Shutter Island - MOVIE REACTION

[@peters4115]

Bravo to Hannah for figuring it out by the 2nd act, she truly is the world’s greatest detective

[@Shawn-st2lx]

When you take 45 guesses and spend most of the movie guessing, odds are you'll get something right. Even broken clocks are right twice a day.

[@ryanhighberg4662]

Watch sincerelyKSO if you want to find a detective when it comes to movie reactions. She is unbelievable

[@MrSirrygoose]

She made like two guesses prior to truly figuring it out. Y'all are really trying not to give her any credit for it 🤣

[@blunt2416]

I give her credit for it, but I noticed that she is the 3rd women I have seen figure this out fairly quickly Most women reacting to this will view it more as puzzle to solve. While men are side tracked by sympathizing with the lead character Leo. We are seeing the movie through the lead characters eyes. Women are just trying to solve the puzzle.

[@MrSirrygoose]

@@blunt2416 so instead of giving credit where credit is due, you decide to be sexist? What are you on about? Women view it as a puzzle and men sympathize with Leo? Are you braindead?

[@reecegraves3738]

Finally someone understands the last line, well done Ash.

[@milissapotter4473]

I know! I felt so relieved when he understood that last line.

[@stepanmakarov1842]

@@CrispyChips007 same thing, I didn't even knew all that time that i missed the ending totally

[@reecegraves3738]

@@CrispyChips007 idk how you couldn’t get it, the line makes it obvious in my opinion

[@ohaimark4180]

@@CrispyChips007 reece out here hating on people that arn't seeing from the same perspective as themselves

[@jordanzdebski5132]

why he refered to him as chuck at the end if he didnt regress

[@dlweiss]

A++ insight after she caught that disappearing glass! It's the first big moment that hints he's NOT seeing things entirely as they are, and she understood the implications of that shot immediately.

[@OBELISK3210]

When I first seen it I thought it was a bad film edit lol

[@Arthaius]

- To be honest, when I saw this, I thought that the woman, who was supposedly a patient in this institution, was hallucinating the glass of water, and that there wasn't one actually there, because from her viewpoint, you see the glass, but when you are watching her drink from supposedly someone elses viewpoint, there is no glass, so, yeah I suppose it could be interpreted a few ways, my impression was that she was hallucinating a glass that wasn't there, and he observed her drinking from an empty hand.

[@Arthaius]

@@CrispyChips007 - Ahh, but you have to wonder... are they really all laughing, or is his mind continuing to slip? A lot of people who are hallucinating often hallucinate images of people mocking, jeering & laughing, hallucinations of persecution, everyone out to get you, so... were they laughing, or was it all in his head? ;)

[@Arthaius]

@@CrispyChips007 - While potentially possible, one has to ask the question, even if they were all told to act and portray certain roles for this experiment, it does seem a little odd and senseless for them to pretend to have a glass of water when there wasn't one, I mean, they still could have played all their roles and acted accordingly, while just drinking water from a real glass, that part seems a little bit of an odd choice, I certainly wouldn't be like "We are trying to slowly dig him out of his delusion, bring him back to reality, so, while he is interviewing you, make sure to pretend to drink out of an invisible glass as if there was one there - that should help him regain a grasp of reality and break out of his delusions" - see.. I'm not buying that one personally :)

[@justtrustash]

That’s my girl!! 🥹

[@Arcotectx]

One of the greatest twist endings ever and is so rewarding on the second watch because you're able to catch all the little signs that something isnt quite right. Also the ending is so crazy to me. He didn't circle back to the routine of thinking he's a detective who needs to "get to the mainland". He's well aware and would rather die being in control, than to lose himself again.

[@justtrustash]

Facts bro!!!

[@fgaitanm]

No. He's wrong for killing his wife, BUT he could "get away with it", if you will, by stating that his wife killed them. The proof is there. No lobotomy, no torture will get him out of this one if he decides to say "it's his fault". That's the true plot, either you sacrifice everything, again, or die a hero... in a way...

[@Babs.vte.90]

Great reaction: can we just take a second to appreciate Kingsley's character, the doctor who did everything to save Andrew, who saw his heart, who understood him. The empathy is beautiful.

[@aussieoranges]

I wonder if Mark Ruffalo let him know that his experimental treatment was successful. That Leo could understand reality and chose suicide. Or if Kingsley resigned to being a failure.

[@jamie8032]

The ending is really sad. Andrew didn't regress. He was brought back to sanity, but he still preferred to be lobotomized rather than live with what he had done.

[@CopiousDoinksLLC]

It gets even worse if you understand how psychology works - it's entirely likely that the only reason Andrew killed his wife in the first place was because he was experiencing an episode of PTSD brought on from his time in the war. When the US soldiers discovered the bodies of those Jewish people in Germany, they were so traumatized that they snapped and reverted to their military training, which conditioned them to shoot the enemy. When Andrew discovered his children's dead bodies, the similarity to those Jewish bodies immediately made him start "replaying" his experience from WW2 (notice Andrew's thousand-yard-stare before he shoots his wife). He simply killed her out of reflex because the emotional side of his brain had been so strongly imprinted with that memory of his time in WW2 and it was in full control of his actions at that point.

[@decrulez]

@@CopiousDoinksLLCllied soldiers* US didn’t join the war till 2 years in and even then had mixed squads. The Soldiers also took people from the nearby town and marched them through it to show them what they were “ignoring” they all claimed they didn’t know. There were a lot of notes next to dead bodies the next morning saying “we knew”

[@Bepractical1995]

After he know what he was done. He called himself moster. He want to die as a good man rather than live as moster but he didn't know what is worst

[@dinuxplay8003]

@@decrulez "Allied soldiers" isn't wrong, but this pedantic deflection is pointless. Dachau was liberated by the U.S. Army’s 7th Infantry Division AND in the context of the movie too. Sure, there may have been other soldiers around, but it was the U.S. Army that led the charge and witnessed the horrors firsthand. And the "US didn’t join till 2 years in"? So, I guess they were twiddling their thumbs? Lend-Lease was already bolstering the Allies, and American forces were in action well before the camps were liberated. Bringing up "mixed squads" or when the U.S. joined the war adds nothing to the discussion. At the end of the day, Dachau was a U.S. Army operation, and trying to dilute that fact just screams desperate nitpicking.

[@Steak514]

@@CopiousDoinksLLClol fake.

[@hideshiseyes2804]

I can’t believe how quickly Hannah figures out the twists of films. She did the same thing with Fight Club.

[@EatYourVegs]

I think today the idea of an unreliable narrator is much more in people's awareness than back then.

[@leonhickson7186]

Detective Hanna Doesn't miss much.

[@jacobj297]

@@EatYourVegsYes- that and when you tell someone “this movie has a great twist.” It’s much easier to see it.

[@alexkrycek3359]

She’s seen the film before or was told of the twist

[@xfabkwood9321]

​@@alexkrycek3359that just seems like a waste of time. you really have to come up with backwards logic to justify your backwards brain

[@Rang3rz]

the people that keep requesting Psychological Thriller movies are amazing, it’s awesome to watch you and Hannah go into detective mode.

[@justtrustash]

FACTS!! It’s so much fun seeing her mind work 😂

[@Zairn12345]

Holy hell, 23:30 she’s right on point man. She’s understanding exactly the whole premise of the movie and picking up on all the small breadcrumbs. I watched this movie the first time and saw none of the breadcrumbs and was astonished at the ending!

[@justtrustash]

Exactly!! It’s her first guess and she gets it spot on 😂 honestly she’s too good

[@Jeremiah.k]

@@justtrustash she’s a genius mate keep her close.

[@Sindamsc]

This movie is so much rewarding on the 2nd watch. I'm pretty sure you caught a lot of small details while editing it, Ash.

[@justtrustash]

Mate I didn’t even get the disappearing glass or how on edge the guards were..it’s mad 👊🏽

[@jeffs.s.]

@@justtrustash Do you also understand now, why all the employees were not willing to help and why the guards in the beginning were chilling on the rocks instead of looking for Rachel? And why the creepy old lady goes shush to him, joking that they were told to not tell him anything about the role play, and why the lady who killed her husband was laughing at him?

[@floridaman.813]

One of my favorite parts of rewatching this movie is at the beginning where Sheehan (or Chuck) struggles to remove his gun from his waist. It really plays up to the fact that he’s just a psychiatrist and doesn’t have experience handling weapons like a true detective would

[@reese8097]

37:47 "You're a Rab Lat! You're a Rab Lat You're a Rab Lat!" Very true Ash

[@lethaldose2000]

When Leonardo realizes his children are dead in the lake is so heart-wrenching. His yelp is so primal like a wild banshee is so intense. That is beyond acting. He makes you feel like his whole world collapsed at that moment. Plus the director uses a great overhead shot to give the desperation needed for the scene. Great writing, acting, and directing. Great movie.

[@MariaHossain]

The looking up while clutching his children's bodies is shown to convey a father begging God above to help him. It's heartwrenching when you think about it.

[@salvadoroars]

That gets me every time. I can only imagine the feeling but Leo's acting during that scene it's so good it's palpable through the screen

[@peteg475]

The cabin by the pond where the tragedy of the climax took place was filmed at Borderland State Park in Massachusetts. I've been in that cabin many times. My wife's family helped build that cabin back in the day. It's just an empty shell with a fireplace for campers and bikers to get out of the rain, but they did a nice job dressing it up for the movie to make it look like someone actually lived there.

[@musicaleuphoria8699]

Awesome fact. I'd love to go back to Mass to sight see. Only remember some parts of it. Moved from there at age 4.

[@samhecocta7196]

Damn yo, that ending scene where Leo says: something about dying as a good man or living on a monster Gets me everytime

[@LoneWolf_8]

Hannah is so clever and cute, she needs to be in every reaction video

[@justtrustash]

She’s the greatest!! 👊🏽

[@chucknutz6269]

The protagonist tried to replace water with fire in his fictional traumatic memories. He is afraid of water at the beginning of the movie. You could notice that glass of water disappeared in the hand of that lady until glass was empty Many people didn't notice it, because main goal of this movie is to get us view world as an insane individual... And no matter that his wife in his dreams turns to ash, his hands get wet Every time Andrew's hallucinations get stronger more fire 🔥 he sees

[@Sd3cinema]

The fact that this film didn’t get great reviews when it came out always baffled me. I think it’s amongst one of the greatest films Marty has made.

[@maryannazurin2322]

I didn't know that! That surprises me, I thought it was a loved movie.

[@deborahpaley21]

I think it's too complex for the average viewer. It's brilliant.

[@suzyq3771]

Leo should have one an Oscar for this seriously 😊😊😊🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️😊

[@pipermccool]

@@maryannazurin2322 It frustrated - confused? - too many people.

[@Central_cnema]

This movie is a masterpiece. You guys realized so quickly wow..you really understand the movies purpose.brilliant 🔥🔥🐏

[@rynepaschall5973]

Watching you two is just another reason why I’m pursuing a life as a director. You two deeply give each and every frame thought, ask the questions the directors want you to ask, and the emotional response you have to climactic moments in each film, is what we call the magic of cinema

[@ericamonroe9351]

No matter how many times i watch this movie, the ending hits hard everytime! It's one of the best movies of its genre ever made. So well written and directed. You just get so gripped by the whole plot. Enjoyed seeing you guys' reaction to it so much! All the theories along the way, could really tell you were both very invested in the main character

[@LiamLacey95]

I'll admit I didn't vote for this in the poll but I'd be lying if I said this isn't one of the most Underrated movies ever made Great reaction as usual guys

[@jaredroberts578]

Whoa, now, what is this honesty? I love it. Much appreciated.

[@justtrustash]

Respect bro 👊🏽

[@DelusionInSanity]

Whoever recommended Shutter Island knows his stuff. Shutter Island is a great movie! That last line is what the film is about, as they (the writers), made you experience his delusional state where he creates his own plot to cover up his own trauma and "live" as a good man, as well understand the wrongness of what he has done by killing his own sick wife, nonetheless a human being, and having to live with horror of knowing the person he loved killed his kids. So, "Would you rather live as a monster or die as a good man?" Great reaction, you always get me to laugh at the most random shit, and great perception skills from Anna, you too Ash. Symbolisms!!

[@kengruz669]

This is one of my favorites. So nice seeing you give it the attention and kudos it deserves. The word was "Kafka-esque", referring to the outlook and themes of the Czech writer Franz Kafka of the early 1900s who explored themes such as anxiety, powerlessness, and bureaucratic nightmares. You're observations and instincts are great, Hannah. You're a queen. So awesome, guys!

[@ZeroFX1]

Watching this film after the first time is always fun.

[@justtrustash]

Honoured to have watched this with you mate ☺️

[@phstabell]

i cannot believe how Hannah pieced all of this together som damn fast, watching it the first time. BRAVO!!

[@Yorbval]

She’s really smart. Great reaction

[@JLH-w6d]

37:45 - "Rab Lats"! I cant stop laughing, bro! 🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂 And Hannah's reaction!... priceless! 😄

[@joneljustbecause]

“You’re a Rab Lat!” Made my day 😂

[@YellowKodiak]

I have gotta say, you two have become my two favorite reactors. your passion, enthusiasm, fights, and banter is reason enough to come back. so entertaining. love you both so much :)

[@Eowyn187]

So hyped to watch y'all with this!! Scorsese really messes with the head in this one. Then finishes by hitting the heart pretty hard.

[@HaIsKuL]

“The Kafkaesque genius of it…” Means something absurd and nightmarish, often treated like it’s normal by everyone except the protagonist. It’s referring to the specific style of the writer Franz Kafka, hence, Kafka-esque.

[@milissapotter4473]

Props to Hannah for figuring out the twists and noticing the little details. Well done to Ash for really understanding that last line, it was so satisfying to watch his reaction cause not a lot of people get it. Thank you guys for another amazing reaction❤️❤️❤️

[@Mikeyw9119]

Been recommending this one for a while! Insane twists, and I was getting so frustrated that you guys were onto the plot the whole time 🤣 I wanted you guys to be as shocked at the reveal as I was. But you guys had a feeling that something had to be hidden. Great intuition, and another great reaction!

[@justtrustash]

Thank you mate for recommending it ❤️

[@ZeroFX1]

Hannah caught on so quick to the twist

[@chadbailey7038]

Yeah I hate that! 😅

[@user-yq3yp9gy6q]

30:20 Ash no….. this is the moment she starts looking at you differently. She tried so hard to not react or comment on that scream of yours 😂. LOVE THE CHANNEL!

[@justtrustash]

Let’s gooo!! Appreciate you mate ❤️

[@darren_myatt]

🤣 This is the moment he realized he fucked up. I mean he uses the word bitch so much in his videos, this was the moment, he literally turned into a bitch 🤣😂. Symbolisms 😆. She's not gonna look at him the same way anymore. Poor guy!

[@lethaldose2000]

Hey Ash, I've watch over 1000 movies in my lifetime and I could tell you only a few like your Hannah would get the eventually plot twist to this movie until the very end. That's what makes this type of writing and directing so amazing and spellbining. Props to Leo and Marty for taking us on a wild wild ride. Next you need to watch "The Departed".

[@Arthaius]

- How about "The Others" - that one has a really interesting and unexpected plot twist.

[@HardcoreGrady]

Hannah is a legend! I've watched this movie multiple times and somehow never noticed the missing glass. Eagle Eye! She had this movie figured out so fast and when I saw it I had no idea lol!

[@BennyHarveyBigMan]

13:38 did you notice the missing bottle?

[@larsprst4231]

You really, really NEED to watch "A Beautiful Mind" and "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest". Love your reactions.

[@Eowyn187]

Yep. And *Awakenings* with Robin Williams.

[@dinkin_flicka14]

A beautiful mind is one of the best movies I've ever seen

[@jeannellebroussard3138]

Jack Nicholson at his finest, a young Danny DeVito, and even Scatman Crothers in really an all-star cast in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest.

[@TC-by3il]

Man great reaction! This film is on my top5 all time for a reason, it's amazing. Incredibly impressed with how Hannah managed to catch so many details on the first watch.

[@SamoanDemigod]

This is one of those movies that gets more and more fun to watch every time you watch it cause you start picking up on things you weren’t paying attention to. Top 10 favorite movie of mine! I remember showing this movie to my sister and it blew her mind. She ended up showing her friends and it blew their minds too. Love this movie.

[@KrazzeeKane]

Lol Ash done in by the slow-mo replay at 30:24, it shows him clearly reacting and screaming before Hannah starts her scream, so he can't blame that one on her lol--you got genuinely got, it's ok that part made everyone in the theater yell too haha

[@irishking2428]

I really enjoy your guys reactions. This is definatley my favourite reaction channel on youtube.

[@b0pps]

So glad you and Hannah were able to really appreciate it by the end. My favorite thriller of all time and such an underrated Scorsese film.

[@Fantomas24ARM]

This movie blew my mind when it came out, I watched it like dozen of times after that and every time I was discovering new details. It is definetly in my top 3 movies of all times.

[@PeterDB90]

Something that was pointed out to me about this movie and one of the things that I appreciate a lot is that this is one of the VERY FEW movies that shows asylum staff as the "good guys" - often times if you see an asylum in a movie/story, they always have an evil, ulterior motive. In this case it's people doing their genuine best to help even the worst of their cases.

[@David-ru8tc]

How in the F*** did Hannah figure that out so fast?!?! Freaking genius.

[@Crevy1467]

Hannah’s empathy is always amazing to watch. I cried at the exact same time when realizing what was happening at the end 😂

[@Shirryon]

I've watched this movie twice and only now, by watching your reaction, I realize the true meaning of the last scene and last line. Awesome reaction, guys!

[@TripleNate-yk1kb]

BEST REACTION YETTT THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR APPRECIATING THIS MOVIE PROPERLY

[@bout350]

You really need to find a way to where you can both have two earbuds in. You have to be missing out on some of the experience by only having audio in one ear. That must be horrible tbh.

[@DjVanillaGuerilla]

"AHH! Your air went in my eye! 😠" Had me in tears. Oh and those dang rab lats 🤣🤣

[@Yorbval]

You caught on to everything that you were supposed to catch on to. Perfect

[@doublaD]

Okay, so this is maybe the 4th reaction I’ve watched. I am so happy that you connected with this film. It is a masterpiece, clearly. And its also humane. It has respect for the characters, and the audience. I loved watching you piece it together, and mostly i loved your reaction to the full realization of the story. You are both the best. Patreoning now. Bye.

[@davidnoel2977]

The inmate he talked to that said "you did this to me" is the actor that played in the remake of Nightmare on Elm Street as the new Freddy Krueger

[@goldenageofdinosaurs7192]

He also played Kelly in the 1976 film, The Bad News Bears.

[@jaredroberts578]

And Rorschach in The Watchmen,...plus Bad News Bears. Jackie Earl Haley.

[@tomasalarconchible9729]

so sad that the remake is a complete trash tho

[@Real_Uce684]

Yup yup, my favorite reaction channel aka my favorite reaction couple. Keep the content coming bro. Love n Aloha from Hawaii nei. LFG bruhh.

[@ReallyGoodandKind]

Eyyyyyy welcome back Ash! This movie is one of my favorites. Another gem from Marty Scorsese

[@susannahdean7]

First reaction I've seen for this movie with someone who really understand so much. Hannah, you're the first one who have noticed that the glass of water missed. It's because Andrew / Teddie was affraid and sick with water so he didn't see the glass. And you realized so early that he was patient 67, bravo. You are both right about the last sentence. I'm convinced that he knew. And that is THE big difference with the original Book. At the end of the nouvel, he didn't say those words so we can presume he has reset. In the movie, I think he made his choice. Thank you for your great reaction from France.

[@sammurphy4894]

Hannah figured it out so freaking fast! nice

[@nicholashall5241]

So happy that you guys did this. It's one of the best underrated psycho-thrillers. Hannah is SO on point with finding that Chuck is the Dr. And Teddy is a patient. Great job you guys.

[@Arthaius]

- To be honest, I am glad I don't have the mind she does; I'm fairly intelligent, but having everything revealed at the end was mind-bendingly awesome, this movies truly took me through the wringer. If I had been like Hannah, I wouldn't have had nearly as good of a reaction, I would have basically spoiled the ending for myself figuring it out too soon.

[@MonicaHolly143]

This movie is the definition of symbolisms

[@glennzeeburg6763]

you 2 should watch true detective season 1. amazing crime/thriller show.

[@timothyhedrick5295]

👍...this...

[@Pillowlips77]

@@timothyhedrick5295 I second this 👌👌👌

[@GlennShook]

Yep and I voted for this so ash knows I know my shit. Lol

[@johanheinhuis7877]

Yes 🙌🏻

[@orcanimal]

Watch it again. There are lots of subtle hints that you don't pick up on first watch. It's brilliant.

[@freedom.pacific]

16:25 "baby i hate the sound of pencils, like that was unbearable for me," lool the genuineness in her voice, proving our millennial perspective on what hardship is

[@samhecocta7196]

Wooooooooooo!!!! OMG! You guys rock, and roll bro! JUSTTRUSTASH is the best! Everyone better watch this video, like and share. 😂🤣🧐😬🥳🤩😃😁

[@steven95N]

Random eargasms and a "Biccup" in the first 3 minutes? I'm here for this.

[@kylemcdonald6756]

Ash... Quit messing around mate and put a ring on it. World's greatest detective!

[@CaesiusX]

🤭 This film, especially for a reaction channel, is a great lesson in jumping to too many conclusions right away. 😁 22:44 _Bravo Hannah!_ 55:18 *Ash:* _"There's no way he's regressed again."_ That *is* the question, isn't it? Did he actually regress? Or is he now only pretending to, so he can end his pain? Terrific reaction. 😄

[@MusicLife-pb2es]

I was laughing through every discovery they made 😂

[@CaesiusX]

@@MusicLife-pb2es 🤣 _Right?!_ LOL!

[@justtrustash]

Appreciate you mate ❤️

[@viddiot]

Hahaha! It's like watching films with dumb and dumber (just kidding kinda!) it's very brave to just throw your ideas out there as you go and so fun that you guys erupt into arguments mid scene hahaha, Excellent to notice the glass! Love it, subbed!

[@subliminallime4321]

The thing I like about the ending is that you can interpret it two ways because maybe he has regressed & that line at the end is just idle conversation. Total Recall has a similar ending. They're the kind of movies that you wanna discuss with someone right after you leave the theater

[@CopiousDoinksLLC]

45:20 Holy shit, did Ash actually say "SYMBOLISMS" in the appropriate context this time? I think he did!!

[@Erik78Johansson]

Glad you liked this one! .... I think is time for you guys, well I´m thinking yu are ready for "Primal Fear" now. Great reaction and take care.

[@stanley2681]

"...yea if she showed up in my bedroom i'd be a bit concerned" lol

[@orarinnsnorrason4614]

Such an amazing film. In particular the dream sequences are phenomenal. Leo clearly knows how to pick a role. Also Ben Kingsley is always a win.

[@WhatExperience]

watching you guys chat about movies I've seen is one of the sweetest things I've seen, like, you both are figuring this movie out but you emote so much about what you think it's actually sick and I love it, good choice of movies and proper down to earth opinions an ideas, subscribing rn xd

[@WhatExperience]

wait, I already subscribed earlier today before work but for real, Imma watch all of these, you are funny - keep it going

[@justtrustash]

Love you mate!! Proper appreciate you for this ❤️

[@WhatExperience]

man, thanks for coming back with that, peace

[@TomDang]

Hannah is always gonna guess the plot if you throw out 50 theories! Hahaha I am just poking fun! I've always loved this movie too. I wasn't a big Leo fan in his early career, but mature Leo kills it in basically everything he's in.

[@justtrustash]

I think her first guess was spot on so I’m going off that first one 😂

[@TomDang]

@@justtrustash haha for sure. Like I said, I'm just poking fun. Hannah is definitely very observant, and has a knack for seeing the future like The Minority Report, haha. I'm usually the one saying to my wife, "Babe, Babe!" Like I'm some genius, pointing at the screen, and she just says, "Uh yeah, you just now got that??"

[@besupaaa]

Ive read in some other comment that thew new approach trying empathy and actually trying to find out and treat traumas of the patients was some new thing that started by that decade-ish. Its interesting to see everyone was in on it, genuinely trying to help him.

[@DrKnight81]

Symbolism Ash! Symbolism!🤣

[@TheGroucho66]

The word the doctor in the cave said that you didn't hear/understand was "Kafkaesque" which relates the the writings of author Franz Kafka where the main characters in his stories experience a nightmarish and illogical scenario where some unknown, powerful entity, power, or organisation is in complete control of you or you sense something sinister and yet bewildering is pulling all the strings and you are helpless to fight it or the complexity of bureaucracy leads to insane and illogical results. For example, in the Kafka story 'The Trial', a bank clerk is randomly arrested out of the blue one day without knowing what crime he has supposedly committed and when he asks why, nobody answers him or they think he's pretending not to know and nobody attempts to defend him. Or like when you're applying for an internship to get experience for a job only to be turned down for not having enough experience. Or imagine you are applying to a bank to get your first ever credit card but the form you need to fill in to get your first credit card requires you to fill in the account number of your current credit card. In this case, the doctor in the cave is talking about the pointless, absurd scenario of being stuck in an insane asylum where admitting you're insane confirms your insanity whilst denying you're insane means you're delusional and in denial about your own insanity, thereby making it impossible to escape as a sane person in their eyes.

[@angelminaj617]

I love this movie. I never guessed that he is a patient so the ending really shocked me.

[@RagnaRantz]

*THESE* are the thriller/mysteries that I love (off top of my head, loved “The Prestige”-4 same reason) A story that doesn’t hold your hand at all, but if you do pay close attention, you can put together just what is going on. Love it, masterclass. Can’t stand mysteries where the “surprise” wasn’t even a part of the story’s world, or when a scene revisited is changed, revealing or hiding an important detail NOT due to a character’s flawed memory/unreliable narrator; but very purposeful & sloppy by the director. Creating a lazy “surprise” rather than a clever puzzle you may or very well may not see-but it’s there

[@silverdoeGirl]

If you like this psychological thriller? I think you'll like ''Identity'' with John Cusack - Or ''Zodiac'' that is HUGE casting wise! Its a great film! Shutter island is a classic - The cast is amazing! You should've heard the gasps in the cinema lol

[@Jasmine-f8t2p]

I first watched Shutter Island when I was 14, and I had no idea what was going on till the end. But watching it, knowing what happened, you do pick up on little hints that allude to the ending. I love how you noticed how that female patient asked Dr Sheen for a glass of water for the purpose of sending him away from almost the beginning of the movie. Love it

[@Sindamsc]

I'm so happy you guys reacted to that! I was recommending this movie a lot. Hannah actually nailed it. You both were so much invested to the movie, it was a pleasure to watch! The best Leo's role ever in my opinion. Finest Scorsese movie too. If you ever run out of movies, I would recommend Bladerunner (final cut) and Bladerunner 2049, both are amazing and got this detective vibe too.

[@justtrustash]

Appreciate you recommending it ❤️

[@mycroft16]

This movie is a fucking trip. It is so god damn good. Absolutely underappreciated film. That ending just hurts. Like the whole thing with him realizing the truth, but then him having the realization that he doesn't want to live as the monster is just a gut punch.

[@tyrionlannister4920]

im not even a quarter in and already love it

[@justtrustash]

My day 1 brother ❤️

[@tyrionlannister4920]

@@justtrustash have a great day Ash ✌and send Hannah my regards 🎻

[@againes.1]

I'm so impressed at how quickly you all put it together. It took me a few watched to fully understand. Bravo!

[@sentosaco]

I feel so ashamed that I only just realised he actually did NOT regress. You guys were so quick on everything, I thoroughly enjoyed rewatching Shutter Island with you.

[@Huhta84]

It was fun to see you guys trying to dissect this movie scene after scene. Me sitting here already seen this one smiling and slightly shaking my head; "Oh, you have no idea".

[@barrybaz2736]

Props to Hannah for figuring it out so quickly

[@justtrustash]

My girl 🙃

[@slvdrfrncs]

ok, I'm not gonna lie, this movie is on e of my favorites. Watched a lot of reaction videos here on YT and yours has to be the best one I've seen! Your reactions are on point! Gained a new subscriber in me!

[@brendanfoehr5086]

For the curious, Patricia Clarkson's character said "That's the Kafkaesque genius of it," referencing writer Franz Kafka.

[@eduardo_corrochio]

I had a feeling she said that. I only know Kafka's fiction via "The Metamorphosis" story in which its protagonist Gregor Samsa awakens as a big insect one morning.

[@Etticos.]

Symbolisms

[@meghanworkman6449]

Love your reactions, and you two are so hilarious and adorable together. One half of my top two favorite reaction channels! And props to Hannah - she is wicked smart and quick to catch things!

[@stuntcock8921]

I love how far off the predictions are 😂

[@RebornLeveller]

I’m a new subscriber and have been catching up on your reactions for about a week now, and I have to say this is my favourite so far. It was so much fun watching you theorise, debate and work out parts of the mystery. I’m especially impressed with Hannah for working so much out. She did much better than me or any one else I know. She’s like Sherlock Holmes - Hannah Holmes. You two should definitely do more mystery films. 😃

[@soloa24]

The beauty of movies like Shutter Island is watching first watchers react 😂

[@anniemae4449]

this is one of the best movies to rewatch! every time i see it i pick up on more clues and double meanings (some of which you guys got on the first watch). great reaction!

[@Sindamsc]

Ash, after this scene about woman axing her husband you should hide your sword 100% 🤣🤣

[@hmpphoto]

“Go find yourself Ms. Trenchbull then…” DAAAAMNNNN! Ok. Instant follow just for that epic zinger! 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@coreyjohnson4954]

Great reaction Hannah is definitely sharp! Not a psychological thriller but great revenge thriller is Count of Monte Cristo if you haven’t seen it yet A++