Kalasha People: Shrouded in Myth & Mystery, Unraveling a Dark Reality as a Minority! Syed Gul Kalash

Connect with me on Instagram / imrannoshadkhan
Welcome to "The Northern Podcast" with your host Imran Noshad Khan. In this episode, we dive deep into the rich history and origins of the Kalash people with our esteemed guest, Syed Gul Kalash. Explore the genetic past, vibrant festivals, and cultural background of the Kalash Valley. Syed Gul shares insights on the current tourism situation, shedding light on the challenges faced by the Kalash people. From the troubling treatment by tourists to the preservation of Kalashi culture, join us for a compelling conversation. Stay tuned for an eye-opening discussion on gender roles, the education system, and the disappearing cultures across different states of Pakistan. Don't miss this thought-provoking episode as we unravel the realities and experiences of the Kalash people.
00:00 Highlights
00:40 Intro
1:55 The origins and history of Kalash and its people
7:53 The genetic past of the Kalash people
12:55 Festivals of Kalash Valley and their concepts
17:12 Cultural background and realities of Kallash valley
23:53 Gul on the current tourism situation of Kalash Valley
29:55 Terrible treatment of Kallash people by tourists
31:17 Gul narrates the terrible experiences of individuals attempting to convert her religion
38:02 Causes of the decline in the Kalash population
39:54 Gender roles in Kalash’s religion/culture
44:01 Education system of Kalash Valley
45:51 Gul’s experience in Hazara University Chitral
47:14 Gul outlines preventative measures to preserve Kalashi culture
49:16 Disappearing cultures of different states of Pakistan
51:25 Outro
Follow me on other mediums
/ imranpodcast
/ imrannoshadk
/ imrannoshad
Connect with Syed Gul Kalash
web. profile.php?...

[@ImranNoshad]

We are going to shoot a part 2 this week!! what questions do you guys want me to ask from Gul?

[@gauravbawa1134]

Hello Team u can ask this question ❓to urself that forcefully converting innocent ppl this way is an integral part of Islam done by Muhammad and Sahaba or not ? Secondly u can find out ur own history of how ur forefathers and mothers got converted to Islam (forcefully) Hint : ur great great grandmother's story is similar to Safiya's!

[@huzaifaahmadsiyal8426]

Apologize from us. the way we treat them or think about them is very bad. after listening you now i aware real things about kalash & i spread it .

[@sajjadkhan4179]

@@gauravbawa1134 did not find any history,albat hindu brahmans were not treating lower class and poor people of india well. in india they left hindus slavery and enter to islam and christianity,when they came out from hindus salvery.now look you indian ca not defeat your own bengali coz they ex hindus, there was no any respect for them when they left hindusm,so now they have thier own country and enjoying freedom

[@mumeezasyeda3531]

Saddening to hear kailashis suffer from this due to us..

[@sajjadkhan4179]

@@mumeezasyeda3531 no ture. kailash mien ur bg mien crime rates zero hai from dacates....go and check the record, she is lying,she di not go to police staion and she did not report because this thing not happened,and she is lying for collecting fun from internation comunity,Fraud funds they are recieving from others

[@sagardutta799]

Unlike modern day Hinduism, nature worship has been very integral part of vedic culture. I think we can safely conclude it is a tribal branch of Hinduism. I hope Pakistan will protect them from forceful conversion

[@sagardutta799]

Addition: the word Kalash comes from the Kailash or the foothills of himalayas

[@youknow6968]

It's not a tribal form of Hinduism, it has nothing whatsoever to do with Hinduism. Stop appropriating everything, it's very childish. All early religions had nature worship, and all religions evolved from that. All religions in the world have a degree of similarities when you dig deep, that doesn't mean they are related. Similarities mostly exist by coincidence, not necessarily by design.

[@sabrinakhan8217]

The term Hindus was coined by persians for people of indus Sindh. It literally means Kala chor. Ghouri created his kingdom after conquering multi-religious, multi-cultural, multi linguistic region he named it Hindusthan and started calling non Muslims as Hindus. Then Britain created India after re conquering historically, culturally, linguistically and racially separated nations one by one. To unite polytheists against Muslims, during Late 1800's ,viveknanda, Gwaliar, Arya Smaj, RSS schools of thought started hallucinating all regions under British empire as Akahad Bharat that never existed. Maurya Kushan were from Northwest ( current Pakistan) and have always nvaded ganga jamuna. Mauryans alone killed 5 million ganga Jamnis. He didn't know what Hindu, Hindusthan, Bharat, or India is. Ask South Indians, They hate kingdoms of Indusvally and were refusing to call themselves Hindus until Indra Gandhi bombed tamil Tigers twice.

[@sagardutta799]

@@youknow6968 that's very shallow of you and your understanding of Hinduism. To begin with, there's no religion called Hinduism. It's a life style of people Born on the banks of Indus River. Unlike Islam, Hinduism is not even a defined religion. Different people within India itself follow it very differently and in contrast to one another. And some form nature worship is common in all of them. Hence we can safely conclude Kalash is a tribal branch of Hinduism, if we keep your hindu hate aside

[@wandererinwonder6977]

​@@sabrinakhan8217you didnt listen her carefully then. 39:00 she talks about KARMA.. And karma is literally a hinduism indian concept..

[@prabic9053]

The Kalash people are primarily practitioners of the traditional Kalasha religion, which is a form of Animism and Ancestor worship mixed with Ancient Hinduism. Mahandeo is a deity whom the Kalash pray to and is known as Mahadev in other languages of the Indian subcontinent in modern Hinduism.The faith adhered to by the Kalash have both pre-Vedic and Vedic influences and resembles the form of ancient Hinduism. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kalash_people

[@FraudBugEradicator]

Stop your Iies They believe in Karma, rebirth and reincarnation; their origin is Sanatan Dharma. Pre-vedic is Briitish construct. Vedas are eternal and most ancient.

[@capricorn9186]

Kalasha=Kailash=Shiva Shyam=Krishna Actually they are hindu..

[@SatishYadav-hi4qf]

Kalash hindu hai enk root sanatan dharma se hai

[@_Bappu_]

"Kalash" The word itself denotes thier religion. Makes sense

[@arhammirza1205]

@@_Bappu_ randian claiming everything🤡

[@sk61186]

Their misfortune that they got stuck with the most radicalised and shrewd people of the world.

[@SMian-ed7ld]

I see the most hateful comments from indians As if nothing happenes to non Hindus over there in india

[@nom278]

Hindus?

[@GalickJr]

​@@nom278 nah , chuslims

[@crimsoncrysolite5056]

​@@nom278 the fking audacity to say that!

[@faaeztalha8271]

​@@nom278😂😂

[@phuntsogangchuk3508]

Your brother's and sisters who migrated to Ladakh hundreds of years before have strictly preserved Kalashi culture. Today they are spread around five villages with a population of four thousand. Their villages are called Aryan vally of Ladakh. Villages are Dha, Hana, Darchik, Garkon and Byama. They are known as Drokpa buddhist. As per the recent order of Government of India you can get citizenship of India. You just have to declare that you are a branch of Aryan vally of Ladakh ,Drokpa buddhist. This is the only way you can preserve your thousand year old culture ,Like Aryan vally. You have to get out of the totally intolerant Islamic society and culture.

[@raconteurhermit1533]

The Islamic ideology very nature is predatory and proselytizing ,emboldened by its soteriology. While slavery existed much of its support was derived from Islam and Islamic countries. There is no obligation on Muslims to release his slaves "..rather, while lightening ,he rivetted the fetters", Koran in matter of slavery is enemy of mankind & woman as usual are greatest sufferers. The Abrahamic debated till recent times on whether women have souls. Islamic invasions were so huge & brutal that scale of people enslaved from India created an entire race of people called Roma, started in Sindh 8th & 11th century Ghaznavid Invasions of India kzbin.info/www/bejne/e5CXhGeprd18bZo For feminists, In Islam marriage is not allowed with Non Muslim & its considered Zina (adultery or fornication ) punishable by stoning to death ,so no Muslim family allows it unless girl converts to Islam So there is no option of marriage without conversion.

[@prponline33]

Most welcome Gul ji with your entire community to India for permanent settlement

[@bichlaa4595]

You are correct 💯

[@yousafsardar8411]

No Body want to go to india - you will force them to accept ram,shiv,krishna into their society or may be cow muter 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@bipins7295]

Even in ladakh, islam is spreading its roots.😢

[@shehla8213]

Totally agreed wd the respected lady and fully ashamed of so called Muslims who are not looking themselves but their only duty to critics and tableegh without being practical

[@bhaumikgandhi5499]

Because it's return in your quran. Thanks to exmuslim sahil like people who now spreading awareness about wuran in india

[@shenibrohibrohi8368]

Bhaumi don't talk things about u don't know

[@bhaumikgandhi5499]

@@shenibrohibrohi8368 I know thanks to sahil. And if you don't agree it's your problem. I can see around the world which community is more aggressive and don't follow rule of law so please don't try to teach me

[@balghari6391]

@@bhaumikgandhi5499 shut up bro hindus acting moraly good is the most funniest thing look at what bjp is doing to minoritys

[@user-rk7pg4bb7q]

Stay in your limits İf you don't know anything then it's better for you to shutup

[@athargulraiz4785]

What a lady , epitome of grace and courage... I'm in an owe of Klaashi Culture, what a festive , colourful, and enlighten culture. This is what education can achieve.. I hope Klaashi people stay in harmony and remain committed to their roots.... Love for KLAASH and KLAASHI ❤

[@naveensharma3331]

This is Himachali culture specially Sirmour and Shimla

[@balghari6391]

no its not its dardic culture nothing comon with himachal or any other indians culture except ladakhi sheen dards but that also belongs to pakistan

[@satyamgupta6986]

You right bro

[@satyamgupta6986]

It's similar

[@nagp7650]

@@balghari6391there was no Pakistani culture.😂75 years birth.to have a culture atleast few generations passed away

[@AI-ok1ch]

@@nagp7650 pakistan was nebver part of india we were never rundians

[@LastBangladeshHindu]

Karma is sanatan tradition since pre vedic period till now 🕉🐄🛐

[@capricorn9186]

Kalasha=Kailash=Shiva Shyam=Krishna Actually they are hindu..

[@Two_wheels7373]

বাংলাদেশের কোথায় থাকেন বাঙালি বাবু।

[@zoomzoom7444]

Wow! What a lovely culture. She talked about karma just like in Hindu Dharma snd Shamanic rituals. 🙏🦚❤

[@capricorn9186]

Kalasha=Kailash=Shiva Shyam=Krishna Actually they are hindu..

[@mariyakhan-gx7zj]

​@@capricorn9186they eat beef

[@capricorn9186]

@@mariyakhan-gx7zj tumlogoka force karne se yaisa huwa hoga..

[@nopek1405]

​@@mariyakhan-gx7zjtamil hindus also eat beef,assam hindu also eat beef, hinduism is much large than what you think.

[@AI-ok1ch]

@@capricorn9186 thryr are not dir....ty as hinfooz

[@Sagar_RS]

In india there's a tribe called brokpa similar to kalash. They are protected very carefully.

[@tabatagu7182]

Kalash tribe is similar to Nyishis,apatang and Adi of Arunachal pradesh.we are also coming from supung and siyam in our folk Lore.

[@rpat17]

Yes the beads also looks similar. But the facial feature looks different

[@gaeig]

Where does your tribe believe Siam is?

[@knmurthy7927]

Pl shed more light on information of Nyishis and Apatang

[@kmt55]

Bro they are worshipping ancient rig Vedic gods , Stanford univ professor made research about their gods go in weekipedia and learn about their gids

[@NiKhilShaRmA-hq2xx]

Is shyam(Shree Krishna ) is similar to siyam?

[@akhilghag5898]

Islam believes in Kalma.... others believe in Karma

[@UmarKhan-cf6bx]

Karma in islam we call it ache aur Bure amaal jo jaisa karega waisa bharega

[@Prasunz001]

@@UmarKhan-cf6bx Or sabse acha amaal hai dusro ko islam kabool karwana taaki aapka jannat ka ticket pakka ho jaaye, right?

[@mariyakhan-gx7zj]

​@@Prasunz001 ghar wpaasi kya jisse ke liye sary hindu bjp ko support krty?

[@Prasunz001]

@@mariyakhan-gx7zj There is a difference between politics and religion my dear.

[@user-tk9qg5sk3o]

​@@Prasunz001 Right. Kyu hindu log nehi karte ye sab? Kyu Buddhists ko mara gya tha, nikal diya gya tha hindu raja ke dawrun.

[@user-nc1hv4iv1j]

The lady is very straightforward and courageous

[@rohidasdagale]

Kalash is not intertentment it's Way of life.....! Indigenous Tribes Culture 💚🌍🙏🏾

[@maheshreddy6609]

ఇస్లాం మతం యొక్క నిజమైన స్వరూపం ఇదేనని మనం అందరూ గుర్తించాలి. అది మానవాళికి ఎంత ప్రమాదమో కూడా తెలుసుకోవాలి. వారిలో మతఛాందసవాదం తప్ప మానవత్వం ఉండదు. ఈ ప్రపంచంలో ఏ ఒక్క ముస్లిం దేశం కూడా సెక్యులర్ దేశంగా లేదు కదా!?! ? ఎందుకు??? వారు ఇతరుల హక్కులను, ఆస్తులను, దోచుకుని వీలైతే వారిని ఇస్లాం మతంలోకి మత మార్పిడి చేస్తారు లేదా చంపేస్తారు. ఈ విషయాన్ని ప్రపంచ దేశాలు గుర్తించి తగిన చర్యలు తీసుకోకపోతే పరిణామాలు చాలా తీవ్రంగా మారిపోతాయి.

[@djdongurpreetsingh5396]

❤❤❤❤u need sikh isam

[@emperoroak7331]

Yes thats true

[@financialplannermandar1138]

You are very correct. It is Curse to the world and humanity

[@yousafsardar8411]

SHUT UP[

[@yousafsardar8411]

@@djdongurpreetsingh5396 NO BODY WANT SIKHI

[@girishn1762]

We are all hindus lot's of love and respect from Telugu state,Andhrapradesh❤❤❤

[@user-en6ek3vc7v]

We're all Humans and not Hindus. Hindu is a political priestly controlled idealogy which segregates human in lower and upper caste that is the most evil inhuman idealogy.

[@yousafsardar8411]

she don't recognized vedas , mahabharat or ramayan - how can she is hindu

[@deeptamak6362]

@@yousafsardar8411 she said she believes on karma 😅 this is sanatan😂 converted bro

[@JPRinntu]

​​@@yousafsardar8411 To become hindu it is not mandatory to recognise vedas😂.... Hindu religion is not like your rigid religion of Isalm..... If any people don't believe in hindu god and it's philosophy then also he can be a hindu..... To know more about this you can study charbaka philosophy, which is Also integral part of Hindu religion....

[@yousafsardar8411]

@@JPRinntu oh my friend study vedas - it say if you dont recognise vedas., kill him, cheer doo paar doo., This is the issue with your hinduo's you guys dont study your holy books.

[@prponline33]

Woh ! What a wonderful lady.... she is really cultured, highly knowledgeable and an excellent communicator. I loved the Podcast. Kalash people are direct descendants of lord Shiva whose abode is Mount Kailash. They are original recipients of four Vedas from heaven to whom Britishers called Aryans. They are Pure Sanatanis found in Kalash valley, Ladakh valley & Himachal & Arunachal pradesh. These rare & pure quality of humanity must be given full protection where ever they are. I love Kalash people, i respect them & pray God for their well being. 🙏 Ranjan Pattanayak from Jagannath Puri, Odisha, India.

[@FaisalGhaffar]

More Kailashi people should come to such podcasts. More visibility of the this community will educate more people.

[@wandererinwonder6977]

Kalash people pay taxes.. It is Pakistan government responsibility to educate Pakistani jahil kom.....

[@Ammaralishah2]

​@@wandererinwonder6977 Nikal paleed Indian..tum loog slums me rehne walay ho.. India me tu har roz riots hote han.. India ko puri duniya badbodar kheti ha

[@iSleepDoc]

What an intelligent person she is!!! I really feel so bad about how some of us Muslims think that we need to convert everyone to Islam. I really apologize to her and all kalash people for all the harm we are doing to their culture. Pakistan govt should really take strict action to protect this beautiful culture and religion!!!

[@maheshreddy6609]

చివరకి ఒక మనిషిని నేను కనుగొన్నాను నీ నిజాయితీ కి ధన్యవాదములు. ముస్లిం సమాజంలో నీలాంటి వారు వర్ధిల్లాలి. సంకుచిత భావాలు కలిగిన వారు నశించాలి లేదంటే ఇస్లాం నశిస్తుంది.

[@Goldenwordsinfo]

I think 🤔 everyone should have religious rights through a proper channel by a political religious party at government level even non Muslims I totally agree with it 💝

[@ranasingh4356]

Do you have a government in pakitan ??

[@CompNerd91]

Imran, you're doing a good work by giving platform to this beautiful culture. Kalashis are tribal branch of Hinduism. Unfortunately, we left them with pakistan. More power to Kalashi people, Lord of Kailash MAHADEV will always blessed you. Har Har Mahadev

[@Suryanarayana-mx8mh]

She is a very spirited lady. Hinduism is also a way of life and I am not saying this but the Philosopher S.Radhakrishnan about a century ago. Marriage is a sacrament to us too. Very sacred. We celebrate the Spring Festival too.

[@LastBangladeshHindu]

U r right, all non Abrahamic faith including pre islamic Arabia has same God same culture same temple same heart ❤(with different name ) as Hinduism example tengri or Shinto or shrana or Tamil Hinduism 🐄🛐

[@Ddgbbhgffnknbbbbbb]

No bro what about sati. Burning woman with her died husband . British stopped this cruelty in subcontinent (India+Pakistan+Bangladesh). Only secular and democratic state can be able peace and equality in people

[@Suryanarayana-mx8mh]

@@Ddgbbhgffnknbbbbbb those who want to resurrect two or three hundred years old practices which are not in accord with the present, may do so.

[@AI-ok1ch]

keep your hinduism in rundia

[@adarshpandey2032]

Yes they are isolated people of Indo Aryan group with various ethnicity following ancient (Rigvedic Hinduism) religion. In short they are ancestors of Morden south Asian 10000 years ago. As Indian I hope they protect there culture.

[@yousafsardar8411]

They are not Hindu., they don't believe in Vedas

[@kmt55]

​@@yousafsardar8411how much you know about their gods ?how much you know about rig Vedic gods?go and search kalesh tribes and read Wikipedia god section of kalesh tribes

[@stardust2270]

​@@yousafsardar8411 they have a God named indra ...indra is a hindu vedic god who was worshipped 5000 years back

[@SingingblissofRajat]

​@@yousafsardar8411it's an is lamic garbage ideology that you need to follow one book to follow a civilization. What a joke 🤮

[@TheMohitsharmayoutub]

A strong woman you are. And i can see this strength came from all the good and bad experiences you had to face in your life. I truly wish your experiences are shared with younger kalash generations. Love from India 🇮🇳

[@rituarvind]

We Hindus also strongly believe in 'Karma'.

[@Goldenwordsinfo]

These women are beautiful 😍 U actually don't want to convert them in ur religion even U change ur religion due to their beauty 😍 and want them to give their religious rights to live in postulation with them media beauty for sale 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@himanshunagarwal1019]

They are the descendants of Of The Early Ancient Vedic Aryan Tribes

[@IamGOD278]

There's nothing like aryan so shut up

[@himanshunagarwal1019]

@@IamGOD278 they but they have less steppe % than average Ror or jaat

[@IamGOD278]

@@himanshunagarwal1019 I said shut up

[@RNathan-nm3mc]

Himanshu, You are 100% right - they truly are the descendants of Early Ancient Vedic Aryan Tribes

[@LastBangladeshHindu]

Krisna used to worship mountain govardhan ( cow pasture) mountain to break pride of king of gods called Indra but mahdeo always loved krisna being next form of sri ram 🐄🛐

[@ignacelakra6777]

Krishna worship goverdhan for what. Mountain give to them but Krishna never worship goverdhan by calling it God of universe

[@LastBangladeshHindu]

We also called woman 👩as nature 🌿🍃& flower 🌺🌻🌹🌷and shkati 💪power like al lat or bhavani or bhav means nature 🐄🛐

[@crashthechemistry7339]

This program should be on mainstream media channels

[@vkone7162]

I know little about Hinduism and one of my friend is hindu and things she said is very similar to their culture.

[@gangadeshmatakimaut4739]

Hinduism is an vague term (in context of religion) concocted in 1833 by the British, these people have nothing in common with Aghori Baba's from the Ganga.Regards

[@Tanya-kk4zm]

@@gangadeshmatakimaut4739 ..... we do not use hindu term in our temples or any of our ritual rather we use sanatan dharma n followers of sanatan r known as sanatani or arya ( real name of hindus ) n almost all hindu knows that, hindu isn't their real name it's nothing more than geographical term later people accepted it as a religious name .hindu word isn't mention in any of our religious text like Veds, Bhagwat Geeta , n Puranas , our geeta n veds always mention about sanatan dharma n arya ..... n there are 84 ganga banks in varanasi where aghori baba's only lives , where cremation is going on, away from common people , so when these aghoris r way different from natives of Ganga land then how come they will share similarities with kalash people .... u know nothing about sanatan dharma nothing about lord shiva or why he use to lives in kailash , why we call lord Shiva as a kailash pati all u know about sanatna ( hinduism ) is aghori , n ganga ....moreover Gomukh , terminus of the Gangotri glacier in the himalaya from where Ganga originated , people over there shares similarities with kailash people or other himalayan tribes

[@FraudBugEradicator]

​@@gangadeshmatakimaut4739Stop lying. Hindu term is mentioned in Rigveda, Mahabharat and Skand Puran,over 9000 years old.

[@NativeBharatiye]

​@@gangadeshmatakimaut4739 how is aghori way of living is relevant in this conversation 😒 aghoris live in secluded place in shamshanghat

[@NativeBharatiye]

@@gangadeshmatakimaut4739 you are muslim guy, still have no courage to admit it. That really show how weak your Allah & Mohammad are. You other comments literally show u as muslim under hindu name. Shame on you , your fake Allah & pdo momo

[@sameerdurgoji5583]

Beautiful culture Kalaash ❤ it is not a religion, but a way of life ✨ Respect from India

[@ergkg]

Kailash and shyam word is use verious times in Hinduism.

[@fifa_edits77]

I am a non-Muslims. my experience is:- musalmano me tablig ka kida hai Jab dosti gahri ho jati hai to vo islam ki dawat or tablik jarur karte hai Kabhi kabhi to aisa lagta hai ki vo conversion karane ke liye hi dosti karte hai. Unka bas chale to jabardasti musalman bana de MENTAL PROBLEM

[@dennisthemenace4288]

It's part of theology to give dawah. But force in not allowed.

[@SingingblissofRajat]

Correct.

[@jaffarimtiaz3228]

Main muslim hun lkn muj main esa keera ni esi trha koi sensible liberal Muslim bnda hoga os main esa koi chull machaa ni hoga mslaaa ye hai k Muslims ko prhaya yehi jata hai k kisi non Muslim ko Muslim krwaa do tumhari jannat paki hai.....

[@waseemahamad5209]

Tum hindu to musalmano ko jaan se maar dete ho agar hindu na bane to India me roj lynching karte ho gay shree ram ke naam par

[@XyzAbc-sm7eh]

Islam ki dawat nahi hum unse chicken mutton aur beef ka dawat khayenge

[@pratyushaghosh661]

She's an IRON LADY, Miss Syed Gul Kalash! I'm in awe with her! As a history, genetics, culture and anthropology enthusiast, this video was tremendously enlightening! Keep up the good work Imran Ji! Love from India! ❤❤❤

[@AI-ok1ch]

rundia

[@pratyushaghosh661]

@@AI-ok1ch Bot ho kya? Itne behude ko insaan nahi kaha jata

[@Aitorma_Debbarma]

Bohut kuch jan ne ko mila kalash log bohut sundhar bohut achhe hai. 💚 from Tripura🇮🇳

[@TruthseekerAC]

Best wishes from Bangladesh for our Hindu brother and sisters of Kalash(Kailash) valley. Protect your culture from jih@dis and safe guard your people. #HindusInDanger #culture #SaveHindus #minorities

[@redrose2905]

Jitna marzi protect karo jisky dill ko haq baat ko qabool kerna hota hay woh khud ker leta hay yehwoh roshni hay jo her jagha pahunchy gi

[@bharatrao7021]

​@@redrose2905tumhara pegambar hi jute khane layak hai

[@KanuniSuleyman4857]

Chal bay kangali we live our minorities 😘

[@AI-ok1ch]

bundgaali has no connection to pakistan they arent hindus

[@AI-ok1ch]

binduism is for bangalis and dravidians

[@hsk7717]

Kalash culture is very similar to himachali culture. They follow vedic culture.. It is so sad ki hmara hazaro saal purana culture mughals aur baki islamic invaders ne taabah kr diya...

[@alankritakaushal]

Yes. I am a Himachali and this seems so close.

[@capricorn9186]

Kalasha=Kailash=Shiva Shyam=Krishna Actually they are hindu..

[@raconteurhermit1533]

The Islamic ideology very nature is predatory and proselytizing ,emboldened by its soteriology. While slavery existed much of its support was derived from Islam and Islamic countries. There is no obligation on Muslims to release his slaves "..rather, while lightening ,he rivetted the fetters", Koran in matter of slavery is enemy of mankind & woman as usual are greatest sufferers. The Abrahamic debated till recent times on whether women have souls. Islamic invasions were so huge & brutal that scale of people enslaved from India created an entire race of people called Roma, started in Sindh 8th & 11th century Ghaznavid Invasions of India kzbin.info/www/bejne/e5CXhGeprd18bZo For feminists, In Islam marriage is not allowed with Non Muslim & its considered Zina (adultery or fornication ) punishable by stoning to death ,so no Muslim family allows it unless girl converts to Islam So there is no option of marriage without conversion.

[@porothashawarma2339]

True even their dresses reminds me of Pahadi people

[@akhileshnegi3733]

I am from uttarakhand, there dress does not seems to be similar to our but the culture , there practices seems quite similar. We all phadi are connected in some way

[@MrMAhmed22]

I am proud of Kalash Valley and its beautiful people. Muslims need to learn a lot

[@user-ly6lm4zf8g]

Proud aside are you fine with what she is telling about forcible conversions. Why a big nation cannot tolerate a small community, they all belong to ur ancestors faith isn't.

[@Indian-Hindu9]

Shame on Islam 😢 Force conversion 😢😢😢😢

[@kmt55]

Timur and ghaznavi forcefully converted our rig Vedic brothers in nooristhan (kafirsthsn ) they are the worshippers of mahan deo mahandev

[@ShSh-xi4rd]

mslms must let them leave alone

[@piskurisabelle7221]

Feel so touched to listen to a brave kailash woman who opens her heart answering a real sensitive , open interviewer . Thanks to both of you ! We need people like you to build a peaceful world .. i dream to get subtitles next time .im french and for sure i can improve my hindi but i miss a lot too. I met Dha , Hanu people in Ladakh who said to me they came from Gilgit ...wish to meet kailash and Miss Gul .. what a wonderful podcast. MERCI from the core of my heart 🙏🌈 isabelle

[@prashantdevadiga6696]

Amazing Podcast 👌👌 Mother Nature is Supreme 💯

[@maqsodcrs]

Gul we are always with you. You are brilliant. We feel proud for being our Kalashi sister. Thank you Imran for such an informative podcast. We are anxiously waiting for the next episode.

[@sabrinakhan8217]

She seems like a result of mix marriage. Such a shame.

[@Aparichit4725]

Kalashi Kailashvasi Hindu he Jo 🇮🇳India ka part he Bhagvan🕉️ 🔱Shiv Istdev he Kalashi ke....🙏🇮🇳

[@ra1944]

yai wo kalash nhi hai

[@Criketkida]

😂😂

[@hariKrishnasharnam]

Kailash duniya me ke hai lekin kailashi sb jagah....

[@capricorn9186]

Kalasha=Kailash=Shiva Shyam=Krishna Actually they are hindu..

[@ra1944]

@@capricorn9186 wo kailash mt Everest ke highest point pa hai, waha oxygen v nhi hai aadmi kaha sai hoga

[@xyzind]

Many tradition, rituals,way of singing, marriage are matching with ancient Bihar specially in between north of Ganga and Nepal.

[@fnm2968]

She is very right. Everything she is asking is thinkable for us. Kalash peoples are rare gems of our country. We should respect them. They are kind hearted and welcoming people. We cannot bear interference in our home so why are we interfare in their culture and society. They respect and honor guests. Best wishes for them.

[@thepakistanihomeschooler5510]

Deep apologies Miss Gul for everything that you have to go through! You're right, your culture is beautiful and as you stated approximately 7000 years old, it's unique and I am sure if people ever try to read about it, and explore it, they will learn many things. Bless you, stay happy! I really enjoyed your conversation and am sure to listen to you for hours and hours! You are very intelligent and eloquent.

[@wandererinwonder6977]

It is Pakistan responsiblity to explore and include them into syllabus..

[@INDIANATHEIST526]

islam destroys every culture

[@user-nc1hv4iv1j]

In Bharat we follow spring festival as new year in April. Then in August, we follow harvest festival. Again Diwali in October or November, when again we say new season or new year begins. Different flowers considered to be liked by different gods, different plants worshipped. Water, fire, sun, moon are respected. We sing, dance in our festivities. Its way of life, along with teachings of way of dharmic life from scriptures

[@yasirurooj8749]

Iranians and Afghani have Noroz so lundians are nothing extraordinary

[@moments4727]

Not everyone is related to your Bharat idiots

[@SingingblissofRajat]

​@@yasirurooj8749iranis and afghanis got it from Hindus as their ancestry was from central vedic Bharat. Pe*nis cut fu'k face wouldn't understand.

[@ignacelakra6777]

And that to subjective to different geographical location

[@user-nc1hv4iv1j]

@@ignacelakra6777 time of harvesting festival will change. But other festivals generally are based on lunar movement or position of sun (as in Souramaan Yugadi). Ofcourse, the customs of celebration may differ, some festivals are celebrated with much fervor in one region while in other regions it may not be celebrated such

[@bantythakur100]

Whatever she described, that's very close to Hindus. Remember, Hindu is not religion but culture, way of living. No one force anyone to follow particular god or way of living. This is why Parsi community exists in India but almost eliminated from their roots.

[@anshitaacharya5849]

Very true

[@Rupaligreat]

True, crow pujan ,all seasons,songs for every festival even situation

[@user-tk9qg5sk3o]

Buddhists logo ko kayi hindu raja wo ne nikal diya tha, mara tha. History padho.

[@Rupaligreat]

@@user-tk9qg5sk3o kindly explain authentic reference please, fake historians,fake narrative etc etc damage thinking power btw insaan bura hai toh apne bhai ko bhi maar deta hai uska us waqt ka dimag kisi manyta per nahi hota use bas bura karna hai isliye agar kisi fake sanatani ne kisi Buddhist ko kuch kiya bhi hoga toh voh vyaktigat dushmani ki wazeh se .

[@user-tk9qg5sk3o]

@@Rupaligreat Maurya empires specially Ashoka killed many buddhists, destroyed their temples but later he converted into that religion. Now i know about the bengals better that rest of india, here king shashank deliberately killed many buddhists and monk, drove them out to Nepal,bhutan. Then came shen Dynasty(radical hindu brahmin empire), they destroyed Buddhists scripture, stopped old Bengali language to be used and imposed sanskrit instead.

[@akansharai2318]

What an enlightening video.... so informative 👍🏻👍🏻

[@vijaysingh-xy4mb]

Why they are named kailash?? Yet mount kailash is situated in tibet as the home of lord shiva and Buddhists and Hindus bow down infront of mount kailash.

[@yousafsardar8411]

Hindu bow down to yogi , ling , elephant, mouse , so many other things

[@vijaysingh-xy4mb]

@@yousafsardar8411 that's why we are far more educated than muslims who still believe earth is flat.😂 what's your contribution to the world??

[@luckysharma4593]

​@@yousafsardar8411 I think u have read hinduism in quraan

[@yousafsardar8411]

@@luckysharma4593 koran have no such things, niyog is in vedas, ling puja , yoni puja., kamakhaya mandir - go and see yourself

[@shubh.bapi_9423]

Well, simply put Hindus donot believe God is exclusive, separable from its creation. What we see this physical reality of universe is the Maya enshrined within the realm of God, the truth, The BRAHMAN, it is who ​has taken multiple manifestation are actually one god. Hindu bow and bestow their gratitude to Sun, Moon, the learned Yogi searcing for moksha, the cat, the man's best friend, the dog, the rivers the sea, the rain, the teacher, our parents, and so on! Ths doesn't degrade the status of our deities aka Vishnu or Shiva or Devi or Brahma, etc, neither it berates Brahman, When our soul and Supreme God's soul are different but inseparable then I am surely proud of this philosophy.@@yousafsardar8411

[@rubinamir7340]

Plz continue 2nd part . We are waiting. ❤

[@vibhagurtu9632]

Beautiful Conversation !

[@mehrubawan]

This is such a beautiful podcast

[@athargulraiz4785]

What a shame we are as a community , im sorry ... im sorry to All klaashi people ... I wish we could start practicing " LIVE AND LET LIVE " ... let the people live in harmony and peace

[@madhumandavi2127]

Your wish can't fulfill until abrahmic religions will be demolished ...

[@ankusshdharma9763]

Kalash people =Old khash people...very simillar to khash culture of himachal

[@himmsingz]

Very informative interview. Excellent!

[@youknow6968]

What a beautiful discussion, and a beautiful culture.

[@avisioncreator9517]

35:45 -- I am totally agreed with you on this point. Bravo-Live and Let Live

[@sarahkhan3711]

Such a lovely podcast! Such a courageous lady…so eloquent, highly educated and polite! May their culture remain in tact. And prosper.

[@neerajsingh5358]

*5:26** ye books jalane wale hamesha Islam ke oarcham leke kyu chalte h, bin kasim, Khilji, babur etc, inko books se kya dikkat h*

[@truthshallrise]

Are you even educated? She is talking Mangols from central asia who killed millions of muslims as well! Educate yourself! why do indians have to comment on everything ( without any knowledge) related to Islam in general and Pakistan in particular? What is this obsession?Get a life!

[@ShubhamGupta-ji5jj]

Kyonki mohammad ne khud arab ki culture aur waha ke knowledge system ko khatm kar dia..wo pre Islamic arab culture ko jahailiyat kehta tha... isliye uske follower jaha jaate the..waha ke culture ko khatm karte the aur phir Islamic ideology inject karte the...

[@princehamza890]

Kalash ki books afghano ne jlai thi.

[@silenceofpotato674]

Beauty of Piss-lam. I'm a Bangladeshi Hindu. & this kind of thing used to happen to me also. Though not at this scale.

[@siddiquiakram1890]

Lindu piss spotted here

[@siddiquiakram1890]

Lindu piss spotted here😂

[@MuhammadIshtiyaqueAdam-vu7hc]

Lindu Saitan

[@user-zv8js6wt2y]

@silencefpotato674 If you hate others, you can't complain about being hated in the same breath, because you're also a hater. Also nothing is more beautiful than Islam, thanks for kind sentitments.

[@chandrashekhartuppad7167]

What a clarity on Karma

[@sanjeevdhingra2327]

Both the host and the guests were excellent and the questions were apt and the answers were wonderful.

[@tejkarki4826]

I am from Nepal . This podvast is very interesting. I respect the Great Kalash people.

[@abrahamharris1670]

Thoroughly enjoyed this podcast ❤❤

[@jatintrivedi5632]

Proud of you gul kalash. Stay strong with attitudes. God bless you.

[@user-pg5xw2bd3k]

Great job Imran. Looking forward to follow up interview. Gul - for the first time heard a proud Kalash person speaking her views/feelings and struggles in day to day life. Thanks a lot Gul. Please encourage more and more Kalash persons to talk to world.

[@ssam7384]

Allah ko wohi muh dikha Jo tere paas hai - epic line

[@shaileshjoshi3383]

'Shakh ke saath'. In indian languages also we call it 'Shakha'.

[@syedafatima871]

Weldon, excellent discussion, Zabardast Gul Sahiba

[@AjitKumar-qc4yv]

congratulations for this wonderful interview

[@AbraarB]

پاکستان کے تمام اقلیتوں کو اسمبلی میں نمائندگی حاصل ہے کیلاش کی نمائندگی کیوں نہیں ؟

[@amarshinde8359]

😂rahinde pakistan nahi o papistan hai...

[@komododragon410]

3000 people that's why

[@capricorn9186]

Kalasha=Kailash=Shiva Shyam=Krishna Actually they are hindu..

[@blackmoon655]

😂😂😂 they are not a hindu

[@ranasingh4356]

​@@blackmoon655 Whole of the planet was Hindu before...

[@mrahats6344]

Thankful for this podcast. It was new information

[@siddsy100]

Very interesting discussion. Good learning.

[@Proudpunjabi1512]

Such a brave laday....stay blessed

[@bikeshyadav7146]

Kailashi ka culture hindu dharm se bahut similar hai Sahi aur yah baat 100% Satya hai ine log ka purvaj Hindu the😊❤

[@sarmayanamandra1011]

I was going through the podcast and i could say that the interview is well educative. Also the knowledge of the Kalash woman is highly appreciative.

[@CD89973]

Very honest and wonderful journalism 👌🙏

[@DeepDive2023]

Excellent🎉

[@saeedullah7833]

Your way of speaking is appreciable and speaks of that Allah is guiding you in the right path for you are literally respecting human beings . Hats off to you madam from the bottom of heart Seed Ullah KPK ,Peshawar Ashrafia Colony street # 8

[@ajeyklg]

❤ great! Both of you were excellent. I could feel the perfect chemistry in this honest conversation. Ask more on ritulas, totems, religious beliefs, deities, place of worship, community activities, language , folklore and oral literature of Kalash... Liberty of women, economy , handicrafts , and more elaborate explainations of gender roles .

[@shortnews6273]

Welcome india 🇮🇳 ❤❤❤ Your culture is very beautiful .......

[@arsen1522]

I really want to visit Chitral one day and meet with the Kalash people. I really love my vedic roots but i feel I want to know more and I believe I'll get to know a lot about Vedicism when I interact with the Kalash people

[@gangadeshmatakimaut4739]

They have nothing in common with Lucknowis, Biharis etc.

[@arsen1522]

@@gangadeshmatakimaut4739 I'm just a curious explorer, I just want to learn what type of paganism do the people follow there ?

[@gangadeshmatakimaut4739]

@@arsen1522 Worshiping nature, mountains etc... are you from India ?

[@arsen1522]

@@gangadeshmatakimaut4739 Sí

[@kishandubey7882]

​@@gangadeshmatakimaut4739Well, they have a lot in common with Pahari Hindus of India Where are u from?

[@jagdish8240]

I believe carring out archiological projects in various part of the place will certainly throw the actual details of the people in the past and may find engraved or written work in the past.

[@sourajparkash1547]

Mind blowing, very informative.

[@saanjanibaar8085]

Last Vedic Indo-aryan Vedic tribals.

[@rajotavo]

Nothing to do with Greeks! These are purely Indo-Aryan people...proto- Vedic people...they practise a form of ancient 'Hinduism'...

[@Sagar_RS]

Yes . There are similar tribes in Bulgaria as well.

[@KomalAnwar-ub3qg]

Very nice conversation

[@rockesh123]

Shame on those people who are converting and degrading other religions, Khud toh convert hogaye ab dusron ko pareshan karte hain! Jai HIND!

[@ivarhakuse8572]

Christian missions will now arrive to save their souls, destroy their ancient culture, and extinguish their ancient spiritual roots. These people will then seek salvation in T-Shirts, jeans, McDonalds' burgers, alcohol, drugs and brothels. To be followed by an hour at church on Sunday to eat the flesh and drink the blood of Jesus and be given sermons on morals.

[@yousafsardar8411]

oh shut up you monkey ., no body is converting anyone understand its up to them to accept islam or not

[@user-vc9xo3kb2p]

For those saying this has nothing to do with Hindu religious traditions are misguided. The fact remains that the Kalasha religious traditions and practices are an early branch of the Vedic religion. Most of the deities they worship are mentioned in the Vedas. Nature played a very important role in the Vedic religion. The distance from Nature is also a very recent development in Hindu religious traditions. It is fascinating how many of the orthodox traditions the Kalasha still practice which are dying out even among orthodox brahmins in India today.

[@samhitabarman4118]

You're a very brave Kalash lady, glad to see you proudly upholding your culture inspite of hostile environment. Sending love from Australia ❤

[@BasharatHussain-md3ge]

Beautiful explanation of everything we are waiting for your next vedio

[@jagadishprasadtosawar2990]

Mrs Gul is a very intelligent lady. She is speaking very honestly and truthfully..Glade to hear about kalashi and knowledgeable.Thankhs God and save the kalaski and their culture and customs

[@parjanyashukla176]

Kalasha are just 1 part of greater Daradistan region, which goes in an arc from East of Kabul valley to Kashmir valley, marking the Northern border of Greater Punjab plains. This consists of Nuristan, Kohistan, Gilgit-Baltistan, Chitral and finally the Kashmir valley itself. These societies are nothing but peripheral (peripheral means non-mainstream) "Arya" or "Hindu" but both terms are problematic due to modern day politics. Vedic society evolved and destroyed in Punjab plains but they absorbed a few things but mainly remained aloof from history. I would sayya that they are Parvatiya Adivasi or Mountain Adivasi, just like we have Santhals/Munda which are Forest Adivasis in Jharkhand. They are not "mainstream Hindus" but peripheral Hindus.

[@yousafsardar8411]

They are not Hindu .,they dont believe in vedas

[@LastBangladeshHindu]

If all abrahmic r one than all pagan, nature 🌿🍃are one ❤

[@rahulp2644]

Nice video, very informative, salute this lady, very honest

[@hussainwarraich8139]

The best vlog on Kalashi culture! Thanks Mam Gul you're a wonderful reacher and human! ❤

[@user-ek7cx3js1q]

Nehru and Congress did way too much damage to India by letting the region go to Pakistan

[@rkrchaturvedi]

The area is surrounded by Muslim majority (94%)Kpk region having no ambiguity with border of india.so unfortunately it has to go to Pakistan and it was not their fault.

[@user-vc9xo3kb2p]

​@@rkrchaturvedi Technically Chitral was a princely State and a vassal of Kashmir. However, I believe the ruler of Chitral chose to go with Pakistan. Only part of Chitral is Kalasha the rest of the region was majority Muslim by this time.

[@ritiksharma6344]

​@@rkrchaturvedi It became muslim majority after Kohat genocide of Sanatanis during Khilafat movement

[@VinodBandari-ps5yd]

we got ladakh ( aryan valley)😂

[@kmt55]

Bro they are our ancient rig Vedic brothers they are the evidence that once hindus was existed in afganistan , Timur and ghaxnavu forcefully converted info Aryan religion people in nooristhan ,read about them,along with Pakistani minority they also need our help

[@shashikantdalwadi3326]

I like this interview, kalash lady’s transparency and interviewer’s soft spoken style is good and appreciated.

[@asishkumarsaha1885]

Sayed Gul Kalash You are an Enlightened person NAMASTE 🙏