Johnny Depp's Witness Testifies About Incident at Hicksville Trailer Palace (Depp v. Heard)

[@EvilPeanut1102]

This guy is speaking very truthfully. He doesn't hesitate, his words come very freely and he doesn't stop to think how he is going to respond. He's telling the truth.

[@bethanyh.9489]

hahahha

[@EvilPeanut1102]

@@bethanyh.9489 What's funny?

[@nonacee5065]

@@kleeamd8274 he wouldn't be able to give an opinion he can only state facts, so like he said, he barely spent an hour around them that night so he could tell what he saw and heard but not guess.

[@EvilPeanut1102]

@@kleeamd8274 I've commented on one witness......so how do you know what I think about them? And it's very obvious when someone is angry, it doesn't really need explaining how.

[@EvilPeanut1102]

@@kleeamd8274 ps GFY

[@Stella-yk1bt]

You know he’s an honest guy because he only charged JD $62 for the damages to the light when he easily could’ve charged 10 times of that amount.

[@maryannazurin2322]

So true!

[@underthegardenwall]

Note that he also said he charged to Nathan (Johnny's employee) instead of Johnny himself. Amber said the damages were immense and that Johnny paid for those damages. Caught her in another lie!

[@honeyholly001]

@@underthegardenwall bet she never expected them to bring in the actual owner of the place

[@Animerulespeople]

@@underthegardenwall wow she said that? Lol 62 dollars

[@underthegardenwall]

@@Animerulespeople Yep, Hicksville was another event where she claimed Johnny asssaulted her and ransacked the trailer, also implying that he paid for the damages out of guilt. But like, the owner charged Nathan only $62 for a light fixture that (according to the owner) breaks easily. Amber's lies are being debunked so hard one by one.

[@WordWorksByShelica]

Elaine ALWAYS insinuates that these witnesses are just seeking for fame! Her line of questioning reflects her client.

[@patriciafoster3347]

YES!

[@aliciabisso]

Soooo pathetic

[@333pinkitty]

Yeah she's so cringe with that line. You come to expect it whenever she cross examines

[@Lumerlume11]

She's seriously insufferable.

[@oldrvr]

Elaine asks the most useless, repetitive, snarky, annoying questions when she cross examinations.

[@hdnft4633]

I’m so glad there are good people like this gentleman in the world. He was genuine and a straight shooter, taking no bull from the lying defense.

[@ILoveCrepes601]

Couldn’t agree more and what a great looking suit he was wearing.

[@lofiftyfifty9206]

Integrity, strong inner-character, succinct, focused, clear observations.

[@Emmm777]

He's real and I'll bet Johnny likes him.

[@sophiashouse7320]

This guy was lying lol. He sat there and testified in his tweet that he was with them all night long. But if you listen to his testimony he said he only spent about 45 minutes with Amber and Johnny and he was in the house when they were at the campfire. Lol he saw clips of the trial on Twitter. I’m Surprised that they even let him testify but honestly it probably was good for amber team. Because his story had holes.

[@barbaraa.walters8798]

Good one Elaine didn't know correct Pronunciation of One of Johnny 's Legal team

[@sadem1045]

I felt bad for Morgan Night, the witness, everytime he mentioned the parallels he saw between what was going on with Amber and Johnny and his own past abusive relationship. I'm sure he didn't mean to go off-track 3 times and I'm sorry he was interrupted. It's really hard to be cut off when you're talking about your experience with trauma.

[@annetroy2857]

The man was triggered by what he saw, it's no wonder he remembered what he saw. Heard smirking was just awful.

[@retrocny5625]

Gotta love the look on Amber's face when he's discussing the damages. Smirking, smiling, condescension, jury saw right through this woman. GUILTY.

[@ninamartinez5171]

Yes she was actually very nervous if you look at her face when he's speaking Amber Heard face is like wth?

[@hildy9678]

Elaine continues to try to find a leg to stand on and, not finding it, draws this out to beyond ridiculous. She's hoping to catch Johnny's lawyers doing something inappropriate and fails each time because that's not how they conduct their jobs.

[@jimmy5353]

That particular look is just disgusting to me. I never watched any Pirate movie or AH's movie. I was never any fan of theirs. I wanted to watch this entire trial to improve my expert witness skills. AH's team is just totally unprofessional and her lawyers are just like her. Their tactics are worse than AH's face of that moment.

[@elizabethc3842]

Amber was so sure that they were going to be able to keep Trailer guy from speaking, she went from smug and condescending to angry

[@liberatiom5781]

he didnt back ME UP???? OMG WHAT A LOSER

[@joyabing7824]

The witness has nothing to be afraid of because what he said was only the truth, no coaching drama on how to look pitiful towards the jury.

[@robby1816]

Nothing to be afraid of? They dug through his twitter history looking for dirt (like the Elon Musk thing) & incorrectly stated he is a JD fanboi. God help him if they had found anything real.

[@busynana7917]

Exactly!!! 👍

[@bereal6590]

His testimony was pitiful enough

[@ccsnguyen3517]

I agree. If he been coaching. Then he would know what to say. And the lawyer didn’t have to change the questions many time.

[@rachaelbrowne2402]

Amber and her lawyer are the liars!

[@4hrtz26]

The attorney’s attitudes in this case really are a representation of each client.

[@4hrtz26]

@@franeikenberg5853 Great point and so true!!

[@maidenmarian1]

Yes YES!!!

[@VSLNorCal_]

Not only the attorneys, the witnesses as well

[@onebylandtwoifbysearunifby5475]

Birds of a feather...

[@janebailey8032]

I agree. I almost went to law school but decided I couldn't spend another year in the midwest. Don't get me wrong, I like it but... Anyway I see why there are so many lawyer jokes. They are awful. How do these people sleep at night?

[@ryn4984]

“I don’t have an objection right now, only if he talks more.” That made my jaw drop, Heard’s lawyer sucks

[@nonmihiseddeo4181]

Like Johnny on the stand, waiting to say more, because he knows Rotty is gonna cry hearsay on what he just said.

[@Ocrilat]

What's even weirder is, that was Bredehoft trying to be kind and funny. Has she never spoken to a human being before?

[@horse-lover68]

@@nonmihiseddeo4181 👍👍

[@horse-lover68]

@@Ocrilat 👍👍😂😂😂

[@KylieJ1230]

My thing is why when Johnny's lawyers were questioning the Hicksville manager, they couldn't ask him "did you ever see johnny twist anyone's arm, or see johnny get physical" it got objected to as leading. Yet Amber's lawyers were allowed to ask him if he ever saw johnny twist anyone's arm and ask how many pounds of pressure it took to break it...but that wasn't leading. He wasn't allowed to saw his innkeeper called him about the trailer being a wreck....but rocky talked about amber supposedly getting texts many of times...yet that wasn't hearsay. I noticed a lot of this throughout the trial.

[@iphoneography]

A very softly spoken, gentle man. You can clearly see he's being honest for his entire testimony.

[@elmascholo13]

that guy is a truth telling god fearing man lol

[@onebylandtwoifbysearunifby5475]

"Honestly, [your babbling] sounds like schizophrenia"- ...was the best line of the trial. He was being honest. _"Did you know Mr. Water Man said he talks to the Umbrella Man?"_ He took that attempted takedown down hard. Her lawyer set herself up repeatedly.

[@josiahrowland2852]

@@onebylandtwoifbysearunifby5475 time stamp for this please 😭

[@onebylandtwoifbysearunifby5475]

@@josiahrowland2852 Around 47:00 but you should watch the entire cross by herd's lawyer, it's hilarious.

[@onebylandtwoifbysearunifby5475]

@@josiahrowland2852 Cross starts at 41:00 and it's worth watching.

[@tinkervance1525]

This man came off to me like he was being very honest, genuine & frankly precious!

[@alexandraburt1037]

So precious! I hope he lives forever and nothing bad ever happens to him!! Lol

[@desertsunset8025]

He was precious ...

[@I_AM_BAYTOR]

Aside fron the accent.

[@whitesandandreef4919]

Do u wanna tinker all over him?

[@tinkervance1525]

@@whitesandandreef4919 😝😝😝🤭🤭 SUCH A GOOD REPLY! I needed a good laugh 😉😉

[@thepololadycharlottemenkes1227]

Very credible witness. Grateful that he was on property to witness what “REALLY” happened. Glad Johnny Depp FINALLY got justice 🙏🦋

[@joblair5607]

This is a genuine, what we in the UK would call “simple” gentleman - he comes across as being honest and calm, like he doesn’t really want to be there but is only doing so as he wants the truth to be told…. Shame there aren’t more people like him 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

[@georgie9755]

Agree 100%

[@simonebye8789]

I agree , I am also from the UK , he is what we call a gentleman, someone who honest , keeps calm and someone who uphold the truth!

[@missichristensen3275]

Perfectly said jo

[@cwells5576]

Yes, I think he is the only who is looking at the lawyer when answering her questions. He had to be asked to respond to the jury. He does seem very genuine and a credible witness. I can't wait for the judgement and compare it to the U.K. one. Judge Nicol's son worked at Talk Radio with Dan Wootton who wrote the hit piece for the Sun Newspaper .He didn't recuse himself from the case which is quite astonishing.

[@johnmutton799]

CHECK OUT POPCORNED PLANET, SEE WHAT THIS GENT TWEETED TO HIS STAFF, AND WHAT THEY TWEETED BACK! THEN SEE ELAINE LIE TO THE JUDGE IN TRANSCRIPTS!

[@Salome11180]

This man just looks wholesome and happy with life. He is obviously telling the truth and I hope the jury sees this

[@janebailey8032]

Yes he is!! What's wrong with AH? Think of the fun she ruined for so many but herself it what gets me!

[@missichristensen3275]

He was glorious Nothing to hide Comfortable in his own skin Real And no arse licking

[@underthegardenwall]

He was the most relaxed witness yet, along with Isaac Baruch. Leads tons of credence to his testimony imo.

[@bethanyh.9489]

hahaha yeah sure....

[@missichristensen3275]

@@bethanyh.9489 ? Your point ?

[@fijay2400]

"Can I leave my water" he is so natural and uninterested in the celebrity drama surrounding this trial. Came across as just a decent believable guy.

[@lrow5416]

You can feel in your gut who’s telling the truth and this guy was being honest not because of any need for fame as Elaine tried to insinuate! He wanted to set the record straight. I mean, really, how disgusting that Amber’s team goes out of their way to humiliate honest people while Amber smirks in the background.

[@feliyulita1755]

Sadly the judge sustained all objections...im dissapointed

[@feliyulita1755]

sorry if anyone is the judge admirer or have different opinion. I might be wrong cause i don't understand law. But i heard elaine objected camille question abt wether or not JD is ever physical towards other, and elaine objected "leading" (again,i dunno how it supposed to be leading) the judge sustained it and at the end elaine objected camille question(the very same question from before) and overruled it?? Again i might missheard it cause English is my second languange. Im just wondering, no need to be triggered 😂

[@karenbrown4524]

I agree 100%.

[@irenefranz4175]

Yes truly disgusting!

[@ari_daviss]

@@feliyulita1755 she always is I’m pretty sure Elaine and the judge are friends

[@Nicholas_Chen_]

Star witness! Just an honest everyday guy who wants to do the right thing. I hate how Amber’s lawyers treated him, using laws and legal languages to try to shut him up and in a way bully him. I think it’s because Amber made the trailer incident such a big thing in her testimony (involving r*pe) and they got scared of the witness’ story so they want to object him to death to shut him up. But they can’t stop the truth coming out of him. Gotta love how he backed up That Umbrella Guy the fact he corrected Elaine’s ‘The Umbrella man’ was hilarious! Honestly Elaine either doesn’t respect people at all (hence getting their names wrong) or have really really short-term memory 🤣

[@fe5018]

A convincing witness for sure. Could not get over how rude Heard's lawyer was to him in the cross examination.

[@DDR248]

@@fe5018 He did very well. They thought they can play with him but he strikes back.

[@thinkingallowed7042]

An intellectually challenged bum who looks like he wishes he had the same budget for booze as his hero.

[@fe5018]

@@DDR248, yes, he did really well. Difficult circumstances but he was very composed.

[@YourGraceMyLady]

I was honestly shocked by Elaine. Couldn’t believe she was bringing Up the Umbrella guy and Johnny Depp fan page

[@funtimes3962]

"This sounds like schizophrenia" might be my favorite line from this trial. Sums up the whole thing really

[@juhuyraz6259]

bless this man for testifying the truth.

[@sickcommode-odragon4193]

@KS Donald because it’s fun. Why are you commenting on something you don’t care about Englishman?

[@shantoreywilkins651]

🎯⚖️

[@juhuyraz6259]

@KS Donald Why do even care replying to a comment about a clip regarding this case then?

[@HopefulInterventions]

@KS Donald What?

[@krystalmoore8943]

Elaine asked him if he followed a Johnny Depp fan page and he denied and she questioned his answer as if she had proof he was lying under oath then offered no proof. Total fail Elaine.

[@godzillamanstreb524]

lol

[@jamiebeck3631]

This is what telling the truth looks like, you don't need to be like put on a show when your words are true.

[@nicolebesser3548]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 I have a bridge to sell you.

[@ScoobyDoozy]

“Can I leave my water?”. That little gesture and how he asked so sweetly and kindly already tells you what kind of man this is, and I haven’t even watched his testimony yet.

[@mirantipa99]

right?? even when he got any objection from both side, he apologize right away

[@tabithashatley5683]

I believe this guy. I think he's a very honest man. A very credible witness.

[@Stardust_Truth_Seeker]

don't agree at all!!

[@debbydooks2241]

@@Stardust_Truth_Seeker you see what you want to see.

[@sumisumi5214]

@@Stardust_Truth_Seeker is this Amber? Aren't you supposed to stay of social media? LOL!

[@gcbryan89]

I cant definitely say if he is honest or not, because there's no way to know behind a screen, but this os how questions should be answered. No semantics and playing with words, just pure direct recollections.

[@Daaaanielle]

@@sumisumi5214 Amber is not a member of the jury. She and Johnny and the lawyers can go online all they want. Not on her side, just stating the rules. Also, I have my doubts with this guy but it was harmful testimony. Very bad for Amber.

[@shannona8771]

They're shamelessly trying to trip him up, twist what he says...he's a respectful, honest person. Thank goodness he didn't get rattled! What he describes is heartbreaking!! Johnny did not deserve this! Justice for Johnny Depp!!!!❤

[@colettejaques2559]

Depps attorney is crazy....aggressive...she likes the attention!! Watching her & Depp eating candy & laughing gave the jury a clear view.....disrespectful

[@nakela2]

@@colettejaques2559 how is Camille of all people aggressive or disrespectful? Cross-examining someone especially an individual like AH in no way would I be polite and nice, she's fighting for her client.. Elaine and her team are rude and disrespectful, furthermore no one knows what Depp's team is talking and/or laughing about. The jurors aren't focused on their table but should be listening to the witnesses.

[@hoanganhviet4383]

Definitely what I've thought. Especially, when being brutally asked about what he & Camille's conversation on the night before his testimony, when Mr. Ben Chew would like for objection of attorneys work, Camille herself signed him NOT neccessarily to do that 😀 And I observed many more JD's testimoniers usually NOT HESITATE to testify or they confused for sometime by AH's lawyers' speechifying unclear questions. Especially, JD's lawyers' questions are straight to the point, but those make AH's testimoniers still hardly answer, they eventhough answered NOT to JD's lawyers' questions , even with AH 😀;-D That leads me to ONE CONCLUSION : AH & her team have NOTHING to prove because of there's simply NOTHING exists on AH's accusation against JD, but LIES 😀

[@hoanganhviet4383]

In AH's testimony, she refused to recognise the man as Hicksville's owner. She's so DESPICABLE LIAR.

[@jansandman6983]

if you tell the truth you can't get rattled.

[@xxMeleadyxx]

I find Elaine to be a horrible horrible person. I know people will say she's doing her job but I can't stand her behaviour and now she's getting desperate so she's really getting nastier... just like her client when Johnny said he wanted a divorce.

[@abbiereynolds8016]

She was so rude to Dr Shannon Curry in particular with that whole muffin fiasco, like I get that you have to defend your client even when they're wrong but she's acting as if Amber is her own relative that she's ride or die for.

[@zankfrappa93]

she did an impression of jonhny depp's voice last week as she was quoting something he said. i think thats all anyone needs to know about her. she is a horrible person, plain and simple

[@b3ng260]

Yup,just like her client, unprofessional and disrespectful in every way

[@melindataljaard2753]

She's a real thing 😂

[@starrymichi9995]

Amber might have also been threatening and causing trauma to her lawyer to pressure her to win this case

[@Yooh_The_Pooh]

Camille's so sweet , the way she smiles and nods to the witnesses while listening to their testimonies is heartwarming

[@Marco_mm]

That's kinda creepy ngl

[@camrivera5735]

@@emilyroseayres84 You must be talking about the crazy Elaine 🤣

[@SwatiPatelnz]

@@emilyroseayres84 completely agree, she is also an awful lawyer! Would never hire her.

[@Yaya-n3k]

@@emilyroseayres84 don't be jealous just cos you can't be like her lol

[@Funsiestype]

@@SwatiPatelnz don’t worry Swati, your rupees can never afford to begin with.

[@st.francisanddr.pepper1304]

And this is yet another example of a truthful witness testifying. Compare the feelings you get about his testimony to Amber's. The difference is stark. And this is one of many on Depp's side.

[@rappala1671]

This guy is the best example of a humble, decent, genuine, honest human being. 👏 Keep being you Mr Knight! 👏

[@colettejaques2559]

He's been bought by Johnny....lol. glad the defense attorney got this!! Not ricket science...They remembered 9 years later...🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥

[@jody6466]

This Hicksville witness testified that it was not johnny who appeared to be jealous, that it was not johnny who yelled and got got angry. That it was Amber who appeared to be the aggressor. Now, I wonder if Amber in all her allegations is she stating the things that she did to Johnny?

[@sondrawatkins4976]

I married one too. So glad to be divorced!!

[@ememdl83]

You are on point, we had one who dated one of our children 😩

[@celin3598]

ive been thinking this the whole time. the reason her story may seem compelling is bc she knows the story but from the other perspective LOL

[@erikac8612]

She was very graphic of the assaults and Johnny just recalls he tried running and hiding from her.

[@hernameisflipper5852]

@@franeikenberg5853 I didn't marry mine but I was with him 9 years😭And you're completely right 1000%

[@missjoasia123]

Amber smiling when witness is talking about the damage in his trailer to the light he obviously loves because he built this is very disturbing to me. Someone who is a victim in a fight where there was property damage would not be smiling like this it’s very creepy and I don’t think she realized how her face looked in this moment. I think he really brings to light an honest image of interaction between Amber and Johnny.

[@heavenmiracle8715]

“He talks to the umbrella guy did you know that?” “Honestly that, idk that sounds like schizophrenia” This guy has me ded lmAO he was being so sweet and honest wish they would stop talking so aggressive to the witnesses trying to just explain their experience

[@heavenmiracle8715]

They’re not the ones being trialed for guilty yet they talk to them like offenders. I get that you’re trying to pressure them into telling the truth but they’re under oath and all you’re doing is making them anxious

[@august5135]

sounded like schizophrenia until they proved he did in fact talk to the umbrella guy lol

[@MeenersKitchen]

I literally had to pause so I could finish laughing so hard…I wish they showed peoples reactions

[@heavenmiracle8715]

@@MeenersKitchen SAME I kept rewatching it to try and see reactions lmao the lawyer ignored it

[@gemstar7286]

@@heavenmiracle8715 This type of treatment is what puts people off being a witness.

[@samantham2204]

I missed this witness before. This was devastating to Amber’s case. I knew she was twisting things like this! God bless this man for coming forward.

[@geneivemary4234]

It's a real joy to watch these videos after we know the result! The incompetence in AH team is hilarious! Even their lack of social media knowledge! It shows what it's like to get paid to defend a liar .... but someones gotta/ gonna do it! ;)

[@alo9247]

The leader for Mr. Depps TWITTERSSS still gets me 😂

[@TheJazz61]

Omg...her lawyer are the worse. Going round round with no direction

[@elaine5446]

Try knowledge of the basic law. Counsel for the defense, EB, objected to AH spokesperson's statement as hearsay as well as other evidence given in court. Unbelievable!! The brief filed on Friday in respect of the age of the juror, is another colossal waste of time as they themselves also noted. The incompetence is real

[@lwalker8855]

Appears ah was bullying her attorneys

[@horse-lover68]

@@alo9247 Yes that was hilarious!!! TUG has a YT channel, but that is to much for her to understand!!😂😂😂😂

[@kadebebesis4204]

This witness is such a breath of fresh air ✨

[@renb6133]

JD’s witnesses come across as dignified & authentic. There’s no mud slinging just pure class from both these 2 witnesses. Mr Knight seemed very genuine & truthful & Dr Shaw is a truly class act. In comparison, Amber’s witnesses seem crass & unreliable. It’s fascinating how the witnesses are reflecting the people for whom they’re giving testimony. Knight & Shaw were likeable & very credible. Frankly, I wouldn’t go near any of the “experts” testifying on Heard’s behalf!

[@colettejaques2559]

He's a fan & has a crush on Depp...lol

[@angelaizzo641]

@@colettejaques2559 you're absolutely asinine

[@beth3099]

VERY very well said.. Exactly what I thought!!!

[@renb6133]

@@beth3099 Thank you! 💕

[@sheila6186]

55:37: That guy, Dr. Shaw, has an incredible background in psychiatry and he comes across as a very sincere person who gains genuine fulfillment from being of service to others who are in difficulty.

[@ThatGirlT77]

I love this witness! He's really cool and so honest! He was just there to tell what he saw and not embellish the truth. $62 worth of damage is a lot different than the "total destruction" AH's side tried to say there was to the trailer. It matters and it's very relevant!

[@rozee1507]

And she caused it all ...thinking 'oh well Johnny will pay for it and they'll think it's him.'

[@stacyward4309]

His business is going to go thru the roof after this. Sounds like a really cool place to stay.

[@kimberleeboydston9570]

She did not expect him to show up either. She keeps trying to move towards places and points she feels no one can contradict her. Especially with her lying sister to back her up. Well Babe it didn’t work this time “either”.

[@janeward722]

This is beside the point but that color suit looks absolutely phenomenal on Johnny!

[@emilyroseayres84]

​@@janeward722 Bahaha! Besides the point...understatement of the century. It's a ridiculous, superficial and disturbingly out of touch comment. I'd expect nothing less from someone court up in the Depp Delusion. All hail the Antichrist hey?

[@Shepherdmom]

My goodness, this psychiatrist is a very gentle man. I have panic disorder and terrible anxiety, I would be so grateful to have a doctor like him to treat me. Just listening to him for a few minutes has great calming effects.

[@xyza5247]

true. now, imagine going to Dr. spiegel. lol

[@alisonlee3314]

@@xyza5247 🤣

[@WriteMeASong7]

Agreed. It’s ppl like him that affirm that some ppl are meant to do what they do.

[@eleanorcooke7136]

@@xyza5247 yeah, you go to Dr Spiegel and say "I've been feeling a bit sad" and he says "it's because you're a sociopath and you want your dad to die but he hasn't yet." Or something like that.

[@c2cooler2]

@@xyza5247 That thing!!

[@DesertSkiesAV]

This is an excellent witness. He is cooperative, articulate and precise.

[@amistenson2535]

All because Amber couldn’t keep her lies straight! 😂 He’s an honest man. Very nice as well. I hope he continues to be blessed in his life, health, and business endeavors.

[@kathylynn9676]

I'm happy he come forward to just to set story straight he's not trying to get any fame he's just telling what he saw n wittnessed Elaine is to the extreme n why cause he's telling the truth

[@shantoreywilkins651]

🕵‍♀️🕵🕵‍♂️👁🔬🔍🔎

[@amynadine9669]

Yes. Great comment. True. Wish him the best.

[@b3ng260]

I hope the jury take this kind soul testimony into consideration

[@Speck23]

I love how he doesn’t look at the jury to confirm what he is saying

[@janebailey8032]

Oh yeah! Truth teller !

[@marinafrancesoldman1819]

Unlike some other people

[@mariar4323]

Elaine: ‘You remember the things from 7 years ago..’ Witness: ‘9 yrs ago’ Elaine: ‘Well, it’s 2022 today and that was 2013! Oh yes you’re right!’ Amber’s lawyer trying to make this honest man be not credible witness. But to the witness who’s telling the truth, that trick would not work.

[@rooismum1023]

I picked up on that.. she's despicable.

[@elinstar6034]

Again, coming across as rude and bossy ....not a good look in front of the jury, I would have thought.

[@skyleawood2649]

What a stark contrast between the professionalism, likeability and credibility between this psychiatrist and yesterday's nut job. Dr Spiegle terrified me!

[@Wizardlizard1991]

Omg he was so creepy!

[@mommys3bratz]

That so called Dr yesterday is the type that tells you everything you want to hear, plus his input! Then prescribes you lots of meds you don't need that you can get addicted to! Also become like a person like Amber Herd!

[@earthwisdomhelps]

Sadly there are more Dr. Spiegles then not out there misdiagnosing and medicating people every day.

[@quinnfreeman2487]

Lol... Did his spas out scare you...

[@stevenlee6529]

@@mommys3bratz dr spiegel is a paid actor that is what i think

[@matt_8142]

You can tell that he is a credible witness just by how he testified despite of the objections by Elaine, he was able to give his story of the events that occured and JD's team did a good job by keeping him out until it was time to let him in

[@JH-cl3qu]

Her team really makes me sick, trying to accuse this man of just trying to get on TV, when he's just literally telling what he saw. Shameful

[@gabrielperezpolanco9545]

Objection hearsay

[@leewilliams7152]

This guy is a star. He tore “Dr” Speigels testimony to shreds in an intelligent, classy humble way. I learnt a lot from this guy.

[@susandougherty240]

Agree with you

[@razamanaz8199]

Dr Richard Shaw…. Not mr Night as I first saw speaking!

[@emmy51673]

Agreed! So glad someone continued watching on

[@nothing5779]

who is dr speigels? Where can i watch?

[@kashia8375]

You can tell he’s being honest. He’s just talking not trying to remember any lies.

[@bethanyh.9489]

Charles Manson was more honest than this guy

[@kaitlynlindsay6265]

🤣🤣🤣🤣💯💯

[@Lil_Valor]

@@bethanyh.9489 You do know Charles Manson was pretty straight up and honest of what he did, who he thought he was, and how he did what he did in his testimonies right? Or did you just think of the first bad man that popped in your head to use for a sarcastic remark and hasn’t yet realised the person you chose renders your insult/remark nonsensical? Not much going on in that head of yours is there Bethany

[@susandougherty240]

Yup I agree

[@bethanyh.9489]

@@Lil_Valor oh my God. I have read it all. What a complete nutcase.

[@oldnursecarter]

Good Lord, Elaine seems SO proud of herself every time she objects. The way she emotes when she says “OBJECTION!” Like she’s thinking to herself “Look at me, I’m just as smart as Camille! Everyone is going to be so impressed!” 🙄 What she doesn’t realize is that after the show she’s already put on, this just makes her look even more desperate. EDIT: I literally cannot stand the looks on Amber’s face. So glad she lost!! A step FORWARD for victims. All victims. Real victims.

[@aliciabisso]

😂

[@heatherbeach4696]

Fantastic comment!!!😮 Thank you!!!

[@jamesk9321]

Exactly what I was thinking.

[@binporu]

29:33 She's checking herself out in the reflection of her computer monitor. Shows how much she cares about this witness and their testimony.

[@lrow5416]

Yuck! Not surprised.

[@jesmasa1]

She readjusted her hair, saw a few strands needed ruffling , and then readjusted her shirt and/or waistband. She really wants us to believe shes a victim? No victim would ruffle their hair.

[@priscillamanymuthu9951]

Considering that she had a whole cavity search done on her (allegedly), she seems untriggered at a diff recollection by a witness......cause there was no traumatic memory to begin with

[@Haru_Miu]

I’ve never seen anyone so vain & egotistical. She always looks & sounds so haughty and apathetic.

[@Haru_Miu]

@@sandra_rosa_1111 Yesterday I saw a video posted on SM that showed her pretending to write notes & just scribbling without the pen even touching the paper.

[@user-ri3su8zv1b]

Credible witnesses in my opinion. They seem genuine. I was touched when the first witness said that he just wanted to tell of what he saw. He’s not even a Johnny Depp fan.

[@donnahill5434]

I thought that was funny.

[@JessMichael150]

Johnny was really proud of him, you could tell, he probably looks up to this man now more than he looks up to Johnny

[@janebailey8032]

Right??!! Gotta love this guy! She suggested he wanted attention. Seriously??? He wanted to do the right thing by telling the truth!!!

[@Juliet_Tobin]

I like him but I do not believe he's not a Johnny Depp fan! He's certainly not a disinterested witness.

[@sandygoad3744]

the most genuine part about his testimony is the fact that he admitted to not being a Johnny Depp fan but still testified in his defense. And you can tell his observation of the Hicksville incident was a true observation and not one to intentionally smear someone's name in the ground like other witnesses have done.

[@southernborn1358]

This guy is a wonderful witness, and comes across totally honesty, with no dog in this fight.

[@diazrigau]

I love this witness, his honesty, you can tell he is a beautiful; person.

[@christianbosse_]

The way Elaine acted was incredibly disappointing to say the least. Like I get she wants to defend Amber cause it’s her job, but she doesn’t have to be disrespectful like that. Idk how the layers don’t argue when they go up to the judge to speak with each other. Cause I’d have a lot to say 😐

[@rebeccapennington9548]

Also she can’t add. 7 years vs 9 years

[@jutarzo]

Considering how many if Elaine's objections were sustained, it's clear Elaine's the better lawyer.

[@RE-ng5uw]

It's difficult for any lawyer to find during a trial that your client has lied about everything. The lawyer is bound to do his/her best to defend the paying client. However a lawyer also has a reputation to retain and uphold so it puts the lawyer in a difficult position.

[@JH-cl3qu]

@@jutarzo Sarcasm, right?

[@Justme_1221]

@@JH-cl3qu let’s hope that was sarcasm…

[@arjayvirtucio4002]

This guy’s genuine honesty makes me cry! God bless this man’s soul and his family. ♥️♥️

[@hoanganhviet4383]

Definitely what I've thought. And I observed many more JD's testimoniers usually NOT HESITATE to testify or they confused for sometime by AH's lawyers' speechifying unclear questions. Especially, JD's lawyers' questions are straight to the point, but those make AH's testimoniers still hardly answer, they eventhough answered NOT to JD's lawyers' questions , even with AH 😀;-D That leads me to ONE CONCLUSION : AH & her team have NOTHING to prove because of there's simply NOTHING exists on AH's accusation against JD, but LIES 😀

[@goodfty]

Why would you cry? Wtf?

[@jemandjemand2362]

get a life

[@igobykkat]

I can see how nervous AH’s team is, this guy is genuinely speaking the truth!

[@shaindyhorowitz3783]

Not right that Elaine was trying to embarrass the innocent trailer park owner public by trying to say he was out for the publicity. He has nothing to do with the trial, he's not an expert witness getting paid a bajillion dollars an hour. Just an honest business owner trying to report the truth. Why try to cause him potentially lasting bad recognition on national television?

[@samantham2204]

Yep if the witnesses were out for publicity, they’d be going to the press not committing perjury!

[@ashleygosse13]

“I don’t have an objection right now, only if he talks more” … Tell us you’re scared of this witness without telling us you’re scared of this witness 😂😂

[@brokenroadhomestead609]

Absolutely devastating testimony to Heard’s case. Renders so many of her witnesses useless.

[@Stardust_Truth_Seeker]

its really weak testimony

[@fbellaann]

@@Stardust_Truth_Seeker compare to the big amount of " weak " testimonies in this trial, this one actually can make the difference bc he saw AH disrespecting JD, besides her sister no one saw anything.

[@sumisumi5214]

@@Stardust_Truth_Seeker His testimony weakens amber's case. Its very damning to her and steathens johnny.

[@zemlyaru1977]

@@Stardust_Truth_Seeker vice versa

[@ABoxIsMyHome]

@@Stiegosaurus they are so rare

[@krisap1635]

This trailer park owner is an honest dude! He only wanted to tell the truth. Amber and her sisters lies caught up to them,again!!!

[@normacolon9618]

Not on ambwrs team.....but being around only 45 minutes is enough to say he dudnt see all...but he saw at the beginning what that amber did and yelled and interrupted is enough to start with johhny where they xoukd hear. Depp has to apologize always doe her actions...she thought he could be controlled 24/7 cause he's older and he would give everything p including his self esteem and everything else. He for tired of her bully crap

[@_HimToo]

@@normacolon9618 it's my understanding that he only spent abouy 45 min WITH Depp & Heard, showing them around n stuff. But he worked the whole night & saw more than 45 min worth of stuff.

[@pAusten]

and the coolest part is How he became a witness just a few weeks ago. Someone on another thread called him an angel sent to Johnny's side.

[@brassgal5039]

By trying to discredit the Hicksville guy based on his motivations, Amber’s team came across as mean and grasping. They made him look like a more credible person.

[@brassgal5039]

LOL - and Amber’s lawyer called Johnny “Mr. Heard” at some point. That is just funny

[@anontwofourfive]

They know they have no actual evidence to confirm Amber's bizarre claims so instead they try to discredit all of the witnesses that confirm Johnny's claims. It's all they have.

[@sophiamartinez6641]

I love when he said, “Camille just told me to throw the truth.”

[@SarahVargasMúsica]

This guy was such a fresh air of honesty. Loved that he is speaking from experience. He knows what he is talking about. The lying side is most likely peeing their pants Take your pill Amber, take 2 Elaine.

[@bloop8803]

Maybe take the whole entire bottle love. 🥳❤️‍🔥👍🏼♥️

[@MariaFatimaRubillos]

hahahahahahha hilarious I was laughing by saying elaine should take 2 🤣🤣

[@tishc.849]

lol I love it they sure do need to take a few an sit down

[@Skippy81]

The trailer park owner was great. He seemed honest and didn't sound he liked the way Amber was treating Depp, a common theme in this trial. I'm convinced now that Heard was the abuser and Depp the victim.

[@bethanyh.9489]

hahahahha

[@abhisekhkumar4948]

@@bethanyh.9489 hehehehhe

[@Blackheathenly]

You weren't before? What took you so long?

[@Man_fay_the_Bru]

That’s funny because I had her down as the abuser from the start after watching the overhauling tv show episode.

[@bethanyh.9489]

@@Man_fay_the_Bru so many dumbasses hahahaha

[@janineparry5316]

Judge: What's the objection... Elaine: My client is a brazen liar and this testimony makes her look bad....

[@shirleyar2010]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣👍🏼

[@pri6146]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@lubabe9969]

Amber's on edge, you can tell she knows exactly what's coming and she's a nervous wreck. Eliana has lost her mind and it's sad to see her attacking a man for his honesty. Heard brought a bunch of her friends to that place, she probably believed they would say it was Depp screaming and being abusive when it really was heard.

[@allyw1364]

Oh yeah....AH is looking very uncomfortable 😏

[@shanamanaiamaia]

Her smile while Elaine was testifying is so annoying like a little brat who's going ha ha you got in trouble

[@Virgo-zx3ez]

It seems she thought she caught him up over something to do with the car they arrived in. She started passing notes and trying to talk with her attorneys. She doesn’t realize she’s so far in this hole that she isn’t climbing out of it.. even if he got ONE small detail wrong.

[@gamingwithalex1553]

This doctor is a lot more creditable then any other psychiatrist. I am so glad they have him evaluate the case.

[@hays9008]

A psychiatrist is a Doctor. The have undertaken a medical degree and then further specialised. They are registered doctors? A psychologist is not a doctor.

[@datstuff6745]

A psychiatrist is a medical doctor lol they have to go through medical school. They can also prescribe medications. A psychologist cannot. Depp's expert psychiatrist in this video is an elite psychiatrist and what he is saying is just the facts. I wouldn't be surprised if the other psychologists that spoke for Amber have their license put into review after this case.

[@cawcawcawculator9067]

@captain scentsible39 nope, psychiatrists are doctors lmao they also went to med school so same years

[@ironsight333]

I love how during pretty much every testimony in this trial, Depp is just sitting there listening barely making eye contact with the witnesses (I'm sure if he was, Amber's team would've tried accusing him of intimidating the witness or something) Meanwhile Amber is trying to stare into & burn a hole in the souls of each person testifying and lawyers questioning

[@joanelizabeth277]

Actually her doing this to the jury shows her need to try to tell what happened and she's lying so bad. Jurors do not like this kind of eye contact and her explanation of everything is so wrong

[@justscrolling7750]

This Hicksville guy is wonderful. Honesty right there!

[@colettejaques2559]

He called Johnny old....yes true

[@amarijoseph4080]

@@colettejaques2559 is that all u got from his testimony?

[@janetrabideau4562]

Well someone is lying because that other girl said the trailer was tore up. I doubt the owner would lie about his trailer

[@desertsunset8025]

I agree .

[@ABoxIsMyHome]

Wow good point

[@reginamills6137]

Great point

[@TeamBTC17]

Love the Dr, no ego. Just facts. Pleasant and on point. Excellent witness!

[@kensleyhammond2547]

Amber and her lawyers really do make themselves look terrible throughout this. Ambers smile is absolutely telling, makes me sad to see this

[@maryocampo3799]

Ya le pago Elon a juez y jurados.

[@equatorialjourney4478]

😂🙄... but Johnnys daily smirking , laughing and ego maniacal narcissistic disdain don’t bother you, hey ? . They speak volumes ...along w his hate filled, cold, dead eyed stare ...Am assuming you r just another fan who hasn’t bothered to apprise yourself of details by reading the UK transcripts and summary ? The echo chamber is so much less confronting isn’t it 😂

[@are_birds_real]

Dude ur projecting so much u might fall backwards

[@haunthunterify]

@@equatorialjourney4478 ok Amber hahaha

[@Haru_Miu]

The smiling assassin

[@onebylandtwoifbysearunifby5475]

_"Did you know Mr. Water Man said he talks to the Umbrella Man?"_ -- "Honestly, that sounds like schizophrenia". Word Salad legal team strikes again.

[@Moss_piglets]

🤣🤣

[@VoguishMis]

Mr. Waldman but yea 🤣🤣

[@heather_doestruecrime]

Seeing her smirk about the light fixture being broken was really gross. Her face annoys me.

[@angeliaparsons4132]

IJust straight to the point of what he saw, not adding anything he didn't see or know, admitted that and that was it...Loved him!

[@susandougherty240]

Totally agree with you

[@johnmutton799]

WATCH POPCORNED PLANET ON KZbin. SEE WHAT HE TWEETS HIS STAFF AFTER HIS TESTIMONIAL. SEE WHAT THEY REPLY! AND HOW ELAINE LIES TO THE JUDGE !!!

[@diankaanadi4632]

Depps brother?

[@lorenasandoval5808]

Omg I feel for the witness who went through an abusive relationship and they won’t allow him to compare his situation with the one of Jepp’s. Man, these were good men that were taken advantage of!!

[@ABoxIsMyHome]

So sad

[@kimmiller1492]

I do too but we both know why it can’t 🤕🥲

[@HereComesKarma]

Dr. Shaw is so professional, knowledgeable, calm and respectful! He's like an A++ psychiatrist whereas Dr. Spiegel sounds like he got his license out of a crackerjack box :S AH's entire list of 'witnesses' (all former friends of hers who can/were bribed, IMO) was like watching a circus. JD's side and legal team are like the Dream Team, 'perfect' examples of how professional experts and witnesses should be, to be believable - because the are! Justice for Johnny!

[@sunshsophprd.0565]

😅😅😅😅🤣🤣🤣🤣😂

[@pennyyoung2877]

The guy who owns Hicksville what a down to earth guy. Doesnt care either way but telling the truth as to what he saw. Ms heardcwas the jealous screaming one NOT Johnny

[@lucys1288]

I could listen to this psychiatrist all day. He is so calming and professional. What a wonderful man and excellent addition to Johnnys case! :)

[@Haru_Miu]

I’m glad he combed his hair. Looks neater. Lol

[@ioanac.1211]

Me too! I was actually disappointed when the judge didn’t let him continue (understandable for the purpose of the trial) because he was so competent and compelling in describing the system, the tests etc. and I just wanted to find out more. I’m sure he could write a thesis about all the issues and situations that went wrong with that man yesterday (I can’t bring myself to call him a doctor) but he is too professional to bring out every ridiculous thing in court.

[@Nicaraguayo75]

Really liked this witness. He seems so honest and keep it simple.

[@Gothicblackchic]

I just want Amber to lose ,That smirk of hers is so infuriating and evil.

[@ABoxIsMyHome]

Be kinda weird if amber loosened up. Maybe losing is better 🤪

[@nicolebolick9663]

Funny how vicious she can turn when confronted by a mild, meek and gentle man who just wants to tell the truth . Shows how arrogant she is and how easy it would be for her to attack him -even if just verbally. Makes one reflect on her testimony of how she was "afraid" of JD. Can't you just imagine her with that same "chin up" defiance when "running from JD? What a joke!

[@driletkharkongor7518]

Even seeing her face makes me 🤮🤮

[@doorknockerpingu6932]

I cant believe how much anger that umbrella guy has generated in Amber Heards legal team

[@lrow5416]

Must be touching a nerve! I’ve watched TUG’s videos and he’s a good guy who’s also focused on truth.

[@jemimahbelsi6081]

😂😂

[@FlurryJoe]

Yeah "Umbrella man" seems really important to Heard's team.

[@lindavieira364]

I love it....tug has rubbed them up properly...fantastic...tug is my favorite man...he's simply the best

[@janebailey8032]

Lol!!! Right??!!

[@elizabethlaplante2947]

Great witness! Amber insisted she never saw this guy, that he's lying because he was never there, ha! Of course she doesn't remember him because someone like her wouldn't acknowledge anyone she'd consider 'beneath her standards'. Love this guy, honest testimony.

[@debbiewood3819]

Dr Shaw emanates a sincere, professional gentleman....a "classy" man....he's defined, clear thorough, controlled, confident w/arrogance...beautiful

[@sova1392]

why does elaine insist she knows how to pronounce the lawyer's name better than the one who actually met said lawyer?

[@karadeniz4822]

That was so weird

[@_HimToo]

She's trying to make it seem like, "look, he can't even remember the lawyer's name right ". But again, her little trick bqckfired, and Depp's lawyer made sure to nod in agreement when he corrected her... I really hope the jury noticed that. Same thing when she tried to correct him on how long ago it was- and once again he was correct & it was her who was mistaken. She just made him look even more credible!

[@leeannasloan2292]

Doctor shaw is a hero. He spent his life's work trying to find effective ways to help parents of disabled and dying children cope with their trauma! This man literally wrote the book on it. Then you have Elaine thinking of how she's gonna take him down!!! Wow the careers people choose really is telling.

[@aisha.b9693]

It’s so embarrassing to see Elaine trying to talk to him the way Camille has been handling ambers whack witnesses 😭

[@christianbosse_]

Sad truth is that Amber’s lawyers will go down as some of the least liked lawyers on the planet 😬

[@ellebell9139]

Especially when she can't even do math

[@ellebell9139]

Especially when she can't even do math

[@joshuadavey650]

@@christianbosse_ that's not sad tbh. They're very rude and unprofessional

[@christianbosse_]

@@joshuadavey650 I think it’s sad cause they’re basically throwing away their careers for a liar. But they probably knew that was a risk when they accepted the job. Added: all I know is, I couldn’t be a lawyer. I have too much integrity to defend someone who’s obviously lying, guilty, manipulative etc

[@stephaniefarnan2085]

‘’ honestly it sounds like schizophrenia” oh that cracked me up. This guy is honest and believable. Great witness for jd.

[@MeenersKitchen]

Finally! Someone else agrees. I replayed that part about 5 times and died laughing everytime!

[@sandstorm5564]

It was hilarious!!!

[@fizzai1]

This guy is awesome!! Sounds like schizophrenia 🤣🤣🤣🤣 He is so calm and well spoken.

[@fizzai1]

@@MeenersKitchen same here 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@motherof1294]

It does kind of sound crazy... " he was talking to the umbrella guy"

[@railroad5024]

Hilarious that she tried to use the "you're here because you just want to be on tv" strategy to lay a basis to discredit him, but that backfired 😂

[@asiri-wijesinghe]

What a genuine witness he is ✨

[@BeeKay4444]

They way they should all behave under oath…..we have seen a collection of dishonest characters. It is a shame that Ms. Heard’s lawyers have about as much class as her. Sad.

[@bluefeather9782]

Good WIN for Johnny!! He's not an abuser! Justice for Johnny from day one.

[@scottie2hot]

Idk why but when he said “I think it’s pronounced Jeralyn,” I laughed out loud. It was such a simple and unimportant detail, but it was funny to me. But it did indicate he wanted to get the facts straight.

[@cherylkirkpatrick7094]

Amber's attorney is fishing for anything she can. She's horrible asking the same question but in a different way, to try and get the witness to slip up and say something.

[@feliyulita1755]

English is my second languange and im too lazy to hear elaine all day,😂 can you explain the summary of what elaine asked and what the witness answer, and is it positive or negative on JD ?? Cause elaine objected a lot and the judge keep sustaining it

[@maha77us]

I didn’t like the way she was asking him questions

[@mariagmeraz3246]

Agreed, she is horrible rude no respect for the witnesses of JD .

[@pdoll96]

She reaches like Mr Fantastic

[@sheilatuano9633]

@@mariagmeraz3246 , the same thing can be said about the lawyers of Johnny Depp.

[@nicolebolick9663]

In reference to AH smirking when the trailer palace man was testifying; Funny how vicious she can turn when confronted by a mild, meek and gentle man who just wants to tell the truth . Shows how arrogant she is and how easy it would be for her to attack him -even if just verbally. Makes one reflect on her testimony of how she was "afraid" of JD. Can't you just imagine her with that same "chin up" defiance when "running from JD? What a joke!

[@Haru_Miu]

This was a display of her true colours. She definitely comes across as very arrogant, entitled, cold and mean and she was practically mocking this poor dude.

[@shanamanaiamaia]

Yesssssss Nicole yes

[@tulip5210]

Why does everyone associate her smirking here as vicious? Or that based on the imagery not the hearing she is gossiping about him? None of us have actually heard what she is saying so we don’t know. It’s not that I’m for her it’s just a fallacy I’ve been seeing and I’m annoyed by it.

[@_HimToo]

@@Haru_Miu right, meanwhile it sounds like he's more successful than she's ever been!

[@_HimToo]

@@tulip5210 ps: I now see what everyone's referring to. She is DEFINITELY talking crap to the lawyer. You can see it

[@darlenewhite5082]

One of my problem's with Amber is how she always talked about Johnny's drug use when she herself had a drug problem she said she used cocaine and her sister that set on the witness stand and all the drugs that they say Johnny supposed to have been doing. They chose not to mention that they did drugs also. How convenient!!!

[@dankendoughnut1370]

This guy is more reliable and credible than those AH's team so called "experts".

[@douluvmee]

All I know is this sweet man is sleeping peacefully tonight for being so honest!

[@JSSTyger]

31:00 Elaine: Objection! Judge: For what? Elaine: He's wrecking my case!

[@soupafi]

Judge: Overruled Elaine: Good call!

[@atem7]

amber's lawyers are just rude..

[@aisha.b9693]

Compared to Camille who was very professional in the way she asked questions and responded to witnesses when they were saying irrelevant things for example.

[@atem7]

@@aisha.b9693 true, she tells him you follow johnny depp fan while he doesn't and accuse him of lying under oath because he likes johnny.. and object to anything every witness say to prevent them from talking.. just rude. it's painful to watch lawyers like that

[@aisha.b9693]

Atem yes as if they were trying to embarrass him or demean his statements. very unprofessional, they know they are losing the case and have turned to this behaviour almost like a last resort.

[@feliyulita1755]

But why the judge keep sustaining their objection???

[@Yooh_The_Pooh]

@@atem7 yeah Truth is a battle of perceptions. And when different perceptions battle against one another, the truth has a way of getting lost, and the monsters find a way of getting out, hopefully not this time

[@janna4527]

She took pictures of everything . Except her multiple bruises , broken noses , busted up trailer etc.

[@moeafrica1674]

Where I come from thats afirst 2 many . If your wife's family see dem bruses and are true 🤔 , just count your days bro .

[@chocolate271208]

Very well said. 🤣

[@claudiastevens9628]

So wonderful how this witness came to pass.

[@onebylandtwoifbysearunifby5475]

Crooked legal team gets laughed at by the entire courtroom twice in 2 minutes: _"You're a huge fan and want attention."_ ..."NO i am NOT. And furthermore your questions sound like schizophrenia."

[@neoyasechaba221]

I quite liked the schizophrenia response 😁

[@onebylandtwoifbysearunifby5475]

@@neoyasechaba221 It was absolutely hilarious. I wonder who it was laughing on the mic.

[@pepperidgefarm5310]

Timestamp?

[@onebylandtwoifbysearunifby5475]

@@pepperidgefarm5310 Somewhere around 40:00 during cross exam.

[@cocostylesnyc]

lol I haven’t gotten to that part but o can’t wait lol 😂