John was Always Cold-Hearted in RDR, except in this one Mission..

[@backlandjbreaker24]

In RDR2 John always act like the happiest man alive 😂😂

[@themadtitan7603]

@backlandjbreaker24 I think in the epilogue specifically, yeah. He's always shouting jovially when greeting NPCs "You, mister!" and swaggers around like a character in a sitcom who's just walked out of "his first time".

[@backlandjbreaker24]

@ Yeah and you can just see the happiness in his face 😂

[@themadtitan7603]

I don't thinkhe's always cold-hearted. He has several moments with Bonnie, Mr. McFarlane, Marshall Johnson, Landon Ricketts, & Luisa or several stranger characters where he's respectful, friendly, & even jovial & helpful when it wouldn't benefit him. He's simply surrounded by hostile strangers for most of the story which is why he's often on edge.

[@backlandjbreaker24]

Yeah he is only angry with time wasters like West Dickens and Irish 😂

[@themadtitan7603]

​@@backlandjbreaker24 Yeah, it seems like people only see or remember the viral "savage" moments he has with those characters & make it his whole personality. Even saying that Arthur was kinder & more moral as a result.

[@realQuestion]

My view is a little simpler: I think both John and Arthur were nice back to anyone who was nice to them. Anyone else...nope.

[@themadtitan7603]

​@@realQuestion Is it? That's pretty much my view too. My OP is simply longer because I list the different characters who John was respectful and/or friendly with and I end by saying that he's just surrounded by mostly hostile people, hence the usual aggression. Unless you simply meant you express it simpler.

[@ArthurMuneh]

0:30 this part is heartbreaking

[@maggotbeIIy]

@@ArthurMuneh You're doing horrible things to my hormones miss

[@Coolguy_2020]

John getting rizzy towards the end

[@maggotbeIIy]

And yet it didn’t bring him anything

[@jasperdreamer9342]

1:18 John enjoying the taste of dinner 💀

[@asapmercury]

bro just wanted to hit 💀