10 Minutes vs. 10 Years of Animation

[@AntiCookieMonster]

To anyone interested, programs used are: Maya (most likely) by Lana, Blender 3D for the rest

[@peachiceteaforeva]

omg ty

[@Pixelman0]

Not most likely, most definitely

[@fellthekiller]

it is maya

[@ReadyMack-g]

As an animator, this is BULL SHIT

[@AntiCookieMonster]

@@ReadyMack-g I'm glad KZbin didn't censor you, but I don't understand what you have issue with.

[@dat_Rasta]

lmaooooo something about 10 min guy having the most creative ideas paired with his severe inexperience is making for the funniest shit I've seen all day

[@pepitocovid-91]

Relatable tbh 😭

[@dat_Rasta]

@@pepitocovid-91 no deadass, his was basically my first experiences in blender. “That doesn’t work, don’t know why lmao”

[@AngelShrimpChips]

@@dat_Rasta common atrioc W

[@appsenence9244]

haha "all day" that wasn't a very high requirement...

[@dat_Rasta]

@ you underestimate my meme wormhole

[@Qw4ntum]

I thought he was going to animate something in 10 minutes and then in 10 years💀

[@pabiedaisy8164]

Moment of silence for all us who thought the same 💀

[@haengihorsetheonewhocancoo8855]

Haha

[@sheMessages]

I watched this video because that title had no sense 😂😂😂

[@Milllollol]

same

[@Asirah_Veroskov]

FR

[@captain4318]

I love how the guy that doesn't know Blender is having the most fun, completely entertained by the nonsense he's pulling 😂

[@ninibupu]

his work was subpar though.. i felt sorry for him.

[@allan9010]

@@ninibupu Doesn't matter. He had fun, he learned something new. The only thing you did, was waste 20 minutes of your time and give unconstructive criticism.

[@naiknaik8812]

this guy felt sorry for a guy whos having fun???

[@doppled]

@@ninibupu ???

[@samueljacobson470]

@@ninibupu damn you must be an unhappy person

[@drakomatic]

I feel like this series should really just be "two industry 'professionals' bully atrioc"

[@Sandy-zu8jp]

wdym they getting humbled by atrioc

[@signaturewithcreativity]

the cybergun

[@quitequeerquesadilla]

I’d agree with you, but the dude’s having so much fun every step of the way that it’s honestly kinda hard to feel bad for him lol. He’s having the time of his life

[@jinz4246]

calling them professionals is literal but a little to much,

[@someonecd9764]

​@@jinz4246one of them is definitely a professional

[@accelerator8929]

Stephen: "Maybe he just hung out" Atrioc: "WARPED HIS MIND AND BODY AND SOUL"

[@misaki5662]

I do love her tip: let the first and last impression tell a story. This sounds like a game changer. I do think of using this in writing. Thank you

[@nk794]

it applies in writing for every single page…. obviously you want every page to tell (add) onto the story??😭 is that not just common sense

[@deotaerd3572]

​@@nk794it's so obvious that it's kinda good to think about it more

[@cit1zz3n.ex3]

Yeah, that's also what stood out to me. Very lovely advice.

[@miakkaatt]

I LOVE how Lana gave Liam so much personality, even though she only had to make him jump from one place to another. The poses are so smart, and I could definitely infer some things about him. UGH she’s so talented!!!

[@huangpyc]

this video series needs to never stop.

[@Atomz09]

Needs to continue*

[@superethanbean]

@@Atomz09 🤓

[@slavsit7600]

@@Atomz09 zaza

[@KyuDoesCode]

@@Atomz09 nah needs to never stop

[@GuyWithDementia-123]

*shouldn't stop

[@miunya]

That lady is so talented The way she sees how his head needs to be and the tweaks seem so seamless. I wish I was her.

[@616Metalhead616]

Start now, practice 10 years and you can do things maybe like her.

[@JeffreyThrash]

@@616Metalhead616 Exactly!

[@Lendariogamedev]

todos sao talentosos o caso e que algun estao a brincar

[@Ahsangill19]

Yeah I agree her skills really impressed me

[@divzk64]

Bro you think 10 years of animation is “talent”?

[@Eshan686]

shes so good man. I LOVEEE seeing industry professionals flex their skills outside of their job

[@sleepCircle]

what's interesting to me is that atrioc and lana both have the same freeform approach, and the guy in the middle is doing stuff very carefully and sort of 'procedurally'. it sort of shows the learning process, you know?

[@smithy2729]

great insight

[@arnold-pdev]

it's like that bell curve meme, lol

[@JohnnyNatrium]

It just showed to me that the 'game designer' guy lacked creativity, humility, a sense of humour and most importantly a sense of freedom. He was more focused on himself through his manner of expression and evaluation, than on what he was creating. Kind of like most post-2006 game devs I've known. The industry's degradation has contributed to that though.

[@sleepCircle]

@@JohnnyNatrium well i can't say i noticed THAT

[@PatrickHoodDaniel]

I think we saw the complete 4 levels of mastery here. I love the freedom that the 10 year and the 10 minute artist has. The ten week artist seems too constrained, but has a really solid jump.

[@MrJayVFX]

i think the matter with the ten week artist is that he's in a mindset of improving, rather than expressing, so he's paying a lot of attention to real-life mechanics rather than interesting animation. he's not quite able to express himself, but he's applying knowledge.

[@LincolnDWard]

Exactly! This is a perfect demonstration.

[@samy7342]

Yes. That one is the most frustrating phases of learning animation and I think the longest one lol

[@aminkia5527]

@@MrJayVFX Actually it was ten days not weeks and they were 3 people so 3 levels of mastery

[@JohnnyNatrium]

@@MrJayVFX You should be applying creativity and expression throughout any stage. I can tell from the way this guy was commentating on his process that he would be like this no matter how experienced he was. It's also something that modern game devs are almost universally suffering from, since the industry has shifted to a complete lack of individuality and originality in game design.

[@arendvandermerwe3309]

I love how she was kind of nervous, but after seeing the other animations her confidence sky rockets

[@Bedite-yr3yo]

two people are animating, one guy is just bored.

[@callularashieka2248]

accurate!

[@gianniarruda]

Quem está entediado? O cara de 10 minutos? kkkkk

[@Zinzinnovich]

who is bored? lol

[@mrman55555]

@@Zinzinnovichthe guy who made the guy walk on a wall twice and unrealistic stuff

[@ayycarrot]

@@mrman55555 what do you mean his was the most realistic

[@openframeofmind]

I like how she’s casually doing extra shit and it’s so effortless 😂

[@isto_inc]

Can someone PLEASE tell Pixar to stop asking me for Atrioc's contact info? Take a hint. Sheesh.

[@KyuDoesCode]

Haha, funny.

[@PMC_Raven]

cybergun

[@guythatlikesbeans]

why does pixar want his contact info? just tell him ITS PIXAR what would they want???

[@bkb087]

You should do a cod themed mission animation

[@jovisthompson2390]

​@@guythatlikesbeansr/whoosh

[@micahsonne3761]

A little something I think they should have mentioned; the 2 guys were using the "world" control for the motion and jumping for their characters, and Lana left hers in place. Animating with that control is honestly one of the most difficult things. Major props for the attempt dudes.

[@niktheyllon1813]

Thank you!!!

[@horseconfused]

I love how much personality Lana gave little liam here

[@signaturewithcreativity]

atrioc is smashing it when i first did 3d animation i was placing cubes everywhere and i had no idea what to do

[@godzilla90fan]

There's 0 chance this is just from 10 minutes practice, hes obviously practiced at least hours.

[@AppNasty]

Im a student at university for 1 year now for Computer Animation. Been enjoying these colabs! My teenage son has been animating in Blender much longer than i have been using Maya and i thought about me and him going at it. Self taught teen using Blender vs 1 year animation student using Maya. Would be fun. Cant wait to see what you guys come up with next.

[@File.Namee2]

maya focuses like much in animations While blender is like both in modeling and animating Modeling in maya is pain

[@AppNasty]

@@File.Namee2 Maybe it's because I was taught but modeling in Maya for me is hella easy. Literally just WRE keys. Right click is a menu, shift right click is a menu. Done. I try to model in Blender and everything is so far apart to access it makes it confusing. Obviously if I spend more time using blender it will be ome easy. My son when he models he is hopping through all the shortcuts just as fast as I am in Maya. So it comes down to if you spend the time. Sculpting and modeling in Maya is pretty much the exact same as Blender. Capability wise I mean. But we use ZBrush to focus on sculpting. I prefer Nomad Sculpt on my iPad personally.

[@BrandonRultidge]

@@File.Namee2I feel that many criticize Maya’s features without giving them a fair chance. It's like dismissing the benefits of going to the gym because it's initially challenging.

[@BrandonRultidge]

@@AppNastyif you've started in Maya stick to it buddy. The truth is a lot of small sutios use blender because its free, so they profit more. Big studios use Autodesk. Regardless which software is “better”.

[@BrandonRultidge]

One last thing, there is a lot and I mean a lot of misinformation online on how to model, texture ext… surrounding blender. Alot of people use blender for a few months think they are an expert and make tutorials that encourage bad practice.

[@Ezeleoxd]

4:56 "So im just gonna shift him forward. UAHGHGG"

[@orinblank2056]

I gotta say though, the idea from Atrioc is amazing. Like it absolutely looks scuffed, but you gotta respect the creativity. If he could animate as smoothly as Lana then it would have looked so cool

[@Jack_______]

damn the 10 minutes guy have done a lot of fun things,he's such a crack and now I want to do a walljump animation hahahaha,thanks him for gaving me the idea

[@MA5HAP]

The ten minutes one is how my spine feels.

[@moonbases]

Been trying to learn blender so my algorithm is filled with 3d videos and I definitely didn't expect Glizzy Hands himself to pop up in a video about animation lmao

[@Solanaar]

This is a great concept! It shows the difference in skill which is something so useful to see. You often don't understand WHY something works so well until you see it side by side with something made by less experienced people. I really appreciate you putting yourself out there and show how a lack of skill is no reason to not try stuff your unfamiliar with. It's a great mindset for developing your expertise. As a side note: What a great approach to engaging with your community by creating content not focused on your games. I really feel you bring something unique that many other devs don't and I wish you that it reflects in your growth! PS: That final composition looks amazing and I love how you've shown both your inexperience and your astounding skills! That sound design was - ugh! - so _crispy_

[@الرياني-د8ك]

Lana is amazing, i watched her video of animating a character at blizzard i think, it was really helpful.

[@isto_inc]

She’s so incredibly talented!!

[@StuffByDrew]

I started learning animation recently and this was really cathartic! Been enjoying the series a lot but excited for what you do next

[@Taibete]

Two people are trynna make it as ealistic as possible one guy is trynna animate spider man

[@Test.Unknown]

Isto: animation complete, good job me Professional: I’m Nothing I’m trash Atrioc: BAAAAAHAHAHAHAH

[@Manny-nh4hi]

Love how the cyber gun continues to be mentioned in these videos 😂

[@vyntage5326]

this series is the only reason ive watched this channel, please keep going.

[@mediocrephil]

im obsessed with this series

[@gotnoja2000]

same

[@alfredoaraujo8077]

11:50 HELP I CAN’T💀🤣

[@PharaHerine]

I'M CRYING LMAO

[@ClassicDaine]

Just so you guys know, this concept is pure gold. I was shocked to see there's only 3 of these, but I would happily watch these videos where it's just different projects and you guys are competing on to do the best with your own levels of experience. I would even suggest doing videos using Adobe After Effects, Photoshop, Illustrator. As someone actively learning about these softwares it was a really nice break to watch these types of videos because I got to learn how the experts did it differently but still relate with the newbie. If you keep this series going I guarantee you'll hit a million subscribers.

[@EpicScamp]

I love these videos; it's so humbling to see how everyone has a good time knowing what they can and can not do.

[@Amelia_PC]

It's amazing how each of the three showcases exactly what they’re great at. The streamer makes me laugh and knows how to entertain in a lighthearted way (streamer = showman). The game dev gets technical, treating the whole animation like a ragdoll and approaching it as kinesiology, while the animator gives the character personality through its movement, even creating a visual narrative. Despite only one being an animator, they all highlight their best skills. It's fascinating, and I loved it!

[@VirusTechKEKW]

Props to the 10 minute guy going in hard

[@chaosmspa8023]

I had so much fun watching this, I hope you guys continue with this in the future!

[@StephHami]

4:58 you know you did something bad when you control z something that fast

[@ALBINO1D]

[@John_Krone]

Lana, I wish I could download your animation knowledge/experience into my head. Nicely done

[@kiddfresh3673]

this was my exact thought 😂

[@imacrazyperson]

Hey! I had a few classes in uni with Lana. Not surprised she's kicking ass as an animator.

[@fogpivvl8341]

Really goes to show that Atrioc must have been great at his job in marketing if I was by far the most excited to see his presentation

[@mrgoldboy]

that transition at 13:00 was kinda smooth

[@ALBINO1D]

Nice eye.

[@samy7342]

underrated

[@AntiSociety100]

The third one clearly is a pro animator lol. The movements and speed fluctuation are perfect.

[@GordWayne]

She didn't get assistant director for nothing haha

[@justyouraverage2dsimps278]

No shit, its her literal job

[@loseControlGD]

"So I'm just gonna actually shift him forward- *gasp* " That was the funniest thing I've ever heard

[@borisadepauldayo948]

15:11 - The guy wearing a cap just murdered the character 😂 I can't 🤣 At some point during his animation, I actually started feeling sorry for the avatar 😂

[@Zndery]

9:35 "what if I put the cybergun in the background" had me on the floor 🤣

[@luizcosta8122]

Seeing the finished 10 year animation gave me chills. Just goes to show if you keep doing something for long enough getting better is just a happy consequence.

[@Speedy_Edits1]

3:45 BRO DID THE GRIDDY

[@jlleell]

I laughed, SO MUCH at this video. This was not only fantastic animation by all three, but the editing of the video was really good too.

[@Peekoh]

I did not expect to see former BlizzLana here. Loved her work on Heroes of the Storm.

[@Noskyz]

14:36 for ppl who wanna skip everything and just see there animations when the first guy go's 15:11 next guy 16:23 Final animation 17:36.

[@GordWayne]

Oof wish I'd seen this before

[@TheRazeryan]

nice little foley at the end there ^_^ cool video, pretty sure it came from youtube recommended. Keep up the good work.

[@atkay4611]

15:16 Thats a very nice idea with the parcour, i like it 👍 And it gives me joy, if somebody is having fun in trying something new and doodleling around, that's the spirit 😄 16:21 Wow, such a huge improvement in just 2 days, amazing 😲 you definitely have talent and are very smart, keep it up 👍 17:30 Awesome. Just awesome 🔥🔥🔥 But to be honest, I have expected this level of quality from a professional Animation-Veteran, who worked at Blizzard and Riot Games for that long 😏 But the best part for me is, that she's giving advise to others 😊

[@6henny443]

i give the handstand flip wall run a 10

[@NintendoKnightThefirst]

Lana has you are my hero, thanks for working on the StarCraft 2 animations

[@MultiverseBro]

9:13 and now a word from our sponsor...

[@MAZER_YT]

This Videos are soooo Good and funny!! I like it a lot :DD

[@-N0PE-]

😳☝️ And then his neck pops out 🗣️

[@chonkysquirrel5940]

All three demonstrated admirable traits, each in their own right, indicative of why they've seen success in their respective fields. Atrioc: Ability to maintain a humble and cheery attitude towards a hopeless task; not many have the character to direct and sustain the mood and attitude to be fun and entertaining like he has. Stephen: Wrestling with unbridled potential of what could be done yet not having the skill to realise it. Courage to invest time to learn and practice an unfamiliar craft yet still risk failure and poor results. Lana: Matured, seasoned skill. Being able to articulate the reasons behind why she does what she does indicates the years of dedication that've went into learning and honing the artistry of her craft.

[@v8wr253]

I was crying in laughter as the 10 day guy was talking about how the 10 minutes guy had done a super simple animation was hanging out and cutting to said animator XDDD

[@bloomingcherryblossms]

I think it’s interesting how this shows the different perspectives/progressions learning how to do animation in general! The 10 minute guy is just having fun. He’s not worried about the technically of it all, he’s just having fun. The 10 day guy is following the basic rules and making it look more realistic (for lack of a better explanation) simply getting from point A to point B. Finally, the 10 year chick makes it follow some of those rules (A to B) while also having fun with it and making it stylized.

[@SoirEkim]

It’s been a real pleasure (skipping to the end) seeing the results. Very entertaining.

[@MemphisOFICIAL777]

0:35 Me(in blender): ah, sh1t, here we go again **riggs epically**

[@skurtyyskirts]

I need to follow more animator/developers on twitch. I love watching this stuff.

[@barbaramalta3998]

1:10 that kick got me dying 😂

[@Beanwing]

I love this stuff bro don’t stop

[@hanzwurst3805]

Did not expect that collab but love it

[@cobbIestonegenerator]

3:44 Griddy moment

[@meyi_ms9342]

11:50 i laughed so hard but still admired

[@NekoSamaIru]

14:39 Playblast! How did I forget that concept! It was the second most helpful thing I had learnt back in animation class (first being the 12 principles). Thank you for reminding me of it. I hope Blender has that option too, since I had to switch to it from Maya and Max.

[@anthonyhauenstein2006]

" I used to work at blizzard..." I'm sorry you had to go through that hell

[@AndrewRuggiero]

This was such great fun to watch, great choice of people to have!

[@wolfelkan8183]

17:26 her participation in this video in a nutshell

[@tigramurhanroblox7515]

Guy who animated 10 mins is just me when i try to build something good

[@Flimzwella]

"SO I'm just going to shift him foward" .... "EUGHHHHHHH"

[@CloudColumncat]

Very awesome wit, I really love that flex pose in the mid of air lol

[@iamwaynecodd]

Loved this series so far, looking forward to the new game!

[@tapiyari]

Please keep doing more videos espcially with Atrioc!!

[@gorsViE3d]

I absolutely love these videos so much! I've been using Blender for nearly 9 years now and watching newcomers do these things is actually pretty cool, and Atrioc's parts are funny but make me want to pull my hair out. Regardless, I love these videos!

[@MubaarikMonday]

i found atypo mistake at 14:38 TEH REVEAL instead of THE REVEAL :)

[@isto_inc]

OH WOW i completely missed that. Good catch

[@MubaarikMonday]

😃

[@ctownthrasher]

@14:38 is the "teh reveal" for Atrioc?

[@Francizy]

I'm more impressed by the other guy who has been animating for just 10 days. Dude is great!

[@DeletedDevilDeletedAngel]

Wow I would love to see more of these! I love seeing different animation ideas

[@Im_Liam_HEHE]

As someone named Liam, I can agree we do wallrun and handstands!

[@BobThef]

The final one is literally neon 360 into el primo dive with chamber teleport animation at the end. If u know u know.

[@NakeyNayNay]

Atrioc: Having fun until he breaks it Stephen: Trying to make it look realistic Lana: Giving the character personality I loved it💜💜

[@ShenobiTF]

Damn, no wonder why Spirit Blossom Ahri's animations are so smooth!

[@simenkolas9373]

I think it is beautiful that atrioc is laughing so much even though it might not be his best work :) He is having fun! And that is so great to see! It does not have to be the best animation for him to have fun!

[@jtbonilla7745]

7:43 "you have good taste, my friend"

[@bandinopla]

0:12 she STARTED at blizzard?????????

[@yoorface4680]

If that was 10 years ago, yeah why not? Its not like Blizzard was big company all of the time.

[@bandinopla]

@@yoorface4680 but I find it hard to believe that her FIRST job was at Blizard and that Blizzard sayd okI will start my team with people with no experience at all... sounds like bullshit.

[@yoorface4680]

​@@bandinopla Its normal for me. Some companies hires a newbies for specific purpose like learning they own programs/engines especially in game industry also they are cheaper than mid/senior and still can do the same light work. In some cases people even work for free for some experience or to make own CV. Its win-win situation, not to mention that 10 years ago when technology was not that advanced, animators and programmers even with no experience was nice to have. Look at World of warcraft, 2014 animations look really bad. Really. but that crap was made with new technologies and its was at that time "WOW ITS LOOK REAL!"

[@MiguelAngel--]

10 min animator put his soul in this project hahaslkdjfah I loved that guy

[@EchoRoss]

the editing on this video was subtly amazinggg

[@LeeDaNoodle]

if I don't see me jump correctly I shall send a strongly worded letter to blender to remove the file - me aka person called liam

[@Zii_Vii]

I love the stuff like the first guy cause it's just a dude having fun learning something new. Obviously the pro fuckin nailed it, but I love the free spirited 'fuck it' we go big with the first guy haha. Good stuff all around

[@Erbazak47]

Lana animation was so smooth and beautiful AMAZING experience does matter a lot!

[@YagamoReba]

thanks for the fantastic insights, really opened my eyes!

[@JBUHJBUH]

I just got suggested this video by the KZbin algorithm (literally from a NERD song) so I have no idea who any of these people are lol but this was awesome! Entertaining enough to have a *first-time* viewer sit through a 20 minute video?! That's a gift - a shame to squander it by not continuing the series! But at least I can go watch the others for the first time now 😊