Kling vs. Runway Gen 3 vs. Luma Dream Machine vs. Pixverse

[@coreyferguson2455]

Hey man Ive been following you for 3 hours now and Im already making some good content but this video really gave me the answer to a question Ive been asking myself for years and that was I cant wait until they make a program that is this detailed as to what you really want and I thank you for classes because you taught me so much in so little time

[@Haunt_Mations]

Great comparisons. I had Kling Premiere plan (8000 credits per month) but ran out of credits after creating 5 or so videos that are usually 2+ mins long with multiple different scenes. I'm going to go with Runway's unlimited plan. If Kling ever decides to release an unlimited plan, I'll swap back to Kling.

[@marcolomiller]

How did that go? I did great shots with kling. Now with runaway iam having hard time. It is not good. Almost 90 generations to have no more tham 5 not soo good options. I fell like i trashed 100 bucks

[@DylanCar]

Wow, I have been using Luma for about 6 months, Looks its time to rock out Kling. Thank you so much for this

[@Vizbot]

Great video! Just to clarify, you can technically specify an End Frame in Runway too; you just have to choose between using a Start frame or End frame, without an option currently to have both. So when you upload the image you can choose to just set it as the End Frame in the toggle option below the image. (Though so far I haven't gotten great results from doing that). I also noticed that the default resolutions that these programs use is different, for example Runway videos were 1280x768, while Luma's were 1360x752, might matter to some people, especially if you are using videos from multiple programs, just keep in mind the difference in sizes. It would be nice if the other players offered unlimited plans, because if you are working on very long projects only Runway is viable right now.

[@bcarse1]

another great video! the comparisons are very helpful not to mention the added insights you offer on challenges of each platform and what they do best. Bravo!

[@1Surinamer]

I love these videos, sit back, do nothing, and see the results. Good job man. And yes, that video was f'ing hilarious. 👍

[@jefferyanderson]

Excellent video, tons of useful information packed in with no filler. Thanks for sharing your findings.

[@growtribes]

Super dig the education. Love the variations side by side, and can't wait for more. Cheers

[@BanthamAI]

super helpful - glad I found this channel - bang up to date as well

[@SillyGoatStudios]

We appreciate this comparison very much.

[@Rick88888888]

Very good comparative review. I have started to use Pixverse, but am not entirely satisfied. It seems Kling is the best way to go for me.

[@heikojohnmoller7853]

thanks for this work and comparison. I know how much time this must take. 10/10 !

[@Awesome_AIs]

Great breakdown! Very comprehensive, engaging, and useful. Thanks!

[@Visualiser33]

Great video (as usual), tried all of them, same experience, Kling is for me the one to go, especially in combination with midjourney. What I missed were some of the extra features like motion brush or lipsync, which is also an available feature e.g. in Kling. Keep up the great work, greetings

[@LisaMurphy]

Would Kling be good for creating a full length dramatic movie? Lip sync is a must but I also need the characters to be consistent in appearance from beginning to end. Also I've been using Pixverse and have made some great videos there but Pixverse gives you a lot of junk along the way. I'd like to try a better tool.

[@Trankilstef]

At last, somebody who tells things how they really are. I have been using Rynway and kling on the premium tier on both and after hundreds of trials and errors in each on them I stopped my Gen3 subscription and I only will use Kling from now on. It's way better in my opinion in almost every aspect. Gen3 sometimes needs 4, 5 or more prompts to actually have something usable but not really good. Kling understands prompts much better, doesn't necessitate to do a dozen prompts to have a good result, sometimes on the first try it's near perfect, it accepts all kind of image ratios without the need to crop like in Gen3, etc. I'm so glad to have tested extensively both of them, cause now I'm truly sure to make the right choice choosing Kling.

[@EmilyNilsen]

I also prefer Kling over Gen3. I wish they had the unlimited video generation plan available as Gen3 does, but I agree entirely about Kling getting the prompt right much sooner than what is capable with Gen3. Getting animated characters to walk with Gen3 is difficult, but Kling does a much better job with 3D characters.

[@Trankilstef]

@@EmilyNilsen yes for now I have the premier tier with 8000 credits a month but I also wish they had an unlimited tier.

[@micbab-vg2mu]

The same - I tested all soulutions and Kling AI seems the best at the moment.

[@indetail2132]

But klings take much time when I generate 2 video in 1 mint gafe

[@indetail2132]

Gets stuck in 99% for an hour

[@manuelahofer6207]

The time lapse was amazing btw 🤗

[@TheodoreGuerlain]

The most useful content on youtube these days

[@manni5636]

Thanks for the comparison. Very detailed and very near to the users. ... and now i ll give kling a try, after i already tried all the other ones :D

[@RobbScottVideos]

Have you moved on from the others because you didn't like them? Or do you want to try other ones too? Just interested because I'm trying to make the best decision for my first time use. Thanks!

[@manni5636]

@@RobbScottVideos Hey thx for the reply. Iam interessted in trying to understand the differences between. In my opinion ONLY if you understand the very small differences between the different tech. possibilities (that each provider (kling, sora, runway, luma, pika etc.) provides) you can understand where the influence is go to and what boundarys are set to the tech. I mean my tech history is longer thna 30 years so I compare alot of different factors with each other which is very exciting especially in the AI and Gaming Branch.

[@RobbScottVideos]

@@manni5636 Thanks for your reply!

[@jango6582]

One of the best AI video comparison videos I've seen! A lot is covered and everything straight to the point. Thank you so much!

[@anuragsingh4087]

Appreciate the effort that you put into this video. 🙌

[@deekay5487]

Thanks for that in depth overview! That helps choosing between all these different option! Although there is another player... Minimax/Hailou which is also impressive. And i love the skateboarding...kind of the spaghetti-benchmark...wondering when it will be possible to generate real good insane fake skatetricks...looking forward 🙂

[@derekthemagician]

17:00 broke my brain. Great video.

[@TheRealUncensoredTravelGuide]

Definitely a great KZbin short.

[@SuperSurreal]

You may not like it, but this is what peak athletic form looks like

[@BoyKhongklai]

I'm still processing it 😂😂

[@napiyosun4677]

Great comparison video. Helped me a lot to choose the best one (almost the best one and of course FOR NOW). Klings looks #1 at the moment. The exact time 19:19 in this video is my consideration.

[@joeteti4958]

This is also a little biased as well, ranking was based on opinions

[@Nehpets1701G]

Been very impressed with Kling image to video - just wish they were a little quicker to render.

[@timooothy1234]

You have to be in a paid plan for there faster generation as they want to force users to do that

[@kay7ot644]

@@timooothy1234 I'm the paid. It seems it's gotten slower over the past month. Could very well take up to 5 mins. Used to be as quick as 1 minute and half.

[@timooothy1234]

@@kay7ot644 really?? Mines like 2 to 3 minutes,must be there servers then

[@IgorDoval]

Thank you for the effort, mate! It helped a lot!! ❤

[@Bullrunnerrr]

Just what I needed. Thanks mate.

[@TheNostalgiaZone-o2s]

Thank you so much for this video! I think I will definitely go for kling💪

[@aliceleblanc7318]

Love your videos, they're so helpful, educational and time saving ❤

[@ThisMichaelBrown]

Fantastic review, thanks!

[@Classicalpianosongs]

Vidu has character consistency even in text to video since a week ago if u want to do a video on that. I think it's a feature a lot of people are looking for and if it's realised they have it maybe the others will finally get it too. Just watching this looks like others can do it image to video but ud always need an image of the exact person in the scene u want

[@ababbitt]

Also... love the golf score ranking of Kling winning the Masters! Thank you

[@Dr.X-Academy]

It’s very very very helpful. Thank you for sharing this

[@christian_duru]

Exactly what I was looking for, thanks for this video

[@zdrowyrozsadek.]

Great comparsion, thanks 👍👍👍.

[@BybbyCreme]

fantastic video. just what we needed! however, Runway is still too expensive for me and I still can´t access Kling :/ I guess, it depends a lot on the shot you want, also. Liked the slo-mo of Pixverse and the writing of Luma

[@NB_nobody]

Thank you for all the effort!

[@AI_Music_channel2024]

The AI comparison video was amazing! Since I also use AI, it was a topic I found highly interesting. Thank you very much!

[@SuperSurreal]

Fantastic comparison! Thank you!

[@ManuelaHoferchannel]

Thanks for confirming. Kling and Runway are great!

[@matthewfedder706]

Would love any information/tutorials on companies exploring AI editing tools for cutting and putting together videos using user provided footage

[@NGW_Studio]

Bro you're missing out on the best part and that's editing lol

[@Multimedia_Magic]

It was mentioned a few times, but as someone who subscribed to Runway on the unlimited plan for one month, it bears repeating. Runway will moderate (generation blocked) when you try to use text, and also randomly at other times when not using text. These are incorrect moderations that will force you to abandon whatever you just tried to use, it's never going to work. The amount of time I wasted on that made me unsubscribe. It was much worse than just inconvenient, they have a real problem.

[@FilmSpook]

Agreed, I am 8 days so far using Runway's Unlimited Plan, paying monthly, and it clearly has a lot of issues. Gen-3 was RUSHED, and they false advertise their product, as it is very difficult or near impossible to get some of the results they showcase. They didn't even respond to my email, either. I'll probably be going with Kling by the end of this month or next month, unless Runway updates within the next several weeks.

[@HystericalHistoryTV]

Yeah I don’t think it will be very good until about 1 years time! It shouldn’t be paid at this point

[@deneex]

Looks like they fixed it, now i got flagged only when I accidentally added a close to nsfw image to video where character’s top part was too opened but not visible

[@ababbitt]

Amazing work and thank you!!!

[@manuelahofer6207]

Thank you. Yes, Kling and Runway seem to be among the best options so far imo.

[@phoenixhk0377]

Superb comparison Thanks

[@DarkWebMarkets4Life]

There's nothing out there that does longer than 10 second videos? I want to make music videos of 3-5 minutes. Any suggestions? Stitching loads together?

[@vidaveo8666]

Thanks, this was super useful. I'm working on a short sci-fi film, which is mainly live action, and I have some VFX done traditionally, but AI is enabling me to add shots which are way beyond my budget. Just a little frustrating about how little 'specific' control I'm getting over the final outputs and how inconsistent the outputs are, even using the same prompts. I'm using Kling and I've noticed that when I shift to Professional mode it's chance of poor image to video renderings increases enormously. But persevering (and watching the credit card payments mount up). Thanks for this review in particular, I was considering switching to Runway, but you've convinced me to stay the course with Kling (for now). Cheers!

[@Killmonger234]

Try Leonardo AI it have an additional feature of image reference so if you generate one image which can generate near consistent images thus somewhat desirable outcome came be achieved

[@vasuthevanpalani7033]

Thank you for your informative tutorial. I would greatly appreciate it if you could provide a detailed guide on creating 3-minute videos using Klingai.!

[@behdistaghavi6621]

Thanks a lot.Your content is the best.

[@halitsanr4439]

Thank you for your efforts !!!

[@CoinOpTV]

7:14 i believe those are supposed to be Lions dancing and not ‘Dragons’

[@lucanaddeo896]

Amazing video. So helpful!

[@JuanDuqueJuanimador]

Thank you for posting this video

[@williamwherewhatwho6177]

To give another perspective on it. I've been using Lumalabs for a while and just got on Kling as well after watching this. Both have their pro's and cons but in Lumalabs defence I must say that you get a lot of videos for the money! In my case I need to generate some 60-150 videos for every project. Lumalabs is lightning fast compared to Kling. You get videos out in like 10 seconds, while Kling currently takes between 6-30 minutes depending on which model I choose and also on the standard plan I only get like 20 videos (35 credits each) which forces me to go up a tier or wait until credits refresh. That is a blocker for me as I need to iterate faster than that. Kling can create super realistic videos, but Luma does the job well for CGI looking videos. Luma is not as good on animating characters, I often get distorted or unnatural animations, even on simple things like animating a character to walk or do any interaction at all. Kling is clearly better there. Both support blood and gore which I need for my projects while Runway blocked that in my free trial with them.

[@AIVerseStudios]

Love kling on top of that you got the draw motion where you can make static areas to avoid morphing etc. And to be honest Its Price friendly

[@pengouin]

excellent review, thank you for that!

[@siwakornie5239]

Kling is good to generate subject with dynamic movement. Runway3 good in camera movement control and special effect.

[@Avembe]

So is it possible to generate videos Runway (for camera, control,special effect) then finalize it on KLING?

[@siwakornie5239]

@@Avembe Not yet, Kling only has text-to-video and image-to-video

[@Avembe]

@@siwakornie5239 ok

[@benjamindeblanzy]

Amazing vidéo 🎉 Thanks a lot

[@arch0nC64]

I’m currently on Runway ML’s PRO plan, using the Gen-Alpha 3 model, and I’ve noticed they’re limiting generations every 5-15 minutes. For me, it usually takes at least 20+ generations to get something I’m happy with, since I’m constantly tweaking the prompts. This makes the process really frustrating, especially when trying to explore creative ideas!

[@mannymanny7787]

Great video! The next video includes Leonardo AI in the comparison.

[@CharlesRosendaal]

Great video! Thanks, that was very helpful

[@LoreCrowd]

We're doing a Vampire Hunter AI story, and found Runway censoring shots which Mid journey made as breaking their TOS, so may be too restrictive for some AI makers

[@artist_with_dharma137]

That is my favourite AI video ever and will never be beaten.. Bob Ross couldn't make a happy accident look so good

[@Escelce]

Great video and very helpful thank you

[@Skalu74]

Thanks, very helpful comparison

[@GloryHouseStudios]

amazing video thank you so mcuh

[@TheStoriesBook-ht4cl]

👍👍👍👍👍 awesome

[@iambot5435]

really helpful video. Thank you.

[@sheidamusic1300]

compare was Perfect . thank you very much🙂

[@matthewclarke5008]

Question: does Kling have unlimited like Runway? Also does Kling offer more extension than Runway? Runway I find it stops extending a video after 40 seconds. Excellent comparison!

[@froehlichwl]

There is no unlimited plan at Kling. You can get 800 standard quality 5 second videos in the Premier-package for 60$ a month at the moment. Also you could top up with additional credits.

[@matthewclarke5008]

@@froehlichwl Thankyou.

[@harshitbhatt3243]

​@@froehlichwl What about how much you can extend the video i.e. length of the video? Like the OP said it's 40 second in runway...what about Kling?

[@froehlichwl]

@@harshitbhatt3243 you can extend the videos up to 3 minutes. At the moment they have a very good promotion for first time subscribers.

[@TheBlessingReport]

thank you so much for this

[@mrcuic1]

Thank you Sir.

[@aliuzairlalani6192]

Thank you my man

[@HaohmaruHL]

Can't get Kling to generate anything. It gets stuck at 99% for each video forever.

[@RaidRawda]

And each time u hit try again it cost u more credits, which was not my fault at the first place

[@justme2024-n9p]

dont trust this content creators kling doesnt do what is asked for. you have to generate so many times..

[@aunjuttjutt7250]

Thanks for your time, you realy made it easy for me. Thanks ❤🎉

[@noNumber2Sherlock]

GREAT Video! Been a lurker- subscribed! BTW, my GF thinks your new hair style , longer down on top says you're fire.

[@LuisSanchez-hg6el]

Kling by a mudslide! Thanks, brother

[@LuisSanchez-hg6el]

Landslide*

[@High-Tech-Geek]

This is gold. Did you run 3 generations for each image to video? If so, you should post a blooper reel, hehe!

[@alfreddesign]

Thanks a lot. great work. for the Chinese new year part, only luma have a Long. all the others have a Lion head.

[@Ahmadkhdmy]

The best comparison on the net !

[@GigglingEnigma]

Got me feeling an idea that is AI FLOPS OF THE MONTH OR HECK WEEK LOL 😂😂😂😂 REAL EXCELLENT TUTORIAL AND A WHOLE LOTTA FUN AND LAUGHTER 👍👍

[@vijaykumar-m5p4s]

Kling vs. Runway Gen 3 vs. Luma Dream Machine vs. Pixverse Comparing Kling, Runway Gen 3, Luma Dream Machine, and Pixverse is fascinating! SmythOS adds significant value by providing a comprehensive platform that enhances the capabilities of these tools, making it easier to integrate and compare their features effectively. #TechComparison #SmythOS #AItools

[@FilmSpook]

😎You are Awesome, Man, I really appreciate you and your in-depth work!! Runway user here, but may go with Kling in a month or two, hehe, unless Runway fixes their prompting very soon for much better control and accuracy of human motions, which I am sure they will do before the end of this year. Cheers.

[@richardglady3009]

Thank you for all your research and putting this video together in a very coherent and informative way.

[@nowandrew4442]

Not sure if they added all thing things you complained about pixverse for, directly after your video, but currently (Dec 2024) pixverse does have: - extend mode - 10s option - no watermark + What I havent seen yet are camera controls. Which would be great because it's terrible at following prompts.... 🤷🏻‍♂️ However I'm at about a 90% failure rate of usable clips, and that's not even counting prompt adherence. It would be good to compare strike rate alongside cost/pic, because if only 1/10 clips are usable, that greatly affects the economics...

[@LisaMurphy]

If you were going to make an entire 2-hour dramatic movie set in 18th Century Italy, which AI generator tool would you use? I need an AI video generator that can keep my characters consistent in appearance from the beginning to the end. Price is no object.

[@iAmSeth]

“Life truly begins when you see death with your own eyes… have you experienced that moment of realization? What did it teach you?”

[@artist_with_dharma137]

Seeing the death of others? Or seeing the death of self? I've seen a few people dying, I've seen animals dying. I've seen my own death in a dream and woke up with really bad pains in the chest and hand after being shot twice by double barrel shotgun That moment actually happened many years after that dream. Except the gunman didn't shoot me The time I actually saw my whole life flash before my eyes, when two masked men jumped out of a car aiming a Colt revolver straight at my chest. What I learnt from that moment, is the one person who I called for, as I sunk to my knees, wasn't able to hear my words and wouldn't be able to help me! What effect that had on my life, is I never called for mum any time I faced the barrel of a gun in the future. I walked towards any gunman telling them to shoot me. When an assassin came to push a desert eagle to the back of my mouth threatening to blow my head off if I say another word, I grabbed her hands removing the gun from my mouth as I said another word. Looking straight into her eyes I calmly put the gun back in my mouth and mumbled "go on, do it!" And I'm the only person who lived to tell the tale I became fearless of death, having seen my own death. For 25 years after that night when 2 masked men aimed a gun at my chest I've put myself in some dangerous situations and I've lived every day to the fullest like that was the last day I would have

[@graphiknoirstudio8267]

Merci cette vidéo était vraiment magnifique et importante

[@theovelentzas7540]

Its all about prompt, I use the same prompt try it on different platforms and see what rocks, its not so of the quality image its how each generator understands each prompt differently

[@alexanderbreuer-roelke6311]

Love the cartwheel. 😀

[@Batmanwithcheese]

Super usefull video 😍😍😍

[@BrahmandaBytes]

great comparision

[@Ai-Art-42]

Very informative, well made video, very understandable

[@KhalilCh]

big thank you

[@oberdoofus]

lol i wish i'd seen this before trying to do my own research! Excellent video! Thank you!

[@fuelformind]

Amazing video ❤

[@DashcamRush]

Kling is winner in creativity when it comes to images to video, does a great job.

[@MilesBellas]

Great ! Thanks! 😊

[@noNumber2Sherlock]

Hi. I went ahead after watching this and got a Kling annual subscription. Major remorse.I have tried at least 5 test to videos that were quite simple and all of them consisted of warbled faces or mouths . Is there a glitch or is it just bad? Simple prompt like "3 different aged people side by side in an elevator staring up with unhappy faces "

[@LuckyGirls77]

Generate an image first, using Kling or a free image generator like Perchance, then do image to video

Great video !!!

[@MariSpa]

Great vídeo, thanks!! Which one would you recommend for pets? Considering the golden retriever animation or have you done further tests? Still runway?