Islamic System and Sharia | Politics | Part 3

[@ahmednaeem5729]

Objective critique with respect... Lots of love and respect for You Sir

[@Crypto_Ghost1]

Dimagh khul gaya Sir ji. Thank you. Keep it up.

[@humerashaiikh9716]

Buhat acha lecture diya he ap ne. Bht dil se teach kerhe he

[@khalidintezar2171]

Nice..... Plz read Shah Wali Ullah philosophy of Islamic economics, politics and social philosophy

[@kangenwithaniitan9077]

Please critically analyse Holy Quran.1) Wether it qualifies as hate speech. More than 50% of its verses teach hate for the non believers. 2) It teaches discrimination on basis of faith as Hinduism discriminates on basis of birth. Does it "mainstream" & "normalise" hate and discrimination

[@aqibsattar9618]

no bro you are wrong Islam teaches hate , I admit there some ayat in quran that talks about war and other but it imply according to situation for example if other relegion or some other countries invades into your country how to fight with them , and how to deal with ...the one line which I sincerely want to mention here that , when we read Qur'an and any ayat , see how prophet Muhammad SAW react or did action ❤️ according to that .

[@sabiruddinsiddiqui8683]

Short, crisp and very enlightening lectures. Lots of thanks!

[@jeffjaffari5895]

you're all lecture is very great I'm really grateful about your lecture & you're so brilliant ingenious !

[@muhammadzainuddin5424]

Sir you are too good in explaining things in historical and modern perspective. I have a question sir that how can we literate people with this philosophy as we see they become afraid when these things are explained to them.

[@Taimur_Laal]

Share the video. Lets see if people become scared or if people listen.

[@muhammadzainuddin5424]

very well sir :)

[@Blue-Grass786]

Thanks for presenting these valuable lecturers.

[@hamzamunir7056]

Thik hai agr aj k masle pr ijtihad nhi hai ,lkn farz to yeah banta hai k phir in pr ijtihad kia jae na k yeah k dosre nizamu ki trf dekha jae.

[@akmaljaved9609]

Thank you sir ..... Your lectures are beacon to all of us ...... :)

[@IKARCHIVE]

Your way of Teaching and explaining is very easy and impressive

[@bilawalkhan4455]

Ur lectures are like opium.. The more I listen to u... The more I am addicted to them ... But seriously its really wonderful to listen you....

[@Pakistan-f5h]

You didn't shed light on what is islamic economic system. You have jumped directly into conclusion that we should not implement nor we can. Though the mode of production changed but islamic economic values are intact, one can't ignore just saying that there is no compatibility of islamic economic system in modern era. If Riba was Haram so it is.

[@khuramshahzad-bp5gi]

Islamic iconomic system 7century mn wujood mn aya jubke capitalism 16century mn ugr technological dekha jay tu dono periods mamooli furk ke sath ik jase hi hn lakin modern period mn capitalism ko fallow kia jaskta h tu islamic system ko keun ni

[@ilmoadab7426]

Plz sir make a video on English Literature and Mythology.

[@hassanahmad2399]

But sir ibn e khaldun already did work on this for example capital and labour. Monetary policy thoery or I buying and selling and Adam Smith already praised him as father of economics

[@rimshaaaiza9407]

One of the best videos on this topic 💙🇮🇳

[@thirdmasteraamirkhan5410]

principles religious honay chahiye rules chahay jo bhi ho

[@syedzain7184]

💯

[@salman9629]

VERY GOOD EXPLANATION

[@syedmustjabhaiderbukhari2728]

Geniusly explained 👌

[@hunjraarslan7221]

Amazing sir!

[@adeelzahid8940]

Iam a big fan your knowledge

[@alinawazkhan984]

Sir emam shah wali ullah 1703-1763 ne indusrial revolution k bad islamic system ki tajdeed ki ha..us ma ye tmam new economic relation ki mukamal rehnumai ki ha..aur islamic basic laws of economy k mutabik ki ha..plz shah wali ullah ko prh k again btaen k ap ka masla hal hua ha k ni.

[@haxnainahmad]

Do you think Imam e Azam Abu Hanifa (R.A) was only Scholar in Islamic History, there are so many scholars after him and they still exist. You just have an open mind to understand the modern interpretation of Islamic Scholars. The Islamic economic system is neither Capitalist where the market is left free to lead to the disasters that we are seeing nor Communist where everything is owned and controlled by the state. Islam distinguishes between public property, state property and private property. Islam forbids the private ownership of the large resources such as the Oil and Gas that we see the Western companies fighting over in the Muslim world. The Prophet (saw) said: “People share in three things, fire, water and the green pastures” reported by Abu Dawud. Anas reported from Ibn Abbas adding “and its price is forbidden”. In addition to this the Prophet (saw) used to take back lands from people if he found they contained vast resources such as a salt mine. The huge revenue generated by public resources such as Oil and Gas in an Islamic state be utilised for the benefit of the public and not for the personal interests of the rulers who siphon off the money into their swiss bank accounts and spend it for their own pleasure as we see today. The Prophet (saw) said: “The Imam is a shepard and he is responsible.” [Bukhari, Ahmad, Bayhaqi]. Please I request first study our religion in depth just like you have studied modern sciences.

[@mamunrashid6126]

haxnainahmad ap ka kis maktaba fikar se taluq ha

[@pclegion]

Islam gave us fundamental principles regarding Politico-Socio-Economic Systems as it is divine guideline till the end of this universe. The Concept of " Ijtihad" is based on this principle that Muslims should evolve their Political and Economic systems regarding their current scenario within the defined limits of Quran and Sunnah. The Economic System of Islam is in between Capitalism and Communism. Shariah Law gave us guidelines about Land ownership, taxation, trade, inheritance and Riba etc. In fact, Bait-ul-maal was the first institute which offered Socialism and public insurance during Khilafat-e-Rashida period. So the argument, "Islam doesn't give us Political and Economic Systems" is false in itself.

[@Blueberry818]

@@pclegion 👌👌👌👌

[@ahmadishaq3002]

@@pclegion I also think of that.

[@moizash]

Very well explained sir.Your videos may get more interactive if you add on screen stats/figures/maps.Ask your Media students to aid with video editing.Again, Nice work.

[@MuhammadAwais-ul7cf]

Excellent explanation Dr. Sahib.

[@tabrezjahangir7639]

Thank you Sir making.

[@sheikhaaqib9169]

that was great..... Can u please elaborate things with the perspective of the Quran.... as you have made me understand through those 5 schools of thought???

[@hamzaafghan8318]

Great persenlity

[@tariqueanwar4897]

Aap ki Kuch baton se main mutafiq hun and Kuch baton par bhut Sare sawalat zehan min hin.

[@muhammadzaheer5513]

its true muslim remained slow to keep pace with the emerging trends which is a core requirement in shria itself in the form of ijtihad and qayas so we lack behind in research and development.

[@humerashaiikh9716]

Zaberdast with example u delieverd lecture

[@AainAli]

Great information

[@asadalitheentrepreneur4769]

Sir taimur u are great teacher. I want to ask how can we develop our thinking like u are saying. And also can our only changed thinking Can do anything good in our country

[@baruchthinker334]

taymour sir ap plz pakistan main trade union k sath jo soulk ho raha hai os pr bhe aik lecture dain kis thara muktalif govt ny labour lows ko change kr dia hai or jo new industry pakistan main lag rahi hain un main trade union ko bunay he nahi daity or purani industry mojood hain un pocket unions kis thara mazdoron ka khoon chose rahi hain or ager galti sy kisi industry main koie emandar humen resources manager appoint ho jaie to kis thara os ko tang kia jaata hai even katal bhe karwa dia jaata hai

[@emaniqra6402]

Sir ! Your work is really fascinating .please make critically analysied series of history of world ..

[@ismajaffery6071]

love the way u r explaining things sir...

[@studyhub1026]

Sir, I have this confusion? Can we say that capitalism was responsible for or one of the key factors in the technological advancements in Europe? These days we have billionaires who are basically not only investing in technology but also competing in this. We also have cold war era when the govts of the US and Soviet union were playing key role in technological race. However, now, these seems to be little role of the govts in this area. Please do make a video related elaborating this question.

[@nadimdeme]

Sit u are great looot of love for u

[@farazimam1831]

Good one Sir!

[@xecibrahim5847]

Great but my question I understood how all dynasty has initialised accordingly but I don't understand why they have not taken others fiqh like Abu Yusuf l learn that there are 100 more fiqh are in al azar University which is not even in sunni and Shafi thought of school ?

[@farooqali9404]

I think your whole thought process of arguments is derive from karl marx according to which political/economical or whatsoever idealogical thoughts depend upon the mode of production of that particular era

[@Suchhaq9824]

in true islam" namaz means system ensuring equality in providing security and safety of honour, wealth and life of all is equal; roza means, every man and woman are bound to have war training to fight in the days of wars. zakat means share happiness and sorrows with each other; hajj means stage a jihad against who attack a muslim state. a muslim is who believe on equality with aiman on Hazrat Muhammad PBUH as messenger of God and God is alone.

[@tariqueanwar4897]

Assalamu Alekum,taimor sb aap ka sood ke bare min Kiya kahna hi

[@helpfulnationhumanbeing262]

What about ganparishd of Buddhist era

[@helpfulnationhumanbeing262]

Do some comments on Kauttillya Arthshastra

[@afzalshabir1173]

which books sir you read ? i want to read those too

[@muhammadaffanzafar6453]

Hi, Sir I'd like to know your opinion about how do you reconcile Roman Republic (an earlier form of democratic governance on an empire scale) with your claim that all large states in medieval/ancient times were monarchies/empires.

[@qa2623]

اسلام نے مقاصد کو اہمیت دی ہے۔ سود حرام ہے چاہے جس بھی شکل میں ہے۔ اسلام صنعت سے منع نہیں کرتا۔ چیزوں کی قیمت کے بارے میں کوئی پابندی نہیں ہے۔ اسلام استحصالی نظام کی راہ میں رکاوٹ پیدا کرتا ہے۔ جدید صنعتی نظام استحصال پہ قائم ہے۔ جس دن سے اخلاقیات اور معاشیات جدا ہوئیں اس دن سے استحصال شروع ہوگیا۔ جب خوف خدا نہیں ہوگا تو آپ کس کس کو بزور شمشیر روکیں گے؟

[@hashamkhan9517]

اسلام اس چیز کی مخالفت کرتا ہے کہ دولت صرف چند لوگوں کے ہاتھوں میں رہ جائے

[@PranavaPakala]

Hi. Could you make these particular lectures in English? Thank you!

[@Taimur_Laal]

Ok

[@sarfrazsae9226]

Question is how to understand social and economic activities? Because once you move towards stability then you get progress but if you are unable to social and economic basics then what ever you do apply any system you will fail out yourself. Now, the issue is to understand what is right and wrong means practically work or not? It is going to study light activities. Sun produces light then how we see its different colors. What makes it brighter? Then you will start building up chain after chain to support your brain so you can tolerate the intensity of sex desire, stop all kinds of leakage like through ups, sleeping with woman, getting sick etc once you done with light behavior like white light; it is charge what people like in their point of view so you have one nucleus and one election at least. Another example is yellow light: here you have two nucleus who push themselves each other away. More they exert force on each other's, more they looks yellow so electron going left on 2nd nucleus if 1st one trying to keep him away or vice versa. 3rd place you have red light; here nucleus is moving every electron in the right direction either it has to extra workout or not. After this you see all kinds of people's attitudes till you make up your mind if you support to keep man dominance or woman freedom which is all about either you allow fucking or not then step up series after series where ever you like to go

[@Suchhaq9824]

my advice for all to also listen modern islamic scholars namely dr. Asar-ul-Islam and Allama Pervez Ahmad to hear true Islam, which has no link with one we are following at present. hundreds of videos of both the scholars are available on youtube

[@luqmankhilji1]

What about interest ?

[@SadiqAli-vl2su]

Sir kindly make a video on al ghazali's political philosophy

[@tawqeermurad9074]

sir it means islamic econimcs system is somehow related to communisim.

[@waqasahmad3073]

Doctor. Your explanation is amazing. Kindly explain that, has Islamic Sharia become comoletely outdated and obsolete or do we have a chance to moderanize the Islamic System.? If yes, how? Link it with this video series plz. The concept of Islamic Banking etc. Or the institutions like Al-Azhar can do something for moderanizing it. Thanks.

[@Syychro]

There are very important and fundamental ideas in islam about the welfare of the poor, the dignity of the poor, and the value of ilm that are important to keep and emphasize for any modernization project in muslim countries.

[@nfazal4065]

Greed is good-Gecco Is this the flag of modern economics ? Prof Dr. Nasir Fazal CAMBRIDGE.

[@salmanzworld13390]

great effort !

[@zaheerahmad2754]

Sir plz tell relationship Islam with politics

[@measaad1]

Thank you for sharing your understanding. I want to ask few things here. When we say Islamic Economic System, we mean a system based on Zakat and not Taxes. Both have different implications. Your explanation does not cover system of Zakat in Islamic Economic System. You ask too many questions based on common sense. What your common sense says about weighing vote of literate and illiterate people. Can you give same value to both? This is the main difference between Islamic Political system and democratic system. In Islamic political system, vote of a literate is of more value than of illiterate person. If you can differentiate and explain both systems based on their principles, I will be thankful.

[@Syychro]

It is possible to turn an illiterate society into a highly literate society (95%+ literacy) in the course of a few years. Many very very poor countries have done this successfully with minimal costs. Also, literate, educated people with secular education and religious education have been running Pakistan for its entire history. What is the result? It is not possible to build a successful country without putting the needs of the poor and so called "backwards" groups first. I am not concerned with the few "geniuses" who run various companies, countries, and institutions, but with the millions of geniuses who are born and die while slaving away in factories and fields without an education.

[@lifelonglearner4387]

Agree

[@abdullahkhan43]

Plzzz renaissaince k bad k philosophers parhao

[@shabeerhurr2994]

nice sir

[@xman7544]

What about fatwae alamgeri

[@MUDDASIRKHALID333]

so banking interest is alright in today's day and age?

[@mahbubrm2148]

It was never forgotten to begin with .

[@bloodandtears678]

abu hanifa K kon sa kitab apne para hai???

[@taimoorhussain9993]

Why not read Imam Jafar As Sadiq ?

[@2yoil]

what is so special about him?

[@SH67uui]

He didn't wrote any book. All we know about him, is through his students. Same goes with Socrates. That is why, there is no conclusive evidence that the ideas of Imam Jafir Sadiq (a.s), we know today, weather belongs to him or not. His students might have added their opinions and biases in his thought.

[@newnomi1]

Why is it "dukh ki baat" at 12:26. It's nothing sad that they couldn't envision something that would take place 600 years later. But you couldn't hide your smugness at being "jadidiat pasand". Jadidiat doesn't have to come without a grain of humility. Slight rephrasing of your "dukh" comment would have ameliorated your smugness. Whenever you mentioned the Imams and how they could not write about governance in the era of capitalism, I waited for you to say they couldn't envision it just like we cannot envision or suggest solutions for the type of socio/economic/political system the world will have in the year 2100, let alone the year 2600. This one comment would have ameliorated the smugness and superior-than-thou vibe one feels at some points in your lecture. I did enjoy this entire series though. Hope you continue your mission and don't get discouraged by views in the low thousands. As Atticus Finch said, ""Simply because we were licked a hundred years before we started is no reason for us not to try to win."

[@SahilKhan-oj9ky]

The works of ibn khaldun are actually similar to Adam Smith. Some argue he should be called the father of modern economics. His influence on taimur & then to Mughal empire is worth understanding(25% of world GDP was from india during mughal). What do you say?

[@Taimur_Laal]

Did he work out the normalisation of profit?

[@SahilKhan-oj9ky]

@@Taimur_Laal you replied to my comment! Thankyou so much! Well I can't tell you precisely about normalisation of profit. But hear this- “Not only did Ibn Khaldun plant the germinating seeds of classical economics, whether in production, supply, or cost, but he also pioneered in consumption, demand, and utility, the cornerstones of modern economic theory.” writes Ibrahim M Oweiss who is an Egyptian-born American Economist, international economic advisor and professor of economics at Georgetown university Washington DC. Ibn Khaldun discovered virtue & necessity of the division of labor before Smith & principle of labour theory of value (among the best known advocates of this labour theory was Karl Marx himself) before David Ricardo and the role of government in stabilisation policy before Keynes.

[@Taimur_Laal]

He was a genius, there is no doubt about that.

[@Complex-World]

Sir please tell me.....why iran's revolution is called islamic revolution?

[@انکشاف]

ڈاکٹر صاحب کیا عرب ممالک میں اب جمہوریت ہے ؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟ جمہوریت کا بنیادی اصول ووٹ کی گنتی ہے ۔۔۔ عالم اور جاہل کی راے برابر ہوسکتی ہے ؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟ اگر برابر نہیں ہوسکتی تو جمہوریت اس مسئلے کا کیا حل پیش کرتی ہے؟

[@tariqueanwar4897]

Sood shahi hi ya galat hope you will reply me, I am from India.

[@Artwithhiya09]

There was Kautilya s Arthashastra before Adam Smith . Though it did not have contents of modern day economics . P.s . I am not trying to peddle any sort of Hindu religious supremacy .

[@samadwani405]

Islam just give you foundation principles of economy, if the system matches that principles it mean its islamic economic system.

[@EASYLEARNERS]

sir mazert se per, islam aik mukamal wellfare state ko janam data he, asa koi system he nahe he,jis ko islam ne explain na kia ho.ap ye nahe kah sakte ke islam ne modern system of political and economics ko explain nahe kia he per ap ye zaror kah sakte he ke us pe kise fikah ke reserch ya analyse nahe ho saka he.

[@sanasama2209]

Taimur bhai aap salamat rahe.🙏...humare mashre me nailm log katalegarat par utarte hai agar unko sach ka paigaam pahunchayeto🤦‍♀️

[@forumofthenations6811]

IM ENGLISH COMMENTATOR N DEBATER N POLITICAL OBSERVER

[@muhammadzainulabidin6509]

Please consult The Muqaddmah by Ibn Khaldum You'll definitely be surprised.

[@armaghanalisarwar9996]

Mean to say that Islamic system is not applicable for this time ! Its out of the date .

[@abdullahkidwai7206]

Sir i think u should read maulana maududi , he is considered the father of morden islamic economics......... You have a very mordernist approach which i completely disagree with.... But then do read maulana maududi,he has done a very good critical analysis of capitalism.

[@babarazam900]

👌

[@abdulrehmanakbar6546]

ummmah awesome lecture as always ..but i don't get why many people speaks ill about you and call you conspirator and bad things...i have always found you intellectual and rationalist..

[@Taimur_Laal]

DYNAMIC SOUL perhaps because they don’t want an enlightened Pakistan.

[@arslanyounas4917]

sir one thing I want to add If u don't mind what u want to say that Islam is outdated ?is it wrong to say Islam provide us guidence about how we can spend life in all perspective till the end of this world ?

[@arslanyounas4917]

@@Taimur_Laal ans sir If u can

[@greengalaxy8873]

You found him intellectual and rationalist. But Mr. Rationalist has never given any sound reason why socialism has failed in almost all countries of the world. There is nothing wrong about being a modernist. But if one cannot see that Hegel and Marx's claim that all values (including moral values) are byproduct of dialectic materialism is unscientific, then his or her modernity must be doubted.

[@khuramshahzad-bp5gi]

Islam qiyamt tuk ke liya ik makumal nizam ye ni hoskta k hum isko ik turf rukh ke west ki undhi tuqlid krna shuroo kr dan

[@GTIXAUUSD]

I agree

[@fartashali]

اسلام ایک دیں ہے نہ کہ کوئی ازم اسکی تعلیمات کے خلاف نہ جاو بھلے جتنی بھی ترقی کرو

[@bilalhussain6193]

Please Study Shah Wali Ullah Dehlwi ..

[@Abc123-b3n]

Please Mr.Taimur read more about Islam or don't create misconceptions about it. ISLAM HAS GIVEN THE BASIC LAWS WHICH ARE APPLICABLE FOR ALL ERAS BECAUSE OF WHICH PROPHET MUHAMMAD S.A.W. IS THE LAST PROPHET. IF YOU DON'T BELIEVE IN ISLAM THEN DON'T REPRESENT YOURSELF AS A MUSLIM.

[@syedzain7184]

Khilafat is not badshahat,Islami nizam jitna jamuriat se kareeb hai utna kisse se nhi! Khilafat me quran aor hadees ke bahr cheezen gn me khuda ki tarf se "choice" Hai wahan Aap SAW ne aaps me discuss krke"people's opinion"ke zarye fasla kia,chahe hr nizam dur ho khilafat se aor democracy khilafat se inspired ho phir bhi bulqul iqbal ki trhan mera mowif bhi quran wala hai,hr nizam shirk hai islam ke elava

[@kashif7934]

Imam abu hanifa par or baqi sb par bhi koi alag se wahi nahi nazil hui thi unhune bhi mojooda quran wa hadees se hi wo sb masail k hal apne zamane me akhz kiye thay or sb imamo k zamane me alag masail samne ate thay jin k wo alag masail usi feqa or quran o hadees me se nikalte thay to aj b agar economic system me bhalay kitni tabdeeli aye ho fundamentals bht had tk same hain lekin bunyadi masla aqeeday ka hay ap khuda ko ye haq hi nahi dena chahte to k us ki taraf se aee hidayat me se usool akhz kiye jayen ap khud khuda banna chahte hain or yahi to khasiyat hy islamic civilization ki us me ek scholar ek hi waqt social or physical science k b experts hote hain to ethics k bhi jb morality ko economics se alag karogay to yahi sb kuch hoga jo capitalism or communism me huwa insan hi insan ko exploit karega to khudara apna qibla durst karen or dunya or akhirat dono k faiday ki bat karen...

[@qa2623]

اسلام میں مستقل جاگیر داری کا کوئی تصور نہیں۔

[@muhammadzainulabidin6509]

ایسا دکھائی دے رہا ہے کہ آپ نے کسی بھی اسلامک اکنامکس کی کتاب سے رجوع نہیں کیا۔ اور ویسے بھی ہم معاشیات اور اخلاقیات کو الگ کرنے کے ثمرات، ہر چیز میں ملاوٹ کی شکل میں سمیٹ رہے ہیں۔

[@Gaming-beastHERE]

bhai temoor Allah pak ap ko Islam samjhne k taufeek dai ap perhe likhe admi hain profesor hain to is ka matlab yeh nahe k Allah ka kanoon aisay he samjh ajata ha is k bhe perhai hoti hai jaisay kisi bhe profession k hoti hai...... duniya ab wapis word of God k tarfa a rhe hai aur ap k Islam per research 40 min k goofle search ha aur wahan se ap ko crap he mile ga ....... meri Adna c rae hai k ap ko itne followers hain agr ap kisi ache sahi alam e deen se jaise Shuja ur rehman sahib ya dr. Israr ahmad k lectures sunein ya kisi alim se pori info lain to acha ho ga kion k ap batein bilkul theek nahe Islam k bare main

[@Gaming-beastHERE]

ap baat theek krte hain lekin let me tell u one thing morals are the grounds agr yeh nahe hon gai to sab mufad k jung larein gai to business k lie ethics ka hona bhe zaroori ha werna ap dekh sakte hain society main kia ho raha ha aur duniya main trump jaisay log bhe isi waja se oper atey hain bhaya ijtehad agr ho to aj bhe aik modern Islamic syatem ban sakta ha agr is pe kam kia jaye aur yeh duniya k tamam school of thoughts se behtr kam kre ga coz word of God ghalat nahe hota

[@greengalaxy8873]

You got it right. We have to understand the timeless and universal morals of the Quran, understand the modern complications and formulate appropriate policies. The danger which comes from these Marxists is the claim that morals themselves are the byproduct of material dialectics.

[@asimhussain2295]

sir, please mention your email.

[@lovebless8056]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/mmW5gKSNn8x0gqs Mard Ko Hoor - Aurat Ko Langoor

[@Abc123-b3n]

PLEASE MR.TAIMUR CLEAR YOUR MISCONCEPTIONS ABOUT IJTIHAD.

[@muhammadbinali2492]

Confused insan Deen right or wrong e btAta e, industrial policies btana Deen ka Kam nai e, Deen bas yhi khta hai k kisi k sath dhoka/corruption wgera kro gey tu ye punishment milay gi... Baki science, industry blah blah develop krny se Deen nai rokta, or na isy address krna Allah ne mnasab smjha, because it doesn't fix our heaven or hell. Or Allah ne ijtihad k zrye new developments ko address krny ki b ijazat di hai...so shut up

[@naziimkhann]

Samjhany k elawa over reaction zeyada ha

[@theimmensegraphics1108]

You knowledge about islamic economic system is so week...if u don't know some thing properly then don't pass judgement on it.

[@shahfahad5986]

Sir monetize your videos too it will beneficial for you and will help you financially

[@bilalkhantanoli4216]

You are communist but you discuss more for capitalism