Judge Judy Knows Horse People

[@sheismymom]

Get that woman an ambulance she's having a drama attack!

[@SirPhilMcCrackinVonBeggington]

Someone call an amberlamps

[@neo_theone]

lmfao. Burst into laughter after reading this comment. Brilliant!

[@speedoMK]

Me too, that was funny XD

[@RizzyWow]

Halsey Robert I'm stealing this phrase.

[@SpiritBear12]

LMAO!

[@dfa3366]

That old blond women acts like she was given the death penalty. I bet everything is a drama in her life. "OMG...the sink is clogged. The world is crashing before me"

[@carolinefawcett4237]

No, when the sink gets clogged I figure out which tools I need and I fix the clog.

[@Pajamers]

Margot Corden what

[@SSJKenpachiZaraki]

oh my god it is xD

[@KitCat-qd3fp]

Margot Corden Why did you react like a crazy lady? You lost. Life goes on. Why freak out like you just ruptured a lung on National TV?

[@EnemyAce88]

I hope you're having a happy life with your new horse and your 28 cats.

[@sarahbee3868]

The defendant has goreous hair. I wonder if she uses Mane & Tail.

[@jonsaunders2179]

You win

[@mscstarz7151]

I actually lol

[@Lady.B0420]

😆😂🤣

[@ladydovedove2240]

there is legit a pet shampoo that People can use

[@THEDOORIZCLOSED]

Blonde hair always looks so pretty

[@ItsIdaho]

"I adopted a Kid. Now I am gonna sue the biological parents for food money and rent."

[@misstynax3]

😂😂

[@nothintoreadhere6168]

Something similar to this this actually happened in real life

[@notu1529]

@@nothintoreadhere6168 i hate people

[@elibertor]

Did that kid turn out defective? If so, you might have a case

[@c7po457]

@@elibertor hahahaha!!!

[@michaelwest1558]

The older lady agreed to pay 15 monthly payments of $100 totaling $1,500 and acknowledged that she has only paid one of the monthly payments. So why is she acting all shocked and surprised that she has to pay the remaining balance of $1,400? I mean come on. It's not like Judge Judy ordered her to pay it back in blood.

[@beegee1856]

“Karen” was trying to say the horse that she was buying off her was deformed and had f*cked up legs And that none of that showed in the pictures she was sent. Then “Karen” said she tried taking all the proper steps to return the horse but the lady that sold it to her wouldn’t take the horse back. “Karen” had it over a year with only one payment made of $100 n was suing her for 3k for feeding the horse and pretty much taking care of it lol even tho she only paid $100. “Karen” didn’t want to pay $1,500 for a “deformed” horse but she signed the papers n f*cked herself pretty much

[@NC-qc2nv]

@@beegee1856 So why wouldn’t the defendant take the horse back if there was nothing wrong with it?

[@beegee1856]

@@NC-qc2nv because she sold it lol and the Karen lady signed the papers saying she was buying the horse for $1500 why would she take it back? She sold him bcuz she wanted to sell him she found a buyer and sold it. The point of her selling the horse wasn’t for her to take him back lol I seriously cannot believe that was a serious question 🤣🤣

[@josejaviermacias4768]

@@beegee1856 CORRECT! im a law school student

[@crusonu]

@@NC-qc2nv stupid question

[@sheismymom]

Judge Judy doesn't deal with nonsense before lunch.

[@PieALaMode]

She doesn't after lunch either xD

[@benm7045]

Halsey Robert You should see her during lunch.

[@RizRyuzaki]

You and Halsey made me laugh

[@andrewm6424]

I hope everyone on here (except for one person who obviously has a problem and vested interest in this case) has seen other Judge Judy episodes, and realizes the “lunch” comment may have been sarcasm just to get a laugh from the audience. Or am I the only one who thinks that?

[@amacuro]

I think she genuinely was hungry. People make comments like that all the time and not as a joke.

[@natalieschannel7675]

“You mean I actually have to Honor the agreement?!”

[@tyronehuston1260]

Terrible isn't it????

[@ryans413]

I don’t think people understand what a written contract means. You sign it you agree to what it says so you are aware of what’s being asked if you. That’s what contracts are

[@tyronehuston1260]

@@ryans413 well as we know, common sense isn't common. Plus people keep trying to bring how they personally feel into matters of Law.

[@dragastarr2926]

@@tyronehuston1260 And then have the nerve to be upset when a court of law doesn’t make rulings concerning their feelings 🤣

[@bb22602]

I have a feeling Ms. Over-reaction is used to getting her own way and this time she didn't.

[@edwardwookey8599]

😂too right

[@dominickjustave3558]

100

[@Renovartio]

Bro she's arguing with people in comment sections of other uploads of this video

[@Sky-CladObserver]

@@Renovartio Lol, are you serious? Is this recent?

[@Renovartio]

@@Sky-CladObserver like last month

[@MystikBlue5]

Legend has it, she is still reacting to this day.

[@DanielSelk]

Even now she is still commenting on the videos of her trying to defend herself. It's pathetic and hilarious XD

[@AZooKeeper]

Can confirm, a year later this bitch still be crying

[@LloydHarrod]

Hahaha

[@BMW9661]

@@AZooKeeper wow. Lmao

[@iammasterbidenspersonalsex400]

You would be correct, she is currently trying to convince me she is right.

[@falseking989]

The plaintiff is clearly a Karen. She pays $100 of a $1,500 horse & thinks she’s going to not pay the rest of the $1,400. Instead of paying the balance of the horse she wants the seller to pay the feeding & boarding of the horse. It’s an obvious scam. I ❤️ the defendant’s reaction.

[@carolinefawcett4237]

Would you continue to make payments to someone who lied, committed fraud and sent you an item that was not as described or agreed upon? You never heard of the Federal Trade Commission Holder Rule? Look it up, it might save you a lot of money one of these days. What would you do if you tried numerous times to send it back and they blocked your communication, refused to pick up certified letters from the post office, reported you to Canada Customs for trying to smuggle a stolen horse across the border ( horse being sent back to his legal owner was a brown and white pinto and hers was a solid chestnut) There were 2 photos of the Canadian horse and he was very clearly a pinto who could pull a cart and not a solid chestnut that no ethical trainer would ask to pull a cart. I can go on about all the crazy things she said and did. All of which I can prove.

[@8698gil]

Her name wasn't Karen. Calling people "Karen" as an insult is unkind and unfair to the many women who actually are named Karen and are very nice people. It's time for this name-shaming to stop. What if it was YOUR name being shit on all over the place for no good reason?

[@carolinefawcett4237]

Ok, yes you're all correct, I am crazy and there are good reasons that I am the way I am, I challenge every single one of you to stay sane and stay alive after all I have been through, and what I am going to share is just the tip of the iceberg. 34 years ago, next week I lost my 11hour old daughter as a result of a horrible medical mistake. One simple medical test and one dose of antibiotics would have saved her life, just try to live with that reality. 4.5 years later on Christmas Eve, her father/my husband announced to me that he did not love me, that he had never loved me and that he had only married me to get away from his parents. In the meantime he was also telling good friends of mine terrible lies about me and turned them against me, and later he also told my three children lies about me and succeeded in poisoning them against me to the point where I have lost the love of one of them and with her three grandchildren, try to live with that reality as well. I was dealing with the anger of that one daughter and the parental alienation at the time that Summer took advantage of me, she sent me a horse that she said was top show quality, but instead he had very crooked legs and was unable to perform the tasks I had told her I wanted him for. Legally I had the right to send him back because she had committed fraud, but she refused to take him back and made threats and told more lies. She lied over and over again not only to me, but to the mediator and to the staff at the Judge Judy show. Then the producers lied to me and told me that Judge Judy would take the time to question me and listen to my evidence. My evidence was totally solid, I had done my homework. So, when I had my breakdown and was sitting there saying "Not again" it was because I was faced with the fact that I had been lied too again. So go ahead and have your laughs and think I am crazy, just know that you are doing it at the expense of a mother who has been to hell and back and was taken advantage and lied to by Summer Ruegger and the producers at the Judge Judy show.

[@ldgdo4158]

@@8698gilyour name must be Karen. 😂

[@ERIN_198]

​@@8698gilCalm down Karen

[@tonyc7301]

2:07-As good as the plaintiff's ridiculous reaction was, the defendant's was just as good. The shocked look on her face that she won plus the loud hand clap like "hot damn!" was awesome.

[@MaeveLaRenarde]

Plus she was likely not expecting it to end that quick.

[@Grovesie35]

I wanna see the rest of it, seems like it was a shock to the whole room!

[@CuzzieGaming]

Oh my gosh I was thinking the same thing her reaction was so incredible she looks so surprised that she won in the her little laugh at the end was great

[@domisthebomb09]

You'd thought she hit the jackpot

[@crackerjackrappr]

Is this a captain holt reference?

[@kylejohnston1731]

$1500 for a horse??? that's it!!??? wow.. some breeders sell their puppies for that. my teacher bought a horse for her daughter and it cost her $4000. $1500 is a steal.

[@shades1756]

horse thief confirmed

[@3piper]

If it is a registered horse.But a grade horse will vary.Also many girls will sell for less if they feel he is going to a good home.We dont know how old the horse is

[@marklarsontube556]

A horse that won the Kentucky Derby one year (around 2004-2009 I can't remember exactly) was once purchased for $1500 ***EDIT*** it was $9,500 not $1,500. Thanks to Quesa Dilla for looking up the horses. Something I should have done before spouting off foggy memories as facts on the internet!

[@marklarsontube556]

My Mistake - Thanks for looking those up - It was Mine That Bird that I was thinking about, but the purchase price was $9,500 not $1,500. I was way off. For some reason I thought it was much less than that. Not that $9,500 is a ton of money for a horse that would eventually win the Kentucky Derby (as you said some can go for hundreds of thousands of dollars), but that's not the $1,500 that I was thinking for some reason. That's weird because I really remember $1,500 for some reason. But it was purchased as a yearling for $9,500. I just looked it up. It was definitely Mine That Bird. Sorry about that.

[@gannonmoore9042]

Kyle Johnston my dog was like 1500

[@beneaththecrust4661]

Look at how the audience is looking at the drama queen.

[@BillGraper]

I know, embarrassing!

[@ToutCQJM]

My favorite part.

[@mso1ps4]

🤨🤨🤨

[@msAK85]

@@DanielSelk uh pause right at 2:18 😄😐😉😃😆😀😆 and at 2:20 😃😐😏🤨😃😁😁. Its pretty hilarious to see.

[@mangobodybutter]

The woman in the blue cardigan's face while she watches the plaintiff is my favorite thing in this video

[@JRPHILLIPS75]

The plaintiff is acting like she's headed to the electric chair or something

[@Martin-zr2tb]

😂😂

[@carolinefawcett4237]

Ok, yes you're all correct, I am crazy and there are good reasons that I am the way I am, I challenge every single one of you to stay sane and stay alive after all I have been through, and what I am going to share is just the tip of the iceberg. 34 years ago, next week I lost my 11hour old daughter as a result of a horrible medical mistake. One simple medical test and one dose of antibiotics would have saved her life, just try to live with that reality. 4.5 years later on Christmas Eve, her father/my husband announced to me that he did not love me, that he had never loved me and that he had only married me to get away from his parents. In the meantime he was also telling good friends of mine terrible lies about me and turned them against me, and later he also told my three children lies about me and succeeded in poisoning them against me to the point where I have lost the love of one of them and with her three grandchildren, try to live with that reality as well. I was dealing with the anger of that one daughter and the parental alienation at the time that Summer took advantage of me, she sent me a horse that she said was top show quality, but instead he had very crooked legs and was unable to perform the tasks I had told her I wanted him for. Legally I had the right to send him back because she had committed fraud, but she refused to take him back and made threats and told more lies. She lied over and over again not only to me, but to the mediator and to the staff at the Judge Judy show. Then the producers lied to me and told me that Judge Judy would take the time to question me and listen to my evidence. My evidence was totally solid, I had done my homework. So, when I had my breakdown and was sitting there saying "Not again" it was because I was faced with the fact that I had been lied too again. So go ahead and have your laughs and think I am crazy, just know that you are doing it at the expense of a mother who has been to hell and back and was taken advantage and lied to by Summer Ruegger and the producers at the Judge Judy show.

[@jen-a-purr]

@@carolinefawcett4237😂😂😂😂😂Get over yourself

[@meeshprice4753]

Wait...so essentially the plaintiff "bought" a horse from the defendant, only made 1 payment, now wants the defendant to PAY HER for her own horse? MORE than what the defendant even "sold" it to her for?? Mann, if self-entitlement was a person... Her dramatics at the end are so mind blowing. Because how tf is she shocked that she lost? She literally tried to buy a horse and charge the seller for selling it to her.

[@reesegabrielle9522]

Well if you get a new truck and pay monthly they can repo if you do not. She said she was sold the horse under the understanding that the buyer will lay $100 a month for 15 months to pay off the horse. She only paid one payment of $100 over a year prior. Horses are very expensive and normal bording is way more monthly than what the woman got away with. At the end of it she signed the paper and knew what she was signing. She had a long time. And honestly anyone who can’t afford $100 monthly for basic animal care/needs such as food etc which a horse will most definitely go through with getting their feet done on top of everything else, shouldn’t have the responsibility of a horse. I pay $100 every month just in dog food alone. Everyone is different but animals always require care and the payment for the animal alone does not imply how expensive they will end up being in total through their life.

[@meagandoesthings]

The plaintiff was trying to "return" the horse but didn't agree to any if the terms in the contract. So when the defendant wouldn't take the horse back, she thought she then had grounds to counter sue for an animal that she felt wasn't hers anymore. But plaintiff didn't take care of the first part, disputing the contract, which ultimately messed her over in the end. Since there was no "legal standing to prove" the horse is the defedants, the horse was still plantiffs. That's why this went so fast. Plaintiff went right to money, not to the contract, and so there's no terms to sue. Game over. Now, if the contract had been overturned, then defendant might have lost..

[@cheyennemontuori1618]

If she can’t pay $100 monthly then why does she have a horse?! It costs so much more for vet and farrier bills plus board. People at the barn I ride at pat $575 monthly and she can’t even pay $100 monthly for 15 months. She got a great deal with that contract instead of paying the $1500 upfront.

[@cheyennemontuori1618]

I also just found from a different comment that the plaintiff is known for doing this. She takes horses and doesn’t pay for them fully, then turns around and tries to sell the horses to kill buyers

[@carolinefawcett4237]

@@cheyennemontuori1618 that is a total lie. I have never done that. I had bought a horse and decided he not the horse for me and gave him to a friend. She was thrown from him and in her anger she said she was going to send him to a kill buyer. I took the horse back and sent him back to the breeder.

[@KayleeCee]

That lady must have been banking on winning her case, although I can't see why. She must have needed that money bad, other she wouldn't have been freaking out so much.

[@derickmajors3620]

Kaylee Foley she walked in so smug too at the beginning 😂

[@roseedge5626]

That, or she's just a drama queen.

[@Espresso_plz]

Kaylee F I love the looks the audience members give when she starts freaking out.

[@FrumpyDucks]

apparently the show pays the cost of the ruling anyway! lol

[@TheEvilQueenHasSpoken]

She was so smug and arrogant when she entered the courtroom that after losing she tried to put on a (bad) show in an attempt to save face...fail!

[@BUHNANUHBREAD]

Judge Judy don't put up with no Horse Shit! Bahaha

[@BUHNANUHBREAD]

I know you are a troll on everyone's comments on this video...face it lady...you are full of horse shit! Bahaha

[@BUHNANUHBREAD]

Exactly citizenxgen! ;-)

[@Woody.Doppelganger]

Susan Hayes hahaha

[@GroundPoundersPlace]

lol !!!!!

[@jamiebrown3816]

Good one...Lol

[@broadwaymelody33]

Lmao she was okay with not getting money, but she didn't want the defendant to get money.

[@fraidykat]

She wanted to recieve $1900 and a free horse. She got to see the show pay for her horse.

[@BillGraper]

She knew her lawsuit was bogus.

[@greekmillennial4540]

Well she is the one who has to pay that money

[@carolinefawcett4237]

So I had a meltdown on National TV, yes embarrassing, but after all that woman put me through, totally within reason. I wasn't crying for me, or for the money, it was only $1400, I was upset because JJ had rewarded that woman for lying and scamming and giving her and others like her permission to do it to others. I was upset because many animals that are used by scammers end up being dumped at the humane society or auction and then sent to slaughter. Go ahead and laugh if you think that is funny, I sure don't

[@artemisb.5853]

Caroline Fawcett the horse wasn't dumped. If it's actually you, the horse is yours. If the other woman is such a horrible person, you should be glad that she didn't get it back, right?

[@greekmillennial4540]

She came in court smiling with glee and left reacting as if she was handed a life sentence XD

[@dimitridelgado18]

This lady really tried to sue her and she only made one payment is she serious how are you going to sue someone you owe money too 😂 at the end she acted like she was dying 😂😂😂

[@niquiwheeler5128]

This clip is so funny

[@StarFighters76]

The plaintiff is a scammer, look at how she presented herself at the end.

[@CaptainCocaine]

My crocodile tears should make me more honest.

[@MrBeevee5]

She certainly walked into the courtroom expecting an easy win. Look at her smiles and laughter.

[@larasky1198]

😂😂😂😂

[@Wickett01]

This is the happiest defendant at the end of a Judge Judy case I've ever seen!

[@packisbetter90]

wow thats one of the few cases ive ever seen that the defendant win

[@CaptainCocaine]

Really? It happens a lot.

[@chewchewtrain]

@@CaptainCocaine They probably meant the counter claim. Plaintiff gets their case dismissed a lot but normally counter claims dont win.

[@annabethsmith-kingsley2079]

This is the best Judge Judy case! Both their reactions are *priceless*

[@Thunder-acro]

I'm pretty sure they don't give Oscars in the courtroom.

[@xxllamaborrachaxx9374]

What if it's a custody case, and the kid's name is Oscar?

[@DiggitySlice]

@@xxllamaborrachaxx9374 casually dropping by a year later and leaving legendary comment

[@TactileTherapy]

@@DiggitySlice ill be back in 5 months with a better one

[@uwillcatchhands2479]

@@TactileTherapy well? Its been 5 months

[@hisdivinegraceimperialmaje4178]

still waiting ))))

[@puppetseducer]

That bottle of Pepto Bismol overreacted a bit.

[@debapratimbhattacharjee1569]

Dafaq 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@oczakwc9398]

Just a bit

[@puppetseducer]

@@oczakwc9398 Your comment made me rewatch it lol, congrats!

[@lordlossize]

JJ: you dont get any money plaintiff: ok! :D *JJ rules on the case, giving plaintiff nothing* plaintiff: what?! no! i... i cant breathe, im having a *DRAMATIC* panic attack! D:

[@OEDODRAGON]

'JJ' rules the case, charging the plaintiff $1400...... I'd like to see this whole episode.

[@lordlossize]

OEDODRAGON this WAS the whole case. the plaintiff was trying to pretend she was going to "rent" the horse when in actuality she was buying it. JJ saw through the lie and gave her nothing, and since she didnt actually finish paying for the horse even in the "rent" agreement she gave the defendant what they had agreed on, which was the $1400

[@OEDODRAGON]

Exactly. She found out she had to pay.

[@carolinefawcett4237]

I think you had better go back and read my comments up above and if you want to see all the evidence feel free to pm me. Judge Judy claims she can spot a liar a mile away, yet this time she totally messed up and let a habitual liar get away with her scam and even rewarded her.

[@carolinefawcett4237]

Let me ask you something. If you rent/buy whatever something and find out after you receive it that it is badly defective would you try to send it back? Then if the person who sent it to you refused and made it very difficult for you to return it, would you continue to make payments on it? This little horse has deformed legs, I tried to return him and she at first refused and then made it very difficult. I couldn't just stop taking care of her horse, he needed to be boarded, Fed, hooves trimmed every six weeks. Read the article I posted and pm me and I will send you photos of him. This wasn't about the money, this was about having been scammed. Summer saw an opportunity to get rid of a "defective horse and offloaded him onto me.

[@Ray_Luv2.0]

The lady’s reaction behind the plaintiff is hilarious 😂

[@elizabethalphonse1697]

That lady in pink is exactly how I act whenever someone tries to make plans to hang out with me😂😂😂

[@patriciabarajas7925]

Haha! Relatable

[@jenniferjohnson8645]

Bahahahhaa

[@datwuznotfunny]

I've watched the ending of this episode an unhealthy amount of times. Too damn funny.😂😂😂😂

[@UnscrupulousAgitator]

2:20 😂😂😂. In the audience, the 2 women to the left of the P Their expressions 😂😂😂

[@WealthyIndustrialist]

I love it haha

[@OEDODRAGON]

I never noticed! xD Thanks!

[@pi_beta7306]

The audience member expressions are some of the best parts. The woman on the left looks like she's prepared for the plaintiff to spontaneously burst into flames

[@marlonscott1014]

Me af

[@SeydaHeart]

UnscrupulousAgitator you used their right... I appreciate that

[@samuelaust]

Her reaction explains why Judge Judy didn’t even bother asking her side of the story 🤣

[@nelsonsams340]

2:38 “ I am never going to financially recover from this”

[@DestroyerWill]

I love this episode! The defendant seems so happy at a surprise win and the plaintiff was smug until she lost then lost it 😂 edit: and the defendant is super cute

[@jasonhurd4379]

2:37 When I go to KFC and they ran out of extra crispy

[@justsomeone931]

HAKAJAJA

[@MRG06]

"Judgement on the Clownter Claim"

[@asmrlilvezzy6601]

I smell a “karen” who didn’t get her way 😒

[@graphite2786]

2:38 Karen says "not again" so she's obviously tried this shit before

[@con8200]

@@graphite2786 She says "No, I can't" not "Not again".

[@ohwowoh7281]

Judge Judy is such a great judge. She managed to squeeze this quick and easy case before lunch.

[@DawnRoache-y9n]

That lady walked into the Court grinning from ear to ear and Judge Judy wiped the smile off her face 😂

[@brendashelton4400]

Why do I get so much pleasure out of this one LoL The plaintiff tho LMAO 🤣

[@DanZam9]

😂😂😂 Wtf was I watching a soap opera at the end.

[@VI.VIII.V]

2:19 LMAOOOO the woman in blue is like "Really ?"

[@SupaEMT134]

Honestly, I'd like to date the Defendant

[@JKahil]

Good Lord she's hot!

[@SupaEMT134]

Ricardo AssLips - she's not only smokin', (while I know it's just her nervousness on TV) her smile is bright and *_genuine_*

[@KimidoriGreen]

SupaEMT134 doood

[@01denese]

She looks like Kate Hudson or Kate Moss.

[@johnj2854]

01denese my thoughts exactly!

[@dkhgr]

Honestly, the lady who won the case is a queen and she doesnt even realize it. I stan.

[@DragonPrincessAoife]

This is the funniest and best case she’s ever done.

[@louseveryann2181]

That's it. I'm going to steal a car and then sue the owner for keeping their car in my garage...

[@voiceofraisin241]

While it’s there could you change the oil for me?

[@LouisianaCityboi]

The defendant looks AMAZED to have won her case. And the shock on the plantiff's face makes me wonder if Judge Judy didn't hear something important.

[@carolinefawcett4237]

LAdwv7495 Judge Judy missed a lot that was important. You are one of the few intuitive enough to figure that out.

[@bert1029]

+Margot Corden What did she miss?

[@carolinefawcett4237]

bert1029 Better yet, what didn't she miss. Send me a pm and I will direct you to a fraction of what happened.

[@kgrkid]

@Anthony Guarino the "brain is backwards" part would require for her to have a brain to begin with

[@carolinefawcett4237]

Ok, yes you're all correct, I am crazy and there are good reasons that I am the way I am, I challenge every single one of you to stay sane and stay alive after all I have been through, and what I am going to share is just the tip of the iceberg. 34 years ago, next week I lost my 11hour old daughter as a result of a horrible medical mistake. One simple medical test and one dose of antibiotics would have saved her life, just try to live with that reality. 4.5 years later on Christmas Eve, her father/my husband announced to me that he did not love me, that he had never loved me and that he had only married me to get away from his parents. In the meantime he was also telling good friends of mine terrible lies about me and turned them against me, and later he also told my three children lies about me and succeeded in poisoning them against me to the point where I have lost the love of one of them and with her three grandchildren, try to live with that reality as well. I was dealing with the anger of that one daughter and the parental alienation at the time that Summer took advantage of me, she sent me a horse that she said was top show quality, but instead he had very crooked legs and was unable to perform the tasks I had told her I wanted him for. Legally I had the right to send him back because she had committed fraud, but she refused to take him back and made threats and told more lies. She lied over and over again not only to me, but to the mediator and to the staff at the Judge Judy show. Then the producers lied to me and told me that Judge Judy would take the time to question me and listen to my evidence. My evidence was totally solid, I had done my homework. So, when I had my breakdown and was sitting there saying "Not again" it was because I was faced with the fact that I had been lied too again. So go ahead and have your laughs and think I am crazy, just know that you are doing it at the expense of a mother who has been to hell and back and was taken advantage and lied to by Summer Ruegger and the producers at the Judge Judy show.

[@11Garrett11]

This episode is so great - the plaintiff was so cocky in the beginning and to see her get smacked down that quick & that hard...what a thing of beauty!! GO JJ GO!!!

[@carolinefawcett4237]

Ok, yes you're all correct, I am crazy and there are good reasons that I am the way I am, I challenge every single one of you to stay sane and stay alive after all I have been through, and what I am going to share is just the tip of the iceberg. 34 years ago, next week I lost my 11hour old daughter as a result of a horrible medical mistake. One simple medical test and one dose of antibiotics would have saved her life, just try to live with that reality. 4.5 years later on Christmas Eve, her father/my husband announced to me that he did not love me, that he had never loved me and that he had only married me to get away from his parents. In the meantime he was also telling good friends of mine terrible lies about me and turned them against me, and later he also told my three children lies about me and succeeded in poisoning them against me to the point where I have lost the love of one of them and with her three grandchildren, try to live with that reality as well. I was dealing with the anger of that one daughter and the parental alienation at the time that Summer took advantage of me, she sent me a horse that she said was top show quality, but instead he had very crooked legs and was unable to perform the tasks I had told her I wanted him for. Legally I had the right to send him back because she had committed fraud, but she refused to take him back and made threats and told more lies. She lied over and over again not only to me, but to the mediator and to the staff at the Judge Judy show. Then the producers lied to me and told me that Judge Judy would take the time to question me and listen to my evidence. My evidence was totally solid, I had done my homework. So, when I had my breakdown and was sitting there saying "Not again" it was because I was faced with the fact that I had been lied too again. So go ahead and have your laughs and think I am crazy, just know that you are doing it at the expense of a mother who has been to hell and back and was taken advantage and lied to by Summer Ruegger and the producers at the Judge Judy show.

[@ericnelson9100]

I hope a model agency scout is watching this....the defendant is a knockout, those exquisite cheekbones and that beautiful long hair!

[@johnfellows2867]

she's gorgeous !

[@FK-mx8hy]

I just realised “judgement of the counter claim” HAHAHAHA the dramatic lady was the one doing the suing when she owed the money 😂😂😂😂

[@PieALaMode]

people who smile that much scare me...

[@eny4life718]

trueman mann 😆😆😆😆😆

[@HisSnuggleBear18]

I found this through the defendant's Facebook page. The plaintiff is known for doing this type of stuff, taking horses and not paying for them fully, and then turning around and trying to sell the horse (through her trainer) to kill buyers.

[@ashleywiley3523]

Same. I just wanted to see the full video

[@carolinefawcett4237]

Total lie. That horse was fully paid for. He was not a good fit for me. So since he had been bounced from home to home I I gave him to the trainer so he could stay at the same barn. He threw her, she got angry and made an empty threat that she was going to send him to a kill buyer. I took horse back and sent him back to his original breeder.

[@ashleywiley3523]

@@carolinefawcett4237 stfu you literally admitted that you did not pay the full price of the horse on the show. How are you gonna sit here and lie when you admitted it already?😂

[@GunguyGib]

Funny. You went on tv and were made to look foolish for fame. Live with the bad choice.

[@spicediggetydawg]

If the horse was defective and abused as you claim in these comments, why weren’t you suing for the horse’s vet bills?

[@priscamolotsi]

Plaintiff is a drama queen galore!

[@facedownchuck]

This is my favorite Judge Judy case of all time.

[@deelightfool]

my favorite was when the defendant shit the couch and blamed the dog.

[@kickinitsportstalk9485]

The moral of this story is, make sure your case is not being heard right before JJ's lunch time because hunger doesn't wait.

[@shanikaayanna9767]

Why would you ever bring someone to court when you didn’t even pay them the cost of what they sold you? 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@risenfallacy3197]

Paused and read the document. Basically her written statement of what occurred. The lady agreed to start paying in Jan. In Feb she said the horse is defective take it back instead of paying. In March the defendant came to pick up the animal and the old lady relocated the horse. Said the defendant abandoned the animal on her property and she wouldn't return it until the costs of its upkeep/food was repaid. So judge Judy figured out this was poor terminology for a payment plan, not lease to own. This old lady tried to steal a horse for a hundred bucks and was dumb enough to go to court about it. So judge says you aren't getting any money for that. Old lady is thinking well I still have the horse so HA! Have fun finding it. Or thinking "There is no horse to return so I win." Judge Judy makes it simple. Instead of going through the power struggle of obtaining a horse the seller didn't want back in the first place. Keep the horse, pay the rest of the money. DONE. You can't prove the animals defective anyways. You wouldn't let anyone see it. Old lady must have thought there'd be some bargaining or something for the return of the horse.... Honestly given the claim of defective, and never found again. Tells me it died. So she was probably hoping to have the last laugh with that info drop, and JJ saw it coming. Animal welfare was contacted after so many months and they could not find the horse. So it's a good bet this horse died cuz of whatever reason. She didn't lease to own. She bought it on a 15 month payment plan. The horse died. The debt is still owed. Kinda like when you make payments on a car and it just blows out and stops working. You still owe the cost you agreed to at the beginning. The horse being taken back was a FAVOR by the seller, to protect their reputation as a horse breeder/seller. They came to pick up the defective animal, but couldn't find a horse to bring back. But we're told you can have the horse after you pay our stable fees you never agreed to. Until then we won't tell you where it is. Pay the seller the amount of the horse. No one cares what you did with it. You bought it. It's yours. You can't begin to blame the seller for a defective animal you refused them from seeing. Imagine buying a car on a payment plan, hiding the car in another state. Then telling the bank they can have the car back once they pay parking/storage fees... That's what this old bitter woman tried to do to get out of the fact she either stole or killed a horse and didn't want to pay for it. JJ protected the defendants reputation by not getting into all the BS of what's going to end up being about a dead horse.

[@yohannah3316]

I know you said you paused and read the documents, but where from? Do you have a link to this info? I would really like to read it.

[@risenfallacy3197]

@@yohannah3316 play the video and pause it when you see the document and you can read it.

[@kennynguyen6810]

Sorry, not going to read the document. I do thank you for summarizing it though. I’ve always wondered what happened.

[@NewRedYolk]

Give that woman an Oscar, I haven't seen a performance that dramatic in years!

[@MrMousley]

I do love it when the defendant wins .. and has their counter claim granted.

[@michaelshannon6134]

2:20 I love how she's glancing over at the lady having a panic attack while she's trying to talk.

[@mattandrews3874]

That's my reaction when I turn on Judge Judy and it's a rerun

[@monicabellu9566]

"No, not again" AGAIN!?

[@wilrobles5392]

The plaintiff needs a safe place, a therapist, and a participation trophy.

[@33married]

She was smiling until that verdict!🤣

[@SuperKrock5]

The plaintiff thought she was winning at first hahah

[@PhillipE1210]

her grin at the beginning and then her shock when she lost so fast 😂

[@StarAnnasDream]

FUNNIEST Reaction EVER! :-) :-)...especially since she was so cocky coming in

[@monica012077]

It's the audiences faces that does it for me when she starts freaking out.

[@mikeklug3369]

That acting in the end. Omg. I can't do this🤣😁🤣😁🤣

[@mazchevalier9890]

The plaintiff walked in smiling thinking "I am gonna make a few thousand bucks, yay..such a wonderful day" Lol

[@rocketrodlover]

What a drama queen!

[@ajfoodiesaiyan]

How the plaintiff chirpily responds with “Okay” when she is told by JJ she’s not getting any money yet has a drama attack after is laughable. How she thought she’d get any money out of this is crazy - said she was given a defective horse and just stood there quietly without trying to defend her “case”. It’s so obvious from early on that she had no case anyway, especially when she says “It was a lease to own purchase” yet didn’t say anything about the horse being “defective”. Lease to own = contract to pay resulting in ownership. Pay. Oh no I have to pay I should have a drama attack and maybe the judge will feel sorry for me and I won’t have to pay. Snooze. 😂

[@gabriellebuie5788]

My guess is her money situation is tight. Not getting the money from the defendant just keeps in the same situation. Being forced to pay the defendant 1400 makes her situation worse

[@victorfullwood689]

@@gabriellebuie5788 then why buy a horse if u ain’t got it like dat she put herself in that position

[@carolinefawcett4237]

@@gabriellebuie5788 nope, wrong answer, it had nothing to do with money being tight. It has to do with having dealt with a woman who kept lying and changing her story, who perjured herself on legal court documents, who filed fraudulent theft and smuggling reports to Canada Customs when I was helping a friend legally get her brown and white pinto (not a nearly solid chestnut) home to her in Canada. Someone who filed in the wrong jurisdiction and wrong state and then argued with the judge that she was right and the judge was wrong, until the judge blew up, yelled at her and slammed a huge book on her desk. So if she can cause a judge to loose it within just a few minutes, imagine what dealing with her craziness for over a year did to me.

[@carolinefawcett4237]

@mcchickenz best go back and read my comments. I did not screw her out of any money. She broke the contract, she refused to take the horse back or come and get him. She lied over and over again. She may be beautiful, but she is as deceitful as they come.

[@ZanDuz]

​@@carolinefawcett4237i do not know the right story but i follow through about what youre fighting for, I hope youre okay and these people never look for the other perspective, never let them get to you. Remember that these shows are very predatory for content and hope you find the justice for what youre fighting for, caroline. Peace and love for you and your family.

[@philb4253]

2:11 The thrill of victory 2:19 The agony of defeat

[@11Garrett11]

This is one of my favorite cases because of how smug/clueless the plaintive looked & how quickly she got smacked down - such a beautiful thing!!! LOLOL

[@DiscoveryNewsNow]

Awesomeness, I love judge Judy. I wish all judges were like her. The criminal courts would be fixed in a week.

[@68corvette08]

The Defendant proudly leaving while the Plaintiff sits there and hyperventilating over losing her case while the audience watches her sulk in her embarrassment is priceless.

[@ghostenchanter]

At 2:20 the reaction from the people in the crowd is priceless

[@firefly-fu3ce]

Why are they so happy walking in!! shes being sued 😂

[@cayv7694]

because she's probably thinking 1. the lawsuit by the plaintiff was ridiculous 2. she will win this nonsense lawsuit 3. she can finally get back the $1400 the plaintiff owed her

[@CyborgNinja7]

They're each getting $5000 I believe no matter what the outcome. At least that's what I've heard on KZbin.

[@shaserdeses]

CyborgNinja7 $5000 is actually the max that the plaintiff can sue for against the defendant. No matter the outcome of each case the defendant doesn't owe the plaintiff, cbs foots the bill just for being on the show. Notice the people who mostly get upset after losing the case are actually the plaintiffs because the don't get there money.

[@DD-d6d3]

CyborgNinja7 they get $300 for appearing

[@ahzar4384]

5000 for what

[@MarilyncarolCornell]

She's so happy when she came in

[@seattlevixen]

I love how happy the plaintiff looks being sworn while I know what the result is gonna be. It literally cracks me up.

[@carolinefawcett4237]

Ok, yes you're all correct, I am crazy and there are good reasons that I am the way I am, I challenge every single one of you to stay sane and stay alive after all I have been through, and what I am going to share is just the tip of the iceberg. 34 years ago, next week I lost my 11hour old daughter as a result of a horrible medical mistake. One simple medical test and one dose of antibiotics would have saved her life, just try to live with that reality. 4.5 years later on Christmas Eve, her father/my husband announced to me that he did not love me, that he had never loved me and that he had only married me to get away from his parents. In the meantime he was also telling good friends of mine terrible lies about me and turned them against me, and later he also told my three children lies about me and succeeded in poisoning them against me to the point where I have lost the love of one of them and with her three grandchildren, try to live with that reality as well. I was dealing with the anger of that one daughter and the parental alienation at the time that Summer took advantage of me, she sent me a horse that she said was top show quality, but instead he had very crooked legs and was unable to perform the tasks I had told her I wanted him for. Legally I had the right to send him back because she had committed fraud, but she refused to take him back and made threats and told more lies. She lied over and over again not only to me, but to the mediator and to the staff at the Judge Judy show. Then the producers lied to me and told me that Judge Judy would take the time to question me and listen to my evidence. My evidence was totally solid, I had done my homework. So, when I had my breakdown and was sitting there saying "Not again" it was because I was faced with the fact that I had been lied too again. So go ahead and have your laughs and think I am crazy, just know that you are doing it at the expense of a mother who has been to hell and back and was taken advantage and lied to by Summer Ruegger and the producers at the Judge Judy show.

[@seattlevixen]

@@carolinefawcett4237 just gonna copy and paste this on every comment?

[@carolinefawcett4237]

@@seattlevixengo ahead, that will reflect on the kind of person you are.

[@tirannlaws8311]

That's the biggest over reaction I've seen yet she must have been desperate for that money lol

[@carolinefawcett4237]

Or upset that an animal abuser, liar and scam artist was rewarded for using an innocent animal to cheat someone and would probably do it again.

[@TheGreekPianist]

The woman was all smily in the beginning and then she was going to have a panic attack in the end 😂

[@kyle30710]

Some people are confused, the case came down to lease and purchase........it was a sale, lady made 1 payment and owes 14 more payments.

[@carolinefawcett4237]

Nope, it was a lease. Get over it.

[@briannawilliams5805]

Um... but that's how a lease works. You make payments, and you didn't. GeT oVeR iT 😂

[@eshnz506]

THE PEOPLE'S FACES IN THE BACK WHEN HER DRAMA SCENE STARTS!!!

[@baldman54]

man that reaction is THEEEEEEEE funniest thing ever hahahahaha

[@siregallahad317]

She wanted a horse, but not pay for anything it needed? That's like leasing a car and expecting the dealership to pay for the gas, insurance, maintenance etc. 🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️

[@BD-il7is]

She tried to steal $2700 and in the end she was forced to pay back the $1400 she stole - PRICELESS!

[@kevinflores259]

And the Oscar goes too: The Plaintiff for best dramatic reaction (applause)👏🏼👏🏼

[@billyboy321]

You’d think she’d been sentenced to time in a maximum security penitentiary or something 😅. She was only asked to pay what she was owed 😅

[@sothathappened]

i can watch that defendant reaction again and again! hilarious

[@b6_ruby]

Never seen Judy rule for the defendant's counterclaim ever.

[@mothra__13]

it happens. just not very often

[@musicaleclecto]

you should see the case of the plaintiff who tried suing a defendant for the cost of her son's medical bills because of a car crash that the defendant's daughter died in. that is a much more epic counterclaim win than this although this was entertaining to watch. that and well... Summer is gorgeous.

[@TheReaper13g]

Well, technically she didn't. The defendant wanted 1900$ in return, but only got the agreed upon amount.

[@acrovader]

The defendant is cute.

[@death3554]

I'm sure the plaintiff was 100% sure that she was going to win😂😂

[@joshuawhite7239]

She says "NOT AGAIN" 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@julia.c.mcclure92]

That lady walked in so happy lol

[@SnowPink90]

I love how Summer/Sommer reacted to her win!!😂😂👏🏻 The show pays for the one who won the case anyways so Pinky doesn’t have to be so dramatic.

[@carolinefawcett4237]

Ok, yes you're all correct, I am crazy and there are good reasons that I am the way I am, I challenge every single one of you to stay sane and stay alive after all I have been through, and what I am going to share is just the tip of the iceberg. 34 years ago, next week I lost my 11hour old daughter as a result of a horrible medical mistake. One simple medical test and one dose of antibiotics would have saved her life, just try to live with that reality. 4.5 years later on Christmas Eve, her father/my husband announced to me that he did not love me, that he had never loved me and that he had only married me to get away from his parents. In the meantime he was also telling good friends of mine terrible lies about me and turned them against me, and later he also told my three children lies about me and succeeded in poisoning them against me to the point where I have lost the love of one of them and with her three grandchildren, try to live with that reality as well. I was dealing with the anger of that one daughter and the parental alienation at the time that Summer took advantage of me, she sent me a horse that she said was top show quality, but instead he had very crooked legs and was unable to perform the tasks I had told her I wanted him for. Legally I had the right to send him back because she had committed fraud, but she refused to take him back and made threats and told more lies. She lied over and over again not only to me, but to the mediator and to the staff at the Judge Judy show. Then the producers lied to me and told me that Judge Judy would take the time to question me and listen to my evidence. My evidence was totally solid, I had done my homework. So, when I had my breakdown and was sitting there saying "Not again" it was because I was faced with the fact that I had been lied too again. So go ahead and have your laughs and think I am crazy, just know that you are doing it at the expense of a mother who has been to hell and back and was taken advantage and lied to by Summer Ruegger and the producers at the Judge Judy show.

[@DSchae2165]

Judy wanted her lunch, damn it. "Let's get this done. I'm outta here."

[@rickyricardo4331]

When JJ says "Stop playing with me and mentions lunch," you've already lost, it's just a matter of how bad.

[@MrAZIZ106]

the defendant looks so kind and attractive with a lovely smile :))

[@ebonyabernethy6308]

It's the theatrics for me 😂😂😂😂