Thanks for watching our show! Josh Seiter is the ultimate troll. His full interview is here! kzbin.info/www/bejne/npyqm4d8d65nfc0
@morkvomork68157 күн бұрын
"Ultimate"? "Ultimate" would it have been, if somebody would believed him, that he is trans. Everybody knew after no time, that he is a false flag! But many thanx, for the link.
@ninja-mouse2 күн бұрын
your link send me to Dinesh D’Souza RUINED Indians for Ann Coulter!?
@pentagonlove1646Ай бұрын
I think there's truth to his statement. There are a lot of self-proclaimed trans women on TikTok who are doing what he’s doing, just like Dylan and his friend (I don’t remember his name), and the gym incident, along with the serial rapist who was put in a women’s jail. Yes, there are many people pretending to have gender dysphoria, but I am aware that there are also people who truly experience it. So, my take on this is that we need to find common ground recognizing that there are real gender dysphoric people and those who might be faking it for their own gain.
@isabelpark7650Ай бұрын
Great comment.
@amandawilkinsontarot7096Ай бұрын
Yep
@nbecker675Ай бұрын
Exactly, well said!
@jerrygregorАй бұрын
Of course there are real gender dysphoric people just as there are real sufferers of anorexia nervosa.
@ana_with_the_worldАй бұрын
Exactly! People like Alexis, Buck, Blaire, Marcus, and plenty more that I can’t currently think of, are not even in the same category as the transgender ideologues who need to be put in line. Like no, you’re not allowed to come into women’s spaces just because you put on a dress and paint your nails! You’ve gotta earn that privilege! The joke is on the woke people that will go along with anyone’s “identity” and their requests to be affirmed, no matter how ridiculous they’re being. The fact that people like us knew it was fake is exactly the point
@teresakeiser1848Ай бұрын
Don't apologize for being sassy. I come here for the sass ma'am. ❤
@wendystalians7718Ай бұрын
He is "trying " to stay relevant, he needs to know.....he never was. He is just desperate. It's completely disgusting. Alexis, you are such a sweet woman. You always show such grace towards all. It is beautiful, and so are you.
@bobbiejojackson9448Ай бұрын
I don't believe that he was conducting a social experiment. I'm convinced that the whole thing was a grift, for money and attention. He's got a history of doing off the wall crazy stuff for just that reason. I'm thinking maybe someone threatened to out him and that made him come up with this story in order to try and get out ahead of it, before anyone else had the opportunity.
@ladytempress3824Ай бұрын
It's the easy way for individuals like him to get out of it without facing any consequences, pushing their little egos like " look how smart I am..." pfffff. Reminds me of that AvocadoNicado whatever dude. Social psychology "experiments " are far more complex , including a design , control group , a thesis to proof etc. What he brought up has just been a rant on trans people in general, not facts. His behavior is so ridiculous & narcissistic. They hate consequences or responsibility for their actions.
@Alexis_blake00Ай бұрын
Thank you so much for this wonderful comment, it made me smile x
@jimmyhyun8546Ай бұрын
Yet he is relevant because everybody is talking about him.
@jovana_kocicАй бұрын
Exactly. Especially the observation of Alexis ❤
@carolynbrubaker1619Ай бұрын
Not a social experiment, just a way to get attention. A different version of Dylan Mulvaney. He proved nothing except that he will do ANYTHING to get followers. You, Blair, and Buck are the real deal. THe three of you promote the reality of what it is to be trans. THANK YOU!! Because of YOUR content I understand, or as much as someone like me can. All Josh did was annoy me. For the record I would have no problem sharing a dressing room with you or Blair. I wouldn't give you a second glance. If I saw Josh or someone who looked that way, I would turn around and walk out because I didn't feel safe.
@Caroline-t7vАй бұрын
But we shouldn't have to turn round and walk out. 😢
@IrememberhuggabunchesАй бұрын
@@Caroline-t7vI’m very curious, if such situations, of being rejected in female spaces, are hurtful and fearful what continues to draw individuals to them? If I’m looking at it through a trauma lens it’s similar to me to females with sexual abuse histories “luring” ( seemingly) a potential threat to them before blowing the alarm on the individual ( watched this play out hundreds of times over my years working in substance abuse facilities). There’s a part that feels very much like control in an attempt to master something, and it’s very likely that sense of control that females are picking up on, feel threatened by, and want out of their space. In recovery from trauma, being able to speak your needs is one of the critical elements of recovery, having women, real women, express their needs for safety is in alignment with that need for healing. If one ever thought they were a woman, it would be great to understand that. I think more 3rd spaces should be available because if we’re being honest, the percentage of people in need of them is very small, and trans people deserve to have a space where they are not at risk of attack, denigration etc so that they too, can have the peace to heal the wounds they might’ve endured in life around this.
@HanChap2Ай бұрын
@@carolynbrubaker1619 and Marcus. Love Marcus as well! He and Buck have done a few videos together
@SanguinaryBladeАй бұрын
Alexis doesn't deserve to be put in the same catagory as Blaire or Buck.
@carolynbrubaker1619Ай бұрын
@@Caroline-t7v I agree but until they figure that out I will turn around a walk out. Luckily, I haven't had to yet
@SanFranitaАй бұрын
I think they call that a “Shit Eating Grin”. So gross. As a straight bio woman: he is repulsive to me. Ick.
@joelreidy2585Ай бұрын
Ick…are you 12?
@dogsofgore770829 күн бұрын
@@joelreidy2585 no she's American, which is worse
@ashley-sh1wvАй бұрын
i can see why he got voted out of the bachelor so early, i wouldn’t want to date him
@Anshika1826-z8uАй бұрын
Lilly tino and dylan should end their drama too 😂😂
@ArcherOfProphecy6Ай бұрын
And let's put Jeffrey Marsh behind the jail...
@pain-killeryates5448Ай бұрын
@@ArcherOfProphecy6👏👏👏👏👏👏
@auouraschannel5230Ай бұрын
Josh repeated alot of stuff they said too
@megangambill2018Ай бұрын
100% agree
@Sweeden268Ай бұрын
@@ArcherOfProphecy6okay!
@VforVictory00Ай бұрын
As cringe as his performance was, it's sad that there are actual people who say they are trans that think and act in the same way that he was acting during his "experiment". His painting all trans women as such and his personal attack on Buck Angel's past as an adult entertainment performer was where he lost me. The biggest problem with society is that whenever a problem occurs, there's always an over correction.
@IrisRainbowHeartАй бұрын
Definitely I think extremism breeds extremism and so the more extremism we have on one side of the spectrum the more we're going to see on the other side. I support trans people but I don't support authoritarianism and I think the far left has become just as extreme as the far right over the last few years.
@bradmesser4807Ай бұрын
@@IrisRainbowHeart Yeah. Unfortunately each side is more or less tried to rein each other in and it's led to a wide variety of crazy folks.
@bradmesser4807Ай бұрын
Agreed. I would like to say though from my own transition (MtF), he's missing the point. All of the basic stuff he did doesn't really account for what we go through as "proper" transfemmes. 99% of the changes happen between the ears and everything else is just an aftereffect. Of course I would never expect him to go that far, but if he'd at least have proper substance, even if just through interviews with trans people, when he says he took everything "to the extreme", it would provide more substantive commentary.
@s.d774Ай бұрын
@@IrisRainbowHeartI agree with you, well said.
@annearly3200Ай бұрын
He was demonstrating that allowing a man to act without scrutiny or effort is problematic. If you believed him, you were naive; if you didn't, you were seen as hateful.
@marylacken4016Ай бұрын
From November 1. questioning self ID will cost you up to €10.000 in Germany. You don't need to transition, you don't need a diagnosis, you just go to the townhall and tell them you are a woman now. Then you are allowed to use women's spaces and nobody is allowed to question your gender. You can change your gender once a year, not more often. It's ridiculous!
@kathartzell4856Ай бұрын
Exactly!
@MsMaryPatriciaАй бұрын
There was no social experiment. This guy is desperate to be famous. He pulled this stunt to raise his profile. Nothing more. A "social experiment" is just a convenient excuse.
@annearly3200Ай бұрын
@MsMaryPatricia The same excuse convicted rapist used to be transferred to female prisons
@melonflowerr5042Ай бұрын
all he proved is that liberals were kind and supportive and conservatives were hateful and violent
@JackC125escАй бұрын
hi alexis, just in case you didn’t know Josh was actually dating a trans woman in 2023, Monica Beverly Hillz who competed on RuPauls Drag Race and came out as Transgender on the show. He also faked his OWN DEATH towards the end of their relationship which Monica says she believes was down to his own insecurity. i’m wondering if Josh’s experience wit a monica has shaped his transphobia and shows his odd obsession with the trans community, hoping to hear your thoughts
@JackC125escАй бұрын
with monica**
@LlamacointsАй бұрын
Curious information it makes you think really
@isabelpark7650Ай бұрын
There are many versions of Josh. He just needs to find out which one he wants to be.
@vavosaАй бұрын
OMGGGG!! I TOTALLY DID NOT MAKE THAT CONNECTION!! im freaked cos i remember when that was on the rpdr subreddit talking about monicas bf at the time but woah i totally forgot that guys name. Thats insane
@sosarah929Ай бұрын
Very interesting
@CatzAndCrowzАй бұрын
No we just need that Lily “I speak about bottom surgery in Disneyland” one to come out as a troll too. Then I can sleep at night lol.
@gabbyb7347Ай бұрын
I wish ALL of the autogynephilic straight men like him and Josh would be barred from transitioning and let this all be a homosexual transexual thing like in the good old Harry Benjamin days
@gabbyb7347Ай бұрын
Only HSTS should be able to transition
@VestaseNewtonАй бұрын
HS make up a majority of those who have the condition, but not all are HS. Just a bigger majority. Like how a significant amount of AGPs are not HS. Im pointing mainly to sexologist Ray Blanchard's papers
@gabbyb7347Ай бұрын
@@VestaseNewton i don't mind if there are 3 autogynephilic straight men suffering from disphoria. Transition should not be for them. Period.
@bobbiejojackson9448Ай бұрын
Unfortunately, Nick/Lily is not the type to ever out himself, because he's a sociopath. I think the only way he's going to be exposed, is for someone with ironclad proof to do the exposing. He's making too much money and getting too much attention to stop himself now.
@heleninglis9961Ай бұрын
I'm livid with the way they spoke about Buck!
@kitc6635Ай бұрын
same, I was gobsmacked
@trilbynhissАй бұрын
What did they say about Buck? I'm not risking my mental health by watching those two fools.
@HanChap2Ай бұрын
Oooh, I haven't watched the whole interview. If they're going after our Buck Angel, bad bad idea! Trans-pa is such an awesome trans man and he speaks the truth.
@mrs.elentz2336Ай бұрын
@@trilbynhissthey just TRASHED Buck as basically being a faker, how “she’s” not a man, never will be (something that Buck acknowledges- he’s biologically a woman). I had to shut it off. Total disrespect… not realizing that Buck is actually on their team!! Straight up bullying. They clearly did ZERO homework on Buck or his views, how he is on the front lines of PROTECTING children. I just love Buck, and he needs to be protected at all costs. The comments in the video I saw were all standing up for Buck… which was refreshing!!
@stanleyfox4201Ай бұрын
Buck has a heart of gold. They did themselves no favours by going after Buck.
@SolthesingerАй бұрын
When I first saw this "announcement" literally my first thought was "omg I can't wait til Alexis sees this" hahahahaha 🤣
@IndyghurlАй бұрын
The smirk is one of the telltale signs of narcissism. My ex did it and I can spot it a mile away now as my body automatically reacts to it
@johnwall1285Ай бұрын
As soon as the news broke that it was all a stunt, my first thought was 'I can't wait to hear Alexis' view on this' while I can understand his reason for doing it, he has gone about it in the wrong way and made things worse. Wrong thing done for the right reason is still the wrong thing. We need more trans women like yourself to speak up and show the truth and reality behind behind trans. You are the beacon of light and positivity this world so desperately needs. X
@meechie69OfficialАй бұрын
The ironic thing of this is if you watch Dylan Mulvaney’s videos, he basically copied everything he did. So is it safe to say that Dylan is not truly trans???
@ajtommoАй бұрын
I've not believed he is trans from day one
@Krinsta1Ай бұрын
That guy hates women so much.
@deefalador857Ай бұрын
I believe Dylan is a female impersonator rather than trans. I have never met a trans woman who behaved like Dylan they have always been more like Alexis, a beautiful respectful soul who I'm happy to welcome into the female community.
@Anypronouns76Ай бұрын
There are actually men that are doing this and coming into female spaces. He is exposing how easy it is to do this.
@shmoo42Ай бұрын
Where? Who? Most of us are not like this.
@emtaylor597Ай бұрын
But there are men just going into female spaces dressed as men. Look at how Donald Trump managed to rape E Jean Carroll. He went with her into a dressing room. She thought he was joking. He wasn't.
@mentalalchemysubliminalsАй бұрын
@@shmoo42Planet fitness for example. Just search up "men in womens spaces" you will get quite alot of results
@mentalalchemysubliminalsАй бұрын
@@shmoo42Also did you hear about the hostel in France? A man was in the female dormand when a female tourist complaied the hostel threathened to call the police on her for hate crime for complaining.
@zzzzzzz7268Ай бұрын
@@shmoo42 It does not matter, supporting that basicaly opens the door to girls and women having their lifes destroyed. Which is quite a efed up thing to defend just to impose on to other women that have to pretend that there is no difference between one and the other.
@cheekyminx8220Ай бұрын
Exactly alexis i dont think josh likes women full stop he is cringe
@IrisRainbowHeartАй бұрын
Also some of my favorite content creators right now are people in the lgbtq community who are calling out the absurdity of the extremist ideology and cringe that is sort of taken over the trans and queer communities in the last few years. I have so much respect for you and others who show the postitive and practical side of trans and queer people.
@Loug21Ай бұрын
To be fair, coming from a psychology background its been interesting to watch and read the comments, hes got a point about the lefts attitude to inclusivity, and what that looks like for women and genuine trans people
@rydbthatsmeАй бұрын
He needs to be de-platformed and sued for any money he got pretending. This is a legal issue.
@rachelfrances9441Ай бұрын
I would love to see Jeffrey Starr confront Dylan...
@bobbiejojackson9448Ай бұрын
Oh.... that would be epic! 😂😂😂
@KJeske8274Ай бұрын
I would pay money for that. Like an old school pay per view boxing match. LOL
@LC-lw4vyАй бұрын
That would be….. I don’t know I am actually a little afraid 😵💫
@HanChap2Ай бұрын
I had a deep dislike of Jeffrey star, but I have recently seen some videos where he talks absolute sense and I had to give him credit for what he was saying, why he was saying it and how he delivered what he wanted to say. So, I'm warming to him slightly. But yeah, Jeffrey V Dylan 😲😆 get them in the ring! 🔔🔔 I think Jeffrey would win on that one. He's very articulate when needed.
@megangambill2018Ай бұрын
OMG yes!
@Larisa1CristinaАй бұрын
As a woman, I was not entirely sure that he was faking it. I really didn't know what to think because every month we hear about someone new who suddenly claims to be a female. However, he does not want to wait for a sex change or, at the very least, to have his face feminized to resemble a woman, as you did with Alexis. No, they demand unrestricted access to all women's areas. It is really shocking how frequently we hear about males who still have a masculine appearance acting as though it is perfectly normal for them to have access to women's restrooms, and we have to pretend that, yes, it is normal. And if we don't pretend, we are labeled as transphobe. In addition, the woman's challenge to the "new normal" comes with consequences. Let's not forget about the current events surrounding the app for women in Australia. Or in Scotland with the grape in prison. So... Yeah... When I watched him, without knowing who he was, I kind of believed him since he did similar videos talking about a lot of the issues Mulvainy talked about, like "normalizing the buldge". Not to mention that person who explains everything in a Disney park?!!! Wth? At this point we have to recognize that a growing number of social media "stars" are emerging that ridicule both women and members of the trans community, ruining everything for everyone. Also, most women, in my opinion, have a strong sixth sense that allows them to discern whether someone is truly honest in their trans journey for example. And we respect it, just as trans people respect women, based on what I have seen so far. Because the majority of us, from both camps, are nice people. But with all of this "politically correct" approach, we women are beginning to feel confined. This is why, I didn't know what to belive. And for that reason, I think that this guy wanted to show case the most severe situations that are now occurring in the world, so that everyone would realize how ridiculous the situation is. And to demonstrate that we began to believe everything only because someone told us to, rather than what our reason told us. Of course, his acting was terrible. He always looked like he was in a SNL skit, trying not to burst out laughing. However, he said he is a woman, and I believed him despite my better judgment since everyone's path is unique, and who am I to argue otherwise? Loved to hear your opinion Alexis! See you next time. ❤❤😊
@LogwallsАй бұрын
As a trans woman that’s just insane and nasty of him all he did was hurt the trans community yeah there’s some over the top ppl in the community but that didn’t help anyone it just hurt our community I don’t agree with anything he did
@christialuella6594Ай бұрын
Barf with how proud his grin read! I must say if he did his posts on TT it might have been more believable
@Makoto03Ай бұрын
There's been so many Trans grifts lately and it's pretty sad. I think Dylan is still getting away with it though. There's also been a strange trend in recent weeks in the sex work circle. Where real women place objects in their pants to simulate bulges, then market themselves as Trans with an OF. Its like they see a market in catering to people into trans women and are grifting off that.
@TheBluntATPАй бұрын
I think that is so freaking funny
@JulianaAnderssonАй бұрын
He’s actually calling out the “Left’s ideology” on trans people… not actually trans people… which I think we can agree it’s the WOKE people who do believe what he says… there are two philosophies here trans people beliefs and WOKE beliefs… and what I hear is him calling out the WOKE ideological reactions to self identifying… so the political + personal… not just the personal trans experience..
@MrsGypsumFantasticАй бұрын
That isn’t a left/right issue, there’s are large movement of left wing feminists that are gender critical.
@jackevans3480Ай бұрын
No so called "woke" people believed him for a second, thankfully.
@JulianaAnderssonАй бұрын
@@MrsGypsumFantastic I’m not talking generalities. I merely pointed out the details of what Josh seiter actually says in the clips. If one is going to respond to what someone says they should understand what the person said, specifically respond to that. You responded to me by generalizing my specific statement. Which makes it not what I said. So you go for making a totally different point! I don’t argue with generalities.
@Picklepower2xАй бұрын
There are so many comparable videos that meant people questioned it. They were for quite a while afraid to say outright he was faking until it got really crazy. But it worked, because under the 'rules', during that 5 months he was a woman and entitled to everything a woman has. ALOT of people hailed him as stunning and brave. Two men talking? Yes about the behaviour of some other men.
@amandamckay3770Ай бұрын
I absolutely love you and Liam so much you bring humor and love into very serious topics that you clearly care so much about
@vickiturner-simpson5091Ай бұрын
Girl, you need to be spicy once in a while! Good for you! I would say that Josh Seiter definitely made me angry while he was conducting his "experiment." I felt like he was just another in a long line of men who wanted to call themselves trans without making any kind of effort at all. I'm terrible with names and was trying to call out a few "trans" women who still sport beards and body hair and seem to sincerely think that putting on makeup and nail polish and wearing dresses makes them women. Can't they be cross-dressers without calling themselves women? They certainly aren't helping the trans community acceptance. I'll try to look up names and edit this post when I find them. Thanks for continuing you make your videos and showing the sane side of the trans community!!
@leslieneill777329 күн бұрын
The issue in my opinion is that this would never had been a thing if it wasn't already taken to the extreme and everyone is forced to accept other people's delusion, present company excluded. I have no issue with those that are genuine in their quest for the life they choose, the problem is when people make their life choices my problem, I think what he did was fantastic for now bringing this issue to light and I agree it's time for real conversation, I love and follow Blair White and Buck Angel, because they are like yourself, coming from a place of common sense, and are not infringing on women's rights, this has gotten out of control because of governments allowing it to take place and just agree with the nonsensical bs. The crap we have to endure as women especially when it comes to our spaces being infiltrated to the point where we no longer have rights and feel unsafe, is crazy town, if you in your current form walked into a women's bathroom, I would not even question what your sex is as you pass as a woman, I find that genuine trans do as buck says, just want to assimilate and live their best life. I think you should be blaming people like Dylan Mulvaney for the ridiculousness of this movement, look how much fame and fortune that person has created by literally taking the piss out of women. Common sense is no longer common. Peace out ❤
@samantharutter7768Ай бұрын
If he said "I am doing this to highlight how it is to get into womens spaces" I would have had more respect
@SilviaVanThreepwoodАй бұрын
Huh? That's EXACTLY what he did, and said!
@G.D.G.Ай бұрын
That's literally the whole point.
@powdersplayground28 күн бұрын
I love how he thought he was pulling off the biggest game ever and no one ever believed him 😂😂 Josh did it for the hits bottom line. And maybe a massive bet with the mates.
@mentalalchemysubliminalsАй бұрын
Why is it ok for Dylan Mulvanry to do it, but not Josh?
@robcampion9917Ай бұрын
They are both very similar, both actors, both started as one sexual orientation and then changed it and then both decided to be trans.
@mentalalchemysubliminalsАй бұрын
@@robcampion9917yup. I do think DM is too deep in it right now, the millions and the fame. But maybe he will transition to gender fluid and then quietly go back to being a guy in the public eye.
@robcampion9917Ай бұрын
@@mentalalchemysubliminals If memory serves Dylan went from gay to NB to trans and their trans videos were the only ones that got them the fame they were searching for, but I do agree when the fame dries up they'll go back to NB or as you said gender fluid and then back to the gay actor that they started as.
@LlamacointsАй бұрын
Because people actually believe Dylan unlike Josh. Josh didn’t do a very good job of convincing the public, which is why I wouldn’t call his social experiment a success. He was very obviously a parody. Now if Dylan came out as not actually trans, just because of how many people believe him, that would be a success
@mentalalchemysubliminalsАй бұрын
@@LlamacointsJosh has literally copied every single "step" from Dylan, including "normalizing the bulge." Dylan happens to be a twink, so maybe people like him more?
@elvacoburg1279Ай бұрын
It was no "social experiment", he did it to get the publicity, dug him self in too deep, and is now calling it a "social experiment" as a way to get himself out. I would not mind his attempts at gaining "fame", except for the fact that it has brought hatred down on actual trans women, by re-representing trans people and making others think that all trans people are faking it.
@SilviaVanThreepwoodАй бұрын
It was. Don't be angry at HIM, he merely outed the hypocricy and danger of the tr ideology as it has become now...
@Sweeden268Ай бұрын
@@SilviaVanThreepwoodtotally agree 💯 When people are losing their jobs/careers and children are being taught this nonsense in schools , parents losing their children to the State, women’s sports being invaded by men and on and on. Yes, everything and anything that brings awareness to show the ridiculousness of it all is fair!
@G.D.G.Ай бұрын
It was a social experiment. It showed how stupid the trans community has gotten. Men with no gender dysphoria, no interest to look/act like women getting off to terrorizing women. Trans isn't an umbrella. You want to be the opposite gender. Thats it. None of this current woke shit.
@paulroberts9425Ай бұрын
Firstly - Alexis hair and make up is 🔥 looks great. Secondly - I first thought this was a social experiment on the extreme far left activists. When he came out with the bravado and god complex he just lost a lot of credibility. It was a really weird middle ground because he made some good points but then some quite bad points… would have been better if he could have seen it more middle ground. I don’t think this is really fair on the trans folks that just want to live their life…. I hope it doesn’t have a bad backlash for the trans friends…
@ladabingo7912Ай бұрын
I enjoyed the whole performance and Josh has got a lot of people talking about how trans politics are playing out in 2024, so I wouldn’t police him, and well tbf the whole stunt was an exercise into who has the right to do what and when! The best question I heard so far is that…if over last week he had the right to go into women’s bathrooms and this week not, what, if anything, has actually changed? He is saying nothing different to what I’ve heard a lot of Trans people say on the right of the debate, so I say good for him. We need as many people as possible questioning self ID and AGPs, the fallacy of the trans umbrella etc. I wonder if there is a little bit of how dare he as a “straight” man say these things, like we know straight men should just apologise these days and not have opinions, least of all talk together on TV about their opinions for fear of coming across as ‘smug’. I say this as a gay man, but I see a lot of smugness and entitlement in the rainbow family these days. I also disagree that there are not many AGPs…basically everyone who used to say they were a transvestite now says they are transgender. Nobody says they are transvestites these days, and conspicuously nobody says these days that their cross dressing is a sexual fetish when even 10 years ago this was just a given and an accepted part of the scene. I also get the point with Buck, but just prior to Josh’s interview Buck did a take down of Josh, referring to him as disgusting etc. and the clip of Buck shown in Josh’s interview is from this take down, so I guess if you’re gonna go for someone online so aggressively and as buck did then Buck should also expect some pushback. I also thought it a bit disingenuous for Buck to call out Josh for the revenue he would have made from his posts, when Buck will also be making a fair few dollars. Alexis, I usually support what you say but I fear here you’re crossing over into policing via your own prejudices. Josh has a right to speak from his point of view, and whether trans issues get worse I would say is mainly in the hands of trans people at the moment, and if there is any call to me from this it is for trans people to sort out their own house. If trans people don’t do that, then it should not be a surprise if other people do what they can to make the point. It used to be that Blair, Buck, yourself and others had distinct takes but as I have listened to each of you over the past 6 months it’s like hearing the emergency of a new orthodoxy, and then the policing of that orthodoxy… The person who has stayed refreshingly himself I would say is Marcus.
@julissavalencia175128 күн бұрын
The main problem is that he speaks in generalizations like “any trans person is a faker” He’s saying every trans person is faking being a bio woman when that just isn’t the case. Like Alexis said, a good portion of transgender people (who usually aren’t online) do know they will never biologically be the gender they are transitioning to, so to say all trans ppl are fakers is a lie and not a very good bias to have and hold so strongly when conducting any type of experiment. Rn I’m only at 10 min 28 sec so maybe he mentions this point later in the video or in the interview but he completely disregards this trans ppl that genuinely feel/have gender dysphoria. They do not feel comfortable in the body that they were born into and that’s an important part to think and talk about to. I agree that his supposed intention is a valuable thing to look into (self id) because there are a good amount of people that do self id with no intention to actually transition. It was just executed badly and proved nothing at all because everyone knew before the reveal anyways😂
@ladabingo791227 күн бұрын
Yes probably not the best phrasing by Josh but I took him to mean that no trans person literally becomes the opposite sex, which is true and which Alexis agrees with. The fact that it was clear Josh was grifting and making zero effort was for me the best part tbf, because it made the dangerous aspects of self ID in gender ideology the more apparent. It was obvious he was grifting, but he can do it anyway is a major trope in itself. Main thing for me, I’m hugely put off by this ‘we must protect Buck at all costs’ schtick. And that that means we must attack Josh. Buck can run his mouth and run people down, tbf he ran Josh down in a way that dehumanised him…he referred to Josh as disgusting in an attack that was very personal to Josh’s character. Also the follow up video with Alexis, Liam and Buck was very much attacking Josh in a way that made me uncomfortable, it became a bitch fest. It felt very much like watching a drama triangle play out between Buck, Alexis/Liam and Josh. All that whilst Alexis and Buck bull each other up. It just didn’t have any dignity for me. Upshot is I’m switching off. I feel like, OK trans ppl enough now.
@tomtom7734Ай бұрын
Dylan is next
@ravens-cryptАй бұрын
I’m sceptical of that since the money is coming in for DM
@ivy456Ай бұрын
Dylan might be in too deep now. Unlike Josh there are people who believe him. He also got to interview the president and got pretty good deals from it. Can you imagine the backlash of him coming out? No one fell for this guys act so he's now grifting for the right. Which seems to work better.
@VestaseNewtonАй бұрын
I hate how Josh was going after Buck Angel. Accusing him of pushing the narrative of transitioning minors when he advocates AGAINST that for years!!
@LlamacointsАй бұрын
I can’t see Dylan coming out with it. He’s in far too deep. The backlash he’d received would be crazy
@paulalord710Ай бұрын
Josh is a total transfob also all his so called research is total trash and he really is the biggest idiot on KZbin
@sosarah929Ай бұрын
Alexis, you are so right on so many levels here. I didn't watch the Bachelor or whatever he was on. And I only saw a couple of his cringe clips that I rolled my eyes at as stupid trend following and scrolled past. So I was intrigued watch your video. I cringe at him saying it was a "social experiment"...there was no control aspect, there were no guidelines, he absolutely provided another example of the worst of the community, but I have a hard time considering it an experiment of any worthwhile sort IMO, you and those like you have the experiences and knowledge to comment on the craziness that the extreme fringe actors that show up with full beards threatening violence if they can't use women's bathrooms. Not a biological male who appears to just like attention of any kind. He may tell us , and himself, it was an experiment but it was an "experiment" to see if he could continue to be in the social media spotlight by any means necessary. Unfortunately, he was successful. Wonder what his next "experiment" will be? 🙄. No matter what it is, I won't be watching.
@shannonharp-e9tАй бұрын
You don't claim to be a woman. You always state that you are a Trans-woman. I really respe t who you are and the honesty of your posts. Thank you.
@jennys209Ай бұрын
This whole ruse was in pretty bad faith, I'm very hesitant to call people grifters but I do think he's one of them. I think he saw how heated of a debate topic trans issues are right now, and decided to jump in to bring some attention to his name. If he actually wanted to discuss some of the nuance around policies regarding trans people, and had open discussions with both trans and non-trans people about this topic, that would be one thing, but this whole thing reads as self-serving, smug, and a bit rude.
@AshleySimpson1Ай бұрын
Absolutely! I hate this ass acting like he did some super necessary “social experiment” when he’s just another reality TV person desperately trying to stay relevant.
@flohawkins1Ай бұрын
This reeks of misogyny. Men thinking they k ow what's best for women and can speak out for women yet again. Anyone who claims to be offended on behalf of a group of people is just a liar
@valbonney2575Ай бұрын
Hi Alexis - I understand why this 'social experiment' (🙄) may upset you, and perhaps to some of the wider public it will reflect badly on people like yourself, but to those of us who follow you (and Buck, Marcus Dib, Blaire, etc) I don't think it will. What I see is two very different things - genuine transsexuals who just want to live their lives inconspicuously, as if they were of the opposite sex, while still fully accepting their actual biology; as opposed to the delusional fake transgender ideologists and TRAs, who have done so much damage to the trans community. In my opinion, they have done far, FAR more damage than Josh and his silly stunt will do. He is quite a sad person, really - he comes across as a self-aggrandising narcissist, but I think perhaps that masks his underlying unhappiness with himself, and his need to be 'seen' and famous, by whatever means necessary. Rather than letting it hurt you, though, I wonder if you could use it to your advantage? Maybe it could present an opportunity for you and others to call out those who are damaging trans people's acceptance in society (which they have fought so hard to achieve in the past), because unlike Josh they are not likely to go away any time soon. The literal 'men in dresses' (complete with beards and chest hair); the militant TRAs who declare that 'trans women are women' if they say they are, and demand entry into single-sex spaces and sports, etc; the people who advocate the transitioning of minors ... these all represent the dangerous and toxic direction that the LGBTQIA (etc) community has taken. Josh, regardless of the fact he wasn't taken seriously by many, has shone a spotlight on this and it could be useful to you and other genuine transsexuals to capitalise on that? I can't forgive him for the way he portrayed our lovely Buck, though! 😡 (You look particularly stunning today, by the way 😍)
@SouthernAuroraАй бұрын
@@valbonney2575 - Well said! 👏
@May_003Ай бұрын
im so happy i found your channel! i followed you everywhere else but i didn't know you had a yt. i love you, thank you for covering this mess ❤
@jgardner404Ай бұрын
Great to hear your take. As thoughtful and even handed as ever! Xx
@ashleymillian6984Ай бұрын
He has dated a trans woman who came out during RuPaul’s drag race and then ghosted her.
@heatherbarnes982929 күн бұрын
Can we all just stop and recognize how absolutely STUNNING Alexis looked in that July 2024 clip?! That top was so beautiful. Alexis you are beautiful on the outside and have an even more beautiful soul. ❤
@katherinesteele619820 күн бұрын
Absolutely I kept thinking it 😅❤
@deborahronander949928 күн бұрын
Alexis, you have nailed the female skill of not saying something with words; your face says it for you. You look amazing!
@katherinesteele619820 күн бұрын
Right, the whole video i kept thinking she is absolutely glowing and gorgeous
@Tara_staraАй бұрын
If it was a ‘social experiment’ I look forward to reading his peer-reviewed, published findings soon! Interested to know his methodology, what the raw data shows and what conclusions he’s drawn from wearing lipstick on TikTok. 😊
@Mommyofgirls-k1gАй бұрын
Thanks so much I clicked so fast 😂
@amandamckay3770Ай бұрын
Me too 🎉
@Alexis_blake00Ай бұрын
Hope you enjoyed it! Haha
@Mommyofgirls-k1gАй бұрын
@@Alexis_blake00 yes I did thank you
@ArtyAnticsАй бұрын
‘You’re so gracious to fly here’… and start your next grift… keep the sass, we’re here for it 💜
@sylasgirlАй бұрын
I also want to say Alexis, on your point that you don’t receive good medical care as a trans person. I’d argue you receive the same as anyone else. Will the NHS pay for your cosmetic procedures? No and nor should it. Transitioning is a choice. There are countless women and men who endure crushed self confidence for all manner of cosmetic reasons and don’t get free surgeries. But if anything went wrong with your surgeries, infection etc, you’d get treated perfectly well on the NHS. Same as everyone else. THATS what its there for. Regarding you fearing for the trans community - the major issue is self ID. This is when it all started to unravel. Your community wholeheartedly pushed for that, you shouted, screamed and demanded it. Now you have it and, shock horror, it’s backfiring and now your community are upset about the consequences of that. Josh isn’t on the wrong side of history, he shone a light on self ID being on the wrong side of history. I’m hoping we look back at this period has a big mistake never to be repeated.
@aprilapril2Ай бұрын
She agreed with you really
@LB-gz3keАй бұрын
Right? She didn't say that she doesn't receive good medical. She didn't complain that her procedures weren't covered by NHS. She just said it was alot to deal with and costly and doesn't happen magically.
@BillieB.Ай бұрын
@@aprilapril2 its just a projection thats why lmao. Josh didn't do anything that we already knew...why are people acting like he exposed "self ID" when we already know about self ID and transtrenders. He added nothing to the conversation. This person who commentired doesn't care about the facts acting as if ALL trans people wanted self ID...when the majority never stood for it. We always had people like Blare and over time Buck , and many more fight self ID and gender ideology. It wasn't pushed by the trans coummiuty it was pushed by politicians (on both sides) and trans "activists" for their own self gain. So of course real trans people couldn't do anything about it, they would have been canceled right alongside anyone else and people have bills to pay. Look how long it took Blare White to grow a decent audience if she was on the "right" side of the trans story she would be a lot further in her career, and that goes for all of the trans people who speak out against this. I won't even address the braindead medical comments, its comparing apples to oranges . Not to mention that its never ok to reinforce stereotypes about women, so yeah hes definitely in the wrong. Josh wanted to be a clown for a few months, make money, and then turn his back on the "trans" community. He's nothing more than a transtrender who used the current reputation of trans people as a back door for then we wanted to be accepted back into "normal" society without being permanently known as a "trans woman" unlike Dyaln who is no different then Josh but seems to be doubling down on his wrongs.
@NeloBladeOfRanni29 күн бұрын
Tbf the NHS dosent do half of the stuff it should be doing so I wouldn't blame alexis for thinking the NHS should have covered her procedures even tho I'm pretty sure that's not what she meant
@rubyscott1650Ай бұрын
I love hearing your perspectives. You do your best to be respectful and fair
@jericabenson85729 күн бұрын
We alllll for sure knew. Draining every last drop out of that 15minutes Omg “demonized”??? Calling him out for lying isn’t demonizing- a different D-word comes to mind… DELUSIONAL!!!!
@WalrusMittensАй бұрын
It's really a shame that it's only the most shocking and offensive of the "community" who dominate the headlines because it paints a very very bad picture for those with true gender dysphoria. I'll admit I used to have a bad taste in my mouth from people like Dylan, lily tino etc. I'm so glad I found your videos because you've taught me so much while at the same time being a fun and positive person!❤
@andeeanko7079Ай бұрын
Alexis, 30 minutes is not too long! Loved hearing you go deep, and this topic needs it. Sure, Josh pointed out some truth with his social experiment, but he is obviously coming from a very un-nuanced and hateful position. He is lumping in bonafide trans women with those who are not authentic, don't have gender dysphoria, etc. Love you, love Buck, Marcus, and Blaire - at the cutting edge of true transgender-ism.
@DanielHerrera-rl1vwАй бұрын
I don’t think he was faking it. I really do think that he is one of those people who gets off on dressing like a woman and saying they are trans - the Caitlyn Jenner types. I think that was his reason for doing it in the first place. I don't know why but that is my gut feeling. It just didn't work out for him. He is a creepy person!
@girlwithintheflameАй бұрын
We all knew Josh Sieter was nothing but a troll. His next publicity stunt will be a podcast, book, rehab, Oprah yada yada.
@416LondonАй бұрын
Always wonderful to hear your take on things Alexis. You bring a calmness and a clarity to some very hot button issues. Thank you.
@swinpurple8680Ай бұрын
Thank you for making the videos that you do, Alexis. You always present a balanced view and talk about difficult issues with honesty and grace. Your voice and opinions are very important in this social media shit show and cruel culture war. So glad I found your channel.
@sweigh72Ай бұрын
The great social experiment that nobody asked for or wanted .. WTH 🤦♀️ Alexis you be as sassy as you want I love it ❤
@pascalorianАй бұрын
its always the trans women that get bashed the most. its insane and honestly so sad. but one thing i wanna say is.. why are they obsessed with whats in our pants? josh seiter is just saying a bunch of words and he has no idea what he is yapping about it. and btw do people not understand that gender dysphoria is a medical condition? im a trans man and its just how i see it. i do see my gender dysphoria as a medical condition and i do think i was supposed to be a biological man just something in the womb went wrong. thats how i always explain it to people who dont understand it and usually most understand it?
@slytheringingerwitchАй бұрын
Annoyed that he and Alex (the interviewer) came for Buck...so cross about that.
@Alexis_blake00Ай бұрын
Was so uncalled for. Me and Liam gonna discuss this on next podcast. Even buck might be joining us! X
@mentalalchemysubliminalsАй бұрын
The show has already confirmed that Buck will be on the show on tuesday! So will be good to listen to the conversation. Btw Alex Stein isnt against trans people, he is close with Blaire White.
@kiraametrine650729 күн бұрын
Honestly, this is really disgusting. It's also telling that much of the discussion concerning the trans movement focuses almost exclusively on trans women, and ignores the existence of trans men. It's a highly misogynistic view of the community and while I have my own issues with the trans community as a trans woman myself, the vast majority of the problems that exist come from the fact that those who want to give us problems fail to understand that basic respect and decency costs them NOTHING. As the issue has become more and more prominent, these sorts of fakers have begun to rise in prominence and thus poison what we seek, which is simply to be left the hell alone and allowed to live our lives without fear of being ostracized for no reason. This guy talks about logic, but the problem is that his logic is faulty. In the end, we know that we can't magically change ourselves to biological women or vice versa. No one is trying to pretend that they can (at least, no one sane). The whole point is to be our true selves without harassment, and the right to self determination. It's taken me over a decade to get to where I can be mostly comfortable with my body now, and even then it's still not finished. His points also completely ignore the fact that there are medical reasons why someone cannot medically transition, and it's a very ablest viewpoint. I know someone who had to cease their transition because they ended up with a DVT blood clot, and as a result could no longer be on HRT. There are people with diabetes who cannot get the surgeries they desire because healing could be very difficult, if not life threatening. Thank you Alexis for your videos, you're definitely the real deal here.
@sailingayoyoАй бұрын
I wonder what the next stunt will be.
@Alexis_blake00Ай бұрын
I know right!
@marianhoblyn2552Ай бұрын
I think his "social experiment" had nothing to do with the trans community, he did it for clicks.
@CajunReaper9529 күн бұрын
While it’s shitty I have noticed a big jump in people who get in trouble for sick behavior have jumped to being apart of the lgbt community because the extreme majority will pull the lgbt card to defend someone who’s done some terrible things!
@kenzi.hАй бұрын
I’m a transwoman transitioned 9years ago from a man to a transwoman, doing transwoman things, thiking as a transwoman, looking as a transwoman, living as a transwoman, using all gender bathroom. I’m not a woman, I’m completely different from them. I’m not turned on looking as a woman because transwomen who really are and take hormones can understand that sexually we are below 0, estrogen stops the desire as well as agp if there’s any, and people need to understand that, we need to start talking about that more frequently so that the insane accusations against transwoman stop. Again, any fetish is stopped with female hormones taken by a biological males.. Now this guy clearly has a fetish and turned it into a pseudo social experiment.. it stinks the fetish 🫤
@Necrophyllis.Ай бұрын
I'm so sick of cis men making a mockery of trans woman and than claiming trans woman are dangerous when its CIS MEN who are pretending to be trans who are the problem.
@candaceseitz7689Ай бұрын
@@Necrophyllis.Biological not CIS
@candaceseitz7689Ай бұрын
@@Necrophyllis.CIS is a label
@Necrophyllis.Ай бұрын
@candaceseitz7689 that's what cis means. 🤡
@laurykristensen6239Ай бұрын
@@candaceseitz7689Agreed. Cis came into use as part of an agenda. It tries to create a binary where there is none. (sex is binary, womanhood is not)
@miniscenesgbАй бұрын
Agree with you totally as usual Alexis. I hate that he messed with Buck too, Buck is just awesome
@lesliefischer66809 күн бұрын
I think beside the medical aspect, I think proper supportive and realistic counselling is very important through all aspects of gender dysphoria / trans people’s journeys
@GHICooperАй бұрын
Cis gender (don’t like the term either, but feel it’s relevant to state prior to comment) woman and I feel that it was obvious that there are a small group of people who are claiming to be trans that just aren’t trans, and this group is loud and drowning out the voices of actual trans community. No one who actually feels like a woman in their heart and mind would treat their own gender (female) in this way, no matter what their gender prior. Most women have suffered at the ideals etc of men, and would not, could not, put other woman in a situation that makes the majority of woman uncomfortable. Even if a trans woman did act this way, a person who actually identifies as trans would stop and listen and learn and change as son as it was pointed out. They would NEVER seek out a situation where they would make cis women uncomfortable. I hope that small loud minority is drowned out by other voices. If and it’s a big IF Josh shined a light on those people than it has some value, but that is the only value. We have to hope that the non trans supporters are clever enough to see him for what he is.
@simongoodwin5253Ай бұрын
I am saddened for humans suffering from Gender dysphoria. Gender dysphoria has been around us since at least the Ancient Greek society. These bigots that confuse Gender dysphoria with Transvestitism need to do their homework. Stay strong Alexis. Transsexuals rarely come out, most are "outed". Your journey is brave and an education to us that are happy to understand. (You look great this evening BTW).
@z0zRAMCАй бұрын
If he’d approached the experiment with a tiny amount of maturity, he may have been able to make a point about self ID and the issues that pose (like pdf files or SA’ers being able to change their name/identity without any actual steps to transition and then not have their new identity on the SA register) and other issues. I feel sorry for Trans people because their stories are always marred by people like AGP or self ID’ers that are doing it for malicious reasons. The empty pots are making the most noise and that’s unfair on the trans community (and women).
@i.n.n.iАй бұрын
The only thing that really shocked me was the fact that he studied sociology. Even the laziest of the classmates I've had at uni wouldn't conduct an experiment that badly. Like you said, he could've made a point, but he never even tried. It's sad that he's having a platform to talk bs, but I hope it doesn't last long.
@eternalbookwyrm9481Ай бұрын
You just be yourself. I'm glad to see you living your life how you want. You are so happy and it is great to see an authentic trans woman experience and opinion.
@abelalvarado5987Ай бұрын
Everything he did/said/dressed up in and pushed is NO DIFFERENT than what Dylan and Alok “tans-activists” have done. And he’s the cringy/embarrassing one?
@melonflowerr5042Ай бұрын
it's about sincerity. dylan is trans josh did the entire thing as a social experiment
@BillieB.Ай бұрын
@@melonflowerr5042 Your very stupid if you think he actually did this as a "social experiment" . Dylan and Josh are the same, both are "normal" men pretending to be trans for clout. But Josh is smarter because he's using this as a way to save his reputation because he knows he was never serious, so its his way of being able to gain from pretending to be trans but having a backdoor when he's ready to be a "normal" man again but he keeps all the benefits, compared to Dylan who wants to keep pretending.
@melonflowerr5042Ай бұрын
@@BillieB. why would dylan take hormones, get irreversible expensive and painful facial feminization surgery, deal with constant hate and harassment, etc. why is it so hard to believe shes just a theatre kid and so kind of cringe lol its not this sinister thing let her be open your heart
@abelalvarado598729 күн бұрын
@@melonflowerr5042 the”alleged” surgeries Dylan had, were paid for, they were advertisements. That’s if Dylan even did them. And there’s many questions around if he really is taking hormones. Josh’s videos are a parody ofDylan’s, because Dylan’s video are so WHACK!!
@melonflowerr504229 күн бұрын
@@abelalvarado5987 bro look at her face its literally different wdym
@suzyrobinsАй бұрын
I'm not trans but after watching 5 mins I want to send you and other trans folks a huge hug ❤
@themikaylashow198729 күн бұрын
Thank you so much. What Josh was doing really affected me as I'm actually trans (52 months on hormones) . I've totally changed my life and I live as a woman 24/7
@salientparadise7831Ай бұрын
Also random but 😅 I’ve been trans since I was 12 didn’t start Testosterone until of age at around 19! I just socially cut my hair and dressed as a boy and went by Frank through my childhood. And it was obviously the right thing for me. Trans people weren’t talked about much when I was younger and I blended in because I was youthful and just looked like a little boy. However nowadays now that I’m on testosterone and I still haven’t changed my birth name permanently when I work it’s known to management and then sometimes people may find out if my dead name is on some documents that are public. SOOO I’ve experienced a lot of transphobia and have lost MOST JOBS due to the fact that I can’t handle the discrimination and hate towards me. And I don’t have any support or anywhere to discuss this. But I’m just terrified of life in general as a trans man. I’m just so so scared especially since I’m like 3 years on T and I’m so fresh. I’m just scared to keep going further in my transition I just have this fear in me that even if I transition and change my name people will still see through me and it’ll be a constant fight. And I just can’t keep handling the hate…idk 😭😭😭 it’s so hard being trans in this world and that’s just sad because I’ve almost lost my life due to the stress when I was 12…and it’s all recircling again with all this talk of trans people and also the trans killings! So 😭 I don’t know if anyone has any advice of how I can surpass this struggle and continue I’m just a very fragile person with my anxiety and depression so it’s just very stressful for me 😅
@joannasmith8991Ай бұрын
He has done irreversible damage❤❤
@SarahBurrows198929 күн бұрын
I love how he’s said “it’s an experiment” probs the best excuse! He went on Timcast and stumbled on talking about the right and left questions… if you’re doing an “experiment” wouldn’t you know about the topic? He wanted to be like Dylan and it’s dampened his career
@JadeLunavrАй бұрын
It's stunts like this that give us trans a bad light, Ive been transitioning for about two years now, and Im loved by most but still hated by other (i feel due to video's like this man made) ... its taking me longer to do the hair removal and the surgeries i need due to lack of proper insurances and monthly bills ... it drives me crazy
@robcampion9917Ай бұрын
Josh still looks like he's got some of the make-up on and doesn't sound like he changed his voice much. Also he could have done a bit more research for his social experiment. Josh was allegedly dating Monica Beverly Hillz, so he could have done this out of revenge for getting dumped by a trans person.
@ongoingawakening4257Ай бұрын
I think it was great. As social commentary goes, it was quite effective. It was hard to watch, but this takeover has all been hard to watch. I think the world is generally supportive of actual trans people, as we've seen with you and Blair. But to have men in our spaces who get their kicks by seeing women react to slinging penises around... It's like they get off from scaring us. I'm grateful to Josh for pulling such a silly ruse.
@shmoo42Ай бұрын
This isn't happening. Idk where you think it is, but it's not. Most trans women, 99% I'd argue are not like this.
@nicole-mq2dkАй бұрын
@@shmoo42 it is happening, not with transwomen but with dangerous men. Look into it
@sylasgirlАй бұрын
but it IS happening! That’s why we’re where we are. Sadly your own community have entirely redefined what being trans is and now it includes anyone who just says their the opposite sex. You did this to yourselves. You only have yourselves to blame for how bad it’s gotten.
@LlamacointsАй бұрын
I personally just don’t think Josh did a good job tbh. And he’s very smug about it , though everyone was pretty aware he was faking it . If he had actually convinced people he was real etc then it would of been successful
@ongoingawakening4257Ай бұрын
@@shmoo42 there's a term for it, autogynephilia or AGP. Sexual kicks off cross-dressing has been around forever. It's completely different from transgendered. I've known a couple men who like to get caught in women's clothing and getting a reaction out of it. They actually get their kicks from seeing themselves and women's clothing. It's not new. Maybe just new to you. Look it up
@dominiquebutel3755Ай бұрын
Why cant josh just go away, far far away.
@iceslick16Ай бұрын
I apperciate you so much, Alexis!!! I hate that many people are falling for this mess and I'm glad you're not buying it!! He's a trans grifter! 😂 I honestly think he's on the right-wing grifter train right now!! I wish everyone can see this!
@christinameredithlewall2815Ай бұрын
I’m so glad you decided to start sharing your opinions and journey here on KZbin. You always make me giggle and I love that both you and Liam lead with compassion. The sass is warranted when it occurs! I’m glad you jumped into your truth and became this magical version of yourself that we get to share in 🤘🏼 rock on sister
@C.ChurchАй бұрын
I'm a woman and wasn't impressed during the whole debacle. And I don't feel "protected" by this.I figured out a month ago he was doing this to amuse da boyz and make cash.
@leonienolan511Ай бұрын
He made so many valid points ,, he mimicked what is out there in social media 😊
@TekkatV2Ай бұрын
Absolutely nobody saw it coming
@leandrahonegger3914Ай бұрын
Me neither, such a genuine performance🤭
@Mokujinko18 күн бұрын
First off, just found your content and love your delivery. I am not trans myself, however I wanted to weigh in because have concerns about deferrence to a medical professional to abritrate who is and is not trans. There may be a case for doing it the 'right way' but adherence to the medical model has caused so much heartache for people with all kinds of conditions whose experiences and symptoms have been undermined, often with dire consequences.
@aisdffgАй бұрын
I love how you apologize for being sassy. So unnecessary but so perfectly you.
@johnnimbus8761Ай бұрын
you seem very fair and balanced in your response....and yes Buck has spoken for many years in support of trans people and their experiences....A genuine advocate but even he has been at the receiving end of some extreme trans commentators.
@jerrichurchАй бұрын
Why apologize for sass? Your truly living it and help us understand gender disphoria sorry if not spelled right.
@DontCareL0L12 күн бұрын
There is also not enough research done into gender in the psychological sense and gender dysphoria. There are so many cases where individuals have detransitioned because they realised that they were not actually experiencing gender dysphoria, but body dysmorphia. There are also many cases of there being underlying health issues CAUSING gender dysphoria, many of which can be fixed. I myself experienced gender dysphoria, and even identified as demi-girl for about a year. I felt very uncomfortable in my body, couldn't look myself in mirror because I felt my body was wrong, and did not feel that the word 'girl' was what best described me. I felt much more comfortable dressing and appearing more masculine, and liked it when people used they/them for me because it felt more 'right' than she/her. I also started developing strong feelings for women, and lost all attraction to men (I have always found women attractive, but not to the level I started experiencing.. I was attracted much much more to men previously). Now here's the explanation for why all this happened: I have a hormone dysfunction. My body has stopped producing oestrogen, and has started producing almost twice the amount of progesterone than what is normal in females. Meaning my body is physically *changing* to become a man. I started developing more body hair, my voice has changed drastically, and the hormones were impacting how attracted I was to women and men. My biological issues were severely messing with my brain. I now take oestrogen medication to balance out the levels of progesterone in my body (my body does not naturally produce this oestrogen anymore), which has resulted in me no longer experiencing gender dysphoria and my attraction to women has also drastically decreased, and I find men attractive again. Our biological makeup is so interesting and there needs to be more research into this, so that we can provide the right care required for individuals struggling with how they see their body and their identity, instead of telling them that they trans and should change themselves.
@taytayhickford561728 күн бұрын
18:00 I completely agree. I think that because he did the experiment even tho he has come out to say it was fake and was an expiriment the damage has already been done and he has already painted trans people in a bad light even tho the majority isn’t how he portrayed them to be
@katherinesteele619820 күн бұрын
Totally! he was actively mocking trans women by portraying the extreme end of the spectrum, and painting trans women with the worst brush, he seems so conceited. But I also think influencers like Lilly Tino who are using negative engagement are no better even though that is their actual lived experience as trans women
@daughteroftime8047Ай бұрын
I really appreciate your take on this. I agree that he was being ridiculous, but I also remember seeing him during his "experiment" and not being able to decide if it's real or not. I think that that does show just how ridiculous certain people have made the trans issue. I don't think that includes you or many other people that are genuinely trans though. It's the Jeffrey Marshes of the world that have done this honestly. However, I also don't think that his social experiment added anything to the conversation or anything of real value in general to the world. It was quite annoying how he smirked like he really did something special. If you want to point out the absurdity of some people that are abusing the trans issue I just think there are better ways to do it. (Side note, I don't know a straight man that could do what he did, so he's either a bit closeted or maybe just that narcissistic). Anyway, thank you for always having a reasonable, logical take on important issues and always approaching it with grace. You are a wonderful addition to women kind ❤
@UbeleiliАй бұрын
I only watched half, but.. Did anyone ever ask him: "Wasn't it lovely to experience how people accept you and let you be whoever you wanted to be without trying to dictate how you should be?"
@melaniemarino7219Ай бұрын
How many thinks he is actually gay and still in the closet that’s why everything he does is outrages on all sides ???
@spiderboyjoshАй бұрын
Unfortunately I do agree with the social experiment. Just as much as I have expressed gratitude for your content Alexis, I feel the experiment that Josh has done is also necessary because society is just telling us we have to fall in line with whatever someone is feeling on any given day. It's really hard for someone like me to understand what someone with gender dysphoria goes through and I'm trying to have an open mind, but I agree with Josh. Parts of the "trans" community, and I'm using that term loosely because it seems obvious that some people who come out as trans are not and are just doing so because they see a positive reaction for others, and they perhaps haven't had that before in their life. They don't feel they have a purpose or have friends. They don't fit in, and are just looking for something that gives them acceptance, but I shouldn't have to go along with it. So in my opinion we need both sides to come out against frauds of the community and say no to those people. I don't think you'll see much from the medical influences because why would they outline certain standards or conditions of what it means to be trans when all it is to the medical industry is another cash cow to put money in their bank. I think doctors should be ashamed because from my belief they are not helping people because they genuinely care, it's all so they can get more money, and when you have a trans person you basically have a client for life because being trans requires lifelong treatment. People are going to hate on me for saying this, but being trans doesn't make you part of the LGBQ community. You're trying to live heterosexuality from a physical appearance standpoint. It doesn't make sense for the gay community. That's also just my opinion. Again. I love your content and your personality. I appreciate your honesty and the information you provide is helpful, but there has to be boundaries and definitions and things that make sense for any of this to work in society. I feel like an outcast because of what I believe. As a gay man I don't align with what society is pushing, and anyone who is falling into this they/them needs deep professional help. I think the vast majority of us would benefit from therapy. I am a man. I identify as a human being. I love other human beings. I am him. A he. A his. I wear my anatomy proudly, and I am not okay with people trying to erase that.
@S.D._777_Ай бұрын
I was waiting for your take on this. ❤ I think it was a desperate act from a person looking for fame anyway he could come by it. It backfired, so now he has to spin it for the other side. It's working somewhat. The more extreme side is giving him that clout/fame. ETA a little bit of context. I thought Dylan was faking because they were so out there. Hiking heels??? I've not met a single woman who would hike in heels. That's asking for an injury. Don't know any who would hike in a mico mini, either. I've only seen full-grown women run from bugs like that in movies. It was so insulting, I thought no way is this real, but here we are and Dylan is still Dylan.