J vs Ben: HARDEST Care of Magical Creatures Harry Potter Trivia Quiz

[@m1tthrawnuru0d06]

I always felt like Newt's book was assigned to first years to give them the absolute basic understanding required to survive in the Wizarding World. Since not everyone takes Care of Magical Creatures.

[@m1tthrawnuru0d06]

Shortly after it was published it was made required reading for all 5th year Charms students at Illvermorny. By the time Harry arrives at Hogwarts, the book has been out for 60 years and several of the creatures found within we see covered in the Defense classes at Hogwarts in the 2nd and 3rd years. Also the book isn't a complete guide to Magical Creatures and how to care for them, but an introduction. Including some of the most commonly found creatures in the world and where to find them.

[@dave9401]

@You're Gonna Hate This they said why it was assigned, not why it was written 😊

[@AnthonySilva35]

Do you think they read it in all classes? In defense against the dark arts? Or do you think they were expected to read it on their own time?

[@Ranger1812]

Knowledge of beasts is useful across a variety of subjects, such as Potions and Transfiguration, and in general life. When his book was first published, Lally assigned it as essential reading for her fifth year Charms students at Ilvermorny.

[@Tophkaneki]

“Is it Dark Arts or is it Floridian” *sighs in floridian* “Its probably just Floridian”

[@filthiman]

Floridaman is usually pretty magical

[@AuthorZaraHoffman]

I’m from NYC, and I was also thinking “It’s probably just Floridian.”

[@mariayeager7423]

hey im from florida

[@SaltExarch]

Florida man is definitely a dark wizard using his powers to cause chaos and confusion in the muggle world.

[@ShirleyLestrade]

“It’s not the worst answer I’ve ever given” Who married Iolanthe Peverell? Ben: SUSAN!!

[@heatherrockwell9012]

We also had a question where Ben answered "Stanley Yeltnats" (the protagonist of Holes) and J answered "Mustafar" (a planet from Star Wars), so...

[@wisteriawalker4403]

Favorite Ben quote: braindeskbraindeskbraindesk J: Is it in there? Ben: NO. Why are we so unorganized, Me?

[@XxGreymoonxX]

He also answered that dumbledore’s first name is alfred

[@adamrabe3105]

Loved the comparison of the stealthiness of Hagird vs Harry. Such a great point! How is a half-giant more stealthy than the youngest seeker in a century that has an invisibility cloak? In addition, definitely never going to forget Ike Razorbeam (possibly the 2nd cousin twice removed of Taserface from Guardians of the Galaxy V2).

[@JuanMataCFC]

Moldevort, Cho "hawt lips" Chang, and now Dr Ike Razorbeam are all absolute unforgettables from the JvB series! 😂

[@Arcane1954]

Dr. Razorbeam's fountain pens were not for writing, but dispensed a stream of cool refreshing liquids. Plain water, giggle water, lemonade, and other drinks were available. They just looked like pens to fool muggles.

[@selonianth]

It let him 'chew on the tip' in public while still gaining refreshments using clever charms to pull the desired liquid from a canteen. He first came up with it in an attempt to cheat at his NEWTS using Felix Felicis.

[@calvinwright2214]

By my recollection, it wasn’t Crabbe that claimed to be bitten by a flobberworm but rather Malloy claiming Crabbe had been bit by one

[@thedragonwarrior5861]

You would be correct

[@ankanand]

Ur right

[@kyellverdonschot9922]

How do y’all remember this? I didn’t even know it was Crabbe Though I must say it feels much more like a Pansy Parkinson type move than anything else

[@Whyteroze28]

Love how he calls Hermione a time-traveling third grader. I get it, but third grade and third year are vastly different...

[@brandibastian4193]

I mean third grade you're 7-8 years old a third year in Hogwarts is a 7th grader very different and I am much older than the Carlin's though they have human kids and I just have black cats

[@Thesis_Rose]

I may trust a third grader more then a 7th grader (someone who just is now an 8th grader)

[@brandibastian4193]

@@Thesis_Rose true middle school is rough

[@kaylatarapaskoski2390]

@@Thesis_Rose why??

[@BestFriendsWhoLiveTogether]

@@brandibastian4193 3rd year at hogwarts is actually year 9 in real life. Year 7 is age 11-12, which would be first year. Year 8 is age 12-13, which would be sound year. Year 9 is age 13-14, which would be 3rd year. Harry’s the youngest in his year so he turns 14 in the holidays, rather than the school year

[@caitlinowens0622]

Actually, I would think that a chameleon is the most magical creature. Those camouflaging abilities are S tier.

[@caitlinowens0622]

@You're Gonna Hate This Iguanas are cool, too.

[@wisteriawalker4403]

Ethan: What did Fred and George bet - Ben: WE ARE NOT DOING THIS AGAIN. Tbh, that one was a. JvsB I re-watch when I need a laugh.

[@pablodelrio8082]

What was the video's title?

[@wisteriawalker4403]

@@pablodelrio8082 It was the J vs Ben Quidittch World Cup Quiz. I think it was the last one that Ethan hosted which is why he threw that question in this one.

[@MordechaiHershoffyoutube]

nah better one was the half of eel farm for Bagman by whatever her name is

[@wisteriawalker4403]

@@MordechaiHershoffyoutube Get your eels at Timm’s!

[@Paulytoadzz]

Dr. Razerbeam killed me, I hope they make him a real character in the next Fantastic Beasts movie!!

[@I_Im_Over_There]

Taught newt everything he knows

[@MCMIVC]

There likely won't be more FB movies, but it would have been cool to have Dr. Ike Razorbeam in it.

[@TheWiseGrif]

God i love when Ben doesn't know and just goes all in on a wrong guess

[@MDev1997]

"What did they change Buckbeak's name to?" used to be my go-to question to stump my dad in Harry Potter trivia

[@retrobro_]

10:00 I want to see an alternate-universe Voltron-Sonic-He-man Harry Potter where Dr.Ike Razorbeam is the headmaster and takes the students on all sorts of wacky adventures.

[@robertbrookes2000]

8:01 At first I had no clue, but then I think it's bonked into my head. I believe the Thestral is called Tenebrous. I'm guessing it was also the first in the herd Hagrid tamed. I think I remember it because A Series of Unfortunate Events (Reptile Room) taught me that it means a dark hue.

[@rho_man]

Tenebrus wasn't first tamed. He was first, that born in Hogwarts, that mean that there was at least 2 tamed thestrals in Hogwarts brought from another place before Tenebrus.

[@onionwielder9728]

1:24- Despite that running through my head seconds before, that caught me REALLY off guard and I nearly spat out my soda 😄

[@Lordpooz09]

Dr. Ike Razorbeam was the care of magical creatures teacher before Kettleburn.... 🤷‍♂️

[@baystated]

Ben has lost his "glasses" bonus now that J has the same ones.

[@paulrankin6032]

These quizzes are such wholesome, fun, and cathartic entertainment! Thank you both for the years of quality production!

[@morbidiablack5321]

I have waited for what has seemed like 4 months for another Harry Potter quiz 😭 Thank you. This is wicked awesome!!!!!!!!!🖤🖤

[@terriejones5640]

J vs Ben are my absolute favourite videos 🥰

[@hannahsonnenburg7718]

Same

[@Nanalagoon]

"Is is the Dark Arts, or is it Floridian?" can apply to many different questions I have about Florida haha

[@countryboyfromtx]

I’ve been dying for another Harry Potter quiz!! I’ll fail this one though 😂

[@JustASorcerer]

They should take a trivia quiz for a fandom they're NOT in! it would be interesting to see how well they do (the questions should be fairly easy and based on surface-level knowledge so it wouldn't be too discouraging for them)

[@Pokeminator]

It's always fascinating how these two never played Hogwarts mystery. Otherwise it would be impossible for them to not know Prof. Kettleburn's name.

[@linggao2602]

Well if they stayed till year 4 that is.

[@TheRealCardoso]

I’m a player & I also forgot 😂

[@candycemonroe7345]

I've not watched all ten years, but I remember when you actually sat on a couch. I have binged older episodes. My socks are amazing.

[@allisonhoff5805]

They had to do a bunch of things in the Care of Magical Creatures O.W.L.s- technically they did do something with unicorns: "On their Care of Magical Creatures practical, they had to identify a Knarl hidden among a dozen hedgehogs, demonstrate correct handling of a Bowtruckle, feed and clean out a Fire Crab without sustaining serious burns, and choose from a wide selection of food the diet they would give a sick unicorn." -Harry Potter Wiki

[@matteoairaghi790]

You should invite Newt and Hagrid next time to have a challenge!

[@blakesherman840]

lol

[@andrest6700]

This

[@katherinemcdaniel8676]

Did they know each other? I think newt was in school twenty years before hagrid but they both knew Dumbledore.

[@matteoairaghi790]

@katherinemcdaniel8676 more like thirty years but yeah it would make sense that they knew each other since they are experts in the same field and the magical community is not that big

[@TheCrispyChip]

i rememebr the old back and forth format when you started out, yes you still do it but i loved that each video was a message to each other in a sense xD

[@AbstractlyMe83]

These are my favorite videos you do!!! I go back and rewatch them all the time! And there are a good amount of quizzes on Pottermore you haven’t done, so I’m literally so excited

[@CatchingPieces]

7:06 The correct answer is none, because Draco didn’t fail to approach Buckbeak correctly. He did, and Buckbeak bowed back, and Buckbeak was even allowing Draco to pet him. The problem was that Draco insulted Buckbeak, and that’s when Buckbeak slashed him arm.

[@AuthorZaraHoffman]

“What IS wrong with my brain?” Poor Ben! So close yet so far.

[@hej.anneli]

They should absolutely do a proper 'Is it Magical or is it just Britis' Themed Quiz

[@TimeTravelerAlly]

10 years?! Dang time flies!! I don't think i've watched all ten years, but i've been a fan for a long long time and went back to watch almost all of the videos including vlogs. I want to say i joined in year 3? Year 4? I can't remember, but happy 10 years brothers and Super Carlin Friends!

[@jeremyjasona]

Oh great! Now I can’t get THIS scene out of my head: “Tony Stark built this in a cave! With a box of SNAKES!” 🤣

[@randomperson2777]

“Is it the dark arts, or is it just floridian” reminds me of John Mulaney “do all my friends hate, or do I just need to go to sleep”

[@00juls00]

This particular video was comedy gold, guys! haha Also there were several instances mentioned in this video (Hagrid having a favorite thestral and Harry ever interacting with a bowtruckle) that I had zero memory of. Meaning it's overdue to reread the Harry Potter books again, folks! (Apparently reading them about 6 or so times isn't enough to remember everything).

[@kylecollins3755]

Haven't watched this yet, but I'm 100% sure it's Ron's niffler! Confidence decreasing by the second though...

[@hannahsonnenburg7718]

This is my favourite format to watch, please keep it going!

[@Mr.Pinger]

I love J vs Ben! good luck to you both.

[@ashleyrobo]

Plot Twist: Dumbledore had Fantastic Beasts and Wear to Find Them so that Harry can read about three headed dogs and learn about Fluffy so he can save the stone. It seems like a Dumbledore thing.

[@sarahclarke1550]

I’ve never seen you guys in such a silly giggly mood! It’s hilarious.

[@thiagoteixeira6537]

I don't even know basically anything about Harry Potter but I love watching them compete against each other in these quizzes!

[@fireblow44]

If you're interested in magical fiction stuff you should give it a read, or atleast watch the movies. You might like what you find

[@romanhowells2180]

Hey guys, I really love watching your videos. Keep up the good work!!

[@mishapenmoonmoth]

_"Excuse me, I have a time-traveling third grader!"_ is one of the funniest J lines i've ever heard

[@baystated]

The few seconds in the film as McGonagal and Harry approach Quirrel's class, you can hear this screeching creature through the door... and then they open the door and he's just holding an iguana. Classic. "Of c-c-c-course" The book has them finding "burly" Oliver Wood in Flitwick's class. I like the iguana moment better. Wouldn't have been bad if the Oliver actor had been burly though.

[@transrightsarehumanrights_]

the way my stomach dropped when you answered my question before it was asked 😂

[@kandipiatkowski8589]

I have a tidbit from secrets of Dumbledore....Newt's niffler is named Teddy. I don't believe it was ever mentioned in the first 2 movies.

[@ryanalex4671]

Draco Malloy gets slight scrapped by Buckbeak and then proceeds to do his best impersonation of a soccer player

[@PeterTheMightyPygmyPuff]

Have you heard about the theory that Bellatrix wasn't a Death Eater until after she escapes from Azkaban in book 5? Voldemort claims two Lestranges went to jail for him in Goblet, but we know three Lestranges did. So who wasn't the Death Eater? The podcast "Determination, Deliberation, and Dragons" theorized that it was Bellatrix.

[@jonlancaster7375]

i had to go and check on this real quick, because i don't remember voldy saying specifically 2 lestrange, and technically he doesn't he says " the lestrange should stand here but they are entombed in azkaban..." the spot where he stops however is described as big enough for 2 people. so it makes for an interesting theory but even if true i would highly doubt it to be bella she is obsessed with voldy and always has been. i would likely believe one of the brothers first as not being a death eater over her.

[@chuckled125]

The only reason to claim it was Bellatrix is that's the most interesting option

[@wha6688]

But didn’t she torture the Longbottoms for Voldemort’s location?

[@m1tthrawnuru0d06]

Ehhh. Why would she be Voldy's most trusted when she escaped Askaban if she wasn't even a Death Eater before his fall? Plus the way she behaves at the trial "The Dark Lord will rise again...He will rise again and come for us,...We alone were faithful, we alone tried to find him.

[@lahlybird895]

The lomgbottoms

[@JBROADRICK]

Love J vs Ben been waiting for these 😍 x

[@lthecatt9667]

Harry did have a third year of Care of Magical, it was his 5th year at Hogwarts

[@KatherineMackenzieSmith]

You guys bagging out HP plot holes is my favourite

[@lalalou123]

THANK YOU for a new J vs Ben. I live for these x

[@danielkennedy8355]

How awesome is Dumbledore to make a joke about one of his professors losing a limb. 😂

[@dave9401]

Yay. I feel like I've waited months for a J vs Ben Pottah quiz. Thank you guys. These are my favourite vids from your team ❤️🧡💛💚💙💜

[@irenefalsini9030]

0:22-0:27 Both what Ben says and how he says it reminds me of Hades from the 1997 Hercules when he tells Meg that she works for him even though she doesn't want to help him hurt Hercules, whom she fell in love with

[@graceb9442]

I really love your Harry Potter theory’s and quizzes I feel really good when I get the answer correct when one of you get it wrong Thanks for the video

[@TheSamkrox]

2:46 wouldn’t their third year of COMG be book 5?

[@PerfectChaos7]

Yup, it would be. I'm glad someone else noticed and said something. J failing at quick mental math... LOL

[@wolverinefangowings]

The third year of Care of Magical Creatures class was in Harry's 5th year. Someone didn't pay the Math Budget.

[@theSBC1409]

"Is it the dark arts or is it Floridian?" As a Floridian myself, this is an honest to god answer. Sadly I think the answer is still unclear.

[@kingpug8318]

Y’all are so cool been watching these forever

[@ultracapacity7531]

At 8:50 the only reason I know the professor's name, is because I take his class in Hogwarts Mystery. You can learn alot about the Wizarding World by playing, but you need patience. Which I have plenty for being a Fouth Year. 🦅

[@asexualbert7262]

Super excited for spirit week! And super lucky that the 24th will be the first Friday that I don't work in WEEKS! I haven't been here for the full ten years, but it's a near thing. A little over nine now I think since I found the channel and proceeded to power watch through all the videos that had come out before I turned up.

[@s1lm4r1l6]

21:00 Ben is actually so close with that guess.

[@ichosecommonsense5295]

Dr. Ike Razorbeam's been everywhere.

[@SkywalkerAni]

Oh man, 10 years! I've been watching since a few months in, and you guys still rock.

[@thebatmary5954]

What is that mysterious ticking noise? Snaps, Snape, Severus Snape RAZORBEAM!!!!

[@keshawnrobinson1011]

I'm from Florida and I think the dark lord must have vacationed here at some point

[@camwyn256]

Were other countries aware of Voldemort? Did they take any actions?

[@keshawnrobinson1011]

@@camwyn256 I think other places just try to ignore us as much as possible muggles think Voldemort is just Florida man

[@pimheron]

This is my favorite HP quiz you guys have done to date. The chaos

[@sparkndark]

I love how express VPN ads are more focused on the changing the region you live in, instead of the other features of it like better security.

[@ThePrincessSabrina]

As a muggle country music lover, love the idea of the Grass Snakes being a wizarding bband. Also, after reading Ss14 one time, I came up with a rock band title: Bourbom Dragons.

[@stonemarkstudiosproduction]

Loved the video. Cracked me up. I use your Coffee as a rub for stake and burgers mixed with ground porcini & seasoning. Family loves it.

[@laha9372]

The first thestral born in the forest is not the oldest one though, his parents are

[@szocszalan964]

Since you like star wars, I think Tenebrus is easy to remember if you know who Palpatine's master's (Plagueis) master was: Darth Tenebrous

[@caitlinowens0622]

My 22nd birthday is Lightsabers vs. Wandsday! I’ll be holding on to Harry Potter’s wand while I get my first MRI done.

[@ejal565]

The real question is who knows more about magical creatures? Newt or Hagrid?

[@jerryakatony5724]

My heart says Hagrid, but I know it’s Newt

[@thedragonwarrior5861]

I would say Newt as it's his literal job

[@TTStopMotionShorts]

@@thedragonwarrior5861 it’s also hagrids job😂

[@kacperkubicki1101]

I'd say Newt for international, Hagrid for british.

[@ejal565]

@@thedragonwarrior5861 is it? I thought his job was being Dumbledores errand boy at this point *joking*

[@Roald13th]

What if the iguana Quirrel holds in that scene is kind of a hint of his meek cover? I mean, an iguana seem scary for us since people are generally scared of reptiles, but this is the wizarding world, with dragons, basilisks and blast-ended skrewts (book 4 though). So Quirrel holding a "regular" lizard is pretty tame, and it might be voldemort's idea that lizards, apart from snakes, aren't that interesting

[@ezra737]

I pride myself in, at the very least, knowing Kettleburn.

[@drewmatthews23]

Box of snakes. Lead singer Dr. Ike Razorbeam. First album "The Cerebus Thestral" with the biggest hit "OH.w.l"

[@Usernamegoeshere93]

Ben… bro you have the right answer almost every time lol 😂!

[@heatherrockwell9012]

I can't believe Ben even misspelled "Cerebrus" in a way closer to the right answer-

[@gingerkays7362]

As a Fire Emblem fan, the “Dr IKE Razorbeam” guess made me grin

[@danielrhouck]

I got all the official questions right except for the one where I knew the answer was one of Crabbeorgoyle and I chose the wrong one. Just like I’d often choose the wrong one if I knew the answer was Fredandgeorge. I had no idea for the first Patreon question, and would have gotten the second right even if the answer weren’t given away in the previous question. I had no idea for the main part of the third question, but got the bonus point. I got the fourth right: Honeydukes chocolate and a triggering of the inferiority complex. 23:24 Okay now I’m imagining that the Hufflepuffs fed them eagle eggs, the Slytherins fed them lion cubs, and the Ravenclaws fed them badger cubs (er, I mean, pancakes)

[@someone2803]

I'd like to see just how many wizarding world quizes supercarlin bros have done

[@camwyn256]

According to the Playlist on their channel, 99

[@highandtight5544]

I needed this laugh this morning. I love this channel so much. Thank you guys.

[@bryprevatte9268]

Love you boys. Need another super trivia fan night again

[@seanmcgovern1779]

I have so many issues with the quiz and the scoring that I'm going to have to re-watch it with a notepad to voice them properly. I still love the quizzes.

[@s6r231]

Well I didn't even know that the Thetrals had names, let alone that Hagrid has a favourite.

[@HaleyMarieBrackett]

the intro of "Its killed me it's killed me" after the discussion about Draco not really having a broken arm had me dying...and then the clip before the first question! :P dead lol

[@ActiveAdvocate1]

PS: Y'all have been doing this for TEN YEARS? Congrats!

[@mariaana6710]

Pokemons? The Scyther in the back is perfect!

[@tammytuell6177]

We do have iguanas like that in Florida, but only in the pet shops. Our lizards in the wild are the Cuban variety and are at most 5 inches long.

[@aaveey]

Are you guys planning on making videos about the obi-wan series, if not I would really love to see more star wars content and im sure many other fans would too!

[@morrigankasa570]

YAY, ANOTHER HARRY POTTER QUIZ. I only watch you guys (on this channel) when you guys do Harry Potter videos AND only if they pertain to the actual books or original films NOT IF THEY ARE ABOUT THE GRINDELWALD/FANTASTIC BEASTS FILMS!!!!!

[@gingerkays7362]

The “is it magical or is it British” joke reminds me of in Chuggaaconroy’s Xenoblade Chronicles lp’s when he keeps asking whether it’s a British thing or a Xenoblade thing

[@Jedi_Nemo]

10 YEARS! Wow...I have been here for all 10. And I miss the socks shoutouts each episode! We should bring those back :)

[@AT-vz2ul]

Sometimes I wish I could do what you guys do it seems so fun making theories and quizzes on some of ur favorite fandoms though you guys are brilliant way better than my literature professor

[@albertbertaton8014]

I've been watching for six years now and still remember the first video of yours I watched

[@diabolicallink]

12:19 I collect fountain owns and have multiple copies of the third book. I am tempted to change the name to Dr. Ike Rasorbeam with on of my fountain pens now

[@shaggygray4828]

Wow I just did the math and I started watching you guys my freshman year of highschool which was now 8 years ago congratulations on 10 years you guys never fail to amaze me by far my favorite KZbin channel ever