Killer Sentenced To Death After Brutal Murder | The New Detectives | Real Responders

Canadian Police are on the hunt for a missing woman although all indications suggest murder, they must rely on a single strand of animal hair to prove it. When an Ohio woman vanishes suspicions swirl around her husband, what police lack is hard evidence. In Missouri, a man is found murdered, to catch his killer police must piece together his final minutes.
Content owned and licensed from New Dominion to Little Dot Studios.
For all questions, please contact [e-mail]
#RealResponders #NewDetective

[@judithpeligro5837]

Gene Galusha is one of the best narrators I’ve listened to. His wonderful voice is so pleasing and so compelling.

[@guesswho1886]

Bill Kurtis has him beat

[@EthanBalmer]

Whether it's nap time or nighttime he is my dream Weaver.

[@douglascroghan9657]

The Doctor actually intended to move into, and live in the house, where he buried his murdered wife ? That is one sick dude !!!

[@ARedMagicMarker]

When you view people as objects, it's a no-brainer.

[@pianomanhere]

Maybe he thought she'd be a foundation for an even better life.

[@LadyVoldemort]

He's probably psychopathic enough to do that, but the pregnant side woman and his new baby will also going to live there? Super creepy yo! Hope the innocent baby grow up okay though.

[@astrialindah2773]

That poor young boy in the Second Story, having to hear his mother being murdered and finding out that it was his father... devastating.

[@LadyVoldemort]

My heart goes for him, I hope he grew up okay. He sounds smarter than his stupid doctor of a disloyal father. Pretty sure the grandma knew, too. Hopefully he can be away from her too.

[@devynhayley6411]

@@LadyVoldemort apparently the grandparents disowned him. And his sister was put up for adoption / foster in a different home and he’s still trying to find her

[@INDLIS]

Collier Landry Boyle (who was 11 when the murder occurred and was 12 when he testified at trial) and he did a documentary called A Murder In Mansfield.

[@INDLIS]

@@LadyVoldemort His name is Collier and his father was truly a narcissist (who had other dark secrets [other than being an adulterous] prior to the murder).

[@celineleeuwe1206]

I don't understand that Boyle only got 20 years after what he did. He'll probably be paroled in 2023? This was premeditated. No ex-wife no alimony. his plan was to start a new life with his mistress and his children. To bury her in his basement. What a freak! I think the mistress was involved also. How convenient that his almost ex-wife disappears all of a sudden. His son is in danger if he gets out.

[@STScott-qo4pw]

his son in danger...? don't know about that. i think if the son was living with a step-family and boyle - if boyle got suspicious the son Knew Something - wouldn't hesitate to kill his own kid. just a feeling. also, i think if the good doktor's plan worked the son would find himself in an eerie situation and not feel welcome one bit in his old man's "new life".

[@timmyshore3755]

that’s canada’s legal system. no death penalty and you get out of prison after you serve at least have your time in many cases. you need not wonder why it keeps happening.

[@feliciabosch8110]

I like when stories are told by the people that are on the case

[@James_Bowie]

Jul 16, 2014 BONNE TERRE, Mo. Convicted killer John Middleton was executed by lethal injection at 6:58 p.m. Wednesday following the failure of various appeals on his behalf in the courts. He was pronounced dead at 7:06 p.m. Middleton was convicted of killing Randy "Happy" Hamilton, Stacey Hodge and Alfred Pinegar out of concern that they would tell police about his methamphetamine dealing. Middleton's girlfriend, Maggie Hodges, is serving life in prison after pleading guilty to second-degree murder in all three cases.

[@leahoakwood9988]

24:49 What a brave young man! He heard his father murdering his mom, yet still had the courage to speak up. Bless you, young warrior.

[@voraciousreader3341]

The boy is now an adult and his name is Collier Landry; he legally dropped his father’s surname. He did an excellent documentary about his mother’s murder called, “A Murder in Mansfield.” I watched it a few years ago on KZbin, so you should be able to find it. You should also check out his podcast (“Moving Past Murder”) which is on Apple, and he has a KZbin channel under his real name, Collier Landry. His father came up for parole in 2021 (I think) and his parole was denied. Collier didn’t just lose his mother and his father....both his mother’s and father’s families rejected him after the trial (he was a key witness), so he ended up in foster care, and his adopted sister was put in a different foster home. He has tried to find her, but never has. He suffered a great deal of trauma.

[@leahoakwood9988]

@@voraciousreader3341 Thank you, for this information about him. His story breaks my heart. So grateful he's been able to sanely move past all the abandonment & terror. I'll look up his channel and his doc. I gave you a "thumbs up" because of your generous and kind response; however, I KNOW, his brutal experiences affect both of us. A beautiful and innocent person in my family was senselessly murdered, too. His sweet little girl was too young, to have ever known him, as well as I did. Monstrous humans have no idea the damage they cause, nor do they care. Thank you, again, friend.

[@jamesb.9155]

Yes, indeed. Such an unfortunate outcome for the boy. So glad he took it personally and got the justice his mother deserved.

[@CourtneyTunbridge79]

​@voracious reader Thank you so much for the update, I often wonder about those that are left to pick up the pieces after a tragedy, I always hope they have received all the supportive services they will need to help them process what they have been through, although I know the reality is most of these people who's lives have been destroyed are often left to fend for themselves after the police, sometimes media and liaison officers have finished ticking all their boxes and paperwork. So much carnage and broken people are left behind it's awful and terribly sad. So it's nice to hear of somebody using all that damage as a catalyst for something good.

[@jenniferroach4153]

Snowball rubbed up against him knowing he was going to kill her and decided the law had to be intelligent enough to figure out the hair came from his coat.

[@CeruleanTalon1]

Does the pregnant "wife" think she has any better prospects than the Doctor's deceased wife? What happens when he gets tired of her?

[@timmyshore3755]

he done gonna have vinnie whack her

[@brandytipene7338]

Safe to say. "This perpetrator got snowballed." Meow. 🐈🤪😎

[@Amor1990]

The 2nd one. What a truly terrible being. Burying his wife in his new house.

[@DavidBrown-bp4iq]

Morgan. You're standing next to them in the market. Selfish, stupid people. Be surprised what they're thinking and why.

[@davidmcknight4525]

Snowball, what a cat!!!

[@angelabroman18]

That young boy's paternal grandmother was a nightmare too I am sure.

[@angelabroman18]

@@wtttff Tote!😔

[@loritracy1385]

So much more fascinated by HOW they solve the crimes than the stories of the killers( although I watch both). For the good ones, massive respect.

[@misty5979]

20 years to life, WTF!

[@diplomamilldoc8562]

And if you do a search he’s trying to get his conviction overturned and also parole.

[@ina-tajwedwab2486]

The doctor is both evil and stupid! Why he would take a body to his new house is beyond me!

[@thimashiangel3026]

All that education down the drain for the doctor

[@mariekatherine5238]

Who could live in a house where your ex-wife’s body is rotting away in the basement?🤮

[@lauraatkinson4790]

Someone who only considered her property and not a human being.

[@lauraatkinson4790]

In a 1990 lawsuit filed on the behalf of Noreen Boyle's children, Noreen's estate was awarded most of the money and assets accumulated during her marriage to Boyle. He retained $20,000 and the title to the Erie house where he'd buried Noreen's body. Boyle agreed to a $500,000 judgement and the estate would also be able to collect by pursuing any future income Boyle earned, including money earned from the sale of rights to his story to publishers or production companies. The judgement also settled a paternity suit filed by his mistress for $67,500. In December 2020, Boyle was denied parole for the second time since starting his sentence. His next parole hearing is scheduled for August 2025. He remains incarcerated at Marion Correctional Institution in Ohio.

[@timmyshore3755]

excellent sleuthing 👍

[@louisliu5638]

@@timmyshore3755 I thought "Marion" Correctional was in Illinois?? (That's Federal; lots of bank robbers and extreme cases). so this "Marion" must be a STATE inst.??

[@melissaupton2097]

What an evil egotistical human that Dr. Boyle is. He STILL denies he killed her and buried her in the basement of the new house he moved into with his pregnant mistress. His son is a remarkable young man who I recently saw on Dr. Phil.

[@corwilliams3098]

so creepy looking ;wouldn't let him near me. and who the hell would want to set him up ?

[@INDLIS]

Her name is Sherri Campbell and she’s Mark Davis’s (Boyle’s business associate who ended up providing the key evidence that sealed Boyle’s fate). niece

[@FC-hj9ub]

@@INDLIS and what would he have to gain by jailing his business partner?

[@INDLIS]

@@FC-hj9ub Davis followed the case through the media and the discarded concrete chips (from the Erie home) sealed Boyle’s fate

[@Anita-k]

Throwing the old concrete pieces onto his friend's property was the most illogical and stupid action the good old doc made in his whole crime! They never would've found those pieces, if he'd thrown them anywhere between his new home and said property, as it's only totally normal human curiosity of his friend, to follow the doc's/friend's criminal case by far more closely than any stranger's crimes. I don't think he got framed though, but didnt understand this decision at all.

[@lisaalexander7248]

He got the right Voice for these stories!!!

[@DavidBrown-bp4iq]

Yes. Simple phonetic American. No accents, no affectations.

[@chrisdissident]

I listen all day at work. Its perfect.

[@stevennabe5356]

Peter Thomas forensic files was the best narrator of all time. Period!

[@wtttff]

@@stevennabe5356yuppp

[@FC-hj9ub]

Do in laws believe it when a previously engaged parent suddenly "walks out" on their kids? Or they're that desperate not to see their son's behaviour?

[@diplomamilldoc8562]

Snowball walked into that cage a lot more calmly than my cat ever did

[@shototodoroki4816]

Lol 😂😂

[@kerryknight228]

Snowball is epic!

[@carriehodgson8920]

Right !?!? Lol 😂 I can get mine to get in her transport carrier for vet visit but I really don’t think a stranger could.........everybody would be Kung foo fighting,,,,,,,,,,,everybody! Lol :D

[@lauraatkinson4790]

Snowball was chill because he was getting scale for that acting job. He had three scenes, plus dialogue. That's the way you bring home the gushy food.

[@Aluminata]

That's the difference between train and ameture actors.

[@joelee662]

Simply amazing How all this was put together and they Caught the perpetrator That's what I call good detective work 👍👍👍👍

[@santakriel9189]

Hope Snowball is okay👀

[@santakriel9189]

Hope Snowball is okay👀

[@carolstrachan4197]

Never ceases to amaze me how dumb murderers really are! It would be laughable if it wasn't so tragic. I feel so much for the kids and the rest of the families who have to go through the murder of a loved one. There's never any closure for them. 😢

[@shototodoroki4816]

Boy. ..oh boy...real demons live with us not only movies

[@elisa.r.]

I think they are not dumb because psychopaths don’t consider consequences. So to us they look stupid but it’s not least the case

[@corwilliams3098]

I always think, why do murderers always keep their receipts? do they plan to get a refund?this is the first time someone actually did ! he must be cheap, too

[@pastelfantasy_rika]

I ask that when they use credit cards or club cards… I’m like UR NAME IS TIED TO IT IDIOT

[@FC-hj9ub]

@@pastelfantasy_rika they just say some one borrowed their card or stole it

[@Ellen-hs7zb]

Right. Returning the left-over bullets after the murder, really smart!

[@hayden823]

I've seen all these cases on Forensic files. I don't mind watching them again. Really sad for the dad on the first case, he said on Forensic Files he should have killed his daughter's ex-husband when he had the chance, he'd be in jail but his daughter would still be alive.

[@irmalaucirica1688]

Yes I think I watched almost all the cases I admitted being addicted to justice because I am a christian active servant of the Lord, though now I can't do much specially with my heard condition I had a heard attack just one a half month ago my heard is working only 30% so I'm in bed but still can give Glory to God. There will be perfect peace, justice and brotherhood in Gods Kingdom men are revels and mostly evil because a life without God is empty no Heavenly light dark nessy it's the lack of light and Satan is darkness he would take control of those who are living in the dark ! Give your life to The Prince of Peace He pay the way with a his blood on the cross ! God bless you all !

[@tThisNThat]

I saw that one too, that was so sad.

[@anyastar8]

I love this channel. So many cases in 1 episode. I'm also glad there are re-enactments

[@WeirdKidThatLikesSCP]

Me too and the voice of the narrator is soothing just like Peter Thomas' voice from medical detectives produced by film rise.

[@anyastar8]

@@WeirdKidThatLikesSCP same. I also enjoy watching Forensic Files by Film Rise

[@WeirdKidThatLikesSCP]

@@anyastar8 wow nice to have met you here fellow fan. 😊😊😊 God bless

[@SecretSquirrelFun]

I remember this!! This is the one where Snowball saves the day? GOOOOO SNOWBALL I do remember that the ex partner wasn’t the sharpest tool in the shed, not the brightest crayon in the box - I guess my main takeaway here is that he was and is an idiot, a solid gold idiot. Thanks again to Snowball and to your many uniquely genetic ancestors.

[@--Skip--]

...the village idiot?

[@shototodoroki4816]

Lol

[@shototodoroki4816]

Ama just relax with my cold beer 🍺.and watch this.. actually I don't even need cable no more..

[@WeirdKidThatLikesSCP]

I am an avid fan too

[@deniseshephard3347]

I do hope snowball the cat was treated fairly before and after the investigations and not killed which happens alot in these places

[@jeanneeber]

I love these masters of evidence! If I could start my life over-thats what I'd love to do for a living! Evidence collection & detection work. It's fascinating.

[@timmyshore3755]

no need to start over. do it now. community college is where you’ll start. 2 year program then you go from there. inside of 5 years you would be doing it. pays very well to boot.

[@markemerson8399]

Getting involved with people who have anything to do with crime is a downhill path.

[@montydendron1]

Three great stories with satisfactory endings.

[@stuboyd1194]

These dummies leave so much evidence behind.

[@tammyhjlpere6714]

just to clarify. We do not have the death penalty in Canada... I guess that might have been obvious when you read the info under the headline and see the doco... but not very clear

[@DavidBrown-bp4iq]

Pity.

[@tammyhjlpere6714]

@@DavidBrown-bp4iq I agree. used to be a pacifist- but no longer

[@KFav]

So what was Snowball's sentence?...Obviously an accomplice

[@phoenixfire2578]

I don't think the cat hair was good evidence. Since she & the kids were around the cat, they could've transferred the cat hair. Pet hair gets everywhere.

[@craighall689]

Yes your right....I'm thinking the cat hair was the least of the evidence they had...think the shoes and clothes he stupidity left for someone to find buried him myself

[@phoenixfire2578]

@@craighall689 It's cool what they did with the cat dna, but I agree, it was the clothes they found that got him. They're lucky they found that stuff outside, bc I would've argued a search warrant based on the cat hair.

[@craighall689]

@@phoenixfire2578 that's it phoenix fire...thank God these murderer's aren't too bright!

[@lauraatkinson4790]

Which is why they looked for more evidence to cinch the case, eg, the footwear impressions on the shoes found with the jacket.

[@geegeestarks2116]

That psycho doctor only got 20 yrs, wow! On another note let's all thank Snowball for his beautiful fur being in that jacket. Thumbs up for Snowball 👍

[@curtiscf1986]

I love how the actors are the less “methed up” version of the real people. 🤣

[@user-rv1wf6sd4p]

I take my hat off to these phorensic doctors..the things they must see!..👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻⚘⚘

[@SecretSquirrelFun]

“He beat her to death” wow, just.....wow. And then Noreen’s beautiful brave boy. What a totally great kid. His mother would be very proud, I’m sad that your father did this. I’m being framed, framed I tells ya’!! Ha ha ha, yeah right - you keep telling yourself that Doc’.

[@shototodoroki4816]

Demons are really and they live among us...looks at Chad and Lori daybell case

[@theranjithjay]

1994- Prince Edward Island - Canada - Police hunting for a missing woman and a material witness - An abandoned car belonging to 32 year old Shirly Dugay, mother of five children was found by the Canadian mounted police. Police questioned her ex husband Doug Bimesh, who became a prime person of interest. Police found a jacket and a pair of running shoes in a field and the jacket had the victims blood on it and a cat hair was found on the blood stained jacket and the cat hair was found to have come from Doug’s cat.

[@Bailemos888]

Many times its best to let these cheating people move on, dont fight it, love yourself and walk away.

[@donnydonnybrook8131]

100%

[@FC-hj9ub]

Umm maybe that is what she was trying to do??? He killed HER when she was minding her own business.

[@mariekatherine5238]

I hope they gave Snowball a reward!

[@ggasco1254]

John F. Boyle Jr., the former medical doctor convicted of murdering his wife in Mansfield's "trial of the century" more than 30 years ago, has been denied parole for the second time. (2020) Boyle has served 369 months in prison. His next parole hearing is scheduled for Oct. 1, 2025, according to the parole board decision. He will be 82 yo.

[@timmyshore3755]

excellent sleuthing 👍

[@droppedbye.2698]

Aww poor cat hope it got homed.

[@alrighty6898]

So many cases of spouse killing their spouse with kid(s) in the house

[@glenndigan015]

Nice to watch all your videos I gain knowledge:. Keep it up and continue 👍👍👍🧡

[@johnhaaland74]

Middleton was so afraid of going to jail that his own paranoia sent him there. How ironic 😅

[@jillsharp002]

He was a p.o.s. I was 16 when he killed those 3 he would drive by me and he was just plain creepy you could just tell he was no good

[@amistoalets3]

Good investigators,everything is perfect

[@billgatesleavingyamomshous8177]

Nightmare fuel before bed 🛏

[@luvtocook6881]

It is incredibly dangerous for people leaving a bad marriage. As soon as someone is missing and the spouse says they left on their own without their kids is a Red Flag. I know… I left a bad marriage with consequences. The police need to act on these ASAP.

[@luvtocook6881]

I miss my fringe jacket and purses lolz

[@lloydburgos8931]

Thank you sir..

[@wendyh3891]

Amazing thank you! Cheers from South Africa 🇿🇦

[@darrenmorgan870]

When the copper said it was strange to get a solicitor before you,d been accused of anything and the only thing that happened was that his wife was missing, yet we all know the first port of call for the coppers is the husband, boyfriend etc when looking into a missing wife, girlfriend, so it isn't in the realms of insanity for the husband to get some protection from ladder climbing coppers, but sometimes it could also indicate that it was themselves who killed their wife, "girlfriend" .

[@barbsyorkies]

Who does this kind of stuffffff....why????

[@movas4927]

It mostly takes easy access to guns for anybody to commit a murder. I'm completely appalled by that...

[@amyjojinkerson6745]

that guy just lost his freedom

[@mcdarkness4779]

A white cat named "Snowball"??? .Guilty of lack of imagination at least!!

[@chesspiece81]

Thank you for uploads like this and other crime/forensic involved shows

[@tubemoozful]

shocking...the overly possessive, jealous & anger issued husband did it...never would gave guessed

[@breegreen6573]

....space so no spoilers ..... I know he was a suspect, but I'd still be heartbroken if my cat got seized by cops 🤣🤣😭😭 she left, took the kids, they took his cat. DAMNNN

[@WeirdKidThatLikesSCP]

Who's the man behind that voice

[@timmyshore3755]

his name is bill tuttle

[@DavidM2002]

For those who have never been to Prince Edward Island... it is NOT isolated or sparsely populated. Actually, it is a large well populated island and is a province of Canada. It has a huge 12 Km long bridge plus a ferry service connecting it to mainland Canada; the Confederation Bridge.

[@351clevelandmodifiedmotor4]

Who else thinks now have I seen this one?

[@misty5979]

Ok it's Dr. John Boyle, he looks so familiar

[@sidclark1953]

Who is the guy in the Veely ad at the end who says "everything we knew about the world might turn out to be completely wrong"???

[@gonavy1]

I'm not so sure in Canada life in prison really means life in prison until you die there. I've always said if you're going to do a crime do it in Canada because you'll be out of prison before you know it. Am I wrong on that?

[@leslieshand4509]

Yes you are wrong. A sentence of 25 years to life leaves it open for parole. A sentence of life in prison with no possibility of parole is exactly that

[@gonavy1]

@@leslieshand4509 so how many people in Canada are actually serving life in prison with no parole ever. Meaning they will die in prison without ever having any possibility of parole.

[@timmyshore3755]

no you are right

[@01MIDWAY]

All these freaking ads....if I wanted to watch TV I wouldn't be on KZbin....

[@tommymorgan4677]

If you use a pc, adblocker.

[@Kinvesu]

lol I could understand nowadays cause how price gouged bullets are but, come on, back in those days, the ammo was so cheap, who the hell returns unused cartridges for a refund?

[@HdHd-hp6qz]

These adverts are killing me

[@The1AndOnlyTeabager]

Wait I was like remote and not populated? Never would I think I’d see my home province on this show I love so much

[@INDLIS]

John Middleton was executed on July 16, 2014

[@timmyshore3755]

💃

[@toby-jeanne_almy]

Reupload? Darn it :( was excited..

[@andrewclarke2638]

I'm wondering , if the cat still alive. The police dept : should study this video for the care of animals. Only the cat (snowball) can tell me if it's alive or police in future look after well being and adopt future animals if needed to catch their owner ! 🤔

[@batmansymbol3645]

Stupid criminals or good detectives...🤔

[@RebekahAPinto]

Both.

[@danlhendl]

Snowball did it!!

[@feliciabosch8110]

Yes he is a monster 😠

[@realisationnation]

REALisation: @15:00 FUZZYduckn [🤬🦆n] panda panda 🐼...

[@jamesanonymous2343]

I USE TO THINK THAT GETTING RID OF THE HOMOCIDAL MANIAC'S WAS HIGH PRIORITY, THEN WHAT HAPPENS TO ALL THE INVESTGATORS, LIDIGATORS,INCRCERATERS, FORENSIC SCIENTISTS,,,,,,,,,""OUT OF THEIR JOBS "" THEN WHAT HAPPENS ????? THE LESS CRIME YOU HAVE THE MORE UNEMPLOYMENT IN LAW ENFORCEMENT

[@Ellen-hs7zb]

With all the mask mandates and job firings, only the criminals will be left. Criminals wear their masks to freely wreak havoc. Try calling 911 and see what happens. Our leaders want chaos so they can take more control. Those trying to find the criminals and control crime have become dupes.

[@mrs.doolittle2180]

Middleton was executed in June 2014.

[@jillsharp002]

Maggie should be too

[@leelajapheth4051]

20 yrs for killing.

[@Waterford051]

Maybe the cat done it

[@morganpettipas9198]

Pei! Damn I'm Nova Scotian haha

[@marilynvallance]

How old is Real Responders? The music is 70/80s

[@landang7906]

16:14 Isn't it circumstantial? Anyone could have feet matching the shoes, a lawyer would say that.

[@SecretSquirrelFun]

At first I thought the person, sitting in the car acting as Middleton, was a woman with a fake moustache. I was very confused for a few seconds and I had to rewind the video and watch the scene again ha ha - I was kinda liking my version better 🙂🐿😂

[@peterjongsma2779]

Does everyone in Canada speak French and English?

[@marymcfarlane5108]

No. Many people speak only one but both are official languages in Canada. The provinces of Quebec and Ontario have the highest percentage of people fluent in both.

[@peterjongsma2779]

@@marymcfarlane5108 Merci.

[@timmyshore3755]

yes and in some of the more remote places creole is spoken.

[@christinesimpson6529]

I think the doctors ring in girlfriend and mother is as EVIL as him, the beautiful son was living in danger with his own father and grandmother they should have been charged as well I suppose it can't be proven but WHAT pregnant women prepares the life of a new baby living in that horror house? You are the blue eyed girl today when you go for divorce poor old psychopathic doctor would have to buy another house with a basement whew he should have got the death penalty I hope his son is with his mums family changes his name and never looks back Blood is NOT thicker than water, it's got to be in you to come out of you

[@351clevelandmodifiedmotor4]

46:02 a dude in primary school used to wear a jacket like that, I'd sit behind him and tie one of the fringes to the bench seat in morning assembly 🤭😆👌

[@lulassong6524]

I wanted to see Snowball...😾😻

[@gcham1209]

the narrator should annunciate. middleton? or littleton?

[@MrRichard57000]

catdidntdoit

[@emmachamberlain7587]

I think snowball did it and then framed his owner !

[@mariekatherine5238]

No! Snowball would never do that!

[@timmyshore3755]

yeah remind me not to hire you if any detective positions open up

[@francisraman4400]

very monotonous commentary

[@Jesus_isLord_andGod]

"For God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten Son Jesus that WHO SO EVER belive on him will not PERISH but have everlasting life" John 3:16 Please all repent from your SINS for the KINGDOM of God is near.

[@hettiemurray2509]

Re run

[@steve62456]

too many

[@theresarasche3173]

AND it shows I never watched it 🤔 Where with other shows it shows I liked it and has a red line along the bottom showing I have watched it!

[@cherokeegirl5908]

Not for me