Israelis: How do you live with the lie you are from here?

[@hassantangasawi42]

That's worries me, as an African. I'm afraid that all population of the earth will claim that their origin million years ago is from Africa! 😂

[@MasterMote]

Don't worry no one wants to be there😅

[@thomaskreisel5764]

Good point! Lol!

[@joshuahoover7700]

thousands of years vs hundreds of thousands of years is a big difference ... dd you forget how to count?

[@Shrulik]

I wonder if the US have taken revenge to 911 attacks by conquering Mecca and Medina if after 5000 years you Muslims will get it back it will also be considerate to be racist crime against humanity or like all Muslims you only tolerate Jews as defeated and humiliated minority?

[@MasterMote]

@@joshuahoover7700 also, by that logic, still no one has claim to Africa more than anyone else lol. Israel was owned by Britain and sold to the Israeli settlers, and to me that means something, cuz im not a leftist hippie moron

[@kingjacob1492]

You have balls to ask that question. I give you props

[@shainazion4073]

It's important because that's what all the Jews haters believe. They believe that Jews are converts even though the DNA proves otherwise!!

[@shainazion4073]

@@poorindiansanddogsarenotal1276 Bot, you write this nonsense on every video that has to do with Jews. Again, 62% of Israeli Jews are Mizrahi Jews forced out of the Arab Muslim countries when because Israel became a state. There are less than 30% of Israeli Jews with Any ethnos from Europe. These Jews have 70% of Levantine DNA, with 30% of ancient Southern European Greco-Roman mitochondrial DNA from the first and second centuries, Not modern European DNA!!! The geneticists have proven there are *less than half a percent of converts per generation amongst Jews.* The Ashkenazi Jews still show 50% of Canaanite DNA after 2500+ years of diaspora. The Canaanites only lived in Canaan/Israel, not Europe!! The Ashkenazi Jews are the closest genetic match to Palestinians out of all the Jewish diaspora communities. So are the Palestinians European converts??????

[@solvingpolitics3172]

@@shainazion4073 Don’t even waste your time. Tell them to go back and fix their logo that shows the moon being larger than the stars. If they were divinely inspired they would know that the stars are larger than the moon.

[@shainazion4073]

@@poorindiansanddogsarenotal1276 Try opening a book!! Or looking on Google!! *Ashkenazi Jews Can be Identified at 100% Accuracy by DNA Tests* _National Vanguard,_ 2015. Search the actual study which shows that Ashkenazi Jews can be told from Europeans at 100% Accuracy, even someone with just one Jewish parent or grandparent. Search the actual study, *_A genome-wide genetic signature of Jewish ancestry perfectly separates individuals with and without full Jewish ancestry in a large random sample of European Americans,_* 2009, _Genome Biology

[@burnin8orable]

​@@poorindiansanddogsarenotal1276Ashkenazi Jews are from Israel. Do your research. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashkenazi_Jews?searchToken=o0mqb2nyy86pln91gamlim3c

[@bethyshka]

" they will be below us forever" wow.. I know that not everybody in Israel thinks like that, still this sentence alone explains so many things.. I can't believe that this mindset exists in today's world. And it reminds me of, never mind...

[@tartarus1322]

I think he meant as nations in the eyes of God, the Jews are a nation chosen to obey God above the other nations.

[@jaxstudios7670]

I take that to mean AFTER us...as in populating the land......not under our feet....as you are taking it...

[@thenellierose]

@@tartarus1322 According to them, lol

[@Warhammer416]

@tartarus1322 lol trying to justify supremacy, keep doing those mental gymnastics bud

[@philip506]

You still have to acknowledge that he answered honestly. Worse are those who outwardly feign equality but in reality look down on others.

[@anthonysherman7340]

Props to the young women at 8:15 for admitting they don't have full understanding. It's so refreshing to hear this sort of vulnerability nowadays.

[@RicardoLopez-ub2hs]

The majority of Israelis currently living in Israel are descendents of jews kicked out of arab countries (who migrated to arab countries after being kicked out of Israel by Romans). European jews are descendents of jews who migrated to European countries after being kicked out from Israel by Romans. Some jews managed to stay in Israel after the Roman expulsion and some returned after the end of the Roman empire.. The homeland of the jews is Israel.

[@MRSDAVID1]

and honestly, you should've started your questioning with "where did your family come from before israel" and then boom ask them the original quesiton on this video.

[@Valmont069]

yeah seriously... bad mishap

[@nickolasgaspar9660]

He actually did that. This is why he knows they are from Marocco Spain etc....

[@floatingdisembodiedhead8975]

Yeah it's not in the video but it's obvious that he asked them off camera, hence how he knows some them are from Yemen or Egypt.

[@lala-ct9ir]

@@nickolasgaspar9660 Well, if that is how you ask then that would mean that the Palestinians would have to say that their families ended up in present day Israel in the 1800's and 1900's and originally came from Egypt, Lebanon, Syria, Jordan... The family of the lady "from Spain" has been there much longer.

[@aumelb]

​@lala-ct9ir except that's not true. Some Palestinian families came there from other parts of Levant (not from Europe, like Ashkenazi Jews). Most have been living there continuously for centuries.

[@masterkay6383]

I can move to another country but it doesn’t change who I am and where I am from. I’m Maori I native of New Zealand and the land belongs to the indigenous people of the land and that will never change.

[@doityourselfpakistan6535]

after 3000 years ur anisters will have new life , world will be not like todays too , the countire will be diffrent , borders will be diffrent nationalties will be diffrent , and u wont be saying same thing .

[@lilyaki]

he/she won't be saying anything in 3000 years :D@@doityourselfpakistan6535

[@mannyechaluce3814]

my blood line is also rooted in New Zealand, way before the Maori even existed, we are talking Cave men here, so I am ready to take my land back from you, once I save up enough airline miles to get there...

[@fun_ghoul]

@@mannyechaluce3814 Follow your Fuehrer, pig.

[@colleenoconnor4099]

So you agree it belongs to the Jews then-great

[@asankagurusinghe6128]

be fair to these guys, they answered respectfully a very confrontational question

[@patchanga33]

It’s only because they know it’s not his question to begin with and that they will be on KZbin for everyone to see

[@psychopathocracy]

Isn't he fair? They are the ones making fools of themselves with such answers.

[@Minnie88Ro]

it's only because they arent insane Muslims@@patchanga33

[@IanMurray-w8o]

Very friendly people entertaining sarcasm

[@MXGIRL87]

@@IanMurray-w8osaying an entire ethnic group is below you seems “friendly” to you?

[@gildahan11]

Ask Palestinians since when have they been called "Palestinians" , ask them how do they live with the lie calling themselves Palestinians and not Arabs

[@frankzappa4935]

They were called Palestinians during the ottoman period. You’re the one believing a lie.

[@PasserbyMan-ju8ky]

@@frankzappa4935 the history knows them as Canaanites

[@travel.music.food.5403]

Doesn't matter what they were called, what matters is who lived there.

[@opendoor-hl1oj]

@@frankzappa4935 Ard Filastin During the Ottoman period, the term "Ard Filastin" (Land of Palestine) was used to refer to the region not the people ,

[@frankzappa4935]

@@opendoor-hl1oj and the people of ard falasteen are Palestinians

[@wilkiecoco]

Corey, I just stumbled upon you channel a few days ago. Regardless of the answers, I really like your channel and your approach and it's very refreshing to hear from real people, both Jews and Arabs, who express their opinions, lack of opinions, knowledge, ignorance, love of their fellow human beings and hope for peace. Such a nice departure from politicians and talking heads (including the so-called "experts" voicing their opinions in the comments section). I love that you are respectful of everyone, while still playing the devil's advocate. Great work!!

[@Peculiarsteve]

Revelation 2:9 I know thy works, and tribulation, and poverty, (but thou art rich) and I know the blasphemy of them which say they are Jews, and are not, but are the synagogue of Satan.

[@mustafael-amin9163]

Yeah but the thing is,no people who check all the Torah boxes interviewed these people so of course the interview were courteous.Had they been interviewed by a diasporan Hebrew from Ethiopia,Basil,or USA,then we would’ve seen the vitriol.Now,let’s interview those who check all the boxes as far as being “in a land not theirs”,and I’m not talking about Poland,Ukraine,Hungary,Russia,Germany either.

[@xaviercruz4763]

@@mustafael-amin9163ehat does it all mean?

[@mustafael-amin9163]

@xaviercruz4763…it means that no melanated person who checks ALL the boxes were interviewed.This is alwys purposely done to deceive the ignorant into thinking that the pale Jew or pale Arab are the original inhabitants of that region.Dont forget that the devil made the Suez Canal to separate Egypt from its mother…the rest of Africa.There’s no such thing as a Middle East because it’s all Africa.Lastly,when you (not you per se)research with an open mind and common sense and a desire to right the wrongs,you’d help us remove what Britain and USA created and that is the khazar from Africa aka the so-called Middle East.If we stick to the status quo and continue the apathy…WELCOME TO WORLD WAR 3!

[@Duolingo609]

6:51-8:10 As an Israeli, I just want you guys to know that this opinion doesn't represent all the Israeli people's opinion. There is no such a thing as equal humans and more equal humans. All humans are equal and that guy made me sick. Btw the interviewer should ask them to answer in hebrew to get honest answers, just look at the last guy.

[@fun_ghoul]

Good point about the language, but I suppose a countervailing argument is that it means more work to translate/caption for an Anglophone audience.

[@Druffmaul]

It's a deliberately provocative question and the guy responded with a very provocative answer.

[@fun_ghoul]

@@Druffmaul Does the truth hurt, Karen? Go back to Poland. 🇵🇱

[@popotade4621]

I actually think forcing them to sintetize in another language makes them respond objectively and more often than not, reveal how superficial and ridiculous their opinions are.

[@lala-ct9ir]

@@popotade4621 Or they cannot express themselves clearly enough and you get to misunderstand on purpose.

[@kaneis915]

I am Greek and i know more about this matter than the 2 girls in 10:00. That is sad...

[@fokana1]

Abraham actually came from Iraq.... Jews have lived longer outside Israel then they have in it

[@eh2542]

Ask the Muslims how do you know that your ancestors were always Muslim? It is clear that all Muslims more than 1500 years ago were not Muslims before the rise of Islam. But the Jews were Jews even before they received the Torah at Mount Sinai.

[@Warlock786]

Jews were Jews before they received the Torah ? Jews are a religion made up in majority of a specific ethnicity The same ethnicity as Arabs, however the differentiation has only begun recently. Prior to the the differentiation was religion. Jews and Arabs were the exact same people except the Jews were a people called Bani Israel.

[@shainazion4073]

Corey asked them that, they had no Clue!

[@eh2542]

@@Warlock786 You are talking nonsense. The Jewish people is a continuation of the same people that came out of Egypt. The Jews and the Arabs were not the same people, and never were the same people. The Jews have maintained their religion for 3,500 years to this day. You don't know the history that's why you talk nonsense.

[@EzraB123]

​@@Warlock786We are related to Arabs but we aren't the same. Jews are from the Levant, Arabs are from the peninsula.

[@grod805]

So native Americans can claim all the land from the US government because it was theirs for thousands of years? What if i already bought my house? It gets taken away from me?

[@SomeExperienceRequired]

Well, I mean they do claim that. Possession is 9/10s of the law.

[@pawisgarcia]

Yes. It's the same as it's happening with Palestinians. People from the US took a land that was not theirs. And had happened in many other countries. It's called colonialism.

[@SomeExperienceRequired]

@pawisgarcia it's clearly more complicated than the US. Technically, the jews are the Natives in this story. The colonizing happened from the Ottoman Empire, when they invaded, Judea. So this is the story of the Native Americans getting their own country.

[@pawisgarcia]

@@SomeExperienceRequired Wrong. Those people are European converted into Judaism. That is not their country. You can tell by checking the physical characteristics. I have never seen a polar bear, living in a desert. That's colonialism, genocide and ethnical cleansing.

[@SomeExperienceRequired]

@pawisgarcia umm what are you talking about. If most of these Palestinians or Jewish people took a census survey they would both check Caucasian. Isaac and Ishmael were brothers. The majority of them didn't come from Europe. Some of them pre-existed the Arabs, and some come from 18 countries in the region that expelled them for being Jewish.

[@MoHammed-rr1bk]

To be the superior and stay exlusive while the state is expanding and officially called an Apartheid cannot be the message of God. People should start understanding that they can all live in peace without corrupt politcal or religious leaders.

[@Hshdzsskidi]

Yeah but Palestinians refuse peace. That's the problem Both us n Isreal totally agree free Palestinians n live peacefully together but If they refuse ,who the hell can help them

[@MoHammed-rr1bk]

@@Hshdzsskidi and Israelis are all like angels...Open your mind and think outside of the bubble

[@Darduel]

Israel isn`t "officialy" Apartheid

[@HOmar-nw2zr]

I think the question could have been asked better. It made them answer very defensibly with no room for actual anthropological discussion. Great channel non the less.

[@Thenoobestgirl]

It's a viewer who asked the question. He's just the messenger.

[@bettyslama5284]

@@Thenoobestgirl Yes but then he should start by explaining that. It's so simple to start with: I got a question from one of our viewers and here it is: "" So there is no excuse

[@SlantedLand]

The question is mean, it's antisemitic.

[@PelegSade89]

​@@bettyslama5284 I think the whole thing with this channel is bringing the questions as they were sent to the people and get their honest reaction to that same question. I love that concept, that Corey doesn't usually spend a lot of time to explain the question (just sometimes when needed).

[@fun_ghoul]

@@SlantedLand Sarcasm 10/10

[@buildertrash4102]

It’s actually incredible that they think they’re somehow apart or better than the Arabs, it’s almost impossible to tell them apart!. They so obviously share the same genetics and therefore the same ancestors. The only ones that look different are the European “coverts” that are turning up claiming they’re Jewish.

[@psychocadet]

Genetics says they are not converts. History says that too. Thanks for playing. There are palestenenians whiter than the whitest European. The middle east has been mixed color for thousands of years.

[@Thaddeus-ml8if]

@@psychocadet Many Arabs are mixed with white European. Arabs have also been intermixing white Europeans.

[@therealzilch]

This argument of right to land because of ancestry is fraught, even if ancestors lived there at some point. If we were to follow this to its ultimate conclusion, then Africa should belong to everyone, including white Americans, because we all originated there. We need to do better than this.

[@judahdaneshtaol]

Except that the Jews never left Israel. There was always a significant community within Israel. Most Arabs living in Israel today came from Egypt, Syria and Saudia Arabia.

[@therealzilch]

@@judahdaneshtaol Except that Jews weren't the first people to live in Israel, nor was Judaism the first religion there. Israel has a long history before there were Israelites. What happened to those peoples?

[@judahdaneshtaol]

@@therealzilch If a people have lost their identity and\or their connection to the land... that is their issue. Israel never gave up the claim and never lost its identity.

[@therealzilch]

@@judahdaneshtaol So those who came before the Jews and were displaced by them are responsible for the loss of their land?

[@judahdaneshtaol]

@@therealzilch Who said that? I said we lost our land but maintained the connection.

[@Phe961]

“It’s in the bible” Crazy how many people think that God is a real estate agent

[@michaelbabbitt3837]

Did you ever read the Bible? or do you just make fun of it in a cowardly and mocking way?

[@Phe961]

@@michaelbabbitt3837 i did. But guess what, religious books are not history books. Big difference

[@lex.cordis]

@@michaelbabbitt3837 I read it (enough of it so far), and that's why I no longer believe. I'm am _not_ an atheist, but the Bible (and all other "holy" books) are allegorical and symbolic.

[@ayeletn.5107]

How about the archeology? Two minutes from my house we uncovered mikvas (Jewish ritual baths). You can't dig here without finding proof like coins and scrolls.

[@Phe961]

@@ayeletn.5107 I am not denying that jewish people were there. We all know there was always jewish presence in that land. But zionists deny that palestinians are also indigenous. Christian palestinians were local people at the time (probably jewish) who converted to Christianity. We call them the early christians. Christian palestinians are indigenous. As easy as that. Similar thing happened for muslim palestinians. It is very wrong to say that all muslims come from the arabian peninsula. Yes, islam started there in the 7th century and then spread all the way to morroco and spain in the west and indonesia in the east. But they do not all come from the same land. Asian indonesians, brown pakistanis, black somalis and white turks are all muslims, but obviously do not have the same heritage. It is called conversion. Whether it was forced to them or not. Muslim palestinians are also indigenous. Jewish people who never left the land are also indigenous. But they only represented 5% of the population in the early 1900s and also used to call themselves palestinians under ottoman empire. So saying free palestine means giving back the land to the indigenous people, all the palestinians. But to say that ALL jewish people are indigenous is very wrong. They lived outside of this land for thousands of years. It is not because judaism started there that all jews come from there. Christianity also started there, and yet we do not say that we all come from there, it just does not make sense. Isra*l was created under the Jewish supremacist ideology that this land is exclusively to the jewish people. “The promised land” and “the chose people”. That is why it is apartheid. Many jews are against zionists. It is two different things

[@JasperStoneRevFourThree]

Don't they go by the Talmud? According with Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer chapter 24 they are Jephethites, they descend from Jephet. According also with the scriptures Esau mixed with the Edomites and they became one. The Scriptures say. Esau is Edom. They aren't Israelites, they are Israelis, none of them fulfilled the curses of Deuteronomy 28:15-68. Especially verses 48 and 68. Joel 3:2, and they are not the one ones Zephaniah 3:10 is talking about, but they are for sure what Revelation 2:9 and 3:9 are talking about. They don't even look like with the people of the Lachish reliefs found in the wall of Assyria.

[@JasperStoneRevFourThree]

That is not even the land either. Watch the video by the Revisionist: The borders of Israel found in Africa.

[@StevenBrener]

Kind of a pointless question since they’ve established a fully functioning nation state where they’ve been living their lives for quite a while now and they’re just not up for self deporting any more than people from the US, Canada, New Zealand, Australia or parts of Latin America would be.

[@ef2718]

Except that Jews in Jewdea are de-colonizers.

[@Jessicaro]

yet history shows that palestine/ jerusalem always transfers from hand to hand. so yeah it might actually be possible that they will eventually end up scattered again. certainly if they follow the jewish religion that teaches that the jewish people should stay scattered till the end. there might come a day when the arabs around them will rise. where the united states won't stand by them. where they will lose everything.

[@burhan8795]

oh so it's totally fine to take a land by force as long as you build your life in it afterwards?

[@StevenBrener]

@@burhan8795 that’s not what I was saying. I’m saying that it’s a pointless question given the reality on the ground since massive self-deportation just isn’t any more likely to happen in Israel than it would be in the US, Canada, Australia, New Zealand or anywhere else for that matter.

[@raanangeberer1903]

@@burhan8795 If the Arab states hadn't invaded Israel in 1948, there wouldn't have been any war.

[@davidbroadfoot1864]

Q. "Did I annoy him?" A. "No. [He is permanently annoyed.]"

[@vae884]

Based on the this logic, every Israeli should immediately give every property and land they have to the descendants of the Romans. How dare they claim the land of the holy Greeks and Romans as their own?

[@jimseltzer2002]

You were watching a different video.

[@yessory]

If you rewrite history that Jews came AFTER the Romans, then you will be correct.

[@Darduel]

they predate the romans

[@MetalGear1]

actually it's the Romans who conquered the kingdom of Israel so the right is still with Israel. The Canaanites came before Israel, if you find them they can have a good claim.

[@poppyd517]

You cannot give the land back to the Greeks and Romans. Romans occupied, Greeks did the same in Egypt and the Holly Land But to take the Home of a Family living there for generations, peacefuly and kick every one out, well, this is criminal

[@pida9669]

Is it logical to say that I can go back to any land that my ancestors came from 3000 years ago and forcibly take the land back for myself? I have 2 parents, 4 grandparents, 8 great-grandparents, ... and going back 3000 years (or 120 generations) that quickly adds up to trillions of ancestors (minus any inbreeding). So, I can go anywhere these ancient ancestors lived (which probably covers most of the globe) at any time, and kick out whoever happens to be living there today? 🤔

[@pikapi6993]

Maybe you should ask that Ghana and other West African countries that are openly advertising the return of Black American descendants of slaves to Africa. I have seen nobody complain about this, even though Black Americans are divorced from African culture. It's only a problem if Jews return to their homeland, even thought they preserved their culture for thousands of years. Even though they are the ones who are able to understand all of archaeological discoveries they are making in the Holy Land, - while the descendants of Arab colonizers understand nothing.

[@pida9669]

​@@pikapi6993 Maybe nobody's complaining about African Americans returning to West Africa because those people aren't using deadly force to push out the current occupants? 🤔Watch the 2022 documentary Tantura where Israeli soldiers themselves describe how they massacred Palestinians in 1948, even those who had surrendered, as part of the founding of Israel.

[@pikapi6993]

@@pida9669 No, this is false. The Jews didn't do this. The Pro Palestinian crowd lied to you. The Jews just migrated back to their homeland to flee persecution in other countries. Do you think refugees are able to occupy a land? Please use your brain. The Jewish refugees also brought Western technological know how with them and improved the lives of people, which led to Arab migration to the region. The Jews were proud of this migration of Arabs to the land. They thought this means that they are going to achieve good things and live in peace with them. But that's not what most of the Arabs wanted. Most of them didn't want Jews which is why they started massacring them. They hate Jews more than they loved progress. See "Sahih Muslim 2922", google it. The Grand mufti of Jerusalem (Islamic judge) collaborated with Hitler and promised him the support of Muslims against the Jews. The Arabs achieved an immigration stop for Jewish people (while Arabs were still allowed) in the British Mandate of Palestine in 1939. During the time when the Holocaust started and Jews needed it the most. People like you mention 1948, when Arabs were the ones who started it decades before this. Countless Muslim/Arab crimes against Jews are documented in the region before Jews started to arm themselves and defend themselves. Just google what's happening to Nigerian Christians. Nigerian Muslims killed 60.000 Nigerian Christians since the year 2000. It's always Muslim who start these things. And then they call the other the oppressors when they defend themselves. Sadly, Nigerian Christians don't have the power to defend themselves. The UN proposed the two state solution in 1947. The Jews accepted it. The Arabs rejected it and started a civil war. Then in 1948 5 Arab countries joined the war against Israel the same day Israel declared its indepence.. legally. The UN allowed them to found their state, they accepted it. Arab countries disagrees, started a war, told the Arabs who lived there to leave and come back after they threw the Jews to the sea, and then they lost. They are bad losers. That's why this conflict is still going on

[@momimel9676]

​@@pikapi6993as long as no genocide

[@maxi0613]

jews have continuously lived in that land, yes at times their population reduced because of expulsion or persecution, but throughout history they've maintained presence in that land

[@bilalrana873]

Your channel and your work is amazing. I can't think of another forum where one can hear directly from Palestinians and Israelis.

[@Peculiarsteve]

Revelation 2:9 I know thy works, and tribulation, and poverty, (but thou art rich) and I know the blasphemy of them which say they are Jews, and are not, but are the synagogue of Satan.

[@fae137]

Amazingly biased.

[@ForrestMccroy]

@@fae137Which side do you think he’s biased against?

[@bagabossa9970]

I am a descendant of Adam and I want the land where he was living...

[@tanvirkabir4960]

Africa,, Adam came down to Africa. And someone at the top of the comment section has already expressed his worry about this, since he happens to be from Africa too. LoL

[@ashj5952]

7:30 In response, The Holy Quran does not talk about Allah promising any land to any one till the end of time. Regarding the Jews being the chosen people, this is what Quran says: "Say, ˹O Prophet,˺ “O Jews! If you claim to be Allah’s chosen ˹people˺ out of all humanity, then wish for death, if what you say is true.” (Surah Al Jum'ah: 6)

[@neil865]

Silly question really as various Jewish manuscripts, such as The Dead Sea Scrolls, originate from Israel and furthermore DNA tests have proven that Jews originated from Israel. The meaning of Palestinians on the other hand has changed through the years, and in 1099 for example, was referred to both Jews and Muslims (who were united in their fight against the Crusaders). What really matters now though, is that we all tolerate each other whoever and wherever we are.

[@trenee23000]

Two questions: 1) Do you know what DNA company was used because 23 & me says differently? 2) I thought DNA test were illegal in Israel? Sincerely asking so I can have a better idea of the Israeli point of view. Be blessed and stay strong.

[@neil865]

Israelis have been known to have DNA tests abroad and 23andMe for example, show a Levantine percentage. @@trenee23000

[@trenee23000]

@@whyka2116 Truly, 100 percent with absolutely no admixtures? As for DNA test being illegal in Israel, it's went viral. An Arab gentleman started if you take the test it will show that your really go back to the caucus mountains and you aren't indigenous to Israel, the land mass. I'll take you at your word but this is what social media is showing. Again stay strong and be blessed.

[@trenee23000]

@@whyka2116 I definitely learned something from you as well. Take care

[@iiiid3443]

The essence of Palestinians hasn't changed throughout years. It's not about being jew christian or muslim. It's about making the difference between the people who lived there , stayed there, and are there for the last 1000 years at least, and the people who came not even 100 years ago and expelled them on the basis of their 3000 years old claim. It does not matter if the firsts are muslim, christians, or jews, since they were there, this is their land. And neither does it matter who these newcomers are, had they been portuguese, hindous, or swedish instead of jew won't make a difference either. If you live in Europe for 2000 years, I just guess you're European. You absolutely can be jew (faith wise and even heritage wise) but that land your 3000 years old ancestors left is no longer yours, how is that even a thing for some people, it defies logic to even need to remind people of that.

[@aestradarespeto]

I am spaniard, and when muslims from middle east and Morocco talk about Spain they call it A-Andalus, and says it is the land of their grandfathers. They consider my country a land that is of their own. So, spaniards have no right to be in Spain and must leave or convert to islam. That is the rule of all muslims. Every place they have possesed in every moment of the history automatically is converted into a muslim territory and their inhabitants are not allowed to live there. How we can make a peaceful agreement with someones that think that way? There is no way.

[@tanvirkabir4960]

You are not talking about all Muslims. We don't live for ever on this rock, and many tend to forget that, even some Muslims. Only the one true Almighty is the king of the Heavens and the Earth and all that is in between. We are nothing but His slaves.

[@ghosthunter0950]

except the fuckers conquered it through their empire. it never was theirs.

[@cnationtv8282]

1st no Muslim ever says that. People of Spain used to to be Muslim Andalusian Arabs before being conquered by Christian powers of Europe the process of conversion for your ancestors was among the most brutal in history ever. What we say is that before becoming a Christian your ancestors were Muslims offcourse now we can't change history of 400 to 500 years but atleast respect the Islamic heritage of your country. That's what we ask. That's it. Peace

[@TheZejota]

@@cnationtv8282 I accept the islamic heritage of my country, beautiful buildings, mix of culture, enriched diet and technology from that time as it was invaded by muslims but before muslim was Christian and Roman. Don't you realize that it never ends? it doesn't matter where you draw the line, there will always be a "but before it was ". Accept how countries have developed over history. Otherwise we could take this rule and retake the spanish empire again, or the roman or the macedonian... it is ridiculous.

[@asifnaeem8783]

Than apply this rule to jews also.

[@lawrencewinter]

You know, 250 years ago my family owned a mansion in England. Should I go there and claim it back?

[@RicardoLopez-ub2hs]

The majority of Israelis currently living in Israel are descendents of jews kicked out of arab countries (who migrated to arab countries after being kicked out of Israel by Romans). European jews are descendents of jews who migrated to European countries after being kicked out from Israel by Romans. Some jews managed to stay in Israel after the Roman expulsion and some returned after the end of the Roman empire.. The homeland of the jews is Israel.

[@LinaC-qx1gs]

Don’t forget to show up with your own army. It really sells the story lol

[@ForrestMccroy]

I appreciate that you seem to go out of your way not to be biased in your interviews. You are tough with both people’s and ask very heavy questions to both.

[@jaggar28]

7:30 Even though we Muslims and Jews worship the same GOD, the Jews made the Torah so corrupt that their idea of GOD is very very racist. Also, I'd like to add a correction here to what Corey said, we Muslims are not the "choosen" people in the sense like the Jews, rather we are commanded by Allah SWT to coexist with Jews and Christians. We are not superior by birth, rather a person can only be superior to others in Allah's eyes (not literally) only by peity and rememberance of him and following his commandments. Muslim is not a race, it's someone who submits to the will of Allah SWT.

[@danielgreen1124]

You could have just said that you didn't understand him. There's nothing corrupt about the Torah.

[@tandavawalsh0777]

@@danielgreen1124 The whole foundation of the Torah is hateful genocidal religious extremism. The jewish obsession's with dominance, control, theocracy, and genocide is absolutely baked in to the very foundation of their religion. You cannot have Judaism without all of these things, and anything without those things is not actual Judaism

[@shainazion4073]

There is not One proof that the Torah was ever Corrupted, not in Your Quran even. Lies spread by the Imams and others. There is NO original Quran available to see if any of the 35+ Qurans are original. The Quran was sent to 5 different locations after they standardized it and there is not one original Quran at all. There are over 5000 differences between Hafs and Warsh alone!!

[@jagardositumorang4320]

That ridiculuos thought of you've said that muslims must co-existed with jews and christians while in quran many verses said to fight and kill jews and kuffar as many as you meet,,are you sure your allah commanded you live co-existence with jews and christians or you've kind of drunk when you typing it???,,,😂😂

[@Aricboccara]

You live in a dream...a nightmare I should say... how do you know the jews corruption their Torah? A book that you never read???

[@user-pm3bx2ee4q]

I love how the same people who are quick to point out how Jews were expelled from every country they’ve ever lived in, can’t comprehend that they were long ago expelled from the kingdom of Israel.

[@elizabethdegroot89]

👏 👏

[@RicardoLopez-ub2hs]

The majority of Israelis currently living in Israel are descendents of jews kicked out of arab countries (who migrated to arab countries after being kicked out of Israel by Romans). European jews are descendents of jews who migrated to European countries after being kicked out from Israel by Romans. Some jews managed to stay in Israel after the Roman expulsion and some returned after the end of the Roman empire.. The homeland of the jews is Israel.

[@DogFoxHybrid]

It is deliberate historical revisionism to try to portray Jews as a culture that never had a homeland (despite ample historical, archeological, and now genetic evidence) that deliberately seeks out to exploit and subvert their "host" nation.

[@4thbranch834]

It was nice seeing the lady around 12 minutes being kind and honest about not necessarily knowing and admitting that the unfairness is wrong. At least that is what it seemed like she was saying to me.

[@user-je7gf5uc3c]

That's funny, my impression was that she's like "I live a comfortable life here so whatever happened in history doesn't matter" 😅

[@4thbranch834]

​@@user-je7gf5uc3cI just went back and watched it again and you are right. It is easy for us to ignore problems when we are not necessarily experiencing the problems for ourselves and not everybody is concerned with putting themselves into other people's shoes to understand their situation, oftentimes I believe it is because if we put ourselves into other people's shoes we will realize that we are doing something wrong ourselves and that would ruin our good time. I guess that really captures the state of Israel today.

[@AmineSoso-ws4eb]

You know the language they’re speaking directly comes from Israel right? 😂 Hebrew is the only Canaanite language that’s still spoken til this day and it doesn’t originate from Germany, Poland, Morocco, Syria….

[@user-je7gf5uc3c]

@@4thbranch834 it's sad but true. I only hope they can open their eyes and hearts enough to care about the suffering that the Palestinians are being subjected to.

[@user-je7gf5uc3c]

@@AmineSoso-ws4eb it's a fascinating language. What's your point?

[@joijencuyah2345]

No, what the interviewer doesn't understand is that jews have never identified with whatever country they are in, they have always identified as "jewish", even if not religious & only cultural. I was not raised Jewish but married a jewish man & have come to experience jewish renewal in a universal way & i celebrate jewish holidays this way with jews & non jews alike. Jewish people have been tortured & expelled from country after country over the centuries..they always know they are home with other jewish people, with the land of Israel, even if it is only in their hearts..a place where they are free to be jews, no one will threaten ti kill them if they "font convert" & no one will ever torture them or expel them again! Anyone who has ever felt "shakiness" around the sense of "home ", feeling safe, feeling connected, no matter what, might be able to identify with the depth of their connection with the "homeland". I don't believe there was ever a country called "Palestine ".

[@hebrewgreek7420]

The Hebrew language is literally “the language of Canaan,” שפת כנען sefat Kenaʿan. Biblical Hebrew is one of the historical dialects of the land of Canaan. It is mutually intelligible with Phoenician, Moabite, Ammonite, and Edomite.

[@zohreHakimi18]

@infinitewatersss5959 not true. biblical hebrew is totally understandable for any hebrew speaking person

[@RosinDaddy5280]

So it's a language not an ethnicity

[@nickolasgaspar9660]

Aramaic

[@pulsar22]

@infinitewatersss5959 I would bet old Hebrew is more intelligible to current people living in Israel and Palestine than medieval English is to current English speakers. You make it sound as if the current language of Israelis is a made up language. Language evolve.

[@LeeHanBoon]

I thought it was Aramaic during Jesus times.

[@matejfele9971]

Simple answer. Why are the temple mount and al aqsa mosque built on the wailing wall?

[@marksimons8861]

You might well ask why there's a mosque on top of the Cave of the Patriarchs in Hebron.

[@zevspitz8925]

The waqf refuses to allow much-needed repairs on the Mugrabi Gate, a crumbling 15-year-old raised wooden walkway leading up to the Temple Mount, because they're absolutely terrified of the wealth of archeological evidence that will be uncovered while replacing it.

[@ulysses4989]

@@zevspitz8925 elaborate

[@zevspitz8925]

@@ulysses4989 See the Wikipedia articles for the "Mughrabi Bridge", and the heading "Mughrabi Gate ramp replaced by a bridge (February 2007)" in the article "Excavations at the Temple Mount"

[@jasonkemmerer5654]

@@zevspitz8925 no matter where a human temple may be built GOD wants to build HIS Temple in your heart and make you a Temple of GOD where HE GOD HIMSELF dwells in. this can only happen by believing in THE MESSIAH WHOM HE SENT WHOSE NAME IS YESHUA HA MASHIACH or Jesus THE MESSIAH. if you put your trust in HIM; that HE IS GOD, that HE died to make The Final Atonement for your sins and that 3 days later HE rose from the dead. if you believe in these things than you will have Eternal Life and become a Temple not made by human hands but made by GOD HIMSELF

[@ofrikalif4938]

It's seems like this question was more of a patience test than a real question. Now go and ask this question in ramallah. Don't forget a bulletproof vest.

[@shanihodia297]

LOL TRUE

[@arhamakhyar3088]

​@@shanihodia297 Palestinians are original people of that land. They've been there for thousands of years. And people in west bank are going through far worse than you can imagine ;by israel of course. So,they wouldn’t be offended at these questions. Cuz,they are going through far worse.

[@arhamakhyar3088]

Stop colonizing

[@Jessicaro]

how was it not a real question? majority of people in israel come from european decent. and yet claim to be palestinian/ israeli who have lived there 3000 years ago. just because you are jewish does not mean you have a claim on the land. judaism is after all a religion. you guys could have lived next to each other like they did before. stop acting like there weren't any jews or christians living in palestine before 1948.oh and unlike the jews palestinians actually are from that land. didn't leave that land and can trace their ancestors.

[@shainazion4073]

@@Jessicaro Actually if you bothered to look, 80% of the Israeli Jews are Sabras, Sixty percent of Israeli Jews are Mizrahi Jews forced out of the Arab Muslim countries when Israel became a state. There are less than 30% of Israeli Jews that have ethnos from Europe, and less than 5% that actually are from Europe, the Ukrainians and Russians escaping the recent war.

[@jamesr2408]

If Arabs want to play the new convert card, saying the Jews in the land were recent converts, then let the Arabs also convert to Judaism. That is not prohibited -- Ruth converted -- and they can have a share in the Land. This is the Promised Land for the Chosen People. At the least, either you agree or find some place else in Saudi Arabia/Egypt/North Africa/etc ...

[@LeastPatrioticIsraelbelike]

why are jews who lived in israel and got expelled to other countries(example morroco) are called morrocan jews and not israeli jews. but people who lived in "palestine" and immigrated to other countries are still called "palestinians and not jordanians ( jordan for example)?

[@sarahsharaf2472]

Because that is the truth. they are Morocon jews and these are Palestinians You can't escape from your origins Whatever illusions media spreads every day, the truth will remain the truth

[@Yoom5]

Maybe because they are from Palestine and the israeli has no connection whatsoever other than what is writtern in their books.

[@gghstlr]

“I have no reason to look into it at all because things are good here”- at least she’s honest

[@3OHT.]

The context of this really matters. She said this in regards to her family's background. The interviewer asked if she considers herself "from Spain". She was born in Israel, with generations going back hundreds of years. Eventually, coming from Spain. She doesn't know everything that happened before, and isn't interested in it. Things are good here.

[@adiadizzz]

jews are indigenous to the land of Judea you brainwashed.

[@imenmabrouki3180]

@@3OHT. she herself admitted it so stop lying propagandist bot

[@3OHT.]

​@@imenmabrouki3180 Maybe you are too lazy to watch the whole video? Here is the transcript: 5:33 Man: They would say you are from Spain, not here. Woman: "First of all, I was born here. I don't know-- something else. I don't know what was before and it also doesn't interest me. Things are good here. The Jewish state, the Israeli state. We respect whoever wants to respect, will respect. Whoever does not can live here and enjoy in his corner and do what he wants. " Is everyone you dislike is a bot? إيمان مبروكي حبيبي

[@roharro2]

@@imenmabrouki3180 Damn you got humbled hahaha

[@khalid4710]

at any country in the world if you want to know the actual indigenous go to rural areas, the farmers whose lives generation after generation is the real native for the land most Palestinians( not all) are indigenous they have connections to the land to agriculture food and DNA .

[@Iefan-oc]

Yeah

[@JM-yn8mb]

Arabs come from Arabia. Jews come from Judea... Its literally in the name...

[@khalid4710]

@@JM-yn8mb most Palestinian convert to Islam and become arabic speakers, the Christian the Samaritan they speak Arabic but 100% are not orginally arabs . It is prove it by DNA test

[@JM-yn8mb]

@@khalid4710 They are genetically related to Jews. Who were there for 4,000 years. They were forcibly converted during the growth of Islam.

[@AanyaLakshimi]

The greatest palestinan Yaase arafat is egyptian

[@rayenghidhaoui890]

There is a thing I don't understand why do they say we're jews as if it was a nationality?!! In my country (tunisia) we have jews they are tunisians!!! And their religion is Judaism. Religion has nothing to do with your nationality! Hope you guys can understand that. You went to Isreal not because it's your country just because there is more chances in there you only have to be Jewish to go there and get a citizenship whereas people who were born there Palestinians (wether they are muslims or not) can't go back to their own country... This world is just so unfair...

[@aetopus1228]

The young women at 8:10 seem to have an idea of where this question runs into problems: they understand that they are the offspring of immigrants, and do not fall back on the "Bible says it's ours" argument. As an American, I am in the same position. I cannot deny that I have benefited from the conquest of my forebears, but must admit that my good fortune has come at the expense of the original inhabitants of North America. In 1920, only about 11% of the population of what is now Israel was Jewish. The only argument available to Zionists is "That's what the Bible says".

[@jessy1982]

Yes. Even if jews were mostly from the area several thousand years ago, many spread across the world, and developed new identities outside of the region with different lineages and appearances. The only reason they are trying to return after so long is because they felt unwelcome in Europe after WW2, so are using the flimsy background from a long time ago to try to claim the area. Which is a weaker claim than native americans who only lost the land a few hundred years ago, and the palestinians currently losing land for less than 80 years.

[@jessy1982]

Plus it's not even a full claim, since non-jewish people ALSO lived in the area back then, so it would be a shared territory anyway even with that reasoning - it's not like the US where it was exclusively native americans with no british colonists.

[@peckerdecker]

First time viewer. Your videos randomly *popped up* . So- clicked. You ask *great questions* Well done. Thank you. Merry Christmas everyone and a Happy 2024.

[@KatariaGujjar]

According to the Torah, Ashkenaz is a grandson of Japheth who is the brother of Shem. Only descendants of Shem are Semites. Israel/Jacob is a descendant of Shem, not Japheth, not Ashkenaz. Moses is a descendant of Shem, not Japheth, not Ashkenaz. In other words, Ashkenaz and his descendants are neither Semitic, nor Israelite, nor Jewish. Further, the Torah describes Japheth as living in the northern countries, as the Isles of the Gentiles (lit. non Jewish).

[@Buffnerd_i]

Now ask the Palestinians which all came here from the surrounding arab countries.

[@shanihodia297]

true

[@701delbronx8]

So people never lived in Palestine before the Arab conquests? Arab is a cultural term not a racial one… Palestinians are not Arab racially

[@amouri0307]

Thats a myth and has been disproven many times

[@Buffnerd_i]

@@amouri0307 You literally have nothing in this land, never ever, while the Jews have legit archeological evidence of being here before Muhammed was a sperm. stop being delusional.

[@brianhanssens7996]

@@Buffnerd_i Joan Peter's thesis she put forward in From Time Immemorial has largely been disproven. If you're Ashkenazim those Palestinian Arabs are a good deal more Canaanite than you are.

[@tommyt8998]

That's not a legitimate question; it's a provocation. And I am not Jewish.

[@klediiiww5528]

Hahaaa

[@shanihodia297]

@@klediiiww5528 you occupathion you are ilegal islamnazim fakstine made up pepole you are invnders arab from turkey egypt and arbia we jews live in israel 5000 years in israel judah kingdom from יהושוע בן נון time

[@shanihodia297]

@@klediiiww5528 shut up islamnazi

[@Thinkit-o1x]

ALL religions and cultures can examine their own histories and discrepancies. For this question to be sincere, it needs to be asked of everybody, including the Muslim / Arab societies. The Jews were colonized and then removed out of Israel because they would not abandon their Jewish identity. When they were spread around the empire, did other peoples mix in and join them? This doesn’t change the central truth of Jewish history, nor the consequences of living in other countries that either only protected them on occasion (when it served them, or when they happened to have a decent leader) or either decided to debase them, persecute, or even eliminate them. An honest look at human history shows that there is no other way than to have countries with borders that protect a culture/religion/people.

[@marksimons8861]

My family have been in the UK for nearly 180 years. By this account I have Anglo-Saxon genes. Hang on, my dad and his family was from Wales so there must be Celtic genes in my veins too. My Jewish ancestors didn't have any genes before we settled in the UK.

[@sharonstonts]

Yes many Muslims convinced themselves that Judaism is only a religion and has nothing to do with genes, heritage etc.

[@Jessicaro]

what are you trying to say? a lot of israeli's are from europe and are from european decent. dna will proof this. if your originally from palestine or israel whatever you want to call it. it would mean you would have the same dna that palestinians today have. there shouldn't be any difference considered they still live and have lived in that same country. and yet a lot of jews do not look like them nor share the same dna. and i bet if you started doing those dna test there wouldn't be a lot of israeli's who do share that dna.

[@shainazion4073]

@@Jessicaro There is no DNA study that shows Jews with predominantly European DNA. The Jews have Levantine Y- DNA with ancient Southern European Greco-Roman mitochondrial DNA from the first and second centuries. They have found through DNA that Jews can be told from Europeans at 100% Accuracy. The Jews can also be told if they had one Jewish parent or grandparent

[@Jessicaro]

@@shainazion4073 meaning they are european. being it west or south, east or north. european is still european.

[@GlasPthalocyanine]

​@@Jessicaro No. There isn't a "European" gene. They came out of Africa through the fertile crescent. The genetic ethnicities are established by comparison with other people in the same group. So, for example, some of my "European" DNA is recently recategorized as Finnish. The DNA didn't change. There are more Finns in the databases for comparison.

[@tulsacaupain2882]

2024 and people still think they are chosen. It might make you laugh if it wasn't so sad and cost the suffering of others.

[@jjmcgee5902]

I will restore the fortunes of my people Israel, and they shall rebuild the ruined cities and inhabit them; they shall plant vineyards and drink their wine, and they shall make gardens and eat their fruit. I will plant them on their land, and they shall never again be uprooted out of the land that I have given them,” says the Lord your God. Amos 9:14‭-‬15 ESV

[@tandavawalsh0777]

Even by their own stories, they stole the land in a genocide... People ignore and forget that. THE FIRST STORY of how they got there was they genocided everyone there because gOd told them too (How convenient) Revelation 3:9 ... ESV Behold, I will make those of the synagogue of Satan who say that they are Jews and are not, but lie-behold, I will make them come and bow ...

[@gghstlr]

I love the guy in the Yankee hat, saying, so vehemently “this is our land” and there’s no such thing as Palestine. “Because no one declared it”. The lack of self awareness

[@mrsandmrbutterfly]

He's right because there were always Arabs and Jews who lived in this area. War changes the boundaries of every country. Palestine does not have a seat on the UN because it's not recognized as a country. It is an area where the surrounding Arab Nations pushed them into after the war. Even during this war - they will not take them in because they've been radicalized into believing they own all of Israel. Jews fought the Arabs on all sides of the Israeli borders and won it's current boundaries. When the current lines were drawn -- no one took in the Palestinians just as they aren't taking them in right now because they were radicalized into thinking that these are their ancient lands. These are not Palastinian ancient lands. These are lands that Arabs were granted in exchange for being mercenaries in a long ago Roman war. The Jews did not kick them out because they lived peacefully along side them. But again it doesn't matter because a war settled the new borders. And again Jews gave Arabs the gaza strip and West Bank in exchange for Peace. They now call themselves Palestine and have decided that they own everything, even though they don't have their own language or their own religion. These are the things that make a place and a people distinct. They are not distinct from the surrounding Arabic Nations, they're only claim at being a distinct people is that they've been told that they have always owned everything, as a distinct people, different than the surrounding Arabic Nations. So Jews tried to make peace with them anyway. The peace treaty negotiated with them was based on the Israel-Egypt peace treaty. The jews gave Egypt the entire Sinai peninsula in exchange for peace. They have offered lands in Gaza and the West Bank in exchange for peace. But instead they have been radicalized to think they own israel. They think Hamas are protecting them against some terrorist jews and shoot rockets into Israel and send suicide bombers into Israel and teach their children to hate and kill Jews. Because Palestinians have not accepted any boundaries for peace, Israel has become more and more right-wing and has settled more and more land becoming more and more radicalized against Arabs/ in the West Bank. Arabs living in the West Bank have had that land for hundreds of years maybe longer. But those peaceful boundaries were not enough for them. They have fought the Jews over and over so the Jews have pushed further and further into them. This is the constant battle between the Jews and the Arabs who live there. This recent Terror campaign was the last straw. Jews will not rest until terrorist groups are rooted out, even if that means flooding the tunnels. Hopefully the right wing Isreali government is thrown out because the left wing government/Isreali's still want peace with its neighbor. But Palestinians will never get as good of a deal over borders as they would have in the past several times they tried to negotiate peace. Terrorists don't ever win. Wars are only won when the soldiers put down their weapons and their people choose peace over terrorism. De-radicalization of a people is very difficult. But history proves that disputes are only ended when people choose peace.

[@AmineSoso-ws4eb]

You know the language they’re speaking directly comes from Israel right? 😂 Hebrew is the only Canaanite language that’s still spoken til this day and it doesn’t originate from Germany, Poland, Morocco, Syria….

[@ydoron]

But there wasn't a country named Palestine, it is not mentioned in the Quran and it was never declared as a country. The lack of basic knowledge...

[@broom_shaped939]

Kingdom of Israel was a thing. Palestine never was. Palestinian ethnicity and self-identity wasn't a thing before jews started coming in waves after having enough of european pogroms. Read a book, moron.

[@Rami0101ify]

@@mrsandmrbutterfly HAHAHA so stupid keep arguin zionist talking point, take your foreign genes out of the middle east you dont belong no one wants you there and you will never have peace until so start behaving like humans and be respectfull of palestinians and all the arabs around you. Abraham accords is just the US bribing the rest of the arab world to accept you. The leaders of those goverments might try to normalize but the people never will. With out the US you are alone in the whole world and the US is starting to decline its only a matter of time until the colonial azhkenazis project is over

[@sagittariusone2753]

Many Jewish people were spread around the World out of their original homeland for many years,so just because a Jewish Person was born in Africa,Europe,Australia,South America,North America,Asia or in other parts of the Middle East doesn't make them any less Jewish just because they were born elsewhere. A Jewish Person will always have a connection/bond with Israel no matter where they were born.

[@Stardustradio-k4f]

That’s great and I’m Arab and I agree with them, but do they mean they got replaced by Arab ? And those Arab called themselves Palestinians? Does it mean that no one Jew converted to Christianity or Islam since 3000 years ? Because they say they own the land as if Jew is something like a race but Jesus were Jew wasn’t he? And his disciples were Jews too are they Arab since then or what should we call them ?

[@mattg3789]

@@Stardustradio-k4f If Arabs want a country with name that bares likeness, then they can migrate to Saudi Arabia. The region was named Palestine shortly after WWI ended, and British took control from the Ottoman. Jews and Arabs have occupied the area for a few thousand years. Had Jews not been persecuted throughout the world, including Middle East Arabs and invaders from other regions, then there would not have been a Zionist movement, and the U.N. would not have granted the nation of Israel. Muslim terrorism and violence will ensure that my country backs Israel as long as it has the means.

[@gertrudevanvoorden1416]

Shlomo Sand contests that.

[@مسلمعربيحر-غ9ش]

If we use the same concept, over 3000 years ago my ancestors were the Egyptian Pharos and the Jews were our slaves and the god Amon has granted us the land of Palestine along with Egypt.

[@000aysh]

Good point.

[@haroldgoodman130]

Jews have always known that our home is erets yisrael. This is only difficult for ignorant people like the questioner to understand. It's our home and we will never leave it. ever.

[@shanihodia297]

תיסלח לי הייתי במצב של מגננה מרוב שאני רגילה לתגובות אנטישמיות בעיקר אם לא הרוב על ידי ערבי רשמתי לך בכלל בלי לקרוא מה כתבת אני מבקשת שתסלח לי במחילה תודה ושנה טובה בעזרת ה' לך ולבני ביתך אהבתי את הסרטון שלך באנגלית באתר שלך עלה והצליח אמן אמן אמן :)

[@shanihodia297]

you are very very right good cooment !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@levelheaded2804]

Interesting that most of them referred to religion. If jews consider themselves Israelis regardless of where they are from. should their loyalty to their real countries (not Israel) be questioned (eg English jews from England)?

[@shanihodia297]

OUR ORGINAL COUNTRY IS ISRAEL JUDAH KINGDOM OUR LOYLATY IS ONLY TO THE ONLY GOD HASHAM AND OUR LAND ISRAEL AND OUR PEPOLE THE JEWS

[@Mg2SiO4]

Jews are as extremist as Muslims. Both of them still watch the world through the glasses of religion. This explains their violent approach to the question (from both sides). The problem is that Jews pretend to be different from Muslims from this point of view.

[@levelheaded2804]

@@shanihodia297 So English jews are from Israel and are not from England?

[@shanihodia297]

@@levelheaded2804 yes they were in england in there force exsile by the rome empire and ottomam empire like syria english he english or sryian

[@johnhewitt1324]

There are Jews in England, Spain, Italy, all of Europe because of the Diaspora originally caused by the Roman invasion at the time of Jesus Christ and the by the Muslim Arab hordes at the time of the Crusaders. Jews originally appeared in England, France, Spain were they were ex

[@baileyfranklin496]

Thank goodness we have the world's religions to tell us who is "chosen by God."

[@tanvirkabir4960]

Which God?

[@burnin8orable]

It's not a lie do your own research. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashkenazi_Jews en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sephardic_Jews

[@eng.am.a.m.a3646]

They are all lying because the original inhabitants were the Canaanites and the Jews were not in Palestine ... They were in Egypt and Sinai and then in Iraq and in other countries

[@burnin8orable]

​@@eng.am.a.m.a3646The Israelites were a Canaanite tribe. Study history and archaeology, not just the Torah.

[@burnin8orable]

@@eng.am.a.m.a3646 Do your research. I can't link anything besides Wikipedia without KZbin taking down the comment so start here. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israelites

[@shainazion4073]

@@eng.am.a.m.a3646 Bot alert! You don't know any other words???

[@georgizagorchev9655]

I'm a Bulgarian Christian and I have a cousin Jew. We have the same blood, but I'm not Jewish. This happened because of a mixed marriage of a Bulgarian woman with a Jewish man. It takes one generation (20-30 years) to become mixed with another people with different beliefs and religions. It's impossible for 2000+ years the Jews to not get mixed with other people after being scattered around world. I repeat I'm a Bulgarian Christian and I have a Jewish cousin.

[@mriwa85]

and your jewish belgarian cousin has the right to go to Palestine, to pretend that this is his land, he has even the right to kick out a palestinian family from their home and to take their place. Hilarious

[@gunterra1]

That question is a covertly hostile question to confuse the person being asked implying that the person does not belong here. The reality of the situation is that a highly skilled and civilised people established the state of Israel with its statehood fully recognised by the UN 75 and the international community 75 years ago. And as such Israel, like any other state, has the right to invite or permit immigration as it sees fit. So, if the person asked was born here or has an Israeli ID document or passport, he/she belongs here and anyone implying otherwise is propagating a lie. Period. I would even go as far as suggesting that those Palestinians who cannot accept that fact and shoot rochets at Israel or send in suicide bombers, in other words break the law, must be asked to leave, or made to leave Palestine entirely.

[@shaneneely3415]

Biblical references aside, there were a large population of canaanites who were hebrews in this land even previous to the ancient solomon temple and israelite presence. The romans recorded numerous times 'quashing rebellions from the israelites' who were in that area when they conquered it. This questions only feeds ignorance and confuses the issue which fuels this issue further.

[@liaa4172]

The Canaanis are arabs 😂😂😂 be so serious please, i cant take you people seriously with this nonsense, Palestinians share DNA with Canaanis more than any European settler will lmfao

[@chavdarnaidenov2661]

I have in my possession a Holy Book that mentions, that my tribe originated from your penthouse on Fifth Avenue in Manhattan. You know, the one with the swimming pool? I will be having my home back now, thank you. Please leave the keys with the janitor.

[@YonatanRosmarin]

There are two answers I can think about. First of all, there are Jewish places in this land, which means that there used to be a Jewish community here. Now let's say that my ancestors converted to Judaism, and genetically we are not from here. Still, the culture is Jewish, and the longing for Jerusalem still exist, and the the prosecution on the basis of Judaism existed. So even if I cannot trace back my family to king David, I still see myself as part of this nation, and this land.

[@mikeg2306]

Why would anyone convert to such a persecuted identity?

[@YonatanRosmarin]

@@mikeg2306 some poeple say that the origin of the European Jews is from the Khazars, that converted as a whole, so there were not persecuted there.

[@transcendentalmess]

This is such important work. Thank you so much for this. What an incredible resource.

[@davidtrak2679]

Now ask the Palestinians the same. They know many of them can trace their origins to Syria, Egypt, even Bosnia

[@ulysses4989]

Most Israelis are European LMFAO. The difference is Palestinians were always on this land.

[@Ash_Queen16]

@@ulysses4989Wrong

[@davidtrak2679]

@@ulysses4989 Most Israelis are Mizrahi and Arab, so Middle East dwellers. Try better next time. Also, I remember no Palestinians in the Bible, Herodotus writings or even the British Mandate paper, so you should try picking up a book sometime

[@shanihodia297]

@@ulysses4989 you occupathion you are ilegal islamnazim fakstine made up pepole you are invnders arab from turkey egypt and arbia we jews live in israel 5000 years in israel judah kingdom from יהושוע בן נון time

[@ulysses4989]

@@davidtrak2679 Ah yes because the Bible is so accurate.

[@peterang6912]

Problem with those people is that they make the mistake between DNA and religion.. two different things....

[@saraleigh5336]

Nope. You have made the mistake of mapping one-dimensional religion onto Judaism, which is an ethnoreligion, a Levantine tribal identity. Think of it this way: Hitler didn’t target the devout, he targeted bloodlines.

[@flutterlump]

Judaism is both tho.

[@rohanmarkjay]

I bet this is what white south africans were saying as well during the south africa apartheid days.

[@Zane70K]

The question itself is biased and racist. It's like asking a Muslim, how do you love with the lie that Mohammed was a prophet?? In some places that question itself woukd get someone hurt. cause it's offensive

[@jth6587]

Why is the question racist!! Rather, say that the question revealed their lies... He says that he has been here for three thousand years, then we discover that he is Yemeni 🤣 .

[@msakbar12345]

muslim is not Arab, you can jewish muslim, white muslim, cjinese Muslim or even eskimo muslim...so it.s chosen by the heart, not by the race.

[@Zane70K]

@@msakbar12345 jewish muslim? jewish is a religion lol

[@sharonstonts]

Jews are from Judea, there is really nothing more to add to that. The Palestinians are the new ppl (relatively in the history of the world).

[@Warlock786]

Why does that rule not apply to the entire world ?

[@sharonstonts]

@@Warlock786 what rule is that?

[@shanihodia297]

@@Warlock786 IT SHOULD ISLAMNAZI BUT WE JEWS NOT RULE THE WORLD I THINK THAT YOU ISLAMNAZIM NEED TO BRING BACK TO ARMINIA PEPOLE THIER REAL COUNTRY THAT YOU CALLED NOW TURKEY YOU STAAEL IT FROM ARMNIA

[@Warlock786]

@sharonstonts why are'nt white Americans in an open air prison and Native Americans are being given stolen houses and land ? Why not the same the the aboriginal people from Australia or the Samoans from New Zealand ? That rule !

[@dogbert52]

​@@Warlock786why are potatoes not butterflies? Why do you people always lie and obfuscate?

[@Neptunian65]

Listen. My grandparents are jewish. They came from Yemen to Palestina even before Israel was established. My grandfather showed me correspondence between the jewish community in Yemen and the jews in Palestina (Yes jews were living in palestina next to arabs) I read those letters and I noticed they called the land of Israel, the Holy land. For generations in diaspora they were praying to return to the Holy land, Eretz Israel. Thank God my grandparents fulfilled that wish. It was not a fantasy, it is in the Bible. Israel is the homeland of jews.

[@tulsacaupain2882]

Very sad

[@Justice--Peace-h5r]

Were they planning to steal it and kill its people?

[@NadaTae]

Don’t you wish to go back to your own country yemen?

[@nigelsheppard625]

It's funny how this question is often posed in the UK by people who are either first generation immigrants from the Indian sub-continent, from Africa or from the Arab world. But if they're asked if they do not come from the UK then they denounce the question as racist and in fact an indigenous Briton is simply not allowed to ask this question.

[@ace6285]

Confronted with a really offensive question, all those people were courteous, calm, reasonable, knowledgeable, confident and kind. Israelis are really developed and wonderful people.

[@BeNGALi4LFE]

you should see the abby martin interview. really developed and wonderful people there.

[@dalisozulu1855]

Thank God I am not fulish and ignorant

[@ace6285]

@@dalisozulu1855 foolish

[@priuss6109]

​@@BeNGALi4LFEi second abby martin

[@restlesssoulme]

So the argument is based on religious text , which we all know belongs to fiction section of book store

[@edinacamden4346]

There are plenty of archaeological evidence to prove they are right.

[@Србомбоница86]

Nah ,its history book

[@cestchill111]

including themselves; as over 70% of them are atheist

[@mirzamirzali5257]

history of 9000years bc from a fairytale jude

[@RobPires]

Basically they are saying 2 thousand years ago, the land allegedly belong to their ancestors. They left thousands of years ago and now they return, so they still own the land. It doesn't matter what else happened in the past 2 thousand years. 😂😂😂

[@rachelsamuel3328]

Learn some history, they didn't leave, they were forced out. Every aspect of being a Jew is tied to Israel, from the calender, to the festivals, to the prayers, to the Holy Days.......etc. For over 2000 years every day Jews around the world prayed to return to Zion!

[@anthonyr963]

Jevvs are the only people who achieved decolonization of their homeland. When are native Americans suddenly not native, according to you?

[@RobPires]

@@rachelsamuel3328 Learn basic common sense. There are many people who have lived on the land and many things happened for that 2 thousands of years. Common sense should tell us they should own the land. 'Praying' from thousands of miles away is not a reasonable excuse to claim rights to the said land. You said Jews around the world 'prayed to return to Zion'. That is dishonest. There are more Jews in USA. They don't seem to share this 'longing to return' narrative of yours.

[@rachelsamuel3328]

@@RobPires You have to use some basic common sense, there was only 350,000 people in the entire land in 1860, and 30,000 were Jews, this is when the Jews started returning in larger numbers. The Ottoman's never built up any infrastructure here, and the people were not the land's owners. It was poor, undeveloped lands. These people were Ottoman subjects living in Ottoman lands, just as all the other parts of the Empire. When the Ottomans signed All their lands to the Allies, It then became the responsibility of the League of Nations to speak with the different people groups living in the lands to decide who would get which lands. Three Mandates were created. The Mandate of Mesopatamia (Iraq), the Mandate of Lebanon and Syria, and the Mandate of Palestine. The other lands of the Ottoman Empire were divided into allready existing states, Egypt, Greece, Turkey, Cyprus, etc. The British illegally gave 77% of the Mandate of Palestine's lands to the Arab Hashemites, who were not even Levantines. This left only 23% of the land to become the Jewish state. The Ottoman Land Registry (1858 to 1871) showed only 13% of the land privately owned. The British Land Survey of 1945 showed that the Palestinian farmers owned only 3.3% of the land. The wealthy absentee Arab land holders owned 16.5% of the land The Jews owned 8.6% of the land. And, 70% of the land was uninhabited State Lands, transferred from the Ottomans, to the British, and then to Israel. Israel was created out of almost 80% of non-Arab lands. Before 1948, every piece of land the Jews lived on was purchased lands. Bought for 10 times the going rate for good rich farmland, and the Jews were only able to buy malarial swampland or rocky desert land from the Arabs and Turks. The early Jewish leaders appealed to the Arabs to stay in their houses and villages and help create a country together, after Israel became a state, the Arabs had 5 other Arab countries attack the one day old country of Israel. They Lost! Their choice of attacking, rather than letting the Jews have the 23% that was left of the Mandate lands. Another thing, The British at the Peel commission in 1937 offered the Arabs 80% of the land that was left. They turned that down because they didn't want the Jews to even have the other 20%. *Which was only 4.5% of the Mandate lands.*

[@RobPires]

@@rachelsamuel3328 We can go through United Nations records on land purchase and it will tell the world who owns most of the lands. It is lopsided. It is a simple research. You yourself cited the imbalance of demographic ratio that was roughly 1 to 9. This ratio carried on until Balfour Declaration. How on earth does the 1 get more than half of the land decades later? You have yet to apply common sense. Lets not forget, none of the thousands of words that you just threw have anything to do with my original comments. Just the usual mind gymnastics that serves as a deflection from the fact people who lived elsewhere 'praying' for thousands of years doesn't have a right to claim lands thousands of miles away and create a country on top of someone else's country.

[@YEORLE]

just wanna say to whoever it was that came up with the idea that morrocan, egyptian, etc jews were converts: a: the jewish nation is not totally genetic: a person only counts as jewish if their mother was a jew, and when someone converts (which is rare, even today) they are regarded as if their "souls" have been jewish since sinai. when you convert, you get the whole package, not just the religeon. b: why the heck would anyone want to convert to judaism? everyone just wants to kill us all the time. edit: just want to mention that im refering to orthodox conversion. i dont understand the point of reform.

[@AhJodie]

I could see their feelings even when I didn't know their language.... it was a very cold question... and I am surprised no one hit you. All the people you asked were very polite, intelligent and even kind. They told the truth of what they feel. I don't think a lot of them do realize the horrible things that go on with the Palestinas.... just like I don't know what it is like in many parts of the USA that I don't live!

[@tulsacaupain2882]

They have been very politie to the Palestinians.

[@mino3d1]

They knew they were in you tube

[@EloheinuElEkhad]

Funny people in the comment section think palestinians were living here for 100,000 years, dna test of palestinians show theu have roots in Chad, Sudan, Egypt, Lebanon Jordan, Turkey Yemen and so on, yet here you are funny people, talking about israelis roots 😂

[@jannahfirdaws9791]

Israelis: " we lived here 3000 years ago!" Palestinians: "we've been living here for the past 3000 years!"

[@Winterfell1066]

Goodness, 3000 years ago, even Israel was not formed. Sumeria was beginning its civilasation at Eridu and Ur. The Akkadians dominated Sumerian from about 2500 on. As far as the Palestinians go, who are their famous leaders of antiquity? Who were their kings? Where is their literature? When and Arab herder found the Dead Sea scrolls, were they Palestinian or Jewish (Israeli). When Sennacherib of Assyria besieged Jerusalem was the King Hezekiah of Judah or was it a Palestinian king? All of the written history and archeological history points to Israel, Judah, Samaria, Nothing points to "Palestinian" heritage.

[@fun_ghoul]

@@Winterfell1066 Do you know how nations are formed, clown? Like, do you imagine Adam and Eve were Jewish??? 🤓

[@edinacamden4346]

FACTS……you are absolutely correct but they don’t wanna hear that.@@Winterfell1066

[@andym9571]

....and who lived there for hundreds of thousands of years before Jews existed ?

[@BanaiFeldstein]

@@andym9571Not the people calling themselves palestinians only since 1964.

[@einavassido875]

Verse 137 of Chapter 7 in the Quran where it is explicitly stated: "We gave as an inheritance to a people who considered themselves weak the land which we blessed, the east and the west, in such a way that God perfectly fulfilled his good word about the children of Israel, due to prolonging their spirit."

[@ajarnwordsmith628]

Thank you. This is one of your most important KZbin pieces to date. B"H

[@MateoMPM]

Damn, that's a hard and spicy question 😂🤣 the majority of them responded quite decently and calm despite being such a hard question, props to them..

[@eng.am.a.m.a3646]

They are all lying because the original inhabitants were the Canaanites and the Jews were not in Palestine ... They were in Egypt and Sinai and then in Iraq and in other countries

[@Abilliph]

​@@eng.am.a.m.a3646if you believe this nonsense from the Bible, then you probably also believe God gave them the land for eternity. If you don't believe the bible, and that the land is theirs, then you shouldn't believe that they came from Egypt. Research show the Jews are a group of Canaanites.

[@ציפיספרן]

​@@eng.am.a.m.a3646No, you are lying and changing history.

[@ronblevins3346]

@@ציפיספרןyou, along with everyone in this video, just do not know your own history. Nor do you want to. It’s great to think that you are the only god’s chosen and believe you belong in a land that was merely one out of 4 options. You people really don’t know and that is sad.

[@עידוגולד-ט6ט]

​@@eng.am.a.m.a3646yea, just like the Bible says right? Here is your Azami Bish-ra the escaping traitor, confessing the lie. P.s. when you call yourself Philistins you call yourself an invader, congratulations. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHWYqZeQnKh7rM0

[@hansdampffer9907]

Why is this dude not going for example to the US and ask them the same question? I promise you he wouldnt do that because that is pure antisemitic question

[@shainazion4073]

It is an important question, as many of the Arabs feel this way, it allowed the Israelis to explain that they are Jews, and Jews come from Judea.

[@shainazion4073]

In America, in one apartment building, you have Chinese, Irish, Jewish, Black, Japanese, Haitian, etc. Most Native Americans live in the West on reservations.

[@abrahamsasa3439]

If they so sure they belong here where were they 80years ago Something don't make sense and why do they destroy everything around them and replace it with modern architecture

[@DanNaim400]

We came from all over the word Just like how G-D says he will bring us back from all over the world..this must be a Palestinian question..now ask them how they feel knowing their losers for the past 100 yrs

[@DanNaim400]

@shalomshalom8715 muslim came 1000 years after Judaism..stop forcing matters..islam is pure paganism…just like the philistines and edomites

[@amouri0307]

Whatsboutism

[@Arzhang-nu4yq]

Palestinian r ex Judaism

[@aragon533]

Weren't jews persecuted like thousands of years and were losers? This is quite hypocritical to ask given the situation the jews were in in Europe before 1946. Your military victories do not decide whether or not you are morally correct in what you are doing neither back then nor now

[@folusoadam]

Do you think the oppression of Palestinians will go on forever?

[@kiyoeyamada2513]

This is exactly same question that I have been asking for long time. It seems to me incomprehensible that Israel is only for Jews. Also national flag is David Star. There are many Muslims and Christians, too. I’m a Japanese married with Israeli and living in Israel. My son is serving in the army now. In this time of war, I’m learning and realizing many things. Focus on what I have and being gratitude. Not looking for what I don’t have. Because if focus on what I don’t have, it makes me to find many parts of bad or complaining about the others. I wish people would live more humble and not let the settlers take the land of Arabs. Just live in peace Arabs and Jews.

[@bip2186]

If you will learn history of jevs , you can see that they are the best thieves and liars in the world.@@rile4199 #FreePalestine

[@midapuella9053]

Thank u! ❤ You are absolutely right!

[@pvilla24]

Wow. Very difficult position you are in. Your opinion is complex and honorable. I hope you and your family the best. Honto!

[@HarryPost-o9c]

Let's talk about Japan. Let's talk about how accepting you were of the Chinese (Rape of Nanking) or the Koreans, or Indo Chinese. You Japanese are very accepting and magnanimous. You accepted the atomic bomb from America quite well. You also said that they land is for both Jews and Muslims . Then you say don't let the Jews take Arab land. So which is it? If the land is for everyone it should be shared and not exclusively for ragheads.

[@molivson]

"Land of Arabs" you mean Jordan, Syria, Egypt?

[@Linda43]

A Blessed Shavuah Tov To Everyone... Have A Wonderful Week 😊 From Eretz Yisroel HaShlema. The Jewish People Are The Indegenous People Of The Southern Levant With A Continuous Presence Of More Than 4ooo Years.

[@maggoli67]

Shavuah tov!

[@Linda43]

​@@maggoli67 🕊

[@eng.am.a.m.a3646]

They are all lying because the original inhabitants were the Canaanites and the Jews were not in Palestine ... They were in Egypt and Sinai and then in Iraq and in other countries

[@Linda43]

G-d is the owner of the world and he allowed the Caananites to live on the land but they defiled it. He then chose to give the land of Israel to the Jewish People as a heritage.

[@Linda43]

​@@Neel71 The Arabs are immigrants from Arabia who occupied and colonized Eretz Yisroel during the Arab Conquests 1400 years ago and again from the mid 1800s - 1945 when Jews brought prosperity to the land of Israel and during WW2 when Jewish immigration was limited by the British at the behest of the Arab leadership ( White Papers) and massive Arab immigration from the region was permitted.

[@PrintProfessor]

Name a famous Palestinian person from before 1948. The country of Palestine has never existed. The kingdom of Israel is well documented.

[@TuncayKaradeniz-j2q]

Name an Israeli prime minister or president whose father was born in the land called Israel.

[@PrintProfessor]

@@TuncayKaradeniz-j2q Saul, David, Solomon, Jeroboam I, Rehoboam, Abijam, Asa, Nadab, Baasha, Eloah, Tibni, Zimri, Omri, Ithobaal, Ahab, Jehoshaphat, Ahaziah, Joram, Jehoram, Ahaziah, Jehu, Athaliah, Jehoash, Jehoahaz, Joash, Jeroboam II, Uzziah, Jotham, … the list of kings go on and on, there’s a very deep history of kingdoms of israel in the region. Is there anything similar for a country called Palestine or has it always simply been the name of the region? If your question is with regards to the Jewish diaspora, and how they were scattered around the planet due to antisemitism, slavery, and various attempts at genocide, one first has to consider that in order to be a diaspora, you have to emanate from somewhere. That place is proven in history to be various settlements and kingdoms in the region of Palestine. They were forced from their homes and villages by various empires and their ancestral homes were taken over by unapologetic Arabs, expanding their settlements. About 1600 years into recorded Hebrew history in the region, a new religion called Islam arose. A few years later a caliphate of adherents captured Jerusalem led by the peaceful prophet’s best friend. Coincidentally, it also quickly became Islam’s third most holy site, with many wonders and miracles occurring there after and prior to it being captured. This in no way reflects a conquering army’s practice of overwriting consecrated grounds, this was real. Palestinian children are brainwashed to believe that they are the rightful owners of all of the region and that hebrews have no history in the land. They believe that once a people lose land to war and are chased from it, their heritage is erased, like an efficient cultural genocide, and that all historical evidence proving that the people once owned populated the land must be false, because their holy book, written thousands of years later, tells them so. This is very ironic, because if they believe it then they must also believe that they lost their history and claim to the land with every new empire that controlled the land. They also lost their history and claim to the land when a country called Israel was rebuilt right in the middle of the region, and they declared war on them, losing it decisively. By their own reasoning and intent, they should become a diaspora. Perhaps someday they might have an opportunity to return to the land of their ancestors and then they can have the validity of their claim and the validity of their heritage questioned by people like you. Now, back to the question, name any famous Palestinian, a person claiming to have been born in a country called Palestine, prior to 1948, when the concept was invented. There are none because there never was a Palestine. That’s not to say that the forebears of people calling themselves Palestinians, did not live in villages and kingdoms in the region, but to say that Palestine is and was a region, not a country. It had no flag, no currency, no leader, and no army. It was a collection of Arab communities that waged war on each other and were dominated by empires of superior power for most of its existence. It was interspersed with Christian and Jewish communities, and there was no Pangea of Arabdom. In 1948, the British mandate ended in the region of Palestine and the empire controlling it with support from the League of Nations and the UN, established two states, one for Israel, one for the Arabs. Israel accepted their state and started building. The Arabs refused theirs and started a war with Israel, on the first day. They were soundly defeated and the land meant for them was occupied by Jordan and Egypt until 1967, when Israel won it. There has never been a country called Palestine, but there has been a mass delusion by a conquered people that they have a placeholder country called Palestine that owns all the land of the region, and until they get it all they’ll live like warring nomads, investing all of their resources in war, and none in desalination plants.

[@YehudaLion]

What a stupid question. Most Jews have roots in the Levant. If you're a Jew, you should know it.

[@baileyfrazier2635]

How about all the so-called Palistinians like Arafat who was born in Egypt.Most Palestinians are Southern peninsula of Saudi Arabia and Egypt and Syria.

[@nizar5191]

I m muslim and I find that question little provocative. Peace from Tunisia

[@zetto814]

That's the style of the Ask Project and he's also procacarive with the Palestinians. The problem is that they used that link to the land to expell 80% of the non Jewish indegenous population. By the way, Tunisian Jews are north African indigenous population (Amazigh) converted to Judaism. I like peace too, but without the zionists recognizing the moral responsabilty in the injustice they performed against the non-Jewish indegenous population of Palestine, no sustainable peace can ever be considered. No justice, no peace

[@nizar5191]

@@zetto814 Cannot disagree

[@zetto814]

Then why do you find the question provocative? It is nothing compared to what Israeli need to be hearing. My favorite answer was "they have to be below us!" Funny from a citizen of a state that built its legitimacy against racism etc. One other interesting answer was "my husband works with Arabs..." Usually when you ask those people if those Arabs deserve equal rights they usually say no because it threatens the Jewish character of the state of Israel. Surprisingly, the girls from the kibbutz admit they don't know everything and are not as confident as any other Israeli seems to be.

[@y.l7455]

​@@zetto814 There were aroud 1,200,000 Arabs in Israel in 1948. 750,000 of them became refuges. 750,000 of 1,200,000 is 62.5%. And according to the Arab scholars themselves: 68% of these 750,000 refuges left their homes without seeing any Jewish/Israeli soldier. 68% of 750,000 is 510,000. 750,000 - 510,000 = = 240,000 That means that in 1948 from 1,200,000 Arabs in Israel: 450,000 stayed in Israel, became citizens of Israel and got equel rights. 510,000 left their homes because of the Arab's propaganda withkut seeing any Jew. And only 240,000 actually lost their homes due to Jewish/Israeli force.

[@zetto814]

@@y.l7455 yeah, it was summer they went for vacation. If zionist didn't want them out, why did they strictly forbid their return? What did they erase any traces of their existance miticulously planting some imported fast growing tree on top of their emptied and destroyed villages? Let me remind you that Zionism is about creating a majority Jewish state on a non-Jewish majority inhabited land. Making non-Jews disappear from that land of that project is inevitable. Blaming the victims for the way they tried desperately to prevent the desaster they were going through is silly. The only reaction Palestinians should have had to please zionists is to pack their stuff and live with no fuss after cleaning their house and hand over the keys to the new résidants freshly arrived from Poland or Romania but that have all rights because they are Jews and not any other faith. By the way, serious zionist historians don't deny anymore the ethnic cleansing of Palestine from its indegenous non Jewish population but rather justify it saying it was necessary, all countries did similar actions, Jews had nowhere to go... Entry level propagandist still deny it.

[@shanihodia297]

And stealing from the people of origin is fine us jews . You stole a shirt from me by force and I took it, does that mean I stole from you? No!!!!!

[@eh2542]

On this it is said, the thief, from the thief, is exempt 😂

[@brekedekdang39]

Thank you so much for these videos. This is great work you are doing.

[@HIHaiki]

George constanza : Its not a lie ,if you believe it

[@ZeekoRamen]

Jews originated from the middle east and were there a long time before any Palestinians were there and that's a damn fact.

[@נקניק-ה4ד]

No palestinian was ever there its made up don't even aknowladge their nonsense

[@MalingAsliSukolilo]

That s the problem when you persist with your ethno-religious principles rather than living together as citizens who differs, but collectively unite towards building a country. 😂😂😂 Because, you feel special, different from others, you degrade others who are different.

[@psychocadet]

Thats not how.it went down. Jews were always mistreated in Muslim lands. I say this as a jew whose familly lived in Iraq for centuries. The desire for Israel was a desire to have a small slice of safe haven.

[@SaraLevins]

These comments are so uneducated. It’s clear people haven’t researched Jews connection to Israel. First, jews didn’t just come to israel after thousands of years and established themselves there. There has ALWAYS been jewish presence in that land. And Israel has always been a land where jews have lived, it’s the ancestral homeland of the jews. It doesn’t matter if it’s 3000 years old. Jews didn’t “all of a sudden” want to return to Israel. The desire has always been there.

[@cristiandicaprio1730]

It was the ancestral land of jews, not the jewish. Not of converted Khazaars descents and hybridized jews of Diaspora with blonde hair and slavic-germanic surname. They are just jewish. They may monopolize their identity as jews by religion excluding the obvious genetics, but the European blood and relatives (which should not be ignored and buried) in Ashkenazi (ethnicity of who descend from the Germanic region of the Rhine river, and at the same time feel like sons of Zion) are visible and they are certainly not indigenous to the Middle East to claim that region.

[@doriansultan560]

​@@cristiandicaprio1730Khazars were Central Asian Turks not Europeans, what drugs you on LOL

[@cristiandicaprio1730]

@@doriansultan560 where would i have written that khazarians were european? Between ''Khazaars descents'' and ''hybridized jews of Diaspora'' there's ''and''. Anyway: according to Wikipedia and other important sources, khazarians are described as turkic language but aestetichally anything but turkic: they had pale skin and were diffused blue eyes and ginger hair.

[@s55417]

Yes but to achieve your desires you have massacred the indigenous population. Just do a dna test

[@andym9571]

But most Israelis are not decendents of those Jews. We know that from dna. Besides...who lived there for hundreds of thousands of years before those Jews. The World is more than 6000 years old you know.

[@k_sstar5645]

They all started from the "3000 years ago story"!! Like It was an empty land at that time!!! So they were the first creation of god.!!!! No other races no one except them.

[@Iefan-oc]

Fr 😂😂😂

[@johnstergioulis8366]

Empty Land in Palestine 🇵🇸.. Theodor Herzle 🇩🇪 vibes in Israel 🇮🇱. YIKES 😳 my condolences to Palestine 🇵🇸

[@saiftariq3163]

This is a powerful thing that the lady said in 12:15... "When things are good, you don't look into it too much." Most Israelis are second or third-generation, they are born in a thriving country, and they don't need to look or "care" about the history of people who lived there. On the Palestinian side, unfortunately, things are not so good, so you can say they care much more about this conflict. They are reminded every day they pass through an Israeli checkpoint of a life and history of pain, loss, and despair. Once Israelis understand the other side, there can be a slight hope for understanding and empathy.

[@dganit8807]

My mom is a Jewish Israeli who was born in Palestine in 1940. All my grandparents came to Palestine from Eastern Europe, because of antisemitism, and that had saved their lives. Other family members were murdered by the Nazis and their collaborators.

[@me-cq7wv]

We should always remember never to forget.

[@shanihodia297]

TRUE