Right to deny Shamima Begum UK citizenship? Feat. Imarn Ayton & Kulveer Ranger | Storm Huntley

Shamima Begum has lost her latest appeal after being stripped of her citizenship by the Home Office.
Judges said she made a 'calculated' decision to join ISIS and was arguably an 'author of her own demise'.
Jeremy Vine on 5 is on television every weekday at 9:15am until 1:30pm on Channel 5.
Subscribe to the channel for more celebrity interviews, hot topics and debates: bit.ly/34DvAv4
Twitter: / jeremyvineon5
Facebook: / jeremyvineon5
Instagram: / jeremyvineon5
#stormhuntley #shamima #citizenship

[@zvikaso]

Do not allow her back !!!

[@kathleen5237]

I agree she could be a danger to our national security. Her life could also be in danger if she came back here. In one interview a few years' ago I remember her being asked about the bins with heads of people who had be beheaded in which she looked apathetic and said it meant nothing to her. She was used to the murders. That is disturbing to me. I think she should stay away. But who will want her?

[@coolcat3452]

Scary though!!…she even might have killed people too; she is a danger & if given the opportunity again will do it!!!😢😢😢😢

[@johannemontreuil8980]

Who will want her ?... country where there is ISIS. There are no countries that can risk the security of their people

[@Channel66678]

Who cares. She did the crimes so she can pay for it. She's definitely not rehabilitated, she's just trying to get out of the camp. She doesn't even believe that the British government should prosecute her on arrival - another Interview I have seen

[@yulo6376]

Now she can apply for asylum seeker in Europe… Germany is likely to take her😂

[@lunarose7234]

She wasnt stupid she knew she was doing wrong...that's why she kept it a secret to leave. She should never be allowed to return.

[@naomicairns8427]

I guess the teenage victims of grooming gangs knew what they were doing too.

[@yorewhyworry7217]

So let's not pretend to care about children being groomed. I will not be returning to child protection.

[@stanbily9416]

Only an anglophobe would want her back.

[@Travelocs]

At 15?

[@Travelocs]

​@naomicairns8427 that's what am saying ppl are using emotions instead of logic

[@niallmurray8654]

She should be kept out of the UK.

[@yulo6376]

She can apply for Asylum seeker in any European countries and get let say a German passport and come back to the UK😂 too many loopholes in EU.

[@MelaniaRose]

@@yulo6376 She could try but she’s a huge liability and risk.

[@theaaronlennon]

Honestly I cannot tell if you are referring to Imarn or Shamima....

[@danielkershaw5998]

Imarn, I was 15 when 9/11 happened….i didn’t pick up and go to Afghanistan. We’re all accountable for our actions. You believe in the rules based global order or not.

[@abi2270]

Good decision UK. Living in a Western country is a privilege...the sooner people like her understand this, the better.

[@danielkershaw5998]

“It looked fun, it looked exciting “ ….the live beheading and burning of people alive in cages…… Give me a break caller number 1

[@user-rv1wf6sd4p]

..ye,looks 'fun' to a.sociapathic psychotic person..with tendencies to murder

[@rickyred001]

Begum needs to stay where she is, it gives a warning to immigrant families wanting to take the piss out of our laws. It doesnt matter that she was 15 when she decided to go join IS, she needs to learn and others need to look at her and think on if they wish to get up to something... AND SHE WAS NOT GROOMED NO MATTER WHAT THE FOOL ON THE PANEL SAID

[@samanthabarry5817]

She’ll appeal time and time to challenge the decision

[@rickyred001]

@@samanthabarry5817but she won't succeed, and theres only a very limited number of times that she can appeal, in fact i do believe now that shes exhausted those channels, no one gets to appeal over and over and over again

[@naomicairns8427]

I guess the teenage “victims” of grooming gangs weren’t groomed either. Furthermore, why would she be Syrias problem? She’s more of an immigrant in Syria… she’s British unless your understanding of British is…. White?

[@conradblack779]

Victims of grooming gangs don’t travel to foreign countries to join terrorist organisations that are at war with their own country and commit acts of terrorism for years and then say they have no regrets about what they did you absolute 🤡. To try to equate what Begum did to girls being sexually assaulted it’s amongst the dumbest things I have ever heard in my life. She’s Syria’s problem as they allowed her to enter their country as a minor and then stay there for years. I suppose Bangladesh are also racist? she was technically a citizen of their country until 21 years old by law due to her parents being born there yet they didn’t allow her into the country either.

[@junelucas4716]

I agree with dat calmer a child is a child an some do all manner of ting how can treat a child like a adult I also felt as a black person it's pretty a low dodge they r doing dis case is judged on a false sense it make no sense giant men make more serious tings an u judge a child an has gone tru a lot of tings she didn't even plan for or fully understand it's sad

[@theinngu5560]

The woman who feels sorry for her would need to take responsibility if she came back and committed any sort of crime here

[@lawnkevin1959]

She knows what she is doing she made her choice

[@mrswindymiller]

As I understand it she can still appeal, at her age she knew the rights and wrongs of what she did.

[@ackers6969]

she going to be coming back !! if your nicked for a crime found found guilty you cant keep going to court intill your innocent !! so how she keep going back to court shes been to the supreme court already enough is enough stop wasteing the tax payers money!!

[@user-in2ws6wd5s]

Well-done Andrew the person who was there himself getting talked down to by a women who's hell bent on making it about race

[@intunewithcars9484]

yes that racist feminist witch is very unhinged

[@danking8379]

If you train a dog to attack people do you let it out on the street ?

[@jamesdaniels763]

lmao Ghina its nothing to do with race. another person who like to bring up race when it has absolutely nothing to do with race. Stop playing the race cards

[@ernestschroeder9762]

Bangladesh, a muslim country, doesn't want her...

[@ioanamaria309]

Relevant, isn t It!?

[@missbegum7610]

This is about citizenship! Her home is here, her education is here, her grooming happened here! Adults grooming her happened here and not just in internet.

[@MelaniaRose]

@@missbegum7610End of the day she was a terrorist sympathiser. There’s plenty of Islamic countries she can settle in.. she’s deemed a national security threat.

[@ernestschroeder9762]

@@missbegum7610 you seem to know a lot about her. What about some groomers names?

[@cvbposhd2789]

​@@missbegum7610just like 6 year old Aiuysha when she got married to an old man 😢😢😢

[@29evolution]

The ideology behind her action is the real problem.

[@williamsafari6437]

the JUDGE said it was right to leave her in the desert. dont waste people's time with your futile phone calls

[@jewellive2819]

People believe her? She should not be bought back . Others who may want to leave England and do the same, need to see what happens when you choose wrongly.

[@nicksherreard1215]

If Scarlett Jenkinson can be criminally responsible at 15 then so can Shamima Begum

[@mickrap6001]

If you are a ten year old you commit murder you go to prison, so leave her where she is in her own prison of her own making.

[@arimdu1408]

No you don't not at 10 years old

[@conorwhite2066]

It's not about her age, it's not about her history.. the assessment was she is STILL a risk/threat Warning to parents.. monitor your kids.. warning to people who defect to the enemy.. you are not welcome back

[@sazikazimabuza1951]

Please keep Imarn away from these talks she’s awful… always wanting to be different and overplays the race card. I think she hates Britain. Look how she wants Harry and Meghan to come back. Now Begum. Plus she’s rude

[@edmondsilorio1922]

She is a threat to UK in the future. It's a BIG NO for me.

[@stanbily9416]

18:01 - So, she did not have the mental capacity to know what she was getting into, Imarn? The delusion… 🤦🏽‍♂️

[@agoraphobicsocialite6897]

She's a traitor..... Punish her accordingly

[@borja1000]

Both sides have a valid argument: 1- She was 15 when she fled. She was groomed, given enticing promises, money and instructions to flee and meet with her groomers. It is necessary to reiterate that she was 15 when this happened. There is no circumstance in the UK where someone of that age would be punished. 2 - She was fully indoctrinated into that madness. She was a part of the religious police. She was an active part of something that rivals the SS in terms of cruelty and disregard for human rights and dignity. She has been caught lying in several occasions. No one really knows what her level of commitment to that cause is. The judge considered these risks.

[@Jason-ku9ex]

She wasn't groomed at all! She new exactly what she was doing, all 3 did!

[@borja1000]

@@Jason-ku9ex Of course she was. 15 year olds don't watch the news, spot an armed movement and go "these is me! Imma find a way of flying out, then get there and join that party". She was contacted, she was fed indoctrinating info and she was instructed on how to do it. That is fact and if you don't believe it, read the report by the justice department.

[@user-jz5ye1iu3k]

WRONG ! Just today has been a court ruling that a 14 yr old has been detained for minimum of 13 years for murder, he stabbed a child of the same age, he is now 15 so that will be the age registered as his sentence age. We do not want or need our world to keep going the way it is, there must be deterrents to this kind of thing.

[@borja1000]

@@user-jz5ye1iu3k True. But there is a fundamental difference between both cases. In the case of the 14 yr old, the authorities had a body, a murder weapon and other evidence that allowed for a court ruling with a custodial sentence. In the case of Shamina, whatever she did, UK authorities have no means of gathering evidence that can lead to a conviction for things that happened in Syria.

[@ernestschroeder9762]

Do the British public have to pay for her court time?

[@Redhotsaycool123]

Of course...

[@kathleen5237]

I hope not. She should be responsible. But I suspect we have to pay

[@philipsidwell5511]

Yes us tax payers pay for all of this but she isn’t a British citizen anymore so why should we be paying?

[@RandhirRokade]

@@philipsidwell5511 sad

[@user-jz5ye1iu3k]

@@philipsidwell5511 Because we have thick people 'in charge'!

[@stevengray6069]

Who is paying for the lawyers? If it’s legal aid then it needs to stop

[@stevengray6069]

@@christinasutherland3604 over 7 million pounds so far

[@paulcrawford5437]

So the taxpayer needs to pay for her security either in prison or without for the rest of her life? No let her rot.

[@Rugmunchersauce3]

She doesn't regret it for the right reasons though.

[@elmonteslim3711]

They can keep her...

[@OmegaDelta82]

Not Imarn......🫣🫣🫣

[@oneblessedladyallsbrook1057]

Maya Angelou - "When someone shows you who they are, believe them the first time." #MayaAngelou

[@Buffyxox]

I empathize with her but she knew what she was doing. She used her sister’s passport to flee. She said she spoke to her family periodically while still a minor. They asked her to return and she said no! It wasn’t until the regime has toppled that she now wants to return. Would she have wanted to return if the regime was still in power?

[@coolcat3452]

Nope!!….even a 10yr old are liable to their decision talk less of 15yr old!! She’s now turning back now that things are not favourable for her! She should stay where she is to keep fighting for her “beloved” ISIS!!…a threat today is always a threat!!😢😢😢

[@michaelnorman7102]

Feel sorry for her !! Lady you are having a giraffe !!!

[@ryacv3cov968]

Cry me a river bringing up the race card

[@tillykaran3383]

She left in hijab and now in western clothing and this must be telling the public that she is changed and ready to mingle haha

[@user-in2ws6wd5s]

Amanda from Lancashire blaming the Rochdale girls for being groomed and comparing that to shamima shame on you!!!!

[@rossspenser8314]

Some people kill at 15 in the UK no she was not groomed she left with her friend s

[@CthRage8946]

Anti-Semitism is a huge issue that needs global recognition. As American taxpayer why should we bring up more ppl that don't share our values?

[@LudiCrust.]

Well we have let a lot of our own Isis brides back in the country & now a significant amount of taxpayer money is going to be spent on watching them. 2 of them were in senior roles within Isis & were higher up than this girl. I forget if it was the woman in Alabama or Oklahoma but one of them was the actual leader of the female morality police that Shemima was involved in. I’ll never understand why we let either of them back in the U.S.

[@rodwhitley3257]

Funny that woman couldnt blame her decision on the british people and being she feels so bad for her she doesnt seem to be running to her side

[@Travelocs]

She wasn't feeling bad for her if u listen carefully she was making valid points that seriously needs to be looks at

[@juliarman]

@@Travelocs If you saw a human head in a garbage bin, slave markets, and the genocide of a people like the Yezidis, would you stay with the ISIS caliphate and only leave once they lost the war?

[@kathygeorgiou7687]

The callers that believe she was a child when leaving & committing these crimes within the ISIS structure. So she should be able to come back. Well here is a question for them, if a 15yr in the U.K. get a bomb or a gun & kills heaps of people. Should will have empathy & let them off because they were a child & simply made a bad decision/mistake. Or do we hold them accountable for their crime?. She has killed people & as a crimal she should service her time in Seria. If she comes back to the U.K. she will be wasting tax payers money in appealing to get all the criminal charges drop, as she was naive etc..

[@MrYumyum11]

At age of 10 your actions are you own , in the eyes of the law, and the same people saying, she was 15, just a dumb child, yet want 16yr olds to vote 😂 total madness

[@NolaDWrites]

It was her choice. She made her bed. Let her lie in it.

[@user-rv1wf6sd4p]

I will ALWAYS say..NO ENTRY..She can appeal 1,000 times

[@rossspenser8314]

Yes it is right we all know this . We watched her leave on the news .No one was pulling her . NO

[@Julie-hf4ch]

One question: How is Shamima's case more different or dangerous than the existing protesters supporting Hamas on the streets of London or the muslim preachers preaching in their mosques in London the same ideology and hate against jewish?

[@Ha15679]

Quite a bit different, firstly the protesters are not picking up arms and fighting. Secondly the protesters are wanting the genocide to stop. If you really can’t see the difference. Take a trip to spec savers!

[@sentinelparadox]

Good, Justice upheld. Citizens over Criminals. Ones ignorance nor naivety is an excuse for ones horrendous actions and choices. There must be a level of responsibility and accountability for such actions. A criminal is a criminal, no matter who they are. There is no guarantee of imprisonment in the uk for crimes committed abroad. Details of the extent of the crimes committed are vague or difficult to confirm. Punishment can only be served where the crimes were committed. To be at such odds with ones nation of birth, then to go to war against it by way of joining a psychotic murderous enemy. It is treasonous. The de-radicalisation system & process, clearly does not work. None of the other terrorists that covertly returned to the uk, have been charged or sentenced for their crimes committed abroad. Still walking & talking freely. These individuals are truly national security threats, and a danger to all the citizens of the nation.

[@highbury4life899]

Being the prodigal child without jeopardizing the national security I can fathom...but to run away in order to join a globally designated terrorist organization I absolutely won't tolerate. Teens these days get far more access to information than my generation ever did. Despite being raised in a developed nation and still choosing a religious terrorist group is no valid excuse.

[@jimjames4348]

Of course Imarn Ayton would sympathise.

[@user-nt2py9np7w]

You take her in then iman 9h and pay her court costs

[@chloek2207]

Imran, would you think the same if it was a white 15 year old girl who falsely accused a black man of r*pe - all because she’s had been having conversations with adult racists who tell her it would be a good idea to make up the story. Would you feel sorry for her? Give her grace? Make excuses due to her age? No you definitely would not.

[@steveeymann6374]

You made your bed, lay in it!

[@kathygeorgiou7687]

Where are her parents ? Do they still live in the U.K.?

[@user-it6py5py6b]

Wharshappening with parents are they been investigated?

[@MelaniaRose]

Her mom died of cancer , her dad returned back to Bangladesh .

[@Joanna7428]

Storm really could do with doing her research and homework before fronting topics - she seems to be very ignorant if the facts and very sure of herself even when wrong - eg. Shamima talking in reference to the Manchester attacks, she was documented as saying this Storm - im not surprised callers hang up, her attitude is biased and quite hostile at times.

[@user-jz5ye1iu3k]

Spot on Joanna, when she stated that she had been forgiven for a certain incident and was corrected she lots our interest immediately! Her stock answer (similar to most ignorant folk) interesting does not wash anymore!

[@ellenbasilio5504]

How she was manipulated ? She said on her interview that something attracted her to go there. She wants to go back after the organisation was defeated. If not, i’m pretty sure she will still stay there.

[@lilywilliams3084]

The interviewer should be more informed about the topic. The example was when talking about the Manchester bombing, then tried to make an excuse, pathetic

[@Roastcrackling]

Their religion says its ok to lie.

[@user-wu5bn6ud1y]

Hypocrisy and double standards as usual without any shame

[@stanbily9416]

Woke 🤦🏽‍♂️

[@hammyhun9356]

Andrew has been using this girl since he met her…Has been on every British morning show pretending to know her so well. Can we trust you Andrew? You’re no expert…She has been your pay 💰 check for the last few years.

[@Sophie-cw7bf]

Let her stay where she is why we always letting people back who do silly things na she was 15 she still has a brain and she should of thought about this before even going no matter her age. Do not let her back she needs to learn her lesson let her keep fighting if she wants the should refuse her entry if the make her come back she should go straight to prison for ever

[@freetobeme6013]

7:50 the age of legal responsibility is 10 so yes, she should be held to account.

[@ShantiLarsson-us1kg]

Well said, just hit the nail on its head

[@user-rv1wf6sd4p]

NO ENTRY😡

[@barneyrubble8590]

Shamima begum is costing this country a fortune 😬 just for her mistake at 15..🙄

[@dWFnZWVr]

There’s mistakes and there’s joining a terrorist group. She denounced her British citizenship the moment she left.

[@sandranixon4808]

She Is not the only one

[@barneyrubble8590]

Imarn!!😱

[@sazikazimabuza1951]

Imarn is terrible. She just hates the UK and I don’t know why you have her on your shows. She wants Harry and Meghan to come back now she wants begum. And it’s always about race and we are tired of Imarn.

[@user-jz5ye1iu3k]

Yep-trying her bestest to be on 'good behaviour' didn't last too long though, she so apologetic that 'she just had to interupt'1 Now, where have we heard that before??

[@Lovepreet_Singh93]

The whole nation is scared of a girl 😅😅

[@therealkevan8158]

she'll do just fine in Syria

[@reshs7362]

Has anyone seen any recent footage of Syria. The whole country is in ruin, most places are left in rubble. Now instead of sitting in a camp and doing nothing for years, getting a hand out and free legal, i think she should be working hard and build the country she had a hand in destroying. Now, that would be justice.

[@seansroberts8448]

1st caller throws the race card into it🙄🙄brilliant 🤣🤣

[@arthursmith6854]

They bring race into it when their case is weak.

[@rolandrothwell4840]

Begum is British, and unfortunately, she is OUR problem. She made a terrible error as a minor. It is also against international law to make her stateless! If it's a national security issue, she'll need to be incarcerated

[@mikkelolsen257]

bye bye wtf are peoble talking about

[@kathygeorgiou7687]

No sorry she shouldn’t be allowed back. Because she left on her own accord, married & participated with ISIS, had three children in Seria. But now because everyone died & she is living in a refuge camp, she wants to come back. And how do we know if she came back to the U.K. that she wouldn’t continue with the terrorist thoughts & take action. It to big of a risk & threat to the U.K. Eg look at hamas leader Sinwar. He was in prison, Israelis did a hostage swap & look what he did.

[@Rugmunchersauce3]

Don't know what your doing at 15 years old ???! That's a ridiculous excuse. You SHOULD know better than that at 15.

[@colinlock-lv9vv]

never allow her back go to prison serve 2yrs out. she knew what she was doing

[@yorewhyworry7217]

Andrew serms to have problems himself tbh...

[@khalid969]

I don't think children should be absolved of their crimes just because they were children at the time of committing those crime. A 15 year old child should know the difference between right and wrong, and if they choose to commit a crime at that age, then they should face the consequences as if they were an adult.

[@hmagix9554]

Are you for real?! You are talking about children who are still in the stages of developing. Legally called minors! That is why depending on the crime depends on how that child is assessed and treated. And it definitely should be on a case by case basis.

[@Charmander009]

I’m sure u support isis too KHALID

[@stever2583]

She made her bed! Her choice.

[@h1g2a3r4]

Shamima Begum, is she a Begum? Begum is a title given to Indian Muslim women not to one who joins the cause of terrorist activity in faraway land.

[@darrinatorrr]

On a moral compass the uk is not responsible

[@mikebluegalindez5329]

IF SHE IS FORGIVEN THEN... AS AN ELDER WHAT ARE WE TEACHING THE COMING GENERATION IT'S OK TO BETRAY THE COUNTRY THAT GIVES YOU SAFE HEAVEN AND SHELTER CUZ THERE WILL LIGHT AT THE END OF THE TUNNEL ... LIFE IS NOT A VIDEO GAME " RESET UNDER OOOPS CONDITION " THAT IS THE PREMISE OF A LESSON be careful where you spread it

[@secretpolice6322]

If she comes back and goes to prison she doesn’t last a weekend 🎉🎉 I say bring her back 😂

[@RUSAKAMA]

Icant STAND THIS WOMAN IMARN

[@waynegodwin426]

It's her own thought her kids are dead

[@worldview730]

She's like the Princess Diana of the Isis Brides, always on social media for this & that

[@tomthornton6259]

I totally despise her and all that she is done. However, I don't see how they can legally strip her citizenship, as according to international law, all persons must have at least one citizenship. Now while it is true that her parents are from Bangladesh, and as such she's technically elegible for Bangladeshi citizenship, she herself isn't a citizen of said country. She would have to apply for a passport there, and Bangladesh have already said they won't accept her. So as such, to comply with international law, she has to have her British citizenship returned. Doesn't matter what we think of her, or what she deserves, or what she wants. Legally speaking, she cannot be left stateless.

[@Rosieshph]

Keep her out all she wants is to come back and be a celebrity make money and sell a story of how badly done to she is she knew full well what she was doing

[@mirembewinfred5353]

She is a threat to uk, try to bring her back.

[@user-cm2by7te6u]

But shes usually so against this country but now there a dicussion of showing it could be worse than living here is daft

[@sxceve25]

" Oh i feel so sorry for her " Am sure if it was u ,she wouldn't give a Damn!!😏...U make u bed u bloody lie in it...😏

[@karenbanogon3244]

Ok, maybe she was 15 and didn't know much, but the crime was joining terrorism not your regular drugs, robbery ,shoplifting etc, .or whatever juvenile delinquents do. Terrorism is way way up in the hierarchy of crimes. So, I can understand why the British government didn't want to risk the lives of their citizens. Better safe than sorry. She could easily change her mind again say in 5 yrs. What then ?

[@UsernamesForDummies]

These interviews are so badly handled, it’s infuriating. I was expecting more. The one lady that always and immediately interrupts callers should not be there. They didn’t “loose” the second caller who was interrupted. I’m pretty sure she hung up. Why even phone in, when you’re immediately cut off because you say something that isn’t favoured by a panel member?!? And yes, we’ve all done stupid things when we were 16, but they generally do not include deliberately putting others into mortal danger, watching them being killed and finding fulfilment in other people’s death sentences. There’s obviously something seriously wrong in her brain and heart. Normal 16-years olds might steal a mars bar or smoke a joint, for heaven’s sake!

[@barneyrubble8590]

That imarn has got some claws 😂

[@kagari08]

Okay you let her back!! now what?. This people with this ideals will just say okay you see she's back despite of what they did.. Gather again & do it until we succeed lets us this country resources for that.. Give the opportunity to those who will contribute in your country & to those that they will not turn their back on you..

[@roseyrosey123456]

No, she should go to jail

[@sazikazimabuza1951]

Why is this host one sided - May as well not had this show and we just listen to you give us your opinion that she must come back. You’re not even engaging the callers that differ from you fairly. Stopped watching. Andrew was great and just as well because he knows her better than any of you on the panel

[@kathrindoll6903]

If she was dyslexic I would feel sorry for her but she is highly intellegent n should be charges a s a adult.

[@agoraphobicsocialite6897]

Gina from London is talking nonsense btw

[@Jp-ny3qh]

29:55 is all the court needs to know