Karate and Weapon! Amazing similarity!【Naka Tatsuya】

[@kuroobiworld]

★Turn on closed captions with various languages!【Subtitles】English, Spanish, Italian, Portuguese, French, German, Vietnamese, Russian, Indonesian, Chinese, Korean, Hindi, Persian, Arabic, Polish, Thai,Turkish, Greek, Ukrainian, Malay, Swahili, Swedish, Hebrew. Please enjoy the video in your native language!

[@josuaabaricia2985]

Thanks master

[@samigarira7971]

thank you for subtitles into arabic .OSS

[@c602]

This is a good video. Most Shito-Ryu practitioners have long been aware of the relationship between karate and kobudo so its not new to them, however I appreciate Naka Sensei's open approach to discovery. It is an extreme rarity within the JKA. He would make a great future "chief instructor" of that organization.

[@hetarekickboxer]

平安四段の落とし受け、最早残像が見えそう 早すぎて何回観直したことか やっぱり中先生すごいなあ

[@user-bultria]

当たり前ですけど、相手を攻撃する時には素手より武器を使った方が有利なわけで、どんな武術でもまず武器術があって、それに付随する形で徒手での格闘術がある。日本は平和すぎるから武器術がどうしても廃れやすいのが悩ましいところです。

[@遊川恒星]

中先生は順調に「先祖返り」を起こしてますねwww どこまで「先祖返り」して、どこを「現代」にアレンジしていくか。中先生の歩みにはこれからも注目させていただきます！

[@dekotahrunninghorse9372]

The bo is one of my favorite weapons in martial arts. Thank you so very much for sharing this great video! Blessings,respect, and abundant prayers.🙏🙂

[@まっつー-x5s]

中先生は良く研究されてますね 夫婦手の技術はもともと棒術から来てますし、沖縄で糸洲安恒が継承させていった平安は、鉄槌部分が手首のスナップを使って打ってますからね

[@y.f8264]

沖縄相撲でも両手を使って投げたり極めたりするからこれも影響してると思う。

[@tuclen-itsmeanttobeangry4383]

Amazing, i know there many martial art come from weapon but never thought karate was also one of them.

[@karatesalamanzen]

Muchas gracias , Sensei Naka , así es, el entrenamiento del arma ayuda adquirir fuerza manos y brazos

[@夢幻紀行]

元々武器を手にしていた身体操作から徒手に変化したのではないでしょうか。例えば剣を持った姿勢、つまり右足が前の姿勢から柔術、そして柔道に受け継がれて、槍または盾と刀などを持った左足が前の姿勢が空手の基礎的な構えに変化した。つまり始めに武器ありき、というのが空手や中国武術をやってきての自論です。

[@stefansandbergsweden]

Dear Kuro-obi, I would love more interviews like this one, talking about the similarities between karate and kobudo. Some great masters to interview would be Akamine Hiroshi (Ryukyu Kobudo Shimbukan, Okinawa), Hidemi Tamayose (Ryukyu Kobudo Tesshinkan, Okinawa), Yukio Kuniyoshi (Ryukyu Kobudo Hozon Shinko Kai, Okinawa), Masakazu Kinjo (Ryukyu Kobudo Hozonkai, Okinawa) or Kisho Inoue (Ryukyu Kobujutsu Hozon Shinko Kai, Japan). All these organizations and dojos were created to honor the legendary kobudo master Shinken Taira by some of his closest students.

[@bigsidable]

I been traing with weapons ever since Bruce Lee picked up two sticks in Enter The Dragon. First I used one stick like a nunchucks. Then two sticks. I do all my Katas with one or two sticks. Shotokan Katas. Since studying Aikido,I’ve incorporated the Jo, Sai, and Bokken in my Kata training. Really adds to your workout and deeper understanding of the Kata and weapon. Oss.

[@satheeshkumar6865]

Awesome 👍🏻 Thanks for sharing 🙏

[@saptarshimandal611]

私はインド人です。中達也先生のビデオはきれいです。中達也先生が好きです。

[@blockmasterscott]

I’ve seen Naka Sensei visiting so many other martial artists, I had forgotten just how fast he really is.

[@moises331]

Simplesmente genial! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 Excelente aula, obrigado professor por nos ensinar. 🙏

[@TehDanno1]

Incredible as always Sensei. 🙏

[@おぶおぶ-x4o]

早いのも凄いけど。。 所作がキレイなのよね

[@Didier33380]

A lot similarities with aïkido, with weapons and without! It's a really hight level

[@m.k3950]

少林寺流空手の型とか最初は無手で、上級者は武器使用になってますね。

[@yuosufalbalushi1705]

ماذا السرعة المذهلة 👍

[@sergebuscemi6200]

Merci pour la traduction en français ❤

[@rayankrystar3742]

thank you for your videos

[@francoismoreira1583]

Bonjour, merci 👍💪🏻👊🏻🙏🇫🇷

[@1ばかぶた]

Yeah, karate is a martial art where you can use defense and attack in one move Basically, martial art is a weapon without weapon. so if they learn to overcome their fear before using it, they can use it in a real situation without the hesitation. This practice has been lost in many other martial arts

[@letsbefranks2062]

Funny thing is I've had the same thoughts a few weeks ago - regarding the use of swords in comparison to fighting bare-handed. ^^

[@galihharisantoso6356]

空手のすごいですね 👊💪

[@laforestacristallinadimegr5372]

Thanks Master 🥋🇮🇹 Oss 👍

[@TurkSavunmaSanayiiNET]

Mükemmel video harika bilgiler çok teşekkür ederiz hocam

[@joari123]

Very interesting, Thx! 👍

[@danielcontreras3218]

Hola ARGENTINA👍👊🙌 🙌

[@hoangly6325]

Kĩ thuật đáng kinh ngạc

[@antoniorocca2278]

Passe évident de trouver le bon compromis dans les couleurs mais le résultat est bien 👍😍

[@k4x4map46]

very nice!!

[@leowhite9873]

Amazing technique the opponents have, I must say. They have truly mastered the art of letting themselves get annihilated.

[@chelovecheskoye_ditya]

Мне пришлось замедлить видео в 2 раза, чтобы лучше рассмотреть ваши движения

[@sendtextmessageto]

thank you for teaching me

[@MrClaudionor86]

Muito boas as técnicas usadas por Naka sensei. Oss!

[@rezajamshidi5139]

Bravooo👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@froilang.s.7353]

Les armes són extensions del cos , lleves les armes i queda el cos que es una altra arma. Estudia armes es estudia el cos, un pensament exelent. Excelencia , un camí a la perfecció, vostè és un mestre excelent. Un gran Mestre.

[@carlosthtorres4190]

I presio ante de masiada práctica y sabiduría me gustaría ser su alumno

[@calisthenicsgp5929]

Primero! Oss🥋

[@samigarira7971]

OSS. hello from algeria

[@placidomoreiraleite4515]

Excelente,

[@taherabadi.m8130]

استاد بزرگوار ما سنسی ناکا در قلب ما هستی .

[@taherabadi.m8130]

shalom سپاسگذارم سنسی

[@vera.oravova]

Naka-sensei is incredible. He is more quick as a quillotine. :-D I like his movies and his real training. He has to have karate in his DNA, his blood and his soul. I would like to have him as my sensei. But I am implanted with a defibrillator, so I am not allowed to learn karate. Who is/was his sensei?

[@sajanharshasimhan9485]

Oss. Sensei🙏🙏🙏

[@gregbignose3631]

Охуительно. Очень хорошая техника

[@EuphoExige]

アニメの原画と原画の間を自然な動きでつなぐ、中割作業のようだと思ってしまった。 何かオタクな感想でスミマセン。

[@tongbei]

👍👍👍

[@felipecorrieri6714]

Muito bom

[@rudymaier6730]

👏👏👏

[@ぽるこ-i6b]

棍術を鍛練してるから 空手でそれを活かす様に 体が動くのか？ 空手を鍛練して その動きが棍術に反映されているのか？ 同じ武道として無駄を省いて いくと似た動きに 似た思考と術理になるのか？ 不思議ですね。

[@arnie1005]

I thought that the Bo I (call pole} is part of the training.

[@masy8525]

やはりどの武術も理合は武器術からなのかな

[@庄司知志-f7u]

今回のお話はなるほどの部分とう〜んの部分が両方ありますね。 う〜んとなる部分は、自分がそのレベルに追いついていないからだと思います。 中先生の説明はわかりやすくていいのですが初めてわからない部分に当たりました。 空手は空手、武器術(琉球古武術)は武器術ではなく、空手＝武器術なんですね。 しかも中先生の研究の成果は、シーンの中で西監督をおしゃっていましたが、 まさに考古学者ですね。こうだったんじゃないか？とかなんで？とか疑問を持ちつつ 自分の研究の答えに辿り着くのは、古文書を研究する歴史学者と同じです。 この動画を見るとますます空手って単にスポーツだけでは終わらない本来の空手を 知ることができる武道なんだろうし、正しいかは誰も教えてくれないけど、 浪漫ではありますね。

[@NewjusDaddy]

karate = katana

[@John-ob7dh]

you can't go round the streets carrying any sort of weapons. Only thing worth carrying that won't attract attention is a short Yawara stick ,that fits in a closed fist .Personally after long time makiwara practise ,I rely on a powerful straight chudan punch .There were not many guys at my dojo could block a straight punch from me.