ULTA VS. SEPHORA COLLECTION | HITS AND MISSES | Casey Holmes

[@CatMcCloud]

I like this video idea, comparing two similar companies! Would be interesting to see L’Oreal vs Maybelline since they’re both owned by L’Oreal and I’ve noticed they release similar products within a short amount of time

[@ibrahimlovesblink]

I mean you looks great really!!

[@allysonhammer782]

Honestly impressed with the commitment in this video 🤣 even with the wrong tones in foundation and eyeshadows and highlight! I know you spent a lot of $$ on this video so thanks for the review Casey! Love you! 💖

[@AlexisGutierrez16]

❤️❤️ Casey makes a regular ol’ day SO MUCH BETTER!

[@JulieNick28]

I appreciated you explaining why/how one side looked different by explaining bronzer vs contour. I have trouble with tones and can never tell the diff!

[@melissaearls68]

I love, love, love that you're doing videos like this again! Missed them!

[@bethanymyers9508]

Love the Ulta side!! I love this video idea as well. It gives you more knowledge between the two brands and the different products. Overall I loved this video so way to go Casey 😍🙌🏻

[@thegoodanfamily9817]

I hardly ever shop at Sephora anymore. They never have decent sales and their rewards are a joke. I usually buy at the brand's website before I will purchase at Sephora.

[@4Him7]

Agree 👍

[@Stefistat]

I agree completely. I only hope Ulta keeps adding more high end and luxury brands. Their point system is waaaayyyy better.

[@chelsealynn9043]

yeppp same. the brands will have sales and sephora never will lol.

[@thegoodanfamily9817]

@@chelsealynn9043 right? That's why I had to give it up. Sephora never ends up having a decent sale, and on top of that they act like 10-15-20% is a deal 🤣.

[@lisamason6881]

Same!!! Ulta wins!

[@HiimShailyn]

I absolutely loved this video! Please do more company battles!!!! I loved the Ulta side a lot more!!!!

[@weeeeece]

I can’t believe no one has done this concept yet! Great video idea and great video.

[@KateKosmo]

You should have tried Sephora's new best skin ever foundation, it's pretty darn good, especially for only $20! I think it's way better than their original foundation.

[@april_ann]

Yes! It’s my Holy Grail! Beautiful on pores and doesn’t settle looks completely natural.

[@musiclover10163]

That’s expensive! I use maybelline superstay for 11$ way too pricey for their brand

[@KateKosmo]

@@musiclover10163 $20 is a good price for a non-drugstore product. Now if it was drugstore then no way I would pay that price but I'm used to paying $40 for "prestigious" brands, so $20 is reasonable.

[@AngelsCry48]

@@musiclover10163 yeah, $20 is a really good price for a high end foundation.

[@sarahbrack287]

Maybelline prices have gone way up now!! You will pay almost 20 for their newer, better foundations! 20 isn't bad for a product that lasts months!!

[@cassidybaar]

This was so fun! Do L’Oréal VS Maybelline next time!

[@keeleyify5]

Loving the longer videos 💕💕

[@akaswc2005]

I haven’t watched your videos in years, like we’re talking when you first met Davis. OMG came across this in my feed and this video intrigued me and IM SO HAPPY I WATCHED!!! You have grown up into a lovely woman and are so much more relaxed. Not only have I not seen anyone do a Ulta/Sephora comparison, which was a great idea BTW, I can’t wait to watch more of your videos. Congratulations on the new bundle coming too!❤️

[@tmcbeauty4275]

This video is gold!! Love this idea and how honest you were in each category! 😍😍

[@nicolefraley7404]

Bahahaha your reaction to the Ulta foundation when you first applied it literally made my day!

[@southernbellescrappe]

I think the Ulta side is my fave too but I’m loving the lip colors on the Sephora side

[@rmiller8000]

I really like videos like this. These products are much better priced for me.

[@tierraburch]

You should do a video trying all Farmasi makeup!!! I always see people posting it on insta butttt dont know if I trust their reviews so I NEED YOU to try it out!!!😝😝

[@slrcosmos]

The Sephora serum concealer is one of my favorites! More medium coverage though, but my older under eyes appreciate the formula

[@michellegentz7026]

I found some really good gems in the Sephora collection: the best skin ever foundation is just so beautiful, the lip jellies and lip blushes are wonderful as are all the bullet lipsticks especially the creamy ones! I love the baked formula as well, they have a quad palette in that formula that has blush, bronzer and highlight and it is stunning! Also the Sephora pro bushes are such a good buy. As you can see I love Sephora collection.

[@katelinmarshall8369]

I love this video idea. I picked up the ulta concealer at half off this week and I’m loving it!

[@vicki.with.an.i]

The best Ulta item I ever bought is their sharpener for $4.. it's really good.. it never breaks a tip, it's very easy to empty, it's not cheaply made.. I seriously love it 💯

[@kmccollum1227]

Love this type of video!!!

[@katelinmarshall8369]

Loved this video! Great comparisons. I actually like the Sephora side better. I haven’t bought a lot from the Sephora collection but this video makes me want to try more from them. I think the Sephora foundation is beautiful. And I just have to say, before you put any makeup on, you are glowing!

[@brianamorrissey8858]

Love the idea of this video!! Always intrigued by store brands but never go for it since they aren’t talked about much. Will definitely be checking out Ulta’s range now!

[@jessicalee698]

Ulta bouncy cream eyeshadow … it is gorgeous

[@jenniferkelly4193]

I was going to suggest those LOVE them!❤️

[@mshearer100]

I'm so happy you're back to uploading 👏👏

[@cindicleee]

Love the background!! Such a great video concept! 💗💗

[@ronnisteinwand9564]

You never disappoint I'm glad your back to doing makeup tetoriols because I watch all your family vlogs as well I love watching Mason they are so much fun when there that age and each year they just get better I can't wait to see your little girl and watch Mason with little sister I'll be waiting for your next tetoriols

[@peaceimafidon4629]

Really enjoying this video so far. Could you also compare their brushes/tools as well. Please do essence and catrice next.

[@morganblalock873]

You get more beautiful in every video, girl! I loveeee this idea. I never try the house brands and maybe I need to!

[@novamom1962]

I love you showing us this. I love ULTA. LOVE Y’ALL 💗💗💗💗💗

[@Nailsbylaurna]

Both are nice, but my vote is for the Ulta side. You pulled it together nicely and look beautiful as always.

[@marthajanethvidea-vega1532]

You are a true makeup artist, I love both sides

[@emilydevlin7454]

I really loved this video!!!! 🤩🤩

[@gingerpetrone]

I love your videos!! Have you ever considered zooming your tutorials closer so we can see more detail while your applying? Rather than the wide view with a background.

[@shaynaleann1054]

I love this! There are some hidden gems in both lines and no one ever tries out their products, I have been wondering about that Sephora primer 💕👍🏻😊 Right now I have $125 in points right now!

[@HeatherTerry84]

I am BEYOND Impressed with the end result considering how bad that foundation shade was! Just another reason why Casey will always be my #1 beauty content creator ♥️♥️

[@mauranoonan8951]

I'd love to see the application up close.

[@arlenescott4530]

Loved the Ulta side better and will definitely be purchasing the face powder and contour palette- thanks

[@hillarygmclean]

This is a great idea for a comparison vid!!

[@MsBelaP]

Oh a 30 min video from you? yes!! My thesis can wait LOL LEt's take a break with Casey

[@taraestes9220]

This was a great idea for a video! Really enjoyed watching it❤️

[@melissakurz5961]

This was so fun to watch and really learned a lot

[@ashleymclain6807]

I’m pregnant too and was wounding what self tanner you use? Any pregnancy tips and tricks would be greatly appreciated! 💕

[@SuperFabulous007]

I really liked this video! Love both Ulta and Sephora... I've never tried their store products but I'm going to definitely try both of their blushes and Ulta's concealer!

[@baileyhurleytv]

CASEY! You MUST try Ulta’s self tanning mousse in ultra dark. It’s AMAZING. I know you would love it! Half the price of loving tan or the other great brands & just as good if not better. 😍 Loved this video!

[@fitfatbrittrny]

I agree, it’s very good!!

[@nicolemeacham6922]

I love this idea!!!!!! I usually don’t head toward ultra or Sephora brands in general cuz I just don’t know enough about either

[@jmbo6261]

Love this video! Ulta side for me too girl!

[@camila-b]

I LOVED this video idea! 💕

[@ibrahimlovesblink]

And I love you too girl):

[@shelbyjohnson7828]

You just knowww how to make my days better!

[@lisamason6881]

I loved this so much! I have been wanting to see these two brands compared. Ulta is by far my favorite because of their rewards system; I have been a Diamond for years and I always get fantastic discounts! I would love to see you do more brand comparisons!! Thanks ❤️!!!

[@abigailpena5950]

The Ulta twist mascara has been my absolute favorite for about four years now, the ability to change the size of your lashes depending on how you feel and what look you want is amazing. Also the lashes tend to be more defined instead of clumpy which I love. I'm sooooo happy my favorite mascara isn't like $30, but around drugstore pricing. And even though it's not waterproof damn it can last in water, I'm a competitive swimmer so I definitely put it to the test and it lasted better than any waterproof mascara I've tried, all in all this mascara will be my favorite till it's discontinued or till the day I die!

[@ItsCharissa]

Loved this! Such a great day.

[@Amanda-nc5sy]

This was such a fun video!!!

[@clevertenor]

Watching full screen on my phone, the bottom-right thumbnail covers up all the Sephora prices. But loved the video and I prefer the Ulta side!

[@Blovee3]

Love you Casey! Can’t wait for you to have ur baby girl 👧🏼 💕

[@morganmiller6408]

Such a fun video to watch!!

[@amberdawnsmith9998]

I love the Ulta side. But I think both brands have pros and cons. Great video!

[@melzzz25]

Love that you are doing this vid!! Def Ulta!!

[@dawnjones5082]

Can you do a video testing different full coverage concealers? Looking for something new!

[@alissasmith5004]

Such a fun video!! I love Ulta.

[@tatummiller2507]

Love the ulta side!!

[@KatelynRose]

This was such a fun video! I agree that Ulta was the clear winner!

[@megreynolds6328]

Showing us the spring with the powder really did help 😂❤️ I was hoping you’d try the micro smooth it’s my holy grail setting powder 😭

[@withlovegrace]

I honestly still can’t believe that sooooooo many people feel this way about Sephora point system and they’ve yet to do anything about it 🥴 that would be SUCH a game changer for them.

[@dheredia2789]

Lots of work. Thanks for the good reviews.

[@sophiatidswell2872]

"ulta concelear in medium neutral again oh my" lololol LOVE HER....but even with orqnge foundation she is stunning!

[@kaseykaylynn]

Ulta rewards/ point system: 🥰💖🥰💖🥰 Sephora rewards/ point system: 😒😒😒😒

[@emilycrouch254]

Ulta!!! But that Sephora lip color 🤩🤩

[@michelledeboer8834]

I agree ulta point system is amazing.

[@dannhorne9782]

The Ulta blush looks good on you

[@juliascardina8089]

I loved this video and the Ulta side definitely won

[@JSSCA-lk7hl]

Sephora has waterproof brow pencils that I like and a newer gel concealer with a doe foot applicator. Also I bought the new micro smooth powder and face pallet from Sephora and I like them but I choose Ulta 9/10 times cause of the sales, points, coupons and free products

[@LivingAccordingToCrystal]

Love this idea this was fun !

[@courte89]

This is an awesome video!! I love Ulta’s products but I don’t know much about Sephora’s!

[@jancollier8653]

Great comparisons

[@Jehniferj_4063]

I for sure like the ulta side. The eyeshadow colors/tones are better & the Sephora palette just looks kind of blah to me....& I'm a neutrals gal. I'll spend an extra minute blending lol. I didn't see much difference in the blushes, & like you said if you had used the cooler tone in the Sephora palette it may have looked better, it was very red looking & not as smooth. Wooh!! Lol So Ulta wins 🏆 Good Match 👍 AWESOME IDEA!! Xoxoxo 🥳👌❤

[@brittanyhafleylifestyle9710]

I like the ulta side better but love the shade of Sephora foudation

[@jessicaconroy8666]

Def Ulta!! I barely shop Sephora anymore, Ulta has everything I need.

[@kamimiles4628]

flashbacks with you talking about the Ulta eye lash curler because THAT HAPPENED TO ME!!! My right eyelashes were just GONE, i laugh now but it was notttttt funny when it happened

[@RAG571]

Great video idea!

[@aaronbuchanan7818]

Your always so beautiful…. But for me I really like the Ulta side better , but yess the eyeliner from Saphora was so much more black

[@christinemarie6264]

Love Sephora collection single eyeshadows!

[@jblack212]

That foundation looked like peanut butter! Really liked the Ulta eye shadow palette.

[@joannabedsaul6211]

Where is your shirt from?! I love it!

[@brixtina]

Slay Queen 👑 This Video Was Iconic 🦋🦋

[@HeatherTerry84]

“Baby this is NOT neutral” 🤣🤣

[@nevona4153]

Love this video! Thank you ! 🤗💗

[@sassysashy9577]

Yes 🙌 the Ulta side ❤️

[@lindapollot388]

I like the ulta side better too. 💖

[@kaitlintrump7677]

Ulta side looks good!

[@karenalvarez2342]

Where did you buy your beauty sponge ? Btw love watching your videos

[@LifeStirredUp]

Awesome video! Die-hard Ulta girl here!

[@lahlm1887]

TFS. I like the Ulta side but I agree with the color selection Sephora wins. Fun video. Take care.

[@ArmyWife8697]

I loved this!!

[@christinemarie6264]

Sadly no Ultas in Canada but whenever I’m in the US I go multiple times!

[@graceduheeley1961]

i liked the ulta side way better! i may be biased but i’ve just always been drawn to ulta brand products more than sephora!

[@aliciajimenez2260]

Ulta for sure!

[@alisondickess5159]

I haven’t seen anyone do this!!! I love it!!