John defeated death

So you can actually kill Strange Man in RDR1
Follow My Social Media-
Instagram account - / reddead_dreams
Discord- / discord
Support channel with options below -
Patreon - / reddeaddreams
Make sure to subscribe so you don't miss out on my future videos.
#rdr #reddeadredemption

[@gamerbro7645]

It's so funny cause he says "I need more from u now" Also can i get pinned

[@Reddeaddreams]

Yep that was funny 😅.

[@gamerbro7645]

THX SO MUCH I LUV UR VIDS

[@Reddeaddreams]

@@gamerbro7645 your welcome mate. And thankyou so much for appreciating my work

[@gamerbro7645]

​@@ReddeaddreamsYOU ARE THE GOAT OF RDR 1 AND 2 AND ONLINE❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@gamerbro7645]

So u inspired me to make rdr1 and 2 vids❤❤❤

[@General_Nitro1020]

Strange Man: “DAMN YOU!” John: “Not that many have, but some did!”

[@heldhostageplshelp]

Arthur from the afterlife: TENNIS BOAT🎾 ⛵

[@Micahs-left-pistol-better]

@yigit-nh2vnI’m not in hell👹😈😡

[@DaddyLumbago]

Always thought it was so odd that they didn’t make him invincible like in the later cutscene. Really ruins the mystery of him

[@Journey_to_who_knows]

He’s observing your behaviour, it’s your free will but it will also be your punishment

[@themadtitan7603]

At the same time, making him invisible might've spoiled the reveal of him being a supernatural figure in the end. Before the last cutscene, he was a strange, illusive man who's intentions and nature weren't clear.

[@DaddyLumbago]

@@themadtitan7603but him not being a supernatural figure now ruins the fact that he’s a supernatural figure later

[@themadtitan7603]

​@@DaddyLumbago I know. That's why i said "At the same time." I think they should've handled it a whole other way. Because both making him invincible and not invincible now ruin his supernatural aura later.

[@descendantofartorias2067]

​@@themadtitan7603have you seen literally every rdr video on KZbin? I'm pretty sure I've seen you in the comments of all of them.

[@Paradise385]

John is not afraid of death. Death's afraid of John 😂

[@Reddeaddreams]

Lol, this is really funny when Strange man is really reference of death

[@Javizilvia]

Video Idea from me: Arthur tries to go to Tall Trees and New Austin.

[@PurelyHyperbolic]

I dont know whats funnier. John, the ex-bumbling gunslinger, unmetaphorically killing death. Or the fact that the Strange Man carries Chewing Tobacco.

[@themadtitan7603]

RDR1 John was anything but a bumbling gunslinger. RDR2's portrayal doesn't translate here.

[@NobleHunter]

​​@@themadtitan7603He said that RDR1 John is an EX-bumbling gunslinger.

[@themadtitan7603]

@@NobleHunter I think they edited it.

[@PurelyHyperbolic]

@@NobleHunter I did edit it.

[@javiervasquez625]

Haven't you heard the news?: Tobacco _kills_ last i heard so there might have been an intent at irony when Rockstar decided to put tobacco into the Strange Man's belongings.

[@wrad3879]

"Now i have become death"

[@Skibidigigachadsigma777]

"Now i become the plan, the goddamn plan"

[@KAY4ZZ]

Of the destroyer of worlds.

[@marsayde1237]

Now I am become the death… of Death.

[@mafia_gamer_official30973]

Probably this will be nice : "Now I have become Death - the destroyer of Dutch's goddamn plan"

[@Miltypooh2001]

I remember the first time encountering him i accidentally pushed him while i tried to trigger his mission, i ended up getting a mission failed but by some miracle he respawned like it was nothing

[@mariarichardson7869]

That happens with all quest NPCs to stop you from getting permanently locked out of completing their quests.

[@average__height8033]

@@mariarichardson7869”I know you” isn’t a mandatory side quest for 100%

[@Grayson-tk5hn]

@@average__height8033 so? they neve said it was

[@average__height8033]

@@Grayson-tk5hn it's been 7 months get over it 😭

[@Grayson-tk5hn]

@@average__height8033 I ONLY SAW IT YERESEDAY SO IT HAS ONLY BEEN 16 hoURS FPR ME

[@Mr-Prasguerman]

Little did John know he was just pretending

[@AbsoluteRatBastard]

merely pretending

[@theCreature773]

John got fed up with his ominous and borderline future-telling statements about his life

[@squindigglyjigglybop1300]

john must not like spoilers

[@Nintendominator]

Yay! John is fine! He wont ever fall to classic opening the barn trick!

[@ComputerAddict23]

He decided to go himself.

[@ryszakowy]

and after this death stands behing john: you seem impatient, are you in a rush?

[@etov2004TV]

''i don't believe you!'' ''HEAVEN-''

[@still_write]

Abigail: John what have you done? You killed death! Now uncle will live forever.

[@JustMabember]

"John kills and loots death"

[@Swedishmafia101MemeCorporation]

"This Chewing Tobacco is brought to you by Death!"

[@Gamerman2910]

I love how because of rdr1 physics engine shooting someone with a low caliber gun in the chest/stomach makes them do 2 backflips and fly several feet backwards😂

[@whyareusobad3528]

.45 is considered low caliber since when😂

[@Max-ek3kf]

@@whyareusobad3528 yes it is a low caliber round.

[@whyareusobad3528]

@@Max-ek3kf .50 is considered like the largest normal caliber (aside from shotguns) Low caliber is usually.35 or below (for pistols ) and 30 or below for (rifles) 45 is huge for both lol

[@Max-ek3kf]

​@@whyareusobad3528 what you are referring to is diameter. caliber is different

[@whyareusobad3528]

@@Max-ek3kf your telling me a life long shooter and someone who works with guns for a living that I’m wrong when a quick google search backs me up?

[@rebelboi88]

*Arthur comes back out of nowhere* "Helluva shot mister"

[@cnrksn]

Bro about to become Sisyphus

[@baguettysheppy1740]

I found it funny when I came back to the game to do another playthrough and then accidentally pushed him off the cliff with my horse after just talking to him lol

[@ttm_53]

Now I've become world, the destroy of the death

[@joshuatremper5026]

He looks like Trelawney

[@otgcheedo]

John: "I need it more than you now" Also John: **shoots a man for chewing tobacco** 💀

[@Isaac_646]

I think it would be so much more creepy if the player kills him, but she shows up in another cutscene again, and doesent acknowledge John killing him before.

[@rookie9028]

'' I don't believe you '' shoots him in the head

[@alkhoaja]

you mean the torso.

[@AntiWokeIsJustWoke]

I got him with the exploding rifle that came out a month after the game. Anyone else remember that? No one seems to remember when I mention it.

[@dumbmoose5271]

Johns like "Ima do my own thing" 💀💀

[@hazmatfirehero6318]

I really want to be able to just fail quests on purpose in new rockstar games. Sure, they can have a pop up where “you failed”, but give an option to retry. I get not killing allies, but there are other ways to do it that don’t feel as bad

[@cream_pieluver]

Then i became death Destroyer of worlds -John marston

[@Jumpyman_thegamerYT]

The fact that you're even able to k*ll quest characters without mods shows exactly why this game could use a remaster, honestly. Like, imagine accidentally shooting a really important character....

[@Michigan_npc]

​@@itsBriebear you dont want a remaster

[@user-uo8ny1kj4c]

I emulate it just fine on my steam deck using the nintendo switch version

[@somethingtoputonpizza6667]

Max Payne 3 and red dead 1 and 2 and the Man hunt games are some how more violent then rock stars newer games

[@alkhoaja]

Manhunt machete/chainsaw executions were gruesome.

[@FunnyRedemption]

I did this by accident and failed the mission lol.

[@Reddeaddreams]

yes, you won't get any missions from him if you kill him

[@FunnyRedemption]

@@Reddeaddreams It's a shame you cannot retry stranger missions after failing them like this.

[@derpyplayground]

@@FunnyRedemptionyou can retry the Remember my family stranger mission

[@FunnyRedemption]

@@derpyplayground Yeah but that's because they lead to the credits of the game.

[@Solutra]

@@FunnyRedemption i literally retried this mission after killing the strange man yesterday

[@marcospunkposermedina4819]

lol I remembered after the strange man finished talking. I immediately pushed him down the mountain and the mission was cancelled.

[@johnwmalesevic]

I used to kill him all the time. It took me awhile to actually talk to him at all.

[@JustinCage56]

Forgot how funny the ragdolls in this game was.

[@Thelast3ambender263]

My brother did this and I said “that’s the most powerful John” 😭🙏

[@ethanbishop802]

I dont think he was death because the people he goes for in the missions dont die

[@TheDNT100]

"I know you quest failed." He know EVERYTHING.

[@beelzebub7221]

the good ending, where john goes and escapes with his family to tahiti to live a long and healthy life

[@crusader2112]

Upon slaying death. John found himself being transformed. His clothes turned to all black and he felt a ghostly aura come over him. He was now death doomed to guide people to their ultimate destiny for eternity, or until someone strong slayed him.

[@CemenntDascobkrert]

[TRANSCRIPT] Strange Man: Well, are you gonna do what I aske - John: I don't believe it! Also John: *pops him like a balloon*

[@just_joonster1784]

bro fought nature.

[@bluexboxgamer2613]

I remember killing him with the Double Barrelled. He was very hard to kill.

[@Max2ds]

So this is why Undead Nightmare happens

[@lt8566]

That's why John Marston became a zombie after that. Death didn't exist anymore...

[@JJ-je5dl]

He can kill death but can’t swim 💀

[@pontushaggstrom6261]

"directed by george lucas"

[@NwarMedia]

14 years later and i didnt even know i could do that ! and i replayed this game 3 times and the nightmare edition #SMH

[@anaillobre5036]

-well? Are you gonna do what I asked? John: I DONT BELIVE YOU

[@deltadog6530]

“I don’t believe you 🗣️”

[@outerhaven8568]

he just shot trelawny...god dammit boe

[@spugamer]

John became Kratos lol

[@Myyoutube625]

🎶 "Trampling down death by death!" 🎶

[@user-nk6up5rn8z]

Puss in boots final rival

[@KaylebKuhn]

This guy spared John’s life❤

[@Th_Uslss_Indvdl]

I’m still pretty positive that the Strange Man is supposed to be a figure of god. He mentions his son at one point and the one nun he sends John to help says that God sent John to help her.

[@Viper.TR06]

Mission name?

[@ruty_bolzga424]

​@@Viper.TR06"I know you"

[@stefanieslater8950]

John marston the one who killed death but couldn't out run death

[@Valentino-29]

I guess that means John is the new death

[@mtnt2]

Puss in Boots Last wish in nutshell:

[@pcgamingwalkthrough]

the love for RDR2 never fades! ❤

[@morgangamez]

This is rdr1

[@WitnessesSay]

0 evidence game theory. Thats not the strange man who speaks to us. Thats the avatar he speaks to use through. He relinquished control afterward

[@themadtitan7603]

I never heard that before but it makes a lot of sense. I always assumed that wasn't the Strange Man's true form given its supernatural nature but I never thought he might've possessed someone. That would explain why he's able to be killed here.

[@WitnessesSay]

@@themadtitan7603 after all, death comes in many forms.

[@Huy-G-Le]

Just because you shot him and stole his wallet, you mugger! Doesn't mean you killed him. For all we know he is already undead. We have entire dlc of zombies of this have never tick?

[@privateerbouncher9622]

“That is a great spot”

[@gi-joe_510CA]

The loot certain characters have is crazy 😂

[@WARRIOR_2090]

Imagine if he got good honor points for that

[@lazymonkeyboi]

his name is john, and he looks like his name should be john, and he looks like john wilkes booth.

[@Ferrochrome12]

Chewing Tobacco

[@gamerakkipad5098]

Damn Close Shot🔥

[@JoshuFoFo]

That’s the husband of the woman Dutch killed in blackwater

[@Grayson-tk5hn]

i feel like they shouldve made it so if you shot at him he would just disappear

[@b00m224]

good ending

[@EnguluEdits44]

no, john defeated: reaper, devil, death, and god

[@shadowinthenight26]

Kratos and John Marston:both can defeat death and that makes them the most badass in the world.

[@reefmyers4015]

This shows we overestimated the strange mans power

[@dj0x825]

Even the jack is going to die now💀

[@ririgo2804]

Fun fact the quote jhon said "I need it more than you now" after looting the body, CJ in gta san andreas says the same thing when he takes money from a corpse.Did i play too much Gta san andreas ?Yes 🙂

[@iamthisiam]

I never considered killing him.

[@kz6_killer]

Fun fact: strange man is known as grim reaper

[@kiro-sv9to]

Chewing tobacco was worth it

[@otioti264]

That is not Death silly, that is the Strange Man, from Red Dead Redemption

[@Kingsaxxy3872]

The Strange Man is implied to be the Death of the RDR universe since John couldn’t shoot in the cutscene, and he seemed to know where John would be buried.

[@justajad2809]

This makes me happy, just so much that it's possible. Love you Rockstar.

[@PranomAdityaGogoi]

is that trelawny?

[@xcastdx]

ye

[@Reddeaddreams]

No, he dress up like Trelawny but he is Strange Man

[@FrostyBastion]

Lost 50 honor even though he killed death or saten himself. Its more likely he's death though

[@Indieindrocan]

@tgtme still think the strange man would beat aurthur

[@Space_c-o-r-e]

Strange man:”Are you gonna do what I asked?” John: ”I don’t believe you!” *Shoots the strange man* Strange man: ”heaven!”

[@Jessesloveshack]

This looks like a nice spot.

[@RicklessSanchez]

To me I thought he was a ghost? /:(

[@Adamsause7]

One time i did this he fell of the cliff but got back up

[@ooooothatsshit158]

I remember i pushed him off the cliff and he screamed "I ALWAYS KNEW YOU WERE A ASSHOLE" or something like that

[@tigerax9953]

Bro I did that and I’m going to consider that as an accomplishment

[@JustChris347]

i pushed him off the cliff when the quest ended😂

[@LiftUpYourEyes]

That guy doesn't represent death. I think hes supposed to be God.

[@DearestAda]

Death - "You know we'll meet again... right? John - "Nah." *BLAM*

[@brix801]

Wait that's it? That's how can kill him

[@thewanderer182]

Noooo!😢 He killed Trelawny

[@CJ_Fino]

-50 honor

[@FrOhhhhZeN]

Why isn’t this red dead on PC? Seems like most other rockstar games are

[@arjunstephen399]

is that trelawny?

[@basedbattledroid3507]

I still firmly believe this guy wasn't a supernatural presence (made no appearance in Undead Nightmare so duh) rather an ordinary flesh and bone gentleman and that in the scene where John tried to shoot him; his sights were off, now that you've shot him at point blank and a reservoir of crimson moisture cascaded through his chest, I can confirm my suspicions

[@ui9kq2xa5c]

the blood effect is ridiculous. physics is weird.

[@josesuarezgarrido4602]

😐

[@YOUEATBABIES19112]

Bro it's a game from 2010 what do you expect

[@jamesnoriega4698]

Was the strange man ever real tho? I feel he was just John's conscience.

[@feiwnakausvkaxbdkebkswowbq8331]

He has a house in RDR2 so yeah. And the guy Arthur gets to either save or drop from the cliff in the beginning was actually a trial from him.