Response to Yasir Qadhi (Part 1) || Karim AbuZaid

Link to the entire Ask Imam Karim LiveShow.
• Ask Imam Karim Livesho...

[@jb223]

One of the blessings for this Ummah is that we will never agree upon misguidance.

[@Zaitoon55]

Yes and the prophet Peace Be Upon Him said "If there is a differences amongst you, Follow the larger group because my Ummah will Never be gathered in misguidance." "Verily, my nation will not unite upon misguidance. If you see differences, you must follow the great majority."

[@waleedsulaiman651]

@@Zaitoon55 Can you provide the Daleel where our Prophet(SAW) said this minfadlik

[@Zaitoon55]

@@waleedsulaiman651 Sunan Ibn Majah 3950 Anas bin Malik said: “I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say: ‘My nation will not unite on misguidance, so if you see them differing, follow the great majority.’”

[@Zaitoon55]

@@waleedsulaiman651 Sunan Ibn Majah 3950 Anas bin Malik said: “I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say: ‘My nation will not unite on misguidance, so if you see them differing, follow the great majority.’”

[@Zaitoon55]

@@waleedsulaiman651 Sunan Ibn Majah 3950 Anas bin Malik said: “I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say: ‘My nation will not unite on misguidance, so if you see them differing, follow the great majority.’”

[@selima1057]

Imam 😂 the way you responded NO,NO 😂 May Allah guide him subhanallah

[@TranquilCastlestar]

That's because sheikh is scared of being misguided or making anyone else misguided, that's not the correct response though. He should let go of his fear, Have hope in Allah, trust and contact Yasir Qadhi to explain himself and with an open heart. Really, they can get along man, this is such a misunderstanding:( May Allah guide us. If you really know Yasir Qadhi, you'll know he says nothing against the Sheikhs beliefs!

[@selima1057]

@@TranquilCastlestar yasir qadir didn give his lecture in private or personalized he gave a public lecture so it has to be public cuz he’s misleading the youth a lot of young Muslims are goin astray all due to they following a sheikh who thinks everything is alright and other say it’s haram

[@umermohiuddin2061]

@@TranquilCastlestar do you think is that easy to contact him, please stop with this talk to him in private talk to him in private , hes saying all of this in public and posting it in public its necessary to refute in him in public he has already caused so much damage. Its necessary to refute him.

[@saharqureshi5873]

“Verily, you (O Muhammad) guide not whom you like, but Allah guides whom He wills. And He knows best those who are the guided.” [al-Qasas 28:56]

[@imzytube]

@@TranquilCastlestar You should give this video a watch kzbin.info/www/bejne/h6W6ZKF8htyMf9E

[@muammar1353]

THE WAY HE SAID NO STRAIGHT AWAY🤣🤣🤣

[@MohamedAshaif]

I laughed so hard

[@leilarocco1158]

Hehehe i laugh hard

[@mobinmirshekari4884]

May Allah reward him for it !

[@wanderingtraveler71]

@@MohamedAshaif me too man. This moment was too funny

[@mariamnone816]

🤣🤣

[@AnakiiD]

Don't be attached to individuals.

[@12345678956824]

Facts!

[@abdoolwahedwahed1802]

Please leave Yaseer Khadaroo alone .He is doing a good job. He is very good. Keep your calm Ann talk to him.

[@mrpandabearofficialchannel673]

His only using his name for more views

[@12345678956824]

@@mrpandabearofficialchannel673 I guess he's kzbin.info/www/bejne/qICsoaCIgrZmbKM also using his name for views?

[@QnA513]

Follow the TWO WEIGHTY matters The prophet of Islam left TWO weighty matters to hold onto The Qur'an and Ahlulbayt These two are the sources for GUIDANCE

[@abdulmunim318]

Even my little brother knows that worshipping a grave is shirk. Audhibillah. May Allah سُبْحَانَهُ وَتَعَالَىٰ guide all the Muslims. Credentials don't mean anything if your Aqeedah is clearly astray.

[@beenishahmed9469]

Yasir Qadhi never said worshipping a grave is ok. ( please brother search for yourself) This guy is straight away spreading misinformation .

[@vvaloachi7263]

I am hearing your lecture and thinking that may be you have not heard the lecture of Yasir Qadhi. and amazingly at 8:09 min you confess that fact. How foolish it is to make a refutation video without hearing the man you are refuting ! an incredible idiot !! Yasir qadhi also said worshiping grave is Shirk. but he said that asking something to the person of the grave without worshiping is not Shirk , but it is Haram and a major Sin.

[@tahidhanna]

worshipping grave is shirk, but those who do istigaathaa actually believe that if u ask a dead holy person, the dead person asks allah to except it. as a way of medium ( which is wrong and haraam. but problem is the other side will say ur worshipping the grave and make it shirk. that was what yasir qhadi is pointing out, and that is how islam got divieded, when abdul wahaab gave a verdict on the 90 percent of entire ummah (ottoman empire) as doing shirk and grave worshipping people and made it halaal to kill them.

[@oghanchi]

@@tahidhanna Asking a dead person is shirk. Whether you are asking them for intercession or not. This is clear in the Quran. No ambiguity about it. YQ says it is haram but not shirk. His reason is because 1) calling it shirk is done by a particular movement, and 2) because majority of others call it haram but not shirk. Both reasons don't make sense to me or any rational person. He also says Ibn Taymiyyah says so. But he never presents an argument or proof from the main source of Aqeedah, the Quran (I watched his whole video).

[@hasnaffinahassnar7445]

@@vvaloachi7263 ya correct, but the issue here is that video making us to believe that yq advocating and mjsguiding us. YQ was just elaborating the 3 establised opinion by ulama tu o the questioner. So if you watch the full video lasting 54 min by Ys qadhi then u would understand...

[@MuslimSkeptic]

JazakAllah khayran shaykh. Much needed.

[@m0hamed_kamz70]

Salami alaikum Daniel, Mashallah I just want to say that I really appreciate the work that you do, especially with how clear cut and unapologetic you are about the deen and I pray that Allah continues to increase you in knowledge and goodness ameen🤲🏾:)

[@iimiboy]

Ha! Brother Daniel, may Allah bless and reward you and your family

[@kaashee]

Thank you for having a direct answer. Thank you. No BS.

[@Melhimri]

Anyone who says they did not have a single doubt at any time is lying. You're telling me there is nothing that you have run into at any time that you didnt understand and before getting the answer, certain things never creeped in your thoughts? Subhanallah, we put others down simply to cover our own flaws.

[@Melhimri]

The sarcasm just shows the arrogance.

[@ShanSidd1]

Assalaamu alaykum I listen to Sheikh Yasir Qadhi and I have never heard him say that muslims are allowed to worship the graves. He has been seriously misquoted. We should be very careful before speaking about others.

[@cledwards2410]

It's not a misquote the video is everywhere and this was not the first strange comment from him.

[@ShanSidd1]

If it is everywhere on the internet pl send the link. Sheikh Yasir Qadhi does not encourage shirk.

[@ShanSidd1]

Ok. I have watched the video now. YQ is not advocating calling on saints- he is saying it’s haram and evil but he is not willing to stretch it to shirk. I personally do not agree with his conclusion however as Muslims, we should not be disrespectful to our scholars. He is more than qualified to give his opinion. Amr ibn al-‘As reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “If a judge makes a ruling, striving to apply his reasoning and he is correct, he will have two rewards. If a judge makes a ruling, striving to apply his reasoning and he is mistaken, he will have one reward.”

[@mysticminority9060]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/iHnQhpZmiLJod8k

[@ShanSidd1]

Whatever people choose to believe, there is no need to belittle another Muslim.

[@Theonyxconservative]

"get a hike" lol🤣

[@wanderingtraveler71]

Too many funny moments in this vid that being one of them

[@holdshiftt2run308]

lol Sheikh was so quick on that. May Allah accept you sh. Karim

[@sharifally28]

Sheikh, the way you approach the question isn’t in Islamic way. Islam has a large number of sects, you didn’t even think about the outcome of your response. You have spend your entire time attacking someone, instead of bringing forth evidence from Sunna, Hadith and you just touched I believe one ayah. I did go back and listen what YQ said about the question, it’s completely different from what ur proclaimed. He was very careful in his responses judging from political atmosphere of the land where question comes from, and it called “wisdom”. You have personal agenda maybe.

[@ijazzzali]

I don't get it. Yasir Qadi is an eloquent speaker, I haven't heard anything bad from him. Why this conflict?

[@ijazzzali]

@Ismail can you provide a reference?

[@kaz4845]

@Ismail he does believe is yajuj and mahjuj.. Your too stupid to even know what he actually said bro lol

[@jenabacamara1678]

Ismail any evidence or videos where he said these things?

[@RonaldinhoOwnz]

@@jenabacamara1678 kzbin.info/www/bejne/n3XWiYN7pNmMhMk

[@Maya-xz7rq]

He doesn’t believe in yajuj and majud, he says shariah law should be changed. Watch tge talk by abu ibraheem about yasir qadi

[@bananasplit7956]

SubhanAllah, this is a clear sign that guidance is from Allah. May Allah guide us and keep us on the right path, may Allah make our hearts firmly established upon Islam, may He allow us to see falsehood as falsehood and stay away from it and truth as truth and adhere to it. Brothers and sisters in Islam, we live in peculiar times, hold on the Quran and Sunnah, continuously ask Allah for guidance, never feel like you're saved as this may lead to complacency.

[@abdulkhafidsulaymaan]

Maasha Allah

[@maryambham3124]

It needed to be said...subhaanallah

[@sykesyke5786]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/jprYhqp4jM2qaNk

[@kevinhoyle9232]

Very Sad. Brother Yasir is very knowledgeable& also a great teacher.. Ive benefitted from his Lives of the Sahaba series & the seerah of the Rasul salalahu alahi wasalam . now he is in trouble. May Allah show him mercy & give him tawfeek Ammeen😞

[@mobinmirshekari4884]

May Allah reward him for it !

[@theahmedfahad]

I stop hearing his lectures about 3 years ago as some of his lectures contradicted with other sheikhs , so I was confused but Allhumdulilah when I was sure this guy is mixing up things I left listening his lectures.

[@MB-yq3ty]

You are right brother don't go back to his lactures

[@shukriadan8191]

MAY Allah preserve you My brother for always defending our beautiful religion MAY Allah aza wajallah make you among those who Will be in the company Al Mustafa(s.a.w) and his companions amin

[@melissaa2337]

Caller: can we take aqeedah from YAS... Imam Karim: NO!

[@Aliii378]

Reminds of YASS QUEEN

[@MohamedAshaif]

He was like can I at least finish my question

[@mustafaadiprahman5753]

Plz dont backbite

[@Atheneon]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qqrCY3qVmtiIrKs

[@mustafaadiprahman5753]

Plz dont backbite

[@ibnhussain3300]

May Allah bless you and protect you from all fitna. Aameeen

[@ismailjama178]

I feel very sad,when I see a brother who waste his time talking about another brother.The scholars should advise each other quietly not on public videos.

[@guraaba]

It should be discussed, because otherwise people will fall in fitna.

[@aadil161981]

If the fitna was restricted to yasir qadhi only, he should've been advised in private. But yasir qadhi is preaching to people. So people are warned lest they fall in his fitnah.

[@guraaba]

It is not possible to let all know about all of the preacher who may spread fitna. It can be clear over time. One of the biggest fitna for this ummah is the misguided preacher. So we need to be careful.

[@daraghkelly4066]

They have been advising him for the past ten years or so. Shirk is a serious matter.

[@BilalHussain-sx3vg]

If a mistake is made privately it’s advised privately, if it’s done publicly it’s addressed publicly

[@imtiazalam996]

Yasir Qadhi never told to worship the grave.Please go and watch the video in full details.This type of comments are not expected from a scholar against other scholar.This is having a negative impact on the whole Muslim community.

[@hannahff]

💯💯

[@geeque4853]

I have listened to most of Sheikh Yasir Qadhi's lectures and I didn't find him on misguidance!! May Allah gives all of us hidayah with goodness. Ameen

[@geeque4853]

@Ismail focus on yourself instead of others!!

[@jenabacamara1678]

Ismail any evidence or videos that proves it

[@jenabacamara1678]

@ismail yes I always watch his videos but never witnessed any false statements in them

[@dylberzylali5065]

May Allah reward you Sheikh Abu Zaid ...amin

[@abdever2140]

Fitnah among the scholars is very dangerous. Islamic scholars, please stop this. Be united. Oh Allah protect and elevate us. Ameen

[@arifzaman878]

You have to be united. Yes. But on truth, right? Not falsehood. See kzbin.info/www/bejne/a5rEcqxqqpZ5rNU

[@noraRvx]

Dear brother. I used to watch alot of videos of him. Now i dont know anymore who to watch. I was almost done with the seerah series. Can i still watch them? Or not? If not where can i listen to lectures about diffirent topics. I have no idea anymore. Could you please tell me where i can get knowledge from. Because i dont know anymore. People say Do not watch nouman ali khan Do not watch mufti menk Do not watch yasir qadhi Do not watch this one that one. Who am i allowed to listen to then Because these people have genuenly made me a better person. Eman rose because of them. I dont know who to listen to anymore

[@mero3170]

As you say, they made you a better person through islamic knowledge. Keep listening to them my brother and remember Allah whereever you are. Some people see it necessary to refute and so on, but with no basic whatsoever. May Allah guide us all and make us firm in the religion

[@noraRvx]

@@mero3170 jazakkalahu khair brother. I am very thankfull to you that you responded may Allaah reward you brother

[@dom3073]

@@noraRvx mufti menk is actually good. Nouman knows a lot of arabic but sometimes he makes his own tafsir, so thats the problem. YQ will give you slow poison.

[@syedjaveed99]

as-Salamalykum wa-Rahamatullahi wa-Barakatuh These are the Duaat(and more) who are recommended by the Scholars.These are the Duaat who left their homes and not their Studies to learn under the shade of Scholars. These Duaat also give Dawah to Non-Muslims but with Sound knowledge of Basics of Islām and not like Ahmad Deedat who supported Mīlād. You can not count how many Non-Muslims accepted Islām in their Salafi Masjids. Church in Birmingham is well known, which was converted into the Masjid, Alhamdulillah, when its father accepted Islām at the hands of Abu Khadījah Abdul Wāhid Hafidhahullah in June 2014. But, you will not read or listen this on social media, because our Salafi Duaat do not like fame. *Some of the English Speaking Salafi Students of Knowledge: (alive الحمد لله)* Abdul-Kareem McDowell Abu Sarah Dr Abdul-Ilaah Lahmaamee Abu Aadam Jameel Finch Abu Hakeem Bilal Davis Abu Idrees Mohammed khan Abu Ishaaq Nadeem Ahsan-Shah Abu Iyaad Amjad Rafeeq Abu Khadeejah Abdul-Wahhid Abu Muadh Taqweem Aslam Ayman Fox Abu Uways Abdullah Ali Abul-Hasan Maalik Akhdar Abu Suhail Anwar Wright Abu Abdillah Hassan as-Somaali Abul Abbaas Moosaa Richardson Mustafaa al-Kanadee Abu Ismael Mustafa George Abu Suhailah Umar Quinn Abu Abdir-Rahman Uwais Taweel Abu Mujjahid Fareed Abdullah Abu Muhammad Al Maghribi Taalib 'Abdullah Abu Hafsah Kashiff Khan Abu Quhaylah Rasheed Barbee Abu Musa Raha Batts Abu Humayd Salim Abdul Wali Nelson Anas Waters Abdul Hakeem Mitchel Abu Anisa Abdul Hakeem Hamza Abdur-Razzaq Abu Arwa Mir Ali Abbas Abu Yahya Saeed Rhana al-Maghribee حفظهم الله أجمعين

[@jayre872]

I mean y would scholar say if u want to be misguided listen to that guy. I mean it doesn’t suit a religion scholar to talk about other Islamic scholar like that.

[@Hassan-ed1mr]

Total madness walaahi they just can't tolerate anything My way or the highway. May Allah protect Us.

[@ibrahimgamer5177]

worshipping anyone with Allah is shirk. Anyone who doesn't understand this statement, who misunderstand this statement, etc, i kindly advise him to corrected as soon as possible. Jazak Allah khair! :)

[@syedabadar4158]

I am biggest fan of yaser qadi and I respect him so much for his hard work teaching the Muslim Ummah about their Deen. Allah knows best but in my opinion he is one of the best Islamic Scholar. So my advice please investigate yourself before you hear things which is not true.

[@ChechenMaga]

Look up refutations on him, you'll find them here. That person has changed, is calling to deviance, kufr, bid'ah, liberalism and other things. Anyone who knows the aqidah of Ahlussunnah will say he is a misguided person.

[@saharqureshi5873]

Indeed I agree, there is point in pulling each other’s leg, subhan Allah what kind of examples are these people setting.

[@aatif7518]

@@saharqureshi5873 there is something called advising the ummah Refuting incorrect beliefs

[@aatif7518]

He has so many problems From calling Allah's laws bizzare to claiming Umar will fail aqeeda test, etc..

[@m.afg124]

I agree sister. Unfortunately Yasir has deteriorated dramatically over the years. In Islam, we never follow any scholar blindly just because we like them or that we are a fan of them. I agree that he had great content when he started, but according to himself his building blocks of Islamic knowledge were all dismantled when he went to Yale which he had to reconstruct himself. I encourage you to have a look at the following videos when you have time to get a full picture of how things have developed. I have no ill intention towards brother Yasser and I pray to Allaah that may he guide him and us towards the straight path. @ @ @ @ @ The last video is of a refutation backed by Quran and sunnah with regards to his idea that invoking the dead does not constitute associating partners with the creator as long as you don't believe that they are able to help you themselves.

[@arshadsheikh817]

Imam you know back biting is a sin. If you have problem with anyone go and talk to him behind closed doors.

[@AmerickiZivot]

Calling out deviants is not considered backbiting.

[@mm-wm3jd]

Shaykh Karim, with all due respect, it is better to challenge Yasser Qadi for a public debate if you have all the answers than trying to cancel him🤔

[@thegameseriesop1300]

He's genuinely trying to make us aware of the Truth about Yasir Qadhi, but ig there are some people I don't know what they're thinking, but they say he's trying to cancel Deceiver Yasir Qadhi, such nonsense!

[@Wassalaam92]

"Sheikh yasir said worshipping graves is not shirk". No, he did not say that.

[@tanzimqurashi7292]

Watch his library chat- explains a lot. The najdi dawah movement explained.

[@Wassalaam92]

@@tanzimqurashi7292 yes, i have watched it. That's why i know he didnt say that. The sheikh in this video has not watched YQ's library chat himself.

[@hasnaffinahassnar7445]

@@tanzimqurashi7292 should watch the video of ys. He was just elaborating the 3 established opinions by the ulama. But the clip by the maker was manipulated make it as if yssir qadhi is advocating shirk...

[@tanzimqurashi7292]

@@hasnaffinahassnar7445 ys? I know bro there is a lot of manipulation making it seem as if Yasir Qadhi is advocating shirk like a Mushrik. Doesn't seem just, although i disagree with him, opinions of Ulama are to be respected no?

[@tanzimqurashi7292]

@James Joe Watch his library chat fully then understand.

[@TranquilCastlestar]

Assalamu Alaikum, | am very less knowledgeable than you ya Sheikh. But Sheikh, he clearly explained the video" Yasir Qadhi refuting Yasir Qadhi" in his own video, the video was made taking his quotations out of context! And by doubts he didn't mean doubt in the revelation ya Sheikh, he was just experiencing doubts like UMAR (R), which is common for Muslim or a human being to be curious and ask questions, he expressed it in front of an audience who doubt ISLAM as a whole so that they can relate and understand that these critical doubts that they face can be overcome by studying and understanding the texts properly. That lecture was particularly for those non-Muslim people in the audience, he didn't expect it to reach everyone on KZbin and put Muslims in doubt (although Muslims at that time had so much doubt if not more than the non- Muslims about Islam because all these fiqh and Aqeedah contents were not available as much then). I went through these videos a year ago and didn't find any mistakes rather the speeches are taken out of context. And I understood that before he ever explained them! Him going to Yale is scary, yes for us, but since his brain had the capacity to deal with all that so he knows what all those people go through in thought process and which way to deal with those issues to best guide them, otherwise why would he take a degree, if he has that ability, Isn't that a good thing? Maybe Sheikh he made some mistakes, but he has nothing against the Ummah! Maybe you've been exposed to only the hate spreading videos about him made by very immature people among the Muslims, You guys are our Sheikhs, you have to work things out with more understanding and care. Please don't fight online, SubhanAllah. It is common that people will try to misrepresent when someone becomes popular. May Allah guide all our Sheikhs and protect them from all sorts of harmful things in this dunya and Akherah. Ameen, there is this Da'wahman brother and whatever he says against Yasir Qadhi has absolutely no meaning! he takes every single thing out of context just to refute the sheikh! I don't know what's wrong with him but that clearly isn't right .

[@mewzi]

Yasir Qadhi is not someone to be taken knowledge from. Please don't get misguided akhi. He said so many things that are contrary to Qur'an and sunnah. Check how he rejected the hadith of ya'juj and ma'juj. How he said Qur'an preservation has holes, Muhammad ibn AbdulWahhab is a takfeeri etc...

[@Ahmed-pl2gb]

@@mewzi Haha my brother I keep bumping into you SubhanAllah

[@TranquilCastlestar]

@@mewzi I did bro, he's right ( just one hadith he found weak, but he's forcing no one to agree with him, he always says you are free to disagree) but that's for advanced students in Aqeedah, normal people should just stick with whatever taught in Aqeedah and about Abdu| Wahhab. Meanings of words change in use as you study higher, but it's not necessary for everyone bro. We just need to convey the proper message to proper places, not get agitated and scared because class1 lessons are not for class 10 and grade 12 lessons are not meant for grade 3, This is what's happening, and because he studied more he's explanations are a bit different than older scholars. Now they are getting scared because they don't know how to handle that much more of study and if it misguides people, but people in this century have the capability to handle these information, There's nothing to be scared about. He's a PhD! His level of understanding can not be compared to intermediate and graduate level. Everyone should study under an authentic Salafi scholar and then have the right to study on their own. When you're studying Aqeedah and keeping an open mind all around you, you have certain questions, Yasi Qadhi is a blessing to answer us those and keep us on the path rather than getting confuse and just stick with the lesson without understanding and clarification. Again his speech is for advanced open minded students of Aqeedah who has the same questions and need clarification to stay on the Path of Salaf, not for laymen and students who doesn't even know the basics of these. Every teacher has their own students, they should teach what they know, not tell the other person just teach what I teach, their personalities and talents is different! I hope I wasn't too confusing.

[@mewzi]

@@Ahmed-pl2gb Yeah subhanAllah

[@mewzi]

@@TranquilCastlestar He's not on the path of the salaf. The problem is people learn from KZbin celebrities rather than real shuokh. I did the same mistake until I saw the refutations

[@saf8684]

Pleaseeeee stop hating without knowledge

[@holdshiftt2run308]

Without knowledge? You are saying that to a scholar? lol Who are you ya shabab?

[@rashidtemuri3419]

Knowledge of Yasir Qadhi. His hate is baseless. I follow Yasir Qadhi and I never heard what he’s saying. May Allah ﷻ guide us all.

[@holdshiftt2run308]

@@rashidtemuri3419 If you are unaware, then maybe you should look into it. I have been following YQ since the 9th grade. I even attended the EPIC masjid and stopped going to Valley Rnach before that because Omar Sulieman and Yasser Birjas were promoting voting for people who killed Muslims and support LGBTQ and then I stopped at EPIC because YQ started saying weird stuff. He even said that it is impossible for juj wa ma'juj to live behind a wall so they must be zombies when Allah made it clear that they are people but it "didn't make sense to him". He also says that Islam has weird punishments and that the Quran is not preserved as perfectly as it was before. Before that, a few years ago he said that if Umar was tested on fiqh today he would fail due to his lacking in this field. Basically saying he is ignorant.

[@advpodcasts7864]

The question is very misleading brothers and sisters because sh. Yasir said “worshipping” anything besides Allah is shirk meaning if you believe that the person is an “illah” a god other than Allah and you believe worshipping that person in the grave will give you what you want; you have commuted shirk BUT if you if you don’t believe that person is a god and you are still asking that person for your needs then you have committed a major sin but that action in an of itself is not shirk. Please go watch the full video.

[@Mimi-Maa18]

Yes but the prophet pbuh said that making dua is a form of worship, so when you make dua to someone other than Allah, that's shirk.

[@jagenaught]

Why would you call to the one in the grave under ANY circumstances? Unless you believe that there is some sort of benefit. Why would you do this? Qadhi is a deviant.

[@vvaloachi7263]

I am hearing your lecture and thinking that may be you have not heard the lecture of Yasir Qadhi. and amazingly at 8:09 min you confess that fact. How foolish it is to make a refutation video without hearing the man you are refuting ! an incredible idiot !! Yasir qadhi also said worshiping grave is Shirk. but he said that asking something to the person of the grave without worshiping him is not Shirk , but it is Haram , Bidah and a major Sin. .

[@jagenaught]

@@vvaloachi7263 Well asking someone something in the grave is shirk. You're the one who doesn't understand. That is clearly shirk to ask the dead for some sort of assistance. The ones in the grave cannot intercede for you. They're dead.

[@vvaloachi7263]

@@jagenaught Please hear the full ans of YQ. he clarified your point.

[@Bongo372]

I listened to that lecture. Yasir Qadhi didn’t say exactly that. He said some schools of thought say that you can ask from the dead. He was giving different schools of thought. And he also said that a very minority of scholars subscribe to that idea. The way this Sheikh responded in the beginning is not a good way to refute without knowing the whole thing. I am not saying Yasir Qadhi is infallible, he is a human but in this case he is misunderstood.

[@hannahff]

💯

[@xamihkhan]

8:13 "I haven't listened to him directly" Yet you spent 10 minutes criticising what you never heard.

[@fahadhusain1985]

Yeah but he heard him on KZbin maybe When you have some deep knowledge of Islam and Aqeeda, you will know how misguided and poisonous yasir qadhi is Stop listening to celebrities who wants to please people but instead listen to real scholars or atleast daees who are upon haq

[@Shikaari1]

@@fahadhusain1985 www.meforum.org/islamist-watch/53171/karim-abuzaid-and-the-letter-they-didnt-want-you

[@mr.s6607]

@@Shikaari1 what does this have to do with this video? Were ordered in Quran to check and clarify things. Don’t just spread stuff you don’t have proof for could end up falling into some big sins

[@Maya-xz7rq]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rnXYl614adedia8

[@vvaloachi7263]

I am hearing your lecture and thinking that may be you have not heard the lecture of Yasir Qadhi. and amazingly at 8:09 min you confess that fact. How foolish it is to make a refutation video without hearing the man you are refuting ! an incredible idiot !! Yasir qadhi also said worshiping grave is Shirk. but he said that asking something to the person of the grave without worshiping him is not Shirk , but it is Haram , Bidah and a major Sin. .

[@vlogsofsamiyusuf6651]

i completely agree with you brother but some muslim still blind they are following yasir qadri blindly

[@nabilakh3152]

that's is the problem, people like to listen to people who sugar coat what their words. Lot think the true scholars are harsh and strict, and they tend to follow those who make a lot of jokes, add innovations to fit our "modern" lives..

[@sykesyke5786]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/jprYhqp4jM2qaNk

[@MR-ne5fg]

My kind request to anyone in this group is : please don't mention the name of the person to give any kinds of comments or advice. This is not Islamic way. This kind of irresponsible behavior of us makes hatetret and misunderstandings that makes divisions in the society. We have to be humble and intellectual. Please use the 'Hikma' to keep the unity in the community. I'm so disturbed to hear these kinds of comments, advices, questions and answers. May Allah guide all of us to be in the right path and to correct each other without hurting anyone's feelings. Aameen. Ya Rabbal aalameen.

[@themeanzone7571]

Shut up you jahil someone is causing misguidance and your only excuse is causing "Division" have some shame and fear Allah.

[@kainaatkhan9577]

In this particular context it is important to name the individual to save the Ummah from his fitnah

[@dizzyinfo]

I think you need to refute his lecture rather than just giving generic statements and claims about Shwikh Yasir Qadih......he broke down his argument, gave evidences, spoke of history and provided classical commentary.....if you can't do that then you should remain silent.

[@oghanchi]

He did in other videos. Asking a dead person is shirk. Whether you are asking them for intercession or not. This is clear in the Quran. No ambiguity about it. YQ says it is haram but not shirk. His reason is because 1) calling it shirk is done by a particular movement, and 2) because majority of others call it haram but not shirk. Both reasons don't make sense to me or any rational person. He also says Ibn Taymiyyah says so. But he never presents an argument or proof from the main source of Aqeedah, the Quran (I watched his whole video).

[@ummasiddika1178]

A good Muslim can’t attack a person like this way

[@Maya-xz7rq]

His deviated. Watch this kzbin.info/www/bejne/rnXYl614adedia8

[@adamt606]

Creating division amongst the Ummah is not advisable..

[@manuelcardinali5340]

Highlighting misguidance and batil is not dividing, but Jihad fisabilillah

[@Aqani01]

@@manuelcardinali5340Do you know about the discussion between Musa (As) and Harun in surah Taha? When Musa came back and saw his people devided he grabbed Harun by the beard and head and said "Oh Harun why did you not stop them when you saw them misguided, are you not following me or have you disobayed my command? Harun responded " Verily I feared that you would say you have devided the children of israel". Mind you some of them were worshipping idols. What will be the result of this except hatred and devision between the muslims? Easy to tear down something but hard to build it. Better to be silent if you can't respond in a constructive way.

[@zoomermcboomer4771]

Something that I really hate and makes me so confused is when people come here and then say "I don't see where Yasir Qadhi went wrong, he is very knowledgable etc..." OF COURSE YOU DON'T SEE BECAUSE YOU ARE NOT QUALIFIED TO ANSWER AND YOU ARE CRIMINALLY IGNORANT ABOUT ISLAM.

[@NafisaLondon]

You're talking about yourself

[@hva22]

You also need to learn that the honour of a Muslims is very sacred, and also learn good manners. Your comment is very rude against Muslim brothers and sisters; many of the Salaf narrated that they sought learning good manners far before seeking knowledge. It's extremely important.

[@hussainomar1729]

Have you spoken with him individually about his flaws or are you teaching the common man to bad mouth each other?

[@mymunaraha6270]

Yasir Qadhi did this publicly so, why he need to advise him privately kzbin.info/www/bejne/h6W6ZKF8htyMf9E

[@elloello2576]

When a man misguides the people publicly on many different platforms then he deserves to be refuted and warned against on every platform possible .

[@sawmaniac12]

I like yasir qadhi he’s a smart guy

[@eg12p34]

Of course, to the American liberals "Muslim" , he is brilliant. Any normal Muslim would question if Qadhi is still on Islam in the first place.

[@nicolehynes6677]

Abu Bakr (may Allaah be pleased with him) said, in his speech after the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) had died, “Whoever used to worship Muhammad, Muhammad has died, but whoever used to worship Allaah, Allaah is Alive and will never die.” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari).

[@juhelkhan]

With all due respect to you Sheikh, before commenting on something or someone you should watch the whole video or comment of a person instead of what someone just said to you in their own words which may or may not be true as you know very well. Which I wish you should have done before commenting as you very well know we have valid differences of opinions many issues.

[@zainabshoka4219]

👍

[@kadarhashim5997]

He clearly has watched,please raise specific issue.

[@Ahmed-ll4dq]

Yeah so watching the whole video Yasir Qadhi basically says it is not shirk to invoke the dead unless you believe them to be god. Yasir Qadhi is misguided and misguides people.

[@User-4517]

@Non Mon I finished watching the whole 3.5 hour video and you’re right - he has constantly said in the video invoking the dead is haram

[@vvaloachi7263]

I am hearing your lecture and thinking that may be you have not heard the lecture of Yasir Qadhi. and amazingly at 8:09 min you confess that fact. How foolish it is to make a refutation video without hearing the man you are refuting ! an incredible idiot !! Yasir qadhi also said worshiping grave is Shirk. but he said that asking something to the person of the grave without worshiping is not Shirk , but it is Haram and a major Sin.

[@Truthseeker0824]

I was in Colorado with cmcc and never knew that we had this sheikh. I literally thought that everyone in US is crazy as YQ and Omer Suleiman.

[@abdihakimawale8621]

Subhanallah Sheikh why you attacking the Sheikh? If you have advice say it otherwise this is not looking good on you. I listen to the Sheikh and I enjoy every word that comes from his mouth. He is humble, respectful, and someone who is knowledgeable.

[@gabrielabdul8372]

It's not correct to cause fitnah due to personal issues you have with someone! We live in a century when this habit of character assassinations is rampant especially to the scholars. I don't think if someone is confident of himself, will have time to criticize others by going into their long lectures and taking words out of context. I was watching Yasir Qadhi for over 6 years and i never heard anything wrong. So many people have even converted to Islam because of Yasir Qadhi. Indeed Yasir Qadhi holds PhD in secular and religious education. And lastly only Allah knows what is in the heart!

[@Mimi-Maa18]

"I have never heard anything wrong" how do you know that what you heard wasn't wrong ? Are you a scholar yourself to confirm that what YQ says is right ?

[@kafiguled7]

SubhannaAllah, wallahi Yasir Qadhi is one of the most learned brothers in Islam in the west. I love Imam Karim, but I think he's just slandering Shaikh Yasir. I can see why. Yasir Qadhi has learned both in the Eastern Islamic curriculum and at the same time studied in the West to cater to what the Muslims in West deal with on a daily basis. Wallahi I live Shaikh Yasir and Imam Karim, but Shaikh Yasir has never said anything contrary to the book of Allah and Sunnah of RasullullaH SAW. I really thought these two brothers and friends. I'm surprised to hear Imam Karims refutation of Shaikh Yasir Qadhi. I'm hopeful they will meet in Jannah and will among those whom Allah said about them that, "we have removed any animosity in their hearts, they will be conversing recling on besutiful couches, facing each other.

[@mewzi]

He said so many things against the Qur'an adn sunnah. Don't be misguided akhi. Look how he rejected the hadith about ya'juj and ma'juj. How he said Qur'an preservation has holes, Umar would fail a test on aqeedah, Muhammad ibn AbdulWahhab is a takfeeri etc...

[@happybird7]

Sheikh is not slandering Yasir Qadhi. He is trying to correct his statement and also you can see his major disappointment towards him misleading others.

[@manuelcardinali5340]

YQ is a fool

[@raselrahman6468]

Akhi stop following yq! Theres so many major statements hes made openly! They all over the internet

[@vvaloachi7263]

I am hearing your lecture and thinking that may be you have not heard the lecture of Yasir Qadhi. and amazingly at 8:09 min you confess that fact. How foolish it is to make a refutation video without hearing the man you are refuting ! an incredible idiot !! Yasir qadhi also said worshiping grave is Shirk. but he said that asking something to the person of the grave without worshiping him is not Shirk , but it is Haram , Bidah and a major Sin. .

[@malikgaming2031]

It was narrated that Abu Umamah (may Allah be pleased with him) said: The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) saw me moving my lips and he said to me: “What are you saying, O Abu Umamah?” I said: I am remembering Allah, O Messenger of Allah. He said: “Shall I not tell you of something better or greater than your dhikr of night and day or of day and night? You should say: Subhan Allah ‘adad ma khalaqa, subhan Allah mil’a ma khalaqa, subhan Allah ‘adad ma fi’l-ard wa’l-sama, subhan Allah mil’a ma fi’l-samai wa’l-ard, subhan Allah mil’a ma khalaqa, subhan Allah ‘adad ma ahsa kitabuhu, subhan Allah mil’a kulli shay’in (Glory be to Allah the number of what He has created, glory be to Allah filling what He has created, glory be to Allah the number of what is in earth and heaven, glory be to Allah filling what is in heaven and earth, glory be to Allah filling what He has created, glory be to Allah the number of what is written in His book, glory be to Allah filling all things); and say Al-hamdu Lillah likewise.”

[@kamcarcrusher857]

If you want to be on the straight path, follow Quran and the sunnah of rasulullah (ssallallahu a'alaihi wa sal'lam) whatever you have doubts in go back to the ajam³ of ulama, the majority of the scholars. Don't just follow one imam. May Allah guide us all and unite us all on the path that he's pleased with. Allah'uma amin

[@idrissabdillahihassan6916]

You make us confused. Criticizing another Sheikh publicly is no good way as imam.

[@mysticminority9060]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/iHnQhpZmiLJod8k

[@vvaloachi7263]

I am hearing your lecture and thinking that may be you have not heard the lecture of Yasir Qadhi. and amazingly at 8:09 min you confess that fact. How foolish it is to make a refutation video without hearing the man you are refuting ! an incredible idiot !! Yasir qadhi also said worshiping grave is Shirk. but he said that asking something to the person of the grave without worshiping him is not Shirk , but it is Haram , Bidah and a major Sin. .

[@peopledontthink1503]

Can u guys provide some proof regarding these claims?! Can u send us a link where Yasir Qadhi says that worshiping isn’t shirk?

[@hamzaalikhoso6688]

He didn’t say that WORSHIPPING A GRAVE is not shirk. The shaikh is misquoting him unfortunately

[@hamzaalikhoso6688]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/b3eZipVpp76Yd9U

[@zackxal6481]

this is what some najdi's always do, changing the words and attacking person upon their understanding and not what the gut actually said, he didn't say WORSHIP he actually said that if someone is WORSHIPPING than that's SHIRK, he said INVOKING which is slightly difference but can have different ruling, YQ is very precise when he says what he says, but those pseudo scholars are really the ones who have an agenda, this video was really painfull to watch

[@hamzaalikhoso6688]

@@zackxal6481 exactly bro

[@abulkalam2671]

@@hamzaalikhoso6688 Thank you brother may Allah reward you

[@mdkhan3928]

I dont know why but I just can't stop watching it over & over again!😝🤷

[@naeem6722]

Ive listened to YQ for a while and never have i heard him say what the imam is saying. Pleae put your energy into other lectures to help people rather than trying to bring other sheikhs down. YQ always explains all issues well and clearly states when he has an opinion from himself and i will continue listening to him.

[@zeeali2565]

Why do our scholars attack one another rather than discuss their intellectual differences. I don't see the same hostility towards one another from leaders of other faith groups.

[@maryambham3124]

MashaAllah...May Allah grant u the ability to further make other Muslims understand that yasur qadhi has now become a liability. ...Allah hu aaalamu

[@SaqibAslam]

You need to listen to what Yasir Qadhi actually said instead of listening to people who twisted his words !!

[@fauziamohamood3610]

No one is twisting his words .....

[@SaqibAslam]

@@fauziamohamood3610 yes this caller did and these other so called Dawah guys are cherry picking things from his lectures.

[@SaqibAslam]

@Ismail Same goes for you .. and did you watch his entire lecture?? he was quoting other scholars when talking about shirk..

[@SaqibAslam]

@Ismail you obviously haven"t watched his lecture ..otherwise you won't be asking such questions !!

[@SaqibAslam]

@Ismail so you are accusing him for something you haven't watched ..good job brother !!

[@hamzaalikhoso6688]

Yasir Qadhi didn’t even say that “worshipping the grave” is not shirk. Please research before speaking.

[@mewzi]

Yasir Qadhi is not someone to be taken knowledge from

[@hannahff]

💯

[@capodon2654]

Lol I love the sheikh, he ended it by saying mixed grill hahahaha

[@Shikaari1]

Spoken like a desi maulvi because food was on his mind.

[@kryzhamid2810]

Subhanallah look at this Sheick. He did not even allowed the questioner to finish his sentence and he just jump into saying something about the man, immature. This man is very dangerous because he only accept his way and other ways are wrong. Even the Sahaba have different opinions about some of the rulings. I watch the video he was talking about please go find the video and watch all of it for your self if he said that. He even stated that he did not watch the whole clip or even watch the clip he heard it from another joker. Even from the way he talk he needs manners. May Allah bless all our Sheicks who unite but not to divide. If you have problem with him call him one on one and ask what’s his proof? Or debate with him intellectually.

[@MonirulIslam-xm6rw]

As Salamu Alaikum Being muslim scholar how can you believe that Dr Yasir Qadi told "WARSHIPPING GRAVE IS NOT SHIRK". Have you heard it by your self or do you understand proper english. Your comment is out rageous. What do you mean by Yasir Qadi's community, what community do you belong, Egyptian community. For your kind information we are not belong to any community, we are one community and we are muslim. Memorising Quran and Hadith , don't make you intelligent, otherwise muslim would be the most intelligent nation over the planet. You don't mind to reap the facilities from american society, you don't mind to get aid from usa ( Egypt got more aid from USA than any other muslim nation since long time and they got 1.5 bn us $ in 2020) and you don't mind to live in usa either but he went yale, you got a problem with that. Do you understand Quran, Do you Understand Hadith, do you? Yes, Yale taught Islamic studies as well as Cambridge and Oxford but being muslim scholar if you go to study in yale or cambridge or oxford , will you follow their life style. You are also surrounded by Kafir people , do you follow their lifer style. So what's the fuss. Before making comment about other muslim scholar over the social media, it's your duty to contact with that scholar personally and ask his opinion about the matter that you are not agree with. You just can't appear into the social media and talk rubbish about other muslim scholar that's not working at all and it reveals your intelligence level as well. Because of you people muslims are the worse nation in the world. Your Sincerely Mohammad

[@user-qb2lv8uo4x]

I am so glad you said this.

[@abidjalil4241]

May ALLAH Grant the so called celebrity scholars guidance, if they deserve so or expose them, eliminate them....AMEEN.

[@fauziamohamood3610]

If you want to be misguided listen to yasir qadir I love that so true

[@thiernobalde8142]

If you want to follow the middle path of Islam, follow Sheik Yasir qadhi he never talk against anyone. You're judging him You're talking about his intentions. Your video is 12 min long you didn't talk about anything only empty accusations. How many times Allah is calling us to think in the Quran . We really need to critically think through out our history and text. I love Sheik Yasir qadhi may Allah guide all of us.

[@wthroofing9036]

Yeah, if you want misguidance. If we does no speak against what not correct is not a badge of faith. It is tacit acceptance.

[@khologne]

Allah Hu Akbar!!! Shaykh May Allah bless you and protect you. Tell it like it is.

[@sykesyke5786]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/jprYhqp4jM2qaNk

[@MrPinkNorway65]

I am sorry to say that Iman Karim by attacking the man instead of the ball he creates fitna and animosity between muslims. What do you think that people who like to listen to Yasir Qadhi feels about this? They will probably get angry at you maybe even hate you and what good does that make? What benefit is it in this kind of attack. Discuss the differences in an intellectual way. May Allah (swt) bless you with guidance

[@fishmorecatchmore2787]

Brother said "get a hike" haha...its take a hike my uncle in islam. May Allah preserve all the true scholars and guide those who are misguided. Ameen.

[@masudalam1985]

Assalamualaikum, Dear brothers and sisters That's why it's obligatory upon each and individual to know Deen of Islam so you can identify truth and falsehood. May Allah guide us all and make us amongst the pious one.

[@abidjalil4241]

Haqq...prevailed

[@sykesyke5786]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/jprYhqp4jM2qaNk

[@esaabdullah2762]

Beautiful answer. May Allah bless you

[@sykesyke5786]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/jprYhqp4jM2qaNk

[@mobinmirshekari4884]

May Allah reward him for it !

[@eg12p34]

Exactly my thoughts on him. I followed him for a while until I noticed he clearly believes in Shirk.

[@mysticminority9060]

Mashallah Im happy your not blind follwoing. May Allah keep us all guided.

[@ashrafalvee7382]

Assalamu-Walaikum Could you give me reference brother?Any video where he said something contradictory to Aqeeda?

[@shafinrahman2199]

@@ashrafalvee7382 I want to know as well, It's hard to believe such a reputed scholar to believe in Shirk

[@Katsuki1031]

@@ashrafalvee7382 kzbin.info/www/bejne/iHnQhpZmiLJod8k

[@lilacblue783]

I used to follow him but some of the stuff he said made me uncomfortable

[@hamzaalikhoso6688]

The shaikh is misquoting Yasir Qadhi unfortunately. He didn’t say worshipping the grave is not shirk. You guys can see what he said: kzbin.info/www/bejne/b3eZipVpp76Yd9U

[@holdshiftt2run308]

Yeah, he said it is not shirk to call on other than Allah unless you think it is Allah. No one is misquoting him. He said it was haram and not shirk. He is wrong, it is SHIRK. Sh. Karim has been working with YQ and knows him personally and has known him since they worked together on HudaTV which is like more than 12-13 years ago. Please stop trying to jump to his defense everytime he preaches misguidance. He said that if Umar ibn AL-Khattab was here today he would fail a test on fiqh. He also said that the had is "weird" and that the Quran is not as perfect as it used to be. He also claims that the traditional method is not a proper method. This means all of the sahaba and salaf were ignorant according to his logic. Unless you attend EPIC yourself like I did or have some inside info please stop trying to defend him.

[@zozoconde4623]

Yasir Qadir has got a serious problem. He is the one who said that there are holes in the Quran. How low could this guy stoop when Allah says in the Quran that if the Quran was to descend on a mountain, the mountain will collapse and it is the same Quran that could make the dead speaks. But Allah will make that same Quran descend on the head of Yasir Qadir. The holes are in his head. If he does not understand the Quran, he has to blame himself for Allah again says in the Quran that there are things that are specific and others unspecific and the unspecific, it is Allah alone who knows its meaning. Allah did not give us that knowledge and ih he did Yasir would have poohed on our head. ALLAH KNOWS BEST.

[@nazhasan428]

You are too aggressive and rude. Condemning other scholar is not welcoming in Islam. You are not representing Muslim. Muslim should be humble and think good thought on other muslim. More so an islamic scholar who dedicated his life for dahwah. Different in opinion is acceptable in Islam that is the reasons we have many mazhab.

[@hannahff]

💯

[@AJ-aabbcc]

Thank-you so much for your response.

[@salathaabdi2067]

Asc sheikh, as far as i know Yasir Qadhi is a great scholar and whatever issues you have with him kindly solve it inhouse. Defaming one of our own in public is defaming Islam. Thanks.

[@mymunaraha6270]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/h6W6ZKF8htyMf9E

[@sharifally28]

Clearly there’s something going on between them,

[@jahangirkabir5682]

Agreed. It is sad to see this smear campaign amongst scholars. Unfortunately this is what happened throughput the Islamic history. There is no discussion, no congenial engagement. There is a divide between the Sheiks from the old countries and the more sophisticated English-speaking American Muslim scholars. Sheikhs have very little tolerance for the American born scholars. Saw the same trends in Bangladesh too. They constantly trying to berate Yasir Kadi, Norman Ali khan and similar scholars. Local maulanas keep on doing the same thing - lecturing on how to do wadhu, how to use meswak, and constantly saying how everyone is going to he'll even for apparently very reason. It's not going to endvsoon,.

[@muhammadprarie8819]

How do u know he's a great scholar?

[@fauziamohamood3610]

Sorry what great scholar your talking about???? Yasir qadir???

[@ikramkhan3894]

That Yasir Qadhi is the best, in the beginning he was wahhabi but Allah subhanuhoo wa taala guide him and saved him from Fitna . Alhamdulillah

[@yourenviousenemy]

It's literally not YQ's opinion, it's a well espoused opinion from notable scholars that praying at graves is Haram, not shirk.

[@affy45]

Mashallah, May Allah keep you strong, Stay strong sheikh

[@penjejakaswaja894]

imam karim remind me of dr sheikh ali jum'ah very much..they were the strong defenders of Ahlussunnah waljamaah in our time..may Allah give them barakah and blessings till their last day...ameen

[@mohammedazim6905]

Brother U can’t criticise people unless u heard his comment. I think some one heard something and little bit change and presentation to u and u comment is not good Thank

[@mewzi]

No, Yasir Qadhi is not someone to be taken knowledge from

[@hannahff]

Exactly, our Deen requires absolute proof in a court of law so this should apply in everything we do. Jumping to conclusions about a person is very dangerous as it can lead to false accusations as seen here and many other refutations of others. Before you make an assumption about someone, go to them directly or examine the evidences directly.

[@mewzi]

Also, I've been watching Yasir Qadhi for the past year, I watched his complete seerah series, watched a bit of ~"most beautiful names of allah", applied his fatwas and even shared his videos with my school mates. Until I saw the deviant ideologies becoming evident as I started watching real scholars. And then the ikhwani methodology of all sects have khair in them. Ya'juj and ma'juj are not trapped behind a dam. Even though it clearly states in surah kahf. Then about ibn abdulwahhab being a takfeeri even though I'm reading his kitab tawheed and it's filled with qur'an and ahadith. Qur'an preservation has holes? this goes against the ayah "indeed we have revealed the dhikr (qur'an) and we will be its guardian". And he said Umar, may Allah be pleased with him would fail a test on aqeedah! And now calling upon saints is not shirk? I'm done

[@spartan187]

Brother pls verify information before you pass a judgment all I say . I saw YQ comments as well what he said was different thing which is also not correct . But what you said about YQ is not correct as well . Walahi brother I m concerned about ummah how brothers attacking one another … you are so senior you can easily talk to him and try to correct him rest is with Allah

[@hannahff]

💯

[@dawoodallen3452]

Brother, you really feel that this Shaykh is taking on SIN and SLANDER to discredit this brother... O brother, I strive to have strong Iman and I don’t believe I’m no where as strong a Muslim as shaykh Kareem, and I even know better than to report something about without proper facts... Really Brother! ❤️

[@diyanaabdullah4255]

Alhamduillah, I have learned immensely from Sh. Qadhi. Its unfortunate to hear this but Allah swt is the Best of Judge. I love them both.❤

[@mewzi]

Yasir Qadhi is not someone to be taken knowledge from

[@abdullahnaseer4559]

Great scholars do not name other scholars and refute them. Sh Dr Yasir Qadi explains pretty much all opinions on a matter (unlike most scholars) and then he mentions his preferred opinion. All his opinions have precedence. With all due respect, Imam Karim says he didn't listen to Sh Dr Yasir Qadi, but is refuting him?? How?? Based on 'something' 'somebody' said abt him?? Reminds me of this video by Sh Dr Yasir Qadi in his Library Chats series on Refutations: kzbin.info/www/bejne/hpvNk3aimK2fpJI Well worth watching.

[@hannahff]

JazakAllah Khair for pointing this out.

[@vvaloachi7263]

I am hearing your lecture and thinking that may be you have not heard the lecture of Yasir Qadhi. and amazingly at 8:09 min you confess that fact. How foolish it is to make a refutation video without hearing the man you are refuting ! What an incredible idiot !! Yasir qadhi also said worshiping grave is Shirk. but he said that asking something to the person of the grave without worshiping him is not Shirk , but it is Haram , Bidah and a major Sin. .

[@luk-man7889]

You guys love to divided people. Whoever has slightly different opinion on certain thing, you rush to brand him or her as " kafir, deviant ". It is all your way or no way. Can you just accommodate each other stop diving us.

[@marlonhosten4693]

It is from the ethics of Taqwaa that if you find something in your BROTHER that you don't like, or if he said something that offended you, that you should seek him out for clarification and rectification. To slander the Brother in a video that will go viral to millions, will only further sow the seeds of DIVISION AND HATRED in the hearts of Muslims. Even if a muslim deviates, the path to reconciliation is never to slander. In America we lack effective Domestic leadership that is Wise and God fearing !

[@keishakelly5057]

May Allah make it easy for for Shk Yasir Qadhi and guide him ...It can happen to anyone Ameen 😔

[@vvaloachi7263]

I am hearing your lecture and thinking that may be you have not heard the lecture of Yasir Qadhi. and amazingly at 8:09 min you confess that fact. How foolish it is to make a refutation video without hearing the man you are refuting ! an incredible idiot !! Yasir qadhi also said worshiping grave is Shirk. but he said that asking something to the person of the grave without worshiping him is not Shirk , but it is Haram , Bidah and a major Sin. .

[@user-qb2lv8uo4x]

What has happened to kind words????? Does it not hurt when we see this 'fodder' for the vultures? Please call brother Yasir and ASK him...PLEASE...please please. May Allah swt soften our tempers and words and soften our tone. ...so deflating....:(

[@vvaloachi7263]

I am hearing your lecture and thinking that may be you have not heard the lecture of Yasir Qadhi. and amazingly at 8:09 min you confess that fact. How foolish it is to make a refutation video without hearing the man you are refuting ! an incredible idiot !! Yasir qadhi also said worshiping grave is Shirk. but he said that asking something to the person of the grave without worshiping him is not Shirk , but it is Haram , Bidah and a major Sin.

[@InshiNaz]

Please ignore these fights between sheikhs.. It will lead to doubts and destroy your sincerity with Allah. These are waste of time

[@theahmedfahad]

Waste of time for common people not for us , students of knowledge and ulema as we will be questioned by Allah on judgement day .

[@ihaq31-Islam-and-Physics]

Masha-Allah Dr. Yasir Qadhi is great and doing a fantastic job in preaching islam. No one is perfect. To be honest it is difficult to follow your logic.

[@ihaq31-Islam-and-Physics]

@TheRockit1991 Brother one can correct another if they are wrong. No one is perfect. I also held a different opinion with him on some matter. But to put out a blanket statement against brother Dr. Yasir is wrong. Agree or disagree on issues but to claim he is totally wrong is not right or fair.

[@kaboom362]

@Brother,Karim I suggest you watch the aforementioned video and make Taubah. The amount of people in the comment section that are bad mouthing Y,Q as a result of your stance is alarming. I ask Allah to forgive you because clearly haven't exercised patience. Borderline arrogance

[@maggyhamada2560]

But it's not about patience, it's about warning people against those who can destroy our aqeedah. This is a serious matter and if no one talks about it then how can differentiate between truth and falsehood?

[@kaboom362]

@@maggyhamada2560 okay. Have you watched the video?

[@peanutbutter-bananashake]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/a5rEcqxqqpZ5rNU

[@kaboom362]

@@peanutbutter-bananashake I'll ask you the same question. Did you watch the same y q video? Somebody put a link to it in the comments

[@aatif7518]

@@kaboom362 his other deviancies are enough to stay away from him He claims Allah's laws are bizzare! How dare he??

[@alisaeed4129]

Yasir ghadir made a video clarifying he did NOT say Quran was flawed or corrupt. Please go see his explanation

[@KhalidKhan-lg2he]

Alhamdullilah! Jazak Allah Khayr shaykh

[@Anon-uv9mj]

By Allaah this is scary to think about. May Allaah protect us all from doubts.

[@fadhilabbas5784]

Are you really a sheikh? If so then why don't you sit and discuss between the two of you rather than talking any him in the media. Cz our religion tells us if someone has done wrong you should sit with and advice the right way.also you were saying" you don't know" if you don't know that means you also not sure of yourself .

[@Mimi-Maa18]

The religion also tells us that when someone makes a mistake about aqeedah in public, they should be corrected in public so that people don't get misguided.

[@ImranAli-tm3rq]

YQ said that asking from dead saints is evil, haraam and should not be done, you didnt include this bit did you? However, he also said it is a gateway to shirk but falls short of shirk. Because those groups that do it say that worship is only for Allah, and everything is from Allah. They ask dead saints believing that they are alive in the barzakh, they can hear them and intercede on their behalf to Allah seen as they are Wali Allah. Very emotive, but one should put personal feelings against an individual to the side and be more academic. Maybe the Muslim world will be in a better state if we were less spiteful and emotional and more academic!

[@starsighting7167]

That quickness tho 😂

[@qinagreen8931]

The Shaikh nailed it , Subhanallah

[@mobinmirshekari4884]

May Allah reward him for it !

[@user-dz4ty5tj7q]

Yasir Qadhi said whoever calls upon the dead, this act is haram, can lead to shirl and should absolutely be avoided however it is not shirk unless the person believes the dead person is an object of worship and the person who is calling upon him believes that dead person is a deity. This is what I understood from that q&a.

[@12345678956824]

Watch Abu Ibraheem Husnain's response to that

[@vvaloachi7263]

I am hearing your lecture and thinking that may be you have not heard the lecture of Yasir Qadhi. and amazingly at 8:09 min you confess that fact. How foolish it is to make a refutation video without hearing the man you are refuting ! an incredible idiot !! Yasir qadhi also said worshiping grave is Shirk. but he said that asking something to the person of the grave without worshiping him is not Shirk , but it is Haram , Bidah and a major Sin. .

[@shafinrahman2199]

What did Yasir Qadhir do, I remember his Yaqeeninstitute did a lot for the Muslim cause. I hope you are not slandering him without investigating. That would be a sin.

[@AISHAHALI05]

Yaqeen is Omar Sulaiman not Yasir Qadi.

[@shafinrahman2199]

@@AISHAHALI05 I see, thanks. His one is called Almaghrib institute it seems. Nonetheless, I hope he's not slandering him without investigating, that would be a sin.

[@mewzi]

​@@shafinrahman2199 There are way too many proofs. AlMaghrib institute and Yaqeen institute are not at all places to be taken knowledge from.

[@jasenkosaric1145]

@@shafinrahman2199 Why don't you go investigate things Yadir Yale Qadhi has been saying for the past 7 years then come back and write things you obviously know nothing about. You need to investigate before you write. Please. Thank you

[@NafisaLondon]

Yasir Qadhi worships Allah not this Sheikh or the people in the comments so Allah will judge him not any of you. Understand that.

[@MohammedShaad-lm4sx]

Dont bring these liberal ideas of only God can judge me. the athar hadith of umar ra says we judge a person (i.e. his deeds) by what is apparent. if someone like qadi is teaching public the wrong thing we tell the public they were being taught the wrong thing. your concept of only god can judge is not found in the quran or the hadith but actually is a saying of tupac. I dont know if you hold preference to the words of tupac over allah or his messengers, that is up to you to confirm.