AZTV7 Pheonix Morning Scramble "U.S. Educations Vs. China and India"

Keith Ballard in Morning Scramble speaking about the differences in the educational systems of China, India, and the United States.

[@nannuuuuu]

Ask the same question when they are studying engineering 😂😂😂

[@Ok-kr4vt]

It is pretty much same why the Westerners want to be actors and rappers, for money.

[@turning_point96]

Not everyone will end up... But having a dream and hope...that's matters most...

[@ftd7435]

The Chinese and lndians have no problem studying engineering. 70% of my classmates are engineers and they breezed through universities and polytechnics. All are retired or semi retired comfortably.

[@Himanshu-im4qm]

Assignment 😂😂

[@ceesparadigm7784]

Hey keith. Its not a joke But the co-Founder of some high tech company in India say this. I am not worried if my son donot get admission in IIT or IIM India. Theres always Harvard. And heres my son, in Hardvard. the point is how difficult is to get an admission in this two prestigious IIT N IIM in India. But so easy to get in Harvard.

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Ceeyuu - thanks for the comment

[@aniketsourav1912]

He is Narayan Krishnamurty owner of Infosys one of the biggest tech company of India.

[@Blast_AR-lol]

India will have many Engineers and Doctors and China will have many teachers

[@Prit307]

When they say teachers they mean a PhD

[@douss8150]

Indian teachers are not that good. It's the environment, the pressures, the social standards that drive students to the extreme.

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Douss - you make a good point.

[@devinanair5549]

Correct

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Lily - God only helps those people who are willing to help themselves. Look at fairly religious Catholic regions like South America, Central America, and even Mexico. God does not seem to be helping the people that live within this area very much. If you really want things to happen, you have to take control of the situation!!! China is certainly not a very religious country but the people have taken control and risen through hard work, education, and a strategic plan...

[@debasishraychawdhuri]

I think the Indian education system is really bad, but the family culture is what makes the students so hungry. In India, it takes a village to raise a child. If your kid wants to be a musician or a dancer or something, your neighbors will complain about it, your extended family members will complain about it and you will be seen as a disgrace.

[@ckpal3575]

It needs to change

[@Shoxnu.17]

I disagree man, A village kid is raised for the main purpose of earning enough to support the family and this is encouraged to a child from the childhood and you can see the hardwork and dedication that the child puts in academically. They discourage them to focus on extra curricular activities because they believe that it's very risky and it actually is in India. Take a musician for example, he is payed less in India compared to the ones in America who make a fortune out of it. But a parent from a really well known school don't really force a child academically because they are thought well in the schools from the childhood. It really depends on what type of school a child studies in. The reason why CBSE and ICSE students do amazing in all fields.

[@SKNayak-gl4xt]

@@Shoxnu.17 a good musician is paid anywhere the best he can earn, even in India. They must be motivated by their parents and peers since childhood. Read about the initial ages Shreya Ghoshal or Lata Mangeshkar began their first stage performance, and that was simply because their parents motivated them in that direction. And I don't think Sonu Nigam, Arijit or Shreya earn lesser than any medical or engineering professional in India, and rather earn 10x times or more. Indian school students lack vocational training and it shows when the colleges try to make them industry/job market-ready. Most of them are inefficient and have no clue about the practical applications of their mugged up knowledge. Stop talking like a caveman, who hasn't been out there since 4-5 decades or more.

[@zeusolympus1664]

@@SKNayak-gl4xtfirst of all I am saying this as a 17 year old. I think parent's motivation is important, but in the recent year parents are more inclined to motivate their kids to do either engineer or doctor. Heck India has more engineer than China, which is why India can see a shortcoming on teachers in the future. India is a growing country and its economy is growing higher and higher, with that growth I think parents also want their kids to be at least financially stable. The most financially stable jobs are doctors and engineers that a middle class family can pursue. Recent artists like Neha kakar and Badshah, when compared to other previous or some contemporary Indian artists, they are pretty bad. But they are still popular because they are rich as fuck, so they can get chances to make songs for a famous movie and spread their audiences. Then there is nepotism and all these factors are going on making things more complex. I guess this is why parents or even students just wants to choose to be either doctor or engineer. Maybe in the future when India becomes more globalized and produces more variety of stable jobs.....them the future might change. This is prety big Maybe though.

[@SKNayak-gl4xt]

@@zeusolympus1664 also, I feel you are putting irrelevant things into an argument about education system. I understand you're frustrated about some trendy social media marketing, but that's not the point here. Parents of our generation do not know or even care about singers or actors, and are pretty much ignorant.

[@varungodbole7835]

What's wrong in saying Professional football player? Asia is obsessed with Math and Science because they are more safe and secure professions to earn money. I don't believe in pushing relentlessly to control kids future.

[@keesomkumar2144]

Wanna know why they go there for study? It's not because Ur colleges are better but...but..but....but... because of "the Placement". Just because we think, we would get better placement opportunities there.

[@ralphzaeger44]

Student: mom i want to become a rapper American moms:honey do what you like i want u to be happy Indian moms:you doctor,you engineer or YOU FAILURE

[@jiyaneol2273]

or occasionally the oh no i am soo open not a narrow minded person you can be a CA as well

[@minerjopeace5915]

@@jiyaneol2273 hahahaha. LOL.

[@minerjopeace5915]

Ralph, that's true for most middle-class god fearing, high aiming Indians.

[@kuralovien5524]

Me being from an CBSE board in India, I personally think every aspect of education is important not just science and math. Kids need sports, sleep, recreation, model based education rather than just making them sit in the class and lecture them for 8 hours straight, I'd think that'd be an utopia for learners who wants to succeed in life, teach them basic medicine, how to do tax calculations along with traditional syllabus such as science and math along with civil rights, sports etc...

[@kollurubharathsimha539]

We knew that pain but these white dont understand it wants to throw their kids into that shit . but our parents are best

[@naiyayika]

Let's work together and change our respective systems guys. We're much happy in aiming towards American universities.

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Mukundan - thanks for the comment. I agree with you 100%. There is a big difference between the university system and the K-12 ed system in the USA. My focus is on the K-12 system which is very mediocre at best.

[@simpleperson404]

Hey Keith, try to google about Kota city in India. There is actual competition.

[@luovisienyusou3211]

Mr Keith always love to cite the same contradictory example the like of NFL... NFL..... In his every interview.

[@manohardixit1928]

Indians admire Americans

[@aditya3984]

As a Indian myself. Keith you havent seen the other side,it not that rosy here.

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Aditya - yes you are correct. The bottom line is that China is far ahead of India in education and infrastructure.

[@aditya3984]

@@KeithBallardEdu yes china is doing far better than india in infrastructure and it's universities are being ranked higher.But in both the countries students are frustrated due to extremely difficult competitive entrance exams,narrow carrer choices,old curriculum and no space for anything else than studies. It is a system which brings up the best and burries the inferior.Societal pressure is hampering students mental health.Many even decide to end their life's. Basically all overpopulated developing south asian countries are in same state.More seekers than finding. But atleast in India we can complain.

[@radhachatterjee3390]

You are right but Steve Jobs,Mark Zuckerberg and Bill Gates are from U S A.They are inspiration for many Indians.

[@rahulnair1305]

Yes Steve jobs. Bill Gates and mark Zuckerberg was not made by American education. It is there society which made them. We indian need to make such society for our kids

[@medogideon4030]

All these interviewers are so proud and stubborn to accept that America is lacking behind 🤣

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Spotany - I agree with you.

[@lilyleong3178]

We should best not decide our future ourselves, God has a plan for everyone of us, we should pray to ask God what is His plan for our future. God's plan for us is the best plan, don't waste your best plan that is given by God. Thanks.

[@calvinripley9093]

OMFG just stfu god won't come down from the sky and tell you your future!!!!

[@keiaccountkhongsai7788]

In my opinion, why the education percentage is not good in America comparing with an Asian countries because of the Government law against the parent. The parents should be given the power to do whatever to their children, let the parents beat their children. Why to sue our own parent, if they beat us to bring us out from wrong to right or to have a bright future.

[@NotMyUsualPersona]

Welp, to be honest, if it is a parent who is home drunk and taking out his frustration on children, I think he should be sued. Don't get me wrong, there should be limits to reprimanding even if it is violent. That being said, yes I too do believe that simply scolding does not work for many kids. When I was in tenth grade, I became too overbearing and also got into the wrong company. My dad slapped me twice right in front of the whole school. At that time, I felt very uneasy but now when I see those guys (most of them have addictions of all kinds), I literally pray for my dad's long life and we'll being. I am doing well today and I am satisfied even though many would consider that incident in other countries as violation of some right.

[@claritypoint82]

The secret of indian doesnt lie in teaching it lies in the discipline

[@kevinmashru5367]

I particularly don’t think the education system quality is to blame. But I think what India and China does is they make their kids ready for high stress environments so that they can thrive in college.

[@manashdb]

You have neither been to China or the US, let alone spend time there on a grassroot level to form an opinion based on facts. So what you think matters as much as horse manure. So go on and smell some farts.

[@RS-uz3ud]

India and China places high value on marriage. You will rarely see parents split up after marriage. When children have a happy and secure home, they will do well in school!

[@vedkharade2484]

He looks like Harvey Specter from Suits

[@current49]

this is at ground level

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Ability-thank you for the information

[@shri2549]

Thats not actually right cause in India parents want/ wish thier children to become a government servant , officer IPS , IAS. Govt. Jobs are more than just a safety net, its like gold mine. And dont forget the reservation system from castes, gender to ex army personal. This is also makes frustrating to people with merit. Now days the competition is so high some students are doing suicide even if they dont get admission in a specific collage or their grades are slightly low And thats the reality. For most of Indians education is the only key of survival.

[@gauravyadav2661]

Indian education system needs to change for the better.

[@davidfrancis8610]

Sir I think American students are correct , because what you know about life in your school life , I don't know is the right answer because it's not about competition it's about experience the education not much people India become wat they tell, because there is a job crises here.

[@HarshilHandoo-cm5gk]

6:18 🤣

[@rahulgokhroo6686]

❤

[@kaliathehell7527]

He was right about china though

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Pkm. Thanks for the info