. If they were the type of company to do that, they'd also have a max fate count of 1 on the weapon banner, rather than 2, and add a 2 point fate counter to the standard banner. The odds of them doing that are low, unless there's sufficient competition that they actually have to start trying to make players happy. Overall, though, they won't let the fate point stay here, because if they do it here, people would also expect that for the weapon banner. And they don't care enough about seeming to care about their players to have set that fate point to 1 to start with. Now, the other thing they could do that would help somewhat is have an announced schedule. Like the four stars in the shop. If we know every 8th banner will have this Mondstadt one, then players can plan ahead and have the 180 wishes set aside to guarantee what they want. But right now, there's this Mondstadt one, and we have no clue when a Liyue one will appear, nor the Inazuma one after that. And while the characters on these banners will be subpar ones, there will still be people that really want them. Because Eula being on this banner means she'll be less likely to get a regular banner. She sells poorly, so she's less than likely to get one anyway, but why run her, when you can re-run this, and also get Klee fans? But that again is another big issue with Hoyoverse customer relations. They don't want to tell us what's coming up, other than the next new five star, because they want us to spend our primos, run dry, and then open our wallets because the character that wasn't announced ahead of time now won't be back for well over half a year. Overall, they only care about getting money out of wallets, and will only do the bare minimum necessary to keep us here, rather than moving on to another game.

[@Light.Of.Kshahrewar2.0]

no -refuses to elaborate

[@Doro44c]

lmao

[@catfacecat.]

Yes -refuses to elaborate further

[@d3fury312]

Yesn't -refuses to elaborate

[@tihmiishu]

All I know is, my triple-crowned Tighnari finally has his signature weapon and it only took me 16 wishes :') Here's the big picture: only wish on this banner if you really want something on it. It's a new system that makes it so there no longer need to be 1+ year wait times between certain characters' (and their weapons) reruns because the roster is simply getting too big. So if you're a new player or had to skip some character a long time ago and now you really want them, you won't have to wait AGES for them to come back.

[@Mrbrndnbrnkly]

Exactly, I’d have paid twice what I paid for Hunters path tbh. This is such a huge upgrade for my Tighnari.

[@Marta1Buck]

"don't pull, you don't have a gun pointing to your head" *Pulled like he had a gun on his head.

[@Doro44c]

nah i did it for you to show you lol

[@DualCore-vw3ik]

@@Doro44c to show us how to summon persona?

[@Nojiko444]

I feel like this banner was scam, but still wanted to wish for the Hunters path. But Chiori sucked my primos dry so I had no chance to even try. And now the banner is gone. I wonder if we have to wait another year and a half before we get another chance for those weapons

[@cecil_242]

pulled for the hunter's path on this then dipped, probably not gonna touch this banner ever again

[@Doro44c]

congrats on the weapon! its a great one

[@danielm872]

You can select the 5* you want, if you lose 50/50 you're guaranteed to get them next time. I don't see how it is a scam... Regarding losing the Fate Point, if you lose the 50/50 on Chiori's banner and instead use your guaranteed on another banner, you won't get Chiori. It's the same principle as a regular limited character banner. I think its a great and welcome change since the amount of characters is getting bigger and bigger. I only wish they made the weapon banner have the same mechanics as well instead of requiring 2 fate points

[@Someone08328]

It's like a weapon banner but You have to spend 180 intertwined fates instead of 240(3×80) pulls at worst luck. So it's better not to pull in this banner for f2p players.

[@Doro44c]

this

[@martinmcfly5405]

Why ? If you want/need the weapon you can get it more easily?

[@durvesh007]

True I will wish on redhorn when the banner for Inazuma comes

[@eliseyganich5576]

Who nobody notices that you can get A NEW CHARACTER when losing 50/50 instead of getting useless QiQi. Especially, when Inazuma banner appear, there will be no standard characters. You just need not to spend your wishes until you get 180(150) ones and this banner will become MUCH MORE USEFUL then event banner.

[@durvesh007]

@@eliseyganich5576 true yae, yoimiya kokomi would be better than standard banner character

[@YrahSGLH]

I think it's a really good idea, for those people, who wants one of the characters or the weapons, and have a lot of intertwined fates, and don't want to skip it. However it's really difficult for those, who wants some of the other banners, and don't want to use money on this. Even I really want Diluc, I'm going to skip it.

[@badz2512]

I've wanted Albedo since the dragonspine event. There i lost the 50/50, then in his latest banner i skipped on purpose for Nahida and got her and now it was finally time to pull for him. Had 130 pulls saved for him. Won my 50/50 after 77 pulls and then had even some pulls to try to get Chiori, lost the 50/50 there, but now i have guaranteed Arlecchino. Quite happy with the banner. Yes, you need to save up a bit, to get who you want. But let's be honest there are many characters that didn't have great sales. Lately you had to wait for a lot of time to get someone like Eula. So for the people that want them it's a great chance. I wouldn't even be unhappy if i lose the 50/50 in the banner to a character like Eula or Klee and for weapons it's way better too.

[@badz2512]

And you can finally get some easy constellations for the standard 4-star characters.

[@FiniksLP]

people crying about it but tbh this is way better then having 3 character banners.

[@nueuling]

I want to preface this comment by saying that I completely agree that the scammy part of this banner is that the fate point doesn't carry over. It wouldn't be that bad if the banner was longer, perhaps for a full patch, but that's obviously not what Hoyo decided to do. That being said, I did just realize a key point to why Hoyo probably chose to use Fate Points in the first place: "charting a course" is the only way to choose between getting a character or a weapon. Obviously, "charting a course" is a mechanic that is specifically paired with the usage of Fate Points, and you CAN'T choose between characters and weapons without it. (Unless Hoyo made two new banners, but that feels very clunky imo.) I still wish that the banner was longer to alleviate this problem, but in case anybody is looking for logic-based consolation, that's what I have. (I also think that the limited amount of four star characters was a nice surprise!! More Kaeya/Lisa/Amber cons are always very nice :)

[@nueuling]

More commentary lol (i'm so sorry): I'm also frustrated that this banner requires Intertwined Fates... but not because I wish it needed Acquaint Fates. It's more similar to when they introduced dual five-star character banners: on the one hand, that's great! More reruns for characters and a more interesting patch for players! But on the other hand, I personally felt a little frantic about adding MORE choice to Wishing. Yes, single banners were kinda boring if you were skipping/pulled early, but if you WERE skipping, it was an easy skip and you didn't really have to think twice about it. And now we have FOUR LIMITED BANNERS to choose where our primos go. It's so much more difficult to call a banner set an "easy skip" because it feels a little bit like we're getting pummeled in the face by our indecision lol. Hopefully other people can relate! Rant over, thanks for listening to my TED-talk 😅

[@marfastreet]

Me: Opens "scam" banner does 7 wishes gets hunters path farms for Father ✌️

[@ender1581]

Omg that so luckyyyyy Meanwhile me only got a 4* weapon at the first 10th pull - literally at the 10th pull i got the first 4* on this banner - so now i decided to only pull for 10 on each chronicle wish banner and then stop to see which one will i get eventually 😂😅😅😅😅😅

[@MeryKeit]

oh to have 7 wishes to just throw out like that 😅

[@khanhtrong7761]

It took me exact 80 wishes to get hunter's path, but at least I didn't lose 50/50 so I'm fine with that.

[@marfastreet]

@@khanhtrong7761 yea, that's still pretty lucky

[@marfastreet]

@@MeryKeit i only had 7, i was going all or nothing 😅

[@alexanderminas28]

Doro: "I want a Wolf's Gravestone." Tectone with a bunch of Wolf's Gravestones: "Allow me to introduce myself."

[@persea__]

If it was standard wishes, as a Diluc main I would have pulled the hell out of that banner I swear, but I'm saving for Arleccino 😢

[@jonathanrobinson198]

You’re pulling for his enemies 😅

[@persea__]

@@jonathanrobinson198 I am lmao but I'm a pyro lover

[@Pulak518]

How many standard wishes you have saved bro and for what?

[@persea__]

@@Pulak518 the answer is surprisingly... None lol. I would just use the ones I'm getting in game on it instead of on the standard one lol (and just so you know, I haven't finished the game yet, so I still get a good amount of rewards daily)

[@MoodyBluesRequiem80]

​@@persea__same here. I'm Diluc main waiting for Arlecchino and Childe

[@NotOliwiec]

If you want to wish on this banner, just have 130 wishes to get specific something

[@BlackPointt]

I dont feel like its a scam you just simply save up enough so even if you lose the 50/50 ull still get what you wanted cuz i mean you do the same thing on the limited banner aswell cuz else ull miss out on that unit for maybe half year or a year etc. You just have to be smart about it and not go into it if you can do only 80~ pulls.

[@jex-the-notebook-guy1002]

Which is why im saving for Furina. Except I gambled. I lost the 50/50 on Yae to mona. I wanted to lose the 50/50 and I didn't have mona.

[@BlackPointt]

@@jex-the-notebook-guy1002 yeh thats a fine thing to do i sorta did same tried to get the past patch nahida to c2 but lost the 50/50 but didnt fuss about it since either way was cool for me and so chiori was guaranteed for me and welp i also got some blessed luck cuz it only took the next 10 pull to get her so lots of savings left now for arlecchino ^^

[@thegamingfox2630]

This is honestly just a personal issue for this banner, if you don't have enough wishes to garentee you get what you want then don't wish untill you do(like this banner is the best one if you into it with enough wishes cause imagine losing 50/50 to another limited character that's amazing) The fate point thing is annoying but just don't wish unless you have enough to garentee that's it.

[@lemonemone8883]

I think it also doesn't help that the first chronicled wish is mondstat where both 4 star and 5 star characters are super hit or miss. Because for me Beacon of the Reed Sea and Hunters Path keep coming up as options for certain characters and it always hurt i couldnt get it so its no question for me: im pulling until i get both. But I DO NOT CARE about a majority of the 5 stars minus albedo so i cant justify going for a third round for albedo. The only charas i really care about are cons for kaeya and maybe lisa. In the future when we start seeing liyue or inazuma characters dripping in: like for example, shenhe (once she gets her third run and qualifies), or we start seeing some super high quality units like Ayaka or Childe, bet u money its gonna turn into: Should i get this niche limited character who may not have their kit fully expanded on yet (example: Baizhu when he released didnt get super popular until well into fontaine and everyone clapped on that man during launch. he also launched with ganyu who had fallen in popularity) It suddenly becomes a thing where players with less complete rosters can be more selective of what characters to pull on each banner. So if you run into a scenario where you dont like the current limited banner (ex: i hate mono geo and i aint into chiori or itto kits. also the xiao and yae banner were just not it), a newer player can still walk away with adding new characters to their roster. the key to this banners fiscal success was removing the issue of consistency between banners. Mihoyo effectivley found a way to ensure a higher likelihood that their playerbase will spend their intertwined fates every single patch. I dont think its a coincidence they launched chronicled during a dead patch with a near mono geo banner.

[@julianpollock5323]

I think this system would have been a great if it wasn't intertwined fate or at the very least it was a guaranteed pull for some of these older characters

[@Orion_TheyThem]

It's not a scam. It's just like the weapon banner. Know the rules before you pull. I LOVE it because after 3 effing years of playing Genshin....I FINALLY got Mona. Leveled her all the way up because I had prefarmed and everything for her. And I got her early so I decided to pull on the weapon banner for shitz-n-giggles and got Chioris sword in the first 10 pull. And it's now on my Albedo. 😊

[@cebe9447]

i'd gladly give my freaking mona I got instead of nahida

[@paralysis_demon_hunter]

I finally got Mona too lol she was the one of the last of 8 characters I was missing

[@Orion_TheyThem]

@@paralysis_demon_hunter I'm still missing Jean but I don't want her lol. But yeah this banner was great imo

[@ananoir]

i definitely agree with that you're saying though -- and it sucks because the banner contains characters that haven't had a rerun in a very long time, and the only way for people to get one of those characters after saving for them for so long, is through this banner -- and i do not like that -- i've been waiting for an albedo banner for so long and then the one chance i get him is through a lowkey scammy banner thats similar to the weapon banner 😭😭

[@AnimeRPGgame]

Doro's voice is so calming....... i want chiori but I also want red eula

[@johns783]

I spent about 300ish wishes on this banner, and omg was it glorious. My 5 star pulls were kinda meh, but the 4 stars I got were either rare stuff or things I actually needed. Had r1 Dragons bane, got r4. 4 Kaeya cons, 2 Lisa cons, 2 Diona cons (incl c2 which i actually needed), an alley flash which is now my Benny's highest base atk weapon, amber con, fischl con, Fav warbow refine.. and a bunch of other stuff I didn't really really need but I guess more fav weapons is never a bad thing. Got Sobp by winning 5050, then lost two 5050 to albedo and klee. I got my Eula c1 and i'll get her c2 before the banner closes. It's certainly not a perfect banner but there's a bunch of really decent stuff here, and for those that want the Mond 4 star cons it's absolutely the best opportunity you're going to get. Not saying to wish FOR them, but if you're on the fence about the 5 stars then the 4 star opportunities might tip the balance to make it a banner to pull instead of skip.

[@TheRecamender]

I think the new banner is a great idea it makes it so we no longer have to wait 3 years for a banner of a character we want like we did Eula instead we wait however long it takes for the banner to switch to the next region or the region with the character we wanted

[@SuohMin]

Beautifully and well said. The only thing I'm happy about this banner is Albedo, Diluc, and Wolf's Gravestone, and at the end of the day, it's my choice whether I want to pull on it or not. It's my account, and I'm grateful enough that I can get more constellations or good weapons. Too bad some of the fan base don't see it that way.

[@petruzzi6268]

Real ^ its a chance for constellations

[@HeikaHH]

it's a godsend banner for me 😍 already set my path for Wolf's Gravestone (gonna give Diluc his weapon🥳) but i just notice there a time limit for this banner 😭 i just spend all my primo for xiao & pjws...

[@moonl1ght_dust]

I feel that sometimes, but i got SUPER lucky yesterday. I set the path for klee and the new event came out. I was just chilling getting primos by cooking potion and was pulling in the meantime. I had ni pity and no primos saved up. I was just skipping the animation adn on the sixth pull i was soo shocked and got klee!!! I was so happy and shocked lol. (Btw i had win the banner of the latest raiden until yae on low pity or less than 70 pity😁)

[@checkmate9099]

Honestly, I’m tired of Genshin players calling banners a scam… Its an OPTION, you wish on it if you choose to and you know what the odds are. (It’s the equivalent of calling the lottery a scam…) If anything, it’s better to have this banner than not having it at all.

[@arthur_pd]

Agree, if they cant control their own hand for drawing, then its not the games fault. At best, they can say is the fate doesn't carry over, but thats all...

[@tim-myton6361]

Yeah. That sounds about right.

[@rohitalia2001]

Yeah, it's the classical 'better than nothing' argument all over again. You guys should be more critical about the game.

[@MarineRX179]

This 1st one is bad because of the number of standard 5 Star characters are featured on the banner (alongside with limit 5 Star characters that many thinks have fallen off on the meta), but for future version when all or most of the 5 Star characters on it are limited 5 Star character, then losing 50/50 to a different limited 5 Star character could well be considered a win

[@fmfatral-bu9bn]

And thats why game is in state as its now, because of people like you! You think that everyone have to accept all the stupidities that hoyo throws at us with open arms and smile in the face! Fuck no! I am not gonna pull in this banner regardless since it is a scam same as weapon banner! And i havent pulled since Xianyun banner!

[@yamixerox5918]

4:30 sometimes what I do is that choose the other weapon, been getting the weapon I want 3 banners in a row. The other thing I do is that I just don't choose a path

[@akomasgaming5595]

Poor bran seeing the new banner after spending so much for wgs😂💔

[@TheToucanDragon]

I like it. It is a way for Hoyo to run even more characters as the roster keeps growing and run characters whos banners would otherwise generate low revenue. They are a company after all. Running Albedo over Neuvilette would be crazy, now they can run both!

[@hollie08cosplayer]

I remember watching this in live, i have to say, it was so funny

[@Ihavebrain_dmg]

BROTHER IM CRYING BC I WISHED A THURSDAY ON THE STANDARD BANNER (48~ pity?) AND GOT DILUC AND I WAS LIKE COOL 👍 HES NOT BAD BUT THEN THE NEXT DAY ON FRIDAY I WISH ON XIAO’S BANNER (76~ pity?) AND THEN IT TURNS GOLD AND I WAS PRAYING FOR MY LIFE BUT DILKUC SUDDENLY CAME AND I WAS CRYING😭 (now i have c1 Diluc and my bff has two wgs 🤡)

[@lmntsgames3848]

It's not a scam.. here's how you should look at it, the character banners are still the best bang for your buck, chronicled wish is a good alternative character banner, definitely worse character banner, but it definitely is a way better weapon banner than the current one.. if there's a scam banner it's the current weapon banner..

[@TacoFartsYummy]

I got jean on this banner! Used 60 of my 80 saved wishes because i wanted to get jean and get some lisa cons. Got nothing but razors but did get JEAN!! YIPPEE!!

[@SundayStarRail1]

IDK I CHARGED FOR EULA BUT I DIDENT GET HER…. YET.

[@di_sood]

I, literally, got Beacon of the Reed Sea on my first pull 😅 I 100% know I'll never get that lucky again so I won't be pulling on that banner anymore 😆

[@ChristianBaumgart-l9q]

Longterm this banner is better then the curent ones. Downside is that you have long to wait for Charakters since it takes 3 Reruns for a charakter to appear there but also the weapon with the charakter is on that banner an if you lose a 50/50 you maybe get another charakter that you dont have. I guess with time there will be alot different charakters on that banner :D. But right now its meh. It will take time until it gets rly good

[@kunoichiotaku]

I think it’s the best thing ever. Totally Not biased when I tried pulling yesterday for Hunter’s Path and got it in first 10 pulls.😂 Jokes aside I think at least it gives us opportunities to get someone we wanted for so long but so niche to get a rerun. I waited for so long to get Shenhe and Nilou (who will NOT be in the chronicled wish anytime soon then where are theyyyyyy) Also I think for this banner, just like weapon banner I think you should ONLY pull when you’re MOSTLY okay with the rest in case you lost the 50/50; just like how I have to be ok with both weapons in weapon banner to try my chance on it.

[@hajarjaber]

You are my favorite genshin impact content creater I love your vids so much

[@Doro44c]

i appreciate you!

[@karinagreif7395]

the thing what is really nice about this banner is it is first really good for new player, and also for f2p (yes even though intertwined fates are a hard to obtain item) but that fact that i can loos the "50/50" to another limited character that i don't have? For me (F2P) that's awsome... i do not have eula, klee or albedo... so my chances of getting at least one new character is sooo nice... Plus for the future, now getting cons for limited characters is also nice. at this point a lot of f2p players have a lot of cons for the lost 50/50 characters (like i have qiqi at c4) but now i could get constellations for limited characters when i lose and get a fate point... I would treat this banner more like a regular limited banner (if there is an older character/ we couldn't get up until this point) and then treat the fate point as a lost 50/50 with better loses cause of limited character cons, ...

[@Shade_of_KinG]

Damn it sucks to pay for a standart 5 star.

[@nameynamd9212]

I guess, but only those who want those characters will pull for them, so it helps not having to wait a long time for the specific Mondstat character

[@gothfalcon]

What I would say about it is that it is really only good if you want the things you would lose your 50/50 to as well. For me, I only have Mona out of the characters on it, so just about every other character on it would be useful for me. Also, the 4 star options are awesome. You have a much better chance of getting constellations for characters that usually only show up on standard banner as well as them including some limited 4 star weapons like the Alley series and Fischl's bow. So far I have gotten both Fischl's bow and The Alley Flash in less than 50 wishes, so I'm happy with it and when I finally get a 5 star, it is almost guaranteed to be one I don't have and would like having

[@ChristopherSison-m8u]

Its not a scam. Its just extra event banners though for F2P or welkin players. Whales and dolphins dont need it. F2P players will realize they can only typically pull on 1 banner per update. so its either event banner or chronicle banner. both are 50/50 and guaranteed the next. it would have been legit option though if the time is not the same as 1 phase of a banner. either an update or 2 updates (40/80 days) and it would have been perfect and viable.

[@jhonreysumagaysay2667]

What Ill do is build pity (around 65-50 wishes) when there is no new character and the rerun banners are characters I already own or dont need. Then wait for what you want and go all out if it appears so if you ever lose 50-50 you can get it on the next pity. The all rerun banner usually appear when a new nation is about to come out so its sooner.

[@12Sayii]

I love the constellations for the OG free characters (Amber, Kaeya, Lisa) coz they never get featured in other banners since the beginning, and I thinks it's really good for the new F2P players and old OG F2P players this is just my opinion, an old casual F2P player, I hope I get my c6 Barbara, finally 😅

[@HylianJayAppears]

As someone who started in November last year, I am glad this banner exists. I was able to pull Klee now I just need Lyney and now I just need Lyney to have all regional specialty people.

[@TakashiDemonServant]

Me: tries the wish Banner: I know you said Diluc c6 but here we give you Jean instead Me:…-_-

[@Senu232]

i lost 50/50 to aquila favonia on my 2nd 10 pull and got the hunters path in next 10 pull :) now i'm addicted to the banner and i have no wishes left for neuvillette 🙂

[@88Opportunist]

It's a concept that could have had potential if it was permanent and used acquaint fates...but as it stands no ways, there's always going to be another 5-star character to get a patch or 2 away. Unless perhaps they feature all weapons on here, even the newer ones, then eventually a banner might show up I need to go for...but I almost feel the normal weapon banner has better odds despite that being wrong on paper.

[@princelula5981]

As Doro said that this banner seems to feature Monstandt characters and might cycle through the other nations. I would recommend pulling if that's the case,. If you wanted to get a specific characters in a nation including 4-stars on the way, I say it might be worth it. I was amazed pulling 50 times and getting 3 4-stars characters. I haven't been that lucky in awhile.

[@Jabkaba]

I really like your view on the banner, it's so true that if they got rid of the fate point and just made it a 50/50 like in the limited banners it would acctually be a decent banner.

[@IrvGottiRumRunner]

I have NO regrets about spending on this banner, as a generally F2P player. The only bad thing about this banner was its short availability time. It should’ve lasted a month. I got Jean, Eula, Klee (none of whom I had prior) for my 5 star pulls, C6’d my Barbara, C3’d Lisa, Rosaria, Bennet, C2’d Sucrose, Fischl and Amber, and got a few others, I just need Albedo and Mondstadt Batman. I am trying to collect the Knights of Favonius as they give off such X-Men disfuncional family vibes. I would buy the $hit out of that comic book series. So yeah, not a waste for me. I stayed away from the Weapons banner because…it’s the Weapons banner. I’m sorry to say this Doro, but “ya shoulda seen dis comin’.

[@ladynikkie]

Nice I walked away with cons for Amber, Lisa, and Kaeya in which I was trying to get forever along with an Albedo and Klee as a bonus.

[@comteqfr525]

I mean the weapon side is fair, and the character one isn't bad per say, except for the fate point not carrying over.

[@qney_]

I also think that it’s gonna be an "only 5star characters from 1 zone" banner like we have mondstadt now and then it will be liyue, inazuma, sumeru, fontaine

[@hoppie4263]

The free 4 star characters from the start of the game are also more common on this banner so it’s more likely to get cons now

[@aether6167]

it is also for new players… it gives them a bigger incentive to start playing since they might to pull for characters that are already out … and if it’s region based it can also help them better understand the characters and their respective regions

[@blitzuchiha8139]

honestly, the main good thing about this banner, especially with the Mondstat one is that you’re only getting Mondstat four stars and Mondstat weapons so that means it’s easier to get characters like Amber, Lisa, and Kaeya if you want them. still not available reason to pull in the banner, but it's there

[@neri1220]

It's improvement for weapon banner, though you'd need to wait for new weapons to get there eventually. It's worse then event banner because it doesn't transfer over your wish chain. It is however a solution to those impatient and unlucky people who may now wish for the character they've been missing - granted they better save up enough fates so that even if they lose 50/50 they could still reach that 5 star pull again (if you can do that - got for it! just stop as soon as you get a 5 star otherwise you may lose unnecesarry intertwined fates). Overall i doubt i will be pulling on it, unless for the weapon. I am f2p casual player and i am patient enough to wait whole year for the character event banner to come back.

[@Umneriko]

my biggest issue with it is that any pitty that i could have used for klee that i had on the old banner is just unavailable to use and this new banner probably means klee isnt gonna be on a normal banner for a long time. so i had enough wishies for klee because of pitty but now i dont because this new banner doesnt use the old pitty.

[@j.i.m.s6027]

When I first started playing 4 months ago, my first 2 5* were two Wolf’s gravestone. I was upset getting it twice in a row but it seems like the two wolf’s gravestone I got were yours and Bran. 😂

[@yursor]

I think the fate point sucks but in the end this is exactly what we all have asked for a way to get characters and weapons without having to wait years for them to get a rerun. They started off this banner with Eula and Albedo two characters with some of the longest rerun waits, and the Hunter's Path which we haven't seen in forever. This banner has a bad mechanic but is still amazing.

[@DemonicRobots]

I see this as a catch up banner. If you started Genshin only a couple of months ago you haven't had a chance for a lot of characters, so this lets you get some of the older ones you haven't seen

[@yourlocalyanfei]

I just wish we had trials for the characters featured. Especially for newer players who don’t know how a character works

[@RebekahHaasCrochet]

I feel like it's great for people who want to build constellations for their favorite characters.

[@CF_fr]

I think it's very cool in the long run. they labeled it as a "mondstat only banner with mondstat characters. I think it's a good way to limit useless re-runs and put characters of said finished region in their own banner. If the keep doing it for Liyue, inazuma and so on it could be very cool.

[@CaramelMarkhiato]

Saw someone put a great comment on this but a grind to do. First, have atleast 100 wishes, then do 1 10 pull every Chronicle Wish banner, & when you get a 5 star and you lose the 50/50, you get 1 fate point and then you can use your 90 wishes to get the guaranteed character that you want!

[@stuartpratuch7036]

I think genshin just wants to make sure every banner has its pros and cons. We’ll see if they choose to improve it in the future but for the time being this is a great way preemptively strike against the triple/quadruple/quintuple limited banners we’d otherwise need.

[@meryzartstuff]

Thank you for explaining this banner. I don't really wanna pull on it, maybe when tighnari is gonna be on it, i want more cons for him, but yeah, like you said it's really not worth it unless you really want a certain character or weapon. Should be called veteran player banner instead XD

[@Mrbrndnbrnkly]

This was the first opportunity to pull for hunter’s path since tighnari’s launch. I’ve got him c5 from 50/50’s and have been dying for a way to get this weapon. Lost my 50/50 to skyward pride and bought $100 in primos. Fully worth it as that was a must pull for me.

[@mangaberry5681]

honestly i love this banner because i've been trying for cyno's weapon for every rerun he had, this banner only needing 1 fate point is like a savior to my pain of loosing 5050 on the weapon banner

[@ItzLumineLilly]

Honestly, the weapon pulls are mainly the scam which I never pulled a weapon banner one time. I go for the characters only and I’m trying to get an 5-Star because I’m broke. Oh yeah! I was in your twitch stream yesterday chatting if you don’t recognize me! I’m ItzLumineLilly! That’s my name! You were the first Twitch stream I went to because I had never gone to a Twitch stream before it was my first time and that was fun! I ended up passing out asleep during it so I couldn’t finish watching your whole stream! I’m up to watch your Twitch streams again! It was awesome!

[@ultrachrishyandjayzenjoyer]

There's a chance you get C1 of a character. It's practically standard and event character banner cross over but limited

[@nazgul4220]

I wished on this yesterday. I am at 70 pity on characters and I wanted another Albedo Constellation. After 20 wishes I sadly realized, that pity doesn't carry over either. So with 80 pulls total I luckily got Albedo (and even a Lisa), but that was pretty risky.

[@slhpproductions6707]

I think this banner us meant for new players maybe. Imagine you're in lyuie rn and you get chiori because you don't understand how the game works quite yet. Well, the only options you have is to put her on hold or walk all the way to fontaine just to ascend her. If you have a chronicled banner that cycles through characters from these early phases new characters can just wish on character they've already encountered and liked. This also frees the special banners from reruning certain old characters and they can just focus on the new ones coming out. And, if you really want a character like Eula she's gonna be running more frequently and you can conserve your primos accordingly. I still think they should've used standard wishes tho. I'm willing to bet they'll change that at some point because at this point i doesn't see this banner making much money for them.

[@Dragon0255]

The easiest way to make us happy would be that the Fate Point would carry over to the Next Monstadt Banner. Same for the other Banners. With this they would still get Revenue because you still need Gems for the Other Banners. With this it would be even a better 50/50 System then the Limetet/Standart Banner. They could even move more Charakters over Time with this too this Type of Banner. But thats all just Whischfull Thinking.

[@hly1226]

I wished and I think I used up all my luck for this banner for life. I wanted Albedo, after 3 years, and I got him! In 30 wishes. He also brought Eula and Fichle's bow (which I didn't know was on this banner) in the same 10 pull. This will never happen to me again. 😅 lol, I even took a picture for memory.