LED vs HID (XENON) vs HALOGEN - HEADLIGHTS COMPARED!

[@everythingdiy]

One million views! You guys are awesome! I'm so glad so many of you found this video useful, we appreciate all of the support!

[@alexmartinez5670]

everythingdiy Where can I get HID bulb i have a 04 Honda Accord lx

[@Rationalist64]

everythingdiy what about bi xenon lamps?

[@worldofai-games1036]

Check your local state laws for headlights. I believe most states require headlights to be white or near-white. Blue may confuse some drivers that you're a police car.

[@medo2142]

everythingdiy I need some assist from u do u have skype or any app so i can communicate with u

[@MisterGrandonk]

everythingdiy Probably you wanna look my bad chanel 😇🙏

[@Jason.W.]

Thanks for doing this test. Must have taken a lot of effort between changes. And kudos for mentioning glare and proper housing

[@nathansnow156]

+Jason Wang Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe the Mazda projector is a halogen projector, which still shouldn't be used for HIDs. The proper projector is fitted for HID bulbs since they don't typically have squirrel finders. On my car the stock halogen projectors had two square boxes above the cutoff line which produces glare when a more luminous bulb like HID is used. Plus you will get far greater width coverage with a proper projector. Still, putting an HID in a halogen projector is better than in a reflector headlight.

[@babybirdhome]

+flurryblizzard That's not quite correct. LEDs don't create NEARLY as much heat as halogen bulbs do, and they also create a TON less heat than HID bulbs do. The reason for all the huge heatsinks on LEDs isn't because they got super hot-- it's because they're semiconductors, and heat over about 160 degrees will obliterate a semiconductor and kill it in very short order. By definition, and LED light HAS to stay cool (for a certain value of "cool") or else it'll die very quickly. Also by definition, they CAN'T get as hot as a halogen or HID bulb, because they aren't consuming as much power as either of those technologies do. Less power = less heat, period, because it's power that creates heat due to electrical resistance. Bear in mind that 100% of the light created by a halogen bulb is a result of HEATING the filament up with a controlled electrical short until it's glowing white hot. And 100% of the light created by an HID bulb is created by an electric arc (like a welder) through a gas until that gas gets hot enough to MELT metal salts into a plasma phase where they'll emit light due to electron excitation. LEDs, by contrast, emit light by electrons crossing a semiconductor barrier and exciting a phosphor as they do so. I'm with everyone on sticking to HID for a little while longer, because LED and laser will both be better very soon, but it's likely they'll always perform poorly in headlights that aren't designed specifically around their light output characteristics. They'll be amazing on cars that come with them from the factory, but not on anything else unless you're replacing the whole headlamp unit with one that's made for the emitters they're using (and even then, only if it's well designed). For what it's worth, you can find halogen headlights that will put almost every LED or HID headlight to shame in terms of actual usable light performance. But that's not because halogen headlights are superior-- it's that the vast majority of headlights that are using LED or HID are not very well designed and make poor use of the light they output. HID at 35 watts is putting out 2.7 TIMES as much luminous flux as a 35 watt halogen headlight, but if you just put an HID conversion kit in your car that came with halogen headlights from the factory, it's going to be outperformed at the same wattage by a good set of Hella or Cibie headlamps using halogen bulbs even though they're working with just over 1/3 as much actual light output. There's also the issue of higher wattage bulbs giving people the illusion of brighter light. Yes, they put out a brighter light, but how well they do that is entirely a function of the headlamp's lens and reflector, not the bulb's wattage. You're better off spending good money on good reflectors and lenses than on brighter, higher tech light bulbs, because if you have crappy headlamp reflectors and lenses, most of the light you're adding is going to be wasted on the sky and blinding other traffic instead of lighting up the road where you want to be able to see. Don't compensate for poor light usage with mroe light-- compensate with poor light usage with good light usage instead. You'll never regret that choice, especially in rain, snow, dust, fog, or foliage in the woods if you're in a truck or jeep. When you add lots more light to your headlights-- ALL of that light is going to reflect off of EVERYTHING and come right back in your face and blind you (even if not painfully-- it WILL reduce your long range vision even if it's not uncomfortably bright up close, and that's why GOOD high beams don't add light on the road right in front of your car-- they shine it all way down the road instead). Y'all should look up Daniel Stearn's lighting website. He's got tons of very well-researched information about automotive lighting and the science behind it, even if he does come across as an anti-aftermarket HID/LED snob. You can learn a lot from his work from over the years.

[@chrisskokan7333]

i just read your whole novel you just wrote, and you nailed every single thing that needed to be said about...everything. its all about putting the light the road. so, well done, sir. l

[@ModernGolfer]

+babybirdhome - Well said. It's really a simple matter of physics. How a bulb, whatever type, produces light and how the human eye perceives that light.It should also be remembered that blinding other drivers doesn't just make you 'that guy' as noted in the clip, it's a ticketed offense in all States and full justification for a traffic stop.

[@danvel37]

+babybirdhome hi i have read ur quote it was great, maybe shouldnt be doing this but, i have a mazda 3 2009 the first generation, and im thinking on changing the lights, im wondering wich kind of tecnology will be better for a rainy and dark road?

[@maniacse]

+babybirdhome very well, sir. Everything was said. Maybe just point out, that mentioned names (Hella, Cibie) is not only ones, and not available worldwide - maybe except Hella, but here in middle of europe, those bulbs are not so good. I can recomand Osram and Phillips. Of course, it is not about brand, it is about technology and quality - both bulbs and reflector+optics.

[@narutolovesbleach]

+babybirdhome thanks for sharing good info man :)

[@boosted2.4_sky]

Excellent review! ..One thing about the"blue/white"HID's...Some local lawmakers are looking to ban the blue bulbs in vehicles...so check in your area...springing for HID's only to replace them again could get costly...FYI...

[@everythingdiy]

Thanks Craig! You read my mind we actually ordered some pure white 5000K bulbs a few days ago.

[@ctrlaltowned5223]

4:08 The bottle on the bookshelf moves.

[@zamborghini89]

new frame

[@shhleeshhmaker9496]

Scott Schilling omg lol

[@Edgaramaya1989]

Scott Schilling dude that’s tripping me out lol

[@gzhang207]

Excellent review. One issue missed may be the heat generated becoming useful in snowy regions. LED light covered by snow may become unusable (and dangerous) due to lack of heat to melt the snow or ice.

[@numinous4789]

You should do an update test with one of those LED designs that has emitters on at least 3 different planes instead of just front/back like the ones you showed here.

[@INTERLAGOS54]

You were very thorough without having excess filler. I stayed for the entire 10min and thats pretty rare for me. Good job on mentioning the need for projectors and oncoming glare.

[@dopespillcomics]

Very enlightening

[@gateway8833]

Best head light review I have seen, very comprehensive and well edited. I know this took a lot of time to do, thanks for doing such a good job.

[@thingsdemystified]

It's kelvin, not kelvin degrees =) halogen bulbs are not 4300K. They are closer to 3000K. Factory HID bulbs are 4300K. Not sure what you mean when you say that halogens give off the best output of light. They don't. HID bulbs put out several times more light than halogens. Manufacturers use halogens because they are several times less expensive.

[@Deere2154D]

depends on the halogen after market you can get up to 4300K I think as high as 4500K

[@thingsdemystified]

Deere2154D I'm assuming that when people talk about halogen, they're talking about clear bulbs and not the blue-colored ones. The natural color of light from a halogen bulb is in the 3000 range.

[@Deere2154D]

+ThingsDemystified putco makes one in 4000K that is a pure white halogen bulb I thought they went up to 4500K but I can't find any so I could be wrong

[@Deere2154D]

+Deere2154D and I know they are pure white because I have installed them in my gf's car

[@thingsdemystified]

Deere2154D Yes, they make halogen bulbs with coatings on them to filter the light to make them look white. The downside is that they're not as bright.

[@KFLY67]

I wonder if leaving your headlights on with the LED's will drain less of your battery vs halogens and Hid's? could be better at power conservative?

[@timramich]

For some reason LEDs measure great in specs, but somehow there is some unknown physical limitation of them being used at great distance.

[@Kj16V]

This is the best comparison video I've seen so far because you changed both bulbs instead of fitting one of each. Left and right lamps are aimed differently, so to get a true comparison you have to change both - which you did!

[@Afrocanuk]

There's one test you still need to do on the LED's. Put it in the freezer for 24hrs., then energize it as soon as you remove it from the freezer. Check right away to see if the luminosity is notably less intense.

[@Wazza722]

This is the most no bullshit review about hid vs led i have watched on youtube! Clearly shows hids to be the best. Good job!

[@jmackinjersey1]

One main issue you have here is the housing. The only bulb that is going to give you their best performance is the Halogen. That is because that particular housing (stock Mazda DOT) is designed for that bulb. If you replace the bulb, then the housing is not designed to reflect those other types of bulb/lights. Now, if you replace the entire housing, then you will get better results from the different typed of bulbs, because they are designed for them. I did not hear you say that you replaced the entire housing, just the types of bulbs.

[@jmackinjersey1]

It absolutely does matter. If a HID or led bulb is placed inside the housing of a regular incandescent/halogen bulb, it will not perform as good as it will if it is placed inside a housing designed for those typed of bulbs. The reflectors and refractors are designed completely different for the different types of bulbs.

[@xLostRemnant]

+Jeremiah Mckenna 03:30 she says she uses the correct housing, the Mazda comes stock with projector housings so putting HID's in the housing works the same.

[@Deere2154D]

+Jeremiah Mckenna I run 6000K in Stock housings and have no problem with how they preform

[@jmackinjersey1]

I definitely understand what you think is "no problem," however if you were to put the proper retro fit housing in there, you would actually get better performance. Yes, the light source is brighter than stock, but the reflectors are not the proper set up therefore giving you lower performance. Not only lower performance, but you are blinding everyone that you are facing.

[@jmackinjersey1]

Anthony Overton Actually it does not work the same. The reflectors are made differently for all the different types of lights.

[@bigchriscrespo3031]

Great video I’ve watched over 20 LEDH ID videos yours is by far the most informative thank you

[@MicBergsma]

No idea what she is saying - I am deaf... anyone tell me if she said something good about LEDs?

[@DCookStaVideo]

MicBergsma KZbin has closed captioning, hit the little cc to the left of the gear.

[@MicBergsma]

***** I know but it is messed up, try it and you will say what?

[@MicBergsma]

***** Thank you so much!! I'm sticking with my HID projector ;)

[@WheeledHamster]

Her kitchen look strange.

[@MicBergsma]

AZREDFERN Thank you!

[@mikejulien2330]

Just want to say was not expecting such a well done and fair comparison. Nice to see people on youtube not making biased assumptions or just comparing by what they read on the box, and seemingly doing some research! Have been doing a lot of research on putting LEDs in my car and wanted to find a good real world comparison. I was expecting to have to watch several vids to find some one that knew what they were talking about, but found this on the first try! Thanks for info, will def look into other videos!(sticking to HID for lows, and going LED for high so I can use flash-to-pass)

[@uptownsamcv]

i went with LED cause i got tired of HID ballasts going out on me. newer LED lights have better design to distribute light better....

[@everythingdiy]

I've personally have never had a ballast go bad on me. The ones on my speed are 5 years old. The only thing to go bad was one of the bulbs but that was due to water getting in the housing. My other car (Mazda 3) still has the factory bulbs and ballast, and after 8 years they still work great. What brand of HID's are you using?

[@uptownsamcv]

i have tried all kinds of different brands and they never last more than a year. right now i have ballasts from DDM tuning in my 02 maxima. 02 and newer maxima all come with factory HID. next time i have a ballast or bulb issue Im going with LED now that i can find them in D2R size.... i have never had problems with bulbs just ballasts. i even see color variances with HID once ballasts age... LED are better for motorcycles since they don't need a ballast.....

[@coreydw1]

That the problem, people buy cheap, crappy kits and they go out. Good hids are expensive.

[@uptownsamcv]

From what I have seen with cheap aftermarket ballasts they aren't as strong as high end ones and the bulbs doesn't gk up to full color...

[@songsyluc]

I've had on cheap aftermarket china brand hid kit for 7 years. nothing ever went bad, lucky me?

[@JayanandSupali]

This was a very informative. Have been using an HID for a long time and i was wondering how LED's would fair against it. You pretty much solved that for me. So thanQ very much.

[@sullivan8733]

Very well done video. excellent detail and thorough. I have been involved in technical lighting, mostly aerospace, for many years and this is one of the best summaries of its kind I have seen.

[@everythingdiy]

***** Thanks you! I appreciate the feedback!

[@ReviewingTech101]

Great video that give me an idea of what to purchase for my car but I have a question, for the headlights I'll get HID's but for the high beams? what should I get? because on my car these double as high beams and day running lights. My car is a Mazda 6 2015 so it won't produce glare for other motorist.

[@kenz1031]

best informative video on lights

[@DK-is-Right]

I have watched a couple of vids trying to learn more about these head lights and this was the most thorough and informative video i have seen. Great vid all questions answered

[@arunrai8006]

Best review i have seen so far. Good job

[@qureshi667]

HID

[@SERGE_Tech]

its color accuracy more important then brightness? arent lights usually too bright anyway?

[@Milosz_Ostrow]

I would still choose the halogen light. It produces a tight beam that reaches farther down the road than any of the others. HID produces a lot of glare for oncoming motorists and LED isn't ready for prime-time yet.

[@dirkalleyne3580]

U must be insane...... Noway is a halogen close to being as bright as an hid. There's a reason luxury car makers use them & also why they're more expensive. Simple physics from the color table. 4300K is the highest output. Halogens are only 2700K. Only have glare if u use cheap shit

[@Milosz_Ostrow]

Dirk Alleyne - You're talking color temperature, which has nothing to do with luminosity, usually expressed in lumens. It's comparing apples and oranges. Please, we've never met and you have no idea what my technical background is, so calling me "insane" is entirely uncalled-for.

[@dirkalleyne3580]

+Milosz Ostrow Ok...... U throw out a technical term as if to educate me. I have a degree in electrical engineering & I'm very aware of the difference u brought up which actually further proves me correct. Fact: 4300K HIDs produce 3000 lumens and 90 McD/m2. Hologen headlight produce about 1400 lumens and 30 mcd/m2. So now u have apples to apples & oranges to oranges. So ....instead of feeling insulted (which wasn't my intention) how about soaking in some knowledge a recognizing that some people actually know what they're talking about as well & the insane comment was nothing more than an opinion & being silly. I don't speak unless I know what the hell I'm talking about. Halogens are only used coz they are a lot cheaper.

[@Milosz_Ostrow]

Dirk Alleyne A Wi-Fi signal from a cheap home router, using the built-in antenna, will cover a radius of perhaps 50 feet; maybe up to 100 feet if it is in an open space with no obstructions. Replace that antenna with an external parabolic dish and the signal will reach at least a mile, possibly up to 10 miles line-of-sight. So it is with halogen vs. HID headlamps. When I'm driving on a highway at night, I'm mostly interested in what is directly ahead of the vehicle. Halogens provide a focused beam that puts those lumens where they're needed. I don't care what's going on in the pasture 45 degrees off my course, because I'm not planning to drive in that pasture anyway. Those HID lamps with their lack of good focus also cause tremendous glare for oncoming motorists and actually _reduce_ safety for all concerned.

[@dirkalleyne3580]

+Milosz Ostrow And I guess u missed the part of the video where they showed that the HIDs were 1. projected further down the street 2 at a wider angel 3 were brighter But..... Hey feel free to have the last word coz ur just a waste of my time & energy. U win Bro..... Hip hip hip

[@sarrum7696]

Great info, great video! I would add one thing, with regards to durability on HID's. I've gone threw about 7 ballast's over the course of 6 years... All were professionally installed. The forums are full of people who have similar stories.

[@RCJOE]

very nice video, still thinking about the LED lights👍

[@RahilChodanker]

Great to see a girl who is interested so much in automotive tech.. cheers and keep up the good work :)

[@RahilChodanker]

and BTW i find 4300K the best for visibility

[@Kingcrt09]

They should make a law against having HID lights in the wrong housing. I swear I get blinded every time I drive at nighttime by someone with HIDs in the wrong housing.

[@CactusJack252]

That is why I didn't put HID bulbs in my 06 focus.

[@michaelmeisman4731]

There is a law about it but I have never heard of any cop ever enforcing it. The DOT rules clearly state the you cannot put a HID or LED into a housing that is not DOT approved for those bulbs. But it is easy to make these older headlight housings compliant. I do it all the time. @JG Car Cleaning First let me be clear you cannot "adjust the housings" to make them compliant. I said that you have to 'make' the housing compliant by installing proper parts into them. Now you can make adjustments to the aiming of the headlights to make them better so as not to blind oncoming drivers. You cannot adjust them with the same systems as used for halogen lights. You must use something like the Hella SEG700L and adjust for HID configurations not halogen. But few shops, even dealers have this tool and you will be lucky to find someone that fully understands this unit to use it properly here in the states. When I was a mechanic I was master guilded with Porsche and I was a master technical specialist with Audi. Being certified with this tool was mandatory to attain these positions. But again this will not make them compliant with the law, it will only make them less hazardous to oncoming drivers. Now you can make them compliant. The simplest is to install the proper projector array into the housing. I said easy and I should have said simple although it requires labor and time. You can buy projector housings that are designed to go into existing headlamp housings. I like the 1.5" H4 ones for the simplest installs. These will fit through the H4 opening and lock into place in the tabs. The ones I have used have the hi/low plate in them and do not depend upon any reflector for proper illumination. But if your housing is large enough you can install up to 90mm projector heads in the housings. This is the one that requires labor and time on your part. Its not hard just laborious. With the 90mm ones you can get Angle Eyes (halos) and/or Devil Eyes in them for varied custom looks. I have installed dual 90mm projectors in my sons 1929 Mercedes SSK and they look great and comply with the law. I am building a set of headlights for my sons 1987 Pontiac Fiero with quad 1.5" projectors in a custom made housing that will be fully compliant.

[@JG_Fit]

Michael Meisman how do adjust the housing to make them compliant bud?

[@Kingcrt09]

Most people aren't going to take the time (and money) to adjust the housing. They just like the coolness factor of having bluish looking light output.

[@michaelmeisman4731]

JG Car Cleaning First let me be clear you cannot "adjust the housings" to make them compliant. I said that you have to 'make' the housing compliant by installing proper parts into them. Now you can make adjustments to the aiming of the headlights to make them better so as not to blind oncoming drivers. You cannot adjust them with the same systems as used for halogen lights. You must use something like the Hella SEG700L and adjust for HID configurations not halogen. But few shops, even dealers have this tool and you will be lucky to find someone that fully understands this unit to use it properly here in the states. When I was a mechanic I was master guilded with Porsche and I was a master technical specialist with Audi. Being certified with this tool was mandatory to attain these positions. But again this will not make them compliant with the law, it will only make them less hazardous to oncoming drivers. Now you can make them compliant. The simplest is to install the proper projector array into the housing. I said easy and I should have said simple although it requires labor and time. You can buy projector housings that are designed to go into existing headlamp housings. I like the 1.5" H4 ones for the simplest installs. These will fit through the H4 opening and lock into place in the tabs. The ones I have used have the hi/low plate in them and do not depend upon any reflector for proper illumination. But if your housing is large enough you can install up to 90mm projector heads in the housings. This is the one that requires labor and time on your part. Its not hard just laborious. With the 90mm ones you can get Angle Eyes (halos) and/or Devil Eyes in them for varied custom looks. I have installed dual 90mm projectors in my sons 1929 Mercedes SSK and they look great and comply with the law. I am building a set of headlights for my sons 1987 Pontiac Fiero with quad 1.5" projectors in a custom made housing that will be fully compliant.

[@rpmrentleadsrpmrentleads3692]

You mentioned the right housing is important. Are you speaking of the headlamp assembly/ lense encasement or projector? How do I know if I have the right housing? Some suggest that putting hid bulbs in place of halogen (in stock headlamps) is a bad idea because of glare, dispersion of light, etc. I don't have the time or $ for huge modifications...just wanting to upgrade where I can afford. I was looking at a plug'n play hid kit that comes with the bulbs, wiring, & ballasts. I'll have to double check to make sure the wiring includes a relay.

[@stephenperry9425]

The best colour temp is 4300 to 5000Kelvins, going too much higher the light becomes blue. The human eyes cant focus on blue light, so will course dazzle and glare.

[@VR46champion]

Stephen Perry true. However I still don't understand why most states/provinces prohibit the use of 3000k bulbs. I have experienced driving with 3000k lowbeams and their perfect (back in my native country) . That's why I have 3k bulb for my high beam so when there's intense fog or snow, I can see everything :)

[@BucketWheat]

VR46champion Most 'set-ups' for HiD single-bulb headlights have a sort of 'baffle' or blinder, that deflects some of the brightness and 'cuts off' the top portion of the projection range. So the SAME bulb is providing both ranges of light. [otherwise, you would have a 'time delay' for each bulb to heat up again.] If you have a dual bulb arrangement, the low beam may remain on as the high beam "adds to it" with additional light and coverage. (Very common in older cars with the factory halogen lights.)

[@corygauvreau3588]

For your tests between bulbs. When switching from Halogen to HID did you install the proper HID Projector lenses with the bulbs or just did a straight bulb swap? If these tests were just straight bulb swapping then they are invalid as you used a Halogen reflector to control how the light is "thrown" from the vehicle.

[@rickgarrison183]

"you don't want to be one of those drivers thats blinding everyone on the road" Why yes I do. I have 6K HIDs and 6k HIDs for my fog lights along with 6k LEDs for my DRL and 6K switchbacks for my signals. God said LET THERE BE LIGHT so thats what I'm doing lol

[@Rafaelent2013]

Rick Garrison hahaha

[@A.nasierkhan]

Lmao!

[@bobherrmann1510]

I can't say that I've seen any other You Tube video that was not only so informative but also so easy to watch. You are awesome and I subscribed! Thumbs up+

[@Pull_It_Apart_Paul_Ham_CB]

you need to be very careful when discussing deg K. headlights are based on the colour temp of the sun, this is rated at daylight which is 5000K, anything over 5000k is illegal in most countries because the glare above 5000k is blinding, you have eluded that Deg K is just a reflection of the light color, this is true in one sense but manufacturers are bound by complying with Daylight Balance, this is why Halogen and 4500K has been the standard requirement by complancing throughout the world. So any color temp over 5000k is bad for the human eye, fact.

[@skirmich]

FACT: Philips CBI HID Bulbs are DOT LEGAL and beyond 5000K (Actual 6000K) and if they are sold in California they can be bought anywhere in the world.

[@edwrd1990]

I have to admit that I didn't think this would be a very informative video but you did a great job. Thanks!

[@TheFlydeagle228]

ok... HID lights juss blind the shit outta me almost like high beaming straight at my eyes...which can cause accident.

[@JParkSD]

daeshik cho only if the owner installed a HID bulb into a halogen headlight assembly (pretty ghetto IMO). Likewise, if the headlight adjustment is not adjusted correctly, any light can blind you. If you get a HID or LED light from the manufacturer when purchasing a car, it will not blind you AT ALL, just badass light pattern that will turn night into day. Modern cars also have self-leveler that will adjust the headlight beam depending on the amount of weight your car is carrying.

[@troypowders4312]

Don’t look at the light. Look at the line of the road on the passenger side. They teach you this in drivers ed😂

[@THEHUNNY]

thanks for the info was very useful, one more thing I wantes to ask about is the watt ... 35wt ... 55 wt ..etc... what does the watt for? I understand Kelvin is for the color but what about the watt?

[@Lifesrad8]

I found led are the best for brightness

[@Kana0211]

They scarterlight everywhere so u can't see very far

[@Lifesrad8]

@@Kana0211 idk I have them on every one is my vehicles and I don't see that.. the key is not too not the cheap ones spend money on a good pair they they put some work into it because the led placement and the kind that you use does matter.

[@stevo091]

Hi , I very much enjoyed watching your review. Would u say that LED are better than HID?.

[@stevew1643]

shut off the fog lights next time

[@gtavtheavengergunnerlegend3340]

steve wujek I AGREE 👍

[@MisterGrandonk]

steve wujek Probably you wanna look my bad chanel 😇🙏

[@artjr61]

You can find some great deals on HID's on ebay that's where I bought mine and they worked great,... I would like to know though like someone else asked on your test of the HID'S what watt did you use 35 55??? Not sure if they go up any higher

[@TheSunnysunny2]

shes using bad qualilty leds bulbs. use Runstreet or Phillips then see who will be the winner

[@ro9967]

Good video! You know what you're talking about! Note, if you want to stand out of traffic you take yellow lights, you immediately see them in between all the white lights in heavy traffic. Especially useful for motorbikes.

[@android175]

I like HID but please people don't install HID's without projector headlights. seriously you will blind EVERYONE

[@ZillaYT]

The LEDs did not have a long throw at all, as apparent from the still pics. How far away was the tree or edge of field from the vehicle? It was also apparent from the road test, and you mentioned this.

[@clydeng87]

From my experience, HIDS have the lowest life span. Either the ballast burn out or the bulb changes color and lose its effectiveness.

[@everythingdiy]

Clyde Ng We've had our HID's for 3 1/2 years on one car (Mazdaspeed3) and 7 years on another (Mazda 3). Both see daily use and perform flawlessly. We have not replaced a single bulb or ballast yet. I think it's safe to say they're reliable. Thanks for watching!

[@EdgarHernandezragde]

Clyde Ng Largely depends on the quality of parts. If you go cheap aftermarket yes, you will be more likely to experience a component failure. If you go with OEM parts the chances of something like that happening are reduced dramatically. My setup: Lexus RX350 Bi-Xenon projectors with STi-R clear lenses OEM Matsushita ballasts. OSRAM 66240 CBI

[@phillipzx3754]

+Clyde Ng 12 years on my original Ford Focus stock HID lamps.

[@squarebomb20]

My factory HID in my 2002 M3 still works. It's on at least 2 hours a day.

[@InCountry6970]

+Clyde Ng . Sorry to say, but my STARR projection HID's have been working for eight years in my truck and no problems. If you use Phillips D1S bulbs, ballast and other components and not cheaper lower quality parts, you should have the same experience as me

[@leocoroful]

Hi. I have seen 3 sided led headlights who claim to fix the dispertion problem you mention of the 2 sided led. Have you guys tested some of these? Would you make a little video to show the comparison? Thanks

[@bobg69]

See what light does the best in foul weather. Do a test in the fog. Watch how the halogen will beat the others in fog. Your best light for driving in the fog is the old-time yellow fog lights. The brighter lights and today's so called fog/driving lights are just that.....a driving light. Amber is best for bad weather.

[@lawrenceharris5840]

On what vehicle was the test done? Did they have OEM headlight or aftermarket projector type? What wattage was the LED, HID, Halogen?

[@matthewporter3724]

who cares people... there is a BEAUTIFUL woman talking about cars.. is there anything better than that???

[@penguinlittlefeet8463]

Yes..beer pizza jerky and video games

[@liamkim3556]

+Penguin LittleFeet nerd

[@penguinlittlefeet8463]

:-) NOT a nerd, just a realist.

[@KableTac]

+Matthew Porter Of course there's something better. A beautiful woman who actually knows what they're talking about when talking about cars.

[@dirkalleyne3580]

+Kable amen to that !!!!!!!! Halogens also don't come close to 4300K as she claimed; they are closer to 2700K hence the reason they are the dimmest of all the lights

[@aquanet2]

Well done and very helpful. Thanks. Halogen for the older Honda Accord

[@santosceniceros9937]

wrong hid kits r only $35 lol idk were u get urs at

[@Performancecustoms]

I go with kensun hid . some kits are 39.99 some are 60 . but they all come with 2 year warranty.

[@kzoomin]

Santos Ceniceros 1. oem projector hid retrofit 2. trs morimoto hid kit into existing projectors or retrosolutions digital hid kit with capped bulbs for reflective housings. 3. kensun premium ballast hid kit. 4. halogen bulbs. 10. $35 dollar hid kit.

[@TomF1970]

Your argument presentation on these headlight types was very well put together. My students could learn something from this.

[@ttampatrick]

nice vid, but Kelvin is actually not a degree, it's just Kelvin

[@kelvinyang7475]

Patrick Bailey hello

[@cflip2x]

I appreciate that you let people know that they should not use LED and HID in reflector bowls. Yes you can use HID and LED in a halogen projector but you can get a lot of better output if you are using a correctly designed projector bowl for the type of bulb you are using. I admit I was one of the people that put a hid in a reflector bowl but once I read up on how to correctly retrofit my car I made sure to do it correctly. It did cost more but I am very happy with the output.

[@KM-qk1oz]

How many Mexicans does it take to change a light bulb? JUST JUAN :D

[@EPereda1995]

it would be funny if a Mexican said it....

[@Xavificationism]

+Paul Langley It is the "how many people does it take to xxx " jokes and the answer is usually "just ONE". Here, Juan is a Hispanic/Mexican name pronounced "Huan", which has a similar sound to "ONE" if you pronounce it quickly.

[@georgiojansen7758]

+DS S. wrong

[@Xavificationism]

georgio jansen Pray tell why.

[@georgiojansen7758]

+DS S. It's like a g in dutch or close like h in croation. you have to hear it. maybe I am wrong. goedendag

[@checkli8047]

Great Review. However, I was having a hard time to see the comparison when the fog lights were on without fog, so was the lot with street lights. On the HID, 35w and 55w ballasts made a deference on the color when running the the same bulb.

[@dustythibodaux]

What kind of garbage hids are those?

[@everythingdiy]

Dusty Thibodaux Morimoto Elite... far from garbage HID's.

[@dustythibodaux]

No way possible that was morimotos. I have ran morimotos for over 8 years and even the old versions looked better than those.

[@everythingdiy]

Dusty Thibodaux So you're looking for some proof huh? i.imgur.com/eg9Dm4I.jpg?1 Have a nice day!

[@sweaterwearingsquirrel9302]

I haven't seen someone get pwned that hard in quite some time. Glad she put you in your place.

[@everythingdiy]

+Adam Reichl (>‿◠)✌

[@glenndm1]

I have a 2016 Honda Pilot with a projector headlight. What brand LED do you recommend to replace my stock halogen bulbs. Thanks for your review.

[@AdamDaley1]

Too bad she's using crappy LED Lights for this video. These LED lights are all poor designs to begin with and not that great. We sell an LED light kit that not many sell. It's the latest on the market and beats all other kits out there. THAT is the kit she should have used in her testing.

[@everythingdiy]

If you want to send me a sample of the LED's you are selling I would be more the happy to review them.

[@AdamDaley1]

Appreciate the offer but we only send sample/demo equipment out to at minimum weekly youtuber. Good luck with the channel though looks like it has potential.

[@CactusJack252]

So you want someone to use your stuff but you won't give out any for review. What gives? You also don't post a website link, prices, contact info, etc.

[@AdamDaley1]

I didn't want to hijack her video is why. I didn't think it was appropriate to comment to her video advertising our products. I hate when people do that. We give them out for reviews for youtubers who have significant followings. Her videos are great, but the subscribers are just not there and more importantly, the amount of videos each week are not there is all... Just wanted to point out that not all LED kits are equal, so the kits she was using in her video are old/cheap kits that in fact DO have poor light output.. and scatter light as she said. Our kits are brought in ourselves and available at www.4x4TruckLEDs.com if you wanted to take a look, but again, we're not looking to piggyback on her video for advertising

[@FredRTP96]

Adam Daley lol sureee typical " we sell the best"

[@charleskim9171]

Thanks for that video, really helpful. I recently bought a Mazda3 GT sport 2016 (which i really enjoy) . Now I noticed the current bi-xenon headlights are not as white as I expected. Any site online where I can order custom headlights you can suggest?

[@Totoroallright]

everythingdiy Hi there, I like the videos you do for Mazdaspeed 3, Just wonder do you know where is the Mazda 3 fuel pump and the filter located? is it under the back seats? Hope you can help as I'm thinking to change it myself or can you make a video about it?

[@shaytan3796]

Thank you for this video. I've decide to change the lights for my (BMW 3 series E90 2011) to HID. do I need new housing or HID light holder? and would this change the colour of angle lights or do I need to get them separately? If anyone has any info please let me know as I haven't got a clue to what to do nor any experience in these things.

[@matthewguthrie722]

This video was very helpful! Any Suggestions on where to get HID kit For a 2015 Chevy Silverado 2500 HD ??

[@NinjaKDot]

Interesting overview but i have a question I can't find a answer for any where, if the ballast on a HID went faulty, still coming on but could it draw more than the 12 volts and drain the battery faster than a regulator or stator can recharge the battery?

[@nofaithjusthope8714]

Unfortunately most people that "upgrade" to HID or LED put them into headlights made for Halogen bulbs, they don't give a damn about how much glare they produce and most police don't even bother ticketing them because it's a fix-it ticket and no fine so you have all these rude drivers out there. Really pisses me off. Yeah I'm talking to you jackass. If you want brighter lights do it right or don't do it at all. BTW, those type of LED (bulbs) are a joke. A proper LED uses a projector type lens like a HID

[@saadqureshi7127]

nofaithjusthope I just got led bulbs and using a projector headlight with halo's on my 12 camaro. don't worry I won't be that guy.

[@nofaithjusthope8714]

Good for you, what type bulbs "were" in your Camaro? I don't mind people upgrading headlights if it's done right but where I live so many aren't following that route, what's worse is they are putting in "lifted" trucks just making it worse at night you can see them from a mile away

[@pradasupremegucci624]

I'm the guy with Hids in my halogen housing that blinds people . But I also have Led angel eyes so I'm good

[@yojomojo6262]

nofaithjusthope what most people don't realise is that there are hid kits that are specifically for headlights with reflectors in them.. these are kits with a letter 'R' at the end. for example.. H7R or H4R. As mainly these kits in this video are for projector headlights.

[@lady_cee_cee_v4096]

lewis king what bulbs are they? I've just gone from a car with projectors with hids to a car with reflectors trying to find brighter bulbs for them

[@MouseyBusiness]

I don't like the blue hue of some HIDs. It needs to be white or very slightly yellow.

[@kevindouglasmatinezbermude7690]

what you recommend me, which its better for my Ford explorer 2014? HID or LED lights?

[@vinniephan9684]

This was a really great video in helping me decide whether or not to put HIDs into my car. Keep up the excellent comparison videos!

[@Michaelbellman13]

I recently ordered new headlights that come with a projector housing and the set comes with halogen bulbs. Would it be a good idea to switch the halogens with LEDs or would it be better to just stick with the halogens since that's what they come with? I'm just looking for a brighter bulb that looks nice.

[@myathletesbody]

great job sweety!! what do you recommend for a land rover lr3 in the HID??

[@MrWaheedulHaque]

You should check out the cree led headlights. They have advanced so far that they have same light output of 3 hid bulbs. It does require using a heatsink with it though so yeah

[@danielurquiza1344]

heatsink?

[@mokanasser]

Some even require fans

[@albinfiskare]

+daniel urquiza Its because the heat needs to be transported from the light source to not cause damage to the "bulb". I think leds need to be below 100 C ( compared to halogen and hid that operates at 2800 C and 2200C). So even though leds are warmer on the outside, they are actually a lot cooler than halogen and hid...

[@Chitown388]

Awesome test! Where does xenon fit into this?

[@jamesd.8574]

Did you use to do how to videos for IFIXIT?. If so I want you to know that I always enjoyed your videos.

[@MrLanmx]

Is it possible to use led headlight bulb with no-xenon projectors? I love the projectors, but am not into hid's. Unaware of their true nature I killed my battery and had to literally replace it. Therefore I would be pleased to have some info about that feasibility...

[@enzogaibisso9691]

Excellent video I’m now using LEDs at the moment on my work van. I drive a lot on dark country roads. I also have a a few lights bars, but definitely want to upgrade to HIDs

[@AdrenalinnVapor]

Eh, this video is so old that it's outdated. LED's have come a looong way. Even within the past 6 months. They rival or are better than HID's at this point. I also suspect she installed the LED lights in the opposite orientation. The way she held it up at 12 and 6 @2:36 when she was explaining the light output on the LED's makes me think this. The light is supposed to shine at 3 and 9. This makes the beam much much wider and even. I'd find a comparison that was created within the past few months. Also, she is dead wrong about never using them in reflector lights. You can get a perfect cutoff line as long as the diodes are at the same height as the original bulb's filament and installed at the right orientation.

[@WaleedAldokhail]

​@@AdrenalinnVapor By far the best and most powerful LED is weaker and less illuminating of the road than the original premium quality HID.

[@kaimogamers9274]

Hi, awesome videos... been looking at some. Decided on buying HID lights. do u have a video on how to install them, but I don't have the relay wires, how long before it may cost a problem. I just bought my mazda 3 2006, but for someone reason one of the lights just started to not work. what could be the problem? thank you so much. :)

[@lnfantryFox]

What brand did you buy for the hid lights on the video thanks

[@raihanmahmud6904]

Hey there can you do any tutorial about how to change door dash light. I don’t know how to open door dash. Mazda CX-9 2009 model.

[@sonicstep]

WoW! Very informative. I've often wondered what you do when not performing on Chaturbate.

[@Alzayayd]

what is the best housing type and the best size for a circle housing HID fog light attempted to be use for a 4 doors sedan when the distance is #1 demanding?!

[@cm.5023]

Very detailed and informative review. Here is my observation of the LED's from your video, at 1:00 the LED's seems to have as good a light dispersion as the halogens but if you notice the hot spots are closer to the car which makes it seem that they need to be adjusted up. At 2:00 the dispersion pattern seems a little different than the parked image but again the hot spots are closer to the car.

[@everythingdiy]

I agree, we played with the height adjustment for almost an hour but there was no way of getting a better dispersion. We actually found that they had the best dispersion at the highest possible level setting. Thanks for watching!!

[@BucketWheat]

C Muir I noticed that as well, since my biggest interest is DISTANCE with a 'standard' light set-up. [Motorcycles and sports cars...not 4x4 hunting vehicles!] I think most of that can be related to the shape of the reflector, as she mentioned when talking about glare. The Factory's design of their reflector is out of our control...unless WE want to design one of our own! *Good Luck with that...unless you have some pretty sophisticated equipment and skills..* (-;

[@MrPaul-sf6cg]

Awesome comparison video! COULD YOU PLEASE DO A COMPARISON ON LED VS HALOGEN DRL/HIGH BEAM BULB, i wanted to know if converting to LED high beam would be better than halogen. (I have a honda accord, so the drl and the high beam are the same bulb). Thanks! :)

[@-G3rRy310-]

Great video. I was thinking about making the shift from HID to high output LEDs but I guess I'm sticking to my HID bulbs now!

[@troymokwe18]

What’s your reason?

[@chadsantos9987]

For 2013 Maxda CX-5 non-tech package does it need relay and capacitor to work on hid's?

[@braulioe.almonte9423]

hi there miss, do you think that a 4 led bulb would fix the light dispersion problem, i mean the one you used on this vid only has two, i've seen the newer models that have 4 leds, one on each direction, i'm thinking on upgrading and so far HID's are the most atractive to me but i've seen a lot of complains with the ballasts going out, even high end brands...i would love your advise on that

[@scottmcbroom3558]

How do these 3 lights compare in Fog/Smoke conditions?

[@edzweiger4548]

I wonder if leds are polarity protected? From some dummy jump starting wrong. Would be expensive

[@good2bhere]

Excellent video. Great starting point for comparison of three different headlights to make ones own decision. Very neutrally objective and superb presentation.

[@mtbhux9711]

I appreciate that someone does all the work to ease my choice. Thanks

[@jamespeters066]

Thanks for this....I think I decided on HID for my truck. Now what brands are good quality?

[@everythingdiy]

+John McClane We like Morimoto and Kensun HID kits. Thanks for watching!

[@jamespeters066]

Thanks I was thinking of doing the morimoto D2S retrofit in my truck and then adding Kensun Hid's to that. Been hearing some mixed reviews on if it's really worth the extra money to upgrade the assembly to projectors or not. Some guys said they just added the bulbs and some say you really should add projectors first. Especially in a truck and when you're doing both your fogs and headlights. Thoughts?

[@123Sander1231]

Toyota, VW, just stay away from the American cars because they are dreadfull, or were you not refering to the car brands?

[@AlienMonkeyDXB]

Nice review. Thank you. Another thing to mention with LEDs is the rear section of the bulbs are very bulky. A lot of headlight housings have limited space behind the rear cover, thus not allowing big bulky bulbs to be used. HIDs are OK as the bulk is in the ballast, which is separate from the normal size bulb. One must check clearance before buying a kit.

[@leo0761]

I have compared LED vs my stock HID's on my Altima. Even though you say in the video that LED's light output is less than the HID, I find that LED's have equal light output on my Altima to my stock HID's with less glare. People used to flash me with my HID's but since I installed the LED kit, no more flashing! With that being said, I think it depends on the actual vehicle/headlight assembly itself whether or not the LED's are as bright as the HID's.

[@kevinalexander8670]

Are there white H1 bulbs ? 4300k or is that only achieved with HiD kit?

[@maveric0738]

+Clyde HID's will out last and the ballast will out last as well. Providing you have the correct housing.