I Don't Own ANY Hardware Synths...Here's Why!

[@Johnmike]

What do you guys use!??? Let me know down in the comments! 👇🏾👇🏾

[@johnhyon8519]

Since covid-19, ive had the chance to dig deeper into MIDI.. I use Native instruments with Studio One. I use a Komplete Kontrol S49 with my MODX as a slave. Works well. Now... I have had both hardware(yamaha p90 power failure) and software glitches ( Mainstage for church) during live performance. To be honest, my macbook pro was 10 years old, and is probaby the reason it glitched, and I keep an extra power adapter on me..

[@swordis45]

I use an akai mini controller. I also agree that hardware is too expensive. It is cheaper to use Vst's. Even though I like the MPC Live 2

[@julianwilliamsTSW]

Nektar GX61 is awesome for my set. Looking at shifting to controllers for church

[@-_39]

computer keyboard lol

[@clarkkent93]

Studio Logic SL88 Grand, M Audio MKS 88, Scarlet 2i2 3rd Gen, Keyscape, Mainstage 3 Sunday Keys 2021, Korg Nano Kontrol 2, Studio One 4 and Garage Band , a pair of Adams T7V's 2019 Mac Book Pro 16-inch 2.6 GHz 6-Core i7 16 GB All of which with the exception of Keyscape and Mac and monitors were recommended by you my Brother. Thank you so much for that. The M-Audio MKS88 I use for Church.

[@James-cn9no]

I use a Native Instruments S88 MK2. I love MIDI for being able to record ideas and having a record of what I played. No more trying to figure out that chord voicing 6 weeks later. Just look at the MIDI editor and all the notes are there. And also being able to hot swap software instruments on to what I played. Try it in a keyboard, guitar, horn section... MIDI rules!

[@benwash865]

Mike I totally agree! I will add a couple more reasons for me 1) Portability The last keyboard I purchased was the Yamaha Motif 8 (2002) I still have it today! I used to haul that beast around from gig to gig. It was exhausting. The case was just as heavy as the keyboard. 2) Less learning curve Everytime a new keyboard comes out there is a learning curve unless you are sticking with the same manufacturer. As a musician all I want are the sounds. Thanks for this video.

[@jptaylor]

John Mike - the most trusted source of everything music tech on KZbin. Always love your great and informative videos! Keep up the great work!

[@rios_5314]

I got the best of both worlds. Omnisphere 2 & Keyscape, Komplete 13, 2019 16 Inch Macbook Pro, apollo twin mk2, Yamaha YC88. All set.

[@robynmiles31]

Watching your reviews helped me select my midi controllers. I have the SL88 studio and the Oxygen Pro 61, still learning them tho

[@hanovergreen4091]

I've purchased two on his recommendations :)

[@Yhuntermusic]

Midi is indeed the future! I literally found about 90% of my hardware modules sounds online for half the price 😂🤣🤷🏾‍♂️ Great vid rev!!!

[@Johnmike]

Facts!! 😂

[@edunabie]

Sure, but you can't sell software on (mostly). I quite like to buy and sell gear just to try it out

[@tuneunleashed]

@@edunabie what’s the point of buying something and selling it later on anyway? You lose money. I’d rather buy just to buy when it comes to software.

[@scottpenn9032]

this channel stands out among music production channels in how well-written, well-argued these videos are. I have a synth bass at home from church (worship from home and all) and still if I had to pick between a MIDI controller and a decent computer with a DAW and the hardware it'd be a no-brainer. software is the future and we are living in the future. subbed

[@CharlieB3rd]

On Point Big Bro!!!! Software IS HERE and less expensive! And, SOUND INCREDIBLE!!!!

[@casadasmelodias3379]

I really agree, midi is the future. You don't need much space for instruments, pianos, drums, perc...very useful in therms of studio.

[@tuneunleashed]

That is definitely not true. When it comes to organic instruments yes. Synthesis? No. It won’t replace hardware cause plugins won’t replace the 3D ness of a Moog for example. It won’t replace the organics of synthesis but when it just comes down to organic instruments yes.

[@casadasmelodias3379]

@@tuneunleashed right, I agree for moog will not replace by now, but it depends on what you want. Not everybody care if it is close as possible to a real moog, midi keyboard is the way to the future.

[@tomasjones3755]

Agreed. I started using MacBook & VST, on my live rig, in 2007. By 2009, I went full controller & MainStage; 60+ shows. In 2010, we non-stop road toured for 4 months. I packed a backup computer & extra inexpensive controller, on the bus. They were never needed. I've never looked back. These days, I have two 88 note controllers & Korg NanoKontrol2 (more parameter controls). On solo shows, I also have MIDI bass pedals. Running GigPerformer, 34 instruments on tap, into six zones. Everything just works.

[@Johnmike]

Amazing!

[@BrianMarshall1]

I like both. Sometimes I like the limitations and known quantity of my JP8000, MS20 mini, JX3P, etc. I've not found plugins that really replace that. A few years ago when I started using virtual instruments I'd find myself trying multiple plugins with lots of different settings and it just felt like a huge time suck. Lately I've been using plugins a lot more. If I have any issue with VSTs it's often the interface rather than the sounds. Like not being able to resize plugins that are super small on screen is very annoying.

[@Lumios_UA]

First time I tried using Mainstage at my church it glitched and I had to restart my Mac. Half the song was just vocals, drums and electro guitar. Most people thought it was meant to be that way but my faith in MIDI/software took a hit. Not sure what caused the glitch though. Nowadays I'm rebooting the Mac before each rehearsal, switching off Bluetooth, WiFi, screensavers and whatever else I can to make sure nothing gets in the way.

[@benjaminlazaro938]

I would add that I only get what I want and I don't buy sounds that I don't want in case I'm not a synthesis designer. And of course, no synthesis design will match the sampling of real acoustic instruments. Thanks for sharing your experience.

[@tonylancer7367]

For the point under software, I think Roland could be leading the pack in terms of software, because, with their new update to the Fantom, they loaded all the classic Roland synths onto the Fantom, which makes it very interesting. I think hardware manufacturers are probably going to look towards making the hardware an extension of the software, that is, since many works in DAWs and have VSTs, make the VST powerful so they can create their sounds, and when they are ready, connect your synth, download your sounds and off you go. Korg does the same thing but not very elegantly. I am not sure about Yamaha though. But with computers getting faster and faster and more reliable, we might see hardware just being a second option for many.

[@gigngamer]

Analog is better in complex modulations (no digital encoding so no aliasing) . and more fun to use, Fun is a big part of music.

[@winip9261]

Absolutely agree with you on this and I'm an old guy who has a room full of more than 30 kbds. When it comes to getting things done I'm in the box for 80% of the time. You have to love being able to get to what you want in virtually no time. No question, I still love playing the real things a lot, but getting stuff done usually takes precedence.

[@Josephduganmusic]

As a saxophonist I like to get analog and hardware synths because I find limitation to be one of the most inspiring things in music creation. I also use soft synths with MIDI but I do love when an instrument does one thing haha

[@lanmichaelmix2818]

i prefer hardware BUT it MUST truly give me the value i need,and i must knowledgeable and create true music from that stuff.Modular synths are the most expensive gear and so many people are just the kid and toy using those,they make no good music out of it and their rooms look totally like an LED bulb with a ton of wires.Some people are just collecting synthesizers because that's their hobby.But real synthesizer especially analog and vintage ones is really good especially in electronic music,it depends.

[@RaymondAinyam]

Midi keyboards have their place. However, for live performances, hardwares are the best option. Especially with newer keyboards like Korg Kronos, and Roland Fantoms with Setlist modes and scenes. They make it quite easy to perform live. And when you take time to learn the hardware keyboards, they are just as powerful as software. There is a relationship you build with a keyboard workstation after you use it for a while.

[@RaymondAinyam]

@A Google User it seems you're more of a music producer than a gigging musician. You should probably sell your Kronos. VSTs and midi controllers are best for the studio. Hardware keyboards are best for live. The ability to play up to 16 sounds at a time, connect external midi controllers to play sounds on the hardware, switch from one scene to another instantly are all great reasons to get a hardware keyboard. You can do all of that on PC but the process isn't as simple and reliable. They all have their place as I said. I use Novation Impulse 61 with VSTs at home. And I use Roland Fantom G8 and Korg Kross 2 for aux keys at my church. The main keys guy uses a Kronos. And we're more than happy with what we're able to do

[@MBMWorship]

Love this! ABSOLUTELY AGREE!

[@leonardovmusic]

I use and and recommend software, but for live I use hardware.

[@jaydabliu]

I love this... I also moved to software (I use mainstage with plugins like Scarbee 88-es, Ravenscroft 275, Serum, etc almost exclusively now for these very reasons.)... Another thing I would add to this list is, if you're a traveling musician, it keeps your rig pretty light... I used to lug my Motif and Nord with me everywhere with no assistant and it wasnt fun... Haha. Having all your sounds on your computer means you also have consistent sound selections with you crafted to your liking (for example if you were traveling with your hardware instruments and one day decide you dontt wanna travel with them and the place you were going didnt have similar hardware as you have, it'd be a problem but if you're using software, all you'd need from them is a controller and you're good)

[@xxxxneoxxxx]

I am using a Korg m50 workstation I grabbed a year ago. I was tempted to buy a Yamaha DX7 that popped up in my area but decided against it. I rediscovered your channel and remembered that I had recorded my first bits using an old Casio board... And actually I can still use it. The Korg is nicer, but really in terms of sounds, the Korg and the VSTs I have already give me everything I need and more. Even more so, nowadays that I'm not performing and doubt I will be in months to come... I don't need any fancy or vintage boards. What I need is to sit down and play and record stuff.

[@vivicomplex]

all else aside something i like about midi is how economic the .MID (etc) filetype is on disk space

[@oslekyios]

I've first learned about midi controllers around 2016. This is when I watched one of your videos where you were using an Iphone connected to different keys. Then, I bought my first midi: Akai MPK mini mk2 and used Caustic as my first DAW. Until now, I've been checking your informative reviews and what is latest on midi controller territory.

[@dartist1176]

I'd also add you save time fixing usual technical issues, particularly in authentic vintage gear. I'm not against to use analog stuff, but at least I think we need to be aware pros and cons before buy.

[@GospelMusic4Life]

I use both at times. Mostly hardware but I have software as a backup. I carry around my iPad and micro keys air in case something goes wrong with hardware. I’m a little reserved in going software completely because sometimes updates or lack there of can break things. You could go the route of not updating but then you are in the same boat of gear becoming outdated. The Kong Taktile was on the right track but I’m not sure why they got rid of it. IK multimedia has something with the iRig io and SampleTank but then it lacks a lot of the control as other midi controllers and has proprietary ports. I wish there was a lightweight 73/76 key midi controller with full pads, knobs, and sliders. I would get that and be straight with iPad/computer.

[@DopamineOverload]

Couldn't agree more. I have SOME hardware (smaller, cheap stuff). But 95% of my studio is midi controllers. And way too many, but it's hard to get rid of a lot of 'em. :)

[@matt8443416]

One point you missed John is that midi board is replaceable you can switch out and use another .. for example if you buy nord for 5k and in the future the key bed damage the keyboard non valid until you pay arm and leg to get it replaced rather buying a midi fr $100 , as long as you have your laptop are iPad

[@Bashanvibe]

I definitely agree with the price and the quality of the patches. I was going to ask what about what happens when it crashes but you briefly mentioned both sides of them. At the end of the day it boils down to personal preference.

[@rafaeljr.navera2788]

As I have viewed this video, I do really agree of what you had said because I have tried Yamaha, Roland, Korg hardware synths and they are costly and after a year there will be another model to release :-) And from there I realize that I don't have that much money to purchase new keyboards. So I decided to buy midi keyboard (IRIG Keys) and my Ipad Air 2 and bought paid apps and it really sounds amazing and now I have upgraded to Ipad Pro M1 and have downloaded my previous apps to it. I use it both for live gig and studio recording . Thank you for sharing your videos and it really saves me a lot of money which I don't need to buy hardware keyboards. More Power to your Channel

[@Johnmike]

🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾

[@HighlandStudio91]

All valid points dude....however,there are some exceptions & some minor advantages to certain hardware keyboards.In particular....keyboards like the Korg Kronos & Nautilus are essentially PC DAW's that are housed in a hardware chassis.In the case of Korg,their workstations utilize a Linux OS(reliable & immune to viruses.Like a PC,these keyboards have a hard drive,have quite a bit of different factory software programs,have multiple synth engines built in and are expandable,in terms of additional sound libraries.Yes...the initial cost is considerably more expensive,but there is no registration or installation issues(such as the numerous ones I've had,with Native Instruments software.) Actually....once a PC user begins to become advanced in their recording techniques & accumulates vast sound libraries,CPU power & storage space becomes a serious issue.Case in point....amy RPropellerhaed Reason 10 program,is one of the most bloated & resource-hungry software programs in existence.While the cost of it is very reasonable for what you get,you need a monster computer to run it and that can get expensive. Ultimately though...I had to make the choice to upgrade to a new PC tower & the M-Audio Hammer Pro(rather than buy a Korg Nautilus,as the payments on the damn thing,would have got in the way of me making the necessary studio monitor upgrade,that I need.Also....I just didn't want to be bogged down with debt,by making year-long monthly payments on the Korg.The Korg Nautilus is the only really decent alternative to that of a PC set-up....so as far as I am concerned,every other brand of hardware keyboard out there with recording capabilities is an absurd choice to make,over a computer workstation.

[@mhediseltana]

Really appreciate your thought. Actually I'm using both of hardware and software when I'm on stage. I think there's no way to compare. Each one has pro and con.. but I agree that future will be in software..

[@stevejnobaptiste4608]

I started using midi controllers, not because I wanted to, but because I could not afford a Triton or Motif or anyway hardware at the time. Here's my list in order from 2006 till now: 1- M audio Oxygen Mk1 (Grey model) 2- Novation Launchkey Mk1 (Orange) 3- Acorn Masterkey 61 4- Acorn Masterkey 61(Bought another 1) 4- Samson Carbon 49 5- Alesis Vi49 6- Alesis Vi61.. Still own #'s 2,4,5,6

[@ryanrice]

Hey buddy! What are your thoughts on the Novation Impulse model, specifically the 61 key? I'm looking to sell my Keystation MKII and get it, but haven't seen a decent enough review of one to convince me to pull the trigger.

[@patrickarend8707]

Excellent video! I use to use hardware synths only, but when i got a taste of software synths and a good DAW, i was hooked. I do have a YAMAHA MODX as a controller and some sounds, and it works great, but it would be no problem for me to start using a dedicated midi controller like NI. Personally, subjectively, i think software blows hardware out of the water, be it sounds or functionality. Although i love my YAMAHA MODX, eventually i will go full on midi controller like NI. I will still keep my MODX as my last hardware synth ever. Also, I am thinking of getting the AKAI MPK MINI 3 after watching your video on it. That little controller is pretty darn cool.

[@ashdee]

I use a retro combo of the 2 so M-Audio Pro Keys Sono 61 (with built in Audio interface handy when on the road or aggregating with main audio interface for expanded I/O setup) for all synths drums etc and use a Korg SP 300 for weighted piano tracking as a slave to VSTs but rarely use on board sounds maybe when practising for next Sunday service!

[@tuneunleashed]

Looking back to this vid. John Mike was right!!

[@billykranberry6077]

I'm split between getting M-Audio Keystation mk3 61 or Oxygen IV 61. Features & extra knobs aside, You emphasized the importance of the "feel" of the keys so i was wondering if the synth action on the oxygen is similar or better than semi weighted keystation in terms of feel and noise Plus maybe you can do a more in depth video about keybeds and key feel in midi keyboards. Keep on making awesome content!

[@drtolgaege]

Also the MIDI keyboard is another type of hardware. IMHO etc. if you have a Yamaha motif XF keyboard, keep it up with you. It’s a real instrument and it’s build quality is like a tank and much better than most of MIDI controllers. I have Korg trinity purchased in 90’s and I still love it. However my computer (MacBook Pro it’s value was $3000) I bought in 2009 does not work at the end of 10 years.for this reason big companie’s trend like Yamaha, Nord and Korg is to produce live performance keyboards such as Montage , Nord stage etc. I have last purchased Yamaha montage it is a great performance keyboard and it can be combine well with most DAWs. It has a build in 32 channel audio interface, touchscreen , faders , knobs , envelope follower...

[@lanmichaelmix2818]

lol every things are physical and it's all hardware.In fact computers are far more vulnerable than the synthesizer circuit boards.

[@joegrant413]

I've been thinking about getting a midi controller for my iPad apps, I have a bunch of them. but I hate futzing around with MIDI mapping. What do you guys think should I go forward with something that has midi knobs, or just try to keep things as simple as possible with a midi controller and gets keys only?

[@jurgenschilinski6677]

I would get one with some knobs and pads , been making music on the ipad since way back and my feeling is that it´s more hands on with some knobs and pads for more creativity ! Do it :)

[@joegrant413]

@@jurgenschilinski6677Thx! which controller do you have? And do you have a go-to iPad app? Model D and Patterning 2 are my current favs.Just have a humble Nanokey controller.

[@jurgenschilinski6677]

Joe Grant Cool , I also have the Nanokey Studio Keyboard and the Novation Launchkey 25 that works with IOS and the keys and pads on that controller is way more smoother than the Nanokeys so nice to have some variations ... I really like the nanokey with it´ s built in arpeggio and chord pad possibillities so in a way i think for me it suits my production style to have that in a midikeyboard , but the keys and pads on the Novation makes me wanna play live stuff on the keyboard with more feeling to it . I use Cubasis and Nanostudio 1 and even Korg Gadget as my Daws and then i use Audiobus to route all of my IOS synths , drummachines to Cubasis for recording the audio I use Sunrizer Imini Arturia ISEM IElectribe Audiokits Synth One this one is a free download , you just go and download it , you will be suprised in the soundquality AudioKit Synth One Synthesizer av AudioKit Pro apps.apple.com/se/app/audiokit-synth-one-synthesizer/id1371050497

[@BluesCat1980]

The only issue I have with software driven stuff is you have to carry around a computer and an interface. It is nice to be able to just plug in a keyboard and not have to worry a computer.

[@BluesCat1980]

There are also keyboards that are standalone units that have sine very nice editing features.

[@TuhinTulsyan]

My aim is just to learn to play by hear. What do I need? A digital piano? midi controller? Weighted keys? Semi weighted keys? Keyboard? 88 keys? Hans Zimmer inspires me, I just want to play his music. Please suggest a model 🙏 Thanks & regards

[@michel.etcheverry]

Very interesting video ! I am looking for a midi controller keyboard 88 keys semi-weighted, able to give a good acoustic piano sensation. I want to use it for gigs with a singer in duo. One of my favorites is the Nectar GXP 88 but I'm not decided yet.

[@javiermoralesrodriguez278]

Nice video John! I've watched almost all your videos about midi keyboards, and I'm going to buy the studiologic sl88 studio! Do you think is better than the Arturia Keylab 88 essential? Love your channel!

[@Johnmike]

Yup it’s miles better than the arturia

[@MrAndy91486]

I think this is the route I’m going. Only midi controllers. You can get everything on software now

[@thepricillove5244]

I was partial to a 76 tone Casio keyboard. It suited my powerful finge rs quite well. I could set up presets. It ws s flat and of low profile. However no pitch or mod wheel. As a consequence of these important things, I have no idea where it is.

[@hermandavid1757]

Is there a hardware controller specifically for organ ?I have been forced to make the switch and I have main stage and I’m wondering if there is something that is a controller with the midi drawbars and the bass and expression pedals...trying to avoid getting the viscount or the Nord they are just to expensive

[@Johnmike]

Check out the Crumar Mojo

[@hermandavid1757]

@@Johnmike I have it’s between the crumar mojo and the viscount legend right now...the viscount Is winning because it has the Leslie hookup...but I’m looking at all my options...appreciate it bro 💪🏾

[@tuneunleashed]

That’s a tough call. I think they both have their pros and cons. You said it yourself! Software is unlimited which is great but it’s also it’s biggest downfall. People would spend over 10,000$ on plugins alone which is absolutely insane because of that. Hardware you are limited which is great because it pushes your creativity but it’s also bad lol because you always want more and it’s much more expensive for sounds that are lackluster. Software has latency issue at times...with hardware there is no any latency l. Hardwares are basically ultimate midi controllers if you think about it with sounds in it as a back up just in case your computer crashes live or something. Most controllers don’t even have attack, decay, sustain and release lol. John you’re absolutely right when it comes down to software I’m not going to lie to ya the sounds are much more better in software for studio use but when it comes to live there is not a better feeling playing a hardware instrument. When it comes to organic instruments software>>>>>>>>>Nord, Yamaha, Korg, Roland, Dexibell you name it. When it comes to analog instruments in terms of realism Moog,Dave Smiths>>>>>>>>>>Software. Digital may be more versatile because you can stack more polyphony and all but it won’t catch that earthiness, 3Dness and just that sound of those synths but they can come like to 70% but you will still feel somethings missing. So yeah...both is good.

[@edsstuffs01]

Why would someone buy a very expensive keyboard to realized they are confined to a particular use, to end up converting it to a midi controller? I have use a Williams Allegro II because of YOUR REVIEW!!! And I love it.

[@tuneunleashed]

Better controllers lol

[@shawndoe6843]

Because everyone doesn’t like playing on them cheap ass plastic Fisher - Price made midi controllers keyboards I hate them damn things who cares about price if you don’t have the money get out the Craft

[@JCox964]

Excellent in-depth information!!!! 🔥🔥🔥🎹🎹🎹

[@tyronecrawford7245]

Will playing pluggins like Ravenscroft 275 sound better on the Ipad pro or will it sound the same on a regular ipad such as 5th generation

[@furiobisotti8150]

Personal opinion. I play keyboards in some rock cover bands. We are amateurs, not professional. But I like to do it at my best, of course. I am going 100% software too. Why? Because software simulation of big and heavy vintage instruments are much better as VST than with hw synths. An Hammond organ, a Moog Modular, a Fender Rhodes are miles better with VSTs than with expensive synthesizers. And on synthetic things too: try Diva to check if I am right. And gap is increasing, new VSTs are hugely improving. Hardware synthesizers don't.

[@a.c.j.8751]

I was looking for differences and saw the following (debating never hurt anyone, right?): 1 - Cost. Cost of Korg or Yamaha is actually justifiable: they can produce an entire song for you, all you have to do is just add the piano. You can also mix and arrange. Also, they come with really good voice effects and everything is really fast to adjust. They are arrangers and workstations and allow you to be in live concerts mimicking and entire band. Not to talk about sound quality, which is super high, they keybed which is always great, etc. 2 - Control - as they have USB, all can be used as a midi controller, too. Also, they are net superior to any controller you reviewed, in number and quality of controls. I really can't think of one thing you could control with a midi controller that you cannot control with the arrangers and workstations you mentioned from Korg and Yamaha. You need to do mapping, but so you do with all midi keyboards from the market. Also, Korg and Yamaha let you control external audio hardware while almost all midi keyboards only allow you to control a DAW. Korg and Yamaha can play multiple instruments at the same time, while midi keyboards can play only one at a time. Zones in midi keyboards only work for a single VST that contains multiple sounds, not for controlling multiple instruments, which was pretty confusing. Korg and Yamaha actually offer zones for different instruments at the same time. 3 - Software - Korg and Yamaha have software that is much more configurable than any midi keyboard has for their instruments. Also, Korg offers the option, on some models to actually record sounds from other hardware instruments. Moreover, they can use the sounds from any other DAW, just like any midi keyboard. DAWs and sound libraries cost hundreds, maybe thousands of dollars and if you add the midi keyboard, you might come to the conclusion that you have paid as much as a Korg or Yamaha, but without the 9 hardware sound engines and without the quality and stability of those brands. I dare you to find a function on a Korg or a Yamaha that you will say about "I don't need to use it", like you can say about half of the controls on the midi keyboards. Hardware fails of old age, Software fails when least expected. You restart your laptop and suddenly, nothing works anymore. Look at all the problems people have with software for Komplete Kontrol or Arturia: keys have weird velocities, knobs get out of mappings, guiding lights don't function as expected, OS update screwed the entire DAW from Native Instruments, both midi keyboards have issues with mappings outside their native DAWs. In conclusion, my opinion is that if you wanna produce music that will get you concerts and plan to do live shows, you go with Korg, Yamaha. If you wanna do music for your bedroom or "sketch"-up a song, you can go with midi keyboard. That is where the difference in money is. If you need a stronger argument, search what kind of keyboards billboard artists are using.

[@Johnmike]

Uhhhh...Billie Eilish? lil Nas X? Jacob Collier?...there are tons of examples of hit songs and producers that have produced whole records using a midi controller and a handful of vsts...hardware is great...I have no real problem with it...but to assume that because you don’t have hardware...specifically “Korg and Yamaha” that you are less of a musician or producer or that you don’t really take your craft seriously is a wrong assumption...you make some great points...but at the end of the day it’s about preference, convenience and ultimately budget...there’s no reason to feel superior because you use hardware...or because you use software...

[@a.c.j.8751]

@@Johnmike I was not trying to sound superior, my arguments were for obtaining top quality and capability, being able to use your keys both live and in studio. Billie and other artists you mentioned are sending their ideas to the labels they work with and their sound is reengineered in professional studios, what they produce is just an initial version it is not what they sell.

[@Johnmike]

@@a.c.j.8751 I didn’t feel like you were being superior...mainly was kinda trying to state a middle ground statement about neither side should feel superior...but even with Billie and the others...their sound started at the source in the box...with a midi controller...They are all independent artists that didn’t have a label but broke through...and even if they did turn it in to a label...I doubt that they would decide to re-record it or do post production to add in analog hardware synths to make it sound better...with the artists and labels I’ve worked with...it either sounds good when you turn it in...or it doesn’t....I think the anchor point for me is that we are all trying to just make and create good music...if you get their using hardware...dope! If you get there using software...still dope!!

[@a.c.j.8751]

But if the difference between pro harware and midi is about $2000, wouldn't it be wiser to buy into pro, to make your road easier by having the right tools, by getting used from the start with the pro tools and their workflow? This will also provide one the opportunity to find jobs in a studio.

[@Johnmike]

@@a.c.j.8751 maybe...maybe not...there is no “one size fits all” approach to this....but mainly it’s the player...not what’s being played...I got a friend down in Seattle that’s doing full professional chart topping records on a Casio...got another in Cali that’s doing the same using midi boards and VSTs...then got a friend in Kentucky that’s got just about every piece of hardware you can think of...follow by myself using nothing but midi for the last 10 years and I’ve had a really successful career...bottom line is...it’s the player...not what’s being played...I know my way around midi just as well as hardware...so if you give me pro...or non pro tools...I can get the job done...

[@laverne506]

Akai Mpk the software that came with it can I download the software and use in Garageband Thank You

[@tdubb1249]

Is Loop Track royalty free?

[@atcordice]

I wonder if the world was in reverse where we started music with digital and evolve in to analog if we would shout for digital. Digital if future analog is the pass

[@Sam_imman]

Just check out artesia pe88 .. this 88 board has in build audio interface. Just connect your iPad or iPhone or a Mac and you are ready

[@savoirfaire8979]

*Some hardware synths are irreplaceable, such as the MicroFreak and analog Moogs.*

[@darrygswa]

I see what u mean about manfacture's. Like Roland new fantom keyboards has about the same features as the old roland fa keyboards, but fa's $1,000 cheaper price.

[@staceycarras3815]

Great Vid !, thank you for sharing :)

[@Fufuman94]

For someone who was like “hardware or go home” because I thought I was going to play live gigs to now kinda regretting buying a Yamaha MX88 and the M-Audio 88 keys (due to your recommendation) I have you John Mike & Jamal Hartwell to thank when it comes to using VSTs and midi controllers

[@youssefselkani]

I do agree about cost but you forget you have to plug it to a computer, for me it doesn't sounds like a real instrument.. playing drums with pads/keys or insert midi notes with a mouse it's just ridiculous to me, I like real instruments, if you look at arrangers they offer a lot more functionalities and it's all dawless

[@maxibutlerov5312]

Great video!

[@ronrobins3513]

Ahhh John...you have to agree. MIDI CONTROLLERS ARE NOT INSTRUMENTS. As such resell value and depreciation is BRUTAL. Look at some controllers that came out a couple years ago and what they sell for used... Recently, I’ve reconsidered the economy of budget gear when it comes to investing in your business. Sure in the SHORT TERM the ROI (Return On Investment) makes sense, but 2 - 3 years down the road...What if you had to pivot away from your current business model for another opportunity? And you had to liquidate your equipment in a hurry....WHAT DO YOU HAVE TO SELL. A bunch of MIDI CONTROLLERS that lost more than 20% of value the first year you owned it. A bunch of software which can be a nightmare to transfer ownership/licenses Midi controllers are fine, but workstation keyboards/flagship synthesizers/top shelf outboard and hardware processers tend to hold more value and be more reliable over time. A five year old midi controller can be had for a half of what it cost new. Most budget controllers are built to meet a certain price point and aren’t meant to last but for a couple years Another case study might be sound design, using your equipment to pay for it self by selling sound libraries. Which do you think creates more value, sound created from the original equipment processed thru hardware outboard, or a bunch of plugins processed thru more plugins😂😊😂😂 An Avalon mic pre, a Korg Kronos, Moog Lil Phatty, all still fetch a decent chunk of money.They may take more upfront investment but they pay off in the long run. Just my opinion 🙏🏾🙏🏾💪🏽💪🏽

[@Johnmike]

Great opinions! Still sticking with my software and midi controllers tho lol

[@ronrobins3513]

@@Johnmike hey do think you’re the FIRST one to think, software and controllers are cheaper...I’m going to just buy software and controllers. In the early 2000s I thought the same thing. I’m going to sell my keyboards and get nothing but software. Until tragedy strikes, despite your best efforts and your main computer goes flat line and you have no back up. Then what...deadlines looming. Possible lawsuits because you signed a contract. In your reply you sound kind of hardheaded... I get it you’re one of the COOL KIDS😊😊 “It will never happen to me” You sound like one of those people in Texas recently who thought they would never need a winter coat...SURPRISE😂😂😂😂

[@Johnmike]

@@ronrobins3513 Naa definitely not one of the cool kids...but to your point tradgedy has struck more than once with both software and hardware...I’ve had hardware to fail on me just like software...here’s what I learned in both cases...especially if you run a business dependent on either...ALWAYS have a backup system...so unless all 4 of my computers fail all at once I shouldn’t have too much of an issue...and the second thing I’ve learned is to never run your business in the red so than when something fails(which it will) you can just go and get a replacement...through tragedy I’ve learned always be prepared for the inevitable....still don’t plan to buy any hardware Anytime soon...I’d much rather invest the extra cash in both my growing businesses...in my 6 wonderful children I’m raising...and in my retirement so me and my wife can be sitting on a beach somewhere in the next 10 years! 😉

[@ronrobins3513]

@@Johnmike back up plan 🙏🏾🙏🏾 I recognize you probably have a family that depends on you, so it make sense to plan ahead for that bump in the road. I just wanted to share with you MY EXPERIENCE. I learned EXPERIENCE REALLY IS THE WORST TEACHER. There’s things I wish I had a listen to when I thought I knew better😌☺️Not to say that I know better than you, because I just put my faith in God and do the best I can. WORKSTATIONS 4 LIFE 🤣🤣🎹

[@Johnmike]

@@ronrobins3513 lol! I feel it! And man don’t we all!! 😂...but yeah man it’s 8 people in my house including me...so yeah I don’t have room to not be prepared! So I’m investing every extra dollar I got...so I can be sitting on the beach with my midi controller in the future! 😂😂

[@justhrillz3245]

Thanks bro need it this

[@theboofin]

Why not? I use vst because of automation. If you want your music to have life, it needs lots of automation...

[@NEKROZADKIEL]

Papa Mike knows what he's talking 😎

[@atcordice]

I agree with you bro. Why go back in he stone age. Sound has changed. And digital sound people like

[@jesavius]

What are “VST”s?

[@casadasmelodias3379]

Lol

[@Johnmike]

Virtual Instruments

[@smak8224]

If u don't know what is a VST .. U don't have a life.

[@sush4243]

Lol

[@BluesCat1980]

About your comment about hardware failing, everything eventually fails. It's not a matter of if, it's a matter of when.

[@Johnmike]

Eggsactly

[@ashdee]

Oh my my

[@MikeyLikesItt]

unless all you use is 808s and drum machines, analog instruments are irreplaceable , software has its pros, portability and unlimited sounds but if software were so great then why don't you see drummers just carrying drum machines around to their gigs?

[@AnthonyCollierMusic]

A very timely video for me. I was wondering if I can pay you for you time, like a one on one session with you because I have a couple of questions about saving/backing/organizing all of my VSTs and midi things. Is that something we can do?

[@Johnmike]

Sure shoot me an email to [e-mail]

[@GordonZamor]

My question is what is the best 88 midi controller with a keybed like the Motif/Montage or Nord? I currently use a Arturia keylab 88 MK1..its okay..but not like the yamahas or Nord

[@Johnmike]

If you are looking for a midi controller that feels like a motif...then check out the Yamaha MX88

[@GordonZamor]

@@Johnmike Will do thanks!

[@cultmecca]

I only use midichlorians

[@Johnmike]

😂😂

[@victorwestii8058]

Man I've wanted to get in to the midi controllers for the longest, you've made that much easier to want to jump on it....

[@DanielEdwards-er1vw]

Has software ever failed on you 🤔 because it has for me

[@DanielEdwards-er1vw]

I also think it's good to have a Balance of both just in case

[@Johnmike]

I’ve had my share of issues...but had my share of issues with hardware as well...I just worked to figure out how to optimize my system to figure out what works and what doesn’t

[@jagdishlalwani]

M odio novason impakt Alesis all makin very low quality n bad keybords they wil not last fr even 6 mnth..better buy lo priced n use fr 1 year n throw away

[@brandoncrenshaw]

You could literally buy a midi controller($500) and Omnisphere($399) & Keyscape ($399) and don’t need anything else for a gig.

[@PRIMEGospel]

A Mac or computer is needed, lol

[@tuneunleashed]

Make sure it don’t crash

[@ashdee]

Second