Miley Cyrus vs P!nk: Same Song Battle

Two incredibly versatile vocal chameleons singing the same songs. List of songs included:
New York State of Mind - Billy Joel
Landslide - Fleetwood Mac
Babe I'm Gonna Leave You - Led Zeppelin
Jolene - Dolly Parton
Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds - The Beatles
Smells Like Teen Spirit - Nirvana
I don't own anything, all credit to owners and original uploaders. Special shoutout to ZoeAntonio, also known as Miley Cyrus Fans on KZbin; I used a lot of their videos.

[@Sunny-ip7um]

Both amazing, I'm certain Miley is a low key fan of Pink and influenced by her. Pink is certainly superior but that doesn't mean Miley isn't wonderful 😍

[@fraan4078]

Miley has a lower voice than Pink’s one, i’m sure about this, but Pink is so great in high notes, Miley lost em cause she had had some problems, her voice became lower and lower and then she had a vocal surgery cause she had tonsillitis, she forced it too much.

[@andre590]

@@fraan4078 wtf, ummm buddy Miley can still sing high. Watch this in minute 2.48 kzbin.info/www/bejne/sKDRZIqaibSEbdE

[@andre590]

In minute 2.48

[@fraan4078]

@@andre590 i follow her so i know everything about her voice, her lives etc.. the point is that before 2015 she had an higher vocal range but throughout the years it became lower, so that note she hit in that video you suggested of course it’s an high note (C#5 in the specific) but , for example in the bangerz tour she hit some notes like F5/F#5 and in 2013 a G#5 too. She had the reinke’s edema and it ruined her voice, but after her vocal chords surgery she turned out amazing but she still have a lower voice, her actual lower voice tone can’t be fixed, but honestly i prefer this 🥰 don’t worry, i’m a true fan

[@andre590]

@@fraan4078 good to hear from a true fan. Omg I feel like her voice is slowly starting to get back to maybe sounding like her dead petz era cause look how good and similar these two clips sound kzbin.info/www/bejne/gpOqdqdned57bsU kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHe4nJaHlpJ-e9k watch in minute 0.38 She sounds so good in the 2021 clip Their 8 years apart and yet they sound so similar

[@BAMOORE94]

P!nk is and will always be my Fave!!!

[@terri-2403]

Miley can sing, no doubt but P!nk has such emotion in her voice that it’s hard to compete.

[@EduardoGarcia-qe8st]

P!nk is SUPERIOR.... Miley CAN'T sing

[@angkhoi3320]

@@EduardoGarcia-qe8st are you dumb

[@den2268]

@@EduardoGarcia-qe8st dumb

[@EduardoGarcia-qe8st]

@@angkhoi3320 P!nk is a real singer and Miley is a product.

[@EduardoGarcia-qe8st]

@@den2268 Miley is like Britney Spears.

[@lindseycork7120]

Love both so much

[@bridgetnorris3025]

Omg I love both so much- love both in different ways

[@hmuakikhiangte5203]

I pick Miley cause she had a good idea how to mody song to her version.Miley always👍👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏

[@shonaboufford7342]

I'm so glad Miley has found her sound. She's reminds me of a cross between Janis Joplin and Anne Wilson. Pink omg Pink her voice is so rich and mature. Pinks entire being is awesome

[@minetopcuoglu266]

Its like two different kind of fabric. No one is better than the other .

[@den2268]

mileyy!!always i’m a smiler

[@Cal90208]

Is a smiler a Miley fan or smth? P!NK fans don’t have a name because it’s mostly adults lol

[@MouhamadouAlphaDiallo-c3e]

​@Cal90208 you are badass you😂.

[@tukanglike7538]

Of course Pink but they both are so talented

[@bibyleon]

Def no comparison…P!nk all the way. Love Miley too

[@Enoughalready20237]

You cant compare these two. They are so insanely talented - it’s impossible to pick. If I don’t see a duet with Pink and Miley before I die, I’m gonna be pissed. I’ll bitch about it on my death bed.

[@barbaraformentin]

omg I love both!!

[@raffaelakaysa6120]

Pink 💖

[@whitesun264]

I listened to Pink for 20 years, I am so glad I was the right age at the right time to enjoy her music. From 2015 I discovered Miley and quickly realised how amazing she was. I had been hoping for Pink and Miley to perform on stage together, unfortunately it never happened. So lucky to have been able to enjoy the music from this era, I feel sorry for people who's musical era is either 70's, 80's or 90's they lucked out! lol

[@TheEarthRealm]

_How_ did you discover Miley in 2015...? She was everywhere as Hannah Montana in the 2000s, and then later caused a huge uproar in 2013.

[@lisachristman1439]

pink rocks

[@sempak-klasikofficial9410]

Pink is the best

[@hollyleesmith953]

Pink by far!! Anyday

[@olivialaforme4714]

Well this is not even a fair battle, I mean miley is good but P!nk is WAY better, my opinion so don't come at me

[@EduardoGarcia-qe8st]

P!nk is a real singer and Miley is a product.

[@jacoblauver4598]

Miley is not a Product she’s a person who can sing just as good don’t get me wrong Pink’s voice is stronger I’ll admit that

[@anthonyforte6706]

Well that Jolene part was very bad for Miley. But I do think overall Miley’s choices of when to add higher sections to songs has made her more exciting to hear at times. Pinks voice is very clear and has very good control when she goes high but in these clips she didn’t stay high for as long as Miley. While Miley has some strain here and there her performances give you chills just because she always goes there.

[@josenovo8570]

P!nk is vocalist and her high notes are superior than Miley. Miley never use vibrato or falsetto. P!nk is in another league. This battle don’t exist because Miley is not a vocalist.

[@gabrielpacheco2214]

P!nk and Miley are the best singers womem actually!

[@metalwitch58]

Pink!!

[@Aesopartemis]

Miley wins

[@kevanofficial1935]

Miley the best

[@sempak-klasikofficial9410]

Pink still better than milen cyrus

[@aristhelynranalan2161]

Pink only

[@aristhelynranalan2161]

smooth Pink cool to hear class..quality voice

[@adanilsoncapel]

Miley Cyrus

[@Cal90208]

I didn’t know Miley was this good of a vocalist. Wasting her potential by twerking on stage... This is why I prefer P!NK. Also I do prefer P!Nks voice.

[@eternal.warrior_2769]

Yeah for miley, That was back then she has had many eras now she is doing music with 80s pop rock elements I recommend listening to her perform, the backyard sessions it's a series of acoustic performances on her channel. She also performed a cover of say hello 2 heaven by temple of the dog as a tribute to Chris cornell. Also I love her cover of beth hart I'll take care of you, zombie by cranberries, and Bob dylan's you're gonna leave me lonesome when you go

[@andre590]

Miley twerking hip hop era was literally 7 years ago 💀😂but yeah I can see why Miley’s talent could’ve been overshadowed by some of the thing she’s did. Watch her sing can’t be tamed in Monterrey at her bangerz tour, that is incredible. kzbin.info/www/bejne/bHKtpmx9qqeeqqs

[@Cal90208]

@@andre590 Yeah, she is a great singer. Honestly, I agree with P!NK in this video. kzbin.info/www/bejne/hnSUcpmujtJsiNE

[@andre590]

@@Cal90208 yeah but Miley’s changed now. She’s more mature. Obvious to her age but yeah I’m very pleased with where she’s at now 🥰

[@jbwvhw6303]

oh

[@gl4270]

Miley

[@jerryboucher8557]

Miley is superior by far.

[@fraan4078]

there were better clips of Miley :/

[@jbwvhw6303]

pink

[@TheEarthRealm]

Hmm, somebody's copying somebody. 🤔

[@andre590]

MILEYS VOICE IS MUCH MORE VERSATILE AND STRONGER THAN MILEYS !!!!!

[@janusnightshade9848]

??? Ah, you might want to read your comment over and save other's from a massive stroke.

[@andre590]

@@janusnightshade9848 Both voices are incredible but Miley’s is more versatile and can rock out more cause of her raspy tone. But she can also go high asf like in her heart of glass cover.

[@janusnightshade9848]

@@andre590 True. Although you said Mileys voice is stronger is and more versitile than her own voice. No hate or aggression but please read over your comment.

[@andre590]

@@janusnightshade9848 oh lmfao I ain’t even seee thank you 😂🙏🏼

[@janusnightshade9848]

No problem mate.

[@jbwvhw6303]

familia

[@eduardosanmiguelsalas2086]

Pink has more control miley is dynamic but if you forget somthing pink can fly!!!!!! And sing with no problem

[@jbwvhw6303]

Miley

[@adanilsoncapel]

Miley