Israel? Palestine? Which Side Should I Take? | Dr. Shabir Ally

Dr. Shabir Ally addresses the question of why Muslims typically stand in support of Palestine. Is it because of tribalism, a desire to support people like oneself? It shouldn't be that way, he says. He emphasizes the Islamic teachings of standing for truth, justice, and fairness for all, regardless of religious or ethnic affiliations. Dr. Shabir says that some people may not fully comprehend the historical and geopolitical context of the conflict. He highlights the challenges faced by Palestinians, particularly Gazans who are living under siege and lacking basic necessities to live. Drawing parallels with apartheid, Dr. Shabir underscores the importance of global awareness and support, emphasizing the need to stand against oppression and advocate for the rights of those subjected to injustice.
If you enjoy this video, please support our work financially by:
Visiting our website www.QuranSpeaks.com OR
Sending an etransfer to [e-mail] OR
Subscribing monthly at Patreon.com/QuranSpeaks
► DONATE: www.quranspeaks.com/
► SUBSCRIBE: kzbin.info_...
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Instagram: / quranspeaks.tv
Twitter: / quran_speaks

[@tugendewego8894]

As a Christian I am proud of my Muslim and Jewish brothers and sisters worldwide working hard for peace. We must end this genocide and teach LOVE because in the end we are ONE human family.

[@Thehermitist]

It’s not even genuine Jews or Christian’s involved in this Gen o side of the Palestinians and of humanity Hurts my heart they emulate them

[@ahmadottoabdurahman5015]

It has been 6 years since i always follow Dr Shabir Ally. So much respect for you sir ! May Allah give you long life,,

[@user-gh2kq6is1r]

Aslm. As a SAfrican our foreign Minister Dr Ndledi Pandor is Muslim by conversion. She heads up the genocide case in SA at the ICJ. It is both as a sister Muslim and the Apartheid experience thats propelled her into taking action, but as a human being alone, its easy to see why. Shukran. I love your program. I really enjoy Dr Ally's balance when explaining the Quran.

[@fidelcatsro6948]

Wasalam amigo

[@alexanderboehmler6451]

Are you sure? I watched the trial and the South African minister heading the delegation was Ronald Lamola, Minister of Justice. Ambassador Madonsela also was there. The only Muslim South African I saw was one of the lawyers, Adila Hassim SC.

[@mohammedsaleem-dh8eq]

Islam came to kill fascism and Racism. That military operation was called jihad. Islam the first ever law institution founded on earth

[@user-gh2kq6is1r]

@@alexanderboehmler6451 Yes, she's Foreign Minister in Govt and she attended the last hearing at the ICJ.

[@alexanderboehmler6451]

@@user-gh2kq6is1r I checked again, I saw her at the ICJ not at the hearing (Minister of Justice was there), but at the announcement of provisional measures. Thank you to Minister Pandor then and to lawyer Adila Hassim SC. I suppose they are better Muslims than all those politicians from so-called Muslim countries who do nothing for Human Rights in Gaza. And thank you to non-Muslim South Africans involved in this, who care more than many Muslims.

[@balemohamad6135]

When injustice becomes law, resistance becomes a duty ❤

[@QueenQaffir]

U don’t know what injustice is! Ur comment is offensive to everyone who knows history.

[@Montanero]

⁠@@QueenQaffirit’s only offensive to you. The world is seeing what has been concealed for 75 years. Zionists can’t keep pulling the victim card so many times while committing massacres and acts of oppression and humiliation so systematically. The victim card isn’t working any longer. Justice will be served.

[@thetruthwithproof8802]

( 📓Al-Mu’jam al-Kabīr 3718 ) ➜ Beware of the supplication of the OPPRESSED, for it is carried above the clouds. Allah Almighty says: By My might and majesty, I will help you in due time. ( 📓 Musnad Aḥmad 1214O ) ➜ The Prophet P.B.U.H , said, “BEWARE of the supplication of the oppressed, even if he is an unbeliever, for there is no barrier between it and Allah.”

[@thetruthwithproof8802]

( 📚 Muslim 2999 ) ➜ The Prophet P.B.U.H said: How wonderful is the affair of the believer, for his affairs are all good, and this applies to no one but the believer. If something good happens to him, he is thankful for it and that is good for him. If something bad happens to him, he bears it with patience and that is good for him.

[@QueenQaffir]

@@thetruthwithproof8802 lol what does that even mean?

[@peterhwang352]

There is absolutely no doubt that the conflict is religiously motivated and propagated. The Muslim concept of truth and justice is that everyone has the right to live in a shariah state.

[@najmu49]

By large this conflict is not religiously motivated Its political from 1947 Balfour Declaration. Christians, Jews and Muslims have lived quite peacefully for many many decades before this present atrocities. Ceasefire now, release all hostages, security and dignity for ALL

[@timmyk2023]

Muslims are religiously obliged to live by the rules of the lands in which they live. Such as Muslims who live in a non-muslim country. We (muslims) are instructed to adhere to the local rules of practice. So stop talking from ignorance and do your research before you write. The war in Gaza is because the Zionists do not see the Palestinians as being human, and believe that they are entitled tonall the land in Palestine.

[@dame6584]

Please check your source. The conflict started with the british mandate...the palestinians are being punished since then, its inhuman. The Western propaganda is disgusting.

[@Montanero]

Zionism is a secular movement, its founder despised Judaism (go read Herzl quotes). This is purely a case of land theft, using religion to make it look “complex” issue. When it’s clear as day that 750000 people were robbed and displaced, some of which murdered and their current descendants are fighting for their freedom and their humanity.

[@LionsHoney13]

this is very false and disingenuous

[@Kadir_1990]

I experienced poverty having no food for weeks, so i know partly how it feels not to have food, i haven't been oppressed yet but sometimes i feel that lot of western countries are becoming more hostile towards Muslims simply because we are Muslims.

[@A_gOD_KESSE]

The west is becoming hostile to muslims simply because muslims try to implement shariah in western lands. Be honest, won’t you be hostile to people who try to change your culture after helping them? Look at what’s going on in Sweden, France , UK etc

[@slaveman2818]

They did this in africa , Namibian population is only 6% white but they own 70% of the land

[@tomceman4451]

"They did this in africa , Namibian population is only 6% white but they own 70% of the land." Is this a prima facie case for injustice?

[@slaveman2818]

@@tomceman4451 when do you recognise injustice ?

[@BruceWSims]

There is a fundamental question here that transcends "choosing a side". At its core, the individual needs to ask themselves how they come to their view of justice and goodness. Picking a side does Not produce a value. Holding a value is what helps us determine our alignment in our society.

[@env0x]

i think the issue is a lot more simple and more dumb than that. most people in the west who have never heard the word "zionism" before this year will say things like "israel has a right to defend itself" just because they've been indoctrinated through years of highschool ww2 studies to have the holocaust as their most historically relevant reference of human genocide in their vernacular. they're not taught about any other genocides from the past 100 years. so, whenever an american or european thinks "genocide", they automatically think the holocaust, and automatically want to support jews thinking they're being anti-genocide. so the problem is mainly the education system. but it's built that way for a reason, governments don't want people knowing the full parts of history, just enough to make you believe it is..

[@Hshdzsskidi]

​​@@env0xzionism means jews having a right to have their own State which is a prophercy fulfilled in the Bible. So the problem is Palestinians reject their state and cause trouble .So we need to come to an understanding that this is both a political n religious problem. Just know that our future prophercies points to Islam as the enemy but we don't use this to cause trouble all over the world. Live in peace. Love life.

[@env0x]

@@Hshdzsskidi okay well your own orthodox rabbis don't even agree with you so there you go

[@Hshdzsskidi]

@@env0x as a Muslim u supposed to know they are delayed on prophecies. Duhh the messiah comes back to genocide not to make a Jewish state. So think bro.

[@env0x]

@@Hshdzsskidi i'm not fixated on prophecies like a lot of zealous religious people are. i care about humanity and trying to make a better future for everyone. not just for a select group of people deemed worthy or whatever. i'm not on that elitist BS.

[@humayungul2120]

Nelson Mandela said their freedom is not complete without freedom for Palestine.

[@ClandestineGirl16X]

Thank you two for breaking this down. Thank you from nyc

[@delpthepath127]

It’s not Palestinian land. How is the land Palestinian when the people there are the result of Islamic invasion? Moreover, how is the Palestinian attitude in all this consistent with what their very faith teaches

[@essienukpabio3879]

Dr . Just one question and I sincerely want a very honest rey.What was the overall pkN and g I al of Hamas in igniting this fight? What was the plan of Hamas after the attack? What would h ave been appropr iatete response from Isreal?

[@Joanne-vr4zu]

Thank you

[@LavaDesert]

Dr SHABIR, You really should make a length video on Religiose Perspective and References on both sides.

[@Meditrix]

please make dr.shabbir ali explain the whole history of this conflict as it would be big help for everyone to get a better understanding of the ongoing conflict

[@Terrythunderpants]

I’m from Ireland and a Christian .. you don’t need to be Muslim to support Palestine you just need to be human .. god bless all good Muslims, Jews, Christian’s .. prayers to my wonderful brothers and sisters in Palestine .. this is not an anti Jewish stance it’s an anti Zionists stance

[@JesusIsaSlave]

peace can only come if justice prevails, even if you don't give children the same treatment [food, presents or love] they start fighting and arguing

[@shettyn375]

When gaza was ruled by Egypt, where these people were ?

[@markdoughty8780]

Sagatious words, as always, from Dr Shabir and Saffiyah Ally...

[@BEITSHEMESH777]

He started well that the Koran is also against his believers when they are wrong, but later he was not objective at all and we will not mention what Hamas did on October 7th. I thought he would tell the truth, but it is rare to find a Muslim who is truly objective.

[@Guest-uo3rp]

october 7 happened not from vacuum, UN has certified, what hamas did was a retaliation for prolonged oppression by israel, read history

[@zamzamadam4811]

Beitshem ur story began from 7octember but Palestinians suffering is very 1948 to 2024 so feel ashame of urseif

[@BEITSHEMESH777]

@@zamzamadam4811 What started in 1948 that Arabs did not want the Jewish state and started a war? And that's why they lost a Palestinian state then. My friend, learn some history

[@yasminjoosub4197]

​@@BEITSHEMESH777you learn history

[@loveandmercy9664]

I respect Shabir but he's a religious tribalists.

[@mohamedmezo1791]

What is taken by force can only retaken back by force.

[@fidelcatsro6948]

Viva revolucion!

[@Hshdzsskidi]

Sheesh so u want more war😮.Wow and then u cry ceasefire..

[@mohamedmezo1791]

Isrshit committin genocide for the last 75 years and got to be stopped only by force in a civilized world ,remember what happened to nazi Germany.?

[@Montanero]

@@Hshdzsskidithe Israeli diaper forces are the ones crying after blindingly killing their own so many times, treading in fear and horror. Humanitarian Ceasefire is for the innocent children who are being collectively punished by the cowards of Zionists. But in a man vs man, the occupiers stand no chance against the might of the resistance. Justice will ultimately be served and everyone will answer before their Lord, for this is but a kind reminder.

[@ibrahimhamza5571]

@@Hshdzsskidi😕 he just pointing out the fact and the fact is the whole land was belong to Palestine when israel come and invaded and occupied Palestine land 76 years ago so in order to take back the land only by force a war

[@ameerrahaman4924]

What a ridiculous question to ask! In light of what's happening to Palestine for more than three months now.

[@wolfgangkohlhof2180]

How come that we have to miss the word 'Hamas' in this video?

[@mohammedabdul3961]

Thank you Dr. Your response to the question as to why we take side was excellent, drawing your argument from the Quran and the Hadith. Anything outside these books cannot sufficiently solve human problems.

[@QueenQaffir]

Are u kidding me. Ur Quran has ONE completed story yet u think it answers all the world’s problems lol? It doesn’t even answer its own questions 🙄

[@kehinde-he2io]

Is wonderful you think things from these books only solve human problem sufficiently. But I believe Jesus is the only sufficient problem to human problem. My findings about these problem tells me that the major problem of that region is the division in the Islamic world. This sunni and shia thing. Imagine they are both sunni.

[@mohammedabdul3961]

Please, learn about Islam with open mind. Keep aside your prejudices, be honest to yourself and certainly, you will be amazed to discover the true Jesus in Islam and not the image of the British movie star Brian Deacon. And to also remind you my friend, Islam is the most peaceful religion. Don't just be a victim of Western media propaganda.

[@doneracer5994]

@mohammedabdul3961 Once upon a time, Christians acted towards the Holy Land in a similar way as Muslims and Jews do now. The results of that were the Crusades. And while the Holy Land is important to Christians as a site of pilgrimage, the teachings of Jesus trump any holy-land-grab. However, if I had to side with anyone, I would side with the Jews. Muslims have 53+ Islamic theocracy lands, some of which neither Christians nor Jews are allowed to even visit. The Jews have only one. Christians, like Jews, are accustomed to being good citizens wherever GOD puts us. In Mark 12, Jesus taught that some men came to Jesus and asked, *"Is it right to pay the imperial tax to Caesar or not? Should we pay or shouldn’t we?” But Jesus knew their hypocrisy. “Why are you trying to trap Me?” He asked. “Bring me a denarius and let me look at it.” They brought the coin, and He asked them, “Whose image is this? And whose inscription?”* *“Caesar’s,” they replied.* *Then Jesus said to them, “Give back to Caesar what is Caesar’s and to God what is God’s.”* *And they were amazed at Him."*

[@tomceman4451]

@@kehinde-he2io What is the solution?

[@rajasekhare9573]

Stop genocide in Sudan.

[@tonydsouza4835]

Keep up the good work God bless yourl

[@user-bx5ec4wx7l]

Jazakanlah heiran Ali

[@user-su9pm3qo2d]

Which Koran are you quoting? I have 20 different books in the library

[@yasminjoosub4197]

There is only one quaraan...one and only one

[@John316TOGODBETHEGLORY]

So True

[@Honestyontap]

I have some questions for you Sir and maam.

[@humayungul2120]

There is no opportunity for the people and then military operations keep on adding insult to injury.

[@loveandmercy9664]

October 7th dr. Shabir?

[@Honestyontap]

I would like to have an honest discussion with a muslim . Do you delete comments on this channel. Every time i try i get deleted. I keep language clean and i seek truth. Should i pursue ?

[@tomceman4451]

I would like to have an honest discussion with you. I am not a Muslim. I am a Christian. I keep language clean and i seek truth. Should i pursue ?

[@elijiah2023]

I agree with everything he said. The Palestinians are oppressed and persecuted. But he didn’t mention why Israel has been doing this all along. The reason is that on the day of its establishment in 1948 the Arab states declared war and invaded Israel. This is the heart of the issue, if the Palestinians and Arabs had accepted Israel from the beginning, there would have never been a conflict. As long as Palestinians resist through fighting rather than diplomacy, there will never be peace.

[@Guest-uo3rp]

israel was established by occupying palestinian land forcefully, all the jews came from western world to rob land of palestinians, why cant they live in their own land in the west?

[@ibrahimhamza5571]

Dude this land belong Palestine israel 76 years ago and invaded and occupied the land

[@arekdr23]

​@@ibrahimhamza5571That is not true. There was neither Palestine state nor Palestine nation when Israel was created.

[@raahilrecordings]

May Allah Ta'ala safeguard the Muslims and strengthen them with upright faith and righteous deeds during these passing times of tribulations and trials.

[@Shabeer54]

Thanks

[@DarulEmtehaan]

Just a suggestion to "Let the Quran speak": Instead of saying God (which has a plural form i.e. Goddess), you should be using the word "Allah". May Allah Ta'ala bless you immensely and reward you for your good efforts.

[@zelialusitana1701]

I am a Christian praying for the people of Palestine. I liked hearing Dr. Shabir on the Quran view and wisdom. I didn't know how oppressed the Palestinian people had been by the Israelis for so long. I know some Jewish people but they have not shared there view either because they feel shame or are complicid . Thank God this has brought me closer to God and the bible and history and to seek the truth deeper. May god have mercy on those that do harm to the children . Thank you Dr. Shabir

[@Farhadmoh]

We need more Muslim like Shabir Ally.

[@blackdog8771]

We don't need islam at all

[@abhatti81]

Long Live Palestine 🇵🇸

[@RobespierreThePoof]

Sigh.

[@icecoldyellowredbull]

ALLAHU AKBAR!

[@Phat-Kat23]

The issue is Hamas is going after innocent people like the Tanzanian they caved his head in look it up

[@kristiemullikin9302]

Long live Israel 🇮🇱

[@ibrahimhamza5571]

@@kristiemullikin9302criminals won’t live long specially if they are in the holy land

[@karenfisher2322]

The hadith Dr. Ally discusses at 1:37 is perfectly to the point on something I have been thinking about recently: People or countries who say they are "supporting Israel" are too often being enablers, rather than real friends. A real friend will call their friend out on their wrong words and deeds. They will do what they can to stop them from causing more harm. One might say, "friends don't let friends commit genocidal acts."

[@yasaiasazuke]

From the Roman untill the Ottoman it was a province and not a country. European, Arab and Jewish leaders wanted to destroy the Ottomans in the region and now still compete for power at the cost of civilians. If the 3 factions manage to destroy an Islamic state open to democracy then what kind of leader it is anyway? 🇹🇷 ❤

[@candicecole19]

Recite this beautiful Dua daily 🤍 Allahumma inni as’aluka ilman nafi’an, Wa rizqan tayyiban, Wa amalan mutaqabbalan. ‎اللَّهُمَّ إِنِّي أَسْأَلُكَ عِلْمًا نَافِعًا وَرِزْقًا طَيِّبًا وَعَمَلاً مُتَقَبَّلا “O Allah, I ask You for beneficial knowledge, goodly provision and acceptable deeds.” May Allah grant us sincere and beneficial knowledge that enlightens our hearts and minds, a provision that is wholesome and abundant, and deeds that are accepted in His sight, paving the way for our success in this life and the Hereafter.

[@marziaball5089]

Thank you Dr .Ally and Dr. S Ally for Good work . Free free Palastine 💚❤️🇪🇭

[@user-jz9hs7wy4z]

الله يحفظكم يا شيخ شبير

[@akpewebiakolo7517]

The dude with the white beard is enjoying the western freedom but intelligently ignore that his brothers don't give others such freedom in @ra6 nations😮

[@daguyudontwannaknow]

I say this as a non-Muslim, I stand with Palestine because I support humanity, truth and liberation ❤ Muslims are so inspiring with how they stand for justice for all. God bless Palestine, God save Palestine.

[@fidelcatsro6948]

Ameen amigo

[@blackdog8771]

Trol

[@Hshdzsskidi]

How can Israel live next to ppl who come out to attack them then hide underneath Gaza?How can Palestinians just resist in violent ways and u expect Israel to not secure themselves?.

[@pei-sanlai8013]

No good tree bears bad fruit, nor does a bad tree bear good fruit. For each tree is known by its own fruit. Indeed, figs are not gathered from thornbushes, nor grapes from brambles. (Luke 6 : 43 - 44) >Palestine, from the Philistines, who dwelt on the sea coast: it was called Judea, from Judah! Muslim into the West : Deaths & Destructions Jewish into the West : Contributions (13 Nobel Laureates) & Holocaust Massacre > It should be noted that in 1948 Palestine was offered the best spaces and regions (which they have rejected still) by UN whereas Israel was given the deserts and marshlands. Before Israel was born the region was never developed. After the rebirth of Israel the region was not only developed but made prosperous. 1948 Palestine - 2024 vs 1948 Israel - 2024 Instead of blaming what exactly have they done with their land and people (despite UN pouring millionsss into Palestine)?

[@tomceman4451]

"Muslims are so inspiring with how they stand for justice for all." I disagree with you. Israel does not stand for justice and truth.

[@clintbryant5060]

Something terribly wrong if you can't figure that out in 2minutes.

[@metalgear-]

5:40 then HOW are the LEADERS of HAMAS all living RICH in QATAR atm if NOBODY can ESCAPE as you claim….

[@KenanTurkiye]

EVERYONE please make a playlist about Palestine like I have and ask others to have such a playlist. Or copy directly the list I have and ask others to copy it from you, and they ask others copy from them. We need to spread the truth, millions, billions of us. Once you copy the playlist, leave messages under most populous comments in videos, drawing attention to your channel, not specifically mentioning the name of the holy lands, because they can block it if it's recognized. And change your message each time so the AI does not block you from posting, just have a series of comments on the side to copy-paste.

[@QueenQaffir]

Hope that playlist includes the “truth” that there is no such thing as a “Palestinian”.

[@KenanTurkiye]

@@QueenQaffir Well have a look. Thank you for displaying to the world the mindset that's trying to control the world.

[@Hshdzsskidi]

I would rather see a religious debate between a jew,A Christian, a Muslim and a messianic jew. Like this issues supposed to be sorted out long time ago just with the Abrahamic faiths.

[@QueenQaffir]

@@Hshdzsskidi Islam isn’t an abrahamic religion. Abraham would have klld Mohammed!

[@yasminjoosub4197]

​@@QueenQaffiryour name is so appropriate

[@misstornton3848]

Weird question. Famous proverb already “you don’t need to be a Muslim to stay for Palestine, you just need to be a human “

[@zamalsutikno4284]

What about Christian People in Muslim countrys? Do they have their freedom??

[@adnaomar8976]

Masha Allah❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@georgeabraham7256]

What is good for both?

[@fidelcatsro6948]

2 State solution as per agreed UN borders of 1967

[@tomceman4451]

@@fidelcatsro6948 "2 State solution as per agreed UN borders of 1967." I don't agree to that.

[@user-ps1kr9yn7d]

his hands are on everyone, and the hands of everyone are on him...” The future fate of these nomads, whose entire restless life alternates between bold raids and cruel retribution for them, is depicted just as powerfully and picturesquely. “He will live in the presence of all his brothers...” The descendants of the two brothers - Ishmael and Isaac - will not mix with each other, but will live separately and independently of each other, they will not always be in good, but always close proximity to each other

[@Guest-uo3rp]

useless boks quoting

[@adamk5700]

Can you show me a verse in Quran that assigns that land to any people other than bani Israel. 22 Muslim Arab states and Arabs of Palestinian origin have been refugees in almost all of them for past 75 years. Why dont we talk about the fact how Muslim Arabs treat each other. Yemen, Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, Libya are all relevant examples.

[@digidalethenagatuhoefromra8047]

I have met numerous Palestinian people and given them money, I don't know maybe are still alive? Thank you for everything, and understanding that only Allah knows the hearts of an individual person..

[@jole9368]

It would have been interesting to hear you address the reasons why the oppression and suffering of fellow Muslims in Palestine is such a central concern to the global Muslim community, while the concern for Muslims suffering under brutal regimes elsewhere-China, Azerbaijan, India, Syria, Sri Lanka, Yemen, Sudan-bleaks in comparison. Certainly, the Jewishness of the perceived oppressor of Palestine has theological implications. Perhaps in a future episode you should address whether the very existence of a Jewish state in Palestine is conceivable or not within the parameters of Islamic theology.

[@Hshdzsskidi]

They won't.only Hate Israel but not Iran n Qatar that mess them up

[@nazmul_khan_]

This is false comparison, every single one of these injustices are talked about everywhere in the Muslim world. You choose to ignore that because it plays nicely with your agenda of justifying violence against Palestinians. If the Muslims wanted to destroy the Js, after 1300 years, the Js will all be gone.

[@CamaroSS1]

Why the Gazans don't produce there own electricity? They are very good in building tunnels, and rockets. They have been free since 2005, it is not an open air prison. They chose terror.

[@marwanmansur8633]

❤

[@AinLion-dd5oe]

Great, great , great you are interesting😍😍😍😍😘😘😘😘😘

[@ibrahimkhaleel3047]

May Allah bless you all

[@JesusIsaSlave]

There is no need to call one's dad by their first name, people already know who he is

[@retro7362]

What about israel you never talked about there side

[@RustyBites]

I don’t want war. 🇮🇱❤️🇵🇸

[@waywayway1459]

With all my respect I think it is more complicated than that. First I think you should recognize muslims are probably more engaged against Israel because people of Gaza are muslims for the great part. Maybe bad things are happening in other part of the world but because they are not Muslims, Muslims are less engaged about those problems. It doesn’t mean that it’s not good supporting people of Gaza but we should be aware about that fact. Secondly, as a Catholic Christian, that was a time agnostic, I was against Israel back then, but after my conversion I saw things differently. Now I can understand a bit more Israel. If we follow the Bible, we see that God gave them the land of Israel. So it could be that it is still legitimate that they ought to live there and not Muslims or even Christians. I could be wrong about this and still trying to discern what is God will regarding that. It’s even possible that prophecies of the Bible that seem to speak about the return of the jews is taking place since 1947. Also again if we take Genesis 12:3 « I will bless those who bless you, and whoever curses you I will curse; and all peoples on earth will be blessed through you.” » and if we take the fact that according to Jews and Christians, Isaac is the legitimate son for the promise of the Covenant and not Ishmael, then maybe we should bless Israel and not curse Israel. Finally, as a Christian I must follow Jesus Who says to bless our enemies so maybe I should not take part of any sides and be against all injustice (either made by Israel or Palestine) but I think those points needed to be said as to understand also the other side. God bless you all and may He bring us all to Him.

[@fidelcatsro6948]

God gave them Israel??? Your bible says Joshua invaded the land from Cananites... Anyway most of the dwellers there arent semite today John Hopkins genetic study shows 97.5% of Judaics in Israel dont have ancient hebrew DNA, whereas 80% of Palestinians carry ancient hebrew DNA thus are real semites

[@fidelcatsro6948]

God made covenant with only Isaac???... you think God is rascist like Biden and Netanyahu?..bible has 50,000 contradictions and you call it word of God?

[@waywayway1459]

There is a promise from God for Ishmael (Genesis 16:7-16) but the Abrahamic Covenant was made trough Isaac. I’m not Jew but even if I don’t understand God’s plan, I want to respect it. Regarding the Bible, I invite you to read the chapter 53 of Isaiah. May I also recommend you to ask God to show you the truth regarding Jesus? God bless you and your family.

[@fidelcatsro6948]

@@waywayway1459 Ask yourself honestly, was Jesus a Christian? The teachings of Jesus ultimately became the teachings about the man instead!

[@waywayway1459]

@@fidelcatsro6948This matter is so important, please don’t base your opinions only on your understanding or on your feelings. Please ask God to reveal you all the truth regarding Jesus and Christianity. I wish you all the best on your spiritual journey.

[@anwarhussain3696]

It is Good that he is " Shedding Light on HISTORY ". I do feel that " Peaceful Co-Existence " is PARAMOUNT !!! Younger Generations don't, and will not know " True History " - thus such Videos will help - In Sha Allah !!!!

[@tomceman4451]

@@nzunknown "Exactly only peaceful co-existence is the solution here." I don't see these two groups can co-exist peacefully.

[@shahabdurrasheed762]

I love you shabir ally.

[@abdirashiddirie3522]

This is not a question that you ask Muslims

[@DAY-ky2qb]

Praise be to Allah, I am also a Muslim, but in the light of verse number 21 of Surah Al-Maidah, I consider the Holy Land to be the land of Bani Israel because it is written in the mentioned Surah. Instead of striving to create a separate Muslim state in Gaza and the West Bank, Palestinian should accept the existence of the state of Israel and they should live peacefully as its citizens. Palestinian Muslims can either become peaceful citizens there or return to Arab lands. They should not contribute to Iran's proxy war in the region. The concept of migration (Hijra) exists in Islam, and following the Sunnah of the Prophet (peace be upon him), Palestinians should consider migrating towards Arab lands.

[@delpthepath127]

Such a balanced view. I can appreciate the consistency

[@Threebrownsoldiers]

Totally understand one Muslim always supports another Muslim nothing new for me

[@user-hn6zb9cj5b]

There is sborder with Egypt, you ignore this fact

[@JesusIsaSlave]

They were exiled from the land multiple times shows their stay in Palestine is conditional, if they fail to live up to certain expectations, rule is a test

[@jameelkhan4101]

Why is this even a question? Are their Muslims who have doubt?

[@gisellehabet2877]

Wherever these people go They carry trouble

[@John316TOGODBETHEGLORY]

spoken like a true puppet of satan.

[@user-wi5pv7yj5d]

You are 100000000% right bradar but jibril is 100000000% wrong right?

[@jacobayalon3381]

Did gaza have an airport before Israel existed ?how is it always Israel to blame ? They can import any amount of weapons but we have to buy them food don't you see something wrong in the picture ?

[@RobespierreThePoof]

Religious leaders should not be promoting taking one side at all if peace is the goal. Christian leaders unfortunately too often do the same that many Muslim leaders do. The Crusades and Islamic conquest ended a long time ago, people.

[@herihehe.]

If peace really is the goal, then equality should first exist. We are talking about inequality here. And taking one side is the first step to get that inequality problem solved before taking the next step: peace.

[@metalgear-]

@@herihehe. • Strange since there’s ZERO EQUALITY under ISLAM or WHERE can WE FIND this UNICORN you PRETEND exists? What ISLAMIC STATE offers EQUALITY amongst other RELIGIOUS Groups…..

[@metalgear-]

@@herihehe. • I 💯 STAND AGAINST the INEQUALITY of ISLAM on FULL DISPLAY in the MidEast & as an AMERICAN 🇺🇸 🇮🇱🫡

[@mohamedrafeekulla170]

Who owns the palastine? What is the history. Why do they have all military equipment.why did the palestine cornered who did that.

[@heregoes8839]

Some verses for the UAE hypocrites waiting around for Gaza to be finished and continuing Abraham Accords: _"Give good news of a painful punishment to hypocrites, who choose disbelievers as allies instead of the believers. Do they seek honor and power through that company? Surely all honor and power belongs to Allah._ ... _˹The hypocrites are˺ those who wait to see what happens to you. So if Allah grants you victory, they say ˹to you˺, "Were we not on your side?" But if the disbelievers have a share ˹of victory˺, they say ˹to them˺, "Did we not have the advantage over you, yet we protected you from the believers?"_ ... _O believers! Do not take disbelievers as allies instead of the believers. Would you like to give Allah solid proof against yourselves? Surely the hypocrites will be in the lowest depths of the Fire_

[@kman55w]

God has made Esau bare, he will not be able to hide himself anymore. The world is finally seeing him for his true colors

[@jannatshkd.5578]

Palestine will be free Inshaallah ✊

[@Aricboccara]

Blablabla blablabla... Everything but the truth... Islam says don't be opressor but there's no one , NOT ONE, muslim country which is not a dictature... Not one

[@willmad3121]

Not mentioned: The multiple times the Palestinians have absolutely rejected peace initiatives offered by the Israelis. Instead…unceasing declarations of war and attacks on Israel )1948, 1956,1967, 1973, 20**….on and on) And LOST every time. Losing wars you start usually means your side loses life,liberty and land. There is an incompatibility here that will only be reconciled in the future: the narrative of modern times to come is given in Ezekiel 36-39. And the End result in Zechariah 12-14.

[@mordechaigoren5534]

Open air prison. Wow. That is a lie. Hamas leaders travelling all around the world. The gazans houses full of supplies. And bilions of dollars, which are used for buying tons and tons of rockets and warfare. And how did we forget: gaza borders the arab muslim country of eygpt...

[@mohabdul1]

I pray the West to one day experience the pains that Palestinians go through.

[@alexanderv7702]

Hopefully your prayers are not answered by any God.

[@Hshdzsskidi]

We see but sorry bro.Our view on things is different from yours. It's that violence of Palestinians n brainwashing their kids that makes us silent. If they just be still n accept peace then atleast something can happen.

[@GoogleUserGmail]

​@alexanderv7702 If they gonna hand it out they need to experience it

[@BEITSHEMESH777]

Yes, but why doesn't his honor refer to what Hamas did on October 7? And he is the one who started this war and Israel had no choice but to defend itself. Even now Hamas holds captives and gives the Israelis a reason to continue fighting.

[@luisramrod9121]

Did you noticed that never did he mention hamas? I wonder why? Hamas play a big role in the current bombing of Gaza.

[@zozoconde4623]

At Least Dr Shabir is telling the truth. Usually, I do not support Dr Shabir

[@TEFinfo]

Are Muslims really looking for the truth to answer is no and it's not even a secret. This is a pre-determined decision based on religion. “Fight those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful and who do not adopt the religion of truth from those who were given the Scripture - [fight] until they give the jizyah willingly while they are humbled. - Qur’an 9:29

[@TEFinfo]

Convert to Islam and we can have peace. That's the crooked definition. Muslims use to say their a religion of peace.

[@metalgear-]

@@TEFinfo🇺🇸🇮🇱🫡

[@doneracer5994]

Both Muslims and Jews are obsessed with owning the dirt of the Holy Land which God Alone owns. In the midst of war, do you think either side thinks about Who really owns the land? I doubt it. Every day I pray that Father God comes alongside both Muslims and Jews and introduces His Son Jesus to every soldier, politician, Rabbi and Imam. I look to Scripture for the answer. Jesus taught, in Matthew 5:38-48: *“You have heard that it was said, ‘Eye for eye, and tooth for tooth.’ But I tell you, do not resist an evil person. If anyone slaps you on the right cheek, turn to them the other cheek also. And if anyone wants to sue you and take your shirt, hand over your coat as well. If anyone forces you to go one mile, go with them two miles. Give to the one who asks you, and do not turn away from the one who wants to borrow from you.* *“You have heard that it was said, ‘Love your neighbor and hate your enemy.’ But I tell you, love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you, that you may be children of your Father in Heaven. He causes His sun to rise on the evil and the good, and sends rain on the righteous and the unrighteous. If you love only those who love you, what reward will you get? Are not even the tax collectors doing that? And if you greet only your own people, what are you doing more than others? Do not even pagans do that? Be perfect, therefore, as your Heavenly Father is Perfect.*

[@tomceman4451]

I would like to interact with you. I disagree with your application of Matthew 5:38-48.

[@emilianosintarias7337]

most zionists are christians, and many displaced palestinians were christians.

[@khaidirmohamed4117]

The Muslim that died in this conflict, They are extremely lucky because they died as Martyr. IDF will consider themselves lucky if come out alive.

[@lalzuimawiahmar513]

72 virgin in heaven..booooommm

[@mozi4305]

A Message To You !! In The Quran Word " Muhammad or MHMD "" Meaning Not a Prophet's Name But A Title , Common Nou , Indefinite noun , [ See-When a noun is used to refer to an unspecified or unidentified person or thing , it is Called ( the indefinite noun ) it usually has tanween ,[ ( an ) A double fathah sign ] , [ ( in ) A double Kasrah sign , ] & [ ( un ) A double dammah sign ] , at the end of the noun and is Translated in English as " a " or " an " like- a man , a student , an apple , a car , a book , a Muhammad [ Because of Muhammad "uuun " Muhammad"IIIN " , Muhammad"AAAN " & Muhammad"eeeeen , In this Point -- In the Quran Muhammad "word " Meaning Not A Person's Name , But A Title , Common Noun & singular & Plural Noun , & Indefinite Noun , -- ----**

[@HumbleConfidenceES]

If the Palestinians were doing the same thing to others, Muslims would stop them. So yeah it’s about right and wrong but also naturally all groups have a little extra sense of responsibility when it’s their own group

[@alexanderv7702]

People get into Gaza, and marry residents of Gaza, and leave for their own countries-thru Egypt.

[@steinadleradler3431]

Is that even a question????

[@fidelcatsro6948]

Nope, even my cat says 🇵🇸

[@fazalulhaq5584]

Shabir Ali Sahib Assalam O Aleykum. Am still awaiting yours" point of view in response to my comments on verse of Qur'an wherein it has been mentioned when last hours will come Allah Will gather the Children of Bani Israel in mingled crowd. The mass migration of Jew from different part of the world to the state of Israel. This trend indicates what is happening is not with the decree of Allah. I shall be obliged if you kindly clarify what is actual interpretation what is mentioned in Quran. It should not be taken that I am a supporter of Jewish state of Israel.

[@provo0618]

The justice and fairness of the Muslims can be seen in their leader Mohammed. He made a treaty with the Quarisch tribe and when he was in a stronger position he killed them. By the way, that was Arafat's justification for the Oslo Accords, a deception. this is the true face of Islam

[@SALIMSHA1971]

Allah swt bless palestine. Long Live palestine. Palestine forever.

[@user-rd9ks8dw8c]

This question is an insult to the Palestinian cause in the first place.

[@Nitzpitz]

It is Hamas that does not provide Gazans their basic rights, Egypt doesn’t want the Palestinians. Israel has very little to do with Gaza, up until 7/10z this video is full of misinformation and misinterpretation of facts. There hasn’t been an occupation of Gaza at least since 2005. There is no justification for the beastly acts of 7/10. Why no talk of the occupation of Gaza by Egypt from 1948-1967? This was a military occupation and the Gazan people were not granted any rights.