RANKING Every RECENT Cozy Game on Nintendo Switch I've Played!!

Celebrate Halloween with #TokyoTreat use code TREATS23 and get additional bonus items in your first box. Check their promotion here team.tokyotrea...
Use my code "NINTENTALK" to get $5 off for your first TokyoTreat (team.tokyotrea...) and Sakuraco (team.sakura.co...)
LinkTree: linktr.ee/Nint...
Carlene's etsy: www.etsy.com/s...
10% Off your entire Gamersupps order!! USE CODE: NINTENTALK
gamersupps.gg
_______________________________________
Become A Member: www.youtube.co....
NintenTalk Discord: / discord
________________________________________
SEND ME STUFF!
Patrick McNamara
30 S Washington St. PO Box 532
North Attleboro, MA 02760
YOU MATTER. You aren't less of a person because you have panic attacks, anxiety, depression, or because you've experienced trauma. You are worthy of love.
988 - Suicide Hotline |
888-662-4357 - Addiction Hotline |
800-931-2237 - Eating Disorder Hotline |
800-656-4673 - National Assault Hotline |
800-222-1222 - Poison Control Hotline |
800-799-7233 - National Domestic Violence Hotline |
877-565-8860 - Transgender Suicide Hotline |
secret message: if you see this put a corn emote in the chat ;)
#NintendoSwitch #NintenTalk

[@NintenTalk]

🎃Celebrate Halloween with #TokyoTreat use code TREATS23 and get additional bonus items in your first box. Check their promotion here team.tokyotreat.com/treats23🎃 🎃Use my code "NINTENTALK" to get $5 off for your first TokyoTreat >> (team.tokyotreat.com/NintenTalk) and Sakuraco >> (team.sakura.co/NintenTalk) 🎃

[@offroad5798]

Wish we saw an actual tier list picture in the video

[@jess2109]

Love videos like this! Very enjoyable content. Personally, I've been playing and loving Sprout Valley and I also want to try Fae Farm but a bit nervous since people seem to either love it or hate it.

[@nikitasaville5422]

I don't know why but I really liked the older Rune factorys, cause the characters seem to have so much depth, the scenes were funny, odd, quirky, actually made me laugh and blush from random hugs and the affection as you begin to date someone. It just felt very off in Rune factory 5, I couldnt wait for it but once I got into it I found the colours and graphics a but too exaggerated, I didnt like any of the male characters (I'm female), and didn't actually want to date anybody or even finish the game personally. While with Rune factory 3, the characters seemed so cute, I wanted to date Pia and Raven even though I'm not gay! I loved that you could throw things at them and I loved that story line where you were part monster. I felt like the newer rune factories really lacked depth in the same way.

[@exonzigma]

D 0:50 Agriculture C 2:03 Paleo Pines C+ 4:20 Rune Factory 3 Special C+ 5:50 Story of Season A Wonderful Life B 7:50 Sprout Valley B+ 9:48 Harvest Moon Wind of Anthos A 11:53 Potion Permit A 13:46 Fae Farm

[@litneyloxan]

Love Fae Farm but it feels SO DEAD. All the characters feel so bland and boring to me, they say the same things every time you talk to them, seasonal events don't affect anything. It's definitely fun but it feels like it's lacking a lot of soul, to me anyways. I'm spoiled on Rune factory 4 special

[@UrsulaPowers]

I luv Fae Farm but don’t consider it to be cozy because the days go by too fast. It stresses me out.

[@alejandrososa3168]

Reminds me of Stardew Valley

[@RobinL4715]

Waiting for Palia to come to switch next. I agree on Fae Farm- enjoying it, but shouldn’t have been priced close to Zelda games- definitely too expensive for what you get.

[@Zodia195]

Yeah I think this is why I am skipping Fae Farm because of the price and also, romance is a major reason for me to get a game like this and if it's lacking I won't get it. Like I plan on getting Sun Haven, because it's cheaper and big on the romance and still has the fantasy stuff.

[@Kampfrattex3]

Rune factory 4 special is the game for you all, I promise.

[@litneyloxan]

I've been stuck on the same part for over a year though I love it so much, im stuck still trying to bring Venti back for good 😂

[@glowinghail]

Thank you for these honest and thorough reviews! I think this should definitely be a regular thing!

[@ziagamer4005]

I’ve played Potion Permit and I totally agree. After you complete the story, there’s nothing much to do. Loving Fae Farm. Wish the day was longer, especially when you’re decorating.

[@litneyloxan]

I finished Fae Farm and now have nothing to do 😢

[@twixbar90]

My time at sandrock

[@DJ32521]

Faefarm has taken over my life.

[@Switchgal]

I can’t wait to get that on steam if I ever buy one lol

[@catbutterfly34]

You seem like a animal crossing girl 😅😅

[@acedemi5229]

Yes, someone else who loves Potion Permit! I can't wait for the updates this game is getting, as I agree you do sort of hit a wall where there's nothing left to do, really. Not that I mind games with a definative ending, but I'd love to have more with this one because it's so fun!

[@littlebirdblue]

I'm so glad you brought up Potion Permit! I think it's such an underrated game. The story, the characters, the world, the music, the minigames. It's one of my favorite cozy games to play!

[@jorgesolorzano1995]

Agree 100% with Fae Farm, it’s an A potentially an S depending on what they will add later. They have also said they will do QoL update aside from DLC, that will be interesting. I already have over 90 hours on it 😂 the decorating is so addictive and love the animals.

[@courtneytatefigueroa1172]

AWL is definitely the game to play after you played an intense game where your stress got high cause AWL takes it all away by the calmness of it... I did sleep most through chapter 6 because I was ready for the ending! 😂 but yeah can't recommend AWL to someone who likes tons of stuff to do! But definitely recommend for the nostalgia of the OG 😏

[@NintenTalk]

Highly agree! You nailed it 😂😂

[@Emma-be7tv]

Would love to watch you play Moonstone Island, if that's a game you're interested in! Love these recap videos, helps me decide which games to buy!

[@BubblyAlexandra]

Is it on switch ?

[@Emma-be7tv]

@@BubblyAlexandra I think it's PC only right now but they're working on bringing it to the switch!

[@packers12to80]

Fae farm on switch with 2 future dlc and how good it looks/runs its well worth the 60 bucks. Its the top tier game in its genre imo. Def worth the price.

[@cryssyplays9517]

I've been playing Paleo pines and I absolutely love it, I am a dinosaur nerd though

[@Concerned_Owl]

Patrick, love your vids :) it would be nice if you put time stamps with each game title in your videos! 🌽

[@Sillysillywithpearls]

Potion Permit is one of my favorite games❤ loved the story, characters, play dynamic. Definitely a 20 hour or so game but such a gem!

[@TeamRocket2012]

Thank you for mentioning the upcoming updates for Potion Permit as I actually did not know about it so I have something from Potion Permit to look forward to!

[@AmandaCef_Art]

Curious where Wylde Flowers would fall on this list.

[@BubblyAlexandra]

My fav game I’ve played so far

[@jamies3205]

Omg i love Wylde Flowers so much!

[@missblisspresents]

Lovvvvvve wylde flowers ❤❤❤

[@litneyloxan]

Soooo good I hope they continue updating it and add more story!

[@mintendogaming]

Great video! I feel the same about most of the games that I’ve also played!!! I also think Potion Permit is great and i didn’t know about the update!!!! 😊

[@ChrisGagner]

Have you played Wylde Flowers? My favorite cozy game that's not Stardew Valley.

[@bunnyaway]

I loved Fae Farm for the multiplayer & the decorating, but you are right about the romance falling flat

[@mminto]

If you had to pick the best harvest moon game for switch, what would you say?

[@kuchikizack2718]

Why there is no 'my time at portia' in this list tho? That game was really good too

[@PurplePh0enix]

Loved this video! Please do one every month as I really enjoy hearing you talk about all these games. The first game you showed reminded me of Farm Frenzy back in the day, but more pixelated and with less mechanics it looks like. Farm Frenzy was a PC game that had you do quests such as "obtain wheat," "make a pizza," and so on and so forth. Essentially you would keep upgrading certain machines and gaining different ingredients from your animals. Some levels had timers and others were open ended (as a kid, I loved the open ended levels and would spawn as many chickens as humanly possible until they started dying lol). Also, what is that pink Wii game you have back there? It looks kinda like a Barbie game, but I could be wrong.

[@NintenTalk]

Haha it’s a Kirby collection for the Wii 🧡🧡

[@KeysFan13]

Besides the nostalgia, the visuals and characters in Story of Seasons keep me playing it. The cutscenes are detailed and frequent. I feel like I'm really building relationships. Harvest Moon falls flat on the visuals and relationship/character aspects for me.

[@josie_the_valkyrie]

I’ve quite enjoyed Fae Farm, but my gaming time is now taken up by HM Winds of Anthos (love it). IMO Fae Farm is way overpriced.

[@abbie321]

Great video 😊 Not played any of these games myself. I think Fae Farm tempts me the most. But I am so tempted to get Mineko’s Night Market for the Switch. Do you have any initial thoughts on this game Pat? Thanks

[@NintenTalk]

Haven’t played that one yet! I’ve heard some good things tho 👀

[@VittoriaVetra88]

Load screens are quite long in Mineko's Night Market on the Switch at the moment as far as I heared.

[@abbie321]

@@VittoriaVetra88 thanks, that could be a bit tedious. I’ve not brought a new Switch game for months so I hope if I get it it’s worth it (though at £15.99 it’s quire reasonable)

[@VittoriaVetra88]

@@abbie321 the devs are aware and looking into the issue, but might be slightly tedious to play right now.

[@litneyloxan]

I beat the game on Switch and it wasn't game breaking for me at all. Some wait screens are a tad too frequent but nothing that made me unable to finish the game in a decent amount of time

[@natelysia5718]

I've put 90 hours into Fae Farm and still haven't finished everything I want to do! I think, with future DLC especially, it's worth the price.

[@packers12to80]

I agree. It's been my fav farming/life sim game since rf5.

[@nicostone2800]

Every single streamer that got to play Fae Farm early, has not revisited the game, discussed it or anything. Tells you a lot. 💸

[@litneyloxan]

It was too overpriced for what it offers IMO

[@CaffeinatedBookwoorm]

I adore paleo pines! You should play it more. I have it for my steam deck and I do notice frame drops occasionally but definitely not game breaking. It gets more interesting and busy as you get more dinos

[@liliespetals19]

This is the first time I've heard someone mention that the switch price includes future dlc. I didn’t know that, it makes more sense now. It doesn't do them any favors to take that option away from buyers though. All I saw was a game I was mildly interested in being the same price as AAA/first party games and no amount of reviews, lets plays or streams could sway me enough to look into it. What if I don't want the dlc? 😂 I just don't think it was the right move, especially as the npc/dating mechanic is on the weaker side. My stance was, and still is; might get it if goes on sale. Potion permit i still have to get, just haven't had the chance yet 😂

[@nicostone2800]

Def wait for a Fae Farm sale or for when their DLC are out. At this time it is not $60 worth.

[@angelfieseler5358]

Wild flowers ruined all other farming games for me, OM much more for puzzle games

[@BubblyAlexandra]

Literally it’s so good.

[@BlinWonderland]

I wanted to hear your review on Everdream Valley here! Lol I think is rough but engaging. I guess not enough to make the cut. Thank you for your input. I am actually considering some of these right now and it helps to hear someone else's experience with them.

[@KeysFan13]

Have you played everdream valley? I'm thinking of buying

[@litneyloxan]

@@KeysFan13I personally didn't like it at all

[@tinahoefs1455]

I would put rune factory 3 special higher next to fae farm and potion permit but that may be nostalgia. I've loved rune factory since the first ds game because rpgs are my first game addiction. I also love the unicorn people because of a favorite book series by Anne Mccaffrey starting with Acorna the unicorn girl.

[@christinac8866]

Thanks, Pat! Yes, please do a video like this every month. 👍

[@AmyRubyMoon]

Allow me to disagree, rune factory 3\4 are still the best rune factory games imo, just like harvest moon sunshine islands and island of happiness. They still have to beat themselfs on that ones as for the rest i dont really like them, i opted for silent hope instead of hm woa 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@NintenTalk]

I def need to play rune factory more! That score could easily go up!

[@AmyRubyMoon]

Yep rf4 has improvements but rf3 still has its charms even if you can only play as male and marry only females , the story is good and the fact that you can be a golden wooly is just pure gold ❤ also im kinda sad the didnt put the old Ost they were in JP and en they say the animation was too centered around only one candidate but the couldve just changed the animation and leave the song be 🥲

[@Jacquenelle]

I’ve been playing Rune Factory 3 and Fae Farm but lately I’ve abandoned Rune Factory and am obsessed with Fae Farm. 30 plus hours so far. Only thing I don’t like is when they kick you out of the dungeon at midnight and straight into bed 😂

[@Raphtor13]

Your high rating for Fae Farm makes me wonder about your other ratings as from everything I've heard Fae Farm is and overpriced underwhelming mess.

[@nicostone2800]

It definitely is everything you described. Cute, but not $60 worth. It’s just a decorating game once you finish the short story. Even getting all the items and accomplishments can be done in a week or 2.

[@sevothtartesama18]

Thank you so much for mentioning the fact that you can only play as a male in the remake of Rune Factory 3 and this is off-putting for a lot of gamers. I really appreciate you for considering us female players even though this is not a problem that affects you. Big hugs! ❤ (and no, I don’t begrudge them for making the game, glad for those that get to enjoy it but *I* certainly won’t be spending money or time on a game if I cannot play as my gender).

[@AmyRubyMoon]

You Do know when rf3 came out, most games where directed to male players ,hence why many games did not have the option to chose your gender ...right?

[@sevothtartesama18]

@AmyRubyMoon you do realize this exactly why I vote with my wallet about which games I support *now* right? Exactly because I've played enough games in my lifetime without the option. I don't get why my comment triggered you.

[@AmyRubyMoon]

Just asking im not triggered im a female myself so i know the struggle it just seems sad to not play a game only because you Can't choose your gender, in light of what You said a non Binary person wouldnt play the Majority of the games because they Can't chose a non Binary option 🙃

[@sevothtartesama18]

@AmyRubyMoon "pity". Yes it is a pity, hence I actually take the time to communicate with game developers when I am disappointed. If I'm just sitting around complaining in an echo chamber then I'm not achieving anything. I communicate in writing and by voting with my wallet about my beliefs. Women are 50% of the world's population and developers should thus cater to such a large segment (if they care about the related profits. If not, that's their choice, and then I'll make my own choice accordingly). Talking about non-binary people is a blatant example of "whataboutism" - a way to stunt opinion and to block legitimate concerns. So I'm not gonna engage in that. I hope it felt good to come shit all over a post I made to thank the creator of this video and to bring positivity. Well done. "Not triggered" my ass. Couldn't you at least respect Pat and let him be thanked for his attention to diversity? No? You "wondered" if I know about gaming history? Lol. Take several seats.

[@AmyRubyMoon]

I think youre overreacting 😅 and im not shitting over anything since we Are both right, because everyone is free to choose whatever they like best, im honestly happy to hear you write to the developers thats not something everyone does, so i apreciate that.

[@cozycouchpotato]

Love potion permit. So glad it’s getting an update.

[@R.Williams]

Great reviews! On par with most I’ve seen. My question, as well as it being a pet peeve of mine is what constitutes a game being a $30 game as opposed to a $60 game? If I spend 200 hrs playing and loving Fae Farm and it has a huge number of features and a big world, why shouldn’t it be $60? If I pay $60 for God of War or some other triple A title but don’t enjoy it as much, is $60 still justified? Another way to look at it is whether the developer tried to make their game the best that they could. Because a studio has 300 people working on an amazing game as opposed to 5 people working on another amazing game, why shouldn’t the small studio make just as much money as a big studio if people loved their game just as much? I hear complaints about pricing all the time but don’t really get it. If I go to an indie film at the theater as opposed to a blockbuster, I pay the same. I feel that if someone makes a game that takes off and becomes very popular and it has many hours on content, it should be worth as much. Just my 2 cents!

[@Jennilynne]

I guess I never really looked at it as "Does x game deserve x price?" When buying it. Since my budget doesn't really allow for me to buy a ton of games, especially at full price, I rarely buy them outside of sales. Unless it's the next game in a franchise I've been playing for years. Since I have more of an idea of what to expect and if I'll enjoy it. Fae Farm is a good example of one I was put off of buying it because of the price, despite good word of mouth/reviews. I'm much more likely to pick up something I'm unsure about if it has a lower price point versus going in somewhat blind on a $60 game. It's one I hope to see in one of the upcoming holiday sales.

[@meamme8]

I hate how much they changed "A wonderful life" the art style strayed too far for me and then the character names and design changes really ruined a lot of it for me.

[@Saki_Yukawa]

Potion Permit is a S for me!! love the game, i can absolutely recommend it

[@PafMedic]

Wait🤔🤔🤔If Your In The Cold Area..Maybe Frozen Corn😂😂🤣😂🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️What…And Your Statement Right Before That Was Your Location Will Reflect Different Types Of Crops…Soooo..If Frozen Corn Grows😂😂😂I Live In Pa…And Beside A Huge Farm…Ive Yet To See That 1😂😂😂😂😂

[@SilverSkyCloud]

paleo pines looks too cartoony for my liking, i dont expect hyper realism like jurrasic world but a bit less "blobby soft" wouldve been nice and it doesnt look like it has much in the way of character customising, im just being picky though lol, faefarm has a bit of a lack of creativity when it comes to the character creation and the models look pretty same-same its not a "cozy" game exactly but what are your thoughts on harvestella?

[@javi4591]

I appreciate that you add a bunch of hotlines to help people with Mental health issues, abuse, etc. But I'd love to have a timestamp in these type of videos... It's a must imo.

[@khierson11]

So happy natsume is finally stepping up their game

[@Stay_Echo]

I didn’t like Wind of Anthos, felt really bear. I did kind of like it, but not enough to play it over and over. I do agree the graphics are great and stuff.

[@SaraiLockett]

Please do this every month! I am obsessed with Cozy games! 🌽

[@estella5575]

Always appreciate your honest videos/rankings!

[@brattyx0836]

the only complaint i have for fae farm is that the NPCs and love interest have no personality at all and they just repeat the same things. whenever or if they fix that then it would be S for me but for rn it’s a B

[@WindowShopwithCandy]

This is helpful bc I'm so indecisive 😅

[@stephaniemcgee2375]

I couldn't get into Potion Permit b/c of the weird bouncing animation on all the characters. Fae Farm is a B. If they added a lot of QoL stuff it could bump to an A. (Also pretty sure the shopkeepers do close down at a certain point? I swear I wandered by trying to turn in a quest or something and the shop owner I needed was gone.)

[@charlottesantos4199]

Yep I saw them all leave around 9 or 10 pm

[@randomcount6173]

Hi, could you make a video about wholesome out and about? It's an upcoming cozy and educational game, so you won't feel guilty when playing it 😁. In this game you learn plant identification for foraging as well does it provide cooking and crafting recipes for real life. Also it broadens your farming knowledge like not so many other farming games does for instance it teaches companion planting (which plants should be planted next to each other for them to grow better). Moreover, if you like romance it will be included as well. Currently they are running their kickstarter campaign! Additionaly, the Paleo Pines team is actually working with them on the game, so I thought I would post it here on this video.

[@RoniStudio]

it's better to add text title to the game while you explain.

[@Nebuladust1018]

I Wanna try some Harvest Moon

[@Nebuladust1018]

cant wait for my birthday im gonna get it then

[@Nebuladust1018]

aww ty dear @@SameePabon

[@TimmyvsTommy]

New background is looking sick! Also monthly videos like this would be cool, a nice recap of games that we might not be aware of

[@_BiologyMatters_]

"It needs me." xD

[@packers12to80]

What games are those behind him on the top right? I know thats Digby and the ac board game but what are the other ones? Thanks in advance

[@NintenTalk]

They are the Amiibo/game bundles for Wii U. The other ones are Captain Toad, Twilight Princess and Mario Party 10

[@GaryLewis-z9g]

White Scott Hall Susan White Shirley

[@lisamaupin6508]

Begging for a Fae Farm decorating stream! I need ideas

[@alys1149]

These are basically all farming. Ugh.

[@TheChiefRockah]

Rune Factory Frontier is best...

[@MarvellousMayvin]

bro has beautiful eyelashes

[@weppingwillow52]

The shop keepers do go home at 10:00 each night

[@NightCross45]

thanks for the list! Some of these I haven't even heard of.

[@miniyooniverse9092]

I loved Sprout Valley for the little entertainment it gave me, but it is definitely a bite-size game. I bought the ultimate edition for $1 (used gold coins on the e-shop, it's lowest price is currently $2) and I grinded for a weekend and finished it pretty much in 3 or 4 days lol. Idk if there's been an update since this video (or maybe you hadn't unlocked the feature/craft recipe yet) but there if terraforming available and you can add little squares of land or water to your island. I don't remember what resources you need to craft it, and when crafting it, you get 1 square of land (so you have to craft multiple upon multiple of them) but I did manage to increase my island size A LOT. I was having so much fun with adding areas to my island and decorating with all the random items the game supplies once I was pretty much close to done with the game. Definitely not a huge and amazingly unique game, but it was a cozy little time and I had fun with it :)

[@catbutterfly34]

Stardew valley is my life 😅😅

[@JJ_TheGreat]

How is Stardew Valley?

[@nerdygeekgamer5528]

it's like they say to each their own some gamers love action adventure games some love RPG games and others love open world games I love all three I also love hidden object games but it really all depends on everyone's own preference

[@nokesyboo]

I wish they kept SOS A Wonderful Life the same graphics as the game cube version. I prefer that style than these cartoony modern ones. It’s not the same vibes as the aesthetics of the old version.

[@jmg5281986]

If PlaySkool made games

[@kianaramos8813]

I've played Paleo Pines (on PC!) and I loved it- I think it's for the people who always wanted jurassic park but cuter😅😅

[@rpederse]

For me, the relationship aspect of games isn’t attractive, so Wonderful Life wasn’t going to be fo me, anyway. But I watched Simply Press Start play a lot of this, and the killer for me is that animals and crops seem to require twice daily care, unless there’s a different way to play.

[@dianacarolinaorozco1702]

New year will come a pixel sailor moon style of art farm game and I know this man will have to update the list

[@nicostone2800]

Fae Farm has tons of bugs right now, story is not that long. As well as everything you mentioned. If you really get into the game, you’ll find there isn’t much to do besides decorating. Real let down for me.

[@AKABoondock19]

I couldnt get past the plant/seed tiles they chose not to replace in RF 3. It looks so bad. Its like they didnt even try to improve on it.

[@dirtysprite2012]

Palia definitely is flat on multi-player and romance. Which game is best for those^

[@joebonaiuto5554]

When I first saw someone playing Paleo Pines, I was struck with the idea that it was aimed at young children, maybe their first introduction to cozy games?

[@jinraigami3349]

None of them are more beautiful than Portia which is what I'm looking for.

[@loqred5026]

How hard is it to make a farm game where the main thing is waifus and the farm? No complex and tedious stuff

[@PK-se2jh]

thanx broo

[@spycoolgal]

Faefarm was kinda boring to me, after 25 hours I was like ehh

[@pecobs]

Palia hasn't stepped its foot on Switch yet 😏 prolly this december

[@ariyanaf4205]

The shop keepers in Fae Farm go to the bar at 11p.m. Also could you do chapters on your youtube videos?

[@elindigeno1215]

Hello my friend, I saw what you did there in the intro with the microphone. I respect that, and I enjoy this channel very much. 👊😊

[@Winter-Svnssn]

This is so useful! Thank you!

[@pamelaj791]

First of all, on Potion Permit, what was wrong with that guy that he had a giant question mark on his crotch? Second, I'd love a podcast of you and Payton going head to head dueling it out on your cozy games lists. And, third, great video Pat. Keep them coming! 🌽

[@ghostietoastiee]

I feel like AWL looks terrible!! Graphics-wise !

[@mightylotan]

Can someone give me the timestamp for the tier list? didn't see. thx

[@gillywitchy]

Sold few sos games and bought it fir £23 absolutely adore it

[@juliosalcido6591]

anyone one know if fae farm is gonna dlc or a update on customizations

[@mightylotan]

I feel like the mic-holding comment was directed at me

[@alvakaren1]

Pat, have you tried Stardew Valley?

[@shotarosann3914]

story of seasons is a big recommendation for me