Is this the return of American Streamliners?: A Ramble About The FRA Long Distance Trains Proposal

  Рет қаралды 32,706

How We Get Around

How We Get Around

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 382
@noahvoris3637
@noahvoris3637 8 ай бұрын
This is something the US desperately needs! Amtrak is a great alternative for the increased inconvenient and expensive nature of driving and flying. 😊
@afcgeo882
@afcgeo882 7 ай бұрын
It “desperately needs” it? What do you base that on? Who actually “needs” this? Amtrak ridership keeps going down, not up and its infrastructure is arguably far worse today than it was 20-30 years ago. In fact, it pretty much has none outside of the NE Corridor. These proposals are going to finally bankrupt Amtrak because they’re failing to address the actual transportation needs of this country. What Amtrak needs to do is invest in high speed services between major cities that would be 4-6 hours between each other, and overnight services between cities that would be 8-10 hours in length. Shorter routes increase predictability in services, reduce delays, and increase ridership while keeping investments down to palatable levels.
@qjtvaddict
@qjtvaddict 3 ай бұрын
Yeah something single LD trains simply aren’t
@qjtvaddict
@qjtvaddict 3 ай бұрын
@@afcgeo882too sane
@MrExec3549
@MrExec3549 8 ай бұрын
I’m in the railroad industry and worked during some sad times in the industry. This is GREAT NEWS for our industry. I always felt that passenger railroading, commuter, and long distance would be reborn. And now, I’m witnessing it.
@migjing23OCMCHS
@migjing23OCMCHS 7 ай бұрын
And this time hopefully it wont go away again
@qjtvaddict
@qjtvaddict 3 ай бұрын
Give up on long distance just break em up into shorter runs that have more trips based on the segments
@himbourbanist
@himbourbanist 8 ай бұрын
I really hope Amtrak takes the Sleeper Pod idea seriously and introduces them as an option, it would work so well for their long distance routes. They could fit more bunks on a given car, and the accommodation could be cheaper than the current roomettes. Maybe they could even have a "super budget sleeper" that doesn't include meals and is only a little pricier than coach.
@odess4sd4d
@odess4sd4d 8 ай бұрын
I like this line of thinking but the old slumbercoach layout is more practical for multi-day trips. There aren't enough lounge seats for all the pod passengers who want someplace to sit!
@ronclark9724
@ronclark9724 8 ай бұрын
Almost all of the European sleeper trains run from 8 PM to 8 AM, whereas Amtrak America sleeper trains usually run 24 hours, if not more. Those pods might work in Europe during the night, but in America the pods will not suffice during the day. Many Americans find roomettes too tiny, the pods would be coffins. As it is even Europeans are finding pods coffins...
@Hahlen
@Hahlen 8 ай бұрын
@@ronclark9724simple solution (with enough funding) is to have multiple observation/lounge/cafe cars on all the 18+ hour long trains for people to hang out in during the day.
@himbourbanist
@himbourbanist 8 ай бұрын
I follow your logic here, but I do think there's still a market for it and people will take it up as long as there's a cafe car / sightseer lounge to stretch your legs in. Routes like the Silver services and the Lake Shore Limited would be perfect for the bunk/pod layout. I know myself and a sleeper train trip in a bunk like the Nightjets sounds kind of cozy and nice, especially with my laptop and some movies to watch, I can't be the only person who feels that way. I see what you mean though, it might not be for everyone and larger accommodations should definitely still be made available, especially for accessibility purposes. @@ronclark9724
@DaMan-jt6dh
@DaMan-jt6dh 8 ай бұрын
​@@ronclark9724it's a shame most European citizens can't afford to ride them because they make next to nothing.
@FrederickJenny
@FrederickJenny 8 ай бұрын
I am so happy to see more lines going into salt lake city (pioneer and desert winds). Now if we could just get the train station there ready with the Rio Grande Plan! Thanks for another great video.
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority 7 ай бұрын
yup agree
@FishyAltFishy
@FishyAltFishy 8 ай бұрын
Amtrak really needs to do something about ticket price, its almost always twice as expensive as flying while taking five times as long to get there.
@ronclark9724
@ronclark9724 8 ай бұрын
However, every night on the train is one LESS night at an expensive hotel whether driving or flying. If you flew there in hours instead of a day, you would most likely spend another day and night there. If you are in a hurry and do not wish to see America, FLY. But if you are not in a hurry and do wish to see America, ride with Amtrak. Nothing beats Amtrak prices riding in coach for most of Amtrak's rural small town stations...
@stickynorth
@stickynorth 7 ай бұрын
Agreed. It needs to offer different product classes. My suggestion? Offer capsule bed/rooms like in Japan and Europe... Even the new overnight ones in Germany have this as an affordable option... It really needn't cost more than $50 for the entire trip if you ask me...
@afcgeo882
@afcgeo882 7 ай бұрын
@@ronclark9724Sorry, but no. NYC to LA costs over $4000 each way for a bedroom.
@afcgeo882
@afcgeo882 7 ай бұрын
@@stickynorthWhere in Japan or Europe do you see rail services that span 3000 miles?
@TomHoffman-uw7pf
@TomHoffman-uw7pf 6 ай бұрын
@@ronclark9724 Rural small towns depend on Amtrak if they're lucky enough to have it. Wanna try and land a 737 in Hinton, West Virginia? 🙂
@kiewies
@kiewies 8 ай бұрын
I'm sitting at my breakfast table, sipping on my coffee, and I'm fantasizing about all the trips I could suddenly take north, south, east & west from my home in Missouri. I hope I'm whizzing past cows and farmlands while sipping on coffee soon. Excited to see any or all of these new services come to fruition.
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority 8 ай бұрын
we resemble this remark, kiki!
@bryanirwin5473
@bryanirwin5473 8 ай бұрын
The North Coast Hiawatha route would pass through Glendive, Montana. Offering access to Makoshika State Park which is really an underserved hidden gem that if given the chance, everyone should go see.
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority 8 ай бұрын
couldn't agree more, Bryan
@DiamondKingStudios
@DiamondKingStudios 6 ай бұрын
@@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthorityWell, this channel must have some reach for y’all to make it here. I hope the cities of Minnesota get reliable passenger service soon, as someone from another state whose cities are largely deprived of passenger rail (Georgia).
@brianr4054
@brianr4054 8 ай бұрын
Denver to Houston would be great because there is no competing Interstate highway along most of the route.
@qjtvaddict
@qjtvaddict 8 ай бұрын
Perfect for a Shinkansen service
@ronclark9724
@ronclark9724 8 ай бұрын
@@qjtvaddict Too far for HSR, whose sweet spot is around THREE hours train journey no matter the speed of the train. If you are going to spend TRILLIONS building HSR, it better win the passenger battle with the airlines, otherwise why bother?
@ronclark9724
@ronclark9724 8 ай бұрын
The former Burlington Texas Zephyr, a train I fondly remember during the Christmas holidays riding on the ski train from Texas to the Colorado Rockies... While US 287 and US 87 mayo't be interstates, they are divided highway along this former Burlington route...
@afcgeo882
@afcgeo882 7 ай бұрын
Actually, the better route would be Denver to Houston as an overnight service. At roughly 800 miles, it is IDEAL for it. There are already plans for HSR connecting Dallas to Houston, which would finish out the trip.
@qjtvaddict
@qjtvaddict 6 ай бұрын
@@ronclark9724that’s BS it has no competition speed closes the distance making the service worth it
@bryanirwin5473
@bryanirwin5473 8 ай бұрын
Comment for Al's go-rhythm so this can be more widely viewed.
@RailAceProd8501
@RailAceProd8501 8 ай бұрын
I should mention that the Sunset Limited is going to be rerouted back to Phoenix.
@TomHoffman-uw7pf
@TomHoffman-uw7pf 6 ай бұрын
Good, because Maricopa is 30 miles S and in the middle of nowhere.
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority 8 ай бұрын
Steve, we so appreciate your thoughtful and informative videos and commentary!
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly 8 ай бұрын
Thanks for watching! I'm wishing you guys all the best in bringing back the North Coast Hiawatha! Montana and North Dakota deserve a good train service, and I can tell you and your team see that! Definitely want to head out there on the North Coast Hiawatha one day in the near future!
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority 7 ай бұрын
we will send you the details about our annual meeting Friday June 7th (the day after the FRA LD Service Study Meeting) and perhaps you can come ?@@SteveGettingAroundPhilly
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly 7 ай бұрын
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority I'd love to see it, though distance may be a concern living out on the East Coast. If there is a way to watch online, that would be great, but I'll see if I can find a way out there, though I do question being able to as it stands.
@13thFlProductions
@13thFlProductions 8 ай бұрын
New Amtrak Long Distance service could be a huge upgrade for Amtrak service. So many states and cities have absolutely nothing to go on with rail because they don't even know what taking a train is like, or maybe they did but only saw Amtrak LD services that were cut in the 70s - 90s with serious issues. Giving states new federally funded rail service that can't be tanked by car-brained DOTs and state legislatures can start to drive demand for rail and put pressure on the state to go further. I will be very happy to ride the revived Floridian and Hummingbird trains as well as 3C+D and hopefully a future corridor service for Cincy - Louisville and Cincy - Chicago.
@qjtvaddict
@qjtvaddict 8 ай бұрын
Buses are more frequent and useful. Why not build dedicated tracks if you want trains? Only way to bypass carbrain is HSR and intercity feeders and regional branch rail lines to serve rural areas like a long distance version of the crosstown lines in urban centers globally
@ronclark9724
@ronclark9724 8 ай бұрын
@@qjtvaddict HSR has a sweet spot of around a THREE hours train journey no matter the speed of the train competing for passengers with the airlines WORLDWIDE. Most people beyond THREE hours FLY, or drive...
@Harvey-x7d
@Harvey-x7d Ай бұрын
Daytime Cincinnati - Chicago round trips would use existing infrastructure and easily implementable before costly faster improvements are needed.
@history_leisure
@history_leisure 8 ай бұрын
For the North Coast Hiawatha, I've though of either dropping the Hiawatha to avoid confusion with the Hiawatha as long as there is no "Midwest Corridor" designation or Republic to give the Empire Builder/Republic a similar banner name like the Silver Service between Chicago and Cascadia. I've also thought of the Sierra Service as a rename of the Coast Starlight and Daylight restoration with a second service along the San Joaquins route and/or via Bend and potentially Yakima
@divox9pqr
@divox9pqr 8 ай бұрын
The sleeper pod is an interesting adaptation. I would definitely try it out for my Long distance sleeping needs. During the day hours, time could be spent in an observation lounge. Also, the frequency of trains on a 12 hour cycle would definitely increase ridership., and I totally champion the use of new routes to include Cincinnati’s beautiful art deco museum station. Lastly restore the Sunset Ltd to its original route, and cheers for the Detroit to New Orleans, and the Floridian routes.
@ronclark9724
@ronclark9724 8 ай бұрын
What if the coach seats were sold out, that observation or lounge car seat may not be available... Could you ride in your pod. or should I say coffin, during the day?
@TheMrPeteChannel
@TheMrPeteChannel 7 ай бұрын
I don't think that pod we be popular facing that way. They should return to the bunk style with 3 levels.
@chicagolandrailroader
@chicagolandrailroader 8 ай бұрын
Thanks for going in depth on this topic. I hope at least a few of these routes will become a reality. Your channel is criminally underated. Thank you!
@Chescat124
@Chescat124 8 ай бұрын
I feel like if we had these trains back and these new ones, it would probably benefit a lot. Heck, possibly bringing back streamliners never operated by Amtrak. Also as someone from Chicago, *we need the Floridian back*
@gonzoengineering4894
@gonzoengineering4894 8 ай бұрын
I mean Amtrak did operate GG1s at one point, but they weren't exactly glamorous by that point
@TomHoffman-uw7pf
@TomHoffman-uw7pf 8 ай бұрын
​@@gonzoengineering4894Not with that flat black paint job
@HighHolyOne
@HighHolyOne 8 ай бұрын
Amtrak MUST bring back the SLUMBERCOACH!!! without plumbing is ok, since I understand that was their downfall. But we MUST have a cheaper sleep accommodation than the roomette! A huge number of us cannot sleep in coach seats.
@migjing23OCMCHS
@migjing23OCMCHS 7 ай бұрын
i greatly loved your detailed deep dive into the future routes amtrak has cookin in the background. i cant wait to ride these new routes when they come online
@ilikehardplay
@ilikehardplay 2 ай бұрын
I remember riding Amtrak's combined Desert Wind/California Zephyr back in the mid 1980s from Los Angeles, CA to Glenwood Springs, CO.....but the Desert Wind certainly did not extend to Denver or Cheyanne. Rather both the Desert Wind and the Pioneer ran from their respective coasts to meet at Salt Lake City with the California Zephyr, where through cars headed east were added to the Zephyr (...and presumably, the Westbound Zephyr detached through cars for Los Angeles and Portland...) It was timed with all three Eastbound trains arriving in the early a.m. hours. I was woken at about 5 a.m. by our arrival in SLC, and watched the switching from the station platform while I ducked out to get a newspaper. I'll be honest. I think a return to these two routes by this model is a lot more practical than your Desert Wind routed over Sherman Hill to Cheyanne and then Denver from the North.
@cornkopp2985
@cornkopp2985 8 ай бұрын
Several things to say for this video: 1. I actually think the billings to el paso route is even better than you'd initially think. The Denver-Albaquerque-el paso corridor is a massive connection on its own, and can also pave the way for more daytime corridor trains too. Also it might have some pretty incredible scenery too. 2. I'm in favor of a new superliner replacement to be a single level car. IMO its past time due for amtrak to try and create a national standard for their long distance cars from a logistics standpoint, and from an aesthetic standpoint I'm very curious what a new observation car would look like for that design, and I'd like to see an observation car on all the eastern routes as well. 3. I almost forgot, but I totally agree about 12 hour service patterns. I really hope that we can start trialing that sort of service on a few of the more popular long distance trains that currently run, and slowly phase it in throughout the national network. It would be a total game changer if every single station had a minimum of 1 daylight train in each direction.
@timnewman1172
@timnewman1172 8 ай бұрын
The other component to this is prioritizing passenger service so these trains can operate on time... people will not use them if they can't make connections or miss important events because their train ran several hours late!
@vincebreen3-55
@vincebreen3-55 8 ай бұрын
Shorter routes could also help That way it's not disrupting freight. But then I know in many places BNSF is maintaining a third main that could expedite passenger travel
@afcgeo882
@afcgeo882 7 ай бұрын
To point 3: there just isn’t demand for this. Trains would run pretty empty.
@afcgeo882
@afcgeo882 7 ай бұрын
@@timnewman1172Amtrak can’t prioritize a thing as they don’t own any rail outside of the Northeast.
@vincebreen3-55
@vincebreen3-55 7 ай бұрын
By only running daytime trains with routes of 12 hours distance performance would improve. AMTRAK CAL runs 4 or 5 daily from San Diego beyond Santa Barbara that run with freight and local commuter trains very successful. You run short trains and add more cars as demand increases
@bryanirwin5473
@bryanirwin5473 8 ай бұрын
I just finished your video and have to compliment you on a job very well done. One item I think you may have overlooked is the potential addition revenue from European tourists being able to use a rail system they may somewhat recognize. Especially if they are reluctant to tackle long distance travel via automobile on American roads. As Americans I think we often forget just how vast this country really is and that many of our states are the size of some countries.
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly 8 ай бұрын
Would definitely agree there. It would certainly make it a lot more enticing for tourists of all stripes since good transport systems can benefit visitors the way it can locals. It's true for a city transit system, and it's true for long-distance trains, too.
@corsacs3879
@corsacs3879 8 ай бұрын
as one of those european tourists i 100% agree. when i visited canada last year i only checked trains. it’s definitely something we just default to doing even when abroad
@himbourbanist
@himbourbanist 8 ай бұрын
definitely agreed. I'm American and I know that the last thing I want to do when I get to a city is go through the hassle and expense of renting a car. An extensive network of trains benefits everyone
@odess4sd4d
@odess4sd4d 8 ай бұрын
The sleeper pods are a great idea for true night trains, but i can't imagine being cooped up in one for two days on a long distance train. We already had a solution, let's bring back the slumbercoach.
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly 8 ай бұрын
Not a bad idea either. The slumbercoach was definitely one of those ideas that was a genuinely good idea but just came too late the first time. Maybe this can be its chance to truly shine like it should have!
@cardiffchris
@cardiffchris 7 ай бұрын
Desert Wind and The Pioneer connect their cars to the California Zephyr in Salt Lake City and Denver becoming one train east bound. Last time I rode the California Zephyr it was still this way. The year of 1994 was also a tragic one - three smokejumpers were among the 14 firefighters who lost their lives July 6 on the South Canyon Fire near Glenwood Springs, Colorado. We slipped through Glenwood Springs the day it happened, but before the fire really got going.
@stickynorth
@stickynorth 7 ай бұрын
What I would like to see is a commitment to create an Interstate Rail System that would allow 125 mph intercity service along existing Interstate corridors where traditional routes would be too slow or over-crowded with cargo traffic. At that speed day or night service could cover most of America from a handful of regional hub cities i.e. Los Angeles, Seattle, Denver, Dallas, Atlanta, Miami, Chicago, New York... This would also get around the major hurdle to building new rail (property ROW acquisition) as Texas and California are soon finding out...
@GeneralLiuofBoston1911
@GeneralLiuofBoston1911 8 ай бұрын
I sat down and listened to this over one hour piece. Sure, it is called a rant, but it was well put together and thought out with some great ideas. The names for services were creative (my favorite being the Lakota and Black Hills). I feel very much more hopeful and the casual style of your video made it nice to listen in while doing my work.
@dungeonbeast1087
@dungeonbeast1087 8 ай бұрын
cities and towns need to increase in density, walkability, and mixed used zoning by ten times in order for these routes to see any inkling of success
@alexanderboulton2123
@alexanderboulton2123 3 ай бұрын
We should have short-hop rail between cities! More reliable, less chance for delays and infinitely scalable!
@timnewman1172
@timnewman1172 8 ай бұрын
The "Great Plains Rocket" is a perfect name! Reviving the "Golden State" name for the California train is also a great choice...
@desertranger1721
@desertranger1721 8 ай бұрын
Thanks for this great breakdown of the FRA preferred routes plan. As an Albuquerque resident a north-south route connecting us to Denver and El Paso would be an awesome addition! Especially since I’m not a fan of the drives.
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority 8 ай бұрын
we are very optimistic about this too...
@DiamondKingStudios
@DiamondKingStudios 6 ай бұрын
My main area of interest is the Houston-NY proposal, since not only does it connect many Appalachian communities that could benefit from a return to passenger rail service, it also comes closest to my hometown in Georgia, which hasn’t seen any regular passenger rail since 1971 being on the _City of Miami_ that was cancelled in favor of the _South Wind/Floridian._ Even though we won’t get direct service (Opelika, AL and LaGrange, GA would be the closest stations, and each is at least a half-hour drive away), it’s still good for the state as a whole, and may counter the effects of staffing our state government full of NIMBYs unlike North Carolina and their state-supported system.
@spuds6423
@spuds6423 8 ай бұрын
The problem is capacity and equipment. Last week I was taking the Auto train North from Sanford to Lorton. While we left 15 minutes early, north of DeLand we got word that the Amtrak train ahead of us hit a trespasser and there was a 3 to 4 hours delay while Law Enforcement did their investigation. We got held up later because of a priority freight and we had to do a crew change for a conductor because their shift timed out. Later we had electrical problems in Richmond and 20 minutes south of Lorton we ran out of fuel... We were supposed to be in at 10 am on Sunday but got in at 5 PM ..... people were not happy. Yes, we got a 200 dollar limited credit for a future trip but this is to be expected more in the future because people refuse to understand that railroads can be dangerous places and that passenger service runs as a loss no matter how efficient it tries to reinvent itself. Foamers and Politicians refuse to understand this.
@johnsmith9165
@johnsmith9165 8 ай бұрын
The California Zephyr does not serve Des Moines. The closest it gets is Osceola, a much smaller town of about 5,000 people 45 miles south of Des Moines.
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly 8 ай бұрын
Ah yes, thanks for the correction. Kind of like what Maricopa is for Phoenix at the moment. Hope that this can mean at some point that it can be rerouted to directly serve Des Moines, since that seems to be what's indicated on the map, but we'll wait and see I guess.
@qjtvaddict
@qjtvaddict 8 ай бұрын
It’s hot garbage and should be replaced by HSR and intercity buses and strategic state sponsored local trains.
@bradyolson4690
@bradyolson4690 8 ай бұрын
@@SteveGettingAroundPhillyunfortunately not happening on the Zephyr. That would require using the Iowa Interstate Railroad, which has spent years blocking the Quad Cities service to Moline.
@timnewman1172
@timnewman1172 8 ай бұрын
​​​@@bradyolson4690 unfortunately IAIS can't see their nose to spite their face... the $ millions Amtrak would bring in track & infrastructure upgrades would easily offset any inconvenience to their modest freight traffic. The Rock Island easily operated five times the trains over the same line, even into their death rattle in the late 70's!
@timnewman1172
@timnewman1172 8 ай бұрын
Another change that needs to be made to have this be a realistic consideration is to extend service westward to Des Moines... running at least 2 trains daily each way would make this route attractive to potential riders... The biggest obstacle to this plan is the State of Iowa itself, which cannot even prioritize education & ranks at the bottom for defficient bridges in the nation!
@MasterSanders
@MasterSanders 8 ай бұрын
I’ve long thought that East Tennessee has needed an Amtrak connection. The area is very touristy with a lot of out state visitors. I’m particularly excited about such a possibility, along with the restoration of the Pioneer.
@stephenkeever6029
@stephenkeever6029 8 ай бұрын
Really enjoyable ramble! I'm right there with you on the Broadway Limited!
@ETNLWM
@ETNLWM 8 ай бұрын
I understand the skepticism of the Houston to New York route. Connecting Knoxville and Chattanooga to Atlanta along with the connection to DC and the North East will be popular. We just need a chance.
@Al3ixhoveutot
@Al3ixhoveutot 8 ай бұрын
True nightrains do not take 24h to go to their destination, they tipically take no more than 12h. For example if ViaRail and Amtrak agreed, they could take the Adirondak and the Maple Leaf and make them run overnight, leaving and not stopping at any station in the middle except the relevant ones, leaving at 8pm and reching their destination by 8am. Much more useful, plus they could implement the sleeping pods for greater affordsbility
@DaMan-jt6dh
@DaMan-jt6dh 8 ай бұрын
I know its not practical for all people, however i rode on the zephyr from SLC to Sac last year and many people were just sleeping in their coach seats. I also met a mother and her kids that were riding from Buffalo NY all the way to Oakland CA and the entire time they were just sleeping in the lounge/view cars on the floor. Multiple people sleep in there at night and at least for coach people the floor of the view car gives a nice place to lie down. Its a cost effective option bare minimum.
@jacobl1657
@jacobl1657 8 ай бұрын
I think Sioux Falls as a connection is a sleeper. Lived there for 3 years and it could definitely benefit from a service to surrounding cities. The city is booming right now with housing selling as it hits the market. Tons of folks run to the cities as they're fans of the sports teams from MN and it could also compete with the region jet service to MSP, since most all flights from Sioux Falls run to MSP, Denver, or ORD. Omaha is another big place of weekend travel. I think removing the 3-4 hour car trips to other cities with rail would be super attractive. Not to mention, you might see a fair amount of business travel as well. I used to travel the Dakotas for work and if I could've taken a train to Pierre or Rapid, I probably would've (if the timetable was decent).
@Harvey-x7d
@Harvey-x7d Ай бұрын
Possible MSP - OMA regional connector.
@Dexter037S4
@Dexter037S4 8 ай бұрын
I think Amtrak or a multinational subsidiary should take over the VIA long distance routes if PoiLIEvre cuts VIA (which is likely) Also word on the street is VIA will be equipping half of it's Manor cars with Sleeper pods during the next refit to last until 2035, when they'll be cut or replaced. The New Orleans-Detroit route is also more than likely actually meant to signify a New Orleans to Toronto route, as Detroit-Toronto is currently being looked at by both VIA and Amtrak.
@TheRandCrews
@TheRandCrews 8 ай бұрын
where’d did you hear about the sleeper pod idea? Also Via Rail is probably going to be privatized with the HFR project being proposed to be so and even the Corridor service.
@qjtvaddict
@qjtvaddict 8 ай бұрын
@@TheRandCrewsok
@PrograError
@PrograError 7 ай бұрын
Wait... isn't VIA the Canadian's Amtrak technically?
@Dexter037S4
@Dexter037S4 7 ай бұрын
@@TheRandCrews It's a public private partnership, not a privatization (although it can become one under Poilievre, probably Brightline North)
@Harvey-x7d
@Harvey-x7d Ай бұрын
DET-TOR also could run by Port Huron and still serve the current Detroit station.
@therocinante3443
@therocinante3443 4 ай бұрын
I'll be taking my first longer than 1 hour train trip this year. A roomette on the Silver Service about 1,000 miles. I'm super excited!
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly 4 ай бұрын
Sounds like a great trip ahead! Hope you enjoy it!
@kskssxoxskskss2189
@kskssxoxskskss2189 7 ай бұрын
Hello from Cincinnati. We desperately need a set of trains running parallel to I-75, from Canada to the southern tip of Florida via Atlanta. There is plenty of opportunity to get automobiles out of several huge bottlenecks along the way.
@jfmezei
@jfmezei 7 ай бұрын
Nightjet Viaggios are not entirely permanently coupled because their trains split and recombine during a single journey to serve different cities with shared segments. They are also sometimes coupled with other railway's cars for shared services (so a Nightjet may be mixed with a MAV train to Budapest, PKP to Warsaw etc). Having normal consists allows for changes in capacity between winter and summer or when there is a charter (a whole school booking on same train so Amtrak adds cars to it). One aspect against the Superliner design as the ADA compliance, unless they add elevators in each car. You start to lose space and single deck like Viewliners an become easier for ADA. It also depends on what the current charging method for Amtrak using legacy freight railroads works. Is it still by the car, or by weight, or by train that fits within all sidings? Since the legacy signaling works by block, it doesn't make much of a difference if a train occupies 2 cars on a block or 15 cars, and as long as the trains fit within sidings, it doesn't matter if you fill 10% or 90% of the siding. But if the charging method is still by the number of cars, then double deck trains reduce number of cars you need.
@morat242
@morat242 8 ай бұрын
There's a better cheap sleeper option than the pods. The Nightjet pod cars have 40 berths. The CRH2E-NG cars in China have 60 berths, and each person gets more room (your feet go into a tunnel that becomes the table of the next room). As a bonus, they're 2 feet shorter than a Viewliner, meaning you could increase the height and upgrade each pod to be a lie-flat seat like an airliner. Replace the curtains with doors, cut back a few to put in an ADA pod, job done. If you've seen the RFP Amtrak put out for their Superliner replacement, the idea is the "Solo Suite" but giving up the headroom so you can stack two of them. That also has an improvement that the seats alternate direction, so above where the feet overlap you have a lockable sliding divider, so they can flex between solo and paired passengers. That means you don't need roomettes, and you kind of don't need LD coaches either (same number of seat pods as on an Amfleet 2).
@pdxmack
@pdxmack 8 ай бұрын
As a corporate traveler, I prefer rail travel over driving or flying. The reason is because I can work while traveling with plenty of room (using a sleeper room).
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority 8 ай бұрын
💯
@Robert0Pirie
@Robert0Pirie 8 ай бұрын
The proposed San Francisco to Dallas train should be called the "Twin Star" referencing the stars that appear on the flags of both states. If memory serves, the red star on California's flag is actually a bit of a nod to the "Lone Star" on the Texas flag. I would also love to see a sleeper service cross the Gulf of Mexico's coast from Corpus Christi, TX to Fort Myers, FL; by way of Houston, New Orleans, Mobile, Tallahassee, Orlando, and Tampa. That's easily an 18 to 22 hour journey. It would be a huge draw for the scenic route fans and tourists as well as provide service to under served and rural communities. Call it the "Gulf Coaster" or something like that. While an AutoTrain service between Chicagoland and Florida would do extremely well, along the Gulf Coast would also work well. Like from the suburbs of Houston direct to Sanford, FL... lots of tourist and business traffic between those two destinations along the I-10 corridor. Also love the thought of pairing sleeper trains with a second day-side service. This could be easily trialed on the existing City of New Orleans... it's already a popular route that has fairly good on-time performance and is about 12 hours long so the timing fits.
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority
@BigSkyPassengerRailAuthority 8 ай бұрын
interesting naming idea!
@dt7353
@dt7353 3 ай бұрын
No one ever mentions in these videos that in Oregon amtrak turns east when it leaves Eugene and skips Medford (metro population 220,000) on its way to California. It should stay on I5 and service Roseburg, Grants Pass and Medford instead of just passing through wilderness.
@AutoReport1
@AutoReport1 8 ай бұрын
Rural communities don't need sleepers, they need hourly service to the nearest larger town or small cities to create a virtual urban area that will attract residents.
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly 8 ай бұрын
Can definitely agree there. In my estimation, most cities and metro areas should have some form of frequent regional rail service to link towns and cities. The population is there, and a good service can draw in the demand that's been dormant for so long. My home state of Pennsylvania as a whole has unbelievable potential in that regard, and it's simply not being pursued, even though there are plans for rail service being brought back to the Lehigh Valley in the northeast of the state that could be a great cornerstone to build on, alongside SEPTA in Philly.
@kskssxoxskskss2189
@kskssxoxskskss2189 7 ай бұрын
Should be a both-and situation because once the tracks are good, capacity depends on labor, fuel, and equipment.
@PrograError
@PrograError 7 ай бұрын
@@kskssxoxskskss2189 I wonder state based rail corridors would be more plausible with Amtrak just complimentary to the state's service. Thinking more like the UK's franchise system, but with its HS/ long distance service being the Amtrak's service, its stopper service being the State's long distance service, Rural (“Sprinter”) service being the Commuter and small town “skipper”. The general management would be by the state's DOT (but I imagine it could use a service operator like that of UK's contracted to provide the service) with FRA as federal coordinator of sort and wrangling with the freight companies.
@seththomas9105
@seththomas9105 8 ай бұрын
I think you should name these trains the "Fantasy Flyer" as lots of pixie dust is going to have to be spread around the Class Ones for this to come about.
@vasquen
@vasquen 7 ай бұрын
The US definitely needs more rail hubs like the one this proposal suggests but for regular day time trips. Think of the Chicago Hub ideia but for Denver.... Dallas.... Atlanta, allowing for daily commute between town clusters around those larger cities. It would also help if the cities would desuburbanize themselves... but we can dream
@Harvey-x7d
@Harvey-x7d Ай бұрын
Those cities have razed terminals, making hubs practical.
@de-fault_de-fault
@de-fault_de-fault 8 ай бұрын
40:24 all the doors on the multilevel cars work with high level platforms. At low level platforms they only open the end doors because that’s where the stairs are, but at high level platforms they open all the doors. Anyway, the real problem is that this setup only partially addresses the accessibility limitations of the superliners, because if you wanted to move through the train (other than from just the “end zone” of one car to the “end zone” of the next you’d still need to climb stairs.
@AutoReport1
@AutoReport1 8 ай бұрын
Most Americans think there's are no trains even when there are. They'll wait three days for a flight, or worry about driving a rental car long distance, when there is a twice daily train going exactly where they want to go.
@qjtvaddict
@qjtvaddict 6 ай бұрын
They are no trains worth using yet
@qjtvaddict
@qjtvaddict 3 ай бұрын
Where are they going to
@Harvey-x7d
@Harvey-x7d Ай бұрын
I was diverted to Albany and NY passengers weren't notified the flight was cancelled for fog until after the last Amtrak left!
@KLarsLohn
@KLarsLohn 8 ай бұрын
Your suggestion of a Billings, Helena corridor service is very interesting. However, I believe it should link the two largest cities in Montana, Missoula and Billings. Helena is in the middle of that route. That has the additional benefit of linking the three largest universities in the state.
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly 8 ай бұрын
Agreed there, and only makes the idea better. Kind of like the CorridorID route proposal for Ohio between Cleveland, Columbus and Cincinnati in that sense. Could be something I go more into detail with in the future, especially if I talk about more rural passenger services, even though I'd hesitate to call the major cities of Montana truly rural.
@vasquen
@vasquen 7 ай бұрын
I reckon many of these shorter city pairs should see frequent long distance daily service like an airliner would do on busy routes. 3 times a day to start, working almost like a long distance commute. It would help to have dedicated row for that in the long run. In Portugal the current plan is to have long distance HSR trains running twice an hour along the coast serving all main cities, eventually connecting to Galiza. The new track will interlink with the old one allowing for current trains serving cities outside the mainline also to use the new track reducing overall travel times even for more regional long distance services. So you see my point.
@uncipaws7643
@uncipaws7643 8 ай бұрын
Near the middle you talk about passenger trains replacing coal trains on the same lines. I'm living in Austria and I'm reminded of the GKB (Graz-Köflacher Bahn) that goes back all the way to 1860 when it opened as a line to exploit coal mines west of Graz, Austria. Those mines are now closed and in recent decades the line developed into a commuter railway. It's currently being electrified (at last) and besides regular S-Bahn trains has a few freight trains serving local businesses, but those aren't the main focus any more. 42:25 That's no TV screen, it's a mirror. So you can adjust your hair in the morning before going out. Passengers nowadays bring their own mobile devices and all they need is electricity and wi-fi.
@pacificostudios
@pacificostudios 8 ай бұрын
Unfortunately, the Rapid City to Sioux Falls route has almost no intermediate traffic potential. Even I-90 is usually lightly traveled west of Chamberlain, SD.
@Interestingenough4
@Interestingenough4 8 ай бұрын
Yeah, I-90's main busy stretches are basically Spearfish to Wall, and then the east Plankinton exit to the Minnesota border.
@MrPriebster
@MrPriebster 8 ай бұрын
It would be really cool to see Amtrack cross the Missouri River at Chamberlain
@ryanspies6170
@ryanspies6170 8 ай бұрын
@@MrPriebster The alignment of the Milwaukee Road line from Rapid to Mitchell had the out out service parts west of Presho railbanked, so it could be theoretically possible, and would be a more direct route between Rapid & Sioux Falls, but I wouldn't get my hopes up.
@pacificostudios
@pacificostudios 8 ай бұрын
@@MrPriebster - The tracks across the Missouri at Chamberlain end at Kadoka, SD, if not earlier. The proposed train would largely follow the route of the Dakota 400 through Pierre.
@pacificostudios
@pacificostudios 8 ай бұрын
As important as an Amtrak service to Sioux Falls and Pierre and Rapid City would be, the Chicago Northwestern's Dakota 400 was cut back to Mankato, MN as early as 1960. Most of South Dakota is sparsely-populated.
@ChadSimplicio
@ChadSimplicio 8 ай бұрын
The proposed lines are great, but it will require the following: * Incentives for the freight railroad companies to upgrade their rails to accompany Amtrak & their intermodal trains. * More Amtrak & regional high-speed exclusive rail lines. * New Amtrak equipment, especially a bi-level replacement for the Superliners & Sightseer Lounge. * New locomotives to complement the ALC-42s.
@sniper.93c14
@sniper.93c14 8 ай бұрын
bi-level equipment is in the works, there's a request for proposals out online, it is very extensive (1000+ pages)
@stickynorth
@stickynorth 7 ай бұрын
One corridor I''d personally like to see that wasn't mentioned is a Salt Lake City-Butte-Helena-Great Falls-Sweetgrass/Coutts line that could hook up the under discussion Edmonton-Calgary high speed rail that has seen new life breathed into it yet again. Then again it makes sense when Alberta will top 5 million citizen by next year and still has the fastest and youngest population base in the nation with housing prices 1/3 of what you'd pay in Toronto or Vancouver...
@history_leisure
@history_leisure 8 ай бұрын
I've thought about through car proposals on the Southwest Chief and changes to the Sunset LTD. One would be with the Front Range service where 1 or 2 trains go to La Junta and daily, with one joining the Chief to Chicago (including an extra train on the Chicago-KC section called the Kansas City Chief, then brining back the Ann Rutledge name and second trip for the combined Lincoln Service-MO River Runner while having both run 3-4 trains only to STL) in addition to daily service to Santa Fe or Albuquerque. In addition, I turned the Sunset Limited into the 2/day Acadian, with one trip continuing with the Texas Eagle to LA as the Sunset Limited
@Pensyfan19
@Pensyfan19 8 ай бұрын
Thanks for explaining the various LD proposals! I hope that all of these eventually come to reality, as I'm most hyped for NY to Dallas along with St. Paul to Denver. In regards to LDs causing Amtrak to lose money, I feel Amtrak should only keep their LD routes to connect these larger cities, and encourage private companies like Brightline to run various intercity corridors inbetween the termini of various LD trains for quicker and more frequent service between popular corridors. Also, nice to see that you utilize DaVinci Resolve as well, since I recognize the text and fades.
@ronclark9724
@ronclark9724 8 ай бұрын
Those in the northeast find Amtrak as an alternative, whereas the rest of the nation from the west to the midwest and the south don't. Amtrak should though... Bring back the Rock Island Twin Star Rocket, Minneapolis to Des Moines to Kansas City to DFW to Houston, and surely the Burlington Texas Zephyr, Denver to Amarillo to DFW to Houston. These two along with the Pioneer and Desert Wind will solve many of the west and midwest Amtrak shortfalls of routes, open up much more of the nation for everyone. The south deserves more routes as well, but I am not as familiar with the rail routes down south. I kinda like the proposed DFW to Miami route through the Florida panhandle, fond of the Florida Wind.
@afcgeo882
@afcgeo882 7 ай бұрын
These long distance services will kill Amtrak. They are solely political projects that will be absolute money pits. Only routes under 600 miles can be sustainable and useful, with frequent and reliable services. Link them together and you have transfer points for those who need to go farther. Rail CANNOT work as a point-to-point system. These routes can be done overnight or as high speed (or both) and can branch out from various hubs. They can also be built separately, each prior serving as proof of concept for the next. That makes investment palatable to tax payers.
@vincebreen3-55
@vincebreen3-55 8 ай бұрын
Bringing Barstow back as a hub would be a great step
@richardsheehan3497
@richardsheehan3497 5 ай бұрын
Great videos, very informative. Railroads built this country, it needs to help rebuild it. I worked for Amtrak from 1992-1997 Onboard Services LSA from Boston to CHI and many other places on the east coast..Went to station services in 96 and didn't like it...Anyway, I live in Ft Myers Fl now and they need Amtrak from Orlando to Tampa and then Naples. The tracks are there for the most part. Seminole and Gulf and CSX just north. It would remove so man cars off the roads and who wouldn't want to see it buy train...
@pi-sx3mb
@pi-sx3mb 8 ай бұрын
It's incomprehensible that there is no current service to Las Vegas. For one thing the drive from LA can be a real nightmare at times and the highway gets choked up, but most importantly, Las Vegas is one huge tourism destination where you definitely don't need or for that matter want a car when you get there, making a train very appealing. They could even just add 3 or 4 coach cars to the end of a long-distance train consist to shuttle them between LA and Vegas to meet the short-length trip demand. Not to mention, a route through Chicago-Denver-Vegas-LA is the most obvious solution instead of through Salt Lake City. Unfortunately thinking outside the box has never been an Amtrak attribute. FTR, I just took the Southwest Chief last week and the lounge car was 100% table seating vs the sideways single seats. What a TERRIBLE configuration - in most cases a single person would be sitting by themselves hogging a table for four, and usually reading or working on a laptop not even looking out the window. 🙄 Who makes these stupid decisions...? Probably some executive who flies everywhere they go. 😑 BTW, I did appreciate the higher speeds out West. The track quality going through Kansas is B R U T A L.
@PrograError
@PrograError 7 ай бұрын
does LV even have a rail station? tho there's that brightrail west HSR into CA.
@jimc5694
@jimc5694 7 ай бұрын
How do you get from Denver to Vegas without going to Salt Lake City, or at least Provo?
@TomHoffman-uw7pf
@TomHoffman-uw7pf 6 ай бұрын
@@jimc5694 You don't. There's an old UP line (at least there was) from Provo to Lyndall (sp?) south of SLC. But ignoring a place as big as SLC would be a huge mistake.
@ThePTBRULES
@ThePTBRULES 8 ай бұрын
For much of these services to function is to double track main lines again.
@vincebreen3-55
@vincebreen3-55 8 ай бұрын
Or triple
@ThePTBRULES
@ThePTBRULES 8 ай бұрын
​@@vincebreen3-55Triple by stations so that you can keep everything moving and not restraint either freight or passengers.
@vincebreen3-55
@vincebreen3-55 8 ай бұрын
BNSF has from Neddles to LA 85% triple track They want to do the whole route through Arizona New Mexico the whole system
@JonBrooks105
@JonBrooks105 8 ай бұрын
What about the return of Head End Traffic? I know Amtrak briefly experimented with their Railway Express concept, but I don't think it could get off the ground without more city pairs. Head End always paid the bills on long-distance passenger trains, and died when the PO yanked their contracts.
@vincebreen3-55
@vincebreen3-55 8 ай бұрын
Even if Desert Wind only terms in SLC to LA it could be a boon for travel
@cryorig_transit05
@cryorig_transit05 8 ай бұрын
My dream is having observation cars for the Viewliners
@Noda971
@Noda971 8 ай бұрын
also it may not seem like it but loads of people who live in Minneapolis/St Paul are snow birds and they go to Phoenix. Usually retirees. So its a good route because its pretty and the people riding it have the time to enjoy a longer trip.
@eottoe2001
@eottoe2001 8 ай бұрын
Double track and 100 to 125 would be great because a lot of rail passenger trains in Europe and Japan that aren't high-speed are doing about half that. 100 to 125 would be good enough for Amtrak and VIA system-wide. (We need a train from San Antonio to Mexico City via Monterey and Tampico.)
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly 8 ай бұрын
100% agree there. It's possible in a lot of places too, especially in the Midwest and southwest too. Obviously for mountainous routes, track geometry is a serious hindrance, but a lot of lines have pretty long straight sections, and the reason the speeds aren't there is because of signaling and single-tracking (often in places that used to be double-track or better in the past, funnily enough). That's definitely a topic I want to delve into for the future.
@eottoe2001
@eottoe2001 8 ай бұрын
@@SteveGettingAroundPhilly yeah, you can't do Horse Shoe curve at 100 safely, where they could it would be nice. Going from NYC to Chicago between 6.5 and 8 hours would amazing.
@PrograError
@PrograError 7 ай бұрын
@@eottoe2001 well... they could rebuild or tunnel that section...
@pilotnflyer
@pilotnflyer 8 ай бұрын
If you look at the demand that Minnesotans and midwesterners have for phoenix its actually not surprising at all that they want to have attain service between the two, its almost similar to the Chicago - Florida service in that aspect.
@timnewman1172
@timnewman1172 8 ай бұрын
I've long thought a seasonal Auto-Train between the Twin Cities and Phoenix would be great! Snowbirds being able to have their car without driving long days in questionable weather to get it there would be a huge selling point...
@Harvey-x7d
@Harvey-x7d Ай бұрын
Denver a clusterf*ck, but rails connect with Sunset at El Paso.
@joelvale3887
@joelvale3887 7 ай бұрын
I like to ride the trains just to see the scenery and small towns.
@hollywood1340
@hollywood1340 8 ай бұрын
And he pronounced our capital correctly. Thank you.
@P0w2you
@P0w2you 8 ай бұрын
The only route I have a strong feelings about the name is Detroit -> Nashville -> New Orleans. That train has to have a music name! lol "The Music Star" or "Music City Limited" some thing Musical... I'll try to think of more! Great video! I do think the first 5 you list are probably the most important, that gotta happen!
@odess4sd4d
@odess4sd4d 8 ай бұрын
I would like to hear more about your idea for a corridor service between Helena and Billings.
@nicholasmarshall9128
@nicholasmarshall9128 8 ай бұрын
It's ashamed I'm about to leave Florida because I know theres a lot of interest for the DFW to Miami route even if it's just mostly between Florida cities, including myself. If they can get a route running north south on the FEC line there's going to be a lot of users. But they are going to have to build a lot of stations though
@Daniel-hj8el
@Daniel-hj8el 8 ай бұрын
I think I might off gotten a name for New LD service that are entirely new 🚅 Sort off... NYC-DFW: National Spirit SF-DFW: Golden Spirit PH-MSP: Ranger Builder BL-EP: Shashone blazer DV-MSP: Crazy Horse Zyphyr, OR Lakota flyer DV- HU: San Houston Zephyr SA- MSP: Great Firefly AT - DFW: Peachfree star DFW - MIA: Gulf Breeze HOU- NYC: Pelican Southerner NOR - DET: Pan- Amegacy
@TimothyBrown2010
@TimothyBrown2010 7 ай бұрын
I do wish there was a route planned from ATL to Charleston and Myrtle Beach via following I-20 to Columbia and then branching off to go down I-26 to Charleston and i-20 to Myrtle Beach.
@donkensler
@donkensler 8 ай бұрын
For years, I've doodled on railroad maps, dreaming of an ideal national railway system. These ideas go beyond my wildest dreams. I live near Detroit and never thought of a Detroit-New Orleans train. BTW, call one frequency "The Pontchartrain", riffing off of the French heritage in both cities, the lake just north of New Orleans, and the fact that Detroit housed Fort Pontchartrain during the French colonial days (there is a Hotel Fort Pontchartrain in downtown Detroit).
@donkensler
@donkensler 8 ай бұрын
It's clear a lot of thought is going into route planning and hard product (equipment and accommodations); now Amtrak has to do the same with regard to soft product (food, beverage, and amenities). Bringing back traditional dining nationwide is a must. I would offer regional specialties of the destination in both diners and cafes, rotated periodically in the diners so the menu doesn't get stale. Regional beers also would be interesting. Also would do TV with a selection of old and new movies and TV shows in the rooms to fill the time on the less-interesting stretches.
@DiamondKingStudios
@DiamondKingStudios 6 ай бұрын
My middle and high school free time was basically doing the same thing. Old railroad maps were how I learned the geography of many states and relative distance between many towns and cities.
@Harvey-x7d
@Harvey-x7d Ай бұрын
I'm glad that Amtrak seems tp be reconsidering all-single 45:44 level cars.
@RVail623
@RVail623 8 ай бұрын
If you've seen any of the "Santa Claus Express" videos filmed in Finland, they are able to quickly add double-decker motor vehicle carrying train cars, whenever needed. Which could enhance the potential ridership of the proposed Phoenix - Minneapolis train to become a 2nd Auto Train. But with better flexibility, to add or subtract vehicles & passengers at select midpoints along the route. Also: the proposed Billings - El Paso long distance route is a repeat of a former (short lived) 1920's or 1930's era long distance train schedule between those same two cities.
@ronclark9724
@ronclark9724 8 ай бұрын
Amtrak attempted to do a second Auto Train to Florida from the Louisville area serving the midwest and Chicago before. It failed to attract enough riders to be profitable unlike the east coast Auto Train that is successful financially. For some reason the midwest Auto Train didn't serve Chicago closer is why it failed. However running a Auto Train daily with just two train sets is limited by how far a train can travel within that day, and why it stopped near Louisville, not Chicago...
@RVail623
@RVail623 8 ай бұрын
@@ronclark9724 The marginal condition of the rails prevented any kind of normal speed operation on either the Louisville Auto Train or of the Floridian passenger train. The entire route would need to be capable of 79 MPH when in motion. Thus capable of running further in one day.
@wallsknob
@wallsknob 8 ай бұрын
A Twin Cities-Texas train name to revive would be the Twin Star Rocket which could me modified to Twin Star Superliner. Twin Star referred to it connecting the North Star & Lone Star States.
@haxorouse3265
@haxorouse3265 8 ай бұрын
personally I would be more in favor of seeing all single level long distance trains with dome cars instead of the bi-level lounges on the routes where clearance allows, the 360° view afforded by dome cars just can't be beat
@pi-sx3mb
@pi-sx3mb 8 ай бұрын
Same! Not to mention, the sleeper rooms on single-level Viewliners feel much more spacious due to the higher ceilings, and the ability to sit up along with the window for the top bunk is a huge plus. Come on Amtrak - dome lounge cars for the win!
@c.d.porter9366
@c.d.porter9366 8 ай бұрын
...the taller the car the smoother and more comfortable the ride.
@odess4sd4d
@odess4sd4d 8 ай бұрын
I love your suggestion of Western Star for the El Paso to Billings route but why not extend it to Montana's third largest city, Great Falls, and then on to an 8th route connection at Shelby with the Empire Builder. Then the Western Star name would be especially fitting because it once served Great Falls and Shelby. Hate to see the plan miss a chance to restore service to Great Falls.
@ryanspies6170
@ryanspies6170 8 ай бұрын
If you're going to dream about implausible extensions to hypothetical services you might as well dream big; run that baby all the way to Edmonton and connect with the Canadian as well.
@ronclark9724
@ronclark9724 8 ай бұрын
Why not up to the Canadian border where VIA could extend it all the way to Edmonton?
@matthewconstantine5015
@matthewconstantine5015 8 ай бұрын
I'd love a good DC to Houston route. I have to do that trip a lot when visiting my wife's family, and I don't especially enjoy flying. I'm still hoping one of these days, they'll reestablish passenger service to Bangor, Maine (and beyond into Atlantic Canada), but I'm not holding my breath.
@ronclark9724
@ronclark9724 8 ай бұрын
Would you prefer to extend the Crescent along its current route, or a new route through eastern Tennessee from either Birmingham or Atlanta?
@matthewconstantine5015
@matthewconstantine5015 8 ай бұрын
@@ronclark9724 I don't know the routes well enough & haven't ever taken a train south of the DC area. But looking at the Amtrak site, if I want to go to Houston, they take me to Chicago first, and that just doesn't seem right. Looking at their map, there seem to be links from DC to Atlanta to New Orleans to Houston, which seems like a perfectly reasonable path, but I don't know how many train changes that has or what kinds of layovers that means. Maybe if the proposed Southeast Corridor gets up and running, it'll make things a bit easier. I'd love to be able to get a roomette in DC and not have to change cars or anything between here and Houston, but if we got real high speed between DC and Atlanta, I'd be OK switching there and then heading west.
@mikereddy-x9f
@mikereddy-x9f 8 ай бұрын
Future work must wait until current service must run safely.
@brianr4054
@brianr4054 8 ай бұрын
Denver to twin cities would be great, but the tracks in SD are laid out in an awkward roundabout way. It may have to skip Scotsbluff, which is the only big town in western NE.
@ryanspies6170
@ryanspies6170 8 ай бұрын
Yeah, while in this video he suggests that you could do Denver to St. Paul in a nice evening to morning trip where you sleep most of the way, you're never pulling that off with this routing. This study estimates 26 hours, after track upgrades.
@Interestingenough4
@Interestingenough4 8 ай бұрын
Yeah, it'd probably have to use the BNSF tracks from Sidney north through Alliance, which would mean going through Bridgeport. The stations in the Panhandle would probably be Sidney and Alliance, and maybe Dakota Junction since the RCPE line from Crawford barely misses Chadron. The only way they could get the Scottsbluff area would be for Amtrak to use the UP line that goes out of Pine Bluffs, which then leads to its coal mainline through Gering.
@Interestingenough4
@Interestingenough4 8 ай бұрын
@@ryanspies6170 Yeah, I'll believe it when I see it. If such a train came to pass, the best bet would be to not have it weave through Sioux Falls, but instead fix up the RCPE tracks straight through Brookings into Minnesota. Sioux Falls could be served by a separate train from the Twin Cities.
@00Zy99
@00Zy99 8 ай бұрын
DFW-Twin Cities? The flagship train on that route was historically the Twin Star Rocket. Two paired cities-easy name.
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly 8 ай бұрын
Sounds good to me!
@Daniel-hj8el
@Daniel-hj8el 8 ай бұрын
Man I wish I knew they also Included possible revival of Broadway limited. 🤕
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly 8 ай бұрын
I wish it was considered, but I guess that it's relatively low on the totem pole, since NYC to Chicago is served by two routes, and technically Philly is connected to Chicago by the Cardinal (the fact that it's slow and runs only three times a week notwithstanding). I can see it being considered a bit more if some of the CorridorID routes, particularly Chicago to Pittsburgh, come to fruition, but definitely nothing confirmed as of yet.
@coolbreeze253
@coolbreeze253 7 ай бұрын
When I was last in Pierre, SD the locals pronounced it Peer.
@railfanhunterjacob6353
@railfanhunterjacob6353 29 күн бұрын
I see three Amtrak trains that would go coast to coast 1. The revival of the Sunset Limited (Los Angeles to Miami) Amtrak's return to Florida would play a huge part, if Amtrak could convince Florida, Gulf and Atlantic Railroad who purchased the route from CSX in 2018 and it would be the first time in 20 years that Amtrak would make a return to Florida's Panhandle. But in order to do this, the bridges need to be upgraded since they are 100 plus years old. Along with track upgrades, but the crossings remain in place. If Amtrak were to return to Jacksonville and Orlando heading for Miami, there is a way to do it. Amtrak would share the same route as Sunrail, Amtrak's Silver Star, Silver Meteor and Floridian, then divert into Brightline's route making connections with Sunrail and Brightline via Orlando International Airport and if new Brightline stations pop up in Florida, it could also serve as an Amtrak stop. It would be the first time in history that an Amtrak train would travel on Florida East Coast line rather than CSX unlike the Silver Service and the Floridian which could terminate at Tampa, if the Silver Star returns as a New York to Miami train in the future The current Amtrak station in Miami which had been opened since 1978 remains the only Amtrak station in Miami, but add MiamiCentral into the mix. It would be the second Amtrak station in the city of Miami, Florida connecting Tri-Rail and Brightline 2. A new Amtrak train (San Francisco-Miami) Amtrak's revival of the Golden State, what it was once a Chicago to San Francisco train. Now a new San Francisco to Miami train with stops at Merced, Bakersfield, Barstow, Phoenix, Tucson, El Paso, Midland, Dallas-Fort Worth, Marshall, Baton Rouge, New Orleans, Mobile, Pensacola, Tallahassee, Jacksonville, Orlando and Miami New train numbers would be 9 and 10 3. A new Amtrak train (Los Angeles to New York City) called the Hollywood Limited would have stops in Barstow, Las Vegas, Salt Lake City, Cheyenne, Denver, Trinidad, Amarillo, Dallas-Fort Worth, Houston, New Orleans, Mobile, Montgomery, Atlanta, Chattanooga, Knoxville, Roanoke, Lynchburg, Washington D.C. Philadelphia and Newark New train numbers would be 81 and 82 Now the two particular routes that show a bit of a difference, but still popular. You have the Golden State showing San Francisco what was once the tech capital industry that is soon becoming a transportation hub for transit and Amtrak trains going to the Central Valley of California and into the high deserts of California including Barstow and heading to big cities like Phoenix and Tucson of the Arizona desert before heading for the Great Plains of Texas at Midland and the Dallas-Fort Worth metro area and into the Gulf Coast like Houston, New Orleans, Mobile, Pensacola, Tallahassee and Jacksonville before making a stop at two locations in Orlando such as the Orlando Health Amtrak station and Orlando International Airport on Brightline's Sunshine Corridor and if new Brightline stations pop up, they will serve as Amtrak stops and it would be the second Amtrak train to travel on Florida East Coast line after the Sunset Limited Then you have the Hollywood Limited which is the most popular due to the fact of stunning views of the Pacific Coast of California in Los Angeles, the Deserts of California and Nevada including the city of Las Vegas, Great Plains of the Midwest, the Gulf Coast and the Great Smoky Mountains of Appalachian before heading into the Northeast Corridor to New York City
@quasimoto7662
@quasimoto7662 8 ай бұрын
Don’t like some of the routes but many do have merit and real benefits. Don’t know how many though would actually come to fruition
@peterwarner358
@peterwarner358 2 ай бұрын
I would also combine the Surfliner & Caputol Corridor into one route from Sab Diego to Sacramento not requiring buses between LA and Bakersfield or between Sabra Barbara abs San Jose. The combined runthrough would result in a 687 mile trip between San Dievo and Sacramento connecting the coastal cities between San Dievo, Los Angeles, the Central Coast, and the Monterey Bay Area abs southwestern San Francisco Bay Area connecting these cities with Sacramento. LOSSAN is design of a six track service yard amin SLO and expanded capacity at Goleta to handle 3 sets of equipment. CCJPA is on the process of building a yard in Roseville and triple tracking Sacramento to Roseville and redesigning of the platform from Italy present layout to an island platform and adding another track there avs the SD train could possibly go to Roseville for a distance of 705 miles.
@StillPlaysWithModelTrains1956
@StillPlaysWithModelTrains1956 8 ай бұрын
Just put the damn Dining Cars back on all the overnight-trains east of the Mississippi for crying out loud!
@c.d.porter9366
@c.d.porter9366 8 ай бұрын
...how about making dining cars a private contract affair.
@StillPlaysWithModelTrains1956
@StillPlaysWithModelTrains1956 8 ай бұрын
I suggested to Amtrak that they reach out to Door-Dash and UBER Eats but have received no response about my suggestion of December 2021@@c.d.porter9366
@Harvey-x7d
@Harvey-x7d Ай бұрын
After a Amtrak - auto collision n of Ocala, FL, I clocked my Floridian at 100 mph to Jacksonville behind an SDP40.
@Noda971
@Noda971 8 ай бұрын
where can I find the map you showed in your video? I cant find it in my initial searches.
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly
@SteveGettingAroundPhilly 8 ай бұрын
I found it initially on a discord server, but I saw it on Google Images on the High Speed Rail Alliance website. Definitely check in there for that.
@Noda971
@Noda971 8 ай бұрын
@@SteveGettingAroundPhilly Thank you! I felt silly because I commented this and then immediately found it
@scottjs5207
@scottjs5207 7 ай бұрын
If any of these became a thing. I have so many trips I want to take to other Nerf clubs... obviously not happening in the now, but I could see the potential and places/people I could see through this, since I HATE AIRPORTS and would rather ride a more chill cross country rail service.
@pelicanrailfanning
@pelicanrailfanning 8 ай бұрын
my idea for the DFW-Atlanta route is the "Shreveporter" context: The Shreveporter was a train run by the Louisiana & Arkansas Railway from Hope, Arkansas - Shreveport, Louisiana with the only stops being Minden, Louisiana, Cotton Valley, Louisiana, and Stamps, Arkansas. while yes, the route is not the same, it still is a train that connects shreveport and the area around where the Shreveporter used to run. Either way, I am still very excited about this route because it will finally give my hometown amtrak service! some other name suggestions: Denver-Minneapolis: The Dakodan ; San Antonio - Minneapolis: Twin City Rocket
@ronclark9724
@ronclark9724 8 ай бұрын
I recall the former T&P Louisiana Eagle from DFW to New Orleans thru Shreveport and Marshall on the way to Mardi Gras...
@pelicanrailfanning
@pelicanrailfanning 8 ай бұрын
@@ronclark9724 thats pretty cool, i love the eagles and T&P/MP are my favroite railroads
@wayneharris5141
@wayneharris5141 8 ай бұрын
I would like to see the return of the Texas Zephyr from Dallas to Denver
@C.Q_Wilkenson
@C.Q_Wilkenson 8 ай бұрын
The Service through Tehachapi Pass will be a game changer, There hasn't been passenger train service there in over 50 years!
@stephenspilker9334
@stephenspilker9334 24 күн бұрын
i love traveling by train especially long distance trains. i am old enough to remember you could go to so many little towns across the country. it might take longer but thats half the fun of the journey. flying sucks lol. the railroads should be taken to task for not prioritizing passenger trains. here in st. paul mn. the union depot has been refurbished and just waiting for more amtrak service. i'd love to see all these routes.
@pacificostudios
@pacificostudios 8 ай бұрын
Fun Fact: "The Trailblazer" was a prestigious Pennsylvania R.R. streamliner, most notable for being an all-coach air conditioned streamliner.
The Amtrak Long Distance Route Tier List
17:04
Climate and Transit
Рет қаралды 20 М.
Молодой боец приземлил легенду!
01:02
МИНУС БАЛЛ
Рет қаралды 2 МЛН
Hoodie gets wicked makeover! 😲
00:47
Justin Flom
Рет қаралды 136 МЛН
Can You Find Hulk's True Love? Real vs Fake Girlfriend Challenge | Roblox 3D
00:24
Former Amtrak train routes: The destinations America lost
21:04
T1D Wanderer
Рет қаралды 105 М.
Lessons from the Yellow Line
4:34
Thomulate
Рет қаралды 4 М.
The Return of Passenger Trains
22:05
ERYNGO URBANISM
Рет қаралды 18 М.
17. Carthage - Empire of the Phoenicians
3:39:04
Fall of Civilizations
Рет қаралды 10 МЛН
Why Weren't Duplex Steam Engines Successful?
20:53
High Iron
Рет қаралды 1,6 МЛН
New York's $16BN Hudson River Tunnel
17:01
MegaBuilds
Рет қаралды 1,5 МЛН
San Francisco's INTERCITY Train - Amtrak's San Joaquins!
15:15
Lonestar Trip Reports
Рет қаралды 16 М.
America's Best Railroad has a MASSIVE Problem. Here's What Will Fix It.
41:37