Keith Jarrett v. Brad Mehldau Ballad Styles

[@piggyfly00]

Glad the algorithm made me find you

[@JeremySiskind]

Aw shucks! I’m glad we found each other too! (And the Eastman School of Music is my Alma mater)

[@titolivio6832]

Bravissimo, lezione eccellente!

[@evelynyturralde4113]

I loved your analysis of their styles and your clear explanation. Also showing the sheet music where we could actually see the use of more notes in the same space. Most of all, love your enthusiasm! Thanks.

[@JeremySiskind]

cool! I'm glad you liked it, Evelyn!

[@MehrSpaamSpaHabenHaben]

Great one!

[@mfurman]

I have been studying “Playing Solo Jazz Piano”. Jazz ballads is my focus, as far as learning jazz is concerned. Thank you Jeremy.

[@JeremySiskind]

You’re welcome. Enjoy, Michael!

[@subschool5415]

thanks Jeremy this was very cool!

[@JeremySiskind]

Nice! Glad you liked it. :)

[@miciomatto1]

Thanks for the shadow

[@JeremySiskind]

Many thanks for watching! These are two of my heroes!!!!

[@MasterRancisis]

Love all your videos. Always categorising and formalising things in a way I've never seen before. Wish I had you as a teacher years ago!

[@JeremySiskind]

Let's invent that time machine! 😂

[@RupertTheD]

Thanks Jeremy! This was really well done and informative. My 2 favourite pianists. 🙏

[@JeremySiskind]

They’re two of my favorites too! Thanks, Rob!

[@nyc130]

Excellent analysis. Does your book have Jarrett For All We Know transcription?

[@JeremySiskind]

No, there are no transcriptions in the book. I never really recommend reading transcriptions for those who actually want to play in a style. 😉

[@wadecottingham]

rich content, much appreciated!!!!!!

[@JeremySiskind]

Thanks, Wade! I love talking about my favorite pianists!

[@pnojazz]

Check Keith Jarrett’s masterful trio recording of Blame it on my youth live in Japan in about 1987. Blew me away. It’s on a DVD.

[@JeremySiskind]

Ooh, cool. I love the tune! I’m sure Keith crushes it.

[@danielmay5337]

Great video. Thanks Jeremy

[@bucketofbarnacles]

This is the first time I’ve come across your channel. Wonderful stuff. I’m an upright and electric player from long ago but still love this stuff. Many thanks.

[@JeremySiskind]

Awesome, MMM! I'm glad you like it!

[@maramazone]

Great lesson Jeremy Siskind! Maybe you can do another video on how they play “Out”. Love the way Keith Jarrett plays out on the Jaki Byard tune: Chandra and Brad Mehldau on the Elmo Hope tune: Dee Dah ✌️🙏

[@JeremySiskind]

Cool! I don't know those recordings, but it would be interesting to do some talks about how folks play "out" and what that really means.

[@maramazone]

@@JeremySiskind yeah definitely! Chandra is off Keith Jarrett’s trio album: At The Deer Head Inn and Dee Dah is off Brad Mehldau’s trio album: Seymour Reads The Constitution. Check ‘em both out! That will be great if you could do an episode on playing “out”. Thank you for replying, much appreciated! 👍

[@kenseidman409]

Another insightful presentation, Jeremy! Here’s an apropos question that may be answered in your book (which I haven’t read all of yet!): when approaching a complex transcription such as the KJ one you referenced, would you recommend the average student mainly study/analyze what is going on or really strive to duplicate what’s being played (using slowed down audio of course as an essential tool)? Not sure this is a clear or valid question as technical abilities vary so much. When I studied with pianist Dave Frank long ago he told me to slow down a Charlie Parker solo and sing with it. I asked him if I should then play it; his response as I recall it was that would be great but singing it (i.e. internalizing it) was the heart of the matter…

[@JeremySiskind]

Hi Ken. It's a great question! I don't think there's a simple answer. I think there are a lot of different things that you can get out of a transcription. You can work to gain muscle memory (what does it *feel* like to play like Keith Jarrett), you can work on your ear (what is that chord?), you can get down to the details of phrasing and continuity (how does one phrase lead to the next?), and you can analyze so that you can figure out why a phrase sounds as great as it does. I think these are all valuable and some might be better for students at different points in their development. So, I think singing is great, but I think there are times to play them and I think there are also times to write them down so you can study them.

[@robsonmartins1062]

I have a question for you jeremy. Please ,don't sit on the fence .In your opinion, technically speaking ,who ia a better pianist, keith jarrett or Brad mehldau?

[@JeremySiskind]

Jesus, they're both so good. I hate to choose. I guess, gun to my head I'd have to say Keith? He certainly has proven his resume with all the classical playing he's done and I've heard him playing more diversely than Mehldau. But they're both like superheroes to me.

[@robsonmartins1062]

Brad Mehldau wraps time and space. His playng is instigating. Disgustingly Beautiful.

[@Nico-rw2tl]

For me, it would be crazy to think that Mehldau approaches the pianistic level of K.J....

[@robsonmartins1062]

@@Nico-rw2tl,I agree with you.Brad Mehldau doesn't approach the pianistic level of keith jarrett. He is better.

[@duongduong2414]

can I request Dave McKenna "3rd hand swing" technique.

[@JeremySiskind]

I'm not a master, but I can maybe fake it? There's surprisingly little information I can find anywhere on that. Have you found a good resource!

[@duongduong2414]

@@JeremySiskind Thank you for replying me. I listen to Dave on spotify but he played so fast and it's hard to imitate. So, could you listen to the tune: " Santa Claus is coming to town" and show us how to interpret that skill or fake it up to 99% LOL. Great to hear that from you soon.

[@alexendrix6]

shadow on left side of the piano you should correct the video make it brighter,thx Jeremy

[@JeremySiskind]

Lol; thanks! I see it too. I try not to record at night because the lights not good, but sometimes the day gets away from me…

[@abadibi]

Wow. The brother of the legendary Scott Alexander.

[@JeremySiskind]

Lol! That's me!

[@abadibi]

@@JeremySiskind tell him his blog helped me through some tough times as a young adult:) reading his posts made me believe in myself and made me look for more out of life. I hope your channels blows up Jeremy! :)