Worst MMO Ever? - Tale of Toast

[@UtaShirokage]

*Kills bunnies for a few hours* Game: Cool, here is your UNDEAD OVERLORD OF ETERNAL DOOM AND OBLIVION pet. Enjoy!

[@AndragonLea]

Do not feed after midnight or release in the capital city to start a new reign of terror or warranty is voided.

[@UltimatePerfection]

Well, you killed cute bunnies. You probably deserved that.

[@KaoKacique]

If this was Adventure quest, it would be a bunny lord with that exact same name

[@TheMamaluigi300]

Not that it’d matter, I’m pretty sure one if them was named Daisy, so you’re gonna get ripped and torn

[@johnynoway9127]

Im surprised you didnt get a debuff called DOOM that makes every enemy harder

[@turrboenvy4612]

I was disappointed the thunder wasn't someone going "booompowpowpow" with their mouth.

[@MisterRandomEncounter]

Right if your that cheap with sound effects own the sillyness.

[@Firepulser]

pretty sure they used an actual thunderstorm for that one.

[@Holyduck777]

Not gonna lie, I'm actually pretty disappointed it's not an mmo about toast. Like, I've never been crushed this hard before.

[@JoshStrifeHayes]

I felt exactly the same

[@Holyduck777]

@@JoshStrifeHayes Future plans: Make MMO about toast call it Tale of inane grinds and xp loss

[@JoshStrifeHayes]

@@Holyduck777 I'd play it

[@ericb3157]

oh, did you know that there's an actual one-player game called "i am bread"?

[@antoniobluregard3089]

Jssjaja

[@zednotdead]

Oh by the way, I researched the HPB blockchain. It's proof of work, meaning the game (probably) mines coins on your PC. My guess is it sends 75% to the developer, and the rest to you - as an incentive to keep the game running. Furthermore, the FAQ of the blockchain is in Chinese, there is no team listed and the market cap is barely over $12M, which is the hallmark of what people call a "shitcoin". The best part? 1 HPB costs $0.18. They are literally giving you fractions of a cent.

[@Abigail-hu5wf]

In order to give Josh anything, it would have to be proof-of-work. PoS coins would have no reason to give him anything, as he wouldn't be able to participate in the stake because he wouldn't own any of the currency in the first place.

[@hats1642]

Back in January 2018, the coin was $10. By August it was under $1. Now, in 2023, it's $0.013. Classic shitcoin.

[@Limrasson]

@@hats1642 ... Apparently still more valuable than the currency I use

[@sauwensvk7589]

​@@Limrassonis it that cyacoin thing? I only know it from cr1tikal

[@Kr0noZ]

The game is still around in 2024. Probably the reason for the 250 buck shop item is meant to funnel capital into that crypto stunt, in case anyone ever actually earns enough to try a pay-out. I wonder how that is going, given how completely dead this is. Oh, and it's still in "Early Access" 🤣

[@mauricesteel4995]

The cutesy charm is a twisted joke, made to draw you in but then after you're tired of the grind, they don't sound charming, they are mocking you.

[@insensitive919]

The undead lich queen pet makes sense, she was defeated in another game and sent to a cutesy dimension to be the thrall of a low-level chibi character. The worst possible hell for her.

[@capadociaash8003]

Tale of toast is a punishment realm, makes sense tbh

[@a-blivvy-yus]

So basically what happened to that Freezer guy in Dragon Ball? xD

[@calmkat9032]

Why buy a sound library when you have a perfectly good mouth?

[@ASIRA89]

imagine an MMO where all sounds are made by one person making sounds with their mouth.. if it would fit the style of the game i'd like that

[@ArmisHart]

Their first words on the casting couch.

[@voilvelev6775]

tbh that gives it actual personality, most of those games cant say the same.

[@Phye]

@@ASIRA89 It's kind of an MMO. 'One hour one life' has sounds made with one person making all the sound effects with his mouth. It's quite a fun game.

[@ASIRA89]

@@Phye hey that looks interesting maybe i will try it out :)

[@dbaki3940]

The crypto thing might've been them using that as an excuse to include mining code in the game and use your pc to mine.

[@lofigaming1092]

your correct i was an old player and the only one with a 1080 this game had my shit runing so hot. i called the creator out on this and in return he added the hpb to the game. basicly he confirmed my suspicion.

[@paintdrinker455]

Thats the gig with early access these days.

[@theclimbto1]

@@lofigaming1092 My question is this... Josh said he got 0.01. So, he actually earned a tiny fraction of a Crypto? How? The Developer is using all the PCs to mine, and then gives you a cut? I'm very confused on the process. What Crypto are they mining? All of them, or exclusively going after one?

[@darkgn0ll587]

@@theclimbto1 yeah, I think that's the plan. They basically give you a low enough cut and just profit off of your hardware.

[@Thor-Orion]

@@darkgn0ll587would that be the worst thing ever if they were open about it and that was what was being used to fund the game development? That actually seems like a viable way to crowdfund once you get to a certain place in development... am i being naive in thinking that if it was done in a more honest way it wouldn’t be a terrible model, provided they aren’t using your hardware to mine at all times?

[@NoAliasForMe]

im actually amazed that even tho you cant reasonably get beyond like lvl 10. there is still a whole world and enemies at lvl 70+

[@clintonanderson7436]

Apparently there are people at lv 60 and above

[@Altobrun]

@@cannedsquasher5923 apparently the game has been out for a few years and used to have a small dedicated community. If that's the case it's entirely possible questing or mob-grinding in groups may be significantly more efficient exp wise. Either that or you reach a gear point where your secondary stats become inflated enough to trivialize combat.

[@leeohe]

@Tilip Muejark Dang for that amount of time maybe I should play! Lolll

[@stpb4756]

@@clintonanderson7436 Used to play this game alot 2015 I'm around lvl40-50 I think

[@dorokaiyinvil5705]

@@stpb4756 why?

[@Creshex8]

If “Enslaved lich queen” was not to your taste, maybe you will find some of these other pets cute, cuddly, and adorable: “Molten magma demon of rage” “Hateful slave reaver” “Guy with gigantic bloody butcher knife” Or... “Two headed wolf marauder of terror”

[@joshrivet4011]

Two-headed Wolf? You'd have to mess up pretty bad to make a doggo not adorable.

[@skyesfury8511]

8:22 //epic thunder roll for several seconds //scared "ba-a-a" from nearby sheep OMGDAWWWWWWW

[@macgargan]

I don't think the fact that this is using users for cryptomining is covered enough.

[@GrimFelArt]

Right? Like, urgh. Scummy and exploitative. It had so much potential too, I really liked the aesthetic and the custom-recorded cute sound effects. Sad to see cryptobros ruining things again It's been 3 years now, I'm curious if that's still a "feature"

[@Tyler-si2rj]

@@GrimFelArt game has been dead and abandoned for awhile

[@GrimFelArt]

@@Tyler-si2rj Ah well. Not really surprising. But the actual game itself minus the shoved-in crypto was cute and just needed some polish

[@trevorduncan9580]

yeah this is WILD. It is a fake game , created to purposefully keep you playing , so the dev can use your PC as a zombie mining rig. How is that even legal?

[@TheNatos]

@@trevorduncan9580 simple. its illegal when a law is passed against it and politicians are geriatrics 50 years behind and are baffled by smart phones.

[@stuglife5514]

Wow this is so malicious. A game that’s all cutesy to draw in kids and the naive, only to turn out to be a crypto miner

[@RAC00NFANGIRL]

@Dakota Rossman this game had Potential and I like the chibi style and I adore cutesy art!

[@ghhn4505]

Actually based tbh, those kids computers were just going to waste NOT mining crypto anyways

[@sadchiefanakin1496]

​@@ghhn4505 wow, I sincerely hope this is a joke.

[@charlesmcclure8000]

@dakotarossman5873 the developer doesn't need to see your wallet. They dont care what you have made because I guarantee they siphon coins like a tax on each player. so they make cash flow off each player's system running their garbage game.

[@okamiba]

@@sadchiefanakin1496 I hope it wasn't so your hope gets cancelled out

[@ShiningDarknes]

"The puns continue! Guess what the character named Berry wants me to collect. That's right, mushrooms." ded

[@Missmay123p]

I read this when he said it lol

[@dakotashroom5401]

There needs to be more games that tell you to collect mushrooms.

[@flossimoth]

'Tale of Toast is not an MMO where you play a sentient piece of toast' my disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined

[@FernandoRafaelNogueiraReis]

His week was ruined.

[@ericb3157]

oh, i've actually heard of a single-player game where you DO play as a sentient piece of toast!

[@ElasticGiraffe]

JSH, the Reviewbrah of MMOs.

[@leet37a9]

Dev: We're alpha, please be nice. Josh: Oh, that's fine Also Dev: Would you be interested in 3K crumbs for $249? Josh: Alright, that's it *removes gloves and wields brass knuckles*

[@ShaggyRogers1]

Dev: We're alpha, please be nice. Also Dev: This game is a cryptominer for a crypto currency you've never heard of btw.

[@gaddyric]

And the brass knuckles are better than any gear he will ever find

[@lisafairymeadow2034]

Imaging having a cute concept, a core strong idea and variety and if you made it very minimally monetized with cosmetics only you'd legitimately make gangbusters cash and you go "You know what this needs? Oppressive crypto malware."

[@ScottieTheFox]

absolutely INSANE that josh kept playing after the game admitted to being a CRYPTO MINER

[@SaebriSelect]

well atleast they pretend to give u a cut xD

[@TheOnlyGhxst]

There's nothing really wrong with that, as long as the players actually get their %. You're already using the processing power to play the game anyway, so if its a game you enjoyed, and you're playing it a lot, why not put that processing power towards mining? Especially if you, the player, can make a small % of money just for playing the game? Honestly it would be great if more games let you earn money while playing and WITHOUT ruining the in-game economy through RMT.

[@DemonSnacks]

​@@TheOnlyGhxstno

[@spankyjeffro5320]

@@DemonSnacks No.

[@twudotJam]

@@TheOnlyGhxst No.

[@lofigaming1092]

im one of those people who made it to level 60 and i can explain the hpb or why i think its there, now alot of players didnt have good gpu like i did (Infact most of them played on crappy laptops) so they didnt notice but this game made my gpu run like crazy and this was during the time games were getting in trouble for using players gpu to mine crypto, i called out the owner on this issue next thing you know hpb was added... additionally this game was cute but was actually ruthless in that anyone could pk anywhere but inside a town this was changed. and that is when player base declined.

[@elisecraig8509]

I made to 64 and actually managed to kill some people 😂😂😂

[@elisecraig8509]

1 guy just couldn’t believe I was that good at killing people that he kept coming back for more now I have 3 of his ears 😂

[@imhulki463]

LEVEL 60!! how long did you play this game?

[@ROYBGP]

...it's a crypto miner.

[@SquaulDuNeant]

but why did u keep playing it ? It doesn't bother u to used badly and without care ?

[@DarkExcalibur42]

I legit got excited when you went off to explore places on the furthest edges of the map.

[@hotaru8309]

It was really fun. Exploration in mystery that may not succeed and being somewhere you weren't meant to be is really exciting and fun. It's great to be unexpected together.👍🏻

[@Conighttonight]

Me too and I don't know why it excited me so much in knowing that possibly no players had got to that point. Actually... ironically it made me want to play it.

[@scintillam_dei]

@@Conighttonight Then see the channel Swankybox. He focuses on Zelda and Mario, going to places players weren't meant to go.

[@steamwings.6532]

I am actually devastated by the fact that this is not an MMO in which you control a sentient piece of toast in an "I AM BREAD" style physics combat and parkour system set in a ridiculous food fantasy setting.

[@dakotashroom5401]

That would be awesome! Just imagine playing as a baguette.

[@MrTrombonebandgeek]

Imagine a pyromancer class called a toaster

[@bib4eto656]

"food fantasy" is the genre we didn't know we needed

[@isabellamorris7902]

Ah damn, that makes me want to go back and watch videos of people playing I Am Bread. So many good times cry-laughing.

[@emperorgrieferus106]

@@dakotashroom5401 So, Spy TF2?

[@meaninglez100]

I was having a cute time and they blindside me with a damn cryptominer

[@LaverniusTucker2410]

"Rick Astley never gave me up" - I legit cried.

[@mikej2489]

When crypto is in a game in any kind of way this is a massive red flag your computer is being used for dark purposes.

[@Kramdaddy]

Ah yes, the indie dev who knows how to program crypto mining and a cash shop into their game, an MMO, but can't be bothered with a sound library. I'm kind of surprised they didn't add a fatigue system while they were at it, too.

[@xchronox0]

They technically did. But not in any way anyone has ever made a fatigue system. Later in the video, Josh dies from going too far out in the map. You start becoming "fatigued" by leaving the playable area.

[@gabriel_cooper]

@@xchronox0 doesn't wow do that as well tho? like when you try to go too far through the oceans.

[@charlylmaoo5953]

@@gabriel_cooper I believe the fatigue system he is referring to is having an "energy" meter like in mobile games, where you will have to spend energy to play the game until you run out and either stop playing or buy more energy

[@cenciende9401]

Their sound is honestly better and more original. But there no excuses for the mining when all they had to do was not make the grind and balancing so awful and actually keep players.

[@farlonmuentes6004]

the main problem with these games is that they try to cramped in so much mechanics but isn't polished in the slightest. working on one mechanic and making it perfect is better than a hundred but all broken.

[@ZorotheGallade]

The main reason they do so is to saddle the player with tons of busywork so the grinding becomes a slow boil.

[@whispersinthedark88]

Than and they are crypto mining scams that use you as cheap labor ...lol

[@davidchristoffersen1404]

I simply love Josh's rating system "This game is shit and you simply wish you could get away from it...That is why I rate this game "an actual human baby out of 10" " so brilliant.

[@BernhardErnst]

Please review "Age of Wushu", it has the terrible situation of that you need food or starve, but the word "Food" does not exist in the manual (it did not when I tried the game three years ago).

[@modkhi]

to be fair i dont remember needing food to like, complete quests or anything. the starvation was just a debuff, wasn't it? i really liked the game until the horrible customer service and botting and lack of... improvement in the translation made me leave. the mechanics were too complicated to understand without a decent translation and it was just horrible. but the graphics were so good, and the fighting was fun, and the life skills mini games weren't too bad

[@okwaho5316]

The looks designed to draw kids in than teach them harsh life lessons.

[@_yakumo420]

I'm quite amazed you were capable of using the wrong form of 'then/than' when it's usually used wrongly the other way. You use 'then' as a follow-up whereas 'than' is used as a comparison. So in this case, it's a follow up, which means you should've used 'then' rather than 'than' as I just demonstrated as well.

[@vincentproud6589]

@@_yakumo420 Congratulations.

[@_yakumo420]

@@vincentproud6589 Basic English has to be corrected when possible.

[@silverreaps6803]

@@_yakumo420 all you had to say was then*

[@aureliaaurita6498]

@@_yakumo420 As somebody with a linguistics degree I can tell you that it won't be wrong anymore if enough people keep using it incorrectly.

[@Parallaxdnb]

Yknow this may be drowned out by the ages, but I just want to say it's so nice to see someone be genuine unto themselves and see them thrive. Keep being yourself Josh we're enjoying it and i'm glad you're putting this content out here.

[@scintillam_dei]

I want an MMORPG of London except it's Londonistan, and the Shariah no-go zones are the most dangerous.

[@Ezio999Auditore]

Based. The white areas are safe and low level, sharia is end game content.

[@pubcle]

The sound design is painfully adorable and genuinely wonderful, but it's really sad the rest of it is. That sound design deserves a good, charming, child-focused game behind it.

[@Cory_]

This is why Valve banned NFT/Blockchain tech on Steam.

[@saucy-one]

Still waiting for Valve to become a bad guy. I heard there's some issues with their handheld internals, but I don't know the details. My account has a 13 yr badge I believe. I've always felt like Valve tried to be extremely fair with their customers. I think it's cool they're allowing adults to buy games that they are mature enough to decide if they want to play. Everyone else is like "violence and gore is fine but 'honey pop?! No!'"

[@video_ouija7114]

@@saucy-one uhh ok

[@thedarkness125]

@@saucy-one what the fuck are you talking about?

[@slightlyaboveaveragebutaverage]

@@saucy-one >Still waiting for Valve to become a bad guy >Still waiting Honestly just the worst kind of person. Do you get off on watching your hero fall? Very goober mindset. Especially since you'd still use their service Mr. 13 yr badge.

[@WalkerRileyMC]

@@slightlyaboveaveragebutaverage Trying to figure this out hold on... so...are you saying Valve/Steam have become the bad guy in something? Cause I don't see it.

[@MrKarato]

33:06 The strafing is correct isn't it? That's how strafing in every game I play works. Your character looks inward while strafing outward. It works like that in FFXIV and GW2.

[@adameves5970]

Right? To me it looks like the character is looking over his shoulder, while being chased. Just because this happens in other games that doesn't mean anything. There are games that do the opposite. But, in THIS game, he looks like he's looking over his shoulder at the people behind him.

[@lattenkack3592]

honestly kind of embarrassing to point that out, when making reviews of mmos which, you know, you as a viewer, would expect him to have some pretty good knowledge of and experience with.

[@Francorocco]

wait, the forest bat is literally a devilmon from summoner wars

[@lofigaming1092]

yes all the assets were bought and you will see in alot of other games

[@dervakommtvonhinten517]

33:37 i think the head movement is intentional cause its supposed to be a way to evade or manouver around enemies and you would want to keep an eye on the enemies you are moving around of.

[@goury]

This game was a lot better in 2019 I've leveled to 15 in a day, there was no cryptofarming nor pets And mobs did deal ten times less damage And there was potions usable in combat And there was iron crafting, you just needed higher skill level for recipes to appear

[@Trelior]

Sounds like they deliberately killed the game off so they didn't have to worry about it anymore. Which is more than kinda shitty because they left all the predatory microtransactions in it.

[@etherealpenguin8683]

@@Trelior Tbh what it sounds like to me is a game that started off with good intent, it had charm and promise and then someone or some company came along and offered to buy it out, probably quite cheaply but I imagine the original developers didn't have a lot of money to start off with, or a lot of time/resources to further the development, so they took the offer and then the new devs turned it into a shady cryptomining 'game' either that or the original devs just stopped caring and thought they'd try and make a quick buck.

[@ThatPianoNoob]

@@Trelior thats what a lot of failed MMOs do. Make a game as good as possible then if not enough people are willing to play, make the few that do pay the bills. That is ultimately what they do when they go free to play. Has nothing to do with "bringing in more players" just really milking the ones you have.

[@Cow-Moth-With-A-CRT-Head]

I'm surprised at how generous you were to the game after discovering a fucking cryptominer in it

[@mafiousbj]

Probably because Josh didn´t fully understand the implications off that code being there. Imagine the game using your PC to mine crypto!

[@JuryDutySummons]

@@mafiousbj do we know it's mining or just awarding coins?

[@mafiousbj]

@@JuryDutySummons would need to see either the code of the game to check what it does or see it in action, we can't know for sure just from the video

[@SpydersByte]

@@JuryDutySummons you think theyd be generous enough to be handing you coins with real world value and NOT using your machine to mine crypto for themselves too? lol. There are *zero* games out there that just give you money for playing them for no benefit to themselves, that would be insane.

[@JuryDutySummons]

@@mafiousbj not really. You can tell a lot from the processes that are running and the utilization. Delving into the memory can tell you about what it's doing.

[@noxturnaI]

That level up sound was too adorable for me

[@mr.handbones9591]

I never want to hear the words "cute, adorable, human" again after watching this.

[@williamhououin]

So disappointing, it’s so cute ! It deserved to be good ... but nope :(

[@biteme9869]

Wym? It looks good and it’s only alpha.

[@elu5334]

@@biteme9869 Very rarely you can bring back an already dead game, also the developers betrayed the core concept of their game within the first few months of it coming public. They hyped it so much that it was going to be an open world pvp game but they basically obliterated that and made it into one area, that perhaps was when I visually started to see the player base declining rapidly.

[@Puerco-Potter]

@@biteme9869 mmos have one chance at launching. After that the player base have to be big enough to keep the game interesting. They blowed up their chance when they losed the early adopters.

[@jacksepticeyesdadisburning7982]

@@Puerco-Potter It doesn't always have just one chance, though. ESO had a really shitty launch and it took months before the game was in a somewhat playable state. They completely ruined their first impression. Now it's one of the titans of MMO gaming. You can still climb out of that hole when you waste your first chance, but you really need to set all sails and make it your one and only priority. Instead a lot of companies will just let the game bleed out and just keep draining the wallets of those stupid enough to stick around until the server costs become too high.

[@flvx4693]

@@jacksepticeyesdadisburning7982 Ah yes just like FFXIV 1.0

[@Leighton9702]

This game has so much charm and I adore the sounds, sad to see a cute little game like this have predatory mechanics.

[@scintillam_dei]

Pissney: Nervous sweating.

[@thacoolest13]

35:20 I like how they just run through that wall after you went around the whole thing

[@Micr0chasm]

The animal sounds are pretty wonderful, but to be honest, I’ve always felt that real sheep sound like people pretending to be sheep.

[@oMuStiiA]

I'm stuck wondering 2 things. 1) have you ever heard a real sheep before? And 2) if so, wtf kind of sounds are the people around you making??

[@scintillam_dei]

The Cambodian language word for "yes" for males is "Baa."

[@MichaelKocha]

I love these videos. I've been bingeing the whole series. Thanks for the quality videos!

[@JoshStrifeHayes]

No problem, glad youre enjoying them :)

[@RAC00NFANGIRL]

@@JoshStrifeHayes I found from top worst mmos and I enjoy so much while I play world of Warcraft!

[@wowgmplayer]

So noones gonna talk about how this madlad actually read the terms and conditions Seems like a serial killer to me

[@nobodyshome6792]

You don't? I always do. *ALWAYS* and without fail.

[@scintillam_dei]

I skim through them. Can't let them steal your soul.

[@egemenozan5641]

I tried this game out about a year ago. There isnt much to do, but It gives me such a special feeling (and I dont know why) but I feel like crying. It is not just cute but weirdly melancholic. I still haven't left the game's discord server cause I just can't bring myself to do so.

[@darkencroix6412]

Ever play LoZ:Windwaker? That'd be why.

[@GodOfPlague]

Mabinogi was a similiar cute anime style game, not sure about its current status it was an old game

[@egemenozan5641]

@Beaverish Buck Teeth I havent claimed otherwise, it never really got much further development either. I still remember that feeling though Edit:still on the discord server 9 months later, tho I never check it

[@sna1466]

@@egemenozan5641 can you send an invite link?

[@egemenozan5641]

@@sna1466 I can, send me yout discord name

[@serioserkanalname499]

Its sometimes really fun to jump into really bad MMO's and see where you can go,I remember finding some azthek temple looking unfinished area in Bless Online devoid of life . You could only get there by jumping through the mountains. Was actually quite pretty,had some unique assets. Well and then the game died and now I am one of the probably very few people with screenshots of this place.

[@the_birthday_skeleton]

37:11 Ha I live near Seven Oaks, it’s a town in the south east of England - just over the border from Surrey in Kent. Maybe I’ll nip round there for Patch’s key sometime

[@tarkan9000]

This guy has 20m subs quality videos.

[@JoshStrifeHayes]

Thanks man, I'll just keep doing my thing and hope people like it :)

[@desanimoosrs6443]

@@JoshStrifeHayes Oh, we do.

[@tarkan9000]

Josh Strife Hayes, KZbin better start recommending.

[@MichaelKocha]

No kidding. I was literally just telling my wife how badly this channel deserves more subs and views when I read your comment. lol

[@RobDozier904]

his sub count is criminally low. ive been binging all his vids

[@Christian_Luczejko]

The kitchen queen gave me a giggle. Edit: I'm not fixing that. Too funny.

[@Kaledrone]

My dad had a kitchen queen, I was inside her once.

[@KaiserDaBard]

Just to let you know that last tirade at the final dungeon entrance is what made me subbed. I'm actually crying great work bro

[@TheAtemAndrew]

33:15 to be entirely fair, when I think of strafing, I think largely of two situations: Either moving directly left and right for situations in which you're shooting at an enemy; moving from cover to cover or dodging fire, and circling around an enemy. In both situations, you'd be in combat. Obviously knowing where you're going is good, but it's also a bad idea to take your eyes off the enemy. In both cases, looking the opposite direction that you're moving while strafing would have you 'looking' at the enemy.

[@leadingauctions8440]

Josh is tenacious when bored.

[@Tyranzor64]

This feels like a crypto mining application disguised as a "im a poor dev " schtick

[@bigtimetimmyjim6486]

"Come on Queen Lichy, I guess you're my pet now!" Queen Lichy: "I....will NEVER serve!"

[@zfazzershroudvietcynide64e58]

@33:48 had me dying.... "You might be good at swimming, but are you move backwards while swimming forwards good?"

[@lockecole3726]

9:45 And that is where I would've put the game down immediately, lol. I can't tolerate games where death causes xp loss.

[@elisecraig8509]

So those snakes and that last dungeon you saw... yeah a bunch us used to grind there and have done that dungeon multiple times 😅 although I don’t like that dungeon much but also there’s probably about atleast 4-5 of us who made it to the max level 64 lol

[@elisecraig8509]

So yeah we basically did all the things that you said no one would do... also the graves they put in after everyone complained their stuff would disappear before they could get to it coz they used to just drop on the ground and it’s very dangerous to eat or even speak of pizza while playing the game 🤣 ok the pizza is more of a joke than anything 🤣🤣🤣

[@minepose98]

@@elisecraig8509 Why did you put yourself through this...

[@elisecraig8509]

@@minepose98 I enjoyed the game and the people I played with, we had a good community going at the time

[@TravisVroman]

"This is an anime game. All you need to do is believe." Laughed so hard XD

[@sui_offical]

Whe I saw “Tale of bread” I instantly was like “why has someone made a mmo where u are a piece of bread” then I was thinking of the game “I am bread” but all mmo like. Now I’m thoroughly disappointed about hearing this game isn’t about being a piece of toast in a mmo setting

[@StriderWolf]

at 3:46 that isnt the buildings roof not coming back correctly when you leave, its working just as intended and their method of doing so was actually pretty clever. they used a method called Backface Culling, which makes the back side of polygons invisible, they did this so that when you exit the building the roof will still be invisible if your camera is still inside of it so that your view isnt being obstructed. if they didnt enable backface culling then there would be a brief moment where your entire camera view is obstructed when the roof comes back upon leaving a building. honestly thats the best way to handle such a thing, so I dont think its fair to call that a mistake.

[@propheinx2250]

I wish more modern games would do the same instead of pinning the camera against the wall.

[@MushVPeets]

Hidey wants hides but Jekkle or whatever doesn't? They sacrificed a good pun for a barely pun?

[@6Rangiku9]

The scared "BA!" from the sheep after the thunder was damn adorable 😂😂 8:27

[@curtnezirbiulent4845]

the forest bat 20:33 is straight up the devilmon from Summoners War... kinda miss playing SW...

[@ClingyParasite]

"What is the point of crafting" this feels like a question I ask for most RPGs, by the time you level up your worker classes and gain the resources required and make am item. It just end up being a waste of time and resources as it usually is inferior to most regular monster drop equipment. Some few games have made it work but most of them, just make crafting and stores irrelevant for equipment

[@ClingyParasite]

@Beaverish Buck Teeth I said in most, not all bozo

[@allaion2897]

It's a shame this is such a grindy nightmare, I was hoping for a positive review. It looked adorable and I was hoping to find a new MMO that I could enjoy 😞

[@DanIel-fl1vc]

When my game is complete I'd be so lucky to have someone tear it apart before release so I don't embarrass myself. Every enemy running past you when attacking is clearly because it only checks the player's position every 0.5 instead of every frame which might save performance. Not being able to close a window might have something to do with how the windows are layered. Tiny bugs that could be ironed out in a few minutes. The graphics however, is going to take a long time to fix.

[@justinenulam]

24:15 - I was listening to the video in the background and genuinely thought you were taking the piss. Wonders never cease

[@cybulasoup2637]

Rick Astley never gave me up, can't stop laughing.

[@zechsblack5891]

Crafting in wow has the same issue. It's basically a waste of time or materials except in niche cases. If I wanted to get heavily into it and play a bit more of an RP style where I gather an make my own gear, the gear is all just junk. Unless it's extremely high level non weapon and non armor items or utility items, it's just useless. The new xpack has fixed this to an extent with crafted armor, but you can only equip one useful crafted item at a time and the grind to craft a better version is huge and expensive... Time better spent grinding gold and just buying the items off the auction house.

[@UnderseaPumaKing]

Crafting in WoW used to be so much more important than its become. The professions in that game have become so neutered that they are mostly pointless. Vanilla to Lich King was when they were so good. Once Pandaria came about they were dead.

[@imasspeons]

@@UnderseaPumaKing vanilla and TBC crafting were pretty great. Sold my account just before Wrath so I can't speak for it.

[@IcicleFerret]

Listening to you describe this game brings back memories of OG Final Fantasy 14. Soloing was impossible past level 10 as enemies were scaled to a full party of 6 players. Quests did not appear on the map, and they never explained where to go. Crafting took insane amounts of time investment if you wanted to gather your own materials, so a major part of the economy was grinding crafting ingredients for other players. It was just expected of the community to band together to play that game. And for a long while, we did. Good times... *edit: I mistyped and meant XI, not XIV*

[@duhotatoday3277]

Sounds a lot like og FF11

[@SpydersByte]

you sure you dont mean OG FF11? Because that's exactly what FF11 was like but I dont remember 14 being like that at all, even back in the 1.0 days.

[@scintillam_dei]

Final is a lie. They are all Intermediate Fantasy....z.

[@IcicleFerret]

@@scintillam_dei the OG FF was supposed to be the studio's final project, because they had no money left. If the game broke even they didn't have enough to make another game, so they called it Final Fantasy and planned to shutter the studio after its release. But it was a smash hit, so they made another, and another...

[@scintillam_dei]

@@IcicleFerret I should play one.

[@amixofgeekcontent]

13:54 parkour jumps over a big green ram sheep lol

[@ViddyOJames]

actually, the looking in the opposite direction while strafing makes sense. after all, if you were strafing sideways, the thing you're strafing around would likely be in the opposite direction. But what I do want to ask nobody in particular is if this is one of those games made of bought assets/engines?

[@limitbreak2966]

35:11 MAN I CANNOT STAND games that take away xp youve earned, makes you scared to do anything risky AT ALL, same for having some super move that takes forever to recharge where you never end up using it because you're too worried to waste it

[@strangeduckling]

If they're going to give a pet a weapon then that pet needs to help in combat. Also, they should have made that lich queen cute a chibi as well. Imagine a bunch of big, scary liches being commanded by a cute lil queen

[@chemistral4943]

For how 'buttered' up the game's art style is it still left Josh 'burnt'. So many incomplete systems like 'crumbs' in it's coding and with no music to 'jam' out to leaves this piece of toast stale. No I don't regret those bad puns~ (P.S. Not sure if your up for it but I think it'd be fun to watch you and your patrons play some of these bad games together on stream or something...but then again given the incredibly low player count of some of these games you'd probably crash the servers. :P)

[@JoshStrifeHayes]

I enjoyed every single pun

[@Micharlus]

Just wanted to point out about strafing and head movement. It makes sense when engaging an enemy. When your target is in front of you and you're just kinda strafing around them, the head looks in a direction where the enemy would be standing. If they don't have head following target system, this is a nice cheaty way to get this effect. Should be only for combat though as it does look silly in every other situation. But on the movement itself, it does make some sense, it has a purpose. :D Btw, my friend was that "good" at swimming, he did manage to swim backwards when we were taught classic style. :P

[@Valdrakken]

the devil blob enemy things at 26:49 are devilmon from summoners war

[@peterparker0999]

Noticed the too lol. But pretty sure it's just basic cute blob design

[@geoffreywilson7008]

This feels like a potion chugging MMO without the potions. Was there a way to craft any, or much like the cabbages, 'you must be out of combat for 3 sec to use that'?

[@claytonparfumorse3101]

woah hang on, first time ive done a double take. the achievement picture for spring heels is the same picture used as the "dexterity" card in monster slayers. totally minor, but caught me off guard. no, wait, as you explain the ranged skill being unusable, i see the icons for the other skills. ALMOST ALL OF THEM are from monster slayers. what the hell? oh, aaand so is the swimming achievement. i know monster slayers is a comparatively small game, but what the hell?

[@viren_jalkun]

Watching Josh lose his sanity slowly to this game was VERY entertaining! 10/10 would watch again! xD And that actress needs a raise for her top tier adorable sound effects!

[@HalcyonVoid]

I just noticed, at 22:35 in the skills window, the melee skill tree, top half, bottom right icon... that is the same icon from Arcfall for the first active skill you get. It must be from an asset store.

[@interstellartravel]

Everything is from an asset store except for the sound effects which one of the devs said was the voice of a relative of theirs. Some of the Avatar wings were straight from Grand Fantasia.

[@konvect8490]

That ending was absolutely fantastic. The massive hype up to instant death was just amazing. 42:30

[@Andyelmasry]

Best Narration starts @42:19 "... Rick Astley never gave ME up." Bro 🤣 great writing

[@smittywerbenjagermanjensen3215]

Are you ever gonna revisit any of these to see if they listened and it got better?

[@aroace7913]

According to steam and seeing they player count it stayed the same.

[@brdevll]

There's no need for that lol

[@smittywerbenjagermanjensen3215]

@@brdevll ive noticed

[@oceanman_8370]

25:46 The shield is the tf2 logo

[@tsbulmer]

This makes me want WoW to have a quest where you experience a child's recollection of something, and while playing as the child, everything appears and sounds like this game.

[@banaman7746]

Hello, I'm someone who has also bounced between a LOT of different MMO's and have been really enjoying your series of going over them (I've even personally played a handful of them myself) anyway, I'm only at 4:10 and had to stop to comment on something I saw you mention,because I think it is worth pointing out since I actually know why it did this: (disclaimer: not part of this game, just happen to be aspiring game designer myself) When you exited the house and the roof "reappeared not quite right as a bunch of sticks" at first, it's because your camera was still "inside" the roof, and because they made the roof to have no inward facing textures, you instead see straight through it like as though it is not even there. truth be told, this is something that I personally wouldn't count against a game designer, as the only 2 other options would be is to: have it appear and block your camera (I'm sure you've seen this happen in plenty of other games were a wall completely blocks your camera as you clip inside of it) or push the camera outside of the house (which if it's designed to be a fixed camera angle, may not always be possible) Anyway, I hope this explains what you noticed a bit better. TL:DR: at 3:50, when the roof "reappeared" as sticks, it's because the camera was still inside the building, and you were seeing the non-existant underside of the roof that would have otherwise blocked the camera's view completely. bonus: if you ever find yourself wondering what mmo to look up next... an mmo I played for a while a long time ago (and is actually still running... though in limbo status) and I know not many know of and would love to see your reaction to is "Pirate Galaxy".

[@AunCollective]

I've been hopping back into each game before the premiere in this series, so looks like it's time to hop on Tale of Toast. Quite a different game from MO, and I'm curious to see if there's an enthusiastic community that shows up in the comments. :)

[@JoshStrifeHayes]

God i hope so. Every diasgreeing comment or personal insult is still a comment.

[@AunCollective]

@@JoshStrifeHayes I just played for an hour. One person responded in chat when I asked every few minutes if anyone was around.. and it was a new player. I was able to fall off of the cliff near Brightwyn, swim down the river to the ocean, and rapidly jump up the cliffs / steep slopes and get back into town. This is like a school project attempt at making a 3D RuneScape in the state it's in now. I can tell that the developer really put a lot of effort into this game, but it seems to be another case of taking on a project beyond one's resources and releasing it to the public way too soon. It has some of the most awkward controls too. I was often hitting combat targets with my back turned to them. Health bars and other elements obstruct the playfield and the UI - while attempting to be cute - looks amateurish. There's a prototype of a potentially interesting Runescape-like game here, but in my opinion -- it should have been developed a bit further before tossing it on Steam and releasing it to the public. The world felt fake as well. There were towns, NPCs, random environmental features, etc -- but none of it really felt cohesive. I couldn't tell you a single thing about the lore or story of this game, except apparently I helped a place called Astaria and a guy named Bony wanted bat bones, and I just logged off. If someone wanted a 3d game of this style to alpha test, Arcfall is in much better shape -- higher pop (still not great), more content, and a better overall presentation. I guess you could say.. The Tale of Toast is toast. :)

[@JoshStrifeHayes]

@@AunCollective it was an interesting little game, and in 8 hours of play it doesnt really change much.

[@dylanisaac1017]

@@AunCollective I’m not sure what it’s like now, but when I played it a couple years ago, it was full of people and I was even in a Discord for a group within the game.

[@aroace7913]

@@dylanisaac1017 Looking at steam the game is dead.

[@themuch21]

Jekkely is a pun name. I think it should be a reference to jekyll and hyde. The jekyll part wants you to kill the animal and the hide part wants you to get the hide from the killed enemy

[@j.d.4697]

Can I just say: Your final adventure is how any journey in Everquest 1 was, even just going to a dungeon for your level, especially when it was on another continent. The thrill of traversing creepy areas with monsters that could 1shot you, causing you to lose exp worth hours or days of grind and even all your possessions if you don't manage to get back your corpse while completely naked. I miss those times. Nowadays it's all just "meh I died, no problem", "meh it's on the other side of the globe, I just click this teleporter"...............

[@codysnowden231]

When you started your whole big anime speech at the end. It was obvious that instant death was coming immediately. Still cracked me up 😂

[@MsCataleena]

I lost it at the Whirlwind animation. Haven't laughed like that in a bit.

[@killerjoe12345]

is the music in the beginning (0:38) from Element TD 2?

[@marcun666]

I feel it's only suitable to give litch queen to a heartless beast that murdered cute, innocent bunnies without as much as a blink of an eye.

[@Marunon1992]

LOOOOOL those 3 demons at the end are the same model as a mobile game i played for a few months (Undead vs Demons) so funny xD

[@cezarystasiak9498]

Now I can't stop wonder whats in that last dungeon...

[@proffessorX]

That rating was perfect : "it was ok to interact with for about 15 minutes(meeting new baby for the first time and make silly noises to get a reaction), but then becomes an annoyance (hand baby back to parents and leave a short time later)". I dropped you a prime sub (sorry it couldn't be more) for all of your excellent content, thank you.

[@Scottthespy]

This video, this game, has given me ideas about an MMO without grinding, without even *levels* . Just Warframe style fights where you doge and attack and use pure skill to take out the enemies...your gear gets stronger as you work your way up through tougher mobs, but technically, if you're *good* enough, you can take on the final boss with no weapons or armor and *win* .

[@HuntsForge]

I remember people doing that sort of thing in Guild Wars 2, final dungeon hardest fight halfway through (giganticus lupicus) naked and solo.

[@Scottthespy]

@Beaverish Buck Teeth It is if it's massively multiplayer and also online. Unless you mean Warframe specifically, in which case I was just using that as an example of the play style. I feel like there would be an audience for a purely skill based MMO. There's plenty of people who enjoy the 'get good enough to kill the boss in your underwear ' style of gaming in single player, adding PVP and cooperative takedowns to the mix would probably catch that audience.

[@MoXiang_Sumika]

44:02 I heard the sound of a mouse click, it must have been Josh making this sound with his mouth, disguised as a mouse click!