[4K] Wow🔥 The second world EP.7 3 Round Results

[@zanacer1784]

Imagine being criticized for belting and showing off her singing abilities in a vocal competition. Hats off to Yubin she did great but the explanation of the judges just doesn't make sense. Moonbyul deserves more than being used by the program to spice things up by lowering her points.

[@moonandsunrise7936]

True! I hope RBW won't let their artists esp Mamamoo to join shows like this moving forward. Getting criticized coz you did your best?!?

[@rbwstanwhohatesrbw9493]

calm down they are just doing it to not make her the winner of every round. ik it's annoying but she probably slayed too hard. edit: totally understanding your frustration guys, I am still annoyed by it too but she still won this round bc of moos votes and it's a flex

[@sebastyann123]

@@rbwstanwhohatesrbw9493 still is fcked up tho they could make it even a 4-1 situation and just saying they liked yubin vibe more than hers not calling her greedy bc she sang too well? they not only disrespected her but us as well as if we are dumb enough to think this was not a production move to close the gap

[@HaengbokSara]

@@moonandsunrise7936 I still think it is a good opportunity. Many didn't know she could sing or at least that well. She also seems to gain confidence. I hope she is aware that is a production move.

[@riyanasalwahafiza4011]

Yesss! At first i just thought that oh maybe its just not the judges cup of tea, but then after knowing the translations i am speechless. Like never i’ve seen in my life so far a critics like that made by the judges, being greedy?? For belting too much high notes in a vocal competition?!?! Thats just straight up ridicilous.

[@nicorobin3785]

I THOUGHT THIS IS A SINGING COMPETITION FOR RAPPERS???! How come Moonbyul didn't get any points for singing her heart out like that?!

[@KiritoHamiltonKPop]

They said she was trying keep with beat but idk why they gave her zero

[@hmm-kt3rk]

Well i think there are several probable reasons why she got 0 vote. 1. They might just like Yubin's version better. For example the guy who said moonbyul was greedy i dont think he meant greedy 4 high notes. He didnt mention high notes @all. I think he just meant the song has no break. Even byul said so herself while practicing. He clearly prefers city pop vibe more, even in round 1 he was the only one who chose exy. 2. The show is rigged 3. They thought since they gave byul perfect score last rounds, they hv to be more critical this time. 4. They just hv higher standard n expectation 4 byul (which if u think abt it is unfair but flattering @ the same time) 5. They thought that someone else will vote 4 byul ( i hope this is not the case since thats disrepecrful 4 both artists) 6. They are bias against park myungso (compare to the other producers park myungso is more known as comedian than musician. N his love 4 edm so maybe they take his music seriously?) Since Yubin forced change the song to suit her style, while byul just go along w/him n make herself fit the song. Which brings to no. 7 7. They wanted byul to fit the song to her style more than fitting herself to the song. Anyway even from round 1 i think we know the criteria was messed up. I think the best fans could do is to hype up favs performances as much as possible so it will reach more ppl. I mean thats the main purpose of this show rite to let the world know their singing abilties which they dont show when they r in group.

[@vanilladeerest]

For real! Her vocals were so impressive this round! I can't believe she didn't get any points at all. Ridiculous! I love Yubin but I feel Moonbyul was the clear winner here!

[@Aria-nu6ko]

​@@hmm-kt3rk wait, isn't eunkwang the only one who vote for exy (city pop) in the first round? I'm sure it's not the one who said that mb greedy.. like other people said, this show judging criteria has been weird from the first round.

[@mairaleao]

Moonbyul: Gives on of the best vocal performances of the show! The judges: Uh.. you did your job way too perfectly.. take 0 points.

[@roseregalado1495]

Exactly!

[@kayink3275]

Yubin: Holds the mic The judges: 700 points! (At least Yubin and Byul are good friends, that takes some of the sting out of it.)

[@moonsstar3159]

The funny point is that..... they kept asking Moonbyul how she felt to lose for the first time. And then who is the winner at the end? MOONBYUL!!🔥🔥 😎😎🤗😌😌

[@hat929]

an emperor indeed

[@yagiyodel530]

They are shamelessly criticizing them so different, Moonbyul deserves respect

[@phoomyatnoe7579]

I cried at the result, are you kidding me? Moonbyul should be given at least one vote in this round with her amazing performance. Is it the reason that she got all-kill in her last rounds that they gave her no votes this round????

[@norasimahrahman2912]

The judges commented on yubins vocal capabilities but still gave her all votes in a VOCAL competition...they tried to downgrade byuls high notes, saying she was screaming...but the notes came out smooth and clean...no crack whatsoever...who are they trying to deceive...they should commented on yubins high notes instead...the notes are not that high but we can hear her voice trembling to achieve the not- so- high notes...do they think we are that stupid to accept their statements blindly? Edit; And they praised her for holding on and swaying the mics wire...as if its the best thing that ever happened in a competition..i was in a total disbelieved..

[@michaelsafan3684]

Totally agree. Such a drama, not a singing competition 🤡

[@moonandsunrise7936]

Agree! She did it perfectly and smoothly. We never hear her voice crack even when she would goof with her members singing songs that are really high. She got really good range tbh.

[@devp2374]

you know you can't really count on this type of competition, they are only searching for the drama and not the talent that the artists have in them.

[@leresonance4418]

​@@devp2374 Moonbyul was more concerned about singing well than enjoying the music like in previous performances. Even if i am a moonbyul fan, I have to admit Yubin played her cards so well. Moonbyul has learned the lesson so it's probably that she win. She is very smart to deal with this situation. Also, I prefer to watch her try this kind of song and lost instead to she stays in her comfort zone.

[@norasimahrahman2912]

@@leresonance4418 agreed moonbyul was a bit tense when she performed this song compared to her other songs...but she executed it well though...compared to yubins monotonous vocal which trembled here and there when she sang the high notes...so overall moonbyul did it better than yubin...no hate to yubin...im just comparing their performance and vocal abilities...

[@lwo_owl]

What the heck is wrong with these judges? "Your high notes were too high" - ehm, no, you standarts are too low since no one can beat our Moonstar if you don't step up! Seriously, i am so mad 😠 Justice for Moonbyul!!!! Best vocalist ever!!!!

[@dandelion8367]

This comment need more recognition. Repeat again, ur high notes were too high. NO DEFINITELY NO, its just ur standart are too low.

[@mauwadebo8748]

To get the high note ....you need to make high note....what is wrong with this judge????? What is so wrong that moonbyul make high note? Maybe she to talented so the judge jealous

[@nuratiqahsyfiyana839]

Exactly I am also mad 😡 😡

[@elioreIH]

Since beginning, the judging criteria had been questionable but this time is blantantly rude and disrespectful. The very least fans can trust from the show is credibility and integrity. Second World and JTBC betray this trust. Portraying an artist's hardwork and sincerity as greedy/excessive is so low for vocal competition. Her incredible performance and high notes are not coming out of arrogance/show off but a humbling battle with her insecurities over the years. She literally taking vocal lessons and having countless practices for the performance while preparing group comeback. Judges smiling and grooving while watching Moonbyul's performance and then giving zero vote is pure non sense and ridiculous to see. This is so personal to the fans, as we care for her confidence as an artist beyond this show. JTBC Second World, your greediness ruining an artist. Please show genuine respect to music and talent. From the start, we tried to be impartial, respectful and hype up this show but you crossed the line this time.

[@Sight4SoreEyes039]

Agreed. I can accept Yubin's win but the score should have been more of a 2-3. It definitely didn't warrant such one-sided nonensense.

[@aasthaj31]

Yeah. They could have at least given 2 or at least 1 vote because her vocals were so strong. they said that but zero is not good. But since it was everyone's votes, they must be thinking that other will vote for her but in the end, it ended up with zero. Because if you see the reaction of the last three judges, they were shocked as well because they must be expecting some votes for her as well. I loved her performance and I hope she doesn't take it to heart and will come up with another banger. But we have to week another week for that. Uwuwu.

[@KiritoHamiltonKPop]

I can accept yubin winning but I know moon gonna stay in first place regardless due to fact round 3 was bad

[@aasthaj31]

@@KiritoHamiltonKPop Yes. Due to her past performances and moomoos support, she was still the top one and will remain as one. I am not doubting the judges judgement here because they mostly gives the decent and helpful comments. A few things that they said were right as well but might not have worded them correctly. They acknowledged her vocal skills and her talent but it would have been great if she had gotten at least one vote. Because it was such an amazing performance and power packed. It was simply a preference based on voting at this point because both performances were great on its own. I just hope she wins the next round.

[@elioreIH]

​@@aasthaj31 Let me add another perspective of the vocal judges. In this clip, the vocal judges basically said to Yubin : We give you 5 votes because you strategically covering your singing with rearrangement of the song and atmosphere of performance. You are great for having captivating gaze and unique gestures of swaying your mic, although the pitch seems too pressuring for you. Congratulation, you get perfect scores. I tried to make sense of their logic, but fail miserably. The unprofessional evaluation are not only directed to Moonbyul, but extended to Yubin as well. They both deserve genuine, constructive and relevant feedback as artists in vocal competition.

[@janellelainecapili7670]

I just cannot get enough of how good natured and kind Moon Byul is. She is such a warm-hearted person. Even when Exy lost, she hugged and comforted her and now when she lost to Yubin, she was still a good sport and maintained her smile and hugged Yubin. Moon Byul is a good sport and a good person overall and that makes me root for her even more. I totally agree to a lot of the comments that Moon Byul definitely showed more vocal technique/ skills and was stable all throughout the performance. And she did what a disco version/ concept should be like. Yes, it may be loud or too much for the judges but that is what a disco song would be like if you were actually dancing in a disco or club. Maybe the concept wasn't really what all the judges prefer but I think she did a concept that would not take away from the original song or what the producer really wanted the song to be which is EDM. So major props to Moon Byul because she gave us all an awesome performance and her fans/ Moomoos will always have her back no matter what.

[@norizain1120]

Moonbyul " you are a vocalist" but that doesn't matter in a "singing competition" what is important is your gaze, vibe and wired microphone!

[@hide8694]

She is not greedy. She has to sing this powerful to go along with the music. If she lower her voice, the music gonna be more stand out than her. If you make the music this hard, the singer has to be this powerful. Moonbyul did great job.

[@jjjulia127]

I’m sooo anxious I can’t describe!!! Justice to MoonByul! All the support to our Imperor moomoos!!!

[@ryuxiyue2982]

moonbyul performance literally nailed it how to unhear the nonsense comment of those judges

[@melek9415]

Moonbyul was called greedy and given zero points for exhibiting her vocals in the best way in the vocal contest.

[@millamalla1824]

I’ve just started my journey into k-pop and I don’t really know any of these artists, but I have always loved music. I think all the performances were good in their own way, but it’s really sad that a show revealed so blatantly that the gap between the contestants points needed to be somewhat closed. Make’s for a bad impression of the judge’s and make one really question their integrity. Since the beginning I think Moonbyul has been held to a higher standard when it comes to her singing and performance, and that’s why they used those really weird excuses to not give her vote’s this time. So all that put aside, I’m now just gonna enjoy all 8 beautiful and talented woman performances. The judges can judge as fair or unfair as they like, I think the ppl votes will be my standard. Best of luck to them all ❤

[@moonbyul1fan110]

The one whose vocals they critiqued won full points.... in a VOCAL competition!!!!! Now seeing the translation for the comments towards both contestants makes the score even more absurd. The comments for the opponent wasn’t even overwhelmingly positive to warrant full points lol

[@hhgg3617]

And for judges , can't accept you say moonbyul greedy for vocal COMPETITION. She's amazing, outstanding and this her best perf. Judges, don't just critizes pinelist, but give them feedback/suggestion too. And congrats for Yubin unnie, you are great too.

[@DS-tz6rm]

they are saying "Yubin you need to go with more comfortable approaches to sing" but also saying to Moonbyul "instead of going for a concept you were sing aloud, go with a different vibe or a concept"? Are you guys sure what you want?

[@anniemichelle654]

They all are already singers and rappers, they already know how to perform 🤷‍♀️ why focus on performance when its a singing show,

[@swas_it4312]

From,Judges smiling & grooving on BYULIE'S performance..to giving her 0 votes..left me with no words....

[@mirroruniverse9331]

I have no issue with Yubin winning but I have issue with giving zero to moonbyul. C'mon it's horrible when u know moonbyul outperformed herself!

[@lishakeyz5920]

Yay thanks for eng subs. Thought Moonbyul would win for sure but not even 1 vote? I can't wrap my mind around that

[@hannahbarbra4801]

Moonbyul's performance should've been the standard! Isn't this a singing competition? Bruh!?

[@najwa7381]

Being criticized because you did an excellent performance !! This is really funny. Mamamoo Moonbyul you are a high-level and I am absolutely in love with you voice WoW Really a very High-level ❤

[@moonbyul1fan110]

Moonbyul was facing Yubin this is the criteria that evaluation should be based. Who did the song better. Not bring everything from previous performances and telling Moonbyul she is greedy for doing high notes in a vocal competition?! and giving it easy to Yubin because her "vibe".

[@missbeautiful4544]

I’m not saying Yubin performance is bad but obviously, MB did better. I believe Yubin got lucky and she should consider to work hard for her next round. I mean congrats to her BUT this is not the end!! MB did really an amazing job! ❤

[@najwa7381]

" Greedy " !!? This is such a ridiculous word to say when it comes to a super talented idol like Moonbyul

[@norizain1120]

Moonbyul being a classy person even when they put her down she will rise with her good morals

[@rand0mpersonontheinternet499]

I have no problem with Yubin winning, she did an excellent job. However, I feel like the way the judges voiced their critique to Moonbyul was a bit harsh and being held to a higher standard. I think at least one vote should have gone to her, but I am happy to see Yubin and Moonbyul being supportive of each other. And see what they have in store next

[@25beee]

Me too, I don’t mind Yubin winning but I don’t accept the harsh comment on “greedy”…

[@mby1922]

(3)

[@tarulichristovina7382]

I am glad to found this comment. As a wonderful who love our wonder girls to the max but also enjoying mamamoo, I kinda affraid of yubin getting hate because she won over moonbyul but thank you :)

[@JaZ-18]

The TRUTH is that JUDGES wanted the GAP to be short that being said Moonbyul HAD to pay. The comments related to voice in a voice contest we can see that definitely goes to Moonbyul showing her power, about the arrangement of the song she was true to herself and performance was on point to show vocals. Moonbyul deserves BETTER and RESPECT. +edit For Youbin I loved the performance too, no hate. ... But is a contest and everybody can see.

[@hhgg3617]

The friendship between Yubin and moonbyul I love them

[@moon9106]

love how they uploaded this so fast-also hate how they tried to nicely translate the judge’s comments lol😂

[@rianevas1076]

It was super satisfying to see moonbyul get 1st from 3 rounds cumulative points. Moomoos always got her back.

[@jlamoo7270]

Moonbyul deserves more votes than this. Her performance and vocal skills were awesome. Sadly seems like it’s all rigged.

[@platiniuamsp1858]

The same happened to seonyou last time against moonbyul

[@anniedoremi]

​@@platiniuamsp1858 Moonbyul's performance has always been good. She is way too good for the show... Even in Queendom, the participants didn't want Mamamoo to be on the show in the pre-interview and they were shocked when it was revealed that Mamamoo was one of the groups who are participating since they thought Mamamoo would be the judge or something and that's just shows how high level Mamamoo is compared to most of the girl groups. Nobody can deny that out of all the female kpop groups, Mamamoo has the best vocals and credibility is when they won on Immortal songs....

[@platiniuamsp1858]

@@anniedoremi okay but you can’t always win ! She still un first place so loosing sometimes is normal 😭 I don’t see why people are so angry know when it happened to seonyou and mimi too few episodes before

[@platiniuamsp1858]

@@anniedoremi i love mamamoo even thought i’m not a stan !

[@anniedoremi]

@@platiniuamsp1858 We are more concern with the comment made not the score…. The judge told her that she was greedy with high notes

[@jjjulia127]

The only song that is in world itunes now - and no votes???

[@jaiyashree]

Yes they never mentioned that in the show, cuz then they would have to address the fact that moonbyul is on a different level than the other contestants.

[@babybear1588]

Damn it’s already hard enough that she had no votes (which honestly still baffling) but for them to keep pointing it out is mess up… Byul was a good sport! Yubin did great too!!!

[@ludb6479]

How can they call someone's hard work as greed... Criticizing someone's hard work is so unprofessional. Everyone is good but their comments on moonbyuls hard work was disrespectful. I am pissed.

[@yooralee9451]

When the judges forgot that this is a SINGING competition.

[@andyrajapaksha9539]

When judges don't understand the assignment this is what happens. According to me moonbyul did well.

[@duckiet3222]

No but is this a singing competition anymore? Like there were two judges saying Yubin’s vocal was lacking a little while praising Moonbyul’s vocal. But at the end they still gave all vote to Yubin??

[@user-zv5jd6yg7z]

I did not like Yubin's performance all that much, but the style is very unique, so I can accept her victory. However, it just makes no sense Moonbyul got zero votes, because even if judge's bias and personal preferences are accounted for, nobody can convince me that Yubin "dominated" like the score indicated. At best, it is closer to 50-50, and a 3-2 split or even 4-1 victory would have made more sense. Whatever. I will just enjoy the performances. "Competitions" on TV are always like that, as producers will make things closer than it is to create drama. It is what it is.

[@jjjulia127]

*So unfair!!!* Yubin did great, BUT are you kidding me??? *NO VOTES FOR MOON BYUL???* WTF???

[@phoomyatnoe7579]

I thought this round was a win for sure, even if you are not a fan,you know this round is the best performance of Moonbyul. Vocals? Dance? Stage presence? Still no votes?i crieddd

[@anniedoremi]

@@phoomyatnoe7579 Agreed.... Even general public who are not Moomoos are siding with us this time and saying the 5-0 win of Yubin and the greedy comment were ridiculous

[@best.2088]

Watched the Moonbyul performance and it has a lot of power, wide range of vocal, techniques, and stable voice all throughout. The Yubin has great vibe, charms and chill vibe but some parts of the song her voice is not confident, I hope she can improve on that. Overall, I think the handsome girl emperor card should won this round. 😎

[@minzyysings]

It's good that they made this show , so now we can judge the judges who are completely unworthy of making judgments... They asking A Diamond to act like a pebble !!! FR bro .. Moomoos Assemble!

[@dangmusings.2589]

It's annoying that they kept saying that it's Byulie's first time to not win 1st place. -_-

[@spidermancihuy9305]

like they really planned it

[@moomoon908]

let just close our eyes to this round of match, since it clearly made to close the gap between each of them. BYUL UNNIE, YOU DID GOOD.

[@elioreIH]

I think it's better to make a noise now. There is no guarantee they will not do the same stunt for 4th round and final round. They did this, not even in subtlety but in such blatant way. We need to call out their audacity.

[@michita7838]

@@elioreIH since she's still number 1, you can bet she's losing the next round too. They will try to put someone else on top to make it look like anyone could win.

[@elioreIH]

@@michita7838 Next round my guess is a matter of whom they want to save for the final round. The show may want to keep those in bottom ranking but having good popularity with the GP, by pushing hard the scores. Which still not fair to other artists. For Moonbyul, I worry more for final round as the scoring criteria has not been revealed. It may not be cumulative points. Moonbyul will be in the final, it's beyond ridiculous if they pulling stunt to exclude her from final. If you see her photos getting off work from the 4th round recording, she looked happy. Well, it's purely my guess and I could be wrong.

[@hmm-kt3rk]

@IH if ur theory is true we should see rite away w/ mimi seonyu match. They would want to keep mimi since mimi is prob more popular than seonyu.

[@anniedoremi]

@@hmm-kt3rk Someone commented that Jimin, JooE and Seonyou are eliminated

[@HeHe84755]

I feel sorry for moonbyul, I don't even know the other artist but I will say my impression of the two performances, moonbyul had my attention from the start of the song, the Light from behind and the calm tone was perfect as she started to progress I actually enjoyed the song it was really different as I felt it more like the songs that were released at the start of kpop, the high notes were will done even though they were difficult for her yet still pushed herself to make it with clear voice and strong one, as for the other artist the song was cool but not for her voice I felt bored as soon as it reached 30 sec, I mean she repeat her all the moves and the stage is empty nothing great but I can feel some people liking her style I would have given 4 votes to moonbyul 🙂

[@mmma_yaaa]

Yubin got 5 votes but moonbyul you got us!!thousand votes for you!!

[@wingwong3617]

The judges are so unprofessional. It’s ok that Yubin won. No hate to Yubin. But please respect Moonbyul….

[@lizjocano7436]

Yubin win is okey, but the explanation on why they voted on Yubin. Not voting on Moonbyu because of being too greedy? singing high notes? it's a VOCAL COMPETITION SHOW RIGHT? 🤷‍♀ question is what are the judges really looking for???? it doesn't make any sense!

[@Dannynite]

This show should never have been advertised as a vocal competition. It has been clear since round 1 that their judging criteria is ridiculously ambiguous and not at all rooted in vocals. They’ve gone and angered everyone watching this because of that disconnect. The way the judges voted for a less vocally forward DJ performance over Exy’s vocal ballad showed this problem early on. (No hate to Mimi. She performed well, but that wasn’t what i would vote for in a “vocal war.” Quoting JTBC’s own description of the show.) Now their arbitrary judging is rearing its ugly head again. Moonbyul challenged herself to do a song with belting, which is outside her usual zone. But she pulled off all the notes cleanly. Yet the arrangement of the song earned her a loss on a supposed vocal show? I wasn’t aware that having a “trendy” arrangement was a requirement to win. Meanwhile Yubin got criticized when they thought her vocals could do better, but she still won with an all-kill. All credibility is lost, honestly. I would have been fine with the results if not for the ridiculous comments about vocals. It’s so disappointing to see. I love Byul, and I love Yubin, and they both did well in their own styles. But I’m frustrated by the judges and the ambiguity behind their choices. And mad at jtbc. It’s not a vocal war.

[@anniedoremi]

It's funny how the producers are the one who came up with the theme or purpose of the show but they are the ones straying away from that purpose....

[@culturedmoonstar6576]

well said comrade. louder for the people at the back! for the judges and producers to hear!

[@pinksone8153]

They both did well! I respect the judge's decisions, but I'm surprised not even one voted MB.

[@thenamefrances]

Cant get over how the judges did moonbyul dirty c’mmon the disrespect not even one voted for her and then criticized her for being greedy with showing her vocal range. Its a SINGING competition! Does these judges even credible to judge? This show is stirring some unnecessary drama. If it werent for moonbyul this is show wouldn’t be that interesting. Just spitting facts.

[@norizain1120]

The way Moonbyul is getting criticized doesn't match the way Yubin is being evaluated and that is ridiculous. Making Moonbyul stage sound so bad and lifting yubin stage as if it something special. Her Mic holding her dance movements her gaze ?!?!?!?!?!?!?!? what is this? a beauty contest or vocal one

[@pqm6383]

They did the translation fast on this one because they knew they were gonna get the engagement on here lol. I wanted Yubin to win points since I didn't want her to get eliminated since I really like her voice thats on the deeper side, but I didn't think it was gonna be like this. If they liked Yubin's performance more because it seemed original, but lacking a bit in vocals, how can that get you all the votes in a comletition were they took point away from mimi&seonyou because they focus too much on performance and not vocal skill? Did nostalgia play a part in winning them over? I honestly liked the disco arragement better. I'm not gonna trash Yubin's performance becuase I liked it but Moonbuyl's song version was more catchy and memorable while Yubin's stage performance was more memorable but not the song. If moonbyul didnt sing clearly and with power she would have been drown by the instrumental. The song wasn't only high notes, there were parts toned down like in the beginning and middle, but they didn't even comment on that because it was really good. Other contestant have done high notes and belts in prevoius episodes and won the round. They focused on one part of monnbyul's performance to downplay her performance overall, while complementing different parts of Yubin's performance like the playing of the mic cord and her penetrating gaze and I don't like that. The judges have maintained a style of giving criticism with positive feedback but that's not what happened here for moonbyul. Its a bit jarring to see that disparity.

[@raissaricarde4511]

The results is clearly for the show's drama. 🤔Hopefully you know that the audience is not happy with the way you judge Moonbyul. No hate for Yubin but I know the other casts knows Moonbyul killed this round!

[@PeteyLeeTV]

Justice for Moonbyul! 넘 멎쪄유 👏🔥🚀

[@Alphaz-xg-co]

I'm really mad😡 right now byuliee doesn't deserve to be judged by them she's way too perfect 💙

[@nabilaimansahameran9443]

That one thing that I really hate is, the fact Moonbyul just accept it and try to play cool and shocked😢

[@one909]

Guys, dont be mad, Im a moomoo, but we know this show is rigged and arranged this way. Of course its weird Moonbyul lose, but they need it to closer the gap and for some twist/drama. I'll bet Moonbyul know it too. The purpose is for the show and drama. Im a fan of retro pop, im sure Yubin sing better than what they shown, too much edited and autotune for Yubin, im mad the excessively bad autotune on Yubin performance. I don't think the judge will solely do that. Im sure its scripted You can see from audiences vote, Moonbyul got full mark. So its quite fishy vote came from judge. Yubin doing great too. I love her version. Keep on supporting Yubin too.

[@michaelsafan3684]

Yes i think Byul aware of this, byk looking to her face and body gesture. The drama show must go on rite

[@elioreIH]

Well, I beg to differ. We should be mad at the show PD and judges and called them out. If this is rigged, it actually disrespect both artists, Moonbyul and Yubin. They come to the show, expecting genuine feedback and evaluation. I don't want to put down Yubin as we know how dear she is to Moonbyul and she worked hard as an artist too, but from Kim Bum Soo' comment, fancam, Exy' comment, her vocal stability is unfortunately not on par in this performance, although the vibe and arrangement is good. Zero vote is rather nitpicking and 'punishing' Moonbyul, rather than elevating Yubin. If this is rigged, what the guarantee that they dont do again for 4th round and final round ? How could we trust judges' words if the credibility going downhill ? An artist deserve a win in all fairness and respect.

[@dandelion6403]

I'm also a moomoo and I wouldn't listen to moonbyul's version of the song on my free time, because, yes, there's too much belting for my liking. I would, in fact, enjoy yubin's version while relaxing. BUUUT this is a vocal competition where everyone is expected to push themselves to the limit.

[@anniedoremi]

@@dandelion6403 Too much belting? You sould exactly like the judge that said she was greedy with the high notes.... This is the first time she is belting so much then you and that judge commented that it's too much? Watch Moonbyul's confidence drop because instead of encouraging her and telling her to push her limit, what the guy is essentially doing is trying to limit her.... You are the only Moomoo who commented that there's too much belting... When Moonbyul don't belt y'all ask her to belt. Then when she finally belt, y'all make statement like this which kinda implies she shouldn't belt....

[@dandelion6403]

@@anniedoremi what I stated above is called *preference* Moonbyul's version will never go into my playlist because that's not the type of music I like. But don't get me wrong, I was ecstatic to hear her perform it live during the show! I was so proud of her and in awe of her skills and there was no doubt in my mind she's the best in this competition. Although, the arrangement wasn't my personal cup of tea, I was like a proud mom tearing up because she's just breaking everyone's expectations and her confidence is up in the sky! 😭🔥 Never doubted for a second that she would lose the round!

[@macgoryeo]

very dramatic, they are such good friends and Moonbyul is keeping a clear head and being the professional she is 🙂

[@silentnight4025]

Even all the idols was shocked because they knew it was rigged. Sorry JTBC you lost all credibility, your just like Mnet no difference. Now stop using Moonbyul for clout and views

[@moonrise7908]

They dare to ask moonbyul how she feels after they did her dirty like that……..!!???? I feel she can’t even cover the disappointment and feeling of betrayal in her expressions. Joke on the industry for killing artist’s real talent and creativity..

[@monethismoemoo]

Moonbyul was out there performing one of her best stages in this competition but I guess the judges were deaf at this point.

[@colddddd455]

moonbyul deserves much better results！

[@syarifahfathin9681]

she didn’t even need the judges help

[@Mamamoo_318]

This is just so unfair. She gave her best to the performance and they criticised her for that. This is just so messed up

[@samiam6615]

How dare a contestant give an amazing vocal performance in a vocal competition?

[@djvillan]

The disrespect and blatant rigging from the judges in this round makes me sick. Moonbyul deserves better.

[@MA-gy3fx]

While Moonbyul vocals are on point they try to discredit her stage being not "trendy" or not sticking to the vibe and accusing her of being greedy for hitting Highnotes in a vocal competition? They gave the full score to the one with less impressive vocals and lacking stage?! I don't mind Moonbyul loosing if the opponent did something equal to hers or better. I don't think Moonbyul signed for this show to compete with the producers of the show !

[@Moonlight298ergh]

True. Tbh, if during the second round (unit round) , if mimi and seonyu group the one who win, I'm gladly accept it as their contemporary performance really amazing. However, for Yubin, i do not feel the same. I respect the judges decision usually, but something very sus.

[@sarahtot07]

JTBC, you've lost your integrity and credibility. You've lost our trust. What the judges said about Moonbyul's performance didn't make any sense in a singing competition show. Moonbyul's and Yubin's performances spoke for themselves. The difference between the effort and the vocal ability that were presented in the show was like night and day. It was clear to everyone that watched (except for the judges it seemed), who had the stronger vocal performance (and stage presence). The result was baffling. It's so plain to see that these judges were ordered not to vote for Moonbyul to decrease the score gap between Moonbyul and the other contestants. You don't deserve Moonbyul on your cooking show. Your show is cooked.

[@mihailgavrishchiv7972]

There are two judges, who are friends with mamamoo members, I wonder how they would talk to her face to face, after they did this to her.(Maybe they should look at their performance from Kingdom, they were greedy too, and shouted the high notes too).

[@kempachiken7848]

1:29 like seriously 🙄 isn't this show about vocals and singing If he wants to criticize altest come with something sensible

[@vsmyslevsezanyato]

yes "trendy" my a**

[@Kosong28]

Wtf judges saying moonbyul greedy? moonbyul just showing his skills

[@misskampungmodern5983]

I know that all the contestants do a good performance but when it come to Moonbyul Vs Yubin , why the judgers give compliment for the one side😌 I think they dont hv respectful to Moonbyul after Moonbyul win every her performance 🔥 It's okay unnie !! You hv moomoos 🌹 You deserve better !

[@radishmoomoo2471]

I bet any money production thought it seems that Moonbyul is too far ahead at this point so they need to make up some dumb criticisms to not put her so far ahead

[@Ming3484]

Doing your best and trying to better yourself is apparently now considered being greedy....

[@naniediaries3047]

I hope @reacttothek make a reaction/review on this so we can hear professional musicians pov.

[@norasimahrahman2912]

With the hope that theyre not under jbtc influence...

[@fmsriver]

Even if you're just a casual listener or not even a Moomoo, you will see how unfair the comments/result that the judges made for Moonbyul. These judges contradicted themselves. Truly disappointed with them.

[@nabilazakie2278]

look at the other idols are very surprised by the judge's results..they must be confused too 😂

[@moonbyuleng1793]

They can't handle a 3,000 points worth vocalist....so they level the playing field by giving her 0 points. Now I understand why Moonbyul had second thoughts on joining the show...😒

[@devigusniawati7962]

Excuse me, You the one who wear a leather black jacket who the hell are you actually ?? Did u say “too much blank area” Wich part ? And “too much add” ?????? She use her deep voice for almost the entire of her life and now she use new color and did so good, don’t u get it ….? OMG i hope you read this !

[@pandadaebak9134]

Moonbyul should be a judge and not a contestant, she has the qualifications and judging would become fair.

[@nikka82]

This!!

[@crispypasta]

thank you so much for the subs now i know that the judges didn't like byul's arrangement of the song? but loved her vocals. there were lots of points about yubin's vocals but her stage was really immersive and that's what they liked? but what makes me sad is that this is a vocal competition, moonbyul didn't deserve that 0 vote just bcos they weren't vibing with the stage and arrangement of the song but ah well. congrats to yubin! she really knows and embodied city pop!

[@culturedmoonstar6576]

sub was done in really nice way. they said. knets went bazinga as well during the upon hearing the comments 🥴🥴🥴

[@crispypasta]

@@culturedmoonstar6576 dang really? i had no idea what knetz were saying about it! may i know what they said? was there a post somewhere about it?

[@anniedoremi]

@@crispypasta The guy on the far left actually meant to say that she was greedy with the high notes....

[@deitypersephone1838]

it seems that the judges has a low standard of judging in terms of showcasing vocals. They preferred more on concept rather than vocals. By the way I really like the genuine friendship of moonbyul and yubin so real.

[@Aria-nu6ko]

If they really like city pop idk why in the first episode they didn't pick the one who sang city pop genre, instead they chose hard beat edm song with dj-ing + 2 verse rap + dance break all in one performance.

[@cielphantomhive9773]

That's not right although Yubin's performance was good but Moonbyul deserve more than this.

[@wheeinab2]

they must be kidding with their comments about byul right?????? lmaoooo WTF. ANYWAY, congrats byul!!! you did so greaaaaat!!!!!!!!! let's win this!!!!!!1

[@moodoot1626]

Damn I didn't know that showing your talent and doing you best to win and competition is considered being 'greedy', What a trashy reasoning.

[@PINKFLOWERBYUL]

we support you Moonbyul!! You did it well

[@yamaneaburami7210]

When you want to make the competition stay competitive to the end, but you can't make a proper reason for that.

[@vanilladeerest]

IMHO, Moonbyul was the clear winner. Vocals were insane. I was so impressed!

[@hiragana8361]

I think they also choose the judges not based by judges criteria🤭

[@chimmychungusmaximus]

so we're going vibes over vocals got it

[@phantomtales_]

The excuses from the judges to criticize Moonbyul are kind of pathetic, ‘you did too much’. The truth is they needed to level up the playing field or she would be unreachable.

[@michaelsafan3684]

Totally agree

[@MA-gy3fx]

Asking about Moonbyul waw points? where is Yubin waw points ?

[@vsmyslevsezanyato]

honestly this is a very funny comment ㅋㅋ it seems like her swaying the mic cord was the wow point to the judges

[@Aria-nu6ko]

​@@vsmyslevsezanyato LMAO😭

[@nabilazakie2278]

@@vsmyslevsezanyato 🤣🤣🤣

[@randomvideostokillboredom9672]

I'm happy for the winner but still cheers for moonbyul who did great. We are here for you and know that you did very well with those high notes you just hit, so don't be discourage over this result.

[@mirroruniverse9331]

There should be more shows like this with experienced artists. No open hatred/jealously. Just enjoying music. I know this show isn't perfect but I loved most part of it

[@jaiyashree]

Yes but they should make the judging criteria more transparent, it's seems vague and keep changing every round.

[@norasimahrahman2912]

They ARE experince artists...what do you mean? Yubin has been in the industry for fifteen years...moonbyul almost nine years...and they are famous and popular srtists of Korea...And we are NOT showing our hatred...we just want honest and capable judges in the show...judges who judged unbiasly....we accept if yubin showed good performance..but it was too blaring that she did not..

[@mirroruniverse9331]

Why are u pressed? This show is still better than many shows out there. Do u have how they edited for mnet, Queendom etc??

[@wereonlyhuman3289]

@@mirroruniverse9331 i watch queendom when mamamoo appeared,,it is pretty fun though

[@Moonlight298ergh]

@@norasimahrahman2912 she do show a good performance,but better than Moonbyul ? Not really in my opinion. But both are good performer.

[@blackbird_art0475]

Nah, this isn't a singing competition anymore change it to drama lmao

[@sebastyann123]

It's the fact that they take us for dumb that annoys me more than anything (besides calling her greedy for showing off her vocals in a vocal competition???) Like i knew she couldn't win again or at least not with another 1000 points since she is already so far ahead everyone else so that wasn't good for the whole "who would win" aspect of the show however it was not a 5-0 thing especially since her performance is the most viewed one on all the channels that upload this show. They should've made it a 3-2 or even a 4-1. Yubin deserves a win don't get me wrong but they didn't need to disrespect us and moonbyul like that just to try to close the gap btwn the points.

[@JJ-nj6ek]

this round really showed the true colours of these judge

[@susan2316]

You Jtbc are so disrespectful. This stage is breakthrough of moonstar’s vocal, a result of her diligent practice, a presentation of the original song. She respect the stage, respect the composer and respect us fans. I’m so proud of her.

[@EXOglobe]

Seems like they give Yubin pity votes cause they realized that the shows main view count is for Moonbyul. They probably have to make things interesting so viewers can tune in to see what happens next. It’s very obvious that wanted Moon byul to go all out next round which will be what happens.

[@KayaaaaDe]

I just lost my respect to this show. I only have watched Byul's cuts from this show and really thought "finally a good show". But now i am not really sure. Now i wonder what they told the other contestants too.

[@randomvideostokillboredom9672]

Same, I don't like to watch this show anymore to be honest. Maybe they just have a different taste from us. I don't know already. At least even a vote for byul could be acceptable but.. 😑