Lady Gaga vs P!nk: Same Song Battle

Two top-notch vocalists and their take on the same songs. Whose renditions do you prefer? List of songs included:
Bennie & the Jets - Elton John
What's Up - 4 Non Blondes
Imagine - John Lennon
Somewhere Over the Rainbow - The Wizard of Oz

[@janesinead8068]

P!nk´s voice and emotions are everything. Gaga is good but P!nk is really her own incredible category..

[@Cal90208]

I agree! She’s also a bit more raw than Gaga. As in shes less the typical Hollywood person

[@courageously_CC]

Agreed. P!nk is queen!

[@JiafeiProducts6969]

Gaga is better for me, maybe not in this video but in her other songs she smashes pink

[@MouhamadouAlphaDiallo-c3e]

​@@JiafeiProducts6969C'est pas vrai.Arreter de chercher des excuses.

[@TS-zj2fh]

Pink is the best

[@Cal90208]

“Best” is opinionated. I do prefer P!NK tho

[@piamarie1619]

Love them both but pink just hits different ❤️

[@fatimasolisalfaro4279]

P!nk💖❤️💖

[@arigoodfriend1762]

I really love both of them but I think pinks voice is just a little clearer

[@РустамКуртин]

Pink💕 100%✌✌✌💯

[@EduardoGarcia-qe8st]

P!nk’s Voice is Better ❤️

[@abelkhan3843]

Bennie & the Jets: Pink sounds beautiful but I prefer Gaga's rockier approach. What's Up: Um, Pink, by a lot. Imagine: Both sound immaculate. Gotta give it to Pink for the emotion. Somewhere Over the Rainbow: Both great but again, Pink's version is more emotive. I love these videos, keep 'em coming!

[@justlikeapill5707]

Glad you enjoyed it, I love your analysis!

[@AlexKamillaKroy]

Both ladies are great vocalists!

[@raffaelakaysa6120]

P!nk 100%💖

[@gregbrown8246]

Hands down pink has a better voice it’s more natural and softer love both of them but I would give it to pink

[@popsingerstar]

ditto

[@kostaskilkis4659]

pink is awesomeee,love her

[@roberttding2179]

Lady Gaga is the most incredible

[@Cal90208]

Have you heard Whitney? And can Gaga sing the same way when flying?

[@AmadeoAVP]

Pink🥰

[@zulmiriam]

They are both incredible. They are magical voices. They are unique artists. Comparing them is an insult. They both touch your soul with their voices. I'm gaga fan but pink is soo especial soo unique love her so much 😍😍

[@justlikeapill5707]

Me too! Both exquisite voices.

[@eduardochavacano]

The video really shredded Gaga. I like Gaga over Pink. But this video slap Gaga with a baseball bat.

[@Cal90208]

@@eduardochavacano How so?

[@NoNameUwUxX]

P!nk of course but Gaga it's cool too

[@jeansnow1116]

They are both of them incredible singers !

[@justlikeapill5707]

Strongly agree!

[@marianoandres5635]

P!nk 10/10 Gaga 9.9/10

[@zoemaury9859]

Lady gaga 100%❤️

[@crying_black]

noooo pink ❤️❤️❤️

[@Cal90208]

I Prefer P!NK. Gaga is awesome tho. I hate her what’s up performance tho...

[@jamiethackerr]

lady gaga for sure.

[@stefankrstev8245]

Agree

[@pablocabrera2217]

Ambas son admirables y cantan hermoso, cads una con su estilo, pero la forma de interpretar de Pink estremece mas, llegá mas directo a la sensibilidad musical, no solo es técnica voval lo que debe imperar, sino saber narrar y transmitir una canción...❤❤

[@bcrbes]

Pink outdid

[@ajf2005]

Both are incredible but by a technical standpoint Lady Gaga is a A+ and Pink is a A. Gaga is the better vocalist by a margin by I prefer Pinks raw emotion and tone.

[@anonygrazer3234]

P!nk is the BEST 100%

[@valogden]

I have to say how much I admire Gaga. How she was with Liza Minnelli at the Oscar's and the loving way she is with Tony Bennett is beautiful. She has a beautiful voice. Pink's voice in my opinion is stronger especially during Somewhere Over the Rainbow.

[@eastsidenicole]

P!nk is stronger on these ballads and so soulfully textured. Her voice is emaculate. Lady Gaga is amazing too.

[@rayzaaffonso3810]

Eu amo as duas sou muito fã delas sonho muito em conhecer elas pessoalmente

[@Littlebatlittlebat]

I don’t think one wins over the other. They have different voices and emotions behind their voices. But they are both amazing! I love them both.

[@Odara708]

They are both amazing!!! ❤️

[@diannahannah4194]

I go back and forth. I LOVE them both!

[@K2LUX]

Bennie & the Jets: Gaga What's Up: both amazing but a little more for P!nk Imagine: P!nk (Gaga's 2009 performance so much better than Baku) Somewhere Over the Rainbow: Gaga more emotional on this

[@erisederom1104]

I think it's better if you used the last verse and chorus during Imagine. I'm waiting for Gaga's climax part during Imagine. During the beginning she's singing in chill and have her emotions out during the last verse and chorus

[@erisederom1104]

Both artist are great tho 🙌

[@kozmikoblivion]

Pink sings the songs because she loves them, GaGa is just so damn theatrical (not a bad thing, just a thing).

[@halliecolville8723]

Pink all day. Authentic…. Doesn’t need theatrics… just her

[@eleeveeayees3425]

Well she does some crazy acrobatics.

[@hellobesties8241]

Gaga is outstanding vocalist, but if we compare her to pink, no, pink wins ❤️❤️❤️

[@iamfragr4676]

They’re both my idol I don’t want to choose cause they’re both the goddess of music industry

[@DannyDownUnder1992]

i love lady gaga and pink.

[@britneyspears8138]

Gaga is better ❣️❣️❣️

[@volcrazy89]

Two of my faves

[@janelleellsworth6670]

P!nk 😊❤

[@risqiarifullah1296]

pink amazing rasp rock voice

[@taint1801]

They should collab

[@anonygrazer3234]

True

[@Veronica-e2z9d]

Lady Gaga>>>>>>

[@midnightpanda10]

Gaga is great but damn I really love Pink eversince and the quality of her voice

[@diannahannah4194]

Something I never noticed before is Gaga changes her voice a lot where Pink is consistent.

[@cat625able1]

I'm a fan of both BUT Lady Gaga did it the best.

[@grissvalladares6676]

Definitivamente PINK 👌

[@danieladelafuent6581]

Lady Gaga Is better than another singer un the story

[@Cal90208]

You are very close minded then. Listen to Whitney, then come back.

[@jakegrear]

Bennie & the Jets: Definitely Gaga What's Up: both amazing but probably P!nk Imagine: both fantastic but Gaga Somewhere Over the Rainbow: I would give the edge to Gaga because she's just such a fantastic storyteller when she sings

[@Cal90208]

P!NK DEFINITELY tells a story when she sings

[@jakegrear]

@@Cal90208 they both do but during that particular song, Gaga was a better storyteller

[@Cal90208]

@@jakegrear I can respect that

[@patriciapappas4087]

They are both great in their own right and should not even be compared !

[@zoeylookey698]

Theres really no comparison they’re 2 very different vocal octaves. They both sound great.

[@eurositi]

1:44, 2:47, 2:55, 3:01, 3:42, 3:46. 3:57, 4:00 - Gaga has the passion, but she completely lacks the vocal power to carry these parts. Although there are far better live recordings of Pink where she sings more parts than this, just compare it with the range you hear at 4:29 ... It's actually not fair, because Gaga is a real artist. Pink is more of a 'craftsman' in comparison. Her voice isn't suited for everything (her Gnarls Barkley 'Crazy' cover was a mistake), but it's outstanding for a lot of classic rock and blues rock songs. Pink was born with some extraordinary pipes. She's not unique (think about Beth Hart, Janis Joplin or some of the many great country and soul singers). You will also notice they barely have any nasal sound like most of us 'normal' singers do. You can train your own voice a lot, but you can't train to sing like they do, unless you happen to be born with the same features.

[@glynislumpkin7411]

Pink is the greatest.

[@rebekahmikaelson1394]

I saw the votes in the comment and Lady Gaga won

[@juancarlosponceperez2670]

PINK LO MEJOR

[@Hannah-oi9yz]

Lady Gaga by miles

[@carladias2104]

Pink ALL THE WAY. Gaga has much more attitude and personality than actual voice.

[@agelnocortes9158]

Gaga Wins

[@MouhamadouAlphaDiallo-c3e]

Pink .

[@kukuhsantoso5190]

People choose pink because they hate gaga But Gaga absolutely better than pink

[@MouhamadouAlphaDiallo-c3e]

Chacun son avis

[@mschnaare]

Common Lady Gaga L

[@Michael-sm2pe]

Pink has always been a better singer. Lady Gaga is performing (overacting) and not singing nearly as good as Pink.

[@eduardochavacano]

Gaga’s Marry the Night and On the Edge of Glory was just Pink Attempts to sound like Jon Bon Jovi.Gaga just sounds so pretentious with rocker attempts... Pink was more Relax. Gaga’s cover of What’s Going On was Pure Demonic with its cringeness.

[@volcrazy89]

MTN and TEOG sound nothing like Pink songs and Bon Jovi is not an influence on Gaga. MTN is Whitney Houston-inspired and TEOG is more Bruce Springsteen. You sound like a bitter Madonna stan.

[@couchguy427]

I'm biased towards Pink. But shes been the best female vocalist too me since her career launched.

[@MouhamadouAlphaDiallo-c3e]

C'est absolument vrai.