Law of Duterte Land: Explaining Marcos’ P203-B estate tax debt

[@cynthiaestrada8318]

Ingles is smart, articulate deliberate. Very good.

[@judetuanzon]

Kulang naman explanation kasi di namn siya privy sa lahat ng anggulo ng issue...may tanong nga nga hindi niya alam ang sagot

[@afamilyworld3904]

Question 🙋‍♀️- after the final assessment na hnd nagfile or nagquestion ang Marcoses to that 23 B amt. hnd ba obligado na ibawas ng BIR sa total estate since sabi nyo pwede ilevy. 2. 23B estate tax na lahat pagaari ni Marcos Sr bakit nasa government pati bank accounts nakafreeze 3. Bakit pinagbebenta ng PCGG ang mga ariarian na kasama sa estate kht ang case on going pa.. 4. Speaking of alahas at gamit ni imelda..takenote si Ferdinand lng po ang namatay bakit pati gamit ni imelda,ng mga pagaari ng mga anak nya winasak nila at kinuha? Hnd nmn sila deceased🤦🏻‍♀️

[@ewan5830]

alam na, inilalabas nola yan kasi dehado sila sa eleksyon , hahahaha RAPPLER, RAPPLER, RAPLLER , ano ka na!!!sige pa dagdagan pa paninira, upak ng upak tulad ko napadaan sa channel nila natuklasan ko na talaga palang tanga sila.

[@mariocabradilla3608]

Tama ka.Bakit nga ba? In short pinagsamantalahan nila ang Marcoses at tinaydor ang mga pilipino.Kung hindi pinatalsik si Marcos asensado na ng husto ang pilipinas at hindi nagsipag-abroad ang mga pilipino na inalipusta sa dayuhang bansa.

[@aljohntongson4636]

Tsaka bakit mga marcoses pa ang magbabayad ng estate tax eh ung ibang mga alahas na kinuha ng government eh nakita ng maraming Pilipino na suot suot ni Kris Aquino,kaya sila nagkakasakit ng malala dahil sa kasinungalingan nila at paninira sa tunay na makabayan na si Apo Marcos

[@yolandacasas3493]

Exactly! Bakit pati pagaari nga ni FL ay pinakikialaman nila. Something is wrong there.

[@Dadbudz]

Ugh.. bakit wala pa tong sagot...

[@maven_grandprime]

pag bibigay linaw pra sa lahat , sequestered properties is no longer taxable. according to our law.

[@JustMe-of3yi]

That is also what I know, that how can they pay the estate tax if they do not have the property because its sequestered. Can you please help me where to find that govt article since you said its under the law. Because way back in 1995 we fight properties sequestered by PCGG. Thank you.

[@rosalindadedios8748]

We inherited properties from our parents and we my other 3 siblings paid estates taxes on the properties transferred to us respectively..

[@Dadbudz]

Tanong lang po nagbayad po kayo ng estate tax para mailipat sa inyo yung properties.. ngayon po nagkautang sila ng 23billion na estate tax ibig sabihin po ba pedeng ipalipat yung properties na hindi muna babayaran ang estate tax?

[@binondolorenzofam6261]

@@Dadbudz Hindi pwede malipat.

[@rolandoe.c8480]

Mgkaiba kau case ng marcos,sila kc d sila intresado manahin ung dpt mnahin nla so hndi nila bnayaran ung tax..so ksalanan ng gbyrno yn kc my option sila na ibenta nlng nla dpt ung assets..wla ng paki ung mga marcos dun kht ubosin nla ibenta un

[@kristinejoyamazona5457]

ANG AMAZING NAMAN MAG EXPLAIN NI ATTY. MICKEY 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

[@marclester3810]

Lian Buan impressed me on this interview. Definitely you studied this issue very well.

[@summerspice6754]

But she sounded less courteous az she cud possibly be... Im particular the way a host handles a conversation esp for people who worked hard to gain their title for it to just be disregarded eg. Doctors, lawyers, teachers, engineers and so on

[@marclester3810]

@@summerspice6754 well shes just trying to have a conversation. Its shouldn't be as formal as it should be, i would have to agree if she is interviewing a public official

[@theresalozano1399]

Thank you so much for your continued fight for the truth and accountability. So proud... "A lie doesn't become truth, wrong doesn't become right and evil doesn't become good just because it's accepted by a majority." Booker T. Washington

[@zenobiegregori2072]

VERY CLEÀR THAT ESTATE TAX IS PAYABLE IN ORDER TO TRANSFER OWNERSHIP OF A DEAD PERSON'S PROPERTY TO HIS HEIRS, THEN IF THAT PROPERTY WAS SEQUESTERED BY THE GOVERNMENT, IT SHOULD NOT BE TRANSFERED TO THE HEIRS ANYMORE. HENCE, WHY SHOULD THE HEIRS BE REQUIRED TO PAY ESTATE TAX ON SEQUESTERED PROPERTIES?????

[@mabedalen3269]

CORRECT!

[@michaeldalde997]

👍 So true and even so the marcoses are ousted from the country and their assets are frozen by presidential decree..further more with the 203B estate tax if this is really not a propaganda why did any of these yellows/pink or Isko use it to DQ BBM? Maybe somebody smart knows the answer.

[@Unknown-ut3pv]

Absolutely! Ikaw na nga ang tinanggalan ng karapatan,

[@usogsaile9721]

Yon nga sabi ni attorney hindi nila (Marcoses) kwenestyon ang BIR assessment ng kanilang estate tax in 1997. They have the right to do it but they preferred to ignore the BIR assessment. Kaya naging final yong decision ng Supreme Court for them to pay P23 billion.

[@pocox316]

Tama..!!!

[@gelderrovero6787]

BASTA RAPPLER MAHIRAP PANIWALAAN YAN.

[@daveszandueta]

Hindi kailangan paniwalaan si Rappler. Samantala, meron bang mali o hindi totoo sa video nito? Makakatulong kung ituro't ipaliwanag anong mali dyan babasakali.

[@redfox4425]

AS PER LAW DEAN MEL , in TED FAILON PROGRAM , ANG MGA MARCOS AY DAPAT MAGBAYAD NG ESTATE TAX . IYAN AY FINAL AND EXECUTORY NA SINCE year 1997. NAIBIGAY SA MGA MARCOS ANG TOTAL DUE PROCESSES WHEN THEY SERVED IT TO THEN CONGRESWOMAN IMELDA OFFICE . THE MARCOSES LAWYERS EVEN GO TO SUPREME COURT FOR CLARIFICATION BUT ON YEARS 1999 THEY DOWN THEIR VERDICT. IT IS FINAL AND EXECUTORY ALREADY. . LAWYER OF MARCOS . ATTY. RODRIGUEZ SHOULD BE INCARCENATED FOR IGNORANCE OF THE LAW AND CARRYING DEADLY FACE.

[@yengsabio5315]

"CARRYING DEADLY FACE." Grabe naman po kayo sa ad hominem ninyo! Pero natawa ako, ha! 😂

[@caseyryback2421]

Hahahha ang final and executory po na desisyon SC is regarding the appeal of macos jr to stop d levy on d acquired properties, dun sila talo...

[@richardbiteng6915]

Final and exectory 1997 pa so bakit hindi kinolekta ni noynoy aquino noong 2010-2016 na preseidente siya. Aggreibo pa naan si kim henares sa ng pagkolekta ng taxes, Paliwanag dito kung hindi nagbayad na estate tax ay hindi mailipat ang mana. Hindi ba kinonpiska at nabenta na 1993 pa so paano pa mailipat (levy sa paliwanag dito) Paliwanag dito na pagna-auction "the proceeds can be used to pay for the tax" so saan nabulsa, este napunta, yung pinagbentahan at bakit hindi pa naikaltas sa estate tax due? P389-B ang assessed value ng BIR at P203-B ang tax kasamang penalty so may ibabalik pa sa mga Marcoses? Hindi ba may tax amnesty tayo na wala ng penalty sa estate tax hanggang taong 2023? So bakit P203-B ang sinisingil at hindi 23-B Kaninong bulsa na naman ito pupunta?

[@MrTboneski]

7:12 another way for BIR to collect the money....

[@richardbiteng6915]

@@MrTboneski The question is the eatate has been confiscated since 1993 for the purpose of selling them and applying the proceeds to the estate tax due. So why didn't the BIR collect it especially under noynoy's daang matuwid in 2010-2016?

[@villgem9112]

BIR should execute payment of the Estate Tax BUT why are they not enforcing the Supreme Court order ?

[@richardbiteng6915]

That is a good question but the best is there has been a supreme court decision since 1997. Noynoy aquino was president from 2010*-2021 and has an aggressive tax colection campaign with kim henares as commissioner. Why didn't he collect the estate tax? More puzzling is the fact that the marcoses are the aquino's mortal enemies. If we understand why then maybe we can understand why the taxes have not yet been paid ang maybe the Marcoses were right all along. There are still many unresolved issues that even a supreme court ruing could not enforce the collection. But it seems we are being lied to by the people who are using this issue to harass the marcoses and not to collect the taxes.

[@daveszandueta]

@@richardbiteng6915 I notice you mention PNoy in some of your comments as if his admin should've been the one (if not the only one) that should've collected the estate tax. If his admin failed in that endeavor, then it failed and that's it pancit. Nothing and no amount of questioning or even criticism will change what happened. Besides, shouldn't previous admins since 1997 or even THIS admin collect that tax anyway?

[@mariareyestactacan5682]

People of the Philippines should know and open their eyes and mind to choose the the candidate to lead us. Please LORD help us.

[@genesislawan8983]

I like how he answered those biased questions fairly.

[@ellengavadan9473]

Real Estate Tax is different from Estate Tax. The Real Estate tax is a tax paid every year for the real estate property an individual owns which is to be paid to the Municipal Treasurer or City Treasurer. The Estate Tax is the Tax that an individual has to pay to transfer the Title or Ownership to him or the heirs of the deceased.

[@richardbiteng6915]

Yes, Real estate tax is a tax obligation Estate tax or inheritance tax gives the heir the right, and not the obligation, to transfer title to his or her name.

[@jericotevar8079]

d pa matatransfer buhay p c imelda

[@agnessebastian6160]

@@jericotevar8079 Sir, khit po buhay pa si Imelda. Siya po at mga anak nya (Imee, Irene, Bongbong) ang heirs. Sa knila po ita-transfer ang estates ng yumaong Marcos,Sr. Kaya nga po in-assessed yung estate tax 23billion. Nung 1997 documented na po sa Supreme Court, final & executory na po.. Dinadasal ko po na naunawaan nyo po.. 🙏🙏🙏

[@raishaemz746]

@@agnessebastian6160 mam e2 po ba yung kay frrdinand senior?

[@romansenior]

Exactly po. Kaya nga po nagbabayad ng estate tax ang (mga) tagapagmana ay para maisalin sa pangalan nila ang mga naiwang ariarian. Subalit sa kaso po ng mga Marcos, na sequester na ng PCGG ang ipagbabayad ng estate tax. So ano pa po ang mamanahin ng mga naulila? Ano po ang rason na magbayad pa ang mga naulila ng estate tax, di na po yata makatarungan.... double jeopardy na po!

[@marga7472]

Sana watch ito lahat ng bulag sa katotohanan.

[@momotaroreincarnatednthtim6303]

It's no use sasabihin nila BIASED din yung tax expert.

[@noelpiggangay9997]

Maraming bulag at bingi.

[@rodolfoop9421]

Exactly you need to open your eyes and read Cory’s Executive order #1. Kung nag nakaw nang pera si Marcos sr sa Philippines money and then He die’s BBM should pay Estate tax before HE can inherit the money his father stole from the Filipinos.

[@judetuanzon]

Kulang pa din ang explanation

[@momotaroreincarnatednthtim6303]

@@judetuanzon Sige explain mo dito word for word hindi kathang isip dapat may sources ka ah. Ano pala credentials mo?

[@yolznets]

Simply lang how they arrived of that amount while other property under PCGG sequestered it must identify first. Show the property under collectibles of estate tax. Thanks.

[@edwardemmanuelg.libunao186]

Very helpful video. Hope more people, voters especially, get to see it. Thanks.

[@totisandoval7849]

Ito kasi ang conflict eh. okay malinaw ang pagkaka explain na yong estate is taxable whether it is llegaly or illegally gotten pero dahil yong estate is already sequestered it is already owned by government. So bakit mo babayaran ng tax yong estate na hindi mo na pag aari. Nawala na nga yong assets mo tapos magbabayad ka pa ng tax? its like saying "o ayan ha, nasequester ko na ang pag aari mo, hindi na iyo ito pero babayaran mo pa rin ang tax nito ha?" Nawalan ka na nga ng property tapos magbabayad ka pa, susmiyo, anong klaseng hustisya iyan.

[@Sol-ek7zn]

oo nga.tama ka

[@karlozaveron3753]

Neutral question: According to GR No. 120880, some real properties have been levied and auctioned for sale but since there was no bidder, the lands were forfeited in favor of the govt. Would that affect the amount of estate tax debt they owed?

[@maydeto2191]

he already answered your question.

[@karlozaveron3753]

@@maydeto2191 not quite. what if the value of the property levied is not equivalent to the tax? hence my question. the principal estate tax debt assessment of the marcoses was 23B in 1991. then 11 parcels of land were levied in 1993. 23B pa din ba ung debt?

[@ronaldlight593]

@@karlozaveron3753 the P203 billion tax obligation is net of those forfeited properties.

[@karlozaveron3753]

@@ronaldlight593 is that so? im just wondering because the properties were not forfeited until 1993. the 23B net estate tax was finalized in 1991

[@uniteamtv3.09]

@@ronaldlight593 naging 203 B LNG po ung dahil s penalty. Original NASA 23B po. Nakapag levying n po ang government Ng properties dati.

[@ellengillego6221]

Sequestered properties are govt properties. The ones not sequestered are for estate tax whether ill gotten or not.

[@nestoranulacion6854]

So dapat na ibawas ang mga sequestered properties Di ang gobyerno na ang dapat singilin sa estate tax .nasa kanila na eh .pls expand your brain.

[@Delta-1X-Ray]

@@nestoranulacion6854 Kahit magbenta ng properties ang gobyerno dun sa mga sequestered properties. Paano mo masasabi na aabot iyon sa 203 billion pesos?

[@judetuanzon]

@@Delta-1X-Ray compounded siguro ang interest at sana i discuss din kung anong mga properties ang involve dito.

[@Delta-1X-Ray]

@@judetuanzon Yun nga eh! Dinig ko nga. Meron pa silang mga properties sa ibang bansa.

[@judetuanzon]

@@Delta-1X-Ray may document ka ba dyan na nagpapakita ng mga properties ng mga marcos na ginamit noong 1990s para singilin sila ng 23B?

[@samueldeasis3903]

The case of Marcos Estate is a very novel case (first case of this nature) because the properties are in the possession and custody of the PCGG and the worth is still undeterminable. It cannot be transferred to the beneficiaries which would be the justification for assessment of Estate tax. So, everybody is guessing what to do. Can you blame the Estate?

[@j.madelozo8222]

PCGG shouldn't have existed in the first place tbh. The BIR could've handled everything from the start.

[@eli392513]

Estate Tax according to the Bureau of Internal Revenue Estate Tax is a tax on the right of the deceased person to transmit his/her estate to his/her lawful heirs and beneficiaries at the time of death and on certain transfers, which are made by law as equivalent to testamentary disposition. It is not a tax on property. It is a tax imposed on "the privilege of transmitting property upon the death of the owner. " The Estate Tax is based on the laws in force at the time of death notwithstanding the postponement of the actual possession or enjoyment of the estate by the beneficiary.

[@richardbiteng6915]

That may be correct from the legal viewpoint but as a layman i didn't know the deceased have rights. Estate tax looks more like the right of the heirs and beneficiaries to receive an inheritance from an estate.

[@zenobiegregori2072]

pag nag pa transfer ka ng title sa PANGALAN MO OR NINYO. ng property ng patay , dapat mag bayad ka ng ESTATE TAX

[@richardbiteng6915]

tama. Sa kaso nin Marcs pati mga sequestered property na hindi naman mamamana nila isinaman sa estate ni Marocos Sr. Kasama na mga maling naisoli na sa tutoong may-ari dsahil sa maling pagsequewster

[@markmark9238]

@@zenobiegregori2072 But if you cannot pay it, the government will do something like sell the properties to satisfy the levy.

[@ronaldlight593]

@@richardbiteng6915 Mali ka. Walang sequestered properties at the time of the BIR assessment ang kasama sa pinatawan ng estate tax. FYI

[@eduardoespiel9868]

marami aq natutuhan sa sa usapan nyo atty. salamat po.

[@gopi7677]

You can only ask Marcoses to pay debt tax if you admitted that the sources of those tax are not from ill-gotten wealth. As long as you believed that those Marcoses wealth are stolen from the government treasury, then, what you need is to recover those wealth and not to ask Marcoses to pay tax debt from wealth that you believed not theirs.

[@j.madelozo8222]

True this, it's like a double edged sword for the anti-Marcoses.

[@valvillaluz2938]

Estate tax is not imposed on the heirs and it is not a liability of the heirs. You cannot file any personal case against BBM to collect the tax from him. You can levy properties of the estate and sell them and collect the taxes from the proceeds of the sale.

[@bornfree1888]

BBM is the estate administrator

[@RonaldoSantos-bh5si]

@@bornfree1888 ...Hahaha HINDI ka lang NAKAKAINTINDI ng mga TAXATIONS!

[@bornfree1888]

@@RonaldoSantos-bh5si what are you, a learner or a manipulator?

[@josephinemanaois6668]

Estate tax is a transfer tax and we have estate tax amnesty until June 2023.

[@HarryEstrellaEduPh]

.🇵🇭

[@bitoylabas4077]

Sa aking trabaho na paggawa ng estate tax returns sa isang law firm, paghindi kayang magbayad ng estate taxes ang mga clients, pina-attach na lang nila sa BIR ang property para mapagbili at mabayaran ang estate taxes. Kung ang BIR ay may final and executory decision ng Supreme Court sa Marcos Estate, e di EXECUTION agad. Di kailangan ang demand letters- isang kalokohan. Hindi rin kailangan hintayin o pilitin magbayad si BBM. Iyong Marcos Estate ay maraming assets at ang dapat magbayad ng estate taxes, hindi ang mga heirs katulad ni BBM. Kung ayaw ng BIR ang Execution gawin agad, kamalian na nila iyon at hindi dapat hinahamak si BBM. Sabi nga ng Supreme Court, it is not a crime involving moral turpitude at walang prison term penalty ang non-filing ng estate tax returns, kasi may mga assets na napagbibili para maging cash. Tama lang di dumalo ng mga debate si BBM at dudumugin lang siya ng mga kandidato na walang alam sa taxes.

[@lovelyami6099]

Comelec po nagclaim na hindi moral turpitude yung non-payment hindi po supreme court. 😊 yung properties po ng mga Marcos may na-levy na pambayad pero it's still not enough. Sabi po ni Henares yung ibang properties eh nasa ibang bansa na so hindi naman nila pwede din basta i-levy. Nagsabi na din po yung former Supereme Court Justice na pwede na kasuhan ng BIR yung mga Marcos since dekada nang hindi nagbabayad, so abang nalang po tayo baka mag-file na ng criminal case ang BIR against Marcos. 😊

[@andressacdalan633]

Kung magenta and the proceeds of the sale is more than the estate due, where will they distribute such to the heirs since they already have the right to do so or what needs to be done?

[@nestoranulacion6854]

Ang tanong ko lang po e kabilang pa rin ba ang sequestered properties sa babayarang estate tax ng mga marçoses and why only now?

[@volantevolante4999]

Klaro psg explain mo po.. gusto ko sana e post sa fb wall dhil marami di tlg ma eexplsin sa Media yan... E post nyo po sana sa fbwall.. thanks

[@sharmaneaurora6332]

Same po sa explanation ng isang atty na napanuod ko. Ang question is bakit hindi inexecute kung final na yung decision.

[@imeldajaucian1401]

Before paying the estate tax , should one file the extrajudicial settlement first? Is there an amnesty to the estate tax since it is pandemic?

[@boyginto7288]

VP Leni Robredo ikaw ang pagasa ng bansa laban sa mapanirang pagpapakalat ng maling impormasyon at pagpapalaganap ng pagkawatak-watak ng mga Pilipino na sumisira sa mga magagandang katangian ng mga Pilipino. VP Leni kasama mo kami sa iyong laban!💖🇵🇭💖

[@rolandocustodio6995]

...but if the job of the BIR is to collect taxes and the job of the PCGG is to sequester properties, it doesn't mean that BIR will simply collect taxes outside the bounds of the law.

[@juntabz4455]

I think the estate tax is due upon transfer but in this case the transfer is not yet consumated since this properties were sequestered suspected to be ill gotten wealth. The properties are in possession of the government. So why marcos should pay it when there was no properties in their possession.

[@nestoranulacion6854]

Ha ha natumbok mo .in addition to that why the target is only BBM? Di ba dahil maliwanag na wala silangl laban.dati kc tinira nila ng trial by publicity.ngayon dumami na ang analyst,researchers ,CPA ,lawyers tax experts.lalong malabo ng makolekta ang 203 billion.salamat n lng kung makakuha pa ang mga kalaban ng mga marçoses.dapat itanong din sa mga PCCGG at ang.natitirang Cory Aquino's clan kung saan na nila dinala o ginamit ang kanilang nasequestered o nakulimbat

[@jimmyleal2820]

Di na kami bilib dyan, 😂😂😂😂😈😈😈😈😈😡😡😡😡😡😡we still believe on bbm, bbm, bbm

[@kalachuchi7060]

Sobrang galit..gustong manakit? Oy huminga ka..namumula ka na baka ja sumabog..hehe. #iskoforpresident #iskoparin #naISKO #switchtoisko #healingpresident #203billionestatetaxbayaran #203billiontaxhindifakenews # 203billionBIRpakisingil #Godfirst☝️

[@kirukuruzawa956]

Estate Tax is a tax on the right of the deceased person to transmit his/her estate to his/her lawful heirs and beneficiaries at the time of death and on certain transfers, which are made by law as equivalent to testamentary disposition. It is not a tax on property. It is a tax imposed on the privilege of transmitting property upon the death of the owner. The Estate Tax is based on the laws in force at the time of death notwithstanding the postponement of the actual possession or enjoyment of the estate by the beneficiary.

[@conradocalma1729]

If the Morcoses did not pay the estate tax the govt can forfiture the property of the Marcoses.

[@shywarrior865]

D pa nga na determine ng BIR, ang mga tunay na pagaari ng marcoses, kaya tumatagal sa korte

[@Chrisrian-pr3gp]

can u please explain it? What is an estate tax? May utang ba sila? May tax bang di nabayaran?

[@ellengavadan9473]

The deadline of filing Estate Tax before TRAIN law was 6 months. In 2018 it was extended to 1yr after the death of the owner. The tax can also be paid in installment

[@cerizzabatario8972]

paano po nung sila (Marcoses) ay na-exile, ayaw sila pabalikin dito ni Cory Aquino, bakit po dine-demand pa rin yung notices ng death ni Ferdinand Marcos? And isa pa po, you keep on saying na walang kinalaman yung pag levy ng properties ng PCGG pero po yung same properties po and involved sa taxes na hinahanap na yan? Meron po ba kayong breakdown bakit naging ganyang kalaki yung amount?

[@timetraveler7233]

napapanahon po ito. many thanks to you rappler

[@titasantos9826]

it is perpetual liability so hindi sya pasok sa prescription period, sabi ni atty kim, it will be subjected to increment as long as you dont pay

[@jalilodelatorre9096]

If the PCGG successfully sequesters a stolen Marcos property, the property becomes the property of the government. Therefore, it cannot be used to pay the estate tax, which must be paid with money from the Marcoses, not with property already owned by the government as a result of sequestration.

[@lanymilallos1767]

alam mo ba kung aling property ang tina charge ng State Tax d naman cguro lahat ng property nila ay nakaw siyempre meron naman yan dating pag aari nila .

[@athanmendoza3934]

@@lanymilallos1767 the problem is kahit may pag aari na sila bago pa sya maging President hindi parin sasapat ang SALN nila doon. So lumalabas na inaamin ng gobyerno na sa mga marcos yung mga ari arian dahil sinisingil nila ng tax

[@Ariel-qc5xw]

Malabo yung explaination kasi bakit magbubuwis kapa yung kinuha na ng government ang property na sinasabing nakaw na yaman. Remember lahat ng taga SC na nagdecision noon ay mga tao na ng mga aquino. Kaya wala ka talagang laban

[@ru3493]

@@athanmendoza3934 sa marcos naman talaga ang ari-arian nila. ang kinukuha ng gobyerno e yung ill-gotten wealth nila. at kahit ill-gotten wealth, taxable pa din yun

[@hilarioilagan2919]

@@ru3493 sir sensya na pararang malabo po yata... kng illgotten po yan tungkulin lng po ng gobyerno na kumpiskahin... ibig sabihin hindi pagaari ng marcos... bakit kelangan singilin ang marcos sa tax na yun kng kumpiskado na?

[@villgem9112]

That's why I believe Bongbong called Martial Law as the Golden Era ? It is golden for them !

[@rubzlim968]

🤣🤣🤣 they made the Philippines their goose that lays the golden eggs.

[@vilmatamondong1675]

Dios ka alam na alam mo

[@user-ri6lc7lx9m]

Bakit mo alam present knb that time???kc the way sa salita mo parang alam mo

[@justine8090]

Bᴀᴋᴀ ɪᴋᴀᴡ ɴᴀ ᴀɴɢ sᴜsɪ sᴀ ʟᴀʜᴀᴛ ɴɢ ᴋᴀᴛᴀɴᴜɴɢᴀɴ ɴɢ ᴍᴀʀᴀᴍɪ...ᴍᴀɢ ᴡɪᴛɴᴇss ᴋᴀ ɴᴀ!!!

[@justine8090]

Bᴀᴋᴀ ɪᴋᴀᴡ ɴᴀ ᴀɴɢ sᴜsɪ sᴀ ʟᴀʜᴀᴛ ɴɢ ᴋᴀᴛᴀɴᴜɴɢᴀɴ ɴɢ ᴍᴀʀᴀᴍɪ...ᴍᴀɢ ᴡɪᴛɴᴇss ᴋᴀ ɴᴀ!!!

[@j.madelozo8222]

So are you saying that the BIR is demanding payment from the Marcoses for estate taxes including the properties sequestered by the PCGG? That doesn't even make sense.

[@gwapanglaagan7530]

Doesn't make sense and not fair

[@phoebemeriel867]

There is no need to discuss it's a SUPREME COURT DECISION nobody among us can question the court decision.

[@teodoralagumbay8971]

Very well said atty. Good job.

[@julanduclay4542]

Dapat magbayad sila para makatung sa mahihirap🙏🙏🙏

[@Angelazian368]

kaya ka mahirap umaasa sa hindi mo pera magtrabahu ka hahaha

[@泡沫-x6j]

tamaka

[@RonaldoSantos-bh5si]

Hahaha HINDI ka lang NAKAKAINTINDI ng mga TAXES!

[@daniloantonio833]

Mabuti nga Yan kaysa bahay sanglaan o bank na may tubo araw araw at may expiration date...liquidate na at pwd ng ibenta sa iba Ang property...

[@benjaminabsuelo5698]

according to former regional director of BIR REGION 6 DURING THE TIME of cory , may 11 properties na ibeninta para ibayad sa estate tax peru walang bumili kaya kinuha ng gobyerno as payment for the 23 billion and that 11 property in tacloban appraised value is 43 billion , so sabi ni director martinez , may utang pa ang gobyerno sa mga marcos .

[@doctororange534]

Eh ang Tax ng ABS-CBN na Trillion ba yon? Nabayaran na po ba? Kung nabayran na? San ginamit? MALAKI di ba ang Trillion kesa Billion? O binago na?

[@justathought8474]

Hypothetically speaking ... What will happen if the Marcoses don't want the properties, do they still need to pay the 203B estate tax?... 🤔

[@2ambrain519]

2

[@HarryEstrellaEduPh]

Yeah

[@rodeloclarit4022]

Problema n ng BIR Yun. Kunin n lang nila at ebenta. Mahirap naman pagbayarin mo Yung Tao s tax ng property n di naman mapupunta s kamay niya.

[@HarryEstrellaEduPh]

Gnito tlga campaign system natin

[@albertdelacruz9987]

Thanks attorney 👍

[@junlaguras886]

MARCOSARAH SOLID 45 SURE VOTERS PERIOD.

[@myrnavillafria239]

Thank you sir for your explainatiom regarding estate tax.

[@levinacristobal8264]

Pakisagot po tanong ko. Pag ikaw b pinamanahan pero wala naman sayo at wala s pangalan mo dahil kinuha ng iba(pcgg) dapat k b magbayad ng estate tax?

[@elmerlabiaga4911]

Tama talaga c yorme, Hindi Yan magsalita Ng wlang basihan. For xure f Marcos will win, thank you na talaga yang mga tax na Yan...

[@bonniebatnag2062]

How can I file my itr or estate tax if I am abroad and not allowed to go back to the Phils.?

[@gildelarosa8606]

Please explain as to why, they ended up owing 203B in estate taxes. You said estate tax is about 6% of the value of the property. So your basically saying that BBM has properties that was transferred to his name that’s worth more than trillions of peso’s? You said it yourselves that you only pay estate tax if the estate is being transferred to your name, correct??? Not a voter, just curious!!!

[@lovelyami6099]

It was initially 23Billion based on the supreme court ruling but since it was long outstanding it accumulated surcharges plus interest.

[@gildelarosa8606]

Ok, so 23b is only 6% of the total estate, so that makes BBM the wealthiest man in the Philippines. If not then these guys are full of it. Because as far as I’m concern, you do not have to pay estate taxes if you don’t claim or have the title transferred to your name.

[@lovelyami6099]

@@gildelarosa8606 if we'll base it off the $10billion that his father stole, 23Billion pesos sounds reasonable. 😊

[@judetuanzon]

@@lovelyami6099 nasa cronies naman ang bulk...tanungin natin ang mga Cojuangco, Tan at iba pang cronies. Dapat ibalik nila ang yaman nila from 1972-1986.

[@karkar8394]

@@lovelyami6099 i hope u can even show proof or any doc of saying that phil has $10B to be “stolen” by the Marcoses in the first place…

[@zalleigofuller1972]

Question lang Ms. Mara.. if i heard it right.. according to Atty. Ingles the property (s) left behind by a person who died the heirs need to pay the estate tax before ownership will be transfer to the heirs. Is it right to say because the marcoses did not pay the estate tax until now, all those properties are still not in their names?

[@richardbiteng6915]

yes, they cannot be transferred without paying the estate tax pero confiscated neither partial o lahat. It was auctioned off auction off in 1993. but there were no bidder. It is quite easy to surmise that the auction price and/or assessed value was set ridiculously high as the estate tax issue was not meant to be resolved easily and was instead meant to be used as a never ending or long lasting polkitical tool to harass the Marcoses upon their return from exile.

[@VeaBaby_and_AlbeMommy]

In essence daw po the estate tax is needed before ownership to the heirs can be done and I think it is safe to assume na some properties that needs registration like real properties/cars, etc are still not under the names of the wife or the children.

[@richardbiteng6915]

@@VeaBaby_and_AlbeMommy Most of the estate have been confiscated by the government and auctioned since1993 but no one was interested in the overassessed assets. Noynoy aquino did not collect the tax or sell the estate in his 2010-2016 presidency even as the supreme court ruled that BIR is the authority on tax matters and confirmed the BIR assessment if final and unappealable. Noynoy can have a supreme court chief justice impeached but he cannot collect taxess from his arch-enemy? It appears that the the assessment, which was rushed just before the Marcoses were allowed to return from exile, was neverr intended to collect the overassed taxces but to be used as a political weapon against the Marcoses as it is again being used now.

[@realitycheck00023]

Paano nga naman sila makakapag file at paano nila mako question ang sobrang mahal na asessment ng properties nila eh ayaw nga sila pauwiin. Sino ba naman ang mag bi bid pag sobra mahal.

[@richardbiteng6915]

​@@realitycheck00023 exactly... so the estate estate tax remains unresolved and avaiiable for use to attract the Marcoses. It was not included in any of the several DQ case because the truth will come out sa courts (comelec included). Tapos ngayon puro press release lang at wala naman nagsampa ng kaso. Para lang sa negative publicity against BBM

[@fred86670]

Solid BBM Sarah 2022.. landslide victory iyak twa n lng kayo..

[@marcelarejuso3326]

ATENEO Lawyer pa paulit_ulit na lang, how many times ba ssabihin ni BBM magbabayad sila kaya lang nasa Court pa di ba?

[@alongduenog1640]

magaling. maganda ang topic na ito.

[@onadmangulovenan7986]

HWAG IBOTO ANG MGA TAX EVADER

[@wellbeing968]

If you dont want any if the estate that was left by your parents, do you still need to pay the estate tax?

[@2ambrain519]

(2)

[@jbatayola9886]

6 percent lang ng total net worth ng ama nya na pinagmana sa kanya

[@cherub0nyx]

Yeah pwd i decline ung inheritance

[@sarahbell7065]

Very informative, thank you!

[@jonconnor0729]

Why would you lie? Please analyze the original PCGG reply letter, the 1997 Court of Appeals ruling, and the 1993 Tax Case resolution. 1.) Marcoses had a tax deficit based on BIR's audit in 1991. The Marcoses failed to file an appeal within 30 days. The Marcoses were still on the exile when the tax audit happened. 2.) BIR levied on 11 properties and sold them as resolution for the tax case. They sent Notices of Levy and Notices of Sale for the said properties 3.) Marcos Jr filed an appeal to annul the 1993 Notices of Levy and Notices of Sale to the Court of Appeals. In 1997, the Court of Appeals dismissed the appeal. The 1993 Tax Ruling that levied the Marcoses's 11 properties were judged final and executory. 4.) There is a verbal agreement between BIR (Commissioner Parayno) and PCGG (Chairman Yorac etc) to enforce assessment and collection of Marcoses estate tax but NOT INCLUDING properties that were recovered from Marcoses, properties under litigation and Swiss bank accounts under escrow. 5.) BIR admitted that they sent the Marcoses (FLM heirs, no specific names) a demand letter for tax liabilities. No exact figure of the tax liabilities given. 6.) The 203 Billion estate tax was fabricated by Former Judge Carpio by computing compounding penalties and interests from the 23Billion estate tax (which is already paid through levies in 1993). Carpio has neither the responsibility or the due authority to audit the Marcoses' alleged unpaid estate tax Read the details (These documents were also posted on Rappler): www.scribd.com/document/564973224/PCGG-BIR-Letters-Re-Marcos-Estate-Tax?fbclid=IwAR2k-oMgyJjYPaJAPmgDg9FNmogHP-7asF8dNRsZVdN3KCYqjIkDdS5hG_A#download&from_embed Also this: lawphil.net/judjuris/juri1997/jun1997/gr_120880_1997.html

[@chillang1925]

Thank you for this information ma'am. I hope everyone will read your comment. Is it ok to share this point of view of yours? God bless..

[@j.madelozo8222]

This is what I've been saying to my colleagues, but they're too stubborn to listen.

[@anitadeocampo8389]

This is so informative. Thank you.

[@renatojosef8921]

Thank you for the explanation Sïr. It would have been much better if (1) given the impressive credentials of the resource person, the questions were given in advance for more structured responses (so the lay listeners could easily follow), and with more elaboration. By so doing, too, the sentence crutch "right?" could have been minimized, if not totall avoided; (2) in the end, the clarification was made as to where in the process of this particular humongous issue for decades of years went wrong; (3) the good lawyer could have taken off his head cap and dressed up a in a more formal manner to add more impact to what he was saying. Please dont take my comments negatively. Perhaps, we could listen to him again in the near future. Very respectfully.

[@realitycheck00023]

He gave a clear explanation of the definition of estates tax and how it is different from other kinds of taxes. But in the specific case of the marcoses he failed to give a clear picture. This case has been going on for years and is a very high profile one. I was expecting an “expert” such as this gentleman who clearly is on the other side of the political fence, to already be well versed with the developments of the case. But I keep hearing “I’m not sure, I don’t know, and I haven’t done the math.

[@dannyb.almazan9916]

It's not important his attire, the most important is the substance of what is he's ssying, the clarity.

[@servandoconstantinodejesus3314]

@@realitycheck00023 EVASIVE for his own safety, security and well-being.

[@letreyes3638]

@@servandoconstantinodejesus3314 🤔

[@willieasto2113]

linawin lang po, who is liable to pay, hindi ba yong estate ang liable at hindi heirs or administrators. yong totoo lang base sa batas, EO 1 and 2 of cory aquino and pertinent provisions of NIRC.

[@markabance2006]

Bkit kasi mayron pa yang pcgg legal ba yan or hindi Bkit pa sila bumuo pcgg na mayron na nga BIR..

[@rolandocustodio6995]

Masyado ninyong pinasasama Ang mga Marcos, Sila na tahimik at mapagpakombaba; imposing amount and penalty that is impossible to beat. VOTE MARCOS -SARA BECAUSE BOTH HAVE THE CAPITAL AND CAPACITY TO INTEODUCE REFORMS, DEVELOP THIS NATION TO PROSPERITY NA MAY PAGKAKAISA AT WALANG PAGKABAHABAHAGI. LET US MARCH IN UNITY TO IMPROVE THIS NATION, HINDI NAGBABAHABAHAGI. VOTE BBM - SARA

[@isidralopez5101]

Kasi rappler, naghahanap talaga ang ibabato sa Marcos para mapasama. At yong alaga nila ang babango kono si lenlen. Pero dami rin kaso ni lenlen bakit hindi hinuhukay sa markos lang hinohokay.

[@richardpogidaw4105]

@@isidralopez5101 wag n si leni at lalong wag yang mgnanakaw n marcos dapat si ping n lng nang matuloy ung imbestigasyon s druglord n anak ni duterte.

[@isidralopez5101]

@@richardpogidaw4105 ikaw na lang bumoto kay ping lacson mo. Kahit ano pang hukayin nila tungkol kay marcos wala pa rin. Bakit pina delete yong. Inilagay nila sa guiness world book of records. Bakit sagutin mo eto.

[@richardpogidaw4105]

@@isidralopez5101 pilit mo pa rin ipinagtatanggol kahit alam sa buong mundo na nagnakaw sila. Guinness lng makakasagot nyan kung bakit nwala s record nila ung actual specifics ng pagnanakaw ni marcos pero meron at meron silang ninakaw. hindi b obvious?? hahhahha. maaaring kulang ung datos o sobra. at oo si ping lacson n lang. siya lang walang me kakayahan at karunungan at walang dumi.... kaysa namn s bbm mo n sobrang dumi.

[@richardpogidaw4105]

@@isidralopez5101 eto sagutin mo.. naniniwala k bn walang ninakaw ang dating diktador n F. Marcos?? at naniniwala k b n hanggang ngayon walang alam si BBM dito??

[@maven_grandprime]

ms lian. , much better to have a conversation with the bir. bec . they are the one who knows the issues point to point . regarding their demand letter. for us to know the basis of their assessment.

[@michaeldalde997]

If this estate tax is as explained with the amount of 203B can someone explain why was this issue not used to DQ BBM Jr. Thanks Atty for the explanation 👍

[@markmark9238]

No one filed a case against BBM po kasi, BIR has the rights to file a case. But I think that estate tax is not an utang. Estate tax is a tax when you're transfering the properties to the heirs. Therefore, if you cannot pay it, the government will take those properties and sell some of your properties to satisfy the levy. I don't know why BIR isn't doing anything about this. Ang tagal nang issue na 'to. More than 20yrs na ata

[@michaeldalde997]

@@markmark9238 True that's why I think these are propaganda against BBM considering the timing. Like you said more than 20 years ago and with 2 Aquino had become president so why just now? I just leave my comments as it is. In the hopes that someone can explain it.

[@RonaldoSantos-bh5si]

@@michaeldalde997 ...Exactly! Samut saring PROPAGANDA...

[@florentinonicolas5178]

Tanong nga po atty.. Maraming nag tatanong kasi wala pa nmn yong pinaman yong late Sr. Kay Jr. Tapos di pa nmn alm kung saan mga yong minana ni Jr...

[@rogercastro5554]

Yuun Ang unfair pag mahirap ka pag dika magbayad ng taxes imbaguhin lupa mo ,pero ayaann 203 billions Ang taxes ni BBM , hiindiii masingil Ng government, BAAKIIITT??? Anong silbi ng government Natiinn particular Ang BIR BAAKIIITT hiindiii nyoo imbarguhiinn Ang property tax ni BBM nayaann GRRR GRRR 😖😣😖😖😣😖😣😖😣😖😣😖😣😖😖.

[@eduardoapon3226]

Hindi mo pla naintindihan bro, estate tax yan.. Yong pagaari ni late pre marcos yan na kung mailipat sa mga naiwan nya ay magbbyad sila ng tax.. Kaso hindi pa nailipat dahil yong iba siniquestered ng gobyerno.. Kya nsa korte pa ang usapin at on going pa ang kaso.. Matagal n yan 97 pa lumalbas ngayon kc panahon ng kampanya..

[@nestoranulacion6854]

Very interesting issue andaming natutuhan.this is informative and educational especially for law and accounting students more power .

[@realitycheck00023]

Anim na taon si Noynoy sa pwesto hindi Nila nasingil yan bakit kaya. Baka kasi mabisto na sobrang taas ng assessment ng nga ari arian kaya walang mag bid kaya di rin maibenta ng gobyerno para maibayad sa tax, at para na rin may pang harrass sa mga marcos

[@graceanndia8495]

I have a treasury bill and inherited properties from parents. The PNB had been asking me to pay a bond and an inheritance tax before getting it. The tax was so high. Why is it so? We own the property but needs to pay almost double the price of the said inheritance and if i couldn't pay the said tax Nobody has the right to acquire it not even the bank.

[@irenerenelonoy5338]

the interviewer is obviously biased. periodt. kudos to you Atty. for answering well her biased questions.

[@j.valerio7956]

Please keep this kind of news coming. Please Please

[@yrnapiaadonai5079]

Ang Estate Tax ay kinokolekta sa pamamagitan ng voluntary na pagbabayad ng heirs (kung gusto nila maibenta ang properties) or sa pamamagitan ng pagkuha ng gobyerno sa properties ng namatay (Estate). By default, pinili ng mga Marcoses ang Tax Levy dahil wala silang balak ibenta un in the future. Wise choice sa mga Marcos. PRRD implied sa statement nya na hindi alam ng PCGG at BIR ang mga natitirang properties ni FEM na dapat patawan ng tax. PRRD is really a strategist alam nyang walang maipresenta ang PCGG at BIR na listahan ng mga properties kasi nung nagsequester sila, basta-basta na lang at walang papeles. Hahahaha! Hindi na uusad ang paniningil nila dahil they are still trying to figure out if the properties that they are alleging are FEM's properties or not. Dahil dun, hindi sila makapaningil. Wahahahhaa! Ang galing talaga ng Marcoses at PRRD. 😀😀😀 Hindi nila mapipilit sina BBM na magbayad ng Estate Tax dahi mas pinili nila ang Tax Levy ng FEM properties instead of voluntary, which is legal naman ang tax levy. Unfortunately sa PCGG at BIR, hindi nila alam which properties are FEM's or not and ang ESTATE taxes do not involve BBM's personal properties. Hindi pwede ipambayad ang personal money and properties ni BBM dahil hindi pa maituturing na Estate ang properties ni BBM dahil buhay pa sya. Ang Estate Tax ay kinakabit lng sa properties ng namatay and properties lng ng namatay ang pinapatawan ng tax, at properties lng ng namatay ang kinukuhaan ng Tax Levy. kzbin.info/www/bejne/roqTaIaVlM11iNU from Nuza Avetria & Coach Jaret

[@ellengillego6221]

Prescriptive for 5 years? So what happen bet 2003 Supreme Court decisions to 2022. What did BIR do for 19 years??? The tax expired if BIR did nothing??

[@lovelyami6099]

I saw an interview with Former Commissioner Henares, she mentioned BIR tried to collect and levy pero yung ibang properties daw po are abroad so they cant just levy it. And then BIR sent another demand letter. Pero if BBM wins since BIR is under the president's umbrella baka di na po nya ipasingil :(

[@onadmangulovenan7986]

DO NOT VOTE TAX EVADER

[@levinacristobal597]

What? 35 yrs na...ilang president n maupo n may kaopangyarihan wala napatunayan,wala nagawa!

[@betterthanharvard]

reaction lang . 1. why would marcos pay estate tax of proterties na wala sa kanila at hindi na intresado? kaya ipina ubaya na lang sa mga lawyers un issue kc hindi ba sila intresado o umaasa pa. actually the marcosses were the ones who offered cory and even prrd na ishare ang yaman nila pero bakit government umaayaw? and now kasalanan nila hindi makabayad ng tax? IBINIBIGAY NA NGA PATI PRINCIPAL OR MISMONG MGA PROPERTIES SA GOVERNMENT. 😂😂

[@raffy3304]

Because this is just pure political made by koringking and her bethrens to destroy Marcoses

[@romelsalud2312]

Ang tanong Atty... Are those properties already transferred to the heirs???.. In fact those properties are confiscated by PCGG?..

[@jonatanhq7808]

Do you pay estate tax kung hindi mo pa naman ililipat yung property sa pangalan mo? Kailangan na bang magbayad ng estate tax kung under litigation pa yung property mo at hindi pa pwedeng ilipat sa pangalan ng heir/s

[@Delta-1X-Ray]

Then paano mo masasabi na dapat sa iyo pa rin yung mga properties? Lalo na't kung hindi mo babayaran yung estate tax?

[@ronaldlight593]

Paying estate tax is an obligation left to executors, administrators and/or the legal heirs of the estate as required by the existing tax code at the time of death of the owner. The estate tax liabilities in question already have a final and unappealable decision from the Supreme Court and had been for enforcement status since 1997. I'm quite surprised why the BIR would be sending another demand letter. 😁

[@twolawkoybrothers937]

Thanks for the clarification....

[@roliecashsite1406]

nag usap usap nlang sila at balak hati hatiin,muntik na nga makalimutan,lahat ng nag hahabol ng kayaman ni marcos nanahimik na yung iba kasama pa sa sa gropo ngayon ng kampanya

[@jonatanhq7808]

203Billion pesos weighs 203tons of money; approximately 1kg per 1M of 1000 denomination equivalent also to 2.03-Million bundles of 1000 peso bill at parang isang warehouse na puno ng pera

[@realitycheck00023]

Even the marcoses dont have that kind of physical money. So what may be the solution? Put the properties up for auction. But no one wants to bid because the assessed value was way too high.

[@SAM-uc3bo]

WhY don’t u guys go ask BIR AND OR SUPREME COURT

[@daveszandueta]

What's to ask, besides maybe why BIR hasn't filed charges against the Marcoses for failure to pay their estate taxes.

[@corazonsaldivar6479]

Very well explained

[@vinseph5641]

MAGBAYAD TAN NG TAX !!!!!!!!! BAKIT QUALIFIED PA RIN TUMAKBO YAN??? GANYAN BA TALAGA PAG MAY PERA? DI NAKUKULONG!!!? MGA KURAP KASI ANG MGA NAKAUPO!!!!!

[@liliaferguson7573]

Thanx....

[@cat-in-shoebox]

What’s to clarify is…SHOULD Marcos become President, can he just shrug the 203B off?

[@fedepositario7810]

Of course if he'll be president , BBM can do whatever he wants to do.

[@richardbiteng6915]

a big YES

[@vilmatamondong1675]

@@fedepositario7810 of course do the better for our nation and naniniwala kami

[@shaneiazyra4359]

Wag natin hayaan c marcos maging presidente

[@erajehyun]

I mean that's the main goal of their family. Ang linisin ang reputation nila.

[@FTL-mm6yd]

Is this not the fault of BIR because they should already confiscated the property/s involved when the Supreme Court decided its finality and the property was not yet transferred to the Marcos Sr. heirs.

[@mataraki_uno]

@2:11 -so does BBM pay this debt if the estate is not transferred to him or his mother or no evidence of estate transfer?

[@inna8348]

Ferdinand Marcos, Jr. was named an executor in the estate of the former dictator, along with his mother, Imelda Marcos. So being executors, yes, they are responsible for paying the estate tax.

[@karlomilitar5815]

Nasa kanila po ang responsibilidad ng pagbabayad ng estate tax. Otherwise, hindi po maililipat sa kanila yung mga property.

[@raybacasmas8466]

arctic nip estate tax is the assessment of the property left behind by the deceased person, in this case Marcos Sr, to be transferred to the heirs( Marcos Jr, Aimee, Irene, etc) upon payment of the assessed amount by the collecting agency which is the Bureau of Internal Revenue(BIR). It’s preparatory or initial step for the heirs to do this for them to transfer legally the estate or properties. There’s no such thing as it’s not transferred or evidence of estate transfer, rather it’s a precondition before transfer of ownership to the heirs.

[@lanymilallos1767]

hindi po maililipat sa pangalan ng lahat ng tagapagmana ni Ferdinand Marcos Sr. ang lahat ng kanyang naiwan na ari arian hanggat d nila binabayaran ang State Tax . Halimbawa namatay na magulang mo may pagaari siya hindi po maililipat sayo ang title hanggat d mo nababayaran ang state tax in other words kahit patay ka na magbabayad ka pa rin ng tax bago mailipat sa tagapagmana mo ang property mo naiwan ang tawag don STATE TAX

[@uniteamtv3.09]

BIR can levy properties of the estate then sell it.

[@dorothybriones9519]

Makinig kang mabuti para maliwanagan ka Tsong! Kuda lng ng kuda ung iba dyan, wala nmn alam pagdating salegalidad ng batas.

[@vashdelacruz9415]

I think if the marcos family just gives back all the ill gotten wealth from the start, then estate taxes would not be a problem for them.

[@aidahonrada4476]

Doyou reall believe there's an ill gotten wealth?

[@RonaldoSantos-bh5si]

Hahaha HINDI ka lang NAKAKAINTINDI ng mga TAXES!

[@ellengavadan9473]

Nasa pamilya yan kung gusto nila ma transfer ang property sa mga living heirs. The downside of non transfering the title to the heirs is they can not transfer or sell the property if not transfered to their names. Who will sign the DEED OF ABSOLUTE SALE because the original owner already died.

[@historyan24]

Nasagot na dito lahat yung mga tanong ng mga BBM loyalist. Now mag aabang na naman tayo ng mga bagong palusot. 🤣🤣

[@richardbiteng6915]

Palusot galing kanino? May supreme court ruling. Noong 1993 pa nakonpiska na ng gobyerno ang mga assets or estate na pwede o dapat ibenta para diyan ikaltas ang buwis. Nakit pala walang ginawa si noynoy noong 2010-2016?

[@catsays895]

@@richardbiteng6915 bakit si noynoy lang pino-point out mo? 1993 pa pala eh. Bakit walang ginawa si ramos, estrada, arroyo & now, duterte?

[@dandferzeplo5450]

Handsome. . . Young lawyer. Kudos

[@edwardtan8307]

Thank you, nasa got lahat ng frequently asked questions ng mga BBM supporters tungkol sa estate tax.😂😅🤣

[@richardbiteng6915]

nasago really? this is oone of my comment ad since you have watched the video please heklp me understad. Final and exectory 1997 pa so bakit hindi kinolekta ni noynoy aquino noong 2010-2016 na preseidente siya. Aggreibo pa naan si kim henares sa ng pagkolekta ng taxes, Paliwanag dito kung hindi nagbayad na estate tax ay hindi mailipat ang mana. Hindi ba kinonpiska at nabenta na 1993 pa so paano pa mailipat (levy sa paliwanag dito) Paliwanag dito na pagna-auction "the proceeds can be used to pay for the tax" so saan nabulsa, este napunta, yung pinagbentahan at bakit hindi pa naikaltas sa estate tax due? P389-B ang assessed value ng BIR at P203-B ang tax kasamang penalty so may ibabalik pa sa mga Marcoses? Hindi ba may tax amnesty tayo na wala ng penalty sa estate tax hanggang taong 2023? So bakit P203-B ang sinisingil at hindi 23-B Kaninong bulsa na naman ito pupunta?

[@nikdocha.5228]

@@richardbiteng6915 hindi po pwede 'yung ganun na ipambabayad mo sa estate tax yung estate na pinag-uusapan. Tulad nga po ng sabi sa video, tax ito para mailipat mo yung ari-arian sayo. Paano niyo po gagawin yon eh wala pa nga po sa pangalan niyo yung assets?

[@richardbiteng6915]

@@nikdocha.5228Kung hindi pwede than I stand corrected. Pero ipina-auction na ng gobyrerno ang 11 lupa sa tacloban noong 1993 pa at wala lang nagbid - siguro dahil mataas ang presyo gawa ng mataas na assessment. So saan pupunta ang pera e hindi naman sequestration ito?

[@reynaldoblas459]

Ano bang properties ang laman ng 23B tax due in 1997. Kung confiscated, wala naman benefit ang heirs, saan kukuha ng pambayad.? Paki enumerate mga properties. Kasama ba mga ilocos wind mills?

[@rhodoramiguel3142]

Pg mhirap k dka exemted mgbayad ng tax

[@enelamskoorb7176]

How will you pay if the government has the properties and then the owner died. That is not on the hands of the owner.