Jethro Tull - With You There To Help Me - 2nd version (1970)

[@stephenpogen1035]

The greatest band that ever walked the planet. I saw them live 26 times starting in 1969. Full of music

[@dupont135]

Lucky you. I'm a bit younger and lived in forest/swamp, so I never had a chance to see them live.

[@enricobotti5944]

Anche per me dal 1972 - nessuno degli amici e conoscenti era d'accordo ma in Italia erano comunque molto valutati - secondo me hanno una base culturale e mistica che altri non hanno - Blackpool è una medio-piccola città europea ma hanno assorbito tanta capacità

[@victoriaallen1857]

Love that ! I’ve seen them 1 time 🩷

[@bernard6129]

Now in my sixties. Still get goose bumps listing to JT early music. None better - long reign to the Tull.

[@bigrebone]

It's good stuff, man! Same here, 60's and shit, too.

[@burlingtonbill1]

@@bigrebone BEFORE "Aqualung" especially.

[@nintzelj]

me three!

[@robin2012ism]

me four!

[@LaMusicade4]

Particularly that lineup

[@travelinben1966]

Great song,great album,great band.R.I.P. Glenn.👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@gustavoautran]

probably one of the best bands ever. certainly the most fantastic multi-skilled front-man of all times.

[@windyhead7960]

His songwriting aside, lyrically he's simply the William Blake of rock.

[@moonfaze]

Fifty years later, I'm still enthralled.

[@gerdschoppenhorst1154]

​@@windyhead7960...for sure !

[@davelogan676]

1970 was Tull's greatest Music "Benefit" and songs from" Living in the Past" Were masterpieces This line up was Tull's greatest chemistry of player's .Cornick Bunker left soon after this Concert.very sad day for myself 15 yr old then 68 now

[@nemyz7421]

I fully agree with your comment. Two magnificent albums. This was in my opinion the best formation of Jethro Tull.

[@sinusiridum551]

​@@nemyz7421anche la formazione degli anni 1971-1973 era fantastica....Anderson, Barre,Hammond,Barlow,Evans...dal vivo erano strepitosi...ricordo 3 concerti...Milano 1971,Varese 1972,Roma 1973...indimenticabili !!!!

[@tommy..980]

No one better than this band… Ian Anderson was so far ahead of his time… Benefit a most excellent album

[@alwilson3204]

The talent level was only rivaled by a few other good bands.

[@coast73]

​@@alwilson3204 I don't think any band in rock history rivals the talent level in the 1976-1979 line up

[@Cantrip1957]

I love this era Tull.

[@justgivemethetruth]

So much energy, youth and confidence ... it's really wonderful. 9:22

[@andrecartier8126]

@@justgivemethetruth It was a great era , except for that little war , far , far away . bravo co. 1/9 Marines . André Cartier

[@nivasantos7653]

Benefit is one of my fav Tull Album. John Evan came to enrich the band sound. The best line-up ever!!

[@108grog]

Ian had just turned 23. Blows me away how talented and accomplished some of the early rockers were at young ages. Many starting in bands at 13 and 14 years old.

[@johnroberts3723]

When I'm in the mood for real music I listen to early tull.

[@jefffelderman2409]

So glad I grew up during this time and got to see the mighty JT perform numerous times. And they continue to evolve.

[@noopportunitynecessary]

You just don’t see mind blowing talent like this now 🤯

[@rallabhandiprabhakar4750]

Benefit is one of the best albums of JT and this track is one of the best in Benefit .

[@BIgBass255]

I love We use to know on Stand Up, but I must agree with you Benefit is awesome.

[@gregthornton4209]

First Tull song I heard when I was 15...Bought Benefit the next day Favorite band for 51 years...

[@MerleDoughty-yw6cl]

Still listening to this old Tull stuff, now in my mid 70s this music is my drug along with a few nice beers and in my man cave I can play this loud and worry about neighbors telling me to turn that music down. I am in my element immediately transformed back to these days and the most brilliant music. I must buy another flute as i could back in the 70s play the damned thing just for my own enjoyment. Music the best drug if you suffer from arse er right arse

[@andycuthbert2763]

I’m mid 50s-enjoy Tull with an IPA and small cigar at max volume! Hope u enjoy !!

[@scottbohe7006]

Seeing this just reminds me that Jethro Tull is still not in the rock 'n roll hall of fame. Where is the justice???? One of the greatest frontmen of all time, and so artistic & creative. Long live Tull!

[@danieljgraham5459]

R n R hall of fame...keep it!

[@kenwilliams3208]

It's beyond ridiculous they are nit in there.

[@vamboroolz1612]

Rock n roll hall of fame is a joke. No one cares about it.

[@XanAxDdu]

i am not from north america it is weird how what was center of the world didnt care its reign

[@Thundergod-]

Tull is too good for hall of shame IMO....

[@johnmoran24]

Heard this for the first time at a party in 1970 where I had arrived peaking on LSD and it shook me to the core. Still shiver every time I hear..ahh those were the days.

[@isiso.speenie5994]

LM Poor old AO. 1971 Blue Cheer tablets.

[@XanAxDdu]

​@@isiso.speenie5994 wtf yoy wrote

[@marsac9892]

Been there, done that, but during his concert...can't tell you how many times I listened to Benefit and Aqualung...timeless music...

[@kristlepickles]

John Evan's piano playing is sublime. The entire band are on fire here. ❤

[@pietkonijn5522]

Beethoven is nodding with his head, Yes, yes this is it ! (John Evan)

[@jbenavides2567]

I return to these songs and they remind me why I love progressive rock, and why Tull remain my all-time favourites after 40 years of listening to them

[@bobcoradi2638]

Beyond excellent. This is the stuff that hooked me for life.

[@kathleenpett3194]

Yup! It'll never get better than Tull.

[@geekay1349]

:Ages well like good wine

[@gerryradford4812]

Undoubtedly the most ORIGINAL BAND OF ALL TIME !! Amazing musicians x incredible songs x Tull have never changed ,,, ASTOUNDING MUSIC 🎼 GX

[@josephcomuniello964]

Simply a phenomenal song & album loved Ian & the Boys of Jethro Tull, good ole days long gone by that’s all I know..✌️✌️✌️✌️✌️😢

[@johnnyazer5779]

My family wanted to strangle me how much I told them I worshipped Jethro Tull from 1972 on. Such peaceful times to this music. I knew who my friends are...not facebook likes and thoughts and prayers. ehehehehe.

[@umitgok3275]

I ♥️ Benefit album 1970

[@alexandrosiliadis4866]

The best my friend

[@alexandrosiliadis4866]

Simdi ismini gordum bende Istanbulun Rumlarindanim Atinadan selamlar saygilar sevgiler

[@umitgok3275]

@@alexandrosiliadis4866 My favourite Tull album is Benefit.

[@umitgok3275]

@@alexandrosiliadis4866 Kalimerhaba Alexandros

[@michaeln3023]

A halfway nice Album - but not the best. My Favorit is from the eighties: The Broadsword and the Beast

[@anthonyornowski9860]

Love Benefit, my first tull album

[@SPSteve]

Benefit is a masterpiece!

[@johndavies8728]

Glen cornick and clive bunker, what a rhythm section, fantastic stuff indeed

[@loricrissey8416]

Playing this for my friend that passed Jan 15 she was that friend

[@danamacfarlane6955]

So Very Sorry for your loss, sending love and prayers 🥰❤️

[@danamacfarlane6955]

How many instruments does Ian Play????Such Awesome Talent IAN❤️🥰❤️🤪🤪❤️

[@ClariceAust]

My older sister had somehow heard of and bought their albums and I listened to them endlessly from age 14; a great band with a unique sound.

[@tomconrad8017]

Ditto

[@unchattytwit]

Flippin' brilliant. Introducing the marvellous John Evans. The freedom to be creative and brilliant was a wonderful thing - ain't seen the days since. What have we got now?

[@kevross4933]

The greatest band ever…. In my humble opinion. Ian Anderson is a genius with every band member adding to the music and performance. To me.. pink floyd and led zep always come to peoples minds when we think of rock bands… but for sheer variety of genders…TULL rule

[@taab7]

Genre not "genders"... other than that I completely agree with your opinion.

[@patrickmegan8224]

Just effin awesome!!

[@tomoday4450]

The absolute best lineup ever 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@chrisesco4485]

Wow! Waited 50 years to hear this version! Jethro Tull, totally unique!

[@gregorallnight371]

Ian Anderson,one of the most creative and talented songwriters,musicians and performers to ever come along and with bandmates also very skilled musicians.. other bands,altho very few,had flute playing such as the amazing album called,Two Quid Deal? by Skin Alley,and that album is a masterpiece...thanks for posting this..

[@justgivemethetruth]

What a great live version of a great song from another great Jethro Tull album.

[@johnspence919]

Just as wild,skilled,amazing,magical as the first time I heard this music 45 yes ago! Brilliant

[@isiso.speenie5994]

53 years ago.

[@alanfletcher9698]

Ian Anderson what a Legend man could he sing a play the Flute . Great musicians. Music then was Amazing

[@davidthieda6841]

My favorite song of Jethro Tull 🌟🎵🥁🎸🎵🌟

[@BadDog69]

Very few musicians can put this much energy into a live performance.

[@scottallen1274]

I was 7 years old when my older brother bought Living in the past . Been a fan ever since

[@marloncamposvindas6479]

Fucking Awesome!!!! I love Jethro Tull and this version of this song is really amazing, the final part... WOW

[@bonniebailey3795]

This song is so underated . It's refreshing to see classic Tull.

[@Thadmotor1044]

uncanny , totally fusion stands the test of time . Iconic band still rockin

[@frankstecker5675]

Jehtro Tull......great live song...

[@adamparker2754]

Best version ever!!! Flashlight up!!!!

[@adamparker2754]

LOL d*** typos best lineup ever.

[@agatamazzone4894]

I hadn't listened to Benefit for at least 10 years .. how wonderful !!

[@frankmerolillo8743]

Tull Best Rock band of all Times.

[@eddiem5997]

Tulls best lineup 🔥

[@justgivemethetruth]

I'd agree, but would like to extend that to cover at least up to TAAB.

[@javierllerena5756]

All Jethro Tull line ups are the bests , there is no bad line up , Jethro Tull is the best progressive rock band ever existed .

[@jorgedelacadena4963]

Jon Evan in the keyboard magnificent

[@thomasbell7033]

Yep. They lost me after this lineup. As a young drummer, I idolized Clive Bunker, who left the band after teaching Barry Barlow the licks to all the songs.

[@salliemae7476]

I was used to hearing their music on Rock Stations and years later on Classic Rock Stations, but KZbin brings this group to life for me because every early performance of them is just awesome to watch. There isn’t another band like them, it’s combination of many things art, theatre and the instrumental side is pure perfection

[@MrChristopherHaas]

HERE HERE

[@edfederoff2679]

I love to come back to this every so often when YT sends it around - the comments are my favorite part - to commiserate with fellow Tull worshippers in affirmation and adoration is as mystically uplifting an experience as hearing the music - much like I imagine hearing J.S. Bach play a new cantata each week at St. Thomas' in Leipzig would have been. Stand Up - was my first album, as a Junior in High School. I found This Was immediately after, and from there, until the time when Ian's voice began to wane - I bought and studied every piece - having taught myself to play flute, just as he did - and attended every concert I could within a few hours drive. It's been a lifetime's joy hearing the musical sermons of Sir Ian Anderson - and still going strong - with a new project that he starts each year. Thank you, Jethro Tull, et al; SDG, as Bach would say - "Soli Deo Gloria".

[@NuTonesForever]

Benefit was always on the playlist back in the day, Amazing album, this is just a tremendous rendition of this tune.

[@johnmccann8319]

They were so brilliant!❤

[@ikeboy8617]

I saw this band at hampton beach casino in New Hampshire, USA was blown away

[@peggs1]

OUTSTANDING

[@borrowed_soap]

1969, awesome, mine was '87 tour cheers mate! one of my favorite of all time! 🙂

[@tomoday4450]

Absolutely fantastic

[@Komponiert-oe7md]

Großartig!

[@eliasfalda5773]

Ian Scott Anderson dispensa comentários simplesmente GENIAL.

[@MrChristopherHaas]

Beautiful. Beautiful message. Beautiful MUSIC, real music. Sounds better every time i hear it.

[@563421094]

One of The Most Influential Bands In My Collection... Seed Drillers...

[@joecomuniello4504]

Best band of all time in my book that’s all I know, Ian @ his best “always”!!! Loved this time era the likes we will neva”EVA” see again, but I’m glad to have seen these lads many times!!! “Especially @ the GARDEN baby, “memories that will live 4/EVA”!!!!👍👍👍

[@fbayer72]

Eva see them at the Fillmore East? 😃

[@Mitch-do4pz]

Stand up is my favorite my older brother wore it out!

[@bigrebone]

Love this performance!

[@adonislayer]

Até hoje escuto esse som, e acho DU KARALHO!!! Muito bom!

[@karenujlaky6928]

Saw in concert mid ‘70’s @ Madison Square Garden, NYC 🧡🎶🎸

[@richpeltier9519]

I love you Beat Club. Whoever there is raining gold on the world right now with all these classic performances, deserves a fucking Nobel. Rich the Ancient Metal Beast

[@richardstuebe9807]

This is one of the tightest, best versions of this song available. Just amazing!

[@keithmilburn4866]

Brilliant contemporary rock band, unique .

[@XanAxDdu]

contemporary lol band

[@sledzeppelin]

Thank god for Beat Club. What a treasure trove.

[@juliusschwencke142]

..always good to hear a live version, without all the floursishes of a studio production. That Les Paul sounds absolutely savage..

[@eddiem5997]

Try Tulls Isle of Wight set. It’s electric ⚡️

[@umitgok3275]

With Clive Bunker + Glenn Cornick!x

[@umitgok3275]

Drum and Bass

[@thomasbell7033]

@@umitgok3275 I agree. They were the finest, most under-recognized rhythm section in rock music IMO. The band was never the same without them.

[@umitgok3275]

@@thomasbell7033 Thank you for your comment Thomas.

[@VictorHernandez-yb5ti]

El show más grande que he visto en mi vida Jethro Tull en los 70’s en El Paso TX

[@anthonyornowski9860]

My first Tull album too!

[@justgivemethetruth]

3:53 - one of my favorite Jethro Tull and John Evan moments ... awesome keyboarding.

[@attiliobastosguarnieri5416]

Banda inconfundível. Som de qualidade e energia. Voz marcante e etc. Progressive Rock !!!

[@eliasfalda5773]

À música é antes e depois de Ian Scott Anderson . Depois de sua aparição nunca mais será à mesma. Profunda,densa,inspiradora,celestial...

[@anthonyornowski9860]

Friend turned me on to it on 8 track when I was 12

[@anthonyornowski9860]

It's sickening that they are not in rock and roll Hall of Fame and kiss is, wtf, over?!

[@briangallagher2236]

At this moment, April/May 1970, while the Beatles were breaking up, bands like Tull were hitting their stride.

[@ernestromero3631]

The sample of Beethoven's "Sonata Pathetique" during the piano solo was great to hear!

[@jgcd66]

This is pure jewel!!!

[@neilangus4401]

This is just brilliant

[@karenujlaky6928]

The best ❤🎶🎸

[@franciscojaviersaenzserran2020]

Perhaps only one little singular song nowadays be like This little piece of wonder

[@danhankins2758]

They are one of a kind!

[@davidrosen3970]

Saw them once in 70, probably this concert, they were a brilliant live band.

[@zog97xy]

This is beat club.

[@gringopistolero]

Saw them back in '80. One of the best concerts ever. Thanks for the great music.

[@elbouamrimohamed9853]

It's a always a real pleasure

[@pflqr]

My favorite lineup.

[@robsonnicoly3060]

Simplesmente sensacional 👏👏👏

[@Laurasiana]

It's cool hearing John Evan using a couple of bits that would eventually become the intro to Locomotive Breath.

[@whatevershebrings]

AND at 4:51 copping the same classical riffs that John Hawken played with Renaissance, also on Beat Club, in 1970! Their first album was '69, before Benefit.

[@gregthornton4209]

AND: from Living in the Past, side C "By Kind Permission Of"...

[@thomasbell7033]

@@whatevershebrings And both were copped from Beethoven's "Pathetique."

[@whatevershebrings]

@@thomasbell7033 and with you there to help me, then it probably will-ll-ll... : )

[@thomasbell7033]

@@whatevershebrings If I had to pick one JT song, it would probably be this one. But after hearing songs from This Was as performed at Isle of Wight, My Sunday Feeling is up there as well. Sadly, they lost me after Aqualung.

[@Aislanzito]

Rock'n'Roll yesterday, today and forever

[@MLewisDesign]

The ENERGY! ♥️♥️♥️

[@marisaelenenadiejamusiccom3974]

Lovely! Wish that I could play flute like Ian..

[@warjoy1]

You seem to be beatiful, are U?

[@ChrisBarry-h5h]

You can see how much went into recording this one, it sounds totally different live.

[@judithl1013]

Always will be great.

[@salvatorelococo1722]

Io l ascolto sempre sono un mito ma i Jethro tull degli anni 70 ..adesso lan anderson non quello di prima..ormai c è rimasto il nome Jethro tull ..

[@LaMusicade4]

Extraordinary musicians

[@mahjoubtannani9532]

Wonderful music channel full of mémoires tks

[@gerhardprasent3358]

I adore the early albums by JT - up to Thick As A Brick - so fresh and individual.