Comparison of China's Y 20 and American Boeing c17

Comparison of China's Y 20 and American Boeing c17

[@laszlotikk8669]

Hi, the speed and range tables are incorrect, please check it and correct to for good numbers.

[@hellocatIII]

If you go to see the five generation aircraft of South Korea and Türkiye, why does no one say they are copied from the United States? In addition, the sixth generation aircraft of the United States have duck wings, can it be said that they are plagiarizing China's J-20?

[@jasonwen426]

颱風有鴨翼、颶風有鴨翼，SU系列有鴨翼jas-39也有鴨翼。 你能說殲20也是抄的嗎？ 但仿到一摸一樣的就只有垃圾老共！幹

[@rdmgwinn]

Because they are not even close or are done under license. That's how allies do things. The USA tried to have China as an allie, and trading partner. Hasn't worked out. Thought it would of been in China's best interest to maintain good trade relations with the US and EU. Looks like China thinks russia, North Korea and Iran will bring in more trade. Guess we'll have to see how it works out with China as an advesary to the US and EU???

[@kenthyousee3950]

because turkey and korea are have a technological support with lockheed martin, the maker of f35 and f22 raptor. china j20 copied the duckwings from eurofighter so how can you say that US copied that? hahahah

[@xiaofengwang9541]

I think you plagiarized Lucy's appearance, so you should apologize.@@kenthyousee3950

[@AmericanMinutemen]

There is a great difference between copying and outright theft of design data.

[@Improver12]

naturally! Let's compare the two aircraft: Boeing C-17 Globemaster III: Production: 279 units. Dimensions: Length: 173.9 feet. Width/Side: 169.8 feet. Height: 55.1 feet. Weight: Curb Weight: 278,003 lbs. Maximum takeoff weight: 585,001 lbs. Performance: Speed: 518 mph. Range: 5,861 miles. Maximum ceiling: 45,000 ft1. Xian Y-20 (Kunpeng): Production: 60 units. Dimensions: Length: 154.2 feet. Width/s: 164.0 feet. Height: 49.2 feet. Weight: Curb Weight: 220,462 lbs. Maximum takeoff weight: 485,017 lbs. Performance: Speed: 572 mph. Range: 2,796 miles. Maximum ceiling: 42,651 ft1. For weapons and other abilities, you can find more details in the sources mentioned above.

[@wenling3487]

The key advantage of Y20 is its fuselage demonstration So its cost is much lower

[@kellyjohnson9394]

It’s called (practically) forced labor. The chinese military paper dragon has the best military equipment that they can steal.

[@talks7795]

@@kellyjohnson9394 stupid loser

[@venonat80]

@@kellyjohnson9394everything is cheaper with forced labor lol. Probably lower quality too. Cheap crap is prob ok on the Amazon marketplace but on military equipment and especially on stuff meant to fly. Risking your life going up in the air with the Y20.

[@liongjiahwong5478]

​@@kellyjohnson9394old story.. come out with something new. Stealing from the US, who is the fool.

[@alustin]

@@venonat80 chinese army dont need to fight wars. where as American army always need to fight wars. I rather join the chinese army

[@manwingchi9156]

A car have window, wheel, window, engine, roof, door, China steal US technology.😂😂😂😂

[@pNHGpNHG]

Do we hear some SLa--ve making screechy Noises ?? 😁😁

[@liongjiahwong5478]

Stealing from America, America must be a fool to let China steal their technologies.

[@taiwanstillisntacountry]

Do i hear a boi crying from his 2 mommy's basement?

[@liongjiahwong5478]

Why is America so stupid to let China steal their technologies. Why ? Old story, come out with something new.

[@bobsmith3983]

The first cars were invented in Europe so the US copied it. The first jet engine was invented by the British so the US copied it. The first looms were invented in Europe so the US copied it also. Gunpowder, rockets, mortars, missiles and paper were invented by the Chinese so the US copied them. USA is a serial copier.

[@saleem956ify]

Oh look the Y20 has 2 wings, landing gear, and 4 engines... its stolen technology.

[@yaoriver2633]

😂

[@RADICALFLOAT95]

​@@yaoriver2633l actually agree with you and finally some one who l found in the comment section that actually has a functioning brain for once

[@wilsonwongnyukweng8993]

Any prove it's stolen? All cargo plane image mostly like tat... Pls don't thinking like child. 😂

[@RADICALFLOAT95]

@@wilsonwongnyukweng8993 I actually genuinely agree with you and finally some one who l found in the comment section that actually has a functioning brain for once

[@dwanelkemprai4983]

😂😂😂😂chinese stuff are copies of the world.

[@nelson2020]

C17 used for war, Y20 used for peace - the difference 😅😅😅

[@nanymitert5447]

BS! There are no need for peace, or may be wars!

[@RahuluddinGandhy]

Joking?!

[@srijanme]

C17 is crap

[@zeeshansyed6290]

Stealing also is the sign of intelligence ❤why other countries can't steal just because they don't have intelligent engineers and scientists 😂

[@YenzikovALCherasLegend]

Of course US Air Force is better as USA had been at War up to this current time. USA air froce had done millions of bombings and transported billions of ton amory . Chinese Fighter and Bomber had yet to fire , bomb anything nor had a kill . USA is specialized in Killing Machines and is a War Expert. There is nothing strange for US to mock anyone who don't tow their line be it about Geopolitic , Trade , Climate .whatever you think of you get it.

[@bobsmith3983]

The Ukrainians ware/were trained by USA/NATO and the Russians are thrashing them. Russia would easily thrash the USA.

[@srijanme]

Are you referring to the clowns who recently ran away from goat herders? lmao

[@ajunaidr]

Check your figures speed and weight error in calculations

[@Lazarov_Tweevles]

I only rely on Chinese technology when ordering fresh moon rocks and dust. I ordered some from NASA on Dec. 20, 1972 (for Christmas presents) and I haven't received any yet. Since I got tired of waiting, in Nov. 2020, I ordered some from the Chinese space agency (CBSA) and received them by Christmas (too late for my kids but my great-grandkids are happy).

[@Minnie--ru2ew]

You sure it’s genuine? 😂😂😂

[@Sami-Nasr]

I have some in stock

[@Utube1024]

The difference China produce themselves. India need to toe the line and beg in order to buy them.

[@nanymitert5447]

In 2025 when the M10-Booker Mobile FirePower (MFP) Vehicles are needed by the U.S. infantry, this C17 will be handy to carry two of these M10 MFP to be ready for the close combat land forces.

[@เชาวลิตอุปบุตร]

Y20, looks more better than C17. Great China.

[@NaRa-wr8xb]

Human being in the world are so hate communist party.

[@李大人-m7p]

还没有

[@dddddh1]

​@@李大人-m7p你说了不算

[@Leti86]

So pretty much what I have learned from this video is that China just wait until the USA invent something and they just steal it. lol

[@XkMeng]

Copying and stealing are two completely different concepts. When you are a primary school student, what you should do is learn existing knowledge, not conduct research or write a doctoral thesis. Replication and mass production are important processes in the progress of human civilization. This is why the Industrial Revolution defeated handicraft industry. If anything is only available to the first manufacturer and is not allowed to be copied by others, then the price of any new thing has nothing to do with you keyboard man losers.

[@zenden9]

Y20 has super critical structure wing while C17 has none becos it design is much earlier. Y20 has higher cargo height compare to C17.

[@pNHGpNHG]

and, ... CarGo HeiGHT is very, very Important when sending our CHINA supports to our RUSSIAN + BELARUSIAN + CUBAN + VENEZUELAN + SERBIAN brothers & sisters. 😁 😁

[@zezoo2107]

But carries less weight

[@vladilenkalatschev4915]

Y-20 definitely needs new high bypass engines

[@kaichang2059]

Y20B is testing the new engines

[@ajaykumarsingh702]

WS-20 engine already in mass production.

[@JohnDunnigan-c5i]

I’m sure that the Chinese answer to the C17 is impressive. Why wouldn’t it, because Boeing (one of our largest and most important defense contractors) has factories in Communist China, teaching our enemy how to build aircraft. Even though they are building civilian aircraft, there is so much of the technology that can be used for military purposes. These scoundrels in the United States Congress will agree to anything when corporate lobbyists dole out cash for their campaigns. The Chinese military harasses American and allied military that are in international waters in the South China Sea. The Chinese military sees the United States as their enemy.

[@anthonytran7566]

C17 is being copied from China Y20?????

[@jimmyyoh8144]

The fact of the matter is where are the US C-17 to be deployed from where. The answer is from US homeland to Pacific east region is 10,000 km away. The Chinese Y-20 from their homebases to Eastern Sea targets in 1,000 km. Thus, Y-20 can fly back and forth a number of trips vs C-17 to fly 1 time. LoL.

[@fredmac1251]

That's one of the dumbest things I have ever heard. How many bases are in the Pacific for the Americans to replenish? Short sighted.

[@rdmgwinn]

Magic???

[@Minnie--ru2ew]

That’s one of the dumbest statements I’ve ever heard. I have to inform you that china has been sending spies to copy western technology especially coming from the US. So, try better next time.

[@jesuscervantesj82]

It's obvious a C-17 in my opinion is superior. It's a war machine in the sense of it carrying war vehicles and supplies. It also offers the ability to get penetrated by a boom and refilled in mid-air so that could be considered unlimited range. I find the C-17 much better in my opinion.

[@balongride3169]

As usual it's xerox copy of the design from US military aircraft 🥴

[@sunroad7228]

Remove the non-stop background noise and re-upload the video.

[@sergeanttrucker]

I'll take the C17 any day. Superior cargo capacity, speed. Air refueling capability means essentially unlimited range.

[@WilliamSaverino]

You want to buy Chinese JUNK? Good luck 😅

[@XkMeng]

At present, it seems that the whole world is buying. The Chinese have just entered the aviation industry, but half of the ships operated by humans on the sea are made by Chinese. The proportion may be even higher in the future.

[@sebastien3351]

The Y-20 is not as well suited for long range to support "power projection" as well as the C-17. I would like to know more about the Y-20s ability to land on rough landing strips.

[@LingjunLi-r5p]

塞尔维亚：？

[@granitecolorado]

No refunds on ali express aviation 😂😂

[@CalvinHsuChen]

99% off from Alibaba!

[@xushenxin]

No need to compare, since C17 is no longer in production. Maybe US will replace them in next 30 years, nobody knows.

[@melvinGat]

us can buy Y 20 from china with cheaper price 😂😂😂

[@CalvinHsuChen]

@@melvinGat No thanks We rather buy from Taiwan. 😂😂😂

[@vision9275]

@@melvinGat ... and with much better quality than C17. See the breakup of Boeing 737-max, that's why C17 is no longer in production.

[@estijo1299]

The US spent years of R&D. China able to create this type of cargo plane in how many years? How?

[@bossmikey7301]

By hacking and stealing blueprints.

[@XkMeng]

@bossmikey7301 Only a layman and idiot would say this. The modern complex aircraft manufacturing industry requires the support of dozens of basic industries and hundreds of companies. A few blueprints are of no use at all, but will disrupt your own research and development. pace. Moreover, China already had a complete heavy industry before the Internet era, including missiles, satellites, nuclear submarines, atomic bombs, fighter jets, etc. China was able to produce them all before the 1980s.

[@liongjiahwong5478]

@@bossmikey7301 stupid right, stealing from America is really smart.

[@bobsmith3983]

@@bossmikey7301 If that is so the USA is really super dooper bad at securing their networks. So much for military grade network security.

[@glenpharmd]

Chinese HAVE A MUCH MORE RIGOROUS PRIMARY EDUCATION SYSTEM. THE PARENTS DO THEIR BEST TO MAKE THEIR CHILDREN THE BEST IN THE CLASSROOMS. WE DO OUR BEST TO MAKE OUR CHILDREN THE BEST SPORTS ENTHUSIAST. MAYBE THEY CREATE BETTER ENGINEERS BECAUSE OF MY OBSERVATIONS.

[@luting3]

Please check numbers

[@jkp2712]

Americans have that big of a plane to move tanks. The Chinese have that big of plane to evacuate fatalities from a conflict with US.

[@yuluoxianjun]

China send warship to israel to retreat normal people,USA warship go there doing nothing except being bombed by yemen rocket

[@rdmgwinn]

Doubt armed conflict between China and the USA / NATO will happen. I believe the Chinese are very intelligent people and would not take such a risk.

[@XkMeng]

It sounds nice, but for decades, people around the world have only seen Americans using large aircraft to drop bombs and kill people around the world, but never use them to save people, including their "allies" in Afghanistan. The Chinese use large aircraft to evacuate their citizens from war and disaster areas as soon as possible.

[@jkp2712]

@@XkMeng where has China ever rescued people? They don’t even watch out for the citizens.

[@jkp2712]

@@XkMeng that is cause the last time China was in a conflict, it was invaded and occupied by a country smaller than your average Walmart.

[@RamZar50]

C-17 has customers in U.S., U.K., Canada, Australia, Qatar, UAE, Kuwait, India. Y-20 is only used by PRC. Even though C-17 has been out of production since 2015 it has no competition.

[@laosasean8482]

Soon! its will get more customers because its cheaper just like Chinese buffet vs McDonald. At least China and Russia can built the own and they don't have to buy from US. India is big country with big population but isn't capable to built the own aircraft.

[@zenden9]

You expect Australia, UK , Canada and India to buy China Y20 even it superior than C17? Lol.. your example is so pathetic to prove your point...😂

[@RamZar50]

@@zenden9 Y-20 got to market because C-17 designs were stolen by a Chinese spy. It has been in service with PLAAF since 2016.

[@laosasean8482]

@@zenden9 China doesn't care if India, UK, Canada buy its or not, they can sell to countries that willing to buys from them and they are so many countries in the world besides them.

[@rdmgwinn]

Likely / maybe true. Just wondering how many North Korea and Iran will buy?@@laosasean8482

[@shajisebastian43]

Excellent 🙌 👍

[@haumvaj5065]

U S's more better and look nicer

[@traquefaux6161]

Extraordinaire Airbus A 400.

[@syq8888]

Y-20 is an improved il-78. No comparison here. C-17 is better

[@Nagpadawala]

You have not mentioned anything of the most important comparision. The RELIABILITY of the Y 20. Is it like most chinese equipment . Totally crap.

[@xuchen4012]

We all know that C-17 is as RELIABLE as Boeing 737-max.

[@dddddh1]

你看起来挺无聊🥱

[@vvr8820]

Speed and range comparison wrong

[@曲辰仁-q4z]

中國運20的装配手工明顯好過美國C17，起降更順，飛控電腦可能更先進，只有渦扇發動機推力比美國少!😊😅😮

[@jasonwen426]

聽妳在叭哺😢

[@fenggao3171]

How do you know that? Do you have experiences of taking these two planes?

[@darrylmuse9948]

Yea like Chinese carriers are better then ours 😂😂😂

[@elijahwakati8639]

It’s not a full copy they made some small/changes 😊

[@KPAU07]

....the number comparison does add up. C17 is no longer in production.

[@laosasean8482]

Because its not reliable and expensive to built. Its big airplane but smaller wing which is not so good for the lift.

[@dantea6]

did they ask joe biden if it was okay to paint the bird gray. it sounds like they need some freedom.

[@iigoofywebsterii]

The fvkery about this is that China stole blueprints and designs to make the Y 20. looks identical to the C 17 Globemaster

[@dennislao7406]

defend scs from foreign invaders

[@javiermejia510]

Con la diferencia que uno es original y el otro copia con tengnologia robada

[@shitoupai]

这是无耻的污蔑

[@HoangNguyen-yc9hs]

Y20 Trung Quốc bắt chước C17 của Mỹ y chang.

[@markkeister6057]

Does the y20 have in flight refueling as the c17? Makes the fuel comparison mute.

[@sweatybotfn9982]

Yes. The aerial refueling version is YY-20

[@xuansu9036]

@@sweatybotfn9982 he meant whether Y-20 could be refueled in flight. So far, it doesn't look like there is such a capability.

[@sweatybotfn9982]

@@xuansu9036 not the Y-20 but the YY-20 is the aerial refueling version

[@xuchen4012]

@@sweatybotfn9982 lmao. His question is "could Y-20 be refueled by YY-20?". My answer is no. Never heard of it.

[@sweatybotfn9982]

@@xuchen4012 oh. Yea no

[@kannankrishnan4333]

ORIGINAL vs FAKE or Clone

[@robertfrauenthal4713]

Since the Chinese are 'great' at hacking/copying is the Y20 an 'upgraded' copy of the C17?

[@CalvinHsuChen]

No. China never make reliable products.

[@glennoc8585]

I hope the QC is better than most chinese goods. In saying that Boeing is not great

[@mwitarijob1557]

Y20 can't match the magesty of c27. Its a clone.

[@Porter92]

Lolol this is the plane The guy got caught stealing info on for china along with the 22 and 35 back in 2014

[@Emperor_of_Manchukuo]

China is by far the best.👍

[@fredmac1251]

You should know since you live there.

[@bobsmith3983]

@@fredmac1251 I don't live there and I agree with the Emperor.

[@Bluemark4683]

Made in china always a trash.

[@CalvinHsuChen]

@@bobsmith3983 Imagine lying here on youtube comment section.

[@ItisNeverTooLateisit]

Xian is pronounced as 'She-An', thanks

[@JetlineMarvel]

Thanks for the NOTE

[@channasenaratne8442]

Wrong figures compare numbers speed, wing span etc

[@独自醉倒]

看到评论里全是嘲笑我们的运20不够先进的话语，既然我们的飞机这么差，为什么得到这么多你们的关注？你们在害怕什么？😂

[@chrislong3938]

1;28 - Showcasing years of copying...

[@anthonybollini]

cheap copy !

[@jjman533]

Is the Y20 made out of scrap elevator and escalator parts?

[@xzdrtxyzxvn]

You must be blind.. Look carefully smooth skin and gleaming new and nowhere USA product have that kind of workmanship quality. USA crude and shoddy workmanship. Not surprising spanner or hammer always left behind inside the wings. Even Boeing planes are crude looking and panels can fly off just like that.. Bad quality control and workmanship.

[@李大人-m7p]

Y-20B

[@taiwanstillisntacountry]

34T debts. Begging China for extra loans. Buy worthless USA bonds. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 So embarressing

[@CalvinHsuChen]

Taiwan is a country.😂😂😂

[@ПИЦКВлад]

❤

[@diortioinocando8976]

hehehe china vs american? more sales of this aircraft ?

[@xzdrtxyzxvn]

Look careful at C17, workmanship very bad, very rough work like back yard workshop. Look at Y20, smooth skin and great workmanship. Y20 is more beautiful thsn C17... C17 is crude in making..

[@Fan.Cooler.Heater.Motor-2012]

wow

[@qake2021]

👍👍👍🇧🇷🇷🇺🇮🇳🇨🇳🇿🇦➕️👏‼️👏

[@landryabraham642]

Y 20 rubbish

[@shuli4389]

The ChineseY-20 is just a copycat.

[@XkMeng]

@XkMeng Copying and stealing are two completely different concepts. When you are a primary school student, what you should do is learn existing knowledge, not conduct research or write a doctoral thesis. Replication and mass production are important processes in the progress of human civilization. This is why the Industrial Revolution defeated handicraft industry. If anything is only available to the first manufacturer and is not allowed to be copied by others, then the price of any new thing has nothing to do with you keyboard man losers.

[@dougmarshall4010]

Compare Y20 to C5 Galaxy. Galaxy can carry 135 tons vs Y20 55 tons with the same range of 4800 nmi

[@АндрейМ-ф5н]

Y20 66 тонн

[@Trueye-sl2mr]

C5 Galaxy need special runways while the Y20 is faster and can land on all runways

[@sweatybotfn9982]

They’re not the same class and are not designed for the same thing

[@araujofi]

C5 is no longer used by US

[@tobascocat1]

@@araujofi You need to check your source as you are very incorrect.

[@pommy2165]

CinaCopyUSA😢

[@jdwht2455]

I see no advantage to the Y-20. Slower, less capacity and shorter range and crap straight jet engines. Happy to see the Chinabots here making stupid statements about their copycat airplane

[@CalvinHsuChen]

Y20 can transform into gundam and can travel through space.

[@jdwht2455]

@@CalvinHsuChenOnly in your dreams, Chinabot

[@jefflai6077]

​@@jdwht2455why are you so proud.? With all the mighty military hardware, you guys got your sorry ass kicked by shepherds in Afghanistan and by rice farmers in Vietnam.

[@jdwht2455]

@@jefflai6077 They got their "ass kicked" by sorry Afghan and Vietnamese leadership not by poor equipment. We kicked ass in WW2, Korea as well as Iraq - where our hands weren't tied by 'diplomats'. Get your history and facts right

[@jefflai6077]

@@jdwht2455 excuse excuse, can't handle the truth.

[@junescabarte1458]

Kawasaki c2 is the best...

[@descartes824]

😂

[@jeremiahlee6335]

One works well and the other a Chinese tofu dreg

[@bobsmith3983]

Tofu like your brain.

[@CalvinHsuChen]

@@bobsmith3983 Even your name is Tofu dreg.

[@fleur6994]

copy cat😂

[@vuthalchann1237]

China..copy.!

[@XkMeng]

@XkMeng copying and stealing are two completely different concepts. When you are a primary school student, what you should do is learn existing knowledge, not conduct research or write a doctoral thesis. Replication and mass production are important processes in the progress of human civilization. This is why the Industrial Revolution defeated handicraft industry. If anything is only available to the first manufacturer and is not allowed to be copied by others, then the price of any new thing has nothing to do with you keyboard man losers.

[@kitwalker520]

Propaganda

[@dougmarshall4010]

Why spend money on R&D when you can just steal the design?

[@ouyangnina]

2023年全世界有130多个国家参加中国的一带一路大会对他们就是（第三世界国家的兄弟非洲的中东的东南亚的南美洲的）而美国欧洲是的他们是发达国家怎么看的上第三世界国家，他们只会要你的石油，粮食，廉价货物！现在中国带着第三世界国家一起发展，是的欧美害怕😨了！所以所有的第三世界国家兄弟一起走向成功吧！

[@juntisoycamen1373]

Its made in china plane, for sure its poor quality, low quality, easy to break

[@kamsunleong6648]

737 Max easy to break apart

[@recondax]

​@@kamsunleong6648Yes, the 737 series aircraft has some serious QC issues.

[@CalvinHsuChen]

@@kamsunleong6648 Cause Boeing hired cheap chinese workers.

[@Rokko-lh4fg]

China are the BEST !! So ... the rest are ... dust ! 😮😅 the best for us ... nb 2

[@mjshuja1948]

THERE IS NO MATCH 😡😡😡😡😡ONE IS REAL👍👍👍👍🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸OTHER MADE IN CHINA REPLICA 😡😡😡😡😡

[@cooldude-bronst]

Y20 its NOT competitor boeing C17, Y20 its alibaba low product quality and match compare to WWII plane😅

[@bitboy22]

😂Silly crying

[@fishchang1522]

制空權後才有空中運輸的能量，第一島鏈群體封鎖，中共極權主義的空運能意義不大。

[@wawuluiwa4647]

There are too many errors in Comparison Data eg. top data is Chinese more but bottom data are Chinese less. Non professional and careless!🔥👻🔥

[@davyren8901]

我觉得两国都很强，虽然我们有分歧，但是如果有一天外星人来了我们应该团结在一起，，因为我们都是人类。。但是这里高傲自大的人很多，，而且很无知，，傲慢，，，，

[@陈冠希-n4o]

SB

[@MM-mo2yc]

Aww. You were doing so well until the end there.

[@alustin]

@@陈冠希-n4o 不见得，我们联合外星人干掉美国岂不是更好？

[@davyren8901]

@@陈冠希-n4o 狗B，，看你那JB操行哈哈

[@tonywyli]

美国不灭，世界永远没有和平

[@peronliu6886]

C17 is definitely better.But Our India will have new plane in 2050.Indian is the best.Jahind!

[@rdmgwinn]

Hope India starts an aviation industry. Not as easy as it looks but with allies it can be sped up. India has a lot of intelligent people just waiting to share there ideas

[@cashflownpv]

1st get toilets second get rid of caste system 3rd win some Olympic medals and fourth stop begging for P5 UNSC membership

[@Harry-lw4dm]

C17 is much better. They were sold to other country and made a lot of money 😅