ChoColat - Black Tinkerbell (2013.06.29) [Music Bank w/ Eng Lyrics]

[@kiyowoshe6034]

If you still here even many years had passed. Then you deserved a veteran awards, you still need listening to their song at last.

[@eri-kuntehee6997]

They had so much potential 😭

[@starfire139]

They sang in key even in the high notes! I'm impressed.

[@fremzter]

I love that "I cant leave you" dance

[@tristv8320]

They call it the fairy dance.. Tia made and named that dance.. 😁

[@page.aneiva]

this gives me so much nostalgia from when i found them in 2014 during my huge tinkerbell phase its sad they disbanded though cuz theyre so good

[@negatron5514]

I miss live performances like this.

[@sittie4637]

I am still a fan. How i wish there’d updates from them. They have SOOO much potential yet wasted

[@Chonchon359]

この歌すごい好き

[@Meauie]

I love that every member comes up to the middle for their part instead of just having the same person in the middle throughout the song.

[@loeildekiara]

i’ve been looking for them in the past 1 hour… finally

[@tyletk]

This group has potential to becoming a huge success because these girls can actually sing really well, especially Melanie. They are very coordinated. I hope they had more recognition. Their company sucks at promoting them. If they promote as much as bap and vixx, they would be more popular

[@우주소녀덥즈사랑유승]

데뷔때부터 지금까지 쇼콜라 팬인 한국팬인 나...티아 말고도 나머지 맴버들인 소아,멜라닌,줄리아 지금 잘 지내시는지...뭐하고 지내시는지 너무 궁금하네요...

[@cutie1847]

Whatever happened to them? I remember being there when they first debuted and being like "damn this is pretty catchy" and all their songs after we're pretty solid too, too bad they never got popular did they disband?

[@RosaPerez-cy2pe]

Yes, they disbanded :'(

[@peach1018]

They debuted ahead of time, if their debut is today they must've had a fanbase now..

[@oFailBoat]

@@peach1018 doubt it. Even if the marketing was this way.

[@adorkable7196]

@@oFailBoat Had they debutted in 3rd Gen they would DEFINETLY had a good fanbase (especially second half of 3rd gen), they would have been really popular abroad more than in Korea but they would have been able to have some sort of market share. Even as 2nd Gen groups i remember them making a buzz during debut, it just didn't last.

[@SuperChunyong]

Guess I will never get over this group & song (':

[@aprillailina2694]

Apa cuma aku yang tetap suka sama lagu mereka dari jaman SMA sampai sekarang, kangen mereka huhuhu😢😢

[@Azie08760]

😄🙋

[@080mochamadnurzakkimubarok4]

SAMAAA

[@oumelj7691]

Their live performance got better during BT promotions

[@gamexii27]

Their voices couldn't be more perfect !! They are so effing good not sure why they only have a few songs since their debut ... They should have way more... Ughhh PERFECTION ^.^ btw i cannot believe Tia is younger than me shes so mature .. I look up to her .. Even tho im her unnie x)

[@KayeMusume]

Korea just wasn’t ready for this amazing group:/

[@imjaewonn]

Melanie have a perfect voice, i miss the group.

[@bismarkdouglas890]

Como o tempo passa rápido. Sempre lembro desse hino ❤️‍🩹

[@Xlovesmaryse]

I miss them sooooooooo much!!!!! Julianne come back😭😭😍😍

[@BBoPPo88]

once a year i get this, syndrome, or one more day stuck in my head

[@tristv8320]

Chocolat! I'm thankful i watched the episode of Dream Team where you participated in (the mud wrestling matches between Kpop girl groups) because that was where i got to know you! Then i realized almost every member was not fully Korean! And i love it when all of you know how to speak English maybe except for Soa noona! Chocolat hwaiting!

[@margaritazuniga8843]

It's sad that they disbanded.

[@콩콩이-p5h]

숨듣명 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@michellesbae]

맞아요……. ㅠㅠ

[@김가영-s7v]

마자요..... 진심 숨듣명 ㅠㅠ

[@hdh020406]

ㅇㅈ

[@MrTrafficcones]

I expected them to not be good live but oh my god was I proven wrong I might have found a new group to obsess over :)

[@akilarius8554]

I'm still here..

[@wulandarimismanap6970]

Miss them

[@NainaiAutumnal-el7cq]

love this song, my childhood 🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@nonsensicalsoul7787]

i hope they get more popular !!!!

[@Kuromichi08]

This song was such a bop

[@sarahdarling6439]

I like the song, and Melanie's part at the chorus is my favorite part

[@AnimeWorld-jw1cj]

I miss them back memori 2011😭

[@21vermouth]

i miss them so much. i regret not knowing them before this song

[@009koi]

I love chocolat ,its good for Kpop to have chocolat

[@wegighusainrobbiardi9115]

i love them

[@RodrigoCevallos-t6h]

Me encantas CHOCOLAT te amo ❤❤❤

[@bwest6275]

They are so good. And arguably one of the most attractive looking groups as well. What happened to them?

[@kinssu__]

They disbanded unfortunately :(

[@Azie08760]

don't worry, there are still people who remember them..still listening to their songs

[@Ma7thew1208]

Im glad they had a comeback :D AWSUM SONG!!!

[@gerher9416]

Mmm, their company is Paramount Music (from the US) and that is hardly little

[@jdjdhdbxbsjjw]

kpop wasnt ready for them

[@gerher9416]

Tia is like the most beautiful girl in kpop atm imo

[@feli4881]

this song is way too good to be thi underrated 😢

[@Rikkulyoko1]

Good Job Melanie!

[@maggottyblackie]

omg thank you so much! :D

[@n.4139]

randomly remembered this song

[@Lynn-oh3tp]

where are they now? it's so unfair they didn't get big

[@WomensIconn]

LIVing in their bEST life

[@김수철-t1e]

5인조에서 4인조로 멤버수를줄인 여성4인조그룹 쇼콜라 현재 그녀들은 활동기간이 그리 길지않아 지난 2014년도에 해체됐다 짧은기간이지만 음악방송에서 열정을다했던 그녀들이 이제는 각자 활동중이라는것을 특히 쇼콜라 멤버 막내 티아는 솔로데뷔후 큰화제를 일으키고있다

[@YebGyul]

ChoColat♥♥

[@adamstark9555]

Tia is......Extreme beautiful!!!!!!same Melanie also!~!!

[@DivineBoyZ]

Soa is so prettty

[@juancarlosgonzalez4113]

Juliane OMG 😍

[@DuaChai]

Melanie ! She sounds beautiful.

[@amizatulnajhah]

I miss them 😭😭😭

[@sweetlyxs9889]

2021 ❤

[@Pipabloi]

Amo que si cantan en vivo no como algunos grupos de ahora 🥺

[@Minwoo1995]

I've been reading the comments and I don't see anyone who like Tia just by e comments but She's my fav!!!!!!!

[@oqs15]

melanie's so pretty.. :)

[@SuperLittlecookiemon]

Tia is soooooo freakinnnn gorgeous.

[@GZBDance]

Melanie

[@Xlovesmaryse]

They grow up so fast

[@belladevina9303]

Where are they now 😭😭😭😭

[@RANDOM-j4u]

Mungkin kalo dilihat waktu itu segalanya terlihat aneh. Mereka seperti datang dari masa depan. Coba lihat sekarang !

[@21vermouth]

MELANIE

[@VirjScarlett]

I watched them since they debuted. I started of as a hater because Tia has a lot of screentime in their debut making the other girls look like backup dancers but I stayed till the end and loved all their songs. It's unfortunate that they had a controversy where knetz didn't like them because they're mixed.

[@tyeWantspie]

I understand that but they've worn the same black dresses. I'm not bashing them at all, I actually love this group a lot...I just...I wanted to see different dresses....jeeze.

[@맘맘마미아]

아직도들음 라이브도 잘함

[@OnCeUpOnATiMeLoNgAgO]

Juliane!! :D

[@loveisinfinite1997]

@Ger Her oh really? I heard that their company ran into some money issues so that's why they haven't done much....I guess I was wrong.

[@WomensIconn]

When ChoColat will reunion :(

[@MrCouchkamote]

who got here because of the new Disney movie Peter Pan & Wendy?

[@JenniferKim319]

Melanie's voice is

[@cutiiepiie4ever]

Juliane

[@alinaugustin4487]

2018? Anyone?

[@jayancatechno]

Julianne.

[@gerher9416]

Yeah Yu Ra is cute also, so is Minah

[@fathiaputri3083]

2019 meeeeee

[@maggottyblackie]

Can someone tell me who is who? Very much thanks!

[@nanyrofi1204]

miss them somehow

[@DGBETCH]

Lol her landing was rough, good song

[@athirahsyafinaz1698]

Melanie! Melanie! Melanie! :)

[@tyeWantspie]

they don't have to change colors. just other clothing that's black. That's all I meant.

[@loveisinfinite1997]

Their company is really small though so I'd understand why they can't provide Chocolat with more than just a few stage outfits.

[@markgeetoh7328]

Somi when she was young

[@XO-uu8kc]

I love chocolat. I know this song is about tinkerbell but the word "small" seems weird should use "young" idk

[@RandomNameName]

Juliane

[@Badalee13]

At least they dont do lip sing 😭❤️

[@asyrafzainuddin]

Melanie 3

[@tyeWantspie]

Are they ever going to change clothes?

[@hannahlee9568]

Melanie -3

[@ILLIT_MOKAWONHEE]

멜라니는 트와이스 미나 느낌난다

[@joanaandjam]

But she looks fine.

[@13loodLust]

Try Girl's Day Yura.

[@13loodLust]

They only have 1 outfit. They can't.

[@cindywangcyun]

Juliane really should lose some weight.... non offensive... but other members are way to skinny~~~