Johnny Depp v. Amber Heard Defamation Trial FULL Day 20

WATCH LIVE: Johnny Depp v. Amber Heard Defamation Trial
More from Entertainment Tonight: / @entertainmenttonight
Exclusives from #ETonline :
• NEW From Entertainment...

[@-the_wandering_eremite-]

Not only is he a fellow of the American Psychiatric Association, he’s also a client.

[@dfrey1885]

You win!

[@kristamaki7379]

I think he's been sampling the free drug samples

[@esmeraldamarquez2441]

😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣💗💗

[@kleatherman1017]

I needed a good laugh thanks. This dude is off his danm rocker

[@Rasheens-Story]

Lmao he’s old now that’s probably why he’s acting funny

[@BenBanklin]

Wait, that psychologist was called as a court expert in three different states and doesn’t understand what taking a break is?

[@marthisa5800]

Yes, I noticed that too. And how she didn’t know how things operate in a courtroom, like standing up when the jury arrives and asking the judge etc…

[@refrefwgwgwegew]

:0

[@009sahibaan]

I thought it was Count Olaf on the stand!!! Where did they find this guy?? Off of the set of a series of unfortunate events! 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@kyttynkross1121]

@@lrout3561 the judge has said before that break times are specific and it doesnt matter what is going on at the time, break happens.

[@kyttynkross1121]

@@lrout3561 yeah, I'm pretty sure it's part of the lawyers responsiblity to keep track of the time and arrange their argument around that. To control the flow of the "conversation" as it were. I've seen several times now, the lawyers ask about time frames and manage to wrap up their line of questions right in line with the break.

[@JustDawn]

There's only one Captain Jack and there's no Pirates of The Caribbean without him!

[@Tkopicks]

if this is the guy they call an "Expert" we're all in trouble seemed like they grabbed random of the streets

[@mamishami9820]

Imagine the damage he has done to people seeking help

[@reneejohns]

Dope feinds.

[@theamberheardplaylist6768]

This is all you need to know--kzbin.info/www/bejne/epSYmnuDrdV4ptU

[@lauralou2538]

Im pretty sure the cooky Dr was actually the patient.

[@sjojo3332]

I was literally laughing the way he was making faces and talking and the way Johnny Depp and his team was reacting to it🤣

[@aprilc3124]

I can't with this Hollywood expert 🤦‍♀️ the bias is so obvious. And let's be clear...the public's opinion of AH flipped to negative because of her own admissions in her own recordings. To say it's because JD's lawyer said some things is utter bullcrap. AH 1000% did this to herself...

[@djm122270]

She was mad thirsty over Momoa and Clooney on the stand, like ewwwww...🤢

[@tillybug_pug4180]

And for all her “studying”, she really didn’t seem to know anything about the actors or the movies they starred in. Not sure how complete or accurate her analysis could’ve been. These were just infuriating and insufferable witnesses.

[@dma2813]

And yet these Hollywood "experts" are so fickle. She's paid to be in court and will drop Heard like everyone else after this. Let's see how this expert supports Heard after this court case.

[@oliverb6550]

Ambuser is a gold digger and a terrible actor. In addition, she is a Pathological liar, narcissistic with a big splash of various mental health disorders. She could have kept the 7 mil and kept her mouth shut. DA beachh. 😂

[@gameonmotivation00]

Yesss!! Thank you! My thoughts exactly! She is so contradicting! What she used to analyze Amber's she wouldn't have dreamed of using for Johnny's!! Wonder how much she got paid for this! The way I see it, she shot herself in the foot with her false accusations!! And my guess is that's where the social media smear campaign started! Because most of social media are seeing through her lies.

[@Xavierpng]

Thank you for making available the complete day's testimony, cross and redirect. Giving everyone an opportunity to get the full 'story'.

[@lollytavares178]

This psychiatrist is diagnosing videos, texts, rumors? WTF?! He’s out of line and its unethical. He should be reported for his behavior

[@ivyhill34]

@OUIJA Q&A Current Affairs Oh My Goodness That's Crazy!!

[@salennaskiles23]

So glad they did! Shows how far they are reaching to get an “expert”

[@rosyc9250]

@OUIJA Q&A Current Affairs insurance is not looking at medical records to diagnose

[@rosyc9250]

@OUIJA Q&A Current Affairs The insurance company places a diagnosis on the patient?

[@sophiemarcaurele]

It’s fascinating how EVERYONE on Amber’s team so far has displayed the same vibe: haughty, condescending, argumentative and defensive, aggressive and especially, they cannot answer a simple yes or no answer without going on a tangent and adding needless fluff. Disheveled manic doc here (doc Brown! You’re back from the future!!) looks like he’s been in his own prescription cabinet a tad too much himself... he’s the same age as Johnny, yet could pass as his dad. Yikes! Imagine being in a fragile state and needing support, and that dude shows up?? He’s terrifying! He speaks of narcissism whilst displaying the signs himself: he’s arrogant, egostical, condescending, believes he knows it all and everyone is below him, argumentative, likes the sound of his own voice and clearly doesn’t like to be told to shut up or follow directions. He’s a pill pusher, not a therapist. Bad move from Amber’s team yet again, I think he irritated the heck out of everyone so hopefully the jury as well! 🤔🤡😅💩🐝🍿🎪💉🎥

[@Nora-cl9qf]

He’s johnnys age ? 😳😳 looks like his grandad 🤣😭

[@mariasibley2773]

👏👏👏👏👏 Well spotted Sophie, I see the same!

[@kiaelinkx]

The worse was that IO dude, infuriating little prick

[@lovensnugs2385]

So so accurate, and hilarious, this guy only read chart notes;he is very haughty, arrogant, thinks well of himself over others!

[@MayBlake_Channel]

I'm not on Amber's team but so far I've been loving the psychiatrists testimony. I'm not seeing the signs of arrogannce or condescension that you've mentioned. Quite frankly, he reminds me a lot of Shannon Curry, and I think that the 2 of them speak in a very similar manner. I suspect that if you're on team Amber, Shannon Curry was a bithch and this guy is awesome. And of you're team Johnny, you find this guy to be a bithch and Shannon Curry to be awesome. I haven't spoken to anyone about their opinions on these 2 so I can't confirm. But I'm not (officially) on either side and I really like both doctors.

[@billionbakerss]

What the heck went on today? That dr is sitting there describing narcissism, he’s a bloody narcissist himself! Can’t admit he’s wrong, doesn’t take responsibility, lack of empathy (sitting there calling Johnny an idiot when he’s never even had a consult with him). How the heck is this bloke on the stand let alone an “expert witness”. What a joke 😂😂

[@Sandyyyyyyyyyy]

I think Johnny's team did a pretty good job of tearing down his credibility. Even aside from that though when he was describing Cluster B personality disorders being more likely to instigate IPV intimating JD is the aggressor. Then when he's reminded AH was diagnosed with 2 Cluster B personality disorders he's all, right and victims aren't perfect. 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@billionbakerss]

@FireCloud14 Hahaha, I'm Aussie

[@billionbakerss]

​@Evan Hodge spicy comment, you ok bud?

[@itsnevertoolate5123]

I’m a doctor and I’m embarrassed of those doctors that testified today! Shame! 🔔🔔🔔

[@rileyg137]

It’s very upsetting that someone can make a psychological evaluation of someone without ACTUALLY evaluating the person.

[@citygirl2808]

@@wilderfier Ellen Barkin's male counterpart???

[@itsnevertoolate5123]

Just by the fact that he kept repeating the word jealousy, paranoia etc means they instructing him to make him look that way. She was consuming the same drugs they could say the same about her. People will sell their integrity these days. Sad.

[@sarahwalsh7965]

It’s so bad!

[@erikasoto-lx2jz]

I am looking at this now again and I can't believe she never understood that she killed her career herself by trying to be malice with Johnny Depp

[@kim-thestay-at-homequilter877]

Dr Spiegel speaking on “narcissism” was very ironic. He seemed to love the sound of his own voice. Good God that was brutal. 🥴

[@kristamaki7379]

So painful

[@009sahibaan]

Dr Spiegel is none other than Count Olaf! The only person they could find to give his 'expert opinion' 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@taylarynn]

I find it interesting how the psychiatrist became increasingly closed of with mouth blocking, fidgeting, stuttering, swinging his chair back and fourth etc when being cross examined. He was very defensive probably because he knew he had to be on Amber’s side and felt that his expertise was threatened because he couldn’t be truly honest. He has a lot of narcissistic traits himself, he’s very worried about what he says and what makes him look good and ultimately making Amber look good. It’s clear as day! “Thank you for plugging my book” sir… this isn’t an interview, this is a legal process.

[@316lvmnoneofyourbusiness7]

So let me get this straight. This "doctor" based part of his diagnosis by watching Depp's movies. I'm just a lowly retired mental health worker, but when we reviewed cases with a psychiatrist, we always gave a provisional diagnosis. If we suspected that a patient didn't meet all the criteria for a mental health diagnosis, we gave a R/O - rule out. Which means, a suspicion of a mental illness. For example: A provisional diagnosis: Bi-polar 2 d/o (because the patient met all the criteria and it's listed first as the diagnosis is what is causing the most problem), PTSD, r/o Dissociative d/o, r/o Personality d/o nos (not other wise specified). And..... 50% of people who use substances go on to commit IPV. I don't know, I've never seen a person who smokes weed go out and beat the shit out of a significant other or someone else or a heroin user or a huffer...... Imo, this guy is full of himself, is distant from patients, and I would absolutely hate to have him be my psych doc.

[@reneejohns]

I have. All 3.

[@vonbonbonjager]

I think these witnesses actually reinforce JDs claims, unless the Jury are sleeping I'm sure they have gathered that.

[@AgentClaytonWebb]

Right on if this guy was my psych, I’d be looking for a new one!

[@gertruidawilhase1613]

He himself doesn't look all there

[@TheBrothergreen]

"50% of people who use substances go on to commit IPV. I don't know, I've never seen a person who smokes weed go out and beat the shit out of a significant other" Using a substance, even an illegal substance, recreationally is not substance abuse/substance use disorder. Substance abuse, by definition, requires the substance in question, be it alcohol or weed or oxy or heroin or whatever, legal or not, to damage a person's life, whether they get fired from a job, land themselves in prison, alienate their support network, etc. Whatever. Starting with that definition of substance abuse, it's not surprising that 50% of people would likely qualify under the latter umbrella. There's also overlap. Most "real" addicts screw their lives up royally and don't limit themselves to JUST one type of self-destructive behavior. The expert in question also testified that his definition of IPV is not exclusively limited to physical violence. Any pattern of abuse could potentially qualify under the expert's definition.

[@suewilliams7661]

There’s no pirates of the Caribbean without mr Johnny depp he is pirates 🏴‍☠️ of the Caribbean

[@jaybeaufort8198]

No one cares about those stupid kids pirate movies. Pirates are meant to be virile men who can fight enemies. Johnny is old, fat and bloated now. No thanks. I don’t want fat pirates

[@charlenereap4804]

Mr.J.D HAS SPOILERS MRSAMBER AND BOOTH NEED HELP BUT ALL THIS IS SO DAD.MR.J.D.ISNT A BAD MAN .IT TAKES TWO.

[@user-ff4tw8uf4b]

I stopped following the series but even I know he *made* that character.

[@calherman8554]

I understand that Amber’s witnesses are hired by her and her team to testify for them but they all feel insufferably biased. Their whole attitude shifts when being cross examined by Johnny’s team, and it’s exactly that… attitude! Just feels really unprofessional, argumentative, and petty.

[@annesophiejp]

So you notice her witnesses bias, but you don't notice his witnesses bias?

[@crz-mzlstaring3375]

@@annesophiejp absolutely i agree

[@crz-mzlstaring3375]

Depp witness are the same hired

[@savannah4340]

@@annesophiejp The motive for their testimony is where it's at. Of course some of them will have bias for Johnny, these are friends and colleagues testifying for him. They're testifying because they've seen the truth and are telling their side. Amber is paying these people off and risking their jobs and credibility. It's insane

[@exmohobobonobo]

@@annesophiejp I think you are onto something here! I think “bias” is the wrong word. Each side probably does have a bias. I think the correct words are “competence” and “professionalism,” which is even worse. Hers are all blow hards that look good on paper, with proper credentials, but are flying by the seat of their pants in reality.

[@Elle-gc8xc]

This is so insane. How did they keep letting this “Dr” talk literally about nothing? I thought this was a trial on the defamation of Johnny Depp, how does an “expert witness” give witness statement without having spoken to the person their being a witness about? Johnny Depp has been open about his struggles with sobriety, and substance use. Amber beards team is trying to correlate his using with the “alleged abuse” and it just doesn’t fit, all the evidence doesn’t fit that he “abused her” during usage. They’re trying to fit a circle into a triangle peg, Ambers team is reaching and it’s horrible to watch. Each witness has stated they’ve never seen Johnny get violent or physical with her, them constantly trying to bring up his drug use that’s he’s been open about is becoming tiring. If that’s their whole case, his drug use? then they have no case. I hope the jury sees through these tactics. I hope Johnny Depp gets justice

[@roc7880]

you have no idea how many such so-called experts are around.

[@RotmgPissmufin]

Oh trust me most of the jury is sick of this shit, noone liked Dr spiegel

[@heavenphillips3867]

Yep. There are audio recordings of the day he lost his finger, amber was in the background crying saying shes sorry. The doctor said "she did this, its gonna have to be reattached."

[@roc7880]

@@RotmgPissmufin whether they like her it not is important. Only if they believed her.

[@salennaskiles23]

He ate up a lot of ambers teams time. Lol

[@Munsy42]

I swear that Dr Spiegel reminded me of Jim Carrey in Me Myself and Irene when he had bad cotton mouth and needed water the way he would contort his mouth and stick out his tongue! 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@nadiameyer3566]

Lol looks like he is struggling with cotton mouth😂😂😂 you can even hear his tongue click against the top of his mouth🤣🤣🤣

[@fivestarversustheworld8359]

NOTICE HOW he stopped looking at the jury and stopped talking to the jury and started really focusing on dennison lmao and continued to get angry everytime there was a question asked.

[@reneejohns]

druggie. Schooled hi to fix that on break. And gave him couple zanax.

[@dma2813]

Dr Spiegel is obviously not used to being questioned. His position in academia and as a psychiatrist allows him to "lecture" to others and its quiet evident that he can't answer a question directly and doesn't like to be questioned. He wants to constantly "lecture" to others his knowledge rather than answer the question directly. He was very comfortable with his relaxed attitude and body language when given free speech by Heards lawyer. Well done to Mr Depps lawyer with his line of questioning, researching of physiactric terminology, knowledge of testing and keeping Dr Spiegel on his toes. I don't think he expected it and you can see how uncomfortable he is and back tracking because he can't remember his grandiose rambling!

[@emilylove1436]

Ben Chew's reactions are everything 😂😂😂😂...I love how he simply enjoys a good lawyer

[@KarenRodriguez-fo1pd]

They’re talking about Johnny and his “substance abuse” as if Amber never used any. I’m sure they did it together. I don’t understand why they’re just pointing fingers.

[@ezip331]

And amber was also on a range of prescription drugs I don’t understand

[@daniiii0825]

Failing to mention how many times she asked Johnny to get MDMA for her. For someone who wants to promote his sobriety you sure didn’t care enough to not get wasted and do drugs yourself in his presence many times. She’s such a joke!! Get this liar outta of here!

[@annesophiejp]

You can use drugs and not become addicted. She's clearly clean now and has made up her life, unlike him.

[@corneliakobilke4638]

@@annesophiejp he is clean too?

[@carolc3279]

She even admitted to doing them!!!

[@reisschancellor9753]

When I first saw Kiera Knightley in Bend It Like Beckham, or Scarlette Johansson in LiT, you knew they were extraordinary. AH, not even close to being a dime a dozen good-looking actresses. Unremarkable. Forgettable. Pretentious.

[@marthisa5800]

In other words, replaceable….

[@saimak7079]

LiT - was that the porno she did?

[@krystalsprouse7026]

There’s some people that just… have it. And Amber doesn’t. She’s just another pretty faced blonde. She gets cast because of her appearance, not because of her skills. Actors/Actresses that get cast for their skill are the ones that are acting long into their old age, even after they bypass their peak physical attractiveness. Johnny was completely correct when he said that when Amber’s physical appearance declines, she will no longer be employable in this industry.

[@marthisa5800]

@@krystalsprouse7026 and also the ones that break through since early on. Her witness said she made 50 movies before aquaman.

[@ashthompson2968]

She was absolutely terrible in the Rum Diary.

[@James-od5eq]

I think the one that has the most narcissistic traits in the courtroom is the psychiatrist himself.... of course except Amber.

[@ioelisasili]

totally agree hahahahhahaha

[@veraandgenc1135]

Waw... you must be a psychologist

[@javeriasiddique7417]

not these clowns believing Aquaman was THE highest-grossing film, like Spiderman, Batman, and Avengers don't exist

[@blue_sky_bright_sun7599]

Watch the full trial and listen to the tapes. Not one person who’s ACTUALLY watched the trial, reviewed the evidence and listened to the tapes would think that “they’re both toxic” or “they’re both abusive”. That is for a reason. A lot of people were “pro Amber” when this all started. Review the evidence and you will see why everyone is on Johnny’s side, and I mean 100% on his side. He hasn’t been abusive to her in any way, form or shape. Unless you consider calling someone names after hours and hours of being bullied physically, emotionally and psychologically. This isn’t a case of “both were…”. Not at all. This is a case of an evil cruel person ruining an innocent’s, a good person’s life who has been nothing but generous and kind and loving towards them. I know it’s hard to believe. But the evidence proves it. I am myself astounded at how frickin evil this woman is. It just…baffles me.

[@StreakyBaconMan]

One thing I have noticed is that people who still support Heard at this point almost exclusively say "I refuse to watch any of the trial coverage" as though watching the court case would somehow brainwash them. They think it's a GOOD think that they won't look at the evidence, and that those who do are being brainwashed and harming domestic abuse victims somehow.

[@Aertistic]

Speak for yourself. I've watched almost this entire trial, listened to the uncut 5 hours of recorded conversations, and read 100 pages of transcripts from the UK trial. Depp is the primary aggressor. Saying she has no evidence over and over doesn't make it true.

[@rileyg137]

I absolutely agree, I’ve tuned in every day since day one of this trial and the insurmountable evidence his counsel has versus her counsels hearsay claims, it’s not a question of who is in the wrong, it’s a question of what is the truth that Amber is not telling?

[@Nora-cl9qf]

1000%

[@StreakyBaconMan]

@@Aertistic So what is this evidence she supposedly has and why aren't her lawyers presenting it? What piece of evidence convinced you that Depp was the primary aggressor towards a woman who cut off his finger and confessed to assaulting him on tape?

[@anastasiakhumalo6985]

This Dr doesn't look 100 in the head. LMAO imagine being diagnosed by someone like him. He didnt even understand what taking a break was, He was super argumentative. Another bad witness for Amber.

[@naeemahmitchell7674]

He prob takes the same 💊 💊 prescribed for his patients. Crazzzzy

[@aanat9704]

LOL he looks like DOC from back to the future hahaha

[@Hotminutemanda]

​@@aanat9704 lol I thought the same thing 😅

[@izybunny1999]

He's on meth

[@kristamaki7379]

Hostile

[@cuppacoffee75]

Well I don't know who the photographer in the court room works for but he sure is focusing on getting a pic of JD's lawyers phone and paperwork. I'm not sure why he'd even be allowed to stand there in the opening and do that🤷‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️ 8:37

[@charlottewright146]

Is someone being asleep behaviour indicitive of ipv violence?? Did I just hear that question right from Amber's team? What a bunch of clowns. This is unbelievable.

[@gerdaklingenboeck118]

It is about being so intoxicated that you lose control and fall inconscious wherever you are, what you are holding in your hand, etc. It is about addiction disorder.

[@caataa2370]

All I’m thinking about is chronic fatigue from severe depression from being in an abusive relationship 😬

[@gerdaklingenboeck118]

It is not. As I have written he stated about abuse disorder. Abuse disorder often geschrieben Hand in Hand with violence, this is scientifically proven. Ever live with a heavy alcoholic father? It is sad but the Substances change your personality over time esp. Ever known a cocaine addict?

[@gerdaklingenboeck118]

@@caataa2370 I really dont like how you all play down what addiction does to you. This is Not fair, Not to the people struggling with it, nor to their families. I am a survivor of that. I dont judge but Playing that down is really Not good.

[@Mckinley-mick]

@@gerdaklingenboeck118 yes I grew up with an alcoholic father, who also dealt with many other drug addictions and for a lot of my childhood he was physically and verbally abusive to my sister and I, COMPLETELY regardless of if he was using a substance or not. You see, my father is diagnosed with many mental illnesses and disorders. Many are similar to AH, including BPD, narcissistic PD, etc. Those issues that he refused to admit and get help for is what caused him to justify and intensify his damage. However, on the flip side, my current partner struggles with alcohol addiction. He uses this much like JD and all of his witnesses seem to attest to, he self medicates and deals with his internal struggles by drinking and doing drugs, like MANY people do. HOWEVER, my partner is THE most gentle man I have ever met. He has never laid a single finger on me, any time he gets the least bit frustrated he chooses to walk away and take some space so he doesn’t even get the chance to escalate his anger. Which can be exactly heard on the audio clips with JD. Sometimes he’ll drink then, sometimes he won’t. However, that does NOT change how he interacts with me, it’s does NOT make him more violent. If anything, most of the people in my life who do self medicate with substances or have in the past are calmed down by those substances. It’s extremely gross and hurtful to generalize all of a group when it’s simply not true. Addiction/substance abuse does NOT automatically mean any other type of abuse or harm of any sort is guaranteed to be inflicted on anyone outside of one’s self. JD liver was definitely abused by JD himself by drinking so much- but according to all other evidence- there is not a single sign that he ever abused any human person.

[@alexchoukas6675]

Imagine this guy diagnosing you? Smh this guy is horrible 💯

[@lilbit4008]

I'm halfway through and I think he looks like an angry Muppet!

[@briellemarie03]

why is he horrible? i’m genuinely wondering cuz i didn’t watch the whole video lol

[@aprilc3124]

@@lilbit4008 🤣🤣🤣 omg you nailed it. He's totally Beaker the meeper!

[@garlicbread378]

He needs to have a detox and go through medical school sgain

[@StarLight37773]

@@lilbit4008 I think he looks like a cross between doc brown and ducky from the land before time lol

[@spzmnky3]

Has anyone pointed out that this doctor's testimony ALSO DOESN'T BACK UP Amber's story either?! She said he crushed it with the phone repeatedly. OBVIOUSLY IMPOSSIBLE!

[@deirdretyson9346]

The witnesses that Amber’s team had up all seemed like paid witnesses that had a tainted viewpoint toward Johnny. I am utterly confused why all of the conversations around Johnny’s substance abuse disorder wasn’t also pointed towards Amber who obviously partook in all of this behavior as well. Just because someone is a drug addict doesn’t make them a IPV perpetrator.

[@corneliakobilke4638]

I think it’s because theres proof to his and not so much to hers so she just pretends she never had a proven

[@KitKat-yw8cv]

Expert witnesses are paid. And by the side who subpeonas them, generally for hefty hourly rates.

[@hamidalharbi5939]

JUSTICE FOR JOHNNY DEPP 💙

[@d.o._cheflife365]

I can't wait for a South Park episode about this trial!!! 🤣😂

[@debwilliard3440]

The Depp lawyer channeling Columbo is the bomb!

[@JL-zn7me]

I do not believe this was a doctor. He is certifiable. His behavior was disgusting, scary and disrespectful. The doctor before him lost all credibility, stating a vodka bottle couldn’t have severed Johnny’s finger! Then we have the woman who held up her baby and said he was Johnny’s! WHAT IN THE WORLD HAPPENED TODAY?! I would have had security surround Johnny and his team today! 😳

[@reneejohns]

Her team- dope fiends all of them. I wouldnt let any of them near me. I knew a surgeon and a pilot who both were crack pipe fiends AND went to work the morning the sun came up from smoking it all nite. Scarey.

[@everleigh245]

Not to mention the judge seems totally pissed and burnt out , .

[@sardonyxz]

Amber claimed the baby is Johnny's?

[@JL-zn7me]

@sardonyx- no. A random woman sitting in the courtroom, watching the trial. She stood up, held her baby up and claimed it was Johnny’s. A reporter that was in the courtroom gave us her witness account. The woman was removed and banned from the courtroom… but remained outside with her baby. The day of the unstable!!!!

[@sardonyxz]

@@JL-zn7me oohhh I see.. I couldn't watch today...it was awful... I felt sorry for the jury when sam the eagle was testifying ..

[@ashleykai8030]

You can totally tell that the judge is fed up!

[@mitsumeeshi]

It's Depp's lawyer, Wayne Dennison, who deserves the credit. HE made it happen. I wonder if that's Dennison's style. If it's a way of making these witnesses see the mistakes and contradictions in their testimonies and knowledge. I honestly think he's better than the other lawyers on the team, if I can compare. I mean, Vasquez is very reactive, I've noticed. She's quick, but could step up her game if she did more research and took the time to learn the lingo that is used and practiced in these witnesses' fields of profession. I mean, Dennison takes his time and is adorably (and perhaps deceptively bumbling in his speech, like Columbo, I'm tellin ya!), but he KNOWS what he's talking about. He surprises the witnesses with his knowledge. It's so entertaining!!! #DennisonBroughtIt

[@heatheranderson3570]

This is spot on. I agree Dennison’s style is purposeful and strategic. He knows exactly what he’s doing. He is a lawyer the jury can connect with. Love the Colombo reference!

[@winstonchurchll]

I didn't consider the "Columbo" angle for Dennison, but I think you're on to something!

[@mitsumeeshi]

@@heatheranderson3570 Thank you! “Purposeful and strategic” - YES!! I hope he’s appreciated.

[@mitsumeeshi]

@@winstonchurchll Wayne “Columbo” Dennison! The Columbo lawyer! :-)

[@santunoo]

Well said. I've been impressed with Dennison more so than Depp's other lawyers as well. He may not be as showy or combative as others, but he is quite skillful in drawing witnesses into traps. If I were a law student, I would be more interested in studying his technique than Vasquez's.

[@yeeyeetseng670]

Honestly, she didn’t stand out that much in Aquaman, I didn’t know who she was… I think she got her fame as JD’s wife and from suing JD as a DV victim. As this case evolved and more are brought to light… that’s when her name is heard.

[@Mckinley-mick]

Exactly she wanted… with as much extra money she can squeeze out of him before moving up her ladder of “success”.

[@spzmnky3]

Exactly. I never knew who she was until this trial.

[@danielbradstreet7731]

pun intended?

[@nehadutta4985]

How can he diagnose someone without ever consulting him ? Making a joke of psychiatry and mental sciences smh

[@emilylee9894]

Reversely, why has Johnny consistently avoided taking a personality test and meeting for a legitimate clinical assessment by a licensed psychotherapist that he had not hired? What is he hiding. Would love to see his lie detector test results regarding the injured finger.

[@user-ff4tw8uf4b]

@@emilylee9894 A different type of test maybe. Lie detectors have been proved to be ineffective and beatable. It’s unclear why anyone still uses them.

[@ezip331]

How can he diagnose Johnny based on his acting in pirates

[@nehadutta4985]

@@emilylee9894 that's a different story altogether , here I'm only making a comment on this man's evaluations based on what ?! I've never heard of such clinical opinions without direct interaction. It's painting a pseudo scientific picture of psychiatry.

[@hannahreed5073]

@@emilylee9894 well it was his legal team too refusing so i’m wondering if they knew ambers team would question him about johnny’s personality, then they could use the argument that he never met him to make the diagnoses so basically everything he said isn’t even really usable

[@Hooklineandsinker145]

Johnny’s attorneys are unbelievable! Excellent team, I just hope it’s enough to get his life back and move on, the world loves Johnny, so Disney, who likes to deem people guilty until proven innocent, can kick rocks. Johnny Depp will always be Captain Jack. I wonder if Johnny wants to direct or produce. I don’t care if he rails lines 24/7, he’s an incredible man inside out.

[@dianekalcevic2095]

I thought Also that his team his unbelieveable. I’m so impressed with the woman atty! U get what u pay for!!!!

[@riccismith8648]

I am with u!!! He is a awesome man & a incredible actor. Im so happy he is divorced from that psychopath .

[@Hooklineandsinker145]

Yeah, and that one kid that had cancer, one of his wishes was to meet captain Jack sparrow, so he got done up for that and the dude visited every child that was inpatient at that hospital. He’s always opening doors/ fixing chairs, the guy genuinely cares about people, he treats his fans w respect even though he sometimes encounters annoying paparazzi and garbage people. I do feel bad for any partner that he’s an alcoholic, but amber knew that. I just don’t think it’s relevant because he didn’t abuse women. I don’t know, I just feel bad for the guy, this woman is psycho. She also criticized him for things she’d do, herself. I don’t claim to know any more than that, but I’m usually good at figuring out vibes. I have respect and admiration for the guy. Seems he’s not the liar, but she lies consistently

[@kristamaki7379]

I cancelled my Disney plus subscription in honor of Johnny Depp... screw you Disney 🤣

[@Barbara-eq6cm]

@Krista… Ignore L.Rout. That’s just Amber and PR team working overtime.

[@Hotminutemanda]

My goodness this psychiatrist is so toxic in my opinion and emotionally unstable and just absolutely ridiculous that I would want nothing to do with him as my personal doctor if I had to speak to somebody about issues in my life.🤦🏻‍♀️

[@BrEmail]

Maybe not, but he could get your delorean up to 88 mph 🤣

[@Hotminutemanda]

​@@BrEmail lol exactly.🤣 No disrespect to Christopher Lloyd but this guy kind of reminded me of his character in Back to the Future.😅

[@wren3895]

He's triggering my misophonia so bad. How hard is it to just swallow you spit?!

[@Mckinley-mick]

@@wren3895 dry mouth from drugs?? 😂😂

[@bonniewhite3711]

Worst expert I ever saw. He thinks Johnny is the narcissist when it’s clearly her. He needs to apply everything he said to her instead open your eyes!!!!

[@hanswurst8380]

Maybe he is one himself.

[@vernaxxx8940]

@@hanswurst8380 People who spend decades in positions of authority adopt that magisterial manner. Diagnosis depends on whether they can drop it in private life. I've known schoolteachers that have a problem in that regard, not to mention distinguished professionals.

[@reneejohns]

Psych doc and her abuse adderall together.

[@Tiffany-Rose]

Oh we all see it, he's describing her to a T

[@Bioflunz]

All this, and I still can't recall having seen Amber in a movie. Ever.

[@mystic8884]

Same 😂😂

[@DallelynRamirez]

Lmao! Same

[@mrsangelafisher]

Me to. I was surprised when that lady said she had been in like 50 movies before Aquaman!

[@corinnesdiary1990]

Johnny looks soo tired now , tired of the BS that’s going on . Hope you get your justice Johnny 💙

[@kristamaki7379]

He needs a smoke break

[@tamraking2838]

That Psychiatrist reminds me of the actor in Back to the Future lol

[@demimaltos2838]

“What if any” her favorite question

[@BrEmail]

What if any of her questions were relevant? 😂

[@deadinthenight]

“It’s not the cure all” Judge Penny😂

[@cheekyvendetta2974]

This makes me so mad. How dare they paint Johnny as the narcissist, when it is SOOO obvious who is. She literally radiates narcissism when she's on the stand.

[@zozaazz8044]

crazy that the doctor thinks that the injury cannot come from a bottle and yet he was not asked about how can a woman look flawless after having a broken nose and being smashed so many times that she does not remember with rings

[@karenday7146]

When she compared amber to zendaya 😂😂 that’s when i knew she is completely biased

[@courtneyreiner]

Also; Gal Gadot, Jason Momoa… not even close lol

[@rizzy1789]

Losing track of what exactly this trial is about in first place. This feels more like a divorce case being argued towards finalising who the real victim is rather than a defamation case. What they did within the privacy of their home has nothing to do with defamation.

[@safiy98]

It has everything to do with it because Ambers lies is what defamated Johnny.

[@nehaliacharya7257]

Didn’t anybody tell Dr. Narcissist that HE was the biggest idiot in the courtroom today 🤷🏻‍♀️ Smh!

[@RosemaryN78]

Lmao truth!

[@jacquelinetorres5668]

Dr. David Smeagol is looking for his precious 😅🤣🤣🤣 got him crazyyy🤪

[@mary-mb2ml]

I need Ambers witnesses to open their ears and listen to the questions before answering…. this was painful to watch

[@m00se40]

Jack Sparrow needs Johnny Depp, not the other way around 🙏

[@Eli_Za04]

Once again, Camille nailed it.. If I have done something wrong and i see Camille on the opposition. Im gonna say 'your honor I plead guilty'.. 😂

[@mirnaperk5804]

There is a distinct difference when Johnny's lawyers ask questions and when Amber's lawyers ask questions

[@jjeanjohnston244]

I know ..she's a beautiful beast. I was hoping and praying that Camille was the one that would question TURD but I wish she had this bitch too.. This on3 needed to be shown who is BOSS for real.. This TWATT ain't it.

[@Savannahlynn]

God this psychiatrist is severely pissing me off. There’s so many points in his testimony where he contradicts himself but the main point that irritates the hell out of me was when he said narcissists will apologize. as someone who’s endured narcissistic abuse my whole life, that is NEVER something I’ve experienced. Narcissists don’t apologize because they are unable to see anything wrong with their behavior. They may say something along the lines of “ I’m sorry but… you did this and this” and push the blame back on you just to gain back control in their minds, but they will never genuinely apologize for their actions. I think those characteristics are FAR more consistent with ambers behavior than with Johnny. if you compare the two side to side you will see that undeniably. Just looking at Johnny’s behavior sure maybe you could find some TRAITS of narcissistic behavior but you could surely see that with literally anyone you examined if you were looking for it, however his empathy for others is enough to see he does not have narcissistic personality disorder ( which is far different than simply have some narcissistic traits)

[@rachelbowers6598]

Same. My partner never apologized. They were narcissistic and it was always me apologizing

[@MayBlake_Channel]

I've also endured narcissistic abuse my whole life and I have two slight disagreements here. 1. A fake apology is still an "apology" in the sense that the words "I'm sorry" still come out. I'm only on hour 3, minute 11 so maybe I haven't gotten to that part yet, but I might guess that he isn't specifying whether the apology is fake or genuine. 2. Because many narcissists go through cycles of idolizing and devaluing you, there are times where the narcissist will FEEL sorry. My mother never gave any sincere apologies but I had a boyfriend who used to cry and tell me that he didn't deserve me. Did he ever change? No. He felt justified in abusing me. But he did feel bad for hurting me, even though he didn't really belive he was wrong. He would go back and for between believing he was a monster and had no soul, to believing that he was the victim of a girlfriend who mistreated him I almost think about me and my daughter. Sometimes I have to punish her but I feel bad when I do. It's like narcissists "punish" for selfish reasons, even when you're a full-grown adult (or over punishing you as a child, which my mother did.) and then feel sad that that they 'had to do it.' Bottom line, I agree with you on narcissists and apologies, but I suspect that you're misunderstanding the psychiatrist.

[@madhusantana9152]

When amber apologizes you can tell it’s not a true apology because she is incapable of that as narcissists are

[@margaridagoncalves2591]

I guess I don´t do doctors anymore!! Sacared asf

[@veeanne5616]

Narcissists are very dismissive, they are self entitled, stubborn, self righteous, have delusions of grandeur, they ignore your messages even when you are needing to talk, they dont acknowledge others feeelings, everything is on their terms, they only love/like you when they are benefiting from it. Once they dont need you? they dont want you.

[@poojachauhan-ch6eb]

Honestly I didn't even know who 🤮 amber heard is until this defamation trial.. The more i see her, the worse she gets😖. Hope Johnny 💜 wins the trial.

[@suewilliams7661]

I agree girl

[@janlea1036]

Same. I had to Google her.

[@tealk9951]

I have seen some movies she is in, but never paid any attention to her because she just didn’t stand out in the movie. Wasn’t till this trial I even noticed her! I don’t think she is loosing the 45 to 50 million dollars that the witness said she is. She is no where near the other actors she is being compared to. I remember them from their roles un like AH. Just saying

[@poojachauhan-ch6eb]

@@tealk9951 after knowing that she was in aquaman, I had to search her part.. I watched aquaman twice but as you said she never stand out plus the makeup made her look different she doesn't look that good irl.

[@selenefroehlich9138]

All I can say Dr Spiegel is a genius, from the records he analyzed and the behavior he saw he recognized true patterns, Johnny's substance abuse and Amber's if she'd been truly abused also fit the perfect ipv example.

[@raulz760]

no bap

[@ChaseisaGhost]

Dude how was THAT guy brought in as an expert witness and HOWWW is he a shrink?!? Omg 😂

[@jarrellbamberger545]

I'm just guessing but maybe he spent so much time with a psychiatrist that he thinks he is one. Someone needs to call the local funny farm and ask if there missing a patient!!!

[@JustDawn]

L'oreal SHOULD be boycotted! Get rid of this abusive narcissist monster that goes by Amber Heard

[@missee7951]

Anything Amber will be associated with will tank horribly. I’m not even sure she will be hired any where now…..too much bad press. Johnny has won the public opinion, that’s all that matters. 👍🏻😊

[@stephenvangogh1]

The rings on Johnny Depps fingers. If he punched her she'd be scarred for life. The only person in that room that scares me is Amber Heard.

[@missnix6151]

Funny when a witness for amber doesn’t like being proven wrong 😂😂

[@MallyNC]

So ready to see who Depp’s team calls next!

[@cheekyvendetta2974]

If Johnny was the narcissist in the relationship, Amber wouldn't have been able to go out and party all the time like she did. Anyone who grew up in a household with a narcissist knows how controlling they can be and to what extent. My own mom was emotionally manipulated to not spend time with her friends or family for 20 years. I've seen it first hand. When you're a victim to narcissistic abuse you essentially don't live life anymore. Does that seem like Amber the whole time she was married to Johnny? No.

[@laurakeplinger6004]

THIS! I've been there...."you essentially don't live life anymore." I felt that so deeply, it's so true. The seclusion from anybody that loves you is easier to deal with than the hell you'd go through just to try to spend time with those people that you love too.😭 absolute hell to live through. #justiceforJD

[@cheekyvendetta2974]

@@laurakeplinger6004 I'm so sorry you know the feeling too well too :( Sending you so much love and light!

[@Tiffany-Rose]

Exactly. They have a handbook, the pattern is nearly identical. Isolation is part of one of those steps. She would not have been able to have all her friends move in. Public appearances would have dwindled, parties too. She would have been cut off from the outside world as much as possible. He wouldn't have that many people who love and care about him, he wouldn't have good relationships with his ex's. The list goes on. You know who followed those steps though? Heard. Shes taking zero responsibility for anything, she's trying to show evidence to prove her claims but it's actually working against her. The only people to come in person for her is her sister. Even her supposed bff's are all EX friends 🤦‍♀️

[@Fadedshadows]

Exactly my mom was that way, if she didn’t like someone or they offended her I wasn’t allowed to associate with them even if they’re family. She tried alienating me from people who made me happy. Amber had a lot of freedom for being the so called victim of a narcissist.

[@Fadedshadows]

@@lrout3561 there’s a good alcoholic abuser? Just curious as to why you said bad as if abuser didn’t already imply that. Also I will add that my mom was an alcoholic and was nicer to me when she’s drunk compared to sober. But even if that would be considered a “good” alcoholic you shouldn’t need alcohol or drugs to be a good person to your loved ones especially. I am a victim and out of the two in this trial Amber reminds me of my abusive mother by far…and like the others in this comment thread I agree with the Commentor you are replying to.

[@billypoertner2138]

We were sitting here waiting for Marty McFly to barge into the courtroom to rescue him saying "come on Doc! Let's go back to the future! Amber Heard lost!".

[@juliesantos3114]

this is the best fucking comment lmaoooo

[@fridamaldonado8426]

🙃🙃🙃🙃👍👍👍

[@MrRayrenz]

If I was the judge I'd say "Ma'am you shut up! Case dismissed."

[@crazy_ninja_force5225]

Johnny Depp with that death stare. I love it. Everyone loves Camile, but I have to say, Johnny's whole team are beast.

[@justineamber6923]

I do not understand how Katherine Arnold can brush off how Johnny Depp’s life was completely ruined by abuse allegations and he was basically fired from one of his highest paying jobs but she can speak so much on how Amber’s potential career was affected like her scenes from Aquaman 2 being cut down drastically, how her L’Oréal ads were ruined by defamation, every movie she was ever associated was affected and even the charities she was affiliated with were bombarded with harassment. Also, Ms. Arnold has the nerve to mention how Johnny is wrong by suing Amber because he is reigniting old issues that keeps her from getting jobs. Are you freaking kidding me. This woman is completely biased. Not to mention how she weakly accused some texts Johnny wrote talking about “burning a corpse” when Amber is on record saying more than once she hit Johnny. This is excruciating to listen too.

[@MarmiAfrinTsubie]

Maybe if he wasn’t a shriveled old boomer abusing drugs and alcohol and constantly late to work and costing others their time and money, he’d be allowed to play pirate again? 🙄🙄🙄

[@RainCloud848]

ThatUmbrellaGuy @ThatUmbrella 2h Warner Brothers made it VERY clear. Amber Heard would NOT have been paid more for Aquaman 2. And it wasn't Johnny Depp that caused her issues. It was her and her issues with Jason Momoa. Meaning her affair with Manoa!!!

[@themagickcauldronwitch5124]

@@MarmiAfrinTsubie He isn't shriveled and honey, in a blink of an eye you will be that age too. Two, addiction is a struggle. It's not an option, people don't wake up and decide to be addicted. Your brain chemically changes for ever, your reward sector's in your brain change. He is sick and needs help and still with all his addictions has a trail of a lifetime filled will good deeds and good things he has constantly always done for his cast, for his coworkers, for his friends, for children and fans in general. She took advantage of him and made him a mark. She wanted his money and fame just like she wanted Elon's. Yall are naive, willingly ignorant or perhaps just as bad as her to not perceive her abusive and exploitative behavior and blame the actual victim. It takes an addict much will power and over a year of being clean to actually even begin to feel normal and even then you will still hear the addict pop and say something that shakes you and triggers you without it actually being drugs there. An addict will always fight an invisible battle every single day with triggers constantly specially the first 8 months. It doesn't get better and even after they been clean for a while they can get too comfortable and cocky and relapse when they lease expected. To them, believe it or not, it's a vicious circle of both wanting, craving and hating the drug and the destruction that follows. They chase the high. The moment they feel invisible and they keep redosing spending thousands of dollars, risking their life, pissing and puking themselves losing consciousness disappearing for days and doing unimaginable things in the midst of it. They feel shame for what they've done so they redose again to numb it. And boom a merigoround of chasing the high, feeling like shame, numbing it, chasing the high, to numb it. Losing control again feeling the shame. It's a fuckin awful life. They hate it. But they succumb to it bc they don't know what else to do about it.

[@justineamber6923]

@@themagickcauldronwitch5124 don’t worry about Marmee Arfrin clearly they just want to be a troll. Don’t even waste your time on people like that.

[@evedroid]

I'm guessing she, like that orthopedic at the beginning, is hired by AH's team and getting $1,000 / hour for her slimy testimony

[@minafl1]

It's eerie how much the psychiatrist is describing Amber to a tee, while trying to attribute those traits to Johnny Depp. With all the kindness and generosity that Depp showed over the years, I think it's clear who the self centered narcissist was in this relationship. From lack of compassion, blame, need for approval, to gaslighting and violence.

[@saimak7079]

Question: these are witnesses called to give testimony on behalf of Amber. Besides being vetted beforehand, do they get paid to 'fight for a side'? They risk their professional reputation.

[@saimak7079]

On further watching, I got my answer. The orthopaedo gets paid 1k an hour, and 5k for each day of testimony! €€€

[@alliebonesVODs]

It's like any witness lying under oath - expert witnesses are supposed to be neutral and as unbiased as possible, not pick a side - but just because it's not allowed doesn't mean people don't do it :\

[@saimak7079]

@@alliebonesVODs ok, but presumably they are already 'persuaded' by a certain enactment of events. Do you reckon there are consequences to being recalled in the future should their testimony be swayed in the process of cross examination by the other side?

[@sthomp41]

Think of it this way - A lawyer approaches you for professional testimony. You agree to review the data presented, in an unbiased manner, and you charge them an hourly rate because it is part of your business. They are only given certain data to review and come to a conclusion based on what they review. This doesn't mean they are biased or lying. They may make mistakes (like any other human) or simply overlook something that another professional might have seen. This is a very common practice in any court room. Both sides have done this.,

[@saimak7079]

Thanks

[@TrezzasVillage]

Stop talking about HIS substance & alcohol use, this is about HER attempting to destroy his reputation & defamation!!!!

[@ginjakel2298]

No. This is about the character of the person too. Both of them

[@ddk567t]

The burden is on him to show that she defamed him. Not the other way around..

[@sophiemarcaurele]

Or at least, talk about HER drugs and drink habits as well!! Seems like her pack of enabling free loading vultures where on it all the time as well, including her “rarely sober” sister!

[@mimitaylorswiftfan4084]

@@ddk567t She counter sued. So she kind of has to do the same.

[@mimitaylorswiftfan4084]

She also drank daily and did drugs with him- Funny they are pinning ALL of it on him. The whole "people who do drugs and drink are more likely to abuse" - could be said about her.

[@ashpolus2512]

1:05:50 Listen closely to the whispering. “I will lie in my testimony; is there anything I am not supposed to lie about?“ It could also be “I rely on her testimony; is there anything I am not supposed to rely on?” What do y’all think? Interesting that we can hear the whispering anyways, Elaine didn’t forget to turn of her microphone this time 💀

[@bwunn2three107]

Can’t even hear anything 😂 but hope they caught it or make it louder

[@janesialandown2776]

I heard it!

[@sandracolquhoun899]

I heard rely on her testimony

[@amandahill3222]

Pretty sad that the judge has to help Amber's lawyer how to ask the question without it getting objected

[@NaoFlt]

I can't believe that some ppl really thought Dr. Doofenshmirtz "singlehandedly won this case for AH.

[@cynjim88]

The psychiatrist is definitely getting paid by the hour a simple yes or no question he takes 15 minutes to “Mansplain”. Lol

[@Hotminutemanda]

I don't think I could have been apart of the jury even if I wanted to be because Wayne Dennison's cross examination on the psychiatrist was pretty funny in some instances and I would have busted out laughing and been asked to leave the courtroom.😅 Chef's kiss 🤌🏻 to Johnny Depp's lawyers.🙌🏼

[@CristinaApple88]

Same. Wondering how hard they tried to not chuckle. Lovely on his part

[@sandrashaya85]

Same here !!

[@daniellehaury]

Dr Moore is not considering if the fingertip was slightly hanging off the counter as he demonstrated at the beginning of his testimony. If the finger was slightly off the edge and struck from an angle it totally could've been cut in the manner described

[@daniellehaury]

Not to mention the shattering of the fingertip bones in my opinion if it were a side to side pinch motion as he described would be splayed A&P instead of laterally as Johnny Depp's x-ray showed.

[@rachelreneer56]

10s of thousands of patients in 30 yrs, he said. That means a new patient almost everyday for 30 years.

[@fridamaldonado8426]

Maybe the same dommy as a patient during this length of time.

[@chasehedges6775]

Hope Johnny is doing awesome ⚡️⚡️⚡️

[@citygirl2808]

Omg. Between the facial contortions, inability to answer a question and the sticky uppy hair, this dude has been the most entertaining part of the entire trial!

[@tamibryceland1475]

kzbin.infoUgkx6RdarN7dmbPCMq9pkou5iU-XUZ4ZvB9U

[@reneejohns]

Hes high. Spun. Adderall diaries....

[@marsoblivi0n945]

He’s a crackhead and quack of a DR. I counted 7 lies and or misinformation. Common things like the seraquel being a benzo. Seraquel sucks ass. It’s not a good buzz either. No ones abusing those things. Only to get to bed maybe.

[@denisegansermiller6300]

He’s definitely on the autism spectrum. His social skills are nonexistent. He also is egotistical as well, droned on and on about how impressive he supposedly is, which is a narcissistic trait. He acted overly sensitive and insulted when his specialty was questioned, which is also a narcissistic behavior.

[@christinajolly5504]

Mr. Depp is not causing his own demise for suing Amber, he has in actuality caused more people all over the world, to notice him, love and support him! And understand better who's the actual perpetrator here. Not him, but her. Period.

[@jenniferrains6170]

I agree. And it’s the opposite …Amber caused her own demise! By trying to ruin an innocent man.

[@jenniferrains6170]

So I’m absolutely agreeing with you just to clarify lol

[@stefaniafiamingo8834]

What Dr. Spiegel is doing is despicable. He's bending his expertise to what HE thinks (or wants or feels more comfortable with and used to) to be true. Science and medicine don't work at all as he claims. The amount of biases contained in his testimony is astonishing. And of course that makes it much more unethical since a lawyer doesn't have the time, while difending their client, to become a psyhiatrist (or an epidemiologist) right away. I am speechless

[@robynpelling3260]

He is absolutely ridiculous. Any reputable doctor like him would never jump to the assumption that cognitive delays are due to addiction. For him to come to this conclusion, Johnny would have to be clean and sober for a year or more and a full dsm5 assessment would need to be done to rule out autism, adhd, etc.

[@stefaniafiamingo8834]

@@robynpelling3260 amen

[@catwoolf11]

re: Dr. David R. Spiegel - a lesson on how to yammer on about yourself, sucking up as much air time as possible, while also leaving everyone listening utterly unclear about anything you yammered about. That guy should get an award for self promotion or something.

[@saimak7079]

Wow these lawyers have to be quick study's to be able to competently tackle the details of specialised professions, going up against very knowledgeable experts.

[@Noshow134]

He is wasting timeee

[@Noshow134]

On purpose

[@karsh297]

Those injured pictures god the pain he went thru😰😓😢🥺🥺🥺

[@hanswurst8380]

The arguments with Jason Momoa's success vs Amber Heard's not existent succes were great to hear.

[@mrotfort]

At one point he says something along the lines of "people get to their bad to sleep no matter how tired they are". He definitely wasn't tired enough. Tired enough people can fall asleep on rocks in a desert(I've seen it first hand) . Compare that to JD crashing on the floor with his head on a piece of furniture and you'll see how that can happen and even be pretty comfy until you wake up with neck pain

[@thestudbq]

Truth! I can attest to this statement. 10year Army vet and trust me I’ve slept in a many uncomfortable and unconventional places after being awake and on the go for almost 50hours.

[@titacast6528]

YOU GO CAMILLE!!!

[@erikawhite2146]

I believe that they are both guilty of abuse, perhaps on a different level. You have to love your spouse and have respect for them. Its just horrible the whole thing is1!

[@reemy2217]

I totally agree

[@blue_sky_bright_sun7599]

Watch the full trial and listen to the tapes. Not one person who’s ACTUALLY watched the trial, reviewed the evidence and listened to the tapes would think that “they’re both toxic” or “they’re both abusive”. That is for a reason. A lot of people were “pro Amber” when this all started. Review the evidence and you will see why everyone is on Johnny’s side, and I mean 100% on his side. He hasn’t been abusive to her in any way, form or shape. Unless you consider calling someone names after hours and hours of being bullied physically, emotionally and psychologically. This isn’t a case of “both were…”. Not at all. This is a case of an evil cruel person ruining an innocent’s, a good person’s life who has been nothing but generous and kind and loving towards them. I know it’s hard to believe. But the evidence proves it. I am myself astounded at how frickin evil this woman is. It just…baffles me.

[@marsoblivi0n945]

You’ve obviously have never dated a narcissistic person. No way to not be abusive. You won’t survive.

[@ezip331]

Did you base that analysis on the actual evidence in the case cause if you did your opinion would be 100% different

[@jonniekairyu]

I have not seen a single evidence of JD being abusive. Do I see a toxic relationship between the two? Yes, very much so. But in the end of the day, that is not what this is about. Do I think JD abused Amber? Then the answer would be a astounding no. Watching the whole trail so far it rather seems she was the abuser in this case.

[@Noshow134]

Today was so clever of Johnny’s team. All the witnesses were ready for Camille but not them . Another great move from Johnny’s team

[@justmekeekee]

Why are most of Ambers side 'witnesses/hired-professionals' so unlikable?

[@djm122270]

“Dr. Seagull” is an embarrassment to his so-called profession. He literally looked like he was swallowing a fish, whole. His testimony about the effects of meds was ridiculously contrary to the truth. He has no concept of reality when it comes to Seroquel. That potent drug puts a person out for hours. Who is he trying to fool? Because this knucklehead claims to be up for hours as a resident means somebody on that drug can’t fall asleep wherever they may lay? And how the hell does this have anything to do with domestic partner violence?! Unbelievably insane and narcissistic himself, with his disheveled hair and all. What a freaking madman! (BTW, I liked Mortdecai)

[@tararosemorrison5831]

Omg. The hair! Comb before court?! This one. Whoa.

[@djm122270]

@@tararosemorrison5831 I know, right?!

[@jessytoth8478]

Yes 🙌🏻 I took seroquel as a teen, it was the only thing that helped me sleep 🥴

[@JamieTheSassenachLass]

Don’t forget the contemptuous, smugness when looking at Johnny. And I THINK I seen the angry old fart make a childish face..also at Johnny when the lawyers approached the bench. He’s a confusing blazing moron! His hair, yes that’s part of the “professional“ look..he’s LACKING! How can we take him seriously, when he can’t be bothered to have any sort of hair grooming and looking professional? #moron

[@hippielove3100]

@@jessytoth8478 Did you buy it off the street ? Are you addicted? Lol. The man is crazy . I'm on it now to help me sleep . No side effects. Edit. Jessy , hope all is well with you 🤗

[@sophiemarcaurele]

Isn’t it interesting how these expert witnesses, who get paid thousands for their performances - I mean, testimonies, still don’t seem to understand basic courtroom etiquette and especially, what constitutes hearsay? And that you have to shut it immediately when objections are raised, and wait for the judge’s direction to proceed?? I have so many issues with the movie industry expert. First, she didn’t talk to Johnny, but she did with Amber so she can relay HER perception on how the bad press has affected her?? The cluster B master gaslighting manipulator, we’re still going to pretend that we can rely on whatever comes out of her mouth?? Amber, a role model?? As an opportunist? Nobody knew who she was before Aquaman. Comparing her acting abilities and status to Momoa? Please. She’s getting bad press because of the things SHE did: her behaviour and lies during the deposition videos, her 💩 the bed and manufacturing evidence, her own drugs and alcohol use, her sneaking men into Johnny’s penthouse whilst he was away. Why would L’Oréal want to be associated with a woman who doesn’t know makeup application 101, describing how you apply corrector ON TOP of concealer and foundation, and calling a correcting kit by its opposite, a theatre bruise kit?? Don’t underestimate the public’s intelligence by saying they’re just “Johnny fans” or bots if they’re finding her behaviours reprehensible, like we can’t form an educated opinion by watching the trial and reviewing the evidence. The recordings are especially damning for her, and SHE took many of these pictures. I’m not enraged and disgusted by her “because Johnny is suing her”, but because she’s already been caught in several lies and perjuries and especially, by the fact that by self-appointing the title of “public figure of DV” she’s USING the plight and suffering of women who have actually been victims of domestic violence to create a personality she doesn’t have. Shame on her, and her former pack of free-loading, perjuring, enabling vultures. 💰💰😒😤

[@jessicalemoine1213]

Wonderfully said!!!

[@elliemiller7537]

literally the only reason i knew who amber was before this was that one episode of criminal minds where she gets to make out with Matthew Gray Gubbler. i watched aquaman and literally didn’t even remember her💀💀💀

[@odetteboucher9635]

J'approuve entièrement le commentaire de Sophie Marc-Aurèle !!Bravo 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏

[@TheBrothergreen]

Why is someone allowed to testify in court that "some people who do X also do Y." That seems like the definition of prejudicial speculation to me.

[@deniseackermann7116]

I am amazed... it makes me wonder if we are hearing the same case... Johnny clearly stated and demonstrated that the tips of his fingers were over the edge of the "marble" bar.

[@expatleanie]

Let’s be honest how many of you watched aquaman for amber heard? …….……. How many watched it because of Jason… all women’shands go up .. I didnt watch Danish girl for her.. either or the rum dairies.. how many watched any of depps films because of depp? Hands go up..

[@kimsmalling5530]

Honestly I didn’t know who amber was in aquaman and didn’t care it was all Jason mamoa! I didn’t know who amber was until she testified and was SOOO overacting it was disgusting!

[@annedonnellan6876]

I have boycotted L'Oréal for two yearsbased on the evidence of reprehensible behaviour of ms Heard

[@jaybeaufort8198]

Awww, I bet they’re so upset that they don’t have your custom any more. How ever will they cope without you?

[@saimak7079]

I have boycotted blondes - the brunettes and the redheads will have to put up with me.

[@heymickeyjo]

They are a giant umbrella company with more than 30 brands under them, something to keep in mind

[@maggieedwards30]

@@jaybeaufort8198 it’s not just them 😂 literally hundreds probably thousands are boycotting them.

[@annedonnellan6876]

@@heymickeyjo sadly, in recent days i have discovered L'Oréal own different products. Indirectly, i may be purchasing products that do not specifically bear the loreal name. However, ah specifically endorsed hair products, which I now boycott. Because she's not worth it! For over thirty years i have practiced my form of ethical consumerism. I also made a point of requesting employees to pass on my feedback

[@ashleyplummer6402]

3 hours in & still on Amber's 2nd witness, no wonder they don't have much time left. The psychiatrist is just blubbering on & on. It's hard to pay attention

[@alliegrace591]

1:5:53 Turn the volume up as loud as you can preferably with ear buds. You hear him say he will lie in his testimony and then asks if there's anything he shouldn't lie about. Omg

[@ivyhill34]

That Dr. is a weirdo and he I'm glad the Judge acknowledged his aggressive and defensive behavior and basically told him to chill. JD's lawyer wore him down though. It's a good thing that his lawyer was patient. He was the perfect cross examiner for that weird scientist because I would have been walked away.