6 Guitars that are as good or better than my 1967 Martin D-28

[@davidmcdermott3625]

I bought a Huss and Dalton TOM with a baked red spruce top and sinker mahogany back and sides several years ago. When you strum a chord with it, you hear every note. An amazing guitar.

[@robbiefest]

I had a Huss and Dalton TDR Cocobolo. Is the best acoustic I've ever owned and played, BUT, I could NOT get used the width of the neck and the V profile. I've tried many vintage style guitars and only can really handle a standard Martin 1 11/16 type neck. Sold a Collings for the same reason. Would definitely consider a vintage D28.

[@DaveDiprose]

@@robbiefest a Martin D18 Authentic 1939 will do it for you then. They made them from 2015 - 2021.

[@garylantinen2819]

@@davidmcdermott3625 hard to compare a huss and Dalton to any factory made guitar

[@vrmn11]

I have a Larrivee OM-03 that I bought new in 2002. What a beautiful wonderful guitar. Not a D size guitar but for my purpose its perfect. I don't play out, I just sit on my porch or in my living room so its more comfortable. I have played several other Larrivee's and they have all been great guitars. For the money they are dang hard to beat.

[@tommysixstring5094]

100% - Larrivee is nigh on unbeatable

[@aliwhitwell]

I agree that Larrivee guitars are the hidden gem amongst high end guitars. All Larrivees are handmade from the best woods available. I have a 2004 D-05 which has mahogany back and sides and a spruce top. Sounds amazing. I recently bought a 2012 LV-03R which has Indian Rosewood back and sides and spruce top and is astounding. Sounds so balanced and truly amazing with bags of power and on close inspection the workmanship is second to none! If you haven't tried a Larrivee you really don't know what you are missing!

[@garylantinen2819]

Absolutely true on all counts I have 5 (and counting) another have a J-03 that is amazing....

[@davestagner]

I just got a new old stock 2007 Larivee L-09, and I’ve been A/B’ing it all week with my superb ‘68 D-18. The D-18 is louder and more aggressive (which is what I love about it - it WILL be heard in a jam), but the Larivee is smoother and much better balanced. Horses for courses, neither is a good replacement for the other. Workmanship on the Larivee is much better than the Martin! Just beautifully made. I think it’s the best construction quality of any of my guitars.

[@dwightlowes]

D28 2017 to present is amazing for the price💯

[@BPToneReview]

I have a Martin Custom Shop D28 w/VTS top. It’s jaw hopping amazing. Completely in love with that guitar.

[@HenryPipes]

Eastman E20D-TC. Handcrafted budget boutique with EIR b/s and a torrefied Adi top. I got one for $1300 and it sounds fuller than than my D-28. They are incredible guitars for the price. Nice video. I like hearing your old D-28!

[@TheGuitarsquatch]

I have the E2CD and it is phenomenal.

[@gammaraygem]

I was expecting that Eastman in the review. I got one last year, and love it. The shop had a couple of them, and I guess I got lucky, it stood out.The lightest touch still gives endless sustain, almost piano like bell sound.

[@scottworsham]

Late to the party here, but I'll concur that a Larrivee is pretty much unbeatable in the price range. Maple binding, maple heel cap, maple neck binding even. Jean has spent his life properly sourcing tonewoods from around the globe, then building them structurally perfected. JR is continuing the family tradition. If you find one with the alpine spruce top, prepare to be astounded. It's like a violin top. Unreal. (I am in no way affiliated -- just a huge fan.)

[@davidmckean955]

Larrivee guitars are incredible. Another incredible guitar is the Tacoma dreadnoughts and they often sell for $500 and they have a great punchy, woody character.

[@capohd28]

I agree with the reimagined series. I bought a 2018 D-41 that might be the finest sounding guitar I have ever played. When I went too look at it I was prepared to not like it due to the bling, but as soon as I played a few notes, I knew it was the one. Martin is now making instruments as good as any they have made with the reimagined series. They also look great too.

[@kamchuenso7836]

Same situation here….I cannot stand the bindings on the reimagined D41 so I finally decided to order an 2022 version 1937 authentic D28.

[@jackbart1960]

As a 2018 D28 owner I can't agree more. Such a awesome guitar!

[@bb38313]

Alvarez the best I've played in 55 yrs. sold my 1967 martin when I got my first Alverez in 1971

[@padrejohnruffle]

Nice to see a shout for Alvarez, which is what I play. A friend of mine did all the set-ups of the Yairis when they arrived in from Japan. about the same time-frame as yours.

[@lowellcalavera6045]

Ray Britt sweet. Very underrated guitars. I have a 1981 5036, signed by a Mr. Yamada in Japan. It's my second favorite!

[@johnmettler995]

My first acoustic guitar, Alvarez DY68 Yahri, 12 string. Amazing guitar. Still play it, bought in 1976.

[@thetruthisoutthere8598]

Alvarez can't be beat for the money

[@Travis_in_Florida]

Hmm 🤔 I don't know about Alvarez being anything special. But I only briefly played one and haven't seen or heard them much. So are they Japanese I take it from the previous comments. They do say that Japanese craftsman ship is really good, that I do know. I think I'd love to get my hands on one of those Japanese fake Gibson Acoustics or a fake Japanese Les Paul.

[@rogerlee440]

I recently bought a Martin D28 Modern Deluxe. One of the best sounding and easiest playing guitars I’ve owned or had the privilege to play

[@tinman8518]

Jeremy: It's interesting you put a Larrivee on the list. I have a 1988 Heritage HFT-445 built by the guys who stayed at the Kalamazoo Gibson factory when Gibson moved to Nashville. They only built acoustic guitars for a very few years. The bodies of these guitars, I'm told, were made by Jean Larrivee and shipped to Heritage Guitars for the neck and finish. Mine sounds incredible and actually outplays my Martin D-42! It's got an awesome tobacco sunburst on it. HFT=Heritage Flat Top. It's sides and back are mahogany and the bass rumbles my chest. Great video, I agree on all five, but I'll still pick your '67 Martin D-28. LOL

[@tulsaghost3837]

For some reason the Ytube guitar shows all forget about Guild. I managed to get a screaming deal on a New Hartford D50CE and I quit playing my 98 D-28. Later I found a 767/76-ish D25M, which I just traded for a Corona build D40 All the guilds are canons loud, balanced and responsive. The D50CE is darker, and the d$0 is light and bright. Even the import guilds are good( except the really inexpensive ones. The attention to detail, fit, finish and sound are topmntch.. ANd I sold the D28 with no regrets.

[@j.dragon651]

I been a Guild man forever when it comes to acoustics. I presently have a vintage D25. Bought it used. I really can't afford any of the guitars mentioned.

[@murraywagnon1841]

I have a '72 Guild G-312 It is an amazing 12 string.

[@voltaspeeder17]

To be honest, that D-28 of yours lights my soul on fire. WHAT A SOUND!! Just brilliant. It just got THAT magic in it which i absolutely love. Going to buy myself a baby like that one day :)

[@geneholdway8836]

Separate comment on a guitar that is separating itself from the pack. Played a new TD-M Huss & Dalton at Artisan a while back. Couldn't believe what I was hearing or the stunning quality of the workmanship. It was the best guitar I've had in my hands. I am placing an order for a slightly custom TD-M this weekend. These are GREAT guitars! Also a shout out to the staff at Artisan Guitars. Just great folks to work with!

[@richardsepulvado3049]

Collings D2N

[@geneholdway8836]

Sure can’t argue that. I have both an older D2H & a 2017 D1M. Love’em both. The TD-M was very strong on punch and nicely balanced. Great piece by H&D

[@alexthegr6608]

Guild D55E 2021. Just bought it. Lighter, more reactive top with an incredibly wide range that sounds wonderful from finger style to hard strumming folk. Amazing power and projection, but also clarity and definition.

[@SteelNGuitars926]

Right there with you! This guitar should be on any list for one of the best guitars on the market. I just bought a D55E 2023, burst top just an absolute stunner I will never get rid of this guitar. I feel it would hold its own to any guitar I don’t care the cost. So much projection on the base tones and the highs as well! I had to buy it!

[@zanzur1]

I have a seagull artist studio cw deluxe q2. It's spruce top rosewood back and sides maple neck and ebony fretboard and bridge all solid woods. Got it for less then 1000 bucks. A martin with these features would cost 5000 bucks+. Sounds great and feels great made in Canada. Nut width is 1.8 inch. love it and you cant beat that price.

[@markvonwisco7369]

I have a 2010 Larrivée D-09BZ. Just bought a used Recording King RDS-11-FE3 for dive bar jams and open mics. Larrivée guitars are very under appreciated. I bought my first one back in 2003. Larrivée seems to have quite the collection of tonewoods. One of best guitars I've ever played was a Huss & Dalton D-RH that a friend of mine used to own. Another one of those guitars that should never have been sold!

[@TorzJohnson]

I have an '18 D-28, it sounds beautiful. It's a lifetime guitar. I'm sure the $6000 - $8000 guitars sound even better, but I don't care.

[@matthewmcclure3181]

Then why are you even watching this video? Yes, there are a ton of fantastic guitars under $2k and many people will be happy with a guitar in this range for the rest of their lives. There are also people who recognize guitars in the range of his 67 Martin and some of the alternatives he's featuring are a significant step up for various reasons. Getting one of these will be their dream guitar and they'll also be content for the rest of their lives. Guess what, there are also 2-3 more tiers above the guitars in this video, so there are going to be some people watching this video who think the exact opposite of you. They're looking at the instruments in this video and thinking none of these are even remotely close to the quality or collectability of what they have or what they want... including the 67 Martin. These guitars aren't being sold in music stores, for the rare exception of a used guitar. Most of the guitars I'm talking about are custom made for an individual by boutique luthiers using extremely high end wood or higher valued vintage instruments (mostly pre-war). A majority of them sell in the $10-25k range but some climb up into 6 figures. What's the intent of your post? To "warn" less experienced players that as soon as they acquire a guitar comparable to a 2018 D-28 there's no need to consider anything better? To "educate" players who are more than likely fairly experienced and knowledgeable about the guitar market that it's foolish to shop in the $5k-$8K range because all they really need is a $2k guitar? Nobody should try and make someone feel inferior if they play a more modest guitar, and neither should anyone feel justified in alluding to someone being an elitist or guitar snob if they're fortunate enough to have something a bit higher end. That's great you've found a guitar that you think will keep you content for life, but the niche of buyers a video like this one are geared towards are on a different wave length than you.

[@nathanpartin7197]

@@matthewmcclure3181 on your period Matthew? It's just a KZbin comment you don't have to write a whole book.

[@RogerThat902]

Me: No, please don't tell everyone about Larrivees! Seriously though, I think they are arguably the best value brand. Very balanced sound that just sounds so nice. I say that as someone who owns and loves Martins. Lari's sit in that nice space where they don't have the broad name recognition of some of the other well known brands, so they have to just make a great guitar w/ a lot of features since they can't rely on the headstock to sell them to the masses. Fantastic brand.

[@angelg8445]

I have a P-09, and had a L-03, they are well made beautiful pieces of art. They play wonderfully too!

[@tinman8518]

Roger That Here's my comment to Jeremy about my "Larrivee" guitar. Jeremy: It's interesting you put a Larrivee on the list. I have a 1988 Heritage HFT-445 built by the guys who stayed at the Kalamazoo Gibson factory when Gibson moved to Nashville. They only built acoustic guitars for a very few years. The bodies of these guitars, I'm told, were made by Jean Larrivee and shipped to Heritage Guitars for the neck and finish. Mine sounds incredible and actually outplays my Martin D-42! It's got an awesome tobacco sunburst on it. HFT=Heritage Flat Top. It's sides and back are mahogany and the bass rumbles my chest. Great video, I agree on all five, but I'll still pick your '67 Martin D-28. LOL

[@RogerThat902]

@@angelg8445 I live in Atlanta and you just don't see Larrivees like you do other brands here. Don't think I've ever actually seen a new one, all preowned. I remember shopping for my first nice guitar and I had enough money to buy an entry ish Martin/Taylor etc, but not enough money to buy a, what I call a destination Martin (D-28s, 000s, etc.). The guy who owned the guitar shop I was shopping at said that if it were his money he'd choose either the Blueridge (I think) or Larrivee. I played the Blueridge and it was a fantastic guitar, but it didn't make me want to drop my dream of owning a name brand. I played the Larri and man, it was just such a beautiful guitar. It just felt so nice and sounded so great. It looked and felt like quality and at the time I think the price was around $1000. I was blown away. Unfortunately, I had my heart set on the name brand, so I reluctantly didn't get it. Long story short, that guitar haunted me for years and sparked my interest in that brand. I felt really silly to learn afterwards that Larrivee is definitely a name brand, it's just one of those, "If you know you know" type brands. My mistake! It's the brand I always recommend for people who have been playing a little bit and want to upgrade to a nice guitar that is just plain great value.

[@RogerThat902]

@@tinman8518 Ha, there is just something magical for me w/ Martins. It's a mental thing because as a kid I always told myself one day I'd own a Martin. That being said, if guitars were based purely on logic I'd probably choose the Larrivee. That's how fond I am of the brand. You compare a similarly priced Martin and a Larrivee taking away the headstock factor and I think most people are taking the Larrivee. It's that good of a brand factoring in value. That being said, guitars are not purely logical, so I'll keep my Martins hah :)

[@redlinemando]

@Roger That I couldn't agree more!!!! I had a D-60 a few yrs back & I traded it off. I was sick for a long while afterward!!!! It had a neck as good as a Cruz & action as low as they come. It was a very well balanced guitar as well. I bought it new & it was setup great from the factory. I have a few vintage Martins but I still miss that Larrivee now & then!!!!

[@mariodriessen9740]

Look my friend, my biggest dream for many years now is to own a good Martin D-28. To me that's the perfect sound for what I want to play. I don't have a Martin and even though I'm an old guy, I'm still very much a sucker for iconic brands and for the guitars that my heroes played, the guitars I saw in the hands of all these great artists on the posters on my bedroom walls when I was a kid and learned to play. And off course these were the guitars that we all grew up listening to, because they were on all the great albums of the sixties and seventies and (to a lesser extend) the eighties. I envisioned myself being on that stage and playing these instruments. I play the electric guitar and I have about 16 to 20 guitars, mostly Fenders and Gibsons, a handful of custom made guitars and a Gretsch. There are still electric guitars I'd love to have and guitars I'd kill for (as a matter of speech), but actually, I don't think I'll ever buy another electric unless strange things will happen that I can't forsee. I already have too much guitars. For 96% of the time I play one of the four best electrics I have. However, I'm a noob when it comes to acoustic guitars, but I love them. I can't think of anything else. I'm obsessed. I have four now. My first one was a Gibson J-45. Then I bought an Epiphone Dove Pro II, just to drag with me when I don't want to be careful with everything I do. My third acoustic was a freaking cheap Recording King something. I wanted to experiment with a small parlor sized guitar in Nashville tuning. Happy I did that. It spices up a recording and really, you don't need an expensive guitar to make it sound good. The last acoustic I bought was the then brand new Gibson G-45. I wanted a guitar that was good enough, but not too expensive, to tune down a major third permanently. Sounds amazing! But the quest had begun. I feel I need a Gibson J-200, but I definitely need a Martin D-28 (and a D-18 and a OOO-28 and the full mahony version and then some more, but I ABSOLUTELY MUST HAVE A D-28!!!), that is my dream. However, I've had another dream for at least 28 years now.... and that's to have a very good one of my favourite guitars, MADE IN 1967 (!!!) for no other reason than the simple fact that this is my year of birth. I once had the chance to buy an amazingly beautiful 1967 Fender Telecaster. It was the best sounding and lightest Telecaster I've ever played (and I've played a lot of Telecasters over the years, vintage and new). Unfortunately I couldn't afford it. Even though today you would pay at least 10 times the price they asked for it then. Vintage guitars was only just becoming a 'thing'. Anyway, to make an unnecessary long and boring story short, if I could pick any of those guitars you show in the video, I would without a doubt go for the 1967 Martin D-28. Absolutely! I don't even care if the others may sound a little better. The feeling it would give me to play an original '67 Martin D-28 just couldn't be beaten by any of the others. And that feeling is more important than the comfort of the guitar itself, or even the sound (by the way, your D-28 sound amazing and precisely the way I want a perfect acoustic guitar to sound). You're a lucky man, Jeremy! 😊

[@gregmccurry5619]

I fell the same way an iconic guitar

[@DaveDiprose]

The Martin D18 Authentic 1937 - I bought one second hand and am totally happy with it. It cannot be compared to a EiR D28 at all, it is so much better dynamically and it loves a mic.It's the 5th '28 I've had in 40 years and it's a keeper - it is so good.

[@mjt5576]

In addition to sounding great, your '67 has soul, vibe and mojo that those other guitars don't.

[@robertfreeman1941]

Always wanted a real D-28 and so glad I watched this video. Now I still want a real D-28 and I think the new ones are the go. Thanks Jeremy!

[@tomswadley5431]

I just played the 1937 Authentic a few days ago. Absolutely the best new Martin I’ve ever played. A killer guitar.

[@JeremySheppard]

Let's both get one!

[@tomswadley5431]

Jeremy Sheppard I wish. It was $6,999. But I have a really good 1977 D-28 that sounds great.

[@adamwhite2329]

I just scored a D-28 A37 (2015, first year w/VTS) for $4800 off Guitar Center's used section, so the deals are out there. It's an unparalleled instrument. Just incredible.

[@stevelacombe5291]

The Martin D-28 Reimagined is hard to beat for the price. An excellent workhorse guitar to take just about anywhere.

[@jeffanderson8384]

Some older Guilds ('70's USA made) can hold their own against some comparable Martins from the same era. I have a D-50 that is a solid contender. On a side note - one thing I have always had trouble with was the fear in owning a VERY expensive guitar and not wanting to see it get damaged (either by climate or carelessness). This means it typically always stays in the case, where-as my cheap beater that spends most of it's time out of the case on a stand gets a lot more playing time.

[@Jameswilliam1982]

New American Guilds hold their own with Martins all day

[@howtheheliru]

I agree with Jeff on the Guild D50. That was my work cannon, and never let me down. Got that guitar in 1975. They were still being made in RI.

[@JackPeters-g5z]

It is Guild no big secret

[@geneholdway8836]

Jeremy - as usual, a great summary and I'm always amazed at how close our tastes in guitars is. Scares Me! Couple of notes that you may find of interest. Through saddles - I love'em and they are not as hard to work on as we think on Martins (can't speak to the other makers) - When Martin re-introduced these into various models such as the Authetic and Vintage series, they actually went to a "drop-in through saddle" design. No more trouble for a good luthier than any other drop-in saddle. They look great, sound great, and lift right out and another can be dropped right in. 2nd, still on through saddles - Collings Traditional Series are standard with through saddles, the regular D series is standard with regular length saddle. Long Saddle is an option on the standard D series for them. On a sadder note, I have also learned that Collings will be discontinuing their handmade cases. That will be a loss. Get one while you can!

[@azcharlie2009]

I have a 1994 HD28. I play it very little because I have so many other "value" guitars that sound pretty good. But, every time I pull it out, I'm amazed how wonderful it sounds.

[@daveboydmusic744]

Play the Martin. Use the good silverware. Dance in the rain ... yada, yada, yada

[@matthewskipper2732]

1" 3/4 was the standard until around 1939 (there were transition guitars, of course), and is the "standard" again with the reimagined standard series

[@PaulJohnson-jq9xw]

Huss and Daltons are amazing. I used to go to famous acoustic shop that had hundreds of high end guitars and I would play many of them often and the Huss and Daltons were often the best in the store.

[@frankbowman230]

Few months back I purchased a H&D JAS and put 5 high end Martins back in their cases. Hands down the best guitar I own.

[@alan4sure]

Molly Tuttle used to always play Huss and Dalton. Then she got a Prewar guitar and played it mostly. Then she got a Preston Thompson, that's her go-to guitar now.

[@waynzwhirled6181]

These are some great guitars. The only one I would consider buying is the Larrivee. Or, for about the same price as the Larrivee, or even less, I can get a Yamaha or Alvarez that sounds as good as anything you presented in this video.

[@briandesjardins728]

I just recently played my first larivee 0m03 mahogany about two years ago. Since then I sold 3 Martin's and 2 Taylor's and now own a Larivee 0m03,0m40r,omv-10 custom moon spruce and walnut back and sides. They seriously are the absolute best acoustics you can buy imo, sound for sound and feel for feel, fit and finishes around the 2000 and up mark. Used ones can be had at about 1k. GET ON TO LARIVEE!! They truly are amazing, the parlor series are absolutely amazing with moon spruce and walnut (my next purchase) lol His wife does some crazy custom inlays too. Best part is they sell all replacement parts stupid cheap tuners,bridges,pins nuts cases etc. And will also make any of their custom fret board and headstock to install on any of their guitars you own.

[@ronmiller7248]

You forgot about the quality of larivee. I've owned 2 and the build quality is amazing

[@chrisholland350]

I have a D40R and it's absolutely fantastic. Tonally it falls somewhere between a bassy Martin and a shiny taylor. It's important to note these Larrivees are part of their Legacy 40 series and have a different bracing pattern more similar to Martin's than the typical Larrivee bracing. It certainly is much more boomy than normal Larrivee's while still maintaining string to string clarity that Martin's sometime lack. It amazes me each time I pick it up and the top has slowly started to get that beautiful aged look.

[@morganadriel9720]

I know Im randomly asking but does any of you know of a way to get back into an instagram account?? I was stupid lost the account password. I appreciate any tips you can give me!

[@mohamedcristian8972]

@Morgan Adriel Instablaster =)

[@morganadriel9720]

@Mohamed Cristian I really appreciate your reply. I got to the site through google and I'm waiting for the hacking stuff atm. I see it takes a while so I will reply here later with my results.

[@morganadriel9720]

@Mohamed Cristian It did the trick and I finally got access to my account again. I'm so happy:D Thank you so much you really help me out !

[@mohamedcristian8972]

@Morgan Adriel you are welcome :D

[@LAboomR]

I wouldn’t call you a nerd. You have enthusiasm. We all do. Your a scholar W/ a love and dedication to his area of study. We all appreciate it too.

[@andrewbowen8122]

That Martin sounds awesome. I’ve heard so many good things about the Boucher guitars.

[@coldisle]

I’m 70 and have had my fair share of high end Guilds, Martins and a Collings. The guitar that just completely gets it done for me (I’ve had 3 and will never sell one again) is my 1993 Taylor 510. It is a remarkable dread and hard to put down. Just my opinion but the earlier 510’s with the 1&11/16ths nut (right up until maybe 2004 I think)are just an incredible value at usually $1000-1500. And they seem to be consistently great. Thanks for a great review.

[@terryjohinke8065]

Pity the D-28 went to 1 3/4 " nut. After playing for 51 tears i got a good guitar with that nut width and gave it to my son. You gotta remember there's a lot of guys /gals out there used to the narrower nut/ fingerboard. I hate the move to 1 3/4 " I prefer 11/16" as that's what I've played for 50 years. but if the younger player grow up on that - Oh Well. Most classical guitars are 2" .

[@sc12100]

Santa Cruz D/PW is a great guitar as well.

[@kenschachsieck1357]

Got one, and really light build, mine is very resonant, sustains for days!!

[@sc12100]

@@kenschachsieck1357 Yep - I owned one years ago and sold it due to tight finances. Wish I could buy that same one back. Great sustain and overtones. I have a two year old HD28 which I love as well but the Santa Cruz is a superior build.

[@philipwatson3541]

Well, I own and love playing my 2015 D-28. It plays fantastic and I hate that you find them so boring, but i still love mine.

[@tgh223]

trying to compare a yamaha to a martin is like comparing shit to ice cream yamaha ok for the price put it against my d42 martin u will take it back to the store

[@TheGuitarsquatch]

@@tgh223 This man didn't even say anything about Yamaha.

[@tgh223]

@@TheGuitarsquatch i didnt say he did i was agreeing with him about playing martins i own 2 a d 28 and d 42 i love them both pay attention

[@TheGuitarsquatch]

@@tgh223 You were trash talking Yamaha when Yamaha had nothing to do with anything.

[@tgh223]

@@TheGuitarsquatch are u talking to yourself u missed the whole other conversation the other guy was stating he had owned all types of guitars and his Yamaha was good has a d 28 thats when the gentleman said he hated he found a d 28 so boring because he loved his so now not that it is any of your business but I have owned a yamaha fg 160 180 a 365 s and a 730 s and still have and a Martin d18 d28 d42 and like I said trying to compare a yamaha to a Martin is like comparing shit to ice cream

[@andrewbootsdekemper3410]

Every video you make seems to get better. Great stuff I’ll have to share some of my guitar finds sometime.

[@stevenwalker2568]

I have a L-15A Yamaha and it's got the power and the best tone I've ever heard, it was my choice I could have had a D-28 it was $950.00 in 1979 its still impressive, I've also played the LL-16 and it's awesome for $1,000 also have heard the recording-king it's a great guitar there's better deals than the Martin I've play some that sounded awful!!

[@keithskelton5596]

LL 16 Is a great option Amazing value 3 years in No regrets My Martin 00028 EC on the other hand needs a binding refit!! Durability issue on the Martin No issue with the LL 16 Which is played every day ✌🏼

[@jdstan9650]

Nothing from Santa Cruz? 1934 D? Please...

[@songsfromspringcreekave821]

I have a 1990's Guild D52NT. Basically Guilds "D28". While I wouldn't say that all Guilds are as good as mine, because they can be a bit inconsistent. I will say that the one that I have is better than every D28 I have ever played, new or vintage. I paid $1,100 for it 7 years ago. It is lush sounding, built with beautiful wood selections, and very well made. Martins are great, no doubt. But there are plenty of other brands that make as good or better, and many for a fraction of the price. Of course, these opinions are mine. The sound quality and feel of a guitar is a very personal thing.

[@Zepfan321]

Every guild i've ever picked up I was blown away by

[@CFMD28]

I enjoy your videos. I played a 1937 Martin at a Martin event. Instant love! Without a doubt, the best flat top I ever played. Second best was a Guild D-55. I’m a Martin guy, so the 1937 is my dream guitar.

[@bradh.689]

You really should've included the Bourgeois Aged Tone Vintage Deluxe D on this list! I have a 2019 one with torrefied Adirondack Banjo Killer bracing and it'll hang with any acoustic guitar I've ever played. I have a 2018 Reimagined D41 and it's nowhere close to the Bourgeois. I played the '37 D-28 AA at NAMM a couple of years ago and I'll say my Bourgeois will hang with it too but includes an adjustable truss rod and a neck that doesn't feel like a piece of firewood in your hand.

[@JeremySheppard]

I certainly should have!

[@alan4sure]

Sounds like you've never handled firewood and lit a campfire then.

[@dcmitchell8008]

I just bought a new Martin D-28, and I'm thrilled.

[@robert_sovitsky]

I enjoyed your comparison but not as much as your playing which was absolutely beautiful !!! The feeling in your playing is amazing !!!

[@geoffreycarter3981]

I’d throw the Martin “Vintage” series in there too. I have a 2002 HD28V and I swear it’s on another level. It’s a pre million serial so it has wood from Martins old library of wood. Really special and I’m sure it would compare with this ‘67

[@no1fibersplicer525]

I love my 2005 D41. Got it new for 3000$. But to be truthful my 97 hummingbird is still my favorite. To me it sounds every bit as good as my Martin. Just that the Martin is 4 times as loud. (No pickup on either) I had an 04 DM for a while and I felt like for the money I paid 600$, it was my Best Buy. Thanks for all you do

[@no1fibersplicer525]

I also have a ‘37 Gibson L00. Sounds like crap 😂 but it’s a cool piece!

[@JeremySheppard]

Haha. That's true.

[@livefromgregsgarage7335]

I have two Larrivee's...an SD-40R and an OM-03. I'm also picking up a D-03E soon. Amazing guitars. You should also throw in the Breedlove American D/SR...I have that one and it's probably my favorite.

[@lhvent]

I love my Martin DX1RAE and it sounds and plays great as does my Yamaha FG830. Not the quality of the D-28 but incredible sound and value for money. One day I will upgrade if my ship comes in.

[@glorioskiola]

Larry Harris I bought a Yamaha FG830 a few months ago, and love it. Happy playing! When I win the lottery . . .

[@imannonymous7707]

Ya its got its ups and downs , owning an investment grade insturment i mean . The prices never used to be so crazy, kinda sad

[@edmurphy671]

@@imannonymous7707 Absolutely! I have a 1981 Martin D42 that someone knocked off its stand on stage and then he stepped on it. It cost me $500 to have it fixed and now I'm afraid to take it anywhere. Would love to have a Clapton or Mayer OM but same issue there. I have actually reconciled myself to finding $1000 guitars with great electronics that I use to play out with. Bought this thing called an Orangewood Ava with Torrified Spruce top and LR Baggs Anthem pickup and I'm surprisingly satisfied with it. It plays well, sounds good, and best of all if something happens to it I wont lose it like I did when my D42 went down.

[@Moonshot568]

I’m in love with my Martin D41 2018 (5000$) .... sound and looks like a dream . Vintage guitars are over rated .......

[@dlm504]

Jeremy I just purchased a Sweetwater limited version of the had 28 style for $2200 and it is just a awsome D28 style that’s only one year old . The neck is wonderful.

[@AdamWillisWilkesMusic]

I have a Blueridge BR-1MS and absolutely love playing it over all my guitars.

[@chrisgabriel9497]

Anything from Bourgeois is 👌👌👌 primo. Of course you couldn’t list all the great brands. And they are pricey. But.... IMHO those are the best guitars being made today for the money. Honestly I wish I could own 1 of everything.

[@charlesbartholomew2910]

I agree Chris. I love my Country Boy. It is one sweet sounding guitar. I play it more than my HD-28.

[@thecamperguy1234]

I heard that Tyler Childers in the beginning. Good Stuff!

[@marklong3610]

Jeremy... How about demoing an Eastman guitar or two.. one with rosewood and one mahogany.

[@davestagner]

I have a ‘68 Martin D-18 that is something of a reference guitar for me. It’s brash, it’s aggressive. Loud and unsubtle, but astounding in jams where power trumps elegance. That said, very few “pretty” sounding guitars can match it. I also have an ‘85 Mossman that I prefer to any D-28 (or D-28 style) I’ve ever played. It’s warmer and rounder than the D-18, of course. If I’m playing by myself and immersing in pure tone, it’s my first choice. It doesn’t have the aggressive power of the D-18, though. It’s still a big bluegrass guitar, but a subtle one. I just got a new old stock 40th anniversary Larivee L-09 that is really good now, but I think may be the best of them all when it’s had a few years to break in. It’s much better balanced than either of the dreadnoughts, and it’s very responsive - it’s a guitar you don’t have to think about when you play, if that makes any sense.

[@jeffbaker2376]

I would go for the Thompson, as I have Martins & Santa Cruz guitars. That said, there are no slouches in these 6.

[@surfrunnerd8457]

I have 2 Martin Sigma DR-7's and they are simply wonderful.

[@jimzartman]

I have a 67 D-28 that my dad bought new for $400. When I was 18 I bought new (97) Larrivee D-03 and I love it just as much. It's given me more songs and it's been everywhere. I'd probably get rid of the Martin before I would that Larrivee. (for an old 0-15 maybe)

[@dionst.michael1482]

Omg, the color of that old Martin is absolutely GORGEOUS. Man has it ever aged nicely. One of the nicest looking classics I think I've EVER seen.

[@johnm3152]

Smooth "nut" edit ;) Great, entertaining channel - always learn something new - thanks !

[@johnfrederick6164]

The authentic are super great played one at guitar center it was amazing

[@adamkoepke1366]

Just received my Collings D2H a couple weeks back. This thing is a canon and puts notes out quick and loud, while still being very articulate

[@magicdaveable]

You appear to believe that Martins rediculously priced guitars are the only choices. $5000+ price tags are stupidly expensive. I will stick with my Alvarez Yairi DY84C. I bought it used for a grand. Plays better than any Martin and has tone that touches your soul. There are many other brands as well. The "Martin Mystique" went out the window when other luthiers began building instruments than Martin. You mentioned one that offers affordable guitars. Larrivee makes fine guitars as does Taylor. I will say that when I bought my 800 series Taylors they weren't stupidly expensive. I don't play them much anymore. Both are up in the $5000 range now. Not bad for guitars I bought in the mid-1990's for about $3200 for both of them. I now gig with my Alvarez Yairi because it plays like a dream and has excellent tone. Some day I may sell my Taylors and my Martin D28 Herringbone but currently they are not for sale.

[@JunkWoodProjectswithJacob]

Martin Hd28’s also sound amazing and play great!

[@mikgui]

I play a Larrivee LV-03 and LV-09 live and in the studio. Just amazing guitars.

[@JeremySheppard]

So so good! I had an OM-09 that I regret selling.

[@mikgui]

@@JeremySheppard The LV-03 is my #1. Mahogany sides and back with an LR Baggs Element system

[@JeremySheppard]

What a thing! I'm sure.

[@mikgui]

Thanks for posting the vid!

[@mr.drewpaintswithyou9034]

From what I’ve experienced, I’d go with the Collings. That would be amazing to get one for around $3,500 like you mentioned for the used price. Thanks for the info. 👍

[@tombarclay7108]

Definitely the Collings. Like Martins, they have their own unique sound, but unlike Martins, the quality hasn't gone downhill over the years. Collings are excellent top quality instruments.

[@gabeah]

I bought a D2H Adirondack Torrified a few weeks ago, shopped around, I think here in 2021, these or well over $4K used, more like $4500 +

[@russellharris5072]

I played a D-28 copy for 30+ years,but when serious money came my way I went for the Martin HJ28 and 23 years later I still have it.............Tone to die for...........................

[@mikedkc]

Yep. I would agree, the reimagined D28 is apparently the best value from my perspective. Thanks for the research and thoughtful report.

[@jjallyn3151]

I have a 1971 D-35 that bought when I graduated high school Have loved it for 50+ years Nothing sounds like a Martin I’m about to buy a 000-28 because the D-35 is too big for sitting around armchair playing Thanks for the video

[@ex-subsailor3480]

I'm just an old beginner so these guitars, although beautiful, are way out of my price range. If they are not OOR for you... then you are blessed. Thanks for the video.

[@sivadyert]

Thanks for this very useful report/review!

[@brooklynboy1000]

I have a Larrivee D40M select. Awesome guitar. Not the loudest but very beautiful tone. They used to be made here in Vancouver so they had good popularity here in Canada, and a lot of the price wasn’t going to exchange rate differences and shipping etc. Now they moved to California. Maybe for cheaper labour costs don’t know. Still great

[@johnmcrae3221]

Jeremy! I really like this kind of video. I have a Martin like yours now and love it, except it is mahogany instead of rosewood. If I did not have it, I would look at the H&D or Larrivee. Great indeed. THE ACOUSTIC SHOP did reviews of craft guitars recently. They included the Martin, but I will not agree that it is a craft guitar. Buy they included Smith. Caleb Smith is with Balsam Range as their guitarist. Super guy who makes wonderful guitars. And Henderson too!!! But I bet you know all this.

[@redlinemando]

Sure, there's always going to be a guitar out there somewhere that you perceive to be better than the one you currently own. Many times we get used to the sound of our own guitars & don't realize what others hear when we play them. That's what caused me to "stupidly" sell my 46 D-18 & I've been hunting for an equivalent ever since. I'm sorry to tell you cause I know you want to sell it, but that 67 suits you better than any guitar I've heard you play so far. I'd be truthful if I'd heard one better. It's clean, clear, it's deep & yet it's bright. When you play it, it's one of the most balanced guitars I've ever heard. The funny thing I'm noticing is..............it's exponentially getting better & opening up more with every video you make about it. "Better" in the guitar world is an opinion & very much up to the "ear" of the beholder. Those authentics are WAY overpriced & when it comes down to it they are still new guitars. You can bake wood all you want to & it's still not going to make it any older. It'll change the sound yes, but it won't add yrs on.

[@redlinemando]

@Eric Porter My 2006 KM-1500 mandolin supposedly came with an old growth adi top as well, but I wasn't there when the tree was cut & I didn't follow it out of the woods to the factory. The mandolin was dated in 2006 & that's probably when the saw hit the wood. From that point on, it became a new entity. A lot of ppl will pay more money for something that is "old growth" or "torrefied" or "distressed" or whatever the latest hype is. Hype usually doesn't mean anything except bells on the cash register. I will say the torrefication process seems to be an exception to the rule because I've seen & heard the difference it makes. That being said, the wood is still new to vibration & takes time to adjust. Old is weathered, broken in & had 20 yrs of musical frequencies played through it. If you build an instrument out of wood that was harvested 100 yrs ago, it will still sound like a new instrument when it is built & strung up. It might produce the frequencies that are more desirable, but it will have to be played in, just like any other instrument. It might not take as long to play it in, but it will never get any better if it stays in the case & never experiences any vibration. BTW Eastman makes some great instruments for the money. I've played quite a few.

[@tgh223]

ive got a d42 been set up by dan bloom sounds amplified plays like a electric deep tones never heard anything like it also have 1974 d28 martin nice but dont come close to d 42

[@swillis3987]

You have excellent taste in guitars Jeremy! Martin’s are great guitars. I own two. However, i also own two Master Grade Boucher’s which are superior.

[@homerwinslow9047]

A very reasonably priced Boutique style guitar is Goodall. Handcrafted in Fort Bragg California by James and his son. They sound great and can’t be beat

[@JeremySheppard]

I had one that was made in Hawaii.

[@patrickroe3260]

At a certain point, how good a given guitar is a matter of human opinion. Even by how a guitar sounds or especially by how a guitar sounds, how good it is, is really a matter human opinion.

[@garylantinen2819]

The guitars Jean Larrivee is building are far and away the best value out there amazing craftsmanship top notch materials and sound beautiful.

[@Travis_in_Florida]

Fun fact: at the end of the tour of Martin factory in Eastern Pennsylvania you get the sound hole cutout. It smells amazing.

[@mrjasondylan]

Well at least it's free

[@Baci302]

That Martin D-28 sounds great.

[@niguel4438]

Delighted to hear you mention Huss & Dalton. In 2005 I bought a 1994 OM Custom from The Guitar Store in DC (sadly now closed. It was run by a truly eccentric guy) when I was on business there from the UK. It is beautiful and made from a rare Sapele back and sides (only 3 made wit the wood). Plays like a dream. I wouldn't part with it. I hope to visit the factory one day soon. Great video, thanks.

[@stephenhanson3647]

I bought a Huss and Dalton 00-SP in Australian Blackwood from Steve at that store (actually named the Guitar Shop). Steve was an interesting character. Told me that Paul Simon bought a twin of my guitar for Edie Brickell. Didn't believe him. He was right. The 00-SP nearly brought me to tears when I played it. Beautiful sound from such a small guitar.

[@niguel4438]

Stephen Hanson he dropped the Paul S name to me too but not in that context. I think he played in his band at one point. I’ll never forget that old safe where kept all the H&D’’s in that unique scruffy store.

[@johnmyers5315]

So sad to hear Steve closed the Guitar Shop. My favorite destination when i was in DC, a 2nd floor walkup museum from the 1920s if i recall correctly. Steve was a fountain of knowledge and first mentioned H&D when they first started up (he didn't have any H&D guitars yet).

[@niguel4438]

@@johnmyers5315 I spent a lot of time talking to him. As you say very knowledgeable and wonderfully unique. He asked me what I was looking for “a Gibson Acoustic” says I”. Good god you don’t want one of those, come and have a look as these H&D’s”. Fond memories.

[@gerald1045]

Some of us don't have a money tree like you. I thought you were about to present us with cheaper alternatives to the Martin; but just as good. Dream on!

[@JeremySheppard]

I don't have a money tree either, haha. I only owned one of the 7 guitars I talked about. These are prestige/aspirational guitars. I made another video called "what makes a good acoustic guitar" that will be great for you. It's much more realistically priced guitars for everyone. kzbin.info/www/bejne/o5m9dGh6ppJ4pac

[@johnedillinger]

Why does everyone leave out Blueridge?! They are awesome! Blueridge BR 160 both the Beauty and the Beast!

[@JeremySheppard]

I love blue ridge but they don't offer anything in the obscene price range, these were all around $6500

[@johnnyd63]

New HD28 owner here.Just beautiful and tone shimmers. Next to my Taylor 914CE the Martin has a nicer tone.2 different guitars, both great but acoustic tone alone Martin just rises to the top.

[@michaelwebster8389]

I'd love to have a D2H, but they're probably over $8000 here in Australia. The Boucher's are much cheaper to buy from Canada or the US, and they're astonishingly good.

[@josephmullinsii8461]

I drive through Staunton all the time, one day I want to stop at Huss and Dalton! I'm kinda cursed tho I'm a lefty, so many amazing guitar out there that are not made left handed :(

[@paullarnce2167]

For the prices you quote we may as well head for the pawn shops and estate sales.

[@davidaylsworth8964]

Okay, this is a nice line up and there are quite a few very nice instruments. For my precious few luxury dollars I would take the modern D-28. I’m running down the last chapters in my playbook so legacy is a consideration. For my money the CF Martin name on the headstock will make it a real winner.

[@tyrssen1]

My old friend the late, great Joe Dabbs bought a new Martin D35S in 1970, a wonderful guitar that he had 'til the day he died - a couple years ago. Wish we could have jammed with his Martin and my FG800. I think it would be a good sound. RIP old chum.

[@paulssounds7129]

Martin D18 2012 onwards is still the best acoustic out there in my humble opinion

[@tacratt6091]

A lot of fine guitars you mentioned, none I would trade a Brazilian D28 for! Put a set of Waverly tuners on the D28, it will lighten the peg head by 4-5 ounces. You would like the results!!

[@BigTandDaBoys]

Thibodaux in the house! I never would have thought I would hear that while watching.

[@JeremySheppard]

I love South Louisiana so much.

[@BigTandDaBoys]

@@JeremySheppard Much love bro!

[@paullewis1637]

Plenty to say, but let’s hear them.

[@rajasik]

Every 'Astounding' = 1 Tequila Shot

[@larrygreen8912]

I’m sooooosoooo dwunke

[@f5mando]

sheramb arrb nnn....

[@tyrssen1]

I know my Yamaha FG800 isn't technically in the same league, at $200.00, but I wouldn't feel under-gunned in the company of Martins. Quality, sound, etc. is top notch.

[@davidlackey4873]

put the right strings on fg and it'll thump like gibson j-45

[@podfuk]

Yamaha made some incredible acoustic, especialy old Red Label FGs are legendary, but some FG800 sounds fantastic too for price asked. They have new Red Label line FG5/FGX5 and FS5/FSX5, incredible sounding guitars handmade in Hamamatsu Japan price is around $1500.

[@cody8804]

Idk I own a “Ventura” (company in the 70s that mimicked Martins as close as possible for budget prices) guitar that I bought on a whim in a pawn shop for $70 bc it played and sounded great (it does) but when put up against really high end acoustics there are undeniable differences. Is better quality worth $1000s more? Idk personally I’d say no but there IS a difference in quality

[@paulkline3011]

A guy at my local music store in Madison,WI had me do a blind guitar test between a Yamaha FG800 and a Martin D28. I went home with the FG800. I do have a Martin D15M which I love but I also love my FG800. I would have easily payed $1000 if I didn't know about the guitar before hand.

[@R.L.Humpert]

Nothing against yamaha and I have this exact guitar. Was my first one. There is no way in the world it sounds even close to a Martin that’s higher end. My HD28 just blows it away and it should for a 2800 difference in price.

[@imannonymous7707]

You make many great points , but one that really does ring true is the point you make about playing great guitars out. To gigs , partys , etc. These fantastic insturments that inspire us to play and make us sound amazing are a liabilty of sorts to enjoy. 8000 dollars is alot of money to lose. Its a constant responsibility that nags at your head everytime you bump it , let somebody play it and or leave it unattended to for even a minute. Kind of a buzzkill. Lol ,i should add id love to own any of the guitars you mentioned