IT'S A STUPID ARGUMENT! 😡 Simon Jordan & Agent Sky Andrew CLASH Over FIFA's Limitations on Agents

[@mewe1771]

If this guy is a top agent, how bad must the others be...

[@jtmmmm27]

Their biggest role is to massage the players egos.

[@nicholascannon5001]

Spot on

[@beejj6190]

The point is if the agents are regulated / paid by the footballers their cut will be less. That's the real issue, lol.

[@alexlanemusic]

Glad Simon cut through the nonsense. I’m sure Simon learned something, and more importantly, so did we.

[@G_Hump3z]

Anyone else read this in Simon’s voice?

[@Harry-mj6tq]

Can't tell you how much this comment made me smile - constantly have that intro going around in my head

[@VR46314]

Nosunsche

[@xjkdx]

agents don't have a monopoly on the market, nor should they. There should be limits because it affects the entire game not just the players and agents. Capitalism at its best.

[@Motownisyourtown]

​@@VR46314Nosunshe

[@mojy77mm]

Well done Simon. Utter nonsense from the agent

[@beejj6190]

?? So the Scots guy asks a specific question. Sky gives his opinion. Jordan ignores the question (and answer) and a says Sky is being irrelevant (and goes of on another one of his idotic coke -fuelled rants). Perhaps you should listen and stop being a Jordan -sheep.

[@matthewwells1817]

I feel sorry for simon sometimes, trying to talk to these people.

[@steaustin8789]

Clone

[@AOK342]

@@MW92.Eddie Hearn put Simon in his place. You would be hard pressed to find someone who think as highly of themselves as Simon.

[@stephengreen6683]

For once I felt sorry for Simon. That was the most embarrassing discussion- we never even got to a single point from the other two that made any sense at all. Jim / Agent - forget agency fees neither should be paid for that drivel

[@garyjohnson264]

Are we sure Sky isn't the taxi driver the BBC thought was an IT expert for a live interview?

[@garytaf]

Players should pay agents not clubs

[@thrilla72]

I mean...then the players would increase their wage demands to compensate

[@Alex123491996]

@@thrilla72then the clubs tell them to get fucked, this might finally make players chose between their club and their snake agent

[@Jim90117]

You think that bill wouldn't be passed on by the player?

[@tonylawlor8833]

Simons argument has always been who pays the agents, not what they earn, it should be the players that pay their own agents, just like any other agent/client relationship, like for instance Actors. At the moment the clubs foot the bill and thus the fans.

[@pascalthe8th66]

100%. Thats the normal way for every agent relationship in sports or business in general. Why is it different in football?? Pure greed from agents bleeding clubs.

[@adtastic1533]

It's a nonsense argument. If the player has to pay his agent he will just ask for more money. The club still pays the same. At the end of the day it's not our money it's not our business. Stop trying to take money out of people's wallet.

[@MrSrimera]

It's all about greed at the end of the day, and the fans finish up paying.

[@aspursy7826]

Sky ain't got a clue. Simon just rinsed him 😂

[@sonark289]

BS thats why Jim had to step in as Simon as just talking lol

[@ConfusedAnglerfish-ik5bx]

​@@sonark289Coward 🙄

[@Rayunicorn1]

You don’t know what you’re talking about?

[@ConfusedAnglerfish-ik5bx]

@@Rayunicorn1 Clown commenter Ray is here on another comment 🤣🤡

[@Rayunicorn1]

@@ConfusedAnglerfish-ik5bx Better to be a clown than a confused fish.

[@nadeemamode]

"World class advice"? Plenty of players have made the wrong moves because the agents pushed for the wrong moves

[@pamjohn1814]

Sky clearly has his agenda

[@albertbrammer9263]

Yeah, make as much money for himself as possible.

[@ConfusedAnglerfish-ik5bx]

*Sly

[@Rayunicorn1]

Why, whose agenda would you prefer for him to have? Yours?

[@hbos9709]

​@Rayunicorn1 what? Sky is clearly angling for a job position at fifa . Seems sky asked you to deflect for him

[@ConfusedAnglerfish-ik5bx]

@@Rayunicorn1 Ray has his unicorn horn pointing firmly in Sly's direction 🙄

[@tajudeennuhu720]

Simon is spot on

[@morriscox6595]

All About The Money, The Whole Game Is Corrupted

[@LifeAtSea50]

Simon’s hatred of Football Agents is fairly obvious 😂

[@zcyf3211]

It was hilarious to listen to cause it only fuelled him to disregard any points made. You gotta link Simon with facts and common sense or you’ve lost your argument before you start it 😂

[@cygnus3632]

Football is getting beyond a joke with the amount of money going around.

[@pooriaansari1674]

nope, not football but the fans/those who are feeding it up!

[@frankford1115]

The player should pay the agent. Easy. Why is this an issue at all? Why should anyone pay the players advisor? Why do clubs deal with them?

[@lawmantheonetrueking3739]

Totally agree Frank but the way it seems to work is: Agent: Mr Club you can have this player you desperately want for x as long as you give me y. Club: Okay. Deal done. The only way to change this is for FIFA to make a law that all agents have to prove they have been paid by their client, i.e. the player. Sadly even if FIFA could make this stick we know their track record for brown envelopes.

[@charliehill2464]

Jim didn’t like the idea of a limit on what he can earn. Changed his tune quick 😂

[@sixfootsosa4466]

Thats for sure

[@kernowchris]

Jim would have buggered off to Saudi if they needed a tv host.

[@saint8471]

Lol

[@stnbch3025]

Why the f*ck should a club pay the employee of the player?

[@lfcspectre4335]

Sir Simon = Top LAD Proper Clobber 💯 Facts

[@lfcspectre4335]

@@MW92. The Jordanite Leader Himself OG MW = Top LAD Proper Clobber 💯 Facts

[@perryx7103]

lol this guy showed the level of competance the agents have. I would of expected agents to be lawyer level education or something. Its contracts and tax dealings etc. Problem is you have dimwits working with kids enticing them and then working out how they can get them payday to.

[@ianharris9081]

Couldn't listen to that had to switch it off. Simon Jordan just likes to talk over people and doesn't let them finish off there points but he'll make sure whatever point he's got to make everyone has to listen, it's getting boring now

[@lemons1986]

Simon and Sky both make good points. Ultimately matters such as these aren’t decided on a basis of “fairness.” They are negotiated ruthlessly according to positions of leverage. Sadly, most of the public has been infantilized to the point that this ruthlessness - this steadfast pursuit of self interest - is considered anathema. As a result, it is impossible to have an open & honest conversation about issues like this in a public forum, for fear of outrage and backlash. Simon and Sky are two brilliant & experienced businessmen and interlocutors more than capable of hashing out their differences on this issue in a coherent manner. However, in a public forum, the naive notion of what “should” be done crowds out the more realistic discussion regarding what SHALL be done. Remember this the next time you hear someone cry about business dealings being conducted with a lack of transparency.

[@HuntsDown]

No top agent would go on Talksport and embarrass themselves like this, surely

[@troydyall6624]

Well done SJ!

[@bornin1948]

Djokovic doesn’t play a team sport. That guest is a fool.

[@JackJackJack123]

In USA the agent is restricted to approx 3.5% of the contract that they negotiated and that’s that. No financial incentive for agents to move players. Works just fine.

[@jonhayes7322]

Djokovic is a world class player - Sancho isn’t. Nothing to do with agents.

[@TheXxaddictxX]

He has a world-class agent. But then again, it's not very hard to trick United to pay over the odds

[@jonhayes7322]

@@TheXxaddictxX of course, but his agent would deal with finances, opportunities, commercial etc, not actually performing

[@jackramsden9346]

The same thing happened with the NBA with them trying to make sure agents have a degree and relevant qualifications to stop Rich Paul from having a monopoly on the sport.

[@billybobthornton9668]

Sky's argument about so-called 'double taxation' revealed exactly what motivates him! "Oh no, we can't tax the footballer and then tax the money they spend on agent fees - that would mean I get less money!!!"😱😱😱😱 What, like almost every other transaction that takes place in society? I'm beyond dismayed at the absolute cheek of this man, especially considering what he must be earning 🤦

[@glover424]

Spot on, it's like any joe bloggs on the street when he gets paid his wages and buys something immediately after. its taxed 😂

[@1980redkremlin]

I don't know how Sky Andrews is successful as an agent but he's an awful broadcaster. I don't understand any of his points

[@billybobthornton9668]

@@1980redkremlin I mean, I suppose broadcasting is a different skillset to corporate negotiations, but it doesn't seem like he's the most articulate bloke. His comments give the impression that he views agents as a closed club which suggests success as an agent comes down to who you know, rather than how good you actually are at negotiating deals 🤷

[@1980redkremlin]

@billybobthornton9668 Yes, but he should say that shouldn't he? Obviously he doesn't want to upset any of hid industry buddies which is fair enough. But at the very least, if you're going to dance around the subject...learn to dance!

[@leedoyle7150]

Love how ruthless Simon is 😂😂😂😂

[@parz6917]

Omg… and millions going out of the game to these parasites. Players should pay their agents full stop.

[@gerardonochie3408]

Now I can see why Simon Jordan failed MISERABLY as the one time owner of Crystal Palace. I thought he was damn right rude calling Sky "as a grown up". The tax issue made a lot of sense by Sky. It looks like Simon got burnt at crystal palace. Make money so long as it is legal and follows due process. Agents and FIFA need to find a common ground.

[@thefroobchoob]

womp womp hes so rude womp womp

[@chriskinge9917]

@@thefroobchoobare you ok?

[@TheBodger7]

Sorry so if I employed a cleaner to clean my house I'd get a tax break for having a cleaner?? Nonsense, the cheek of players expecting clubs to pay their agent is just ridiculous and an utter scam

[@Isleofskye]

I am not keen on Apples and Oranges but I do love Greengages. A very underrated Fruit...

[@jonhayes7322]

SJ: “I don’t know what you’re talking about!!!!” X10?? 😂😂😂

[@JamaicanToast]

I agree with Sky, he does work in the industry at the end of the day. Everyones agreeing with Simon but then when Simon invites him back on and acknowledges Sky's argument just like he reconciled with Eubank Snr. You're all quiet

[@sonark289]

Ive noticed alot of people just agree with Simon regardless of what hes saying

[@ConfusedAnglerfish-ik5bx]

Has Simon been sleeping with your Husband again?! 🙄

[@nickchivers9029]

And some people disagree with him no matter what he says. Some people are stupid and just blindly follow or blindly hate.

[@rsamancunian5609]

Simon appears to look at things logically, and he comes across as being sensible most of the time. Sometimes, people are just agreeing with the way he lays down the argument.

[@leemoffat159]

Simon at his best here! Well done 🙌🏼

[@denisoleary1407]

This guy comes across as a right money grabbing scam artist !

[@DJeMo]

As desperate as car salesmen on the lot

[@Isleofskye]

Tru Say,Mi Bredda. Tru Say,Bredrin..

[@Explorations84]

The only representation I would need as a footballer would be my own accountant I can drag along with me to negotiations. These "agents" are self-professed and not qualified in anyway - they just have good contacts. They'll spout how important they are simply because of the amount of money they are taking out.

[@williampotato1221]

Money for old rope my friend!

[@languageoffootball]

There are lots of “money for old rope” roles like this out there. I don’t think it’s as unregulated as it used to be either in terms of entry level.

[@williampotato1221]

@@languageoffootball oh come on 🙄... Wake up and smell the coffee! It's an absolute cesspit of corruption.

[@kerrysgold1]

Same for me. I know Roy Keanes never had an agent. His family solicitor does all his dealings-even contract negotiations with Man U

[@bobsocks7575]

@@marditoon1128How did they do that?

[@djmattblack]

Anyone notice how much louder Skys voice is than everyone elses, is that deliberate?

[@NibberKSmooth]

No agents at all in football. Players should employ a solicitor to discuss contracts.

[@Bren2011feb]

Clubs and fans are ripped off, full stop, that agent speaks pathetic of the gains for agents take out of the game ripping off clubs for average players

[@nigelhaworth1353]

I wouldn’t take Sky’s advice on laying my dinner table. Scary to think how bad the others must be if he’s a “top” one.

[@fyarlynx]

They need to put limited on how much a club can earn off the players ffs 😂😂😂 put limits EVERYWHERE 🤣🤣🤣

[@thrilla72]

Yeah great point that gets overlooked

[@richarddawson8479]

HMRC should look into this tax fiddle

[@Stringer_Bell89]

Perform and get picked

[@maher136]

Skye’s a muppet - any club or player dealing with him need to re think - it’s simple - agents should have a tier fee system based on the league. Agents should be able to have crossed opportunities meaning they can’t represent club and player - you register for either or. Players should be responsible for the agents fees not the club

[@ajjo-ni8mw]

Agents deserve every penny they get, bang average premier league players getting hundreds of thousands of pounds a week because of great work by the agent

[@SDCLFC1]

Wow. What a waste of a discussion. This was such a poor discussion. However terrible Sky might have been Jim, and his producer, did a terrible job setting up this segment. Simon didn't help. He just threw his toys rather than trying to find something constructive.

[@skusami2548]

It's pretty fitting that a guy called Sky should have his head so far up in the clouds. well done Simon for calling him out on his self-serving nonsense

[@iamfordy3457]

This conversation was absolutely pointless

[@matthewbarber13]

Simon is right 9 times out of ten but in this case because he wouldn’t let Sky actually get his point across he became rude, childish and petulant, how many times has he tried to make a point for someone to interject and him furiously say let me finish what I was saying! He bangs on about how players earn to much and agents are parasites etc but here’s Sky who if was allowed to finish his point was basically agreeing that the way agents make money needs to change. Yet Simon couldn’t be bothered to be civil for 1 minute to listen. If Sky had told Simon that Christmas is on 25th December Simon would have agued that it’s not and Sky doesn’t know what he’s talking about. There are a lot of unscrupulous agents who act only for themselves and cause division (which is a point a wholeheartedly agree with Simon on) but Sky is not one of them, for him to be treated with such disdain by Simon is completely out of order.

[@albertbrammer9263]

Simon does not like agents. He would like them to be gone.

[@atikurrahman9304]

Agents are the bane of football.

[@yarp123123123123123]

bad owners are by far the bane of football, like simon here who got crystal palace bankrupt.

[@Inst19ct]

"Tell'im Jim" ... 😂😂😂😂😂

[@fiddler8395]

Simon from the Piers Morgan school of interviewing. Just put him in a paper bag and let him fight with himself. Why bother inviting a guest on.

[@stevenjohnson7442]

Simon, really can be blasted rude at times! And it's so unnecessary.

[@tanman966]

I’d say the sky’s the limit for this bloke I’ll get my coat

[@peternielsen8723]

Ofc. it has to do with taxation. If the club pay 110 mio to the player and the player pay 10 mio to their agent, it's taxated more than if the club pay 100 to the player and 10 to the agent because the 10 mio to the agent only gets taxated once when it's directly from the club. It's all about tax evation. The club doesn't realy care for them it's 110 mio out either way.

[@nitronori5816]

Simple accounting means we pay a service provider (ie. Agents) a fee irrespective of taxes hence if you represent the player they are responsible or club if they hire the agent. Agents are nothing more that spin doctors and should not be allowed to give legal/financial advice without being accredited. For example, I cannot be a financial broker and give financial advice without passing my fiduciary assessments which makes Sky's argument invalid on "expert" advice then.

[@stnbch3025]

Whoever employs him should pay his fee disconnected from whatever transfer fee the club agrees.

[@Thurmoman]

Top agent😂 Christ!! Can you imagine the chancers in that industry 😅

[@machinefannatic99]

they are basically arguing about capitalism, and explaining its flaws.

[@alanclark4569]

This discussion needs to start from the identification of what is/are the problem(s) that need to be solved. My suggestion is that the problem is the capacity of agents to manipulate the clubs and players to their financial gain, has gone out of control, This lack of regulation is taking huge amounts of money from the game, dictating to a large extent which players go where, creating hyperinflation of transfer fees and player salaries, diminishing player loyalty, taking away the obligation to perform, and destroying some clubs. Of course the clubs themselves need to question their modus operandi. But right now they are at the mercy of agents and the power that they have, and the obsession/financial neccessity to succeed.

[@abiodunbuddy]

Omg!!! Let your guests speak and stop interrupting!!

[@The4BsPodcast]

Why is jim so angry agents make a lot of money, if he's so jealous he should change careers and become one

[@villainofthepiste8275]

Fancy having an agent on then not listening to his point of view and cutting in every 5 minutes because you love the sound of your own voice- Simon Simone wasn't interested in asking him questions or having any logical counter-arguments, just interested in speaking his usual Codswollop

[@LFC4LIFEJEDI]

I got out of that is Sky is jealous that none of the top players want him as their agent.. As for Jim, my God he has never been ore annoying, he was so out his depth

[@si_w8201]

He's always annoying and always out of his depth, today was not an exception...

[@si_w8201]

@@rebelwill412 agreed, don't even get me started on the current format on SSN...

[@BigAlCapwn]

Restraint of trade clauses do exist though and can be perfectly legal (dependant on how they are shaped and what their purpose is, including the clause being necessary for the good of the industry)

[@prvvideoonline7993]

I worked in the game a few years back , as a club CEO - agents are parasites. full stop.

[@whodoyouratemore]

Simons attack dog style gets s bit boring

[@jackswaby8532]

Am I sitting in the right seat? I'm not sure

[@stargazer6154]

Sky made a comment "Thats not nice". If thats the future of debate when tough people in a tough industry debate facts, then I fear for the future of how buisness is done. A lot of bumps in this area need to be sorted and soon. If agents are not able to provide the best advice, then who is and what are they earning vast amounts of money for. Should it fall back onto the club to monitor and advise?

[@Ben_Gunner]

All I hear is that agents are the important ones. It's like writers and actors...

[@crimsonknightuk]

“Gormless sods” 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@Thomas-ki7sz]

Can't stand agent's aspecialy that mug ! With Simon all the way .

[@jamesasc7709]

are all agents sole traders? why dont we see large entities in this space? Sotheby's et al

[@willhanlan8077]

money grabbing agent sky andrew knows nothing about football. use to be a table tennis player 😂

[@bwalya773]

Simon is a sad story

[@richyrose99]

call them out

[@headsroll]

Sky Andrews was not making any sense

[@GaryJames-n3w]

Agents should not be in football full stop

[@yarivlavi1]

This agent is a terrible communicator

[@JP-nb7tm]

Why would you even ask an agents opinion?

[@campfirefootball]

Can someone tell Jim White that if he wants to come to a solution on a debate, interrupting others to repeat the same sentence over and over again is probably not the best route?

[@soapboxparishrecordings5287]

Introduce a fixed 5% of the transfer fee for agents. Paid split between both clubs and the player. That’s more than enough 3:51

[@LeftWinger9]

The game would be better without agents.

[@bornin1948]

What does “people not sitting in the right seats” mean ????

[@adriangill5504]

The argument is just going round and round At the end of the day it’s not in the agents interest in a player staying at a club for the length of their contract Agents make money on a percentage of a transfer Agents should not get a percentage but be paid by the player over the length of their contract The player should agree to pay their agent a percentage from their weekly/monthly pay packet

[@iaincolquhoun-bg2nk]

The problem is agents. Sky being a prime example. Clueless. All about the $$.

[@russty2996]

This is a agent and he can’t even get his opinion over he just talks rubbish and he just sat there and agreed with Jim he was baffled by Simon’s simple question

[@TheJayMarsh]

I'm currently 9 minutes into the video, and Sky has yet to make a single point. How has he talked for 9 minutes and said absolutely nothing? Could've had a brick wall in that seat for all the sense you'd get out of it.

[@InPursuit-ToddMay]

Plenty of good agents, even more dirty ones

[@rob-24971]

Simon, let him speak for gods sake. He never got a chance to put his point across.

[@kavitvora6654]

The solution of this agent problem is to let players pay their agents

[@rosshaugh7937]

EXACTLY!

[@rosshaugh7937]

Why the hell should a club have to pay the agent?!

[@rc9719]

they will just get higher wages then , the club is still going to foot the bill.

[@stnbch3025]

​@@rc9719 The wagebill has an FFP cap.

[@njabulonzimande7980]

P11D? Please someone help me

[@georgearthern]

Family agents/managers is a regular thing in boxing. Ask Lawrence Okolie how that has worked out for him.

[@riaddaniels2823]

I'm always concerned about a player, with an agent, going broke.

[@sicklymaad]

You can’t become a top agent without the top players hiring you. FIFA doesn’t have the authority to tell agents what they should charge for their services. Sounds dumb and illegal.

[@dbfhorses]

"Lo 'angen frooo". That's what football is.

[@JoeBrennan-lj8sg]

Sky clearly doesnt like players choosing their agents if they are family