Jay Smith: The Germans Created the History of Muhammad!

[@FaridResponds]

You want awesome thumbnails? Hit up the illustrious SollyLucid! Link: x.com/SollyLucid

[@keksi6844]

Jay claims there are 33 verses in Birmingham Quran.Problem is it is 62.He cant even count not to mention something made him say it 33 which is MAGICK number.

[@hassamneetoo956]

Jazaakallah khair br Farid for intelligently and indisputably challenging the stubborn and blind Jay Smith and his cohort . May Allah reward you for defending Islam. In the beginning Jay also mentioned a parallel contemporary example of eye witnesses with the sahabas quoting John, Mark, Matthew and Luke. Does he not know that Luke was not one of them as he himself declared it in the new Testament.

[@TheRockeyAllen]

Kuffar: He was evil Also Kuffar: He never existed

[@mabmoh7340]

Also : he was a Christian 😮‍💨 just hopeless people

[@Random_username_1234]

they only recognize His existence when it fit them

[@redhakiim789]

Yep, you nailed it in short terms. It isn't new as well since all of the Prophets went through the same in different times.

[@samy7013]

Jay Smith embodies the age-old maxim: “Without lies, Christianity dies.”

[@exposingcrossdogtianity]

Praying it does 🙏

[@marufahmed3416]

Even with lies, Christianity is declining

[@AllenAnderson-b6t]

​@@marufahmed3416so what no religion is true

[@AllenAnderson-b6t]

No religion is true

[@UnchainedSlave]

@@AllenAnderson-b6t As if you went through every religion. That's a ret@rded.

[@優さん-n7m]

The ludicrous arguments these Christian missionaries keep inventing, there is no doubt that they are desparate.

[@keksi6844]

They are stealing their ideas from Atheist who also make same claim about Jesus.

[@blueman-z1m]

​@@keksi6844lmao true

[@tark_reyes4711]

if they spent their time "inventing lies" on actual research they wouldn't be "Christians" anymore

[@Suleiman212]

Like honestly, is there any clearer proof for the truth of Islam than what it's opponents have to resort to, to even attempt to bring a refutation?

[@7625e]

This level of desperation churning out feeble arguments does nothing but make our faith ever more solid and impervious and shake up genuine TRUTH seeking logical christians. So let him keep being desperate in his fight against submitting to God

[@TheMuslimApologist]

Even with lies, Christianity dies.

[@FreePalestine_____]

Big fan.

[@dqschannel]

Hey are you the guy who ran from debating me? LMAO

[@ElectroBolt]

What was the question​@@dqschannel

[@dqschannel]

@@ElectroBolt question for what?

[@ElectroBolt]

@@dqschannel what were you guys debating about

[@moojza]

No serious Scholar between Muslim and Non Muslim western academics still hold that Prophet Muhammad never existed😊

[@Xenor999]

Jay smith is a joke

[@dqschannel]

are you sure? Have you read the books from the Germans? Can you find me evidence, historical or archaeology for a city called Mecca in the 7th or prior centuries? Hell how about for Islam, quran, Muslim existing in 7th...

[@blueman-z1m]

​@@dqschannelYeah you're joking right

[@UriPhoneCracker]

​@@dqschannelThere's no way you're serious 😂😂😂

[@kishk0]

It’s like saying Germans never existed 😂 lol.

[@dzvw]

At his age, he's already one foot in the grave and he decided to speedrun into Jahannam 🤣

[@mohdhafiz9955]

With a back flip

[@normanyacob4235]

​@@mohdhafiz9955 And a faceplant...

[@ElectroBolt]

​@@normanyacob4235 and a roll in the end

[@GutzOverFear]

Bro that is foul... 😭😭

[@hassamneetoo956]

Allah does not guide those who want to stay blind despite thousands of evidences staring at them. These christian missionaries seem to have a grudge against our beloved prophet(s.a.w) because maybe he was not israelite but from arab descent. Allah knows best. You can take 20 horses to the river but you can't make one drink.

[@brotherlogicrmf2199]

This doesn't even need a rebuttal 💯

[@kinetic3971]

Yeah just clowns playing what if with absolutely no concrete proof whatsoever. Just babbling in front of a camera.

[@idrisanimagac.4086]

No way to counter Islam and they come with this

[@fromtheperiphery]

Poor Jay. He thinks Matthew, Mark, Luke and John were eye witnesses to the events. Perhaps he should first educate himself on his own religion before embarrassing himself further. Or perhaps not, you cant teach iq points.

[@jordanm169]

Farid is hands-down the king of thumbnails lol

[@FaridResponds]

It's by SollyLucid. You can find him on twitter. He actually said: "This is the first draft." I was like: "How can this even be made to be better?!" And I used it as it is. 😃

[@jordanm169]

@@FaridResponds nice…would he do mine??

[@ZDL679]

Sup bro

[@ceti_9998]

Is jay smith mentally ill or a stand up comedian? No matter how many times we literally debunk it he comes again shamelessly. This guy must suffer.

[@moojza]

@@ceti_9998 Well he thinks Uthman sent a Mushaf to Baghdad (a city that didnt exist yet at that time) so probably closer to mentally ill

[@testtester6520]

@@moojza what ??? please send the clip .

[@assassinwithalqalam]

None of those, he's an idiot

[@blueman-z1m]

I would say maybe it's his belief in the trinity. It lowers your IQ

[@jeremymartin301]

I'm going to the mall around Christmas and sit on Santa's lap and say please retire your arguments are getting weaker than your IQ

[@lemonke3774]

Farid’s thumbnail game is unmatched

[@AmbasinggBouttabust]

i know right🤣🤣

[@Ajmolali82]

You can tell even Hatun is not buying the BS what Jay is spouting.

[@Kashmir84828]

Well, they're both haters and liars.

[@siyovushm2317]

Jay is a gift that just keeps giving lol. His theories are by far the most entertaining out there.

[@ConvictedBattler]

These thumbnails get me everytime 😂😂

[@Majas101]

and here i thought their arguments cant get any WORSE, it turn out i was wrong all along 😅

[@James_ibn_Cody]

Done and dusted! Allahumma Barik, brother Farid. Exquisite work, as always.

[@Exposing21]

Prophet Mohammed (PBUH) is the most recorded human in history, we know everything about him lol, literally.

[@kinetic3971]

"B-b-but did he really EXIST!?" 😂🤣🤡

[@qafrd5487]

He's all over the place! He said " -ibn Malik- " 🤣imam Malik was a Sahabi that wrote al-Muwatta, then later backtracked saying there was no hadith collections until 600 years after the Prophet ﷺ? Does he think imam Maalik time-travelled 600years to write Muwatta?!

[@Ali-zt9ky]

Jay Smith is correct Imam Malik is Ibn Malik who time travelled with Imam Murrah to change history, this was authenticated by Jalaluddin Al-Tabari.

[@mohdhafiz9955]

CP:Must be imam murrah doing

[@HFBN2004]

​@@Ali-zt9kyDid he meet Marty McFly?

[@trappedinexistence]

are you guys living under a rock? it's common knowledge that every muslim has the ability to time travel☝️🤓

[@Ali-zt9ky]

@@HFBN2004 according Jalaluddin Al-Tabari’s seerah of imam Murrah they ended up in galaxy far far way

[@eelmohamed]

Remember other fools denied the existence of Jesus too.

[@mfahadfayt]

Love you brother so much ❤ from 🇵🇰

[@aliasabdulrahman4893]

Excellence Farid 😊

[@vortexvampire]

بارك الله فيكم... اللهم اغفر لوالدينا و ارحمهما و اجمعنا معهما في الفردوس الأعلى مع الأنبياء و الشهداء و الصالحين و جميع موتى المسلمين.. اللهم احقن دماء المسلمين و انصرهم على من عاداهم.. رب إني مسني الضر و أنت أرحم الراحمين... لا إله إلا أنت سبحانك إني كنت من الظالمين..... ............. ............. ............

[@mdnoszyekov2967]

that post credit is important for christians to ask jay smith. he laughed because he know he cannot answer.

[@shueybosman2017]

Akhi may allah reward you the thumbnail got me dead laughing on the floor.

[@MuhammadSaeed-ku1us]

Brutal.

[@f1aziz]

Jay is completely off his rockers.

[@noticing33]

Bruh wth is this new consipracy 😂😂😂

[@mohdhafiz9955]

Dog logic: write it down

[@TheHaqtivist]

He needs to smith his darkened heart.

[@thetruthwithproof8802]

Jazak Allah

[@محمد-ر6غ4ذ]

I'm already tired of this Jay guy just by reading the title, I haven't even watched the video yet lol.

[@Spreadingthetruth]

Surprising that he even trusts the information surrounding this German guy given it was 160 years ago....

[@saudalkaabi3353]

The Sira claim being debunked was just too funny. He js “So here’s a copy of the book that was written centuries before Mr. German Man”

[@KalliKall-r7n]

"I hope you can do it under a year" farid is FARID

[@ryder-m5r]

Jay smith ladies and gentlemen The guy who's spending his whole career trying to convince Muslims that "don't" and "do not" are two different words with two different meaning .............. Cuz they are not written in the same way and not spelled in the same accent

[@nowajishmuhtadee6802]

Assalamu Alaikum brother, it has been 4 ish years since I have been watching you, by the help of Allah your videos gave me much ilm and helped me many times in my life. May Allah increase you in goodness and make many more people like you.

[@ahmedabdulwehab5665]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 "We can't blame the Germans of everything "

[@derdadermenzi5294]

Chriatianity never existed ! It has always been Paulian Paganism !!!

[@jcs184]

The endings are always gold!

[@danalmariti509]

Why do these missionaries do this? Just go to Timbuktu or Mauritania, you will find manuscript copies of Islamic works going back hundreds of years.

[@hjs9td]

Just like every Danielle Steele Novel.

[@AliD1812]

Even by the criteria and standards of western academia, Jay Smith’s research and conclusions are not taken seriously.

[@testtester6520]

8:21 it rolled the heck out of me ☠☠💀.

[@aliozer85]

Excellent response.

[@TheNamedVosto]

If Jay smith says I saw aliens yesterday and they show me their world it would be more logical than whatever he speaks in the video

[@OAW-LetusDiscuss.]

It will never baffle me when a christain wants to talk especially with such confidence about these topics when they believe in the bible

[@ahmedd408]

Funny thing is guys what, we have even earlier manuscripts of Bukhari centuries before the one Farid showed😂😂 alhumabaarik brother

[@tigerdude2727]

Free palestine

[@Theguidancebook]

the way he says sahaba HAHAHA sorry i cant

[@SalehAbdurRaheem]

😅

[@smansmans8631]

جزاك الله خيرا 🇲🇦

[@tanzeelurrehman1985]

The Best ( Number One ) Human ever walked on earth 🌎 🌍 is Muhammad Peace Be Upon Him. [ Micheal H. Hart Christian ]. My choice of Muhammad Peace Be Upon Him to lead the list of the world's most influential persons may surprise some readers and may be questioned by others, but He Peace Be Upon Him was The Only Man in history Who was supremely successful on both the religious and secular level. [ Michael H. Hart is an American astrophysicist, author and white nationalist. Since 1978, he has published five books, most notably of the best-selling work, The 100: A Ranking of the Most Influential Persons in History ].

[@DoomedSkull]

Finally,your video are in 1080p. now we can watch farid cooking in high quality 😂😂

[@salman0ansari]

😂😂"we can't really blame the germans for everything" 8:22

[@ooze91]

MashAllah, thank you

[@isaacjamaar4794]

If Jay Smith says a cat is monkey it will make sense than trying to explaining trinity

[@hamdibeekeeper]

They even misinterpret the cover of a book?na'udzubillah tsumma na'udzubillah

[@kmno4-h8v]

Wa Alaikkum Salam Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakathuhu

[@albanistaner300]

💪🏽

[@Double4Filth]

I used to watch and like David Wood four years ago when I was less progressive and recently discovering your videos really helped open my eyes on Islam

[@FaridResponds]

Where you at in your journey?

[@tatooinenative860]

This is just hilarious 😂

[@Issa_Alkubi]

Just by the title I laughed

[@LastWordInSilence]

First they try to refute Al-Quran and when there's no success then they attack Prophet Mohammad (Peace Be Upon Him) and when they fail then they say Prophet did not exist. This is a defeated attitude.

[@ttta-s3r]

جزاك الله خيرا

[@yaznhanfi9090]

I like how jay tries his best pronouncing the arabic names 😂

[@raiyaanshaikh0114]

"Excellent excellent question" gets me every time lol

[@thaknobodi]

It's so offputting to hear someone say "Prophet Muhammed" without saying salalahu alayhi wa salam. As a muslim i take for granted that we always respect him salalahu alayhi wa salam and mention the dua except for these atheists

[@xxtayebxxt.o3556]

salam Farid. May allah keep you strong. You have already made a video about umars bravery. But everywhere i go on insta reels and tiktok comments, they still try to say umar ran in battle. You know your video about how supposedly fatima was attacked in 30 sources. Can you please do the same for what they say about umar running in battles. The forums already disprove it, but some shia like to send 20 more sources saying that its also in other books. I dont have arabic knowledge to read these books. If you could please do a video like that and break down every single source. I have most of the sources they like to use.

[@beep1859]

How can they claim what they claim, when they need to use lies, deception, manipulation, or conspiracies while we need only documented history and fact to discredit them?

[@IbnMahir1993]

Assalamou aleykoum wa rahmatoullahi wa barakatouh, jazakAllahou kheira. I think a video or a document gathering the earliest sources Quran and hadith with isnad and also the date of the earliest manuscripts of Quran, hadith books, sira and tafasseer could be beneficial so that the information would be concentrated in one place. Quoting the book with the classical transmission that gives a time period and then adding the earliest manuscripts that corresponds. I don’t know, just sharing my thoughts… Wa Allahou aleem

[@mcgullible5212]

Upping the thumbnail game.

[@anzar420316]

seriously embarassing.

[@obijack08]

lolll jay admits most scholars attribute the seerah to ibn hisham but because one copy was made by a german he just calls all of them frauds 😂

[@Commons_usa]

the apologetics are jealous of mohamed

[@Days6281]

Also I love how you've chosen a knight's-cross-decorated SS uniform for him. Although, I think a lowly brown shirt would have sufficed.

[@1sosukeaizen1]

I thought jay smith was dead 💀. Not literally ofc but no one thinks about what he has to say

[@waseem.kooora]

Jay smith? Haven't heard that name in years

[@7625e]

🤦‍♂️ these ppl are not serious ppl. Since its an echo chamber with very little room for critical thinking in their camp his base wont challenge him on his very hypocritical standards and takes. Alhamdulilah (All praise be to God alone) for Islam❤

[@FreePalestine_____]

I mean they literally can't see the contradictions of their own Bible. Of course they will contradict themselves.

[@syad911]

he can throw these ridiculous claims because his followers never asked him for responsibility whatsoever, so keep lying, the supporters will keep simping behind him.

[@Abd-k8x]

The best response is laughing at him .. like literally

[@szuvibes9474]

Farid listened to my request 😅

[@xila8861]

lol you're good at endings

[@MakaiJohnkenneth]

They argue that this one called Mohamed is a created scenario of another person who is a great warrior

[@zm_headhunter]

In this moment jay got completely destroyed by Farid 7:35

[@Abd-k8x]

8:00 "We can't blame Germany for everything" 😂😂

[@7625e]

Ma-sha-Allah (As God wills )❤

[@Aladin-r8t]

Alfred Guillaume translated Ibn Isham...himself admitted it...

[@Berliin9]

which germans... were the blonde eyed crusaders (germans) fighting other germans in crusades?

[@محمد-ر6غ4ذ]

The earliest complete new testament manuscript dates from 3 centuries after Jesus. Christians have no direct connection with the eyewitnesses who lived during Jesus's time. And there is no mention of the Trinity until after these 3 centuries. Their creed doesn't come from Jesus (Peace be upon him).

[@HamzaAhmed-al-aqsa360]

What!!😂😂😂.Now they have gone This mad. I Think we should give them some relief or They will get super crazy 😅

[@NDP719]

How can anyone believe someone who believe that "God would come as a man to die for our sins", can ever be taken seriously is beyond me. Unfortunately his videos will reach many ignorant souls who would just take them as fact without doing their own researches. I wish your videos would reach them, you are preaching mainly to the converted.

[@irreview]

Nice thumbnail 👌

[@MohamedShou]

Bro non of these anti Muslim missionaries cannot even access the original sources 🤦🏾‍♂️😂. And some Christians still think they are “experts” on Islam? Jay Smith trying to pronounce the names of these great men and their works is almost making my ears bleed Subhanallah 😩

[@catholicreconquista7456]

At 11:22 you say that the Bukhari manuscript was completed in 689 AH, i.e. 1311 A.D. (correct me if I am mistaken). The Ottoman Empire commenced in 1299. So, Jay Smith would appear to be correct on this point. On the other hand, your point about the Ibn Hisham manuscript seems to be well made.

[@RayhaanBhoola-tr3jc]

689 is in 1290 afaik, and in any case the Ottomans were a small city state in 1311, far from an empire and certainly far from having any real influence over the Islamic world.

[@catholicreconquista7456]

@@RayhaanBhoola-tr3jc Thanks for that correction.

[@FaridResponds]

Jay's claims that everything was made by this "palace scholars" is an unfounded conspiracy theory that doesn't even require debunking. He'd perhaps put some effort into proving his claims, but his fanbase eats it up, sadly.

[@Jaywalker45]

@@catholicreconquista7456 sahih bukhari in 1311 AD what are u smoking

[@catholicreconquista7456]

@@Jaywalker45 1311 AD was my calculation of 689 AH. The chap above corrected this to 1290 AD. This is the date that Farid said that the Bukhari manuscript was completed. You seem to have thought that the original Bukhari manuscript was being talked about.

[@sonofpaper5722]

Ain't no way that's the thumbnail lol

[@izharulhaqtruthrevealed1185]

Yesterday i asked him why je didn't respond to your question throughout the 1hr+ plus stream. But yet no response

[@Spreadingthetruth]

Is Farid a pilot in the thumbnail?

[@Onegod40-v4h]

❤

[@naeemulhoque1777]

7:23 this is the biggest clownery i've ever heard 🤡. I wish the non-muslims could understand how Jay Smith lying to them, and how gullible he thinks people are 🤣🤣🤣.

[@deezy6984]

If he did this with the Bible he’d be telling the truth… but he chooses to lie and do this with Islam lol