Kanye West - My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy REDUX REVIEW

[@PaxAmericana__]

He gave this album a 6 twice, so really he’s saying that this album is a 12. Thank you melon man

[@swansonjoe7121]

The logic checks out. Here's your meme medal my dude 🏅

[@theneedledrop]

I love it when people find a silver lining.

[@wizard1370]

@@theneedledrop Indeed

[@AK-uj2zw]

theneedledrop I love you melon

[@jameswatts2310]

TLOP 14/10

[@nikovsj]

2010 : light to decent 6 2020 : strong 5 to light 6 Premeditated murder

[@seanc8130]

2030: decent to strong 5

[@brownleaf_o1]

Hahah

[@murilohdo]

2040: light to decent 5

[@BryceRogers_]

2050: strong 4 to light 5

[@Yottifferent]

2060: decent to strong 4

[@johncenaFU42]

I can't believe Anthony changed to a 5 point rating system.

[@fuzzyharmony]

Big Mouther creative. I applaud you

[@liamheafey]

first extra credit album

[@aaronquist8125]

Lol

[@owenf2835]

good job.

[@SirRunk666]

This is a good comment.

[@kirkhaskell9179]

This is like when the second plane hit the south tower.

[@YVman24]

damn lol

[@rodriligma9940]

perfectly described

[@PlumsYT]

Best comparison I have ever seen truly

[@trnnrjn561]

I'm dying at this 💀💀💀

[@Narcissist808]

Omg💀

[@rv.9658]

This man celebrates a subscribers milestone by telling them he still hates their favorite album.

[@monkeybusiness6687]

Lmfaooo

[@MikkelPickel]

Now that's alpha af

[@kjk607]

6 isn't a bad score. He just doesn't subscribe to the hype.

[@BRobMint]

He never said he hated it. He just thinks it’s overrated

[@rv.9658]

@@BRobMint potato potahto

[@ripricsaw]

Kinda disappointed he didn’t just repeat the old review word for word tbh

[@ilovecody7514]

Or just reupload it.

[@cai6972]

I actually liked that he elaborated a little more

[@owenjzx3070]

I thought it would've been hilarious if he gave it a lower score

[@TerreurTerence]

Or end the review right before giving the score.... sition have you given (while looking confused like he didnt expect to be there so soon)

[@Vedsetta]

That would have been a great April Fools video

[@VictorDiaz97]

Don't let Fantano giving MBDTF a 6 distract you from the fact that Fantano gave MBDTF a 6.

[@pianoboi4842]

Ikr? His bald egg-shaped head keeps on distracting me

[@thxvilla]

@@AbirInsights What the fuck am I reading here

[@cyborgsquad1756]

@@AbirInsights settle down there "stephen hawking assignment" headass

[@ek5160]

@@AbirInsights go pee in a lobster then boil that lobster and eat it

[@homelessman1453]

@@AbirInsights went a little too hard on him and got 6 likes from homophobes LMAO gj

[@tjgirard7557]

I recently got into Kanye and love this album, Hell of a Life is my personal favorite Kanye song of all time. Can't wait to see what Anthony thinks of it!

[@tjgirard7557]

oh

[@danpodgurschi3107]

@@tjgirard7557 underrated comment lmaoo

[@-Scrapper-]

@@danpodgurschi3107 6 likes underrated af

[@CaIebGG]

@@tjgirard7557 Banger no doubt

[@kingretub3513]

@@tjgirard7557 LMFAOOOOOO

[@vaguevtx5090]

Oh yeah melon? Well my mom said you can't come over anymore

[@bingbong754]

Vague Turtle hahahahaha yo this comment and the pic make it so perfect

[@giovannivieira5830]

@@bingbong754 right? I read it in a minecraft kid's voice lololol

[@tylerburton6558]

Where's my pizza man? I ordered it like 2 seconds ago

[@vaguevtx5090]

@@tylerburton6558 why is there a hole in the box melon

[@FrannieFibgert]

@@tylerburton6558 and i better get it too

[@fishoutofwater7743]

2010: light to decent 6 2020: strong 5 to a light 6 2030: NOT GOOD

[@ericlytle2209]

Fishout ofWater 2040: it’s arguably much worse than speeding bullet 2 heaven

[@somegeekguy]

2099: worst album of the century

[@Trazynn]

a NOT GOOD is better than a 0 or even 1. He gives NOT GOODs only to albums about which there isn't much else to discuss, usually by new artists. Someone like Kanye won't be able to get a NOT GOOD because there's so much to discuss if he made a bad album.

[@DrRocketLauncher]

This classic old President West album? It's NOT GOOD.

[@lilnoodleboy1658]

decentradical have you seen the wall by nostalgia critic

[@DolanDark]

Maybe in 2030 you'll give it a 7

[@peterkistler3537]

at this trajectory it's lookin more like a strong 5

[@MajorLeagueBassboost]

Another ten years he'll surely give it even less. Like a 4 or something

[@Noah-to1cq]

Maybe you'll shut up

[@nate803]

TGSFortunato dude I can’t believe it you made him shut up good job 👏🏼

[@thelssjbroly9873]

Underrated comment

[@josephhanicak7922]

I am still in awe that someone can listen to an album with Runaway, Power, and Devil in a New Dress and think "Yeah, this is a 6".

[@skerion7956]

Bro heard one of the greatest albums of all time and thought. Yeah this is decent.

[@couchwilly5575]

He’s trying to hard to be different

[@StrawberryLanza]

Runaway is corny, power has one of the worst mastering jobs ever, and devil in a new dress is way too quiet

[@josephhanicak7922]

@@StrawberryLanza I cannot believe that a person on this green earth can say those words unironically. Are you deaf? I can kinda understand Runaway, I strongly disagree but I get it. But Power has bad mixing? That's literally one of the best mixed songs of all time, with one of the most unique beats in hip hop history. It has three separate samples in the first 45 seconds of the song in ways that all uniquely add to the overall experience. And worst of all, Devil in a New Dress is too quiet?! What the fuck are you even talking about 💀 Did you listen to it with like, broken headphones or something? What part of the song is quiet? Just because the song isn't bombastic doesn't make it quiet. In fact, that lack of bombast is part of what makes Devil in a New Dress my favorite song of all time. It has an impeccable mood, starting with the fantastic beat and very evident emotional rawness in Kanye's voice, before a fucking awesome Mike Dean guitar solo and an amazing Rick Ross verse.

[@bacla100]

3 songs does not define an entire album. You judge the entire album not the best of it

[@kiddkrool]

"Can we get much higheeeer?" Melon: "No"

[@IVUSER]

Melon's answer should be that GIF of squidward saying NO.

[@goonwhiteboy]

lul

[@shivangigarg9280]

Hahahaha

[@cheesecakelasagna]

budjonbanjiel lul ka rin

[@johndo3650]

Kidd K Rool “we about to set this bitch on firee”

[@pwninc.4055]

I don’t think when Kanye said “all of the lights” he was talking about a light 6 melon

[@TheGamer280]

"all of the lights" = light 0, light 1, light 2, light 3, light 4, light 5, light 6, light 7, light 8, light 9, light 10. the album is a light 55

[@thirtyyearoldmulberryfield]

@@TheGamer280 Which when rounded up and out or 100 is still 6/10.

[@garywilliams6124]

I love this comment section

[@HipHopfan_]

🤦‍♂️

[@JUSTREGULARSCREAMINGAAHH]

​@@thirtyyearoldmulberryfield 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯

[@EikSike]

Respect for keeping your same opinion for 10 years! Unsubscribed.

[@swx6074]

XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD

[@cbrad_edits]

Your profile picture makes the comment much better

[@EikSike]

@@cbrad_edits holy shit... Just realized

[@luxxhaze]

lol?

[@MyBeautifulDarkTwistedFantasy6]

My profile picture is better

[@nspectorr]

fun fact: original MBDTF name was "My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantanosy"

[@jahterminatedlmao5473]

Wouldve probably gotten a 10 if that was kept

[@person8546]

@@jahterminatedlmao5473would’ve gotten a 10 if its name was “My Beautiful Dark ‘To Pimp a Butterfly’ Fantasy”

[@superchargedmvp2984]

7

[@user-qg5bl2kt7u]

MBDTF: CAN WE GET MUCH HIGHER??? Fantano: No

[@strangerofthe2067]

I was just about to copy this comment but then I saw that you already did

[@quiskeepitreal]

Will Valerio this comment is so underrated 😂

[@ritvik9489]

So highhhh

[@vladimirklizschko9337]

Thats a good one

[@WhatSmada]

well played

[@izzydrago34]

"Where'd you learn to treat an album like this?" "Melon taught me"

[@mrjos1404]

LMAO

[@mateusnobrega9092]

Melon reupholstered my taste

[@jezminfaq8289]

Melon taught you well

[@jacksonfournier8659]

Underrated comment 😂😂😂

[@Lil_Homeschool]

I just cracked up

[@alessio7702]

You're not a real fantano fan if you didn't dislike this video

[@HalfAryanHunterGatherer]

Almost forgot to un dislike just to re dislike it, thx bro

[@Onepieceistheworstanime]

Lol this is funny

[@amer-ib9gn]

I guess we can't get much higher

[@jesus.e126]

no no noooo :c

[@Brandon-sb3nw]

@@jesus.e126 So low

[@holymoly849]

This comment is meta

[@shmoneydance9911]

Brandon oh oh oh

[@yhavinmiles]

you will not see melons hands at the concert, this review leaves me *so* appalled

[@mikewalters7]

I mean yeah cool but you were supposed to like it more this time

[@investigate711]

Reapurr i mean it went from a light to a strong 6

[@davidwu8951]

:((

[@brandonayong752]

This was trolling at it's best

[@SnaggleWumpus]

investigate 3/11 it went from a light 6 to a strong 5 light 6

[@edheimberg7758]

HE CANT KEEP GETTING AWAY WITH THIS

[@MrSpencerMcIntosh]

HE KILLED CUDI...... JUST AS A MOVE YO

[@neimsterdam1638]

Lmfaoo

[@goldenchi1d228]

Don’t worry. We will stop him...together.

[@asvpfern]

LETS JUST TURN THE 6 UPSIDE DOWM

[@david0115]

Read this as Jesse lmao

[@Renzo1198]

I lost it once he praised Jay’s verse on Monster and talked down on Nicki’s. Nicki’s verse was so hot Kanye almost didn’t put it on the album bc he was afraid of getting overshadowed

[@grapeape4589]

Exactly brooo, it doesn’t help that Jays verse fucking sucked too

[@silverman1601]

i mean she was the highlight of the song so he was kinda right

[@grapeape4589]

@@silverman1601 except her verse was fire. Theres a reason that verse alone helped her career explode

[@silverman1601]

@@grapeape4589 that’s what i said. it was the highlight. it was good.

[@grapeape4589]

@@silverman1601 ohhh shit my fault, i misunderstood

[@Sephei]

2010: Light to Decent 6 2020: Strong 5 to Light 6 I have come to the conclusion that if Kanye released this album in 1870, it'd be a strong 10.

[@bigboineptune9567]

To be honest, if this album came out in 1870 I would rate it as the single best musical effort ever made by mankind. The amount of technology Kanye would have to invent to produce this masterpiece would be staggering.

[@Martwypłód2k12]

To 10 decade = 1 point. so it would have to came out in 1970

[@suned3128]

Mikołaj Dardziński But there’s also three tiers within the points. So: 2000: Decent to Strong 6 1900: Strong 6 to Light 7 1980: Light to Decent 7 1970: Decent to Strong 7 And so on

[@Martwypłód2k12]

@@suned3128 1960: strong 7 to light 8 1950: light to decent 8 1940: decent to strong 8 1930: strong 8 to light 9 1920: light to decent 9 1910: decent to strong 9 1900: strong 9 to 10 1890: *10*

[@swankyturtle6727]

Mikołaj Dardziński so close

[@matisepu8812]

Good luck explaining this to the president West

[@災厄-b9o]

R.I.P. Melon :'(

[@laug1576]

HAHA you mad

[@4Rbabi]

Maybe next elections

[@災厄-b9o]

@オクタビアンOCT calamity

[@zackzallie8735]

@オクタビアンOCT thats funny, id ask you the same thing lol

[@DrHurricaneA115]

Anthony is that teacher that doesn't curve your grade.

[@XD123771]

He increased TLOP’s score to an 8

[@jamhopsey]

My teachers curve it down when I ask :(

[@стрелок-ч7р]

I have never had a single teacher who curved my grade.

[@elusivegrain9162]

стрелок must be the smart and the lucky ones then. My class in Biology and Human Geo needed a curve to pump are grades for passing

[@Nazhussain07]

curve you grade

[@ryancranston2283]

"In celebration of hitting 2 million subscribers, I'm going to lose them all."

[@cheesecakelasagna]

I felt this on a spiritual level.

[@phil-bean]

Basically

[@franciscom.retamal2346]

"look how they re-masacred my boy"

[@keegananderson5924]

LMAO

[@unrealmuffin6836]

underrated commemt

[@royedking]

This is us waking up a decade later to find a light 6 (horse head) again

[@UntitledNameGangIsTouringAmmos]

MBDTF: Melon's Back Doing This Fuckery

[@AK6ix9ine]

Untitled Name Gang 😂

[@disjointedhoudini]

My Boy Did The Fuckup again

[@97EDUB]

At least it’s a 12/10.

[@brandonayong752]

He will give it another six in 10 years ...it will be 6 6 6

[@Aya_02571]

He’ll give it an 18/10 next time.

[@godofzucc5727]

Whitebeard: "THE 20:34 ! THE 20:34 IS REAL!" Anthony Fantano: 4:10

[@malupit8ian]

He say the thing

[@mazdamiata786]

SO HIGH

[@mediumrarechicken837]

I can die in peace now…

[@Klaux]

@@mediumrarechicken837 One Piece...

[@linixx10]

All of the lights Spot light Street light Stop light light 6

[@qtshutin3030]

turn on the light in here baby!! Extra bright I want y'all to see 6!!

[@traplover6357]

Flashing Lights Street Lights All of the Lights Highlights

[@bobball622]

Turn the 6 upside down it's a 9 now.

[@mayoislife4968]

Bob Ball turn the 9 upside down and it’s a 6

[@willblaker3746]

@@traplover6357 Lowlights

[@hello-hg4ki]

Anthony: *gives MBDTF a six* Me: re-review it Anthony: *gives it another six* Me: re-review it again

[@valx5]

top comment

[@upon.my.liars.chair.]

Its not that good stop

[@ogshrimpsauce]

10/10 review it again

[@SnaggingRaccoon]

@@upon.my.liars.chair. it's a meme

[@Swisha35]

@@prod.drewuplife3575 I personally agree with all of Melon's criticisms. I still haven't finished Ye's discog but it's still the worst one in it after listening to half of it or so.

[@tewr024]

melon actually dropped the score from “light to decent 6” to “strong 5 to light 6” lmaooo

[@TheeDeeM]

OK OK! So I just listened to MBDTF **for the first time** and knowing about your review of the album for a very long time, I was expecting the record to be just OK. People kept calling it one of the best albums ever and yadda yadda but, thanks to your reviews and finding hella good music, I was really expecting this album to not hit as much as people have said, but, man...this album is damn near flawless to me. MBDTF is amazing, it sounds like all the best sounds of that era in music in which I grew up.

[@yojackdylan]

exactly. this album at worst is a strong 8 to me but flourishes at a solid 9-10 on most listens/revisits. He always stresses this, it’s just his opinion. Opinions can’t be right or wrong, they’re just opinions.

[@小果儿-h7r]

History will remember this album and forget some unimportant ones

[@mrmxyzptlk8906]

@@yojackdylanand opinions can be garbage which his is.

[@20usuario]

The sounds ard goated but the lyrics is very mid.

[@Gastemaz]

​@@20usuario bro is music this isnt poetry

[@nilabhsaksena1634]

Keep in mind, this is the same guy who gave MBDTF a 6

[@fathersdayclub]

lmaooooo

[@chopstickingstylus]

amazing comment

[@Halotyman]

twice

[@JeromeProductions]

damn

[@gcwens]

@@JeromeProductions 7/10

[@WDESJ3]

Imagine if he moved the score down. That would have been a power move.

[@straightways25]

he did 2010s review was a light to a decent 6 this one is a strong 5 to a light 6

[@rolodexpropaganda]

Ion know why y’all let this white man hold so much weight on this album. This album is a perfect . Ain’t nothing this “melon head” gone say to change that. His hair gets a light fade to a strong disappear Transition

[@daniellarsen5520]

No one man should have all that power.

[@allforthebit]

@@rolodexpropaganda Only white people listen to Kanye foh

[@rolodexpropaganda]

Ben Jackson everyone listens to ye

[@murph46]

I respect that he stuck to his opinion, he could have easily given this a higher score just to please everybody Unsubscribed

[@frankiecaputo]

This shit made me laugh so hard

[@alvaro3003]

Had us in the first half ngl

[@Bigcheifer]

Gold

[@browniebizzle]

Understated af 💀

[@haydengallina5554]

Lmao that’s great

[@temno8127]

genuinely cannot fathom that an album with dark fantasy, runaway, power, all of the lights, devil in a new dress and lost in the world gets a 6, its impossible

[@spoodermanreal]

Dont forget gorgeous, blame game, hell of a life, and power

[@akashmuruganandam1462]

Yeah this mf looks for connection between songs. Like bro enjoy the damn music.

[@teodaw]

"genuinely cannot fathom" did u watch the mf review he articulates it pretty well

[@rosadoliteral]

watch the review

[@JoanGamer99]

@@akashmuruganandam1462even if we take that into account, it's still an incredible conceptual album. Seems like this guy it's just denying the obvious.

[@yungcade4480]

This is like the director's cut of the original review

[@arch4ngel]

Original review: very very light 5/10

[@marinnabigh]

Complete with 15 minutes of bonus footage!

[@Solly68]

The outtake where Cal's mustache fell off and hit Melon right in the nards was classic.

[@connorketchum9063]

I just came out of a 10 year coma. And this homie had the balls to give this album a 6 twice. I’m going back under

[@willoverdoseonmusic]

Lmao

[@williamknightsshinconditioning]

Hahahaha

[@creamu2roblox]

Would be amazing if that were true

[@marselo1316]

@@creamu2roblox wdym its not true

[@joshoshow6229]

bitch i'm back out my coma

[@samnewton3007]

HOW MANY TIMES DO WE HAVE TO TEACH YOU THIS LESSON OLD MAN!!

[@GregPoblete]

scrolled a little while but I finally found the best comment

[@Genesis_1984]

🤛🤜👊🦶💪

[@yisforyawada]

I love the young people. LOL

[@ronaldomalcom4768]

@@GregPoblete Yessir agreed!

[@MassiveJimmy09]

He would’ve given it a 10 if it was called “To Dark a Fantasy”

[@freshpersimmon9515]

Fantano 9 years ago: light to decent 6 Fantano now: Strong 5 to light 6 He lowered it. Respect for not conforming. Unsubbed

[@theaveragemegaguy]

LMAOOOOO

[@ek5160]

ok

[@Musaaaa653]

DEAD

[@KjvYaBoii]

😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹

[@joeb7640]

You mad? Hehe

[@lsk7514]

Hey Anthony, I just spoke with Mr. West and he’s crying and I don’t know what to do like how can you make a grown man cry :(

[@PCFROMVCS]

First they make Kai cry, and now Melon Man himself, what is the internet coming to.

[@FabulousKilljoy]

But not this man!

[@PeterGriffin-rp9iq]

On the phone with Obama rn we’re trying to hash out what we can do about the situation

[@invertebrate7377]

By omission, he’s letting us know that his favorite part of “Monster” was when Jay Z listed off a number of monsters.

[@estebanb7166]

@@saumitjin5526 Jay=figurative language. KW= literal language.

[@ThatGuy-zo5iv]

Saumit Jin thats the point of the song 🤦‍♂️

[@kyleat126]

Saumit Jin monsters in their own right 🤯

[@second1814]

Saumit Jin fuck off

[@aaronjohnson8490]

GOBLINS GHOULS!

[@KyoPewz]

My melon saw that the MBDTF memes were slowing down so he went and kickstarted the shit out of em again

[@kylehatch3748]

KyoPewz Charlie heat version

[@422youngstar]

2010: 6 2020: 6 Ten more years and melon will end the world by summoning the beast, which he will then also rate a 6/10

[@Trazynn]

And then ten years after that he reviews 6666 by Four Fists and P.O.S.

[@wood4life]

Oh shit... 2030 AntiChrist Melon 🤟👁 11:57 11:57 11:57

[@lonewalkerproductions]

Lmao

[@tuckerwoodson4134]

Anthony fantano is the antichrist confirmed

[@doormantdarner7815]

Andre Alampay That fate will actually be avoided. The first time he gave it a Decent 6. Now it is a Light 6. If in 10 years, the same continues, he will give it a strong 5 and the beasts summoning will be halted.

[@wilky946]

Everyone: RE REVIEW MBDTF Anthony: Ok. Everyone: NO, NOT LIKE THAT

[@ameldzihic5247]

wilky ah good one Jake

[@wariogotdeleted]

wilky Yes. Good one, Jake.

[@टैं]

fuck everyone

[@xothehost3781]

wilky let’s run them dislikes up again! 🥳🥳

[@jakelee8245]

Thanks guys

[@jerrys1]

If he had called it “Kids See Ghosts”, you would’ve given it a 10.

[@parisbrannigan1009]

LMAOOO

[@stefanristicmovies]

While I massively disagree with this review, I do really appreciate you actually going into detail. The big problem I had the the original review is that I don’t think it really went into free ail or explained itself, whereas here you were really clear and explained all your decisions. Shows how much you’ve improved as a reviewer over the last 10 years

[@sobsbot]

Top Shagger underrated comment

[@thraitor7819]

Exactly so now he needs to do a HOB re review lol

[@bruhffffgggg]

@@sobsbot wish he reviewed all albums like this.

[@ElGiganto17]

Did Fantano really improve or does he just put more time in "classic" reviews? For most new releases he only talks about them for a few minutes.

[@HighDeafRadio]

@@ElGiganto17 He improved dude. You dont do anything for 10 years without improving.

[@mitchlmitten5874]

Remember kids, you may have some unpopular opinions, but as long as you're honest, respectful, and articulate, everyone will get pissed off anyways.

[@monkeybusiness6687]

Lmfao

[@Moonhack95]

kanye stans something else

[@GamingOS]

@@Moonhack95 ok

[@benchidley9508]

2010: Light to decent 6 2020: Strong 5 to light 6 2030: Decent to strong 5 2040: Light to decent 5 2050: Strong 4 to light 5 2060: Decent to strong 4 2070: Light to decent 4 2080: Strong 3 to light 4 2090: Decent to strong 3 2100: Light to decent 3 2110: Strong 2 to light 3 2120: Decent to strong 2 2130: Light to decent 2 2140: Strong 1 to light 2 2150: Decent to strong 1 2160: Light to decent 1 2170: 10

[@MySocksAreOnFire-b4c]

You are the best

[@raystroman4473]

Earth won’t survive past 2090

[@viktoor7245]

wtf

[@Distorshroom]

@@raystroman4473 earth will survive, but humanity won't

[@Chrisratata]

Sometimes people begging you to love something is precisely why it can be so easy to see it as relatively bland. The higher you set a person's expectations and/or the higher you set the bar for greatness then the sharper their scalpel of scrutiny is going to be. Case in point, Kanye would've had more fans over the years if it wasn't for him practically begging people to see him as a genius; some humility would've done wonders for his career.

[@quest9133]

MBDTF: 6/10 Donda: 7/10 According to Anthony Fantano: Donda > MBDTF

[@thatguy-hq3ck]

actually true. imo tlop is the best kanye album

[@archiesutherland6127]

@@thatguy-hq3ck tlop and college dropout are his best imo

[@ilikemusic3041]

@@archiesutherland6127 late registration >>>>

[@archiesutherland6127]

@@ilikemusic3041 ,than what? I would say late registration is equal with the life of Pablo tbh

[@ilikemusic3041]

@@archiesutherland6127 both college dropout and tlop. I recently relistened to LG, and I honestly don't understand why people think College dropout is better

[@Lohnx]

Fantano is just mad that Kanye used the word Fantasy instead of Fantano at the end

[@Zhendwang]

my beautiful dark twisted fantano

[@Dhdhdyqha]

@@Zhendwang dark fantano

[@krishan736]

😂😂😂😂

[@natealderson]

Did this technically get a 9 in Australia?

[@natedurinho]

Yes

[@Adi_1922]

Turn that 6 upside down Issa 9 now

[@fifacentral4095]

I live in Australia and i can confirm this

[@nootinshootin7720]

@@fifacentral4095 same

[@cheflefrog1721]

That’s still blasphemy

[@alara4006]

Re-doing his most infamous review from 10 years ago just to give the same score... I respect the game you're playing here Melon.

[@frankiemartinez505]

I know everyone has already said this, but I appreciate how much more detailed he is with his thoughts in this review compared to the original where his criticisms were “I don’t like the hooks” and “I’m not interested in Kanye’s personal life.” It really shows his growth as a reviewer.

[@invincible794]

6/10? *That ain’t Christ like*

[@jamiewilson.420]

vagabond - I was looking for this comment. Thank you

[@ethansmith4442]

No, but it's what life like.

[@mattspyro]

Like 5 to 6 actually

[@phenton8249]

Ok but you get a like just for that vagabond pfp

[@weloc]

I would like this comment but I also want to keep it at 666 likes

[@acely8044]

He gave this a 6 which is 3/5 which is .60 we would round that to 1, which makes it a 5/5 which is a ten. This album is a ten.

[@urayoangarriga]

It’s not even a 8

[@benjaminsibson4265]

Gay

[@benjaminsibson4265]

AceTMT Lee we would also round 6/10 (0.6) to 1 dum dum

[@Isaac-ym8kq]

Benjamin Sibson that’s one of the jokes....

[@benjaminsibson4265]

Isaac Glasman it’s not funny bro

[@immaculatetechnique7306]

At least he breaks down his reasoning really well. He’s wrong, but he does being wrong pretty well.

[@calinamariei3593]

Samuel Kay How is he wrong?

[@wagabagabobobebe]

Calin Amariei re think your comment

[@Chrisratata]

@@wagabagabobobebe he asked a question

[@immaculatetechnique7306]

Calin Amariei Think a 6 is definitely low. I think it’s a shame the album was stacked at the front, and it does tail off at the back a little, but the first 9 songs is worthy of at least a 7 alone. He says Rick Ross’ verse is OK. That’s one of the best hip hop features in the last 15 years. Gorgeous he said he’s torn but that’s one of Kanye’s best deliveries on any track ever. The chorus of so appalled is in no way corny and the features only add to it.

[@fatdude2763]

@@immaculatetechnique7306 Honestly, it is at least a 7 or 8.

[@slippybeats377]

“The Ross feature we get at the end is not mind blowing” Sorry Fantano but yes it is

[@pedroordonez2a362]

YES. IT. IIIIIS!

[@jukaa1012]

Well, your profile picture certainly confirms your shitty opinion

[@193kaige7]

@@jukaa1012 yours is trash

[@jukaa1012]

@@193kaige7 yours is quite nice. Only great album Travis ever made, Sico Mode is good but just more of the same

[@gavyn9576]

Anthony: "its overrated" Everyone: "thats a weird way of saying a 10"

[@oscarh5439]

Its a 7.5

[@ScottyBanyanistheGOAT]

@@oscarh5439 Hm. I never heard someone say "10" that way

[@zapify6999]

It's not a 10, it's at best a strong 8

[@isuck6049]

​@@zapify6999 yeah i'd argue it's a strong 8 to a light 9, but a strong 5 to a light 6 is just outrageous

[@wildcherryguy]

6/10 Me: "Turn it up!" Melon: "That's the max"

[@arch4ngel]

“But it’s at its lowest volume setting”

[@kevanathra8741]

Can we get much higher?

[@sachinpandya2518]

Kev Anathra SO HIGH

[@ianish5060]

“Ah Ohh Oohhhh”

[@oozy1333]

BRO 10/10, YOU NEVER MISS.

[@kevinross6235]

You would've given the album a 10/10 if it was called "My Beautiful White Twisted Fantasy"

[@alimustafa4923]

@@ashtonharrell2290 👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀👀

[@ld2573]

Ashton Harrell nah he beat up my cousin for holding a BLM sign

[@zekewow2682]

*My Beautiful Bright Twisted Fantasy*

[@milk5002]

@@zekewow2682 Light*

[@farhannr28]

@TJ Martin bruh you didnt know anything about him

[@3alenciagaboots]

Runaway is a flawless song. The "cringe" lyrics make the song feel so authentic and the singing is good.

[@Ismael-kc3ry]

Lmao

[@omaralfageeh4636]

Lol

[@RalaxysWorld]

lol

[@peep3879]

??

[@isaacm4159]

Exactly it's raw and authentic, Lyrics are cringe because Kanyes true self is cringe (in a good way). That's who he is.

[@staticsight]

Last time I was this early MBDTF was a 6/10

[@InkAndPoet]

It still is.

[@z1kk]

@@InkAndPoet bruh

[@Bishcona]

@@InkAndPoet bruh

[@withnail-and-i]

@@InkAndPoet SIS MY PUNES

[@InkAndPoet]

What, have you read the description?

[@orokenzo]

Saying you would've given it a 10 if it was called "My Beautiful White Twisted Fantasy" was racist to say the least, Melon.

[@sebastienchen7160]

finally a normal comment

[@Linkbrawler9000]

emu honestly that’s a great title for a follow up and/or Kanye satire

[@arthurdunn07]

Overused joke

[@christianjunegregorio3053]

*Light

[@AudibleVisibIe]

@@arthurdunn07 fuck off clown

[@bryanchu5379]

Cuz we all know we're gonna be coming back to this video over and over again for the next ten years: 00:00 Intro 00:25 Reasons for re-reviewing 01:38 Background 03:51 Dark Fantasy :) 06:00 Gorgeous :) 08:48 POWER. :) 09:45 All of the Lights :( 11:35 Monster :| 13:09 So Appalled :| 14:25 Devil in a New Dress :) 15:14 Runaway :( 17:14 Hell of a Life :( 18:23 Blame Game :) / :( 19:46 Lost in the World :( 20:28 Who Will Survive in America :( 21:23 Conclusion

[@spark9_]

you deserve a 10.

[@brettmobly9525]

Bryan Chu thank you for your service

[@sebastianminardi6933]

still can’t believe this nigga said runaway overrated

[@stanleyyelnats901]

No waý runaway is bad to him

[@yessirski9367]

H Hh I’m more upset with All of the Lights, that song is such high quality

[@garbz1414]

Wow im so glad everybody agrees with this review now. Absolutely no dislikes whatsoever :D

[@baifor7]

65K/10

[@Isa-fn6rs]

CAL CHUCHESTA HAS BEEN REPORTED MISSING SINCE 2019! Gender: Male Height:6,2 Weight:Thicc Race: unknown Mixtape:Fire

[@mikaelk8659]

Race: Fruit

[@unnamedgoon6196]

Hotel: Trivago

[@frank8752]

Sex: yes

[@jessebout9829]

Race: Logic

[@Culturedbum1985]

Car: Oscar Mayer Wiener

[@macafromthewired]

this kinda shows how much better he's gotten at reviewing though, he's way more clear in this review than he was in his original.

[@orphanion9468]

Well I think it's just he had to dig deeper because he couldn't say the initial thoughts that he had already said in the first review

[@DeronHargrove]

I agree. This review, going track by track, and explaining what he liked and didn't like compared to the original is amazing. I appreciate him for doing this

[@conciliator6440]

I think after the years of watching Nicki Minaj blow up, become an over-saturated global superstar, and fizzle out, her voice is kind of tired now, but that Monster verse was a goddamn revelation when it first hit

[@jeddgangman4502]

Conciliator nicki hasn’t fizzled out

[@walshythemusician]

Agree

[@medes5597]

100% agreed. That monster verse is one of my favourites and I'm not generally a hip hop fan but it god damn blew me away back when this album came out.

[@jeyneo.8924]

@@medes5597 then that explains a lot.

[@medes5597]

@@jeyneo.8924 Whatever. I bought MBDTF the day it came outz, the whole record blew me away. Still not my genre generally.

[@cly_]

The year is 2042. The white house announces that the president, Ye North-West has died. The funeral, held in the politician/musician's hometown, is attended only by those close to him. His wife, Vinetria, his husband, Kanye West. As well as all close friends and family members. As well, Anthony fantano comes. He is the world's biggest Ye fan, and a respected critic of his work. He has remained that way even through backlash and controversy. He loved Ye's works, and prepared a speech going through the life of pab- Ye. Some other people come up to the podium at the funeral, and go through their own speeches. Anthony remains stoic and serious, despite some of the world's most beloved music playing, Ye's entire discography. Finally, it's his turn. He walks up to the microphone, glancing down at his flashcards, right as the final song of Donda ends. Anthony takes a deep breath, when suddenly, he hears a familiar tune. MBDTF begins playing, and immediately, melon's flight or fight instinct kick in, but he freezes. Having nearly died after the Threedux review received immense hate, he buried this album from his memory. As the true reality of the situation sinks in, he thinks back to his reviews of the album. All three were 6/10s, and that's all he can muster. After a long silence, he begins yelling uncontrollably; "SIX OUT OF TEN, SIX OF TEN" shortly afterwards being escorted out by secret service agents. Melon loses all credibility after a video of his incident is published online. Melon spirals into despair, doing anything he can to remain relevant. He published redux reviews of every album he reviewed. He gives A2TC a 10 and TPAB a NOT GOOD. But, ultimately it fails, and pitchfork buys his channel for 10$ and 5¢. Melon eventually locks himself inside his home, listening to Nostalgia critic's "The Wall" on repeat, never to be seen again.

[@gcwens]

feeling a decent to strong 10 on this one

[@criley0007]

me: 2020 is off to a rough start, at least we don’t have to experience Fantano reviewing my beautiful dark twisted fantasy Fantano:

[@dravocon5485]

people have been asking ever since he reviewed it originally

[@lh757]

Conner Ovard That’s because they thought he would give a higher score, but he didn’t.

[@RealDirectorDru]

@@lh757 he gave it a worse score🤦🏻‍♂️😭💀

[@kieaht]

Hey melon, there’s this great album I think you should review, it’s called my beautiful dark twisted fantasy from kanye west

[@joecruise185]

I think he’s already reviewed that, he gave it a 10/10

[@recipoldinasty]

Kareem he did review it, twice, kanye white stans got mad

[@dabobfotoday5397]

Lemon By Rihanna, not even close

[@MuhammadSalman7236]

@@dabobfotoday5397 you replied to the wrong comment.

[@dabobfotoday5397]

Muhammad Salman lol

[@adamreginald7673]

“Your wild sexy fantasy is just basically every college-aged straight dude’s porn search history” DAMN ANTHONY WENT STRAIGHT TO THE HEART LMAOOOO

[@Moneyman-33]

Adam Reginald Pretty gay to watch gangbangs. It’s usually multiple men with a women lmao. Idk how that’s a straight fantasy to wanna share a chick with other dudes at the same time. Just being honest here lmao.

[@MSPMK03]

Atlas Unchained dude it’s okay to come out, new year new you my guy

[@Moneyman-33]

Adam Reginald Kanye lyrics was “well a lot of niggas do gangbang” if I remember correctly. Nothing in the line says he does gangbangs.

[@Moneyman-33]

Steven Bailey You’re cringe bro.

[@tesset8828]

But he is only gay for our lord and saviour Jesus Christ.

[@BravePvP]

This video is why the update to KZbin’s dislike system is an incredibly bad idea.

[@irishmapping1089]

Lmao

[@fromgreattobrilliant922]

Saw this review in Australia, and I don't know why everyone is mad that he gave this album a 9...

[@mkatkitkat]

:) funne

[@asaltofsomething]

it's a 01/9, absolutely horrible, that's why

[@mkatkitkat]

@@asaltofsomething hmm 🤔

[@Chooopy]

This boy even coming out with the 10 year old jokes

[@fromgreattobrilliant922]

@@Chooopy better than the new jokes. Modern internet humor is completely dead, reduced to vine booms and cartoonish sounds.

[@TStamp-lw4ku]

Why has noone made a compilation of him singing songs from albums he’s reviewing 🤔🤔

[@LordBrozart]

Your time to shine

[@TStamp-lw4ku]

outbreakm25 I was thinking about it but honestly that would mean I’d have to watch all of his videos and that wouldn’t be that much of a problem except I don’t really care for Music reviews that much so I would eventually get bored, also I know it’s kind of the point but I don’t find his Cringe Humor funny in the slightest so that would get annoying real quick having to sit through all that. Hopefully one of his dedicated fans is willing to be up to the task.

[@toogoodlimegreen]

T. Stamp nahh do it

[@thirtyyearoldmulberryfield]

Sick Moral Orel pic btw, up there with Venture Bros and Superjail as Adult Swim's best achievements

[@TStamp-lw4ku]

Kris Rusty I’ll think about it, but if I do it’ll probably only be in the Hip Hop Sphere and maybe Pop stuff cuz that’s all I’d be willing to Listen to him talk about.

[@NanaMioVT]

bro if kanye made this album you would've given it a 6/10

[@BaileyVII]

bro facts. Melon is so based.

[@meatlejuice]

Not wrong

[@Soc-q7j]

I don’t get it

[@trunestor]

@@Soc-q7j he is joking that fantano is racist

[@Mrs.Magix58]

Bruh

[@Person-wr6wr]

If this album was called "My Beautiful Dark Twisted Pimping of a Butterfly" you would have given it a 10

[@imranreaza3337]

No, he wasn’t describing YOU in Gorgeous, Anthony.

[@eatyourvegetables87435]

Dead 💀

[@randomguy4788]

Yes he was

[@DiabolicalPaperClip]

Kanye's loss. :)

[@szymonmirek6389]

"Domestic violence is bad... HOWEVER" - Melon 2020

[@sen-te8oq]

why the fuck does everybody have that profile picture

[@30kUzi]

sen oh yea yea

[@harvey9352]

This is why I love melons comment section

[@noahleveille366]

sen It’s a reference to the KZbin channel MaximilianMus

[@korydevs5711]

This man really said “farty ass bass”

[@jzsson2283]

2 MILLION SUBSCRIBERS

[@rimlix939]

Melon is farty ass

[@Super-zq3pn]

Toe Bandit shut it farty ass

[@SkinnyOnion]

i legit cried at that point lmfao

[@flying_rat]

Where does he say it again? I wanna loop it so I can fall asleep to it as the soundtrack to my next fever dream.

[@stnbl1569]

I love this album especially all of the lights. Can’t wait to hear the praise for my favorite song from Anthony! 😍😍😍

[@jennifer008]

You ain't gonna get that, bud.

[@mailman6220]

💀

[@TheWelkynnsAlt]

is this commenter okay

[@judeleahy6108]

Your 10 years late Anthony, I already formed my own opinion on this album

[@monk_moshpit]

How controversial

[@seclvded]

How bold of you to say that

[@krombopulos_michael]

Sucks that you have to change it now :'(

[@GrayMason1]

this aint gonna go over well...

[@Astral0G1]

Least it didn't slip even further

[@kelvinleung6746]

this aint Christ-like

[@giovannizerbini3119]

Kelvin Leung “I think i fell in love with a pornstar”

[@theaytacbahar]

W

[@RobbieLugos]

MBDTF stands for Music Being Dissapointing To Fantano.

[@OrangeCrush_Brandon]

Everybody: So Anthony, are you gonna give us what we’ve been wanting for years? Anthony: well yes, but actually no

[@BOAYang]

*checks score in the description *”SO YOU HAVE CHOSEN DEATH”*

[@ilovecody7514]

I wouldn't have it any other way.

[@swansonjoe7121]

Lmao he hates y'all and he want you to know it

[@ilovecody7514]

@@leonsalgeuro If you think this is serious then you're worse than the people who disliked the video.

[@oaklaz7899]

Let’s make it a tradition to review this album every 10 years

[@somerandomname3124]

He's going to give it 6 6's before he dies.

[@peachabutt]

No thanks.

[@sobsbot]

OAKLAZ he said on Twitter he‘ll review it again in 2030 lol

[@CartyCantDance]

Yes

[@siivamander8460]

great way to check in on the melon’s mental health

[@Masato_Kusaka]

If MBDTF was named "To Pimp A Butterfly", you would have given it a 10

[@chilihotdog7257]

Where is the funny ?

[@aaronpescasio]

@@chilihotdog7257 qwerty

[@aaronpescasio]

@@chilihotdog7257 asdfgh

[@aaronpescasio]

@@chilihotdog7257 zxcvbn

[@aaronpescasio]

Funn y

[@BigBoy-vp6lp]

Wow! Over a million views and 57k likes? This video must be loved by the audience!

[@dodgechance4564]

I fucking hate youtube so much for removing the dislike bar (FYI: get the Return KZbin Dislike add on, it isn't perfect but still)

[@xiscaw]

@@dodgechance4564 wym dislikes were never a thing

[@boxtupos7718]

@@xiscaw wdym? It's clearly there, people just unanimously agree with this review.

[@ryanguzman4480]

I’m gonna tell my kids this is what started WW3

[@MR.GOAT.]

Ryan Guzman 10

[@miscellaneousmedia3753]

WW1: Archduke assassinated WW2: Axis Powers pissed at getting the short stick WW3: Melon with great teeth has incorrect music opinion

[@c4shguy224]

It is though ???

[@michaelotis223]

This review could be a supervillain's origin story lol

[@jeanmichelsnake]

2029: Well actually To Pimp a Butterfly was trash

[@Victor-ge8cs]

I felt that it wasn’t as good as good kid ma.a.d city

[@flutterwind7686]

He didn't like MBDTF even back then.

[@roman.nose.enjoyer]

Raiyyan Siddiqui he does, though?

[@nadavya2612]

@@Victor-ge8cs you *liked* gkmc more, and I do too, but tpab is objectively better and had a huge impact, not only on hip hop and rap, but on society.

[@nadavya2612]

@Ther Ther it's deeper and has more important topics, and had a bigger impact on rap as a whole.

[@hrcr101]

Pitchfork: This is the second best album of the decade Rolling Stone: This is the best album of the decade Melon: Nah it's not even as good as lil pump's debut album everyone already forgot about

[@EvWuzhere]

Thats why melon's the best reviewer in the game

[@ByeByeDeadName]

Believing Jeffrey Epstein killed himself is more credible than Pitchfork and Rolling Stone

[@armanamini8408]

Oh yes Pitchfork and Rolling Stones two of the shittiest music review websites ever

[@second1814]

Rohan Bais what kanye vendetta? Pitchfork haven't given any of his albums under a 7 and a lot of them got best new music

[@YoQ]

Lil pump still beat kanye. I cant, melon, pls

[@suppressedchicken]

I hope somebody plays venom at your funeral

[@Tasuliakas]

i dont know what is worse.... the fact that you thought of such an evil punishment , or the fact that melon deserves it

[@parkbruner6037]

"too many Urkels on your team that's why your Winslow" MBDTF - 6/10 "GRA GRA TATTA TATAT" Kids See Ghosts - 10/10

[@jdrum208]

Imagine rating any of Kanye's albums below an 8

[@swagmonee5699]

@@jdrum208 Imagine forgetting that Yeezus, 808s, and Jesus Is King exist

[@DrewFKADruid]

@@swagmonee5699 You get Yeezus off there right now or you're grounded for a month

[@mcskittlez8499]

@@swagmonee5699 HEY U LEAVE YEEZUS AND 808s alone

[@Moneyman-33]

Swag Monee Jesus Is King was an 8 gimme a break.

[@adrianaparkofficial]

"And I always find, yeah I always find somethin' wrong" -fantano critiquing MBDTF

[@brandondavis1496]

"We've been putting up with his shit just way too long"-fans ejaculating on the subscribe button

[@benjaminsibson8760]

Brandon Davis too far

[@MarcusSantill20]

Lmao

[@thekaseychannel1318]

@@brandondavis1496 YES

[@mahfuzvx3967]

@@brandondavis1496 I'm so gifted at finding what I don't like the most- melon telling us how good he is at finding shit he doesn't like about mbdtf.