LEGO Star Wars Tantive IV Comparison! (10019, 10198, 75244 | 2001, 2009, 2019)

[@MandRproductions]

Which Tantive IV do you think is the best? My next comparison video should be the Mos Eisley Cantina!

[@leonmuller2205]

I think the 2009 Tantive IV is best

[@leonmuller2205]

Wow! I am exited

[@lssjgaming1599]

2001 but the newest one has best minifigs. I like it as a sort of model. Although I wish you could open it up and put minifigs inside

[@cannot3162]

MandRproductions do you know why it’s not a UCS but not a master builder?

[@BrickMotion]

MandRProductions definitely the new one!!!!!!! 😀😄😮😁

[@Monostat7]

I want the detail from 2019 with the size of 2001

[@obrezfamous]

Nihils Maw then make it

[@Bloorgusgoorge]

Norway that’s fucking tuff

[@iamaspaceman8533]

Nihils Maw said everyone

[@danemorgan1794]

Nihils Maw I agree

[@ringorodruiges5450]

@@obrezfamous er du norsk?

[@lukerope1906]

Just a suggestion. But when you do the design section of comparison. You should show a picture of the craft in the film. So we can see how close it matches up.

[@maxdickson8649]

Joe Kerr good tip gamer! Let me know when you discover deodorant.

[@zap192]

@@maxdickson8649 pretty dickish response for no reason

[@DiLL-PiCKLe02]

@@zap192 that's the internet for ya.

[@thelonious2213]

@@maxdickson8649 guess I know why DICKson is your name. Pathetic response with no sh** to be based on. What is wrong with you?

[@giogiosepicchannel5195]

Yeah cauz funnily enough, the newest set seems to be the least accurate lol. The neck between the main body and the cockpit is faaarrr to long.

[@ArkOnYoutube]

All these Tantives and none of them have a hallway, ya know, the most iconic scene on the tantive? Hopefully the next one will

[@DonChij]

You mean the Darth Vader Hallway scene? It wasn't on the tantive, it was on the Radus

[@pedrovieira8602]

@@DonChij I belive he means the first scene in Episode 4.

[@DonChij]

@@pedrovieira8602 ohhhh ok nvm

[@treeetres9002]

LEGO Boba Fett yeah and the deaths stars don’t even have a hot tub

[@jpasby779]

So true

[@joshuahoge1662]

I feel the mini figure selection feels incomplete as I think Vader and two storm troopers would have completed it for me to recreate scenes like the break in or Leia’s confrontation with Vader.

[@MandRproductions]

Honestly smart bro

[@joshuahoge1662]

MandRproductions thanks! I grew up watching both trilogy’s and playing the LEGO Star Wars games it kinda have me that idea!

[@rundownpear2601]

Set was based off of pre rouge one, so that wouldn’t really make sense

[@WtfHippoGaming]

@@rundownpear2601 have you watched the og trilogy?

[@rundownpear2601]

@@WtfHippoGaming yeah, read the designer interview. The Tantive IV set is based off of pre rouge one where bail and leia are traveling together before they separate during the movie.

[@Mahan_]

The old one is so good but it really lacks now

[@giyuutomioka8360]

Mahan the 2019 one makes me somewhat regret getting the 2009 set a couple years ago

[@leanderseiler]

The 2019 is so ugly...

[@leanderseiler]

Just fill the whole set with stickers and sell it overpriced...

[@leanmeangreenbeanmachine3347]

You better hush, or I will crush

[@user-fg3dz5kv7q]

@@leanderseiler + It's overpriced, but that doesn't mean it's ugly. And "ugly" is opinion thing. Lot of people think it is nice :) The stickers are kind of annoying, but they look pretty good by me...

[@Samuel-ex8xp]

I prefer the look of the brick built cockpit on the 2001 version

[@gamerboyofficalyt]

Same I like the clear Windows on the 2009 model vary nice

[@matthewsmith5169]

Yes

[@oskarLaiho]

Same i like it more

[@assassingoose3984]

Personally i dont cuz imo it doesn't look as good as the newer ones (again my opinion) but its still cool and i mostly prefer lego for playing cuz im 14 soooo ye

[@cletusclucker]

Really hate the sticker for the cockpit instead of a printed piece on the 2019 model

[@gavincampbell9576]

Cletus Clucker 2019 has a sticker on cockpit

[@tmaacattack]

Gavin Campbell he’s saying it sucks that its a sticker and not printed

[@aceofmangos3509]

At least the sticker isn’t on both sides..

[@misterjerofficial]

Bruh, the stickers aren’t that bad

[@inarb]

@@misterjerofficial they aren't, but printed would be nicer and show that Lego cared more.

[@a25luxray37]

The 2001 version is definitely dated, but I think its retro look adds to the charm. That brick built cockpit just looks so sweet.

[@Mutilise]

I miss the early 2000s era of sets.

[@griizzlerhops633]

When the figures were straight up yellow

[@leonlawson2196]

griizzlerhops good times.

[@Siltarie]

@@griizzlerhops633 my 99 Darth Maul wasn't yellow 🤣

[@darkwarriors...]

The times where big sets where cheap, than today where a small is 40 pounds (in UK)

[@pringleaddict5827]

@@darkwarriors... inflation brother

[@bigmocollectibles1995]

Nothing beats the original UCS set. Playability isn't really an option at my age. Really disappointed Lego didn't rerelease the 2001 set this year, big mistake. Great if you own the original though.

[@sebastianw614]

I agree completely, the UCS sets are made to be models. These are marketed towards an older demographic of teens and adults, which I fit into. I don’t care about playability and just want something that looks impressive for a good price

[@falconsite]

“Swooshability...Shwooshable” MandRproductions - 2019

[@Furno-hm8yp]

everyone says that tho...... Its a LEGO term

[@SubduedRadical]

I mean...everyone instantly knows what he means, though. We've all swooshed our toy planes/space ships. : )

[@usernate5995]

@koot that dosent work

[@martymcflyy6775]

@koot r/ihavereddit

[@ffjreviews9029]

I wish that the tantive 4 could’ve had playability where u can recreate the battle between the rebels and the empire.

[@ryanleadbitter7749]

Yeah they should’ve made the hallway instead of the office area

[@gamerboyofficalyt]

And they should have included 3 more of the tantive 4 guards instead of ONE

[@kimjongun1348]

gamer boy 12237 gamer boy 12237 You wouldn’t have enough room in the ship for that.

[@ffjreviews9029]

Kim Jong Un the office area has enough room

[@alexziolkowski6858]

The ‘09 set was the first “big” Lego set I was gifted, and I still have it. I love that it is big enough to display and still “swooshble”. For a big ‘09 set the Tantive IV provided an impressive amount of mini figures and detail.

[@kingofmee1]

The gaps in the engines of the new model are actually more accurate to the in universe design of the Tantive IV

[@miles4618]

I love the 2009 because I love older sets especially with old outdated prints on figs! I just have the nostalgia for the old figs and sets!

[@ryanaegis3544]

So many of the new faces look so bad. I love having two faces on each head, but quantity doesn't beat quality. Leia here is a great example: I would rather have the lips than that horrible smirk.

[@Flusherrug]

This is getting out of hand now their are three wait three?

[@davieturner339]

The 2001 kit is fantastic, especially considering the age of the design, it has a few scale issues but it still looks great and was incredibly well designed for the time. Overall I’d probably pick the most recent one (need to see it in the bricks), but I still think the 2001 version is great in the history of Lego Star Wars kits.

[@razorfett147]

The 01 set seems to be proportioned more like the CR70 featured in Ep 3...which is shorter and stubbier than the CR90 ( the actual Tantive IV)

[@luccamessana7680]

@@razorfett147yea, like the engine seem super disproportional to the rest of the build. And that’s just like the cr70

[@forthememes2426]

The 2019 one is acurate with the holes in the engine compered to the movies

[@markgreenough8602]

The dimensions on the 2019 version are the most accurate by far. I just wish they’d made it UCS; including a proper stand and plaque and printed elements on the cockpit.

[@AtwoicAnimations]

This is sickkkkk i wish i had *ONE* of them!

[@Mahan_]

The Brick Group well I was going to give you 2 but now you are getting 1 jk

[@dgdxv3607]

Mahan you madlad

[@saviour1754]

@@Mahan_ r/madlads

[@saviour1754]

@Callum Crawford I was making a joke Mr. IhateReddit

[@hatsunemiku8007]

@@saviour1754 do not speak any further

[@liamf7295]

Why was there a little car in the 2009 model? I dont remember seeing it in any movies

[@Jakethesnake831]

The quality of the 2001 model surprises me, especially for the year.

[@lbricks7631]

A classic mandr comparison.

[@starwarsroo2448]

Still needs a corridor scene where loads of rebels get killed an Vader gets a stranglehold of the situation

[@Avghistorian77]

Yeah, would it really have been too much to include a darth vader, and even just one stormtrooper in this set?

[@saviour1754]

@@Avghistorian77 this is just meant for using it in space wars

[@starwarsroo2448]

@@bogdanasaurus you know what I meant, in the first Star Wars

[@OrphanedZombie]

I like the hallway design of the Tantive IV. I wish that was there

[@Tuckerscreator]

I think the one thing the 2009 model has over all the others is the use of printed transparent pieces for the cockpit. Making the "cones" transparent but printing over them so that the front visor is see-through is really clever in my opinion. You can look in and the minifigures can look out.

[@Wi-Fi-El]

Im actually getting a UCS tantive iv soon. I already have one from when I was a kid, but I'm going to add rooms and play features to my new one because I hate when the huge Lego sets have no interior

[@eewag1]

I’m suprised that the 2009 one (which I voted for) only got 9% of the vote.

[@stepanzatloukal3381]

Well, the 2019 has better minifigures, better design, the handle, it’s bigger and overall better

[@augsdoggs]

I knew I’d find this set comparison video on your channel! Big help in making the distinction when I see them listed on eBay!

[@meh837-_]

I'm asking the 2019 tantive iv for Christmas

[@allanwielund9545]

I bought the 2019 as a Christmas Present for myself, but I´m not building it until easter (because I also got the new Falcon). Just having the set in the box feels nice :o)

[@timgo5829]

I’ve always thought stud shooters and flick fire missiles are stupid, I hate them. It’s just not how LEGO is meant. It is much more fun to use your imagination but nowadays that doesn’t seam to be something kids have though (maybe because of stuff like this). If I would have a lego pirate ship battle I would never shoot studs or what ever with the “playable friendly” canons. I would imagine it was shooting as I destroyed the other ship, a stud shooter can’t do that, it doesn’t do anything.

[@CMDRturner]

I want the playability the swoosh ability on the 2019 one on the UCS one

[@alexboyajian2096]

I'm so glad we finally got a bail organa figure. He is literally on of the creators of the rebellion

[@speakingofman5062]

“Swoosh”- MandRproductions 2019 either way still love you Dude

[@verybigman2270]

"its swooshability is like a 2 out of 10" MandRproductions 2019

[@stryder1174]

Honestly the UCS looks like wasted potential it is so big you could have more mini figure stuff and imagine it with micro figures because it might make a accurate interior and micro figures are revolution for making big ships

[@michaelbauers8800]

I don't have an opinion of which is best, but I think mine is the 2009 model, 10198. Because I own it already :) And I loved building and displaying it.

[@markjoe6423]

Hey Ryan, I know it's an older review and you might not see this comment but wondering if you are able to do a comparison of the all of these plus the new 2024 tantive coming out!

[@TeenageMutantZuckerTurtle]

The 2009 one might be the smallest, but that was my pride and joy as a kid, it was one of the biggest and most detailed sets I had

[@Andrew-el8xi]

The first one love how the front has clear plastic window with nice flip open front to me as a kid back in the day I like propper windows rather than naff stickers

[@glitchii_uwu]

i got my 2009 model for $25 at a yard sale, unopened box. I didn't actually open it until 6 years later.

[@primeghost111]

Same thing happened to me at a yard sale. Got like 4 unopened sets all for 30 bucks. At first I thought they were knock offs because the boxes looked weird but then after doing some research it turned out they were legit

[@brodytorrice5504]

I used to love the 2009 and I still do but now that you put the 2019 model next to it. I will never look at it the same 😞. Lol

[@conradklose4545]

The reason Lego made the 2019 tantive with a stickered cockpit is because the 2009 one was transparent and gave it a lighter look which was not consistent with the other parts of the cockpit. Also I've realized to solve this problem Lego could've printed over the white cockpit. Anyway, great video sorry for the long comment.

[@bricktrooperstudios]

I missed these comparisons, so glad you brought them back! 😃👍

[@leoseguin5761]

We need Swooshablility as it's own section

[@EdgeofBricks]

Probably 2019 is the best but still have a lot of ugly stickers :D I want printed parts in this price!!!

[@LiquidSnake6954]

Give it another 10 years, stickers are slowly fading away

[@TheCubixPL]

And more minifigs for this price would be welcome like at least one more rebel fleet trooper

[@letgosmego8984]

You forgot about no windows, stickers for windows on a $200 set?

[@putitawo74]

@@LiquidSnake6954 I don't know; this last year or two the number of stickers in sets I've gotten seems to be increasing.

[@CraftsmanOfAwsomenes]

I prefer stickers over printing when it comes to clear parts. The coloration on printed clear parts always looks garbage.

[@scottjordan1662]

The UCS and the 2019 are roughly the same length, but the UCS is “bulkier” thus making it look a bit stubby and Ive always thought the engines were way out of scale for the model compared to the movie model.

[@jmp_fr]

2001 has a better build, 2019 has a better minifig selection and playabilty. But I like having a better build more than playability.

[@jcw4969]

There is a 18 year difference between design, with new pieces over the years. 2019 has a better build imo.

[@jmp_fr]

@@jcw4969 you have an extremely valid point. In fact I kind of agree with you, because if the 2019 aet was bigger it would be almost perfect

[@jcw4969]

@@jmp_fr Yeah, I love the 2001 model, but it's too squished together.

[@griizzlerhops633]

@@jmp_fr I guess Lego just intended to make the tantive IV a normal playset. If it was UCS then it would EASILY take the cake with the much more slick design and playability. But I'm keeping my Hope's up for the New star destriyer... if I can even afford it

[@jmp_fr]

@@griizzlerhops633 i'm so broke lol

[@icy5982]

Seeing these videos and having the Lego makes me feel so much better

[@gof5017]

Lego: “They aren’t escape pods.” Also lego: proceeds to make them escape pods in 2 sets

[@A_couple_of_cakepies]

Haha

[@acronix2805]

Give the original captin antillies a purple ligthsaber NOW

[@LegoMotionandMore]

Awesome comparison! You have an awesome collection!

[@christianbommersholdt3099]

Wow, there basically is nothing else wich can make me nostalgic in the same way as seeing old lego sets, that I used to look at at in the stores. And now i have just bought the new 2019 Tantive IV and feel like my inner 10 year old would approve so much :D

[@bobross8424]

I would love to have the 2009 version. Always wanted it never got it. Same with the Clone Wars Venator Class Star Destroyer set from the same year.

[@NovacaineRebelxx]

The 2019 one does it for me. I think it’s reasonably priced, has a pretty good piece count and it has really great updated mini figures. Also with the inclusion of Bail Organa added in, that makes the 2019 version that much better than the other two. Plus I like the size accuracy more with the 2019 version. Yes the 2001 one is massive and looks great for its time, but a LEGO Tantive iv shouldn’t be any bigger than a Star Destroyer. The upcoming UCS Imperial Star Destroyer (I’m 90% sure LEGO is gonna remake it, considering the Tantive iv rumor became true) is gonna be massive (it’s supposedly gonna have over 4,500 pieces). The 2019 Tantive iv will look really great size accuracy wise when stacked up next to the UCS Star Destroyer.

[@13thmistral]

i honestly think the older play model has a more interesting interior because it is kinda messy, buuut i agree overall i'd like to own the new model the most as for the ucs model, it aged really well, but i just do not care for it in such a state.

[@grimtemple]

UCS is still the best one. Notice yours has a bunch of replacement parts tho

[@leanmeangreenbeanmachine3347]

grimtemp25 you better hush, or I will crush

[@grimtemple]

Lean Mean Green Bean Machine ?

[@sturmwind1180]

I think it is the fake Lepin version. The elastic bands are the wrong colour and there is no sticker on the radar dish.

[@YKplaysMC]

I doubt it's even real. I have a real one and some parts on his look different

[@JohnBanana]

Sturmwind You can see the LEGO stamp on the pieces when he shows close ups.. Obviously not lepin. I bet this guy bought replacements off bricklink or he bought it incomplete and had to get pieces to finish it, and were slightly different.

[@merafirewing6591]

Please give some hints of how to get all three of them.

[@MythicBricks]

The alt face print for the OG Antilles is still my favorite

[@ryonolson2654]

Thanks for the video. I've been considering whether to buy the 2019 version, and I'm sold. I'm glad that the proportions are finally correct. That was the one things that stopped me from buying the previous two releases (although the UCS one is a fantastic model in its own right).

[@razorfett147]

The 2001 has the proportions of the CR70 Corvette which is featured in Ep 3. The 2019 has the proportions more fitting to a CR90, which is what the Tantive IV actually was. It would be really cool to see someone convert the '01 model into the CR70 from the film by swapping the red trim pcs to blue

[@jamesohara2410]

2019’s model is definitely the best, I need that set...

[@obi-wankenobi1916]

I used to like it but now that there’s something new and shiny I just can’t look at it the same way anymore. This is a quote that describes why I now like MCU more than starwars

[@LotlLabs]

I love the 2001 set because of how it is made with more of the basic lego pieces and not the special lego pieces only for it. I just feel like it seems more L E G O

[@mr.sir3193]

2019 Tantive Vl I saved my money for it. Worth it.

[@JBCrafted]

Better be, I didn't even realize there was a 6th model 🤣

[@redjfulfer5577]

The 2019 model is a surprisingly decent remake of a classic LEGO Star Wars model... well done LEGO.

[@andrewkatz5689]

I've known for years that the 2001 Rebel Blockade Runner (10019) had an oversized cockpit. Seeing them next to each other really brings that out. In terms of overall look, the 2918 version just outdoes the 2001 version for me as well due to accuracy.

[@jacoblyman9441]

The old (2009) one would be nice to modify with blue coloring to make it into the Tantive III/Sundered Heart from Revenge of the Sith.

[@chrissyoutubechannel8679]

What I want to no is why are the older Lego models bigger than the new one shouldn’t the new ones be bigger

[@alanyale4611]

I like the 2019 the best as it looks really good, and has great Minifig selection and playability.

[@kostastzafi9691]

2009 JUST BECAUSE IT HAS MORE FUN FEATURES(LIKE THE CART)

[@scarletspdstr_]

KOSTAS TZAFI Wow. A cart. So amazing

[@lordcolsonthomas9412]

@@scarletspdstr_ yea, a cart, if you wanna get mad at someone liking a tiny lego cart, maybe you should reevaluate some of your life choices

[@SiOConnor]

Great video Ryan, I loved seeing them all together 😀

[@pacmanosaurus1971]

Can we all agree, that LEGO should just make a 20$ tantive IV hallway set?

[@hk_4014]

The 2001 version looks like the ship from Spaceballs compared to the others

[@Jojojoeyx3]

The UCS one looks greatest obviously but the modern one is my favorite

[@Jdi1945]

I love the senna and the competizione on the shelf in the background

[@zestylamb]

“Swooshability” -MandRproductions 2019

[@usernate5995]

People just dont get it. It's a lego term!!

[@breizhrudie4757]

I don't like the new Lego trend with the springloaded stuff, to me 2019 doesn't worth the 2009 one due to the waste of space with those springloaded missiles and all.

[@miles4618]

9:25 on the right Just2good?

[@Elizabeth-fm1kh]

?

[@VaderBrix]

Everyone knows that the *ORIGINALS* rock!

[@pantelisdalezios1086]

Nope. The newer ones have better details amd improvements and everything.

[@VaderBrix]

That’s Because There Weren’t So Many Specialized Pieces That They Are Now To Look Better! The Old One Was The Best Set Out Of The 3! It Was WAY Ahead Of It’s Time! The Newer One Could Have Been Better By Loads Of Newer Pieces But The Designer Didnt Accomplish It’s Top Priority For The Ship’s Interior Unlike The Old One Which Was AGAIN Way Ahead Of It’s Time For Basically Every Feature The Ship Should Include As Per The Technology Of 2001!

[@pantelisdalezios1086]

Ok but still you cant tell the old one better. The new one's specialised pieces and stuff make it look way more beautiful than the old one.

[@griizzlerhops633]

@@VaderBrixmind you that the 2019 wasnt intended to be A UCS set, just a normal playset so of course the older 2001 version would have much more details than the 2019 one lol.

[@VaderBrix]

griizzlerhops I Respect All Your Opinions, Guys! Mine Was Shared As A Comment!

[@andrein_501st]

The newest is my favorite.

[@A_couple_of_cakepies]

2001 is big and realistic on the exterior, 2009 has the best mini figs and 2019 is small but kinda sick

[@christianweber7435]

When you do the design section, you should include movie accuracy

[@Tsurnari]

A new UCS version might be on the books as they are about re-release the UCS Star Destroyer.

[@No773.6]

Could you make a video where you update the new tantive iv like the inside For example improving the cockpit area

[@Evan15]

That first one is massive and I really wish the new one was that big.

[@callmecassian6952]

The 2009 I have very fond memories of it, as it was a great bonding experience with my dad and uncle, and was one of my first LEGO sets, and while I am very sad that it didn’t win, I respect your choice, as the winner was a great pick!

[@lordquackers5764]

Gotta love that 2009 bridge design

[@fractalelf7760]

Just bought the 2019 on EBay, excited to build it and add it to the stable!

[@youtubegamer2369]

Drink a cup of root beer every time he says swoosh

[@miles4618]

@mandrproductions could you add a display category for if you just want to have it displayed on a shelf rather than like play with the set? This may fall into the design category but I don’t know.

[@guyomeprime]

How did you get your hands on he 2019 one 2 weeks before its release?.

[@lmd499]

guyomeprime Star Wars celebration

[@erikjan15585]

9:59 in the actual cr90 model, there are gaps there, so it's pretty accurate

[@skefsongames]

2001 brickbuilt looks so much better than the other two

[@dooziexx123]

I like the see thru cockpit of the 2009 set. wish the 2019 maintained that instead of stickers.

[@asator0505]

while it does look better than stickers, it makes the white look kinda off. transparent parts with white printed on is nothing that lego is particularly good at. or recent minifig prints-...look at the 20th anniversary luke in his pilot suit. the grey print is kinda pink

[@mightylotan]

Biggest downside to 2019 build is lack of transparent front windows

[@creativebricks9418]

Ryan u should do the value based on what u would have to pay now so that people can judge which one they want to buy

[@t65bx25]

9:56 is supposed to be like that, the other two are inaccurate.

[@Dodge_this]

I've never had a problem with Ryan but seriously look at the old one it's just better: it's more accurate, it's smoother and bigger but don't forget the biggest thing it was made by old technology and the last thing Is just simple nostalgia

[@frankegordon326]

Yeah but taking into account nostalgia is kinda dumb

[@Romans8-9]

@@frankegordon326 I agree about nostalgia but everything else he said is right. I think playability is overrated. I mean who other than 12 year olds are playing with lego sets? 2ndly, minifigures are overrated too. The most important part of these big space ship sets is how they look on display and for me the 2001 is the best. The 2019 while maybe having more detail looks too narrow. Wish he had shown the backs of the engines too because that is such an iconic shot from the movie and probably the most recognisable part of the ship.