Nightmare Cruise

The plaintiff says he used to date the defendant. He claims while they were on a cruise, she attacked him and stole his wallet. He’s suing for emotional distress and breach of contract. The defendant says the plaintiff has a criminal history of violence against women. She’s countersuing for pain and suffering and emotional distress. #JudgeMathis #RealityTV #Court

[@quayjackson5241]

I knew this was gone be a long one when the “I prayed for this moment” started😂😂😂😂

[@latoyafisher7900]

LOL

[@anthonyhale5237]

When they start with I prayed I said here we go. !!!!!!! Now he sanctified. !!!!! Watch them church people who start with God as a shield. !!!!!!

[@darylmartin6989]

😂😂😂

[@darylmartin6989]

I’m not stuck around for this nonsense

[@SummerYelloww]

Lmaoooo

[@ChicagoGuy72]

Shouldn’t he have a suit to wear since he’s been in court multiple times for beating on women? 🙄

[@mzfancy4767]

Hush 🤣

[@waldolydecker8118]

He musta thought his "lawsuit" was enough

[@streetsofgold4310]

😂😂😂😂

[@ViveLaIsrael]

He comfortable. Feels right at home.

[@Aumunique_92]

Or a shirt with a collar at least....

[@QUiNTiNBANKS]

If you’re reading this I wish nothing but wealth and health all 2022

[@mabelpentil5056]

Amen

[@nowyukno7981]

Same to you

[@candyjones6800]

AND TO YOU AS WELL 🙏🏽

[@leir2005]

This guy posts this on every Judge Mathis video. Why do you all keep falling for it? He's not even a real person

[@giveback]

@@leir2005 😂😂😂😂😂

[@gracej384]

2 things judge Mathis can’t stand: an addict who won’t get help and a woman beater

[@marvellaharbin877]

And people That don't pay child support

[@larissamccord4968]

@@marvellaharbin877 I swear I was just about to say that too!!!!!

[@larissamccord4968]

And i knew he wasn't gonna get his judgement right when she came with the evidence of his background

[@jazzydarling7218]

Man beater

[@cnickyxoxo193]

And a deadbeat

[@terry4161]

How you come to court with a purple t shirt lol

[@Cookiemom675]

I was like he wearing a champion tee to court 🙄

[@scottrogue946]

Looking like Grimace 🍔 🍟

[@mzfancy4767]

And I figured even a QDog would own a suit. 🤣

[@bryanjohnson8982]

😂😂

[@kg1521]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@ISayToMyself]

I knew something was up when he first started talking religion and dropping names of pastors and things. I was like “wait for it…” but I really didn’t expect the rap sheet. Somethings wrong with this man. Thank God you didn’t marry him, lady.

[@lovemii3kids]

Maybe he is on the straight n narrow now

[@jesusisgod4992]

That is one of the amazing things God does is heal the broken!

[@carriepriegel6477]

Exactly. NPD feel superior to us mortals and only have themselves fooled 🙄

[@carriepriegel6477]

@@lovemii3kids I'll go to Vegas and wager on that 😃 no, guaranteed he's not because narcs do not change because they don't feel they need to change. Period.

[@carriepriegel6477]

@@jesusisgod4992 agree with God as Healer 👍💗 but we have to accept responsibility for our actions, sins, failings and repent, then God starts a new work and we become new creations in Christ

[@cheyennebanks2308]

Imagine taking someone to court for $5000, then losing and owing them $5000 LMAO

[@conniemoore4801]

🤣🤣🤣🤣 the laughing emojis are a sign that I didn't expect it!!

[@latarareed7321]

MANNN THE BADDEST DAY EVER

[@shalanathomas7751]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@boobear9488]

It’s always the ones that start off giving props to the judge lol

[@maxxpopp2373]

@@boobear9488 right, then throwed popular tv preachers in it like they were his friends 😂😂😂

[@NubianP6]

This was like pulling horse teeth. 🤦🏽‍♀️ Between JM interjecting, and the plaintiff dragging his tongue, seems like it took *FOREVER* to get even the most basic facts. 😩

[@liljerry496]

Rt …. JM need to chill with that 🤯… that’s a sure sign he’s getting up in age 👍🏿

[@amandaz9762]

You're not lying. This one took forever lol

[@stephaniejohnson5809]

He was trying desperately to make those kids believable, hence the dragging of his testimony. He appears to be slow. I have no idea what she seen in him to want to pull up and leave to relocate.She seems too classy of a lady to downgrade to him. They looked so uncompa bible standing in the c ourtroom. I am so glad Judge Mathis ruled in her favor.

[@linneastokes1289]

Facts! I should've known when the vid said 22 minutes lol

[@arlenesmith7366]

I'm DWL 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@slowjamsam]

Chiiillleee...aint no way he's watching allllll that church and show up to court in a purple tall tee 🤔🙄😐

[@DominiqueWFabulouslySmart]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 thats most definitely a tall tee

[@larissamccord4968]

Say that again 🗣💯🗣💯🗣

[@cameronweekley8973]

🤣

[@leahmiller6890]

so who care what he got on why do bp always worry about what the next got on ur not paying his bills smh 2021 bp still think looks and materials make u wonder why bp forever at the bottom worried about the wrong things

[@stizzthadrifter7608]

😂😂😂

[@cthegoddess6968]

Uprooting your life to go live with and depend on a man you only knew for a month? 🚩They both made bad decisions tho smh

[@Mr.Boring_Man]

Facts!

[@sweetsweet81]

That's the truth!

[@larissamccord4968]

I was thinking the same thing 🤦‍♀️ SMDH

[@MrsJones-oj3cp]

Exactly! I think she was already in a bad situation and probably desperate. Thank God things ended quickly being in that situation is no bueno and hard to get out if you’re depending on someone.

[@cthegoddess6968]

@@MrsJones-oj3cp right, she moved way too fast.

[@jilldambrosio4273]

RED FLAG. His first words were on religion and pastors. Immediately I knew something was wrong

[@everybodyistrash]

The case ain’t even start and I’m already looking at dude like 🤦🏾‍♂️

[@leyahruizdeloreto6420]

This man just doesn't look, or come across as intelligent at all.

[@drewoke2584]

Facts … he seems slow and stupid .

[@5822huron]

I agree

[@dr.a2160]

Yes too much weed through the years or maybe just intellectually disabled

[@victoriamiller7738]

How does he accuse her of stealing his wallet when his cards were being used in Miami while they were on a greyhound bus from Vegas? He lost his wallet of his own accord and wanted somebody to blame. 😩

[@Arron413]

He said she was lying. No one was using his cards in Miami. She said that, not him.

[@shelocsher2396]

Exactly he made no sense. She had to borrow the $ to get the tickets home. What would be the point of stealing from him and being stranded?

[@MrsJones-oj3cp]

Greyhound bus from the Cruise. Vegas was a whole nother trip as he clarified.

[@desmondmitchell3177]

When he read those criminal charges out you saw the look of a narcissist psycho being EXPOSED

[@ELl_e..3]

Why did this man come to court looking like when you get sick on yourself on a road trip and your mom has to put you in whatever clean t -shirt she can find out the back?

[@carolinemagee8033]

The defendant was looking so proud while listening to JM read the charges out loud. If burst with joy was a person.

[@rondaallen7211]

however she didn't prove he beat her.

[@carolinemagee8033]

@@rondaallen7211 I didn't say anything was proved or not. I described her "look" as I saw it.

[@K_Cole0128]

😂😂🤣😂. She acted like she had a hand full of draw 4s in a game on uno while to plaintiff gave his version of events. She did not interrupt or anything 😂😂🤣

[@NaomiIsSoAwesome98]

@@rondaallen7211 patterns don't lie..

[@rondaallen7211]

@@NaomiIsSoAwesome98 but plaintiffs do. all the time

[@giveback]

Why would you be with someone you don't trust? 🙄🤦

[@khrisi9410]

She relied on him financially so it wouldn't benefit her to steal from him and force them to go through a whole bunch of changes and unknowns after the trip. I believe her when she said the stranger couple on the cruise he was hanging with marked him. Should've left his wallet in a safety deposit box and carried his ID and one credit card with him.

[@brixxaries6667]

He told her that things weren’t working out so when he left In the heat of the moment she took an opportunity to steal from him. Tht was pretty obvious especially since he broke up with her during the trip

[@lilliana1605]

@@brixxaries6667 a thief wouldn't pay for a plane ride and Uber back home. Makes no sense. She could've just bailed out I think this man is just paranoid.

[@gazastripmad]

@@lilliana1605 you werent there a theif is a theif most theives are just theives

[@gazastripmad]

@@brixxaries6667 facts

[@Mrbiscuit70]

@@gazastripmad Neither were you. Just saying

[@susielow7563]

When she brought up the domestic violence he knew it was over🤦🏽‍♀️

[@bepos1luvok989]

Back at cha🧐

[@rubyjaez]

Crazy thing is she never said he put hands on her and the police reports she had were from his past with women that have nothing to do with the case. Smh

[@millionairesdream9106]

​@rubyjaez Thank you! Judge is a simp. That had nothing to do with the case.

[@PrincessZaire100]

@@rubyjaezthat proves it to be a pattern of behavior

[@QUiNTiNBANKS]

Hard to trust people these days

[@beverlyhall4578]

All days. People are money hungry.

[@coco_poppinjewels1323]

He could've at least wore his Sunday suit 😒😒

[@Rosebud331]

He doesn’t seem right in the head. . . And I don’t know her deal but she knows how to present herself in court lol

[@Gratefulness7725]

FACTS

[@ciarraleone2040]

Women like this are the worst!

[@veronicamoody3981]

Yes, she does present herself well, but something about her rings false.

[@Gratefulness7725]

@@veronicamoody3981 good look 👌🏾

[@KahaliaC]

@@veronicamoody3981 I feel she did what he said but he cant bring his self across properly and judge was biased

[@authorlydiagreen1862]

From the top he tried to act like he was an innocent person talking about church well you know the devil goes to church too

[@jojoagogo912]

And can disguise himself as an angel. Smh

[@authorlydiagreen1862]

@@jojoagogo912 exactly

[@arlenesmith7366]

I know right a lot of people use the church for a cover-up, it's called the church umbrella

[@leahmoonbeamflower333]

I don’t understand how people who brag about going to church don’t see that everyone knows that that’s just a mask they wear to pretend to be be a good person. Church people be some of the most evil, judging bitches, perverts, etc EVER.

[@whinnie7529]

@@leahmoonbeamflower333 Some of them are the worst aren't they

[@scottrogue946]

He has that Ike Turner “If you miss a step, it’s your ass Anna Mae” voice 🎤 😂

[@Ash-ol3ji]

The accuracy of this comment though🤣😂

[@larissamccord4968]

💯🤣💯🤣💯🤣💯🤣💯

[@2008akir]

😂😂😂

[@kymkym3347]

I can not 😂🤣😂🤣 with you sir 😂🤣😂🤣😂

[@annlong548]

☠️💀☠️💀

[@Felicia_The_Creative]

Ladies, always have your own.

[@RobbinLynn-lh9ie]

Oh my goodness please say it louder for the women in back!

[@joviamckibben6030]

Is it me or did anybody else’s IQ drop a few points while listening to this case? I mean it took forever to get to the dam point 🤦🏽‍♀️

[@phillysimpson7341]

💯

[@ariamarshall5161]

22 of the longest mins EVER!!!!! I was like damn Sir. What is it that u trying to sue for.

[@irenesawyerr3246]

Once they start talking all righteous, just know they are only trying to cover something up. He looks and acts real slow. Dunno what you saw in him ma'am.

[@sabrinakeys250]

Alcoholism possibly

[@malachithegreat3889]

We dont know this man full story. Judge was clownin this man. Unfair biased judgement

[@viewmaster617]

"I hope you got a video showing this woman going in your piggy bank" when judge Mathis said that I spit out my drink 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@KaiserShield]

Could they tell these people to stop praising Mathis, and their love for the show, or maybe just edit that crap out? It's a huge waste of time, redundant and nobody cares.

[@shelocsher2396]

Thank u 🙄

[@kg1521]

😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@bethehype5339]

Cause all it does it blows his title pea brain up

[@lm406]

Judge Marhis, I believe him, she didnt have any problem marrying him. Something not right with that woman.

[@virgo7956]

💯

[@bresams2917]

Facts 💯

[@tommyyguunn6984]

I literally don't understand what his past conviction had to do with that case

[@Belle2oo8]

He tried to paint himself that he was holier than thou and present her like she was the most evil person ever

[@mmsmart1014]

Me too. We all do things that is not nice but we can change. I believe is because he claim to be a bishop but is not living the role of one. 1 Timothy 3:2

[@lavinder11]

A testament to his character.

[@FinDom1]

Those charges weren’t that old

[@freelikeyve]

He has a pattern of victimizing women you moron. Using em beating em lying on em

[@cynthiaquansah2969]

I’m like 12mins gone and the judge stay bullying this fellow 🤦🏾‍♀️ let me watch till the end.

[@MyThoughtzAndOpinionz]

I wonder if he’s an alcoholic

[@shelocsher2396]

He seems like a drunk to me too

[@Ash-ol3ji]

"I'm much too flawed to be a pastor"? Your Honor, we are ALL flawed! Religious does not mean perfect.

[@MsBdoll87]

Thank you! 7 Day Adventist have really strict rules. I’ve heard other members of their church speak in a not good enough way

[@j.dillonthescene]

I agree none of us are perfect but I'm sure judge Mathis know if you're not called according to his word then you shouldn't be a pastor at least he was honest a lot of these pastors want your money to go buy Jets live a good lifestyle some of them have boyfriends feeding them grapes on yachts that you pay for it's a mess they don't care about your soul they just care about you making them rich

[@jilllowman9848]

Even all pastors are flawed.

[@johnquirk4896]

Pastors are the most crooked bunch ever. Taking money from the vulnerable on a fake promise is as low as it gets.

[@Alex-sq3kp]

@@johnquirk4896 facts

[@jusmejaussyb8237]

Maam did you do your research on these “batteries” before you moved down there in less than a month? JM gets on my nerves

[@Ash-ol3ji]

That part!

[@bethehype5339]

He is annoying

[@mrsgrier8034]

she should of did that background check before she jumped and moved in a man you met 5 minutes ago.

[@scottgilliam8185]

Yeah she wanted his money she too pretty for him homeboy really came to TV Court wearing outstretched T-shirt she was scheming on him🤦🏾‍♂️

[@deejai1173]

Right… I thought my eyes were deceiving me, looking at that T-shirt…

[@scottgilliam8185]

@@deejai1173 it was the first thing I noticed when he walked in🤦🏾‍♂️

[@Queenprissy814]

Am I the only person that feels like JM Doesn’t read the cases before hearing them 😭😭

[@shelocsher2396]

He’s not too bright

[@alvinallen6645]

I do agree you are right!!!!!!!

[@lm406]

He slow, I think thats why he has had so many issues with women, she ran game on him. He paid for both trips. She had to borrow money for the greyhound, what women doesnt have her own nowadays. She was trying to come up.

[@mjandarie]

I could tell that within the first few minutes

[@AmysExquisiteGifts]

Yeap

[@BlkOut305]

He’s as sharp as a butter knife.

[@Jesseleegrayson]

Honestly I like JM but sometimes his rulings are based off of personal feelings or opinions about certain things. He often ignores true justice after he hears something he doesn't like personally, mainly domestic violence, but truth be told those charges had nothing to do with that specific case.

[@virgo7956]

The defendant played the card to her advantage but she let him pay for things and laid up with him with hopes of marrying.

[@andrekelly3150]

I totally agree!!!!!

[@andrekelly3150]

She never said anything about him hitting her!

[@zip7751]

@@andrekelly3150 it’s edited, we haven’t seen the full case, so she could’ve brought it up … we don’t know

[@supermarioandfreddyfazbear9577]

Absolutely. JM was completely wrong and totally biased on this one.

[@tblaze7brown788]

Hmm, definitely bad decision making on both of them. He offered to relocate her in a short timeframe & she accepted w/o awareness & totally dependent on a stranger.😳

[@GIGI-hz7ps]

I knew something was up with this grown man showing up in court in a T-shirt. He seems a little slow which makes me look at her sideways. So quick to hookup with someone before vetting them

[@redeemfaith]

Did Judge Mathis call himself... "FAIR?" LOLOLOL. Emotional--YES. Fair is whole discussion.

[@redeemfaith]

😂😂😂 exactly

[@harmonie3997]

🤣🤣 Judge Mathis"AAHHAAHHAA you lost all yo money and had to take the bus back" 💀😂

[@sumaiyahsmith7813]

I know right!!! 😂

[@dianewhiteharden]

She used him he may not be too intelligent but he paid for her daughter's education and wasn't considered violent then she wanted him to take care of her when he didn't she got vengeful. Sometimes Judge Mathis is wrong in judgement in my opinion

[@teairathomas663]

I agree with you

[@uplift56]

BandWagon Judge basically.

[@brixxaries6667]

Exactly his past don’t have anything to do with who is now especially since he shared with her so The judge was definitely wrong

[@MzHershey_2]

I definitely agree!!!

[@sharoncarter4107]

She took his wallet ,she knows the game and she played it very well !!!!!!!

[@mlmlsmith2505]

Yes she should have done the background check before moving w him or going on a seven day cruise

[@cnickyxoxo193]

How many people u know does that especially now that their aren’t any small children around

[@kymkym3347]

@@cnickyxoxo193 Not that many… Let’s you know we all need to be more careful.

[@Klassicvibes1979]

She stole that wallet. She never finished the wallet story, she just instantly started saying things he did in his past. Just because he has a past doesn't give you the right to steal his stuff. It's the deflecting for me

[@taeburton41]

I agree

[@jadub320]

I agree but judge Mathis so mad at men that he’s blind

[@millionairesdream9106]

Yes she definitely stole. Judge is a big simp if he hears you did anything to his momma i mean women then he goes crazy.

[@movingforward789]

After the plaintiff’s first statement… I knew this one was going to be a doozy 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@jaydub4661]

He was getting ready to abuse and trap her. Be careful if someone wants to break you from your family, stability and be totally dependent on them. Its a SET UP! Glad she got away- he messed with the wrong one!

[@Foxx229]

Background checks before engagements…

[@fashionshowsdlh]

Help him Lord

[@Teyoncee]

The beginning took me out. I couldn’t even finish watching.

[@butyoucancallmesam]

Judge, now you know! You ain't always fair.

[@Proverbspsalms]

Right!!!!!?

[@justapettymess]

For real tho!

[@dancealicious]

Yes.

[@Proverbspsalms]

22 min long- I knew this was gonna be boring.

[@shelocsher2396]

😂😂

[@larissamccord4968]

Lmfaoooo 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 u silly

[@Proverbspsalms]

I’m back a month later and still can’t get past the first 5 minutes. I’m gone again. Gonna watch paint dry.

[@marcw1712]

He’s starting to joke around too much. The forceful side jokes make it awkward & cringe to watch.

[@brandonbroadus3319]

Agreed

[@WandaTaylor-u9r]

😂

[@Foodfightmike]

I just don't believe her.... She leaned in on old Mathis and his outdated mindsets

[@dancealicious]

Exactly.

[@mielissa100ify]

Damn this case could have been cut in half

[@urluvizmyluv1999]

They need to stop playing with the Lord. 😂😂😂💀

[@langeldvyne1126]

The plaintiff has issues but the woman ain't do him right

[@lm406]

Agreed, she suspect

[@missbeeline]

What does his past have to do with his claim that she hit him on that day? Nope. He wasnt lying. She stole his wallet and did exactly what that man said she did.

[@MsBdoll87]

I thought i was the only one who felt that way. She played judge mathis like a fiddle

[@virgo7956]

Exactly!! I'm not condoning his behavior beating women. Did he beat her? She couldn't wait to bring that up when asked about his wallet. He paid for the daughter's college too? Something off and yeah she played him

[@actualfactual1882]

I knew she did when she said this supposed couple had him marked....then she said she went somewhere else when he wanted to go hang with them....like if that's your man why would allow him to get got..she should've been around to make sure he was good 4eyes is better than 2 right

[@lavinder11]

Her claim was for emotional distress!

[@rubyjaez]

Nothing, and she never said he put hands on her either. Judge Mathis made that assumption on his own

[@pamelarhoad9689]

He looks like a drunk. She look like she like men that don't know what is going on.

[@perriredd615]

Agree

[@LuigiNotaro]

Is this the Judge Mathis show or the Pastor Mathis confessional?

[@supermarioandfreddyfazbear9577]

I know I get so tired of hearing JM stories, he always interrupts to tell about himself and no one really is interested anymore. After more than 20 years on air we have heard alllllll of his stories. I just fast forward until they get back to the case.

[@Talkthattawk]

it was when JM said Reverend it sent me lol

[@jaydendavis8751]

Take your case to normal court setting. This would not of happened in their local small claims court.

[@bethehype5339]

I believe she was stealing

[@brilliantlybritt1928]

The way he came dressed provided all the proof I needed that his was going to lose this case… fake prophet! 🙄

[@kermonwilliams2180]

She got flew'd out,lol

[@hellzel912]

Any man that comes to court, knowing he will be on national television, with a blank purple Champion tee is guilty off the muscle 😆😭

[@saywonap]

She FINESSE this guy 😂😂

[@uplift56]

Judge Mathis seems to have a drunken tendency to assume the story line of this man’s life 🤨. Discredit provokes confusion- smh.

[@chaundawalker6741]

He walked in the courtroom confused. I could see it in his eyes 👀. Common sence should have told him take the financial lost. The last place he needed to be was in court, ON TV. Now the nation knows his story, his rap sheet.😕

[@thexavierkingshow]

I can't believe that people cannot see that he is telling the truth. I don't know the situation with the women that he may have abused but in this situation he was definitely telling the truth. He is not very intellectual and has a hard time getting his point across. The defendant took advantage of that. This case had nothing to do about him physically abusing women, it had to do with his stolen wallet. Her reasoning for stealing the wallet is because he broke up with her and told her that they had to separate. I hate when Judge Mathis starts clowning someone in the beginning because it makes them automatically lose credibility.

[@ggboot1]

I don't believe that she stole his wallet. He believes that she stole his wallet, but I don't think that she actually stole it. I also don't believe that he battered her. She never once said that he did. She chose her words very carefully and I listened to everything she said. She wanted to punish him because they didn't get married. All she ever mentioned was money.

[@deangelabriggs6413]

@@ggboot1 she definitely stole the wallet lol she tried to blame a couple by painting this picture of him trusting a couple that marked him but how is them asking him if his gratuities were removed proof that he was marked by them??you don’t get cash for getting gratuities removed, they take it off of your final bill so it’s less you’ll have to pay at the end of the cruise but HOW could that couple rob him for that? She’s lying and she made up the “routine” they had with the couple.. notice he called her out on that lie BEFORE he/we knew she was going to say the couple that stole the wallet

[@bresams2917]

Right 💯 She stole that Man wallet but she get hers

[@malachithegreat3889]

Judge was on joke time.

[@Rosehybride]

She depended on him financially during that trip and it was a huge inconvenience for her to steal his wallet being that she became fully responsible for their safe return. I also find it hard to believe that she premeditatedly stole his wallet before him breaking things off with her lol.

[@venisemcclain1171]

No, he is slow. She took full advantage of him.

[@ShortNSweetTay]

When Judge Mathis be like, "We just having fun" but nobody laughing and everyone is kind of cringing ... 😬😬😬😬

[@the4cqueen148]

Plaintiff watches all of the phony televangelist's, poor unfortunate soul.

[@MemoryChronicles]

19:00 it’s all business when Judge takes off his glasses 😁 judge does not like women b3aters-at all!

[@sweetsweet81]

Judge Mathis schooled this man on the right way to pray....and the plaintiff blew right past it. Then, he schooled the defendant on the difference between consummate and fornicate. SMH

[@solascriptura2940]

You are completely right. Both of them got schooled but blew off the knowledge he was passing on.

[@malachithegreat3889]

Judge was clown in this one. Biased and unreasonably indifferent.

[@sweetsweet81]

@@malachithegreat3889 Hey... that's your opinion.

[@JGTVijep]

Dude is taking forever to get to the point.

[@plainjaneofalltrades3853]

She used him. 🤷🏽‍♀️ if he hit her, Why wouldn’t she file a report as opposed to printing out reports from the past? Definitely a fishy case.

[@reginaharrigan7454]

What his criminal pasts have to do with she stole his wallet and she a thief

[@jazzyblues773]

That shirt makes his body look womanly. Nothing wrong with that. He just needs to know how to dress especially when going to court.

[@Mirarashi]

😂😂😂

[@uniqueEnergy83]

😂😂😂😂 I couldn’t help it

[@ChangedUpNowWhat]

Only a few seconds in and the way the gentleman in the purple shirt is postured, I know this is gonna be lit 😂😂😂

[@yolandefrancis4547]

To be fair I'm not sure what his past behaviour with ex's has to do with his wallet getting stolen.

[@caramama1731]

Unpopular opinion. I agree she never said He hit her..

[@brixxaries6667]

Exactly especially since the judge has a past as well and he changed so this man can’t ?! Plus he helped her and her daughter

[@GiGi2O11]

Agreed. That was cold.

[@shortstackgames]

Her counter sue claimed that she underwent emotional distress because of him. A civil court judge's job is to determine what *more than likely* happened between the two parties, not prove it without a doubt. He ruled in favor of the defendant because 1) she had quite a lot of evidence against the plantiff for what she was claiming (emotional distress) and 2) The past charges of abuse were the nails in the coffin for the plantiff. The plantiff had almost no evidence of his claims, and it could be argued that him suing her was unneeded and was also a source of emotional distress. He didn't sue her for stealing, he sued her for abuse, which he had zero evidence of, while she had evidence of multiple situations that would've almost certainly cause her distress.

[@yolandefrancis4547]

@@brixxaries6667 Exactly

[@hondo597]

I'm not sure why she's bringing his past up. How that come into play with you stealing his money? Sounds like she's trying to take the pressure off herself. But you was dating him after he beat those women so...

[@moniquespight8667]

Right..EVERYBODY GOT A PAST..HE SHOULD'VE LOOKED HER COUNTRY A$$ UP..SHE PLAYED HIM GOOD!!!!AND WHILE JUDGE MATHIS TALKING ..WHAT IF WHEN HE WAS TRYNA GO TO COLLEGE..THEY SHOWED HIS REPETITIVE FOOLISHNESS..SMH😒😒😒

[@percyjackson5417]

What do you mean? Shes bringing up his past of domestic abuse because shes claiming she was abused by him as well. She was suing my for pain and suffering. So ofc shes gonna bring up his past cuz he has a pattern of beating on women. Did u even watch the whole thing??? And how was she suppose to know hes a woman beater untill after the fact??

[@percyjackson5417]

@@moniquespight8667 his past shows who he is as a person even to that day. He beats on women. Unacceptable and inexcusable

[@moniquespight8667]

@@percyjackson5417 BULLSHIT she would not have sued him if he didn't sue her...She used that against him...He left HER..you can tell she sneaky ..he probably shared some things with her and he used it against him .and all his charges weren't against women

[@moniquespight8667]

@@percyjackson5417 I agree to disagree..

[@yadirahadessahisrael3026]

Judge Mathis really disappointed me on this ruling. If he was such a woman beater, why did she move in with him and why did not move out after immediately finding out ... go stay in an abused womans shelter. Why didn't she call the police on him when he attacked her. She had every police report except her own. Judge completely ignored the fact that his credit card was used at the same greyhound station she purchased the tickets at. She never once told him to cancel the cards after she said the couple on the boat stole his wallet. She never suggested reporting it to security on the boat She will reap what she has sown

[@lavinder11]

She didn't say that he beat her

[@payton0427]

Ok I try to keep quiet on reruns.. but RECENT reruns is where I draw the line 😒 we JUST seen this

[@ojaym9769]

The judge is crazy in a good way.

[@claudendifon4289]

Just because he has a history of domestic violence doesn't mean that this woman could not have violated him

[@LilMissPretty06]

EXACTLY..

[@BSTVsports]

Thank you. I read this chick from the door. Dude is a grade A simp and judge Mathis is one too.

[@mashan1978]

8 different cases? I mean if it walks like a duck and talks like a duck. Come on. That grape drink t shirt said it all.

[@supermarioandfreddyfazbear9577]

Exactly. Judge Mathis always lets his deep disdain for someone's past interfere with the facts of the case. I thought he accused her of stealing his wallet? So what does his abusive past have to do with this exactly?

[@BSTVsports]

@@mashan1978 we are just bringing up fact in law. She never even accused him of assaulting her. She bought up his past after his accusations of her assaulting him.

[@JAM2USA2018]

Judge Mathis, you should be a stand up Comedian. You make me laugh and you brighten my day every time.

[@Headnotthetail2]

She most definitely stole that money

[@quetuc6023]

Why does he talk so slow

[@giveback]

💤💤💤💤💤

[@PillzBerry27]

She brought all the receipts on him!!! I give her props for that !!!🔥🔥🔥♥️💯✌🏿

[@judyjean9059]

Judge Mathis is the best judge.he,s so funny and fair.

[@waldolydecker8118]

That's no way to treat a "Reverend."

[@Ellebee1993]

The piercing under the lip lets you know she’s a freak 😂

[@MrsJones-oj3cp]

This case started out hilarious to me but that ending was something else. He’s real cool and calm which only lets me know if he did all those things on his record he’s probably a Sociopath. Literally praying for his healing and his victims. That wrap sheet was no joke! Even if it’s not true like he said. It’s still a lot of drama!!! And how is everyone lying on you? 🤔

[@chaundawalker6741]

Hehe 😀 oh my goodness

[@millionairesdream9106]

Could've been the same person🤷‍♂️ women lie because they know they will be believed before the man

[@jaydendavis8751]

She never accused him of battery/assault so why is JM using that against him in this case. I would understand if she did say or accuse him. JM had his mind made up on this case even before the past battery charges came up during the case. I love JM but he was definitely being biased on this one. Not saying plaintiff had enough evidence to win but she didn't deserve any money or a judgement.

[@bluerangerx11]

She did use that in her complaint in the beginning of the episode

[@sweetsweet81]

Her counter claim was specifically for that: pain and suffering and emotional abuse.

[@jaydendavis8751]

@@sweetsweet81 actually. Emotional distress. Not Emotional abuse. Pay attention...lol

[@jaydendavis8751]

Direct me to the part she said she was abused by him. I will wait

[@sweetsweet81]

@@jaydendavis8751 Sir, yes Sir! 🪖

[@aliciacarter2443]

She should have did that background check 1st

[@johnnyrobinson8168]

If his record was such an issue, then why was she so happy with moving in with him and taking all those trips he paid for? And why was that so important in this case? If he was so bad to her, am sure she would have had him arrested or something! His wallet being missing had nothing to do with his past record!

[@brininahoward5445]

Correct and if she had all this evidence before hand, why did she even give him a second look? And would even consider marriage?

[@LilMissPretty06]

I mean, its like one of those "I gotta see for myself" type of things... A charge is just that, and if a man an woman fight, or man defends himself against a woman during a fight he goes to jail (our current legal system 😪).. so she probably bought all of the BS he was telling her until time revealed the truth to her eyes.. she trusted him.. but As you can see in this case how he started off all God fearing, just to get to the ugly truth.. so don't blame the good hearted believer, blame to liar/manipulator..

[@zolo4209]

Probably found out later on

[@mlm1916]

I think she found out while preparing for this case. That's the research she should've done b4 relocating. ijs

[@mlm1916]

@@zolo4209 I think so.

[@karondalittlejohn]

SMH, praying he finds peace!

[@martinsocheje3260]

When you meet someone and his first introduction about himself is I am a pastor. Put your guard up, this is advice for you religious people and others too

[@deloresdavis5446]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@standmccray1037]

Dry begging