Which Doraemon Story of Seasons Game Should You Play?

[@yakumorisuke9403]

I'm so happy to hear about the QOL improvements - especially the friendship and prices. Everything was SO expensive in the first game, I couldn't decorate my farm at all because every penny went to the essentials, and I never finished the story because it took so long to make friends with everyone.

[@jazzyhk1809]

ever since the first game came out i've been praying for more games made in this art style. it's soooo beautiful and I love all the little details in the different buildings.

[@Jexxa.]

I played the first one but it was really tiring and slightly annoying to make progress because of how much grinding was needed. I certainly don't mind (and even kind of like) a bit of grind, it makes things feel more rewarding but the first game was on another level with it. The second one has been SO enjoyable, harvestella has distracted me from it but I'll definitely be going back to it at some point.

[@buttarain27]

Same here, I like some grind for a challenge but that game was overkill and it was hard to keep track of quests and what to do next, I often had a small notebook with me everytime I played. It did get tiring, so I never finished.

[@eggegg8181]

Which one are you enjoying more, Doraemon or Harvestella? I can’t decide which game to buy

[@Jexxa.]

@@eggegg8181 they're MUCH different games. There's a huge emphasis on combat in harvestella and it's much more a like to say rune factory. But personally I am enjoying harvestella much more. The story is really good and I like the combat. But it does start off slow, it takes like 13ish days in game to start picking up. But it's worth it!

[@whatthe9256]

@@eggegg8181 For farming and quality of life the doraemon and for an ARPG with farming thrn harvestella

[@Nidorom]

I absolutely adored the first game, but the second game is SO much better. I agree with what you said about the villagers and dialogue, everyone is just so adorable and likeable, and have real character development as you go through their events. The game isn't afraid to mention more adult themes like the loss of a loved one, and chronic illness but it does it in such a cosy way and makes everyone feel so much more real. I also love the feeling of living with a group of friends, and the fact that they can help you with chores is the best feature and it should be in every game going forward, it would be lovely to do it with your spouse in future games. This feels like the older story of seasons games, and it's so much better for it. P.S Josh, I didn't know you could buy stamina boosters from the clinic, I found out in your stream yesterday, so thankyou so much!

[@packers12to80]

Definitely recommend the 2nd one over the 1st. Grt video Josh!!

[@noevalverde7104]

How is called the second one?

[@svenbtb]

This looks cool! I only just started SoS Friends of Mineral Town remake and I'm super excited for Wonderful Life, but at some point I wanna check this one out, too! It looks pretty charming and fun, and like it offers an interestingly different flavor of game compared to the mainline SoS games.

[@ravengomez9777]

Literally here for the same reason lol

[@priscillayg]

this was very helpful! The first game is currently on sale and I considered getting it but after watching this I realized that I’ll probably enjoy playing the second one more.

[@scragar]

Not a fan of making it Noby when his name is Nobita Nobi. Such a weird change I wish they'd revert back to the real name.

[@Z0Z33KY]

Me either, in general I hate XSEED feels the need to hide any form of Japanese culture & ethnicity in their English translated games. Always changing it to a western name, personally I really appreciate and like to see new names. It gets tiring seeing Bob, John and Jane for the millionth time over. Some names I guess I could understand because perhaps it’d be too confusing to pronounce, but other names like Nobi like cmon- anyone can pronounce that. Same reason I’m salty with RF5 making Ryuka into Ryker. Like whyyyyy??? Or RF4 Kiru into Kiel (at least Kiel is a cool name) but the original Japanese names were perfectly fine as is. I don’t like the changes.

[@catkitte]

@@Z0Z33KY agree with you. I can tolerate Noby since it's still pronounced the same, but changing Shizuka to 'Sue' and Suneo to 'Sneech' (wtf??) is the biggest crime ever.

[@annalepper457]

The name change wasn't an Xseed decision. The characters were named in English when the cartoon was brought over in the 1970s. But yeah, still is dumb.

[@Kogami]

Agreed. I know it's their Disney XD dub names but Doraemon is WAY more popular in Asia than in the US so they really could've at least kept their Japanese names since its what their biggest audience (even on general non-US English speaking side) are more used to.

[@annalepper457]

@@Kogami other languages included in the cartridge do preserve the Japanese names. That's why I choose to play it in German

[@Jose0421]

Am totally loving the great kingdom and have played the demo and I have to honestly say it really appeals to me definitely going to get it over Harvestella. This game is what the first doreman should of been.

[@jeremychong8541]

I agree. This one is much better.

[@RunnyElephant44]

Doremon is such an underrated show and I hate that it flopped in the west because disney put it on disney xd. I love the show and now watched all of it and love the show and love that the games are in the west

[@Nahan_Boker94]

One thing, is furnitures in home is better? Like we can actually sit and eat kn table, read books, studying in the nobi desk? Since the 1st game furniture serve as decorations mostly and no purposes. Edit: Nvm my previous comment, the game felt like different yet faimilar game. The story is different and not a sequel of the last game. The villages totally different, the farm is larger than 1st game. But so far I missed we can modify our house. The newer game we can upgrade them but not totally changing anything inside it. But those QOL, we are now live together in one roof with Doraemon gangs, still yet how to get companions for helping me mining/fishing,etc. I dont have other people to play coop locally with me sadly..

[@75gmag]

I have both games. I loved the first one, but as you said, it was very grindey. I bought the second one right when it came out on Switch and I love it!!! The quality of life changes are a major upgrade!!! It makes it more enjoyable!!!

[@mylady_]

does the two game have a same storyline?? i wanna buy both but im scared if it will wasted my money cause im broke

[@francisrolland547]

As a French speaker, there is a huge down is that there is no french version anymore. The first game has a very nice french translation

[@heiako5934]

aw that really sucks :O

[@dijahmedi4882]

Still enjoying the first one, but I will be picking this up shortly. Currently debating if I should get the physical copy from play Asia, or from the eshop. Either way, I’ll be getting it. Your live play through have been great to watch as well Josh!

[@fastica]

You can make a ton lot of money by selling bread in the first game.

[@ptscan2]

I’m loving it! It’s so relaxing and engaging!

[@lexbeltran1354]

The 1st Doraemon game is on sale on the switch eshop for $14.99. Definitely buying it, it's a steal. I'll wait for a sale for the second Doraemon game. Started playing the demo for the 2nd game, really fun.

[@shonshon3523]

Are you enjoying the first game?

[@lexbeltran1354]

@@shonshon3523 Yes, I like it a lot.

[@ErgoDog]

You have the cutest accent/dialect

[@buttarain27]

Can't wait to get Pip! He's such a cute robot! And I agree, when I first saw Ori, I was like "aawwwww" everytime he was on screen. Definitely like the second one better. In the first one, everything was so expensive and yes extremely grindy, lost interest after awhile. I can tolerate SOME grind, but all in all, I play games for relaxation only. Life is enough of a grind...lol.

[@jeremychong8541]

This game is amazingly good. I enjoyed the first one but the second one is just so much better that I will never go back to the first. It's less grindy, I feel like I am making progress, the characters and world is more fun and interesting too. The QOL improvements is just too good. It's not my favorite farming game. Not too complicated and not too simple too. Just perfect!

[@pandalionful]

Thanks Josh, the first game was cute but too grindy for me so I think this one will be perfect for me! I also had a weird issue with running properly in the first game but I’m not sure if it was a stick drift issue did anybody else ever have that? Thanks for showing us all the QOL improvements you have made me want to get this one :D

[@ririrue93]

I also had the running issue. It was annoying and actually made the game unplayable for me so I only played a short bit before selling it. I was on the switch.

[@PocoSan-gv7hw]

Me too

[@themaxtails]

Thank you sooo much for this. I already heard that the second game had a lot of improvements, but the info in this video is very precise and makes me confident I will enjoy it. I loved the story, visuals and feel of the first one, but the grindy nature made me stop playing because I felt like my time was wasted. I was looking into Pioneers of Olive Town as well but I think it looks a bit generic compared to the Doraemon titles.

[@millecrepes47]

what a great review and help me decide which one I have to play. Also english is not my first language but I can hear clearly in this video even without subtitle, thx

[@InternetReviewerGuy]

Friends of the Great Kingdom has taken the spot of my second favorite game ever, and I have played a lot of games.

[@sullyg9342]

What's the first ? :')

[@InternetReviewerGuy]

@@sullyg9342 Afrika on PlayStation 3

[@bethanykelsch1367]

i loved the first one although it was tough to grind. once you actually beat the game it feels so rewarding because its actually difficult and time consuming haha! i love the new one and how easy it is to befriend everyone, and i love the new fruit trees! i find in the new game that it is more difficult to forage than in the previous game

[@floyddominique3731]

@josh Please make video guide for the latest one. I cant find any, anywhere 😭 Mostly need best crops/season and some tips&trick ☺️ Thankyou, love you videos as always

[@dropofjupiter7421]

Played and platinum both game. Great SoS game 👍

[@grandheroking]

yes, i was wondering about this!! i'm totally gonna get it now, thank you ❣

[@primohikari8087]

Nice upgrade from the first one.

[@Yano83]

i just bought first game, and THEN i saw this video.... but im not mad, first i bought it for about 10$ and new one is full price. second - i loved harvest moon on psx, and it seems that the first game is much more like harvest moon (grindy and slow) , i thing ill have fun :D

[@sammythehamster9093]

First one was grindfest I find progress slow down in Winter of first year. I did unlock the harvest sprites. I'm currently trying out the demo of second game it feels lots better. I was hoping for physical version but currently e-shop only.

[@jeremychong8541]

Yes the second is so much better.

[@KonDragon008]

Ori is a precious cinnamon roll who must be protected at all costs. I'm loving the second game, though I haven't figure out how to split a stack of items (if it's even possible).

[@alanze18]

I really like this game a lot more than the first one.

[@smaao]

Thanks for this, I've added this game to my wishlist on steam

[@Shay331]

I didn’t know Friends of the Great Kingdom existed. I bought story of seasons because it was on sale for 15 dollars in the nintendo E-shop. I really want Great kingdom 😭.

[@Flipah]

Thank you for an amazing and informative video! ❤

[@RealmsofPixelation]

I'm several hours into the game and absolutely love it. I loved the first one as well.

[@karaaurora5112]

The map is so confusing. I wish there was a interactive map and although it says in the controls section I can zoom in on the map, I can't which is odd

[@mcp3187]

Spent a lot of time on the first one, still haven't complete the game. Don't want to left a game unfinished. On the other hand, i don't want to grind anymore.

[@wajeehattallah8903]

Im planning to buy the second came Two things i wanna know.. when exactly should i go to bed and when to nap and for how long in the second game?? Thanks…

[@annalepper457]

I played the first game for 100+ hours and I agree with everything you said Josh

[@SpicyMatti]

the first game annoyed the heck out of me, supergrindy, and most of items locked behind friendship and random f'ing times you have to be at random locations to progress "chapters"... thank god they changed that in the second game.

[@ngockhanhlinhpham7866]

Hi, I'm really appreciate your video, may I ask if the DLCs of Doraemon Story of Seasons: Friends of the Great Kingdom worth to get?

[@777residentevil]

I love how you say “Doraemon” in French accent

[@NoeliaEncarnacion]

I'm really enjoying the second game and it's the first time playing Doraemon but one thing I can't figure out is how to invite friends to help on the farm I thought maybe I need to build their friendship but they are already at 3-4 hearts so no clue if anyone know how to have them help let me know

[@JoshGamingGarden]

You need to build the first house upgrade to unlock that feature!

[@NoeliaEncarnacion]

@@JoshGamingGarden aaahhhhh ok thanks so much haven’t unlocked the first house yet thanks so much

[@estrioleyin5667]

@@JoshGamingGarden i think first house upgrade is the top priority to do... it unlock kitchen... unlock "friend help"... unlock fish/bug cage (so we can feed expensive low star fish to raise the star)... unlock lots of event including one that give horse... if possible do house upgrade at Day 4 (as soon as it available). so it will be finished at Day 8...

[@thejonbrownshow8470]

Feel like a professor Layton x story of seasons crossover could work fairly well

[@josie_the_valkyrie]

I already loved the first one. That they improved on it is absolutely brilliant! Best modern Story of Seasons, do you think?

[@eatmoreporkporky4342]

Definitely best modern SOS so far, despite the lack of romance. It's put together so well and with the beautiful graphics and QOL changes it's really good.

[@dabadidabadax5]

@@eatmoreporkporky4342 the next story of seasons main games should definetely take inspiration from this spin off in many aspects, like graphics

[@karaaurora5112]

How do you do the coop mode? Is it the 2 player option? Because when I try that it wants me to play with someone so I don't really understand how to do it solo 😭

[@smaao]

I like grindy games but the cluckiness of the first game is too much. I would like the second game to just add a difficult mode

[@aishatrbl]

thank u so much!! was really debating whether to get 1 or 2 cause i've not got a lot in my budget for games but ur video helped me decide and i think the higher price tag on the second one is totally justifiable with all the improvements made

[@anionleader]

Oh my gosh it looks like it took a lot of quality of life improvements from Stardew into it!

[@XD-rd8zd]

nice vid ^^

[@vinniakp665]

Why not both? 👌

[@mira-uf1ie]

The latter of course. Btw, the SoS reddit community has been badmouthing you. They said your Doraemon SoS FoGK review can't be trusted because you either lie or omitted some details.

[@Crobat-queen]

I just saw that comment over there, and I was like, what the heck?! Why are people so cynical and suspicious :(

[@mira-uf1ie]

@@Crobat-queen Right? It made me so angry that they have extremely negative perception towards this game, but warmly embraces Harvestella instead. And I don't know why they have something against Josh. At least he had tried to play the game. Unlike them who dismiss it because it lacks customization, no marriage, child(ish) characters blablabla (without even trying out the demo).

[@Crobat-queen]

@@mira-uf1ie I agree. I played the harvestella demo but hated that it forced me to go back home at night and the time mechanic was extremely stressful. And they totally dismiss the doraemon games because they "can't stand to play as a little boy! No romance waah" which is fine if you don't want to play it for those reasons but Josh is positive and cheerful but also honest, why badmouth him???

[@mira-uf1ie]

@@Crobat-queen They fixed that via day 1 patch. It would have been nice if they could fixed the demo too, but oh well. The reddit community is weird. The SoS discriminate Doraemon SoS because of the reasons mentioned before, and so dislike anyone whobsay good things about it (which includes Josh). On the other hand, you can't say bad things about Harvestella at all. The reddit community is very hostile to those who think so.

[@Keishabarnett69]

Does anyone know if you can sell the animals? I don't think you could in the first one.

[@estrioleyin5667]

i think we cannot sell animals... but to free the slot... we can talk to mary (animal seller) and ask to part away with animals...

[@archiesantos5219]

VERY YES TO IT.

[@widaygames9329]

A lot of people complain now about stuff being hard to get and games being tedious because they dont want to use their brains. 1st Doraemon was amazing… i got everything except on achievement cus i had to replay a chapter and make other decision. Farm decorated all gotten. It felt good… 2nd Doraemon is way way too easy and everything way too cheap plus too many cutscenes that is annoying. Year 1 day 18 i have house upgrade, bee and horse stable plus horse cow, alpaca, sheep and chickens. 3 cookware and upgraded my water can to silver and pick to copper and fishing rod. No effort at all. I fish next to my house all day make thousands easy. And thats without playing multiplayer.

[@lo974]

Sadly, the second have no French localization , only the first have.

[@thejonbrownshow8470]

From what I looked up on the series'wiki, apparently Doraemon is basically the Japanese equivalent of the fairy odd parents premise wise😅? Just intriguing as I am going with second game and got through the main tutorial, and I'm just intrigued by the series as it's like the kids got upset with their parents and got taken to another universe, yet none of them seem homesick and landed in a pretty chill story of season-esque farm town😅

[@lockongaming]

great kingdom is great game

[@archiesantos5219]

HELLO THERE? WHERE'S FOR ME?

[@denardanderson2946]

I did want to know the base answers to what you were saying but I do wish you would give less detail on what happens in the game, while they may not seem like spoilers, they are still spoilers because these are things I would prefer to find out by experiencing them but thanks for answering the frequently asked questions,. Just try not to go so into detail maybe, the next time you do this