Lessons We Learnt From Ehd e Wafa & Alif | Weekend in Review | Something Haute

[@mariammm3329]

In my opinion, infact Dada jee is the pillar of Alif. He is the one who change qalb e momin life to a better person.

[@sumayrak5652]

Mariam MM Absolutely!

[@usrahussain133]

So true!!! And Husn e Jahan herself wanted a refuge and to get remarried. Dada just suggested her... And she wanted to get remarried too as living with Dada ji would expose her truth that she didn't die 😤 Amna ruined the finale's interpretation so bad 🤐

[@hiraimran2848]

He ruined momin’s life at first. He should’ve at least told Momin the truth about his mother so he didn’t hate her for his entire life.

[@ShahwarAKhan]

Hi I'd like to answer Hassan's question about Momina saying "Tumhein taufeeq mil gai hai tou tum jao, mera safar abhi baki hai". I dont think so it is about Momina wanting to continue acting rather it is the safar of finding the purpose of life and finding Allah. To me what she really meant was that Momin has been blessed because he found his true calling and his purpose of life but she still has to figure out. The reason why I think so disagreeing with Amna's opinion is because Momina NEVER really wanted to act in the first place. She did so because she had to arrange for the money for Jahangir's Treatment and later she did to repay the debt she had on her. Also I don't think so that Master Ibrahim knew she was husnejahan because he had been in Italy all his life so how could he possibly know some actress of Pakistan and that too when her fame had died down anyway. When he says "mujhe Abdulalla ne ye nahi bataya k aap itni haseen hain, aap tou husnejahaan hain, he said that metaphorically". And about Dada not trying to change Momin's opinion of his mother, he did try. You guys can rewatch initial episodes, he tries to tell Momin k tmhari maa ki koi ghalti nahi thi koi qusur nahi tha"

[@hebazuberi5145]

I love how you have summed up momin and mominas scene What you have said was actually the true essesnce of that scene not what they were trying to discuss in the review

[@user-io1cu3zl4g]

True!! And I think Dada never knew why Momin actually hates husn e jahan... Momin mever told Dada abt Sultan and what her mother used to do in Pakistan when they went back... so as he never told Dada is liay Dada ny koi clarification nai di... but he always used to say k tumhari maa aik achi aurat thi..

[@fouziakhan9324]

Why husne Jahan doesn't live with momin in turkey?

[@ShahwarAKhan]

@@fouziakhan9324 because Momin hates her. He doesn't even see her face when she brings him gifts.

[@shaheeradil9567]

Nicely put

[@asmafarooqi3251]

Master Ibrahim was basically complimenting her by calling her Husne jahan (The beauty of the world)

[@maryamrumesa5677]

I disagree with amna's interpretation of Dada's character, she thinks of dada as a very dark character but he's not, he has made one mistake of opposing taha's marriage to husne jahan, that was also because he had this common stereotype of an actress character and that she'll mislead taha from religious path, later dada also decides to forgive taha but taha dies by then, he married husne jahan to master Ibrahim because he wanted both of them to find peace and love in each other, he did it with a right intention, and he didn't tell momin the reason for his parents separation because then momin will blame himself for that but he said to momin that his mother was very good women.

[@usrahussain133]

Husn e Jahan herself wanted a refuge and to get remarried. Dada just suggested her... And she wanted to get remarried too as living with Dada ji would expose her truth that she didn't die 😤 Amna ruined the finale's interpretation so bad 🤐

[@reviewkicycle]

Dada ji ko maaf karne main 8 years lag ge jo Har waqt Allah Pak ka name se mohaabbat karte hon wo itna time laga de maaf karne main kya baat hai wo rohaniyat dekh kar attract Hoi thi taha ko dekh kar lekin dada ne kabi larki se baat ni karna chahi humans se hate ni karni chaye os k profession se karte jo wo chor chuki thi dada ka fault hai es main

[@deeptimohla8672]

What touched me the most in the last scene between Momin and Momina is when she tells him " hum phir milenge....sahi aur galat ki hadh se parey..." what a beautiful expression of longing.

[@parudahal6314]

This line was taken from the work of the poet Rumi," Somewhere beyond right and wrong there is a garden, I will meet you there."

[@FatimaKhan-oo7nu]

In the movie rockstar this line is portrayed

[@ayesharaza7287]

and his reply was befitting...why does it have to be in another world..why cant this world be where there is no right no wrong and no judgement i liked Momins reply i can resonate with this

[@attitudebyatty]

Dada jee said ‘ God forgives, we humans dont’ That’s the reason he was how he was.

[@zufeshanansari7205]

Ye same dialogue yakeen ka safar mei bhi tha na🤔

[@attitudebyatty]

Zufeshan Ansari yes 😊

[@lamhe.]

Amna and Hassan, I didn't want to say this but I'm honestly VERY disappointed with this review! "Abdul Aala ki jagah sirf Momin hi le sakta hai" because he's his ONLY grandchild. There's nothing about men in this. Momina didn't go with Momin because as two DIFFERENT individuals, she has her OWN path and Momin has his OWN path. She wasn't ready at that moment because she hadn't completed her journey yet! The "journey of finding Alif"! And there's nothing wrong with Momin leaving the industry to start calligraphy, I mean we should atleast respect his choice. And Dada accepted his mistakes...and that's all that matters at the end!

[@ik1997]

Yes... I've always been disappointed with their reviews of Alif

[@SauteStylesUK]

I absolutely agreed with you, even i couldn't bear her misinterpretation, i left watching,

[@sumayrak5652]

Sana Kausar Agreed

[@usrahussain133]

Husn e Jahan herself wanted a refuge and to get remarried. Dada just suggested her... And she wanted to get remarried too as living with Dada ji would expose her truth that she didn't die 😤 Amna ruined the finale's interpretation so bad 🤐

[@usrahussain133]

Had hai waise biased review kerne ka bhi... I'm seriously pissed off at them....

[@strikingassignment3870]

Honestly I always loved your reviews for your deep analysis of dramas but I am EXTREMELY disappointed with your 2day's reviewof alif it was so shallow and superficial.. wasnt expecting this from u guyz!☹🙁😒

[@SauteStylesUK]

Same here so disappointed

[@samanmasood6404]

Did not expect this from Amna. Very weak interpretation of such a strong message. She made it all about misogyny and men while ignoring the depth of the message and key takeaways.

[@kashaffatimah3859]

Alif was complete as dada said Allah ki mohabbat k illawa hr mohabbat ko.zawal hai so alif potrayed it very well..

[@fatiman18]

Aamna is totally wrong today . Didnt like her review on alif. Dada jaan ka perspective towards husne jehan buhut baad mein change hua .

[@ashas82]

I don’t agree with dada being the villain. It’s more right to say that a pious person is also just a human being.

[@aliyabawany2444]

She said that he was flawed, a human.

[@wardaaman9607]

I don't agree about Amina 's view about dada, she made his character very dark, she forget all the teachings he did to momin, the Quran ayah, and DADA ALSO ASK MOMIN NOT TO THINK OF HIS MOTHER AS A BAD WOMEN several times

[@user-io1cu3zl4g]

True! I think Amna forgot abt those scenes... Dada told Momin that husn e jahan was a good woman... Also I think clarification is k elawa is liay nai hoi kyn k Momin ny kabhi dada ko nai bataya k why he hate his mother, he hides sultan part and how his mother dances in Pakistan to earn... etc...ye sari cheezain sirf momin ko pata thien aur us basis pe he used to hate his mother......! Jab k dada dusri side pe apny ap ko taha aur husn e jahan ka kasoorwar samjhty thy is liay he always praised husn e jahan and didnt realise k Momin kis wja se nafrat karta hai apni Maa se

[@syrafayyaz1154]

Yes but at the same time Dada never tells Momin all his life that his mother married a poor man. You are forgetting that Momin felt all his life that the reason his mother left him was because she found a richer man. Husn e Jahan only asked Dada to not tell the reason for the fight between her and Taha and not tell of why she wanted to sell the paintings. Dada couldve still told Momin his stepfather was not rich.

[@user-io1cu3zl4g]

@@syrafayyaz1154 Dada didnt tell because I think Momin ny kabhi Dada se ye openly discuss nai kia... He used to ask why Taha left husn e jahan aur un k darmiyan kis baat pe larai hoi etc...but he never told dada k us ko aur apni maa k baray mai kia ghalat fehmian thien... is wja se dada ny us k issues address nai kiay... that is just my personal observation...might be wrong... I felt k dada aur momin mai husn e jahan ko lay kar aik communication gap tha jo k dono ny fill nai kia...aur misunderstandings jo momin ko thien wo clear nai ho sakien

[@zamzamanas3714]

I agree

[@hiraimran2848]

Yes but he should have EXPLAINED why he should not hate his mother! What’s the point of telling him don’t hate ur mom without clearing up the misconceptions he has about her?

[@Ankitajp123]

I loved the drama ALIF , such a great writing and portrayal of the story and of course Sajal Aly , I love this girl ❣️💕

[@msmehmood]

Husn e jahan didn’t want momin to blame himself ,thats y truth was never told to him.thats what i get from different conversations (in bits n pieces )throughout the previous few episodes

[@sannaqamar7420]

Do not agree with Amina's interpretation of Dada's character at all, he says himself a few episodes in that he made a mistake with his behaviour and Taha. I think Hassan understood the drama better.

[@estyak8780]

Correct, she is not taking everything into account. The last episode is the culmination of all the events before.

[@asmamuhemmed4316]

Agreed

[@usrahussain133]

Sanna Qamar Husn e Jahan herself wanted a refuge and to get remarried. Dada just suggested her... And she wanted to get remarried too as living with Dada ji would expose her truth that she didn't die 😤 Amna ruined the finale's interpretation so bad 🤐

[@hiraimran2848]

Usra Hussain thanks we’ve read the same comment at least 10 times now :)

[@parizaabbasi6292]

Amna you misinterpreted Alif’s whole ending seriously.

[@fareehamunir7744]

After watching their review of Alif, I think both of them literally ruined the purpose and above all the after effect of the play. The main lesson of this story was not to judge someone's character on the basis of mere assumptions. Master Ibrahim's last conversation with momina clears this out. But thanks to you guys jinho NE fazool criticism start kardiya. It proves that Alif is indeed a masterpiece and it's not for everyone to get the true essence of it.

[@somithestoryteller1151]

So tru.i agree

[@MuhammadHassan-ih5yw]

Yes alif is not for everyone

[@sanashahbaz1564]

fareeha munir so true

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

People in aggressive mood today.😊

[@nhum1962]

Totally agreed!

[@Sam-jm6yt]

Amna is being unnecessarily harsh towards dada jan! The reason he couldn’t let husnae jahan stay with him & momin was because her mum ( husnae jahan ‘s) would have found here there! She knew her susral was in Turkey and she was supposed to be dead and if someone saw her there , she would have been exposed! Yes dada was at fault initially but he tried his best to do the right thing by husnae jahan later on in his life! Amna has got the total wrong end of the stick! 😏 Also master ibrahim didn’t know she was husnae jahan, until he saw the paintings brought by Momina! When Momina told him she was a famous actress!

[@zainabzaman55]

I am surprised at how they both have not even watched drama alif carefully and dont know like half of the events and reviewing just to disappoint fans

[@usrahussain133]

So true. Husn e Jahan mentioned that she can't live with dada because he's also a famous person and her truth to be alive would be found out by the landlord who wanted to marry her. Unreasonable hatred towards Dada jaan doesn't make you a great feminist... I'm so disappointed in this review honestly

[@hebazuberi5145]

After hearing alif's review the only thing I'd like to suggest is either you rewatch the drama or read the novel

[@hunzlashabbir3238]

Master Ibrahim didn't know about husn e jahan. He said to her," ap sirf husna nahi husn e jahan b hein" And momin asked the reason about the separation of his parents he asked what was his mother's mistake. Dada didn't want to tell momin that his parents got separated because of him.

[@nadarq]

ok I'm sorry but thats so silly. The parents did not separate because of him. They separated because their love story and trust in each other failed. Warna toh any poor couple who has a child with basic needs should split up and say it was because of the child.

[@raniaashar4748]

I cried for alif! I couldnt control my tears honestly, i NEVER cry for movies/dramas. I didnt cry for ehd e wafa even though i loved it soooo much. Ehd e wafa and alif have ended.....what am i supposed to do with my life now!😭😭😭

[@adeensyed]

Alas Aamina didn't understand character of ABDUL AALA ..

[@statesman01]

On the contrary, Alif shows that if a person who claims to be a man of God has an ego, he can do more harm in the name of religion/spirituality than a woman of the street who does not claim to know God but is a good human being. He kept the truth from his grandson for which he does not deserve to be forgiven. There was nothing aala about him.

[@user-pf3vz3rd9h]

What's not to understand? That he wasn't egoistic? He deliberately let Momin hate his mother? He kept the truth from him even after she got married? What is the justification of all that?m

[@adeensyed]

I agree. He is not an angel but not THE VILLAIN .All characters of Alif are grey ..

[@user-pf3vz3rd9h]

@@adeensyed he is the main culprit of ruining the life of his son(by not forgiving him till he died), his daughter in law(by not accepting her and letting momin judge her) and his grandson(by keeping him away from the only parent he had and growing up with emotional issues and with weak faith). A lot of people like me who haven't read the novel blame him for the misery in these 3 people's lives because that's the only perspective we have of him.

[@estyak8780]

Amna ji, sorry to say but i think you were unable to understand Abdul Ala's character.

[@amnaiqbal6420]

Alif was outstanding! It was sound, peaceful and full of emotions. It was not a drama it was a journey.. Ehd e wafa's last episode was rollercoaster of emotions. I absolutely loved it ❤️ The casting of this show was so on point and the chemistry SSG boys shared seems so real. SSG will be missed.. My weekends will never be the same again 😔

[@zuha514fatima]

Hassan's rant regarding Saad and Dua was the cutest and most realistic thing in the entire video.😂❤

[@nadarq]

It really bothered me throughout the last two episodes that they completely erased the cute chemistry between Saad and Dua that they did such a good job of establishing throughout the drama. Very anticlimactic on that storyline

[@yourgirlmia627]

Amna has successfully and sadly become the educated, poised, elegant, and very polite version of Marvi Sermad.

[@azkasaqib2349]

Dada changed his opinion about husna jahan.momin would have not accepted husnajahah as he went to dada for same reason.dada wanted husna jahah to live a different life and be happy and live spiritually and master also wanted a woman like her that's why he married them both so they could learn from each other and in terms of momin he already had seen and visioned her mom as bad person and his dispart from God was not because of dada but because of the his wishes not becoming true for a long period of time.

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

Yes, probably dada did not want to influence momin the way he wanted his son to get influenced by him and as a result had seen his son's revolting behaviour. Maybe that is why he did not try to force him into calligraphy.

[@khansa1525]

Yes this is better understanding of the last episode and of Dada. Really disappointed to see amnah and her colleague not understanding this....

[@syedauroojtariq7185]

Really disappointed with amina’s review!

[@farzanasaqib8877]

I agree that dada had created some issues in the beginning. When Taha tells him he wants to marry husna jahan, dada got angry because of who she was and her background. Dada had judged her and was a bit arrogant. But later he realizes that good people who are close to Allah and love Him, can come from anywhere. Allah guides whomever He likes. Husna Jahan was actually a pious and God fearing lady.

[@ashas82]

No master ibrahim did not know that she is husne Johan. When Momina brings the pictures then he realises he was married to husnejahan

[@sariasiddiqui]

Yes master ibrahem ghunghat otha k Husna ko peyar ma boltey Hain k aap husna nhn Husan e jehan hain

[@user-io1cu3zl4g]

And see the expressions of master ibrahim when Momina brings husn e jahan pictures... expressions aisy change hoay aur aik different vibe ai when he got to know k his wife was husn e jahan...aik na pasandedgi bhi shaid us time... dont know how to explain but us scene mai master ibrahim k expressions were changing alot and were meaningful

[@belazia4572]

ashas82 you missed the scene when master ibrahim unveils her he says that you are husne jahan so he knew who she was

[@user-io1cu3zl4g]

@@belazia4572 Watch that scene again... he is complimenting her by calling her husn e jahan... wo jis andaaz mai boltay hain wo dekhain dobara... he says k ap husna nai husn e jahan hain yani he is trying to say k u r so beautiful....

[@shehwarshoaib7486]

Extremely disappointed with Amna’s review... don’t know whats wrong with her today ,,, she didn’t understand the whole novel and seriously very bad review from Amna

[@FA-re9yh]

Shehwar Shoaib exactly she didn’t seem to get it at all

[@Rabeckham2]

I think she is reviewing the drama, not the novel here. Many things that might have been clarified in the novel were not shown in the drama

[@usrahussain133]

She ruined the finale so bad! 😤

[@user-io1cu3zl4g]

Actually Dada changed his views abt Husn e Jahan much later and like Master ibrahim said k hum logo ko judge krty hain aur ye sochtay hain k hum badal saktay hain to dusra nai badal sakta kia? Dada realised this too but very late. And Master Ibrahim also agar unhain pata hota husn e jahan ka to wo judge e krty rehtay sari zindagi...is liay Dada didnt tell... ye hamary society ka issue hai k insaan dusray banday ko bohat judge karta hai without spending time with the other person

[@Littlenestofmine]

Well said

[@fouziakhan9324]

Why didn't dada let husne Jahan stay with her son?

[@user-io1cu3zl4g]

@@fouziakhan9324 because momin hated his mother. And secondly husn e jahan deserved to live a happy married life too... And dada was already old so he wanted to secure Husn e jahan's future too..

[@user-io1cu3zl4g]

@@sab-ali by later I meant after Taha's death.... aur bachy se dur krny k reasons samjh atay hain...1) he wanted to give a happy married life to husn e jahan which she really deserved 2) he was already old. So he wanted to secure and protect her 3) momin wasnt ready to accept her mother

[@Yumna_Bilal]

If you remember dada jaan said that calligraphy was their profession for last 10 generations. And when taha started painting husn e jahan, that was the thing that dada was concerned that this great work will gonna end from their family. It was not the matter of pasand ki shadi it was the fear of ending calligraphy from dada's family.

[@kukuali]

Alif wasn’t everyone’s cup of tea..... still some questions unanswered....they should have made it more clear.... Hamza n Sajal nailed it and made it all worth watching! Will going to miss them both...☹️🥺

[@madhusharma-kk7qe]

Both these serials have raised the bar so much that it will be difficult to appreciate forthcoming dramas. The current ones are nothing to write home about. Hope something comes up to fill the void

[@nimrahkhan9105]

I found that drama is boring.

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

Nimrah Khan please don’t say that , people will take you as being blasphemous.🤪 Haven’t you read the way people are slamming Amna for disrespecting dada ji.😂calling her a misandrist .

[@kukuali]

Mahnoor Qureshi good thing I don’t read comments 🤪😅

[@nimrahkhan9105]

@@mahnoorqureshi3281 who is amna?

[@MuhammadIbrahim-cf1yr]

Amna, I think that u are being too judgemental regarding Abdul Alla's character and Master Ibrahim. He just wanted Husne Jahan to live in happiness like everyone else, so he married her off to Ibrahim. In addition, it was probably not safe for HeJ to live with Momin and Abdul Alla (+Momin refused that) with the fear that somebody might find the truth about her death ( Abdul Alla was a famous calligrapher!). Therefore, the marriage had become a necessity.

[@hafsajalali921]

Amnaa should interview Umera Ahmed to get her points cleared, MUCH NEEDED !

[@asiyamuqaddas3795]

Alif is the drama I'd love to watch all over again in a year's time

[@AudioNovelLovers]

Now

[@Farah-sh4fr]

Was looking forward to this review so badly. Now I wish so badly that you guys did it next week and saw the episode seriously and gave an honest review. This was not a review in any way like the one that you yourself have set the bar for

[@nhum1962]

The way amina is doing Alif’s review is purely feminist .. looks like she is doing this all intentionally..

[@sm743]

Can we not judge Momin's decision to go off to Turkey in the end and assume he did 'ghaate ka sauda'. I'm sure the drama has taught us to be better than that.

[@estyak8780]

Didn't they watched the final episode? Momin clearly says he has found peace after a long time and doesn't want to lose it that's why he is going to do whatever gives him peace. So him going to Turkey is a decision of a person with clear mindset. These people can't even appreciate something that good.

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

@@estyak8780 People in an aggressive mood today. Being too harsh on Amna.😊 Actually the ones who had read the novel have a better understanding of the characters. But still, Dada did admit he made a mistake with his son and his wife and I feel he should have made effort to change momin's perception about his mom. He could have atleast told him that he got her married again.

[@TINTIN-123]

I agree S M

[@manihazehra]

I think she says “mera safar abhi khatam nahin hua“ in the context that she still has a lot to learn in her relationship with God whereas Hamza’s journey is good. Idk maybe. And tofeeq logon ko sikhanay ki nahin Mili abhi idk

[@anamsadaqat4170]

Amina Jab Momin ny kaha k Dada ki jagah sirf momin lay sakta hai Iska mtlb tha k *dada k khandan ka Akhiri banda momin hai jo k unki family famous hai calligraphy k liye*

[@hamnahsaqib2147]

She does come back to live with them and plans to raise Momin but Momin refuses to see her and calls her a bad woman so she tells Dada to send her away somewhere and he marries her to Master Ibrahim. There was a scene earlier when Momin is in his room and Dada comes to tell him that his mother is here to see him but he refuses and then locks the door when her leaves but he starts crying when he sees her leaving from his window.

[@NayyeraKhan]

It was many years after her marriage

[@izzaatif9799]

Its many yrs later, momin is teenager and husn e jahan is bit older

[@hamnahsaqib2147]

​@@izzaatif9799 you're thinking of the scene in the ost when he throws her gift at her, I'm talking about the scene with Pehlaj.

[@javeria7774]

Hassan you missed shahzain's response to the statement that army alone is enough to deal with the national security issues, he clarified that it is the politicians' job to raise the issue on national and international forums and unite the entire opposition for that particular cause just as we actually saw how PM Imran Khan raised the Kashmir issue internationally which was almost dormant. And strongly disagree with Amna's interpretation of Alif as being about men. It wasn't. Neither was dada's character as dark as she perceived him. I didn't find any misogyny in the entire novel. It feels like she has a very strong bias against men

[@teaisfantastic6340]

True true true, har. Jaga feminism

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

India did not have the courage to annexe Kashmir in 70 years. It did that easily during imran khan tenure, because he made Pakistan the weakest economically with no international support. Kashmir had always been high highlighted and practical steps taken in form of nuclear explosions, without any propaganda being done about it. Obviously the ones who had been conspirating for years to bring their puppet into power, will support his every shit till it comes to their own bread n butter. If that gets affected, or are told to remain within constitutional limit, they will take no time to slay their own created puppet.

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

Secondly feminism does not mean being against men. There was nothing in Amna's review to show that. She commended strong characters of girls shown in Ehde wafa and expressived her view of how even a religious person can flaw, being a human. That is true, you may not agree with her entire review about dada. There was no mention of feminism or misogyny in the entire video.

[@javeria7774]

@@mahnoorqureshi3281 Your hatred for Imran Khan and army will never let you see how your dears bhuttos and sharifs got into power. How one divided pakistan and the other's statement was used in the ICJ as a proof against our own country. How he barred our foreign office from speaking against India, he would meet his friends from indian business community but won't the Kashmiri leadership. I'm a kashmiri and I have seen how our relatives in IOK have praised Imran Khan for giving voice to the voiceless. They consider him their true ambassador and representative. And who do you think has isolated whom internationally? Get your facts straight woman And amna did call dada a misogynist. You may watch the video again

[@nadarq]

I disagree that she has a bias or that being a feminist means hating on men. I think we are so used to seeing everything from the standpoint of men that most of us don't notice or question. But trust me, some of us notice all too well. Alif was HeJ's story - but it was shown through the lens of men mostly. Ehd e Wafa had strong female characters, which was commendable even though the story wasn't about those women. I found Amna's interpretation of Dada very interesting and enlightened. Because I don't think that even the writer intended to make him a dark character. But if you really do analyze dada, he was truly the cause of most of the issues because as Hassan pointed out rightly - he thought that his way was the only right way of being connected to Allah. Lovely analysis - this drama is like an onion. You can not only keep peeling the layers, but you can actually see the story and the characters in the light of your own perspective and interpret it completely differently - and each perspective is equally valid

[@asmamuhemmed4316]

Itni complains to husne Jahan ko dada jaan say nahi thin.. She always looked at him at the time of need and dada jaan fulfilled all his duties after the death of taha...

[@asadfk]

Agreed

[@MuhammadIbrahim-cf1yr]

I am sorry to say Amna, that when every single person was criticizing Meray Pass Tum Ho' ending, u were all praises for it. And when every single person is praising Alif's ending, relating to it, crying over it, isn't this bias and hypocritical of u to criticize it just becz u are in a bad mood or so? Extremely disappointed!!

[@shafaqshah2890]

True

[@najmaqidwai2374]

True she spoiled the charm of alif for us

[@MuhammadIbrahim-cf1yr]

@@sab-ali U need to listen to the review again. She missed so many points about the actual last episode, just to state that Abdul Alla was a misogynist and that even the parting dialogues of Momin and Momina were gender discriminatory!! I mean, what??

[@estyak8780]

I didn't even watched the full video, she started analyzing Abdul Aala's character and i totally disagreed, clicked the dislike button and left. She doesn't seem qualified enough to review something like ALIF.

[@sukainatariquejamall]

Gulzar was singing in remembrance of his good times with his friend.. and not praying.. Pardon please dont mix way of praying in different ways.. yes you can definitely mourn in different ways.. thanks

[@HUDAIRFAN]

Thanks for this point....

[@gulsaanga4533]

It wasn't a way of prayer, it was a way to deal with pain. I loved that part of Gulzaar. It was the only part when I cried.

[@sukainatariquejamall]

@@sab-ali praying has actual format.. yes one can mourn ..make a dua.. with all the natural urge he/she feels.. One can do whatever he wants to.. but not addition to what has be made it clear. Thanks

[@zahidaabdullah2762]

It was a perfect ending, not dragged unnecessary . Amna was unnecessarily criticizing the dada part. Nothing is perfect at least much better a good drama as compared to other that are on air at the moment. One of the best drama in the history .

[@zishanparvez9494]

He told momin before dying that he asked his mother to remarry that man....i dont agree at all with you amina....dada was the pillar of this drama....he accepted his mistake and he told everything to momin before marrying ....and dada asked husn e jahan to remarry because in islam after your husband is dead a woman should remarry

[@samsamar2000]

Zishan Parvez yes and bahu and Susar should not live together after son’s death which pious people’s will not be happy to live like this

[@SauteStylesUK]

It was true Islamic sharia point of view, but sadly they completely failed to understand,

[@noreennabeel1526]

I'm also an army officer 's wife. My husband loves me so much but he behaves so composed in the presence of family members. Especially when he was committed to his job or other tasks.

[@just_maha]

Dada Jaan didn't know what happened the day Sultan visited HeJ. Even then he believed in HeJ's character. And told Momin that he didn't know what mistake she had made but he knows that she is 'Naik Rooh' and 'why do you blame your mother' etc. HeJ never clarified herself but Dada told Master Ibrahim that her character was so pure that is why she felt indebted to him. It was always Momin who saw things and made judgements. Although I agree Dada should've told Momin that he made HeJ marry Master Ibrahim. *But* Momin didn't want to hear her name and when Momin finally asked Dada whom she married, she had already passed away. Now Dada only had Momin left and he didn't want to burden him with guilt and only wanted peace for him. I understand Dada had made some wrong choices but I don't doubt his intentions at all. He had always loved the people around him.

[@sehrishkhalid126]

Ehd-e-Wafa is no doubt,ONE of the BEST dramas of Paksitan’s history🇵🇰 which inspired me to sing 🎤 the first female OST of Ehd-e-Wafa,for the love of the martyrs of Pak Armed forces.❤️ P.S: Amna & Hassan .. you both are truly a gem💎 I haven’t seen more authentic reviews than yours!!

[@xxcooloballxx2466]

Zara Hassan you sung it so beautifully, just heard

[@vapestersmokeshopltd6000]

Zara Hassan so emotional 😭

[@VapesterSmokeShopLtdVancouver]

Zara Hassan WOW what an OST😍👌

[@itsmeayana3220]

Zara Hassan such a beautiful voice

[@badarshah554]

Disappointed with amina s review of Alif, really disappointed

[@rubyummehasnain]

I think Aminah didn't understand The basic concept of Alif.

[@image9851]

Amna I was desperately waiting for your Alif's Review but today you were in a very negative mood. You considered everything, every aspect as Negative and about men. Which is not actually true. Iam quite disappointed with Amna's review today of Alif especially when it was the last episode review.

[@statesman01]

But her view on the old man is exactly right. And you have to say that both of Husna's husbands, her father-in-law and her son were all unfair to her.

[@hudairfan9102]

How can u judge her relationship with her 2nd husband? How master Ibrahim was unfair? Why didn't she tell him about momin? It was her choice...may be she was satisfied and happy.... Her equation with her Father in law was much positive then ur judgment....she trusted him nd left her house and went back to turkey nd he was sorry for whatever he did wrong in the past... Nd do mention that husan.a.jahanz mother nd siblings were also unfair with her..

[@statesman01]

@@hudairfan9102 She went back to Turkey to be with her son. She was not looking to get married. The old man took advantage of her goodness and married her off instead of allowing her to be with her son and setting the boy straight about how his mother was a good woman and deserved his respect and love. He should have told Momin that he (old man) had wrongly misjudged Husna. Master Ibrahim's idea of a good woman was a woman without a child. The reason for that is the selfish need to have all the attention on himself. Is a widow with a child a bad person? No. But would the child take attention away from him? Yes.

[@image9851]

Amna was in a bad and sarcastic mood today. Which had an affect on the whole review today and the most important review of the weekend. Did not like today's review

[@faizajawad6750]

You are right. Don't know what was up with Amina today.

[@sajidaosman3900]

Me too was really disappointed with amina today

[@sakinakothari5618]

Fr me Alif was a holistic experience rather than a drama. One of a kind! Though many felt that the pace of the drama was slow n preachy, the production quality was nt good, but according to me it was a part of the aesthetics of the story. I have watched Umera Ahmed's dramas before n observed that her characters r predominantly subjective n gv a deep insight into human psyche entwined in relationships. Her female protagonists r strong, highly moral yet vulnerable. Be it ZGH, Durre Shahwar, Daam or Alif.They belong to a different league of dramas fr a different set of audience. Alif has a much deeper meaning beyond the superficial story..Umera Ahmed has intricately concealed it n it unfolds as the story progresses. We need to see it frm a different perspective. Abdul Ala is doing khattati...his ancestral profession which has to be passed on to his nxt generation bcoz they feel they r privileged ones to be bestowed with this talent by Allah. When Taha deviates frm this path, he looses his privilege..i.e symbolic here that when u leave Allah for the material world, u lose everything. Husne jahan was a witness to his turmoil n downfall n she realised that mayb Momin could complete wht his father could nt.(thr ws a painting of an ayat which Taha could not complete). Dada never came to claim Momin. Probably she blamed herself fr Taha's loss n didn't clarify her image evn though she knew Momin hd begun hating her bcoz of Sultan's intrusion n her profession.Dada cm into thr lives much later after she hd nowhere to go, she turned to him. Abdul Ala was flawed he was blinded with rage bcoz he blamed Husne Jahan fr his son goin astray but when he realised he had misjudged her he tries to compensate by marrying her with a man of similar values. Why he never confronts Momin about his Mother's character..is nt shown clearly but he does mention to him a couple of times that his mother was a pious woman. Well thats hw the story unfolds n thr is a message thr...Khuda apne har bande ke aib ka parda rakhta hai..har raaz amanat hota hai..her bhed apne waqt par khulta hai...

[@atifabokhari3866]

Oops! Amna is sooo angry at Dada that she even missed few points. 😁

[@fatima_binteasad]

I'll miss Alif and Ehd-e-Wafa on the weekends!!! 😭😭😭❤️❤️❤️😭😭😭

[@wardaaman9607]

Dada always try to hide about what happened that day, because he didn't want to make momin blame himself, and dada always told momin that it was not the fault of his mother.

[@monarauf3112]

Basically dadajaan wanted husne jahan to have a happily married loving life which he deprived her of earlier

[@zainabzaman55]

Exactly. And it is NOT WRONG. ask a widowed young woman they would all like to remarry a pious person who is capable of providing her happiness she has been deprived of. And it is a great good deed to get widowed remarried He did the best for her and he never knew if momin thinks of his mother as cheater otherwise he would have cleared like he did in his last days

[@usrahussain133]

Husn e Jahan herself wanted a refuge and to get remarried. Dada just suggested her... And she wanted to get remarried too as living with Dada ji would expose her truth that she didn't die 😤 Amna ruined the finale's interpretation so bad 🤐

[@daisydaruwalla4189]

Amna has misunderstood some of the things in this final episode. I haven't read the novel but some things were very clear. 1. Momin clearly says that he is going away to Turkey because after ages he had achieved peace. He says Bahut der ke baad mujhe sukoon mila hai aur main woh khona nahin chahta. 2. Master Abrahim did not know that his Husna was Husn e Jahan till Momina gave him the pictures. 3. Momina 's refusal to go with Momin was not that she wanted to continue to act. In that Amna is absolutely off the track. She clearly says she was skeptical about their relationship not becoming one of Taha and Husn e Jahan. Probably she was right in her fears. Both of them were headstrong individuals and their previous quarrels prove that. Probably they need this time apart so that Momina can realise that nothing matters more to her than Momin. I liked the ending. Their expressions and dialogues were superb, and their one and only hug spoke volumes. And the last 15 minutes were the most touching ones out of all the episodes. Hats off to the makers for giving us an epic show which will go down in the history of television and will be remembered for many many years to come. From an appreciative Indian

[@hashhina7324]

Was so looking forward to the review of alif but after I started watching I didn't even want to continue bcz of how u misinterpreted everything. I literally wanted to skip the review.

[@faizajawad6750]

Agreed

[@aqsach7406]

Same here

[@najmaqidwai2374]

Same here

[@amnaaj5608]

Dada made a mistake as a parent by not accepting Taha's marriage but later he accepted his mistake although it was late. He tried to give Husn e jahan a new life. He didn't tell abt her past to master ibrahim bcz ibrahim already had a bad image in mind abt his daughter in law. He wanted Ibrahim to get to know husne jahan on his own. Dada's character tells that parents are not always right. He's just human like any of us, not as negative as u perceived.

[@saimaasimrehman3330]

Being a doctor myself, I want to correct here, pregnant doctors work in surgery and they are NOT forbidden from doing surgeries....plus in Pakistan, doctors are allowed to treat their own family....so it wasn't weird...though I really don't understand why and how, from the very beginning, Dr Duaa keeps saying " chhota saad, maa beta etc etc " ...how do they know from very initial time it's a boy..or it was taken for granted

[@Amwaseem3624]

Humayun saeed scene was unnecessary.

[@user-ow9ct6nt8k]

@@smn4905 guys is alif really worth watching? I mean I watched first episodes and found it really boring although it was all about good things then also it was so slow I stopped watching it!

[@sakinakothari5618]

Alif is sublime..it gives u some food for thought ..to reflect n ponder on ur thoughts, actions, judgements n life which deter u frm the path of Allah. Like Momina says in the end...Tum jao tumhe Taufeeq mil gayi hai..main abhi raaste main hoon..thats a beautiful message...each one has thr own journey towards reaching the Creator. Alif was an attempt to reestablish n reassert our connection with the Supreme

[@shafaqsaqib9012]

I respectfully don’t agree with Amina’s interpretation of dada jee’s character ... I think it’s a story gap that why did husn-e-jahan got married... why did she agree to marry anybody and why didn’t she chose to live with her son alone ... these are not flaws in dada jee but questions for Umera Ahmed

[@maryamrumesa5677]

It's not a story gap, husne jahan agreed to Dada's decision of her marriage because she thinks of dada as a very pious men that whatever he decides for her will be the right thing for her, she before that sent momin to dada in Turkey because she trustes dada.

[@fouziakhan9324]

I think momin starts disliking his mom after seeing her dancing in parties. When hysne Jahan goes back to turkey, momin probably didn't want to see her (at that point she and daada ofc didn't know what's going in momin's mind, all they thought momin didn't want her mother after seeing her dance). How could they know momin had so many misunderstandings regarding his mother and father's break up?

[@wardaaman9607]

Just loved alif's ending, both having their statement of peacefulness , momina will turn to momin after getting all the things wind up.. Her parents,

[@LifeofPakistani]

It wasn't weird k abdul ala sahab ne kabhi bataya nahi k husn e jahan bahu thi meri, q k abdul ala or master ibrahim ki conversation me sirf yeh point nahi tha k wo bachey wali aurat na ho, shadi ki baat krney se pehley master ibrahim husn e jahan k baarey me baat kr rahey they k us ne aap se aap k bete ko cheen lia and all that! Isi liye dada ne husn e jahan ka naam bhi badla or kabhi yeh nahi bataya k wohi meri bahu thi. Second thing yeh k momina ne yeh question kia tha k master ibrahim se aap ne kabhi abdul ala sahab ko q nahi bataya k aap jaan gaye hain sab. Unhon ne kaha tha k agar me unko batata tw mjh se nazrain na mila patey. Isi liye kabhi momin k baarey me bhi un se nahi poocha

[@anniechoudhary6028]

Totally Disagree with amna's opinion about dada in alif

[@amerapaikar9075]

Exactly...amna's view regarding dada is totally incorrect

[@aishadar8389]

@@munirahmad2943 yes🤣🤣

[@aishadar8389]

Amna kuch zyada hi bol gyi

[@najmaqidwai2374]

@@aishadar8389 😂😂😂😂yes Ott ho gya

[@Farah-sh4fr]

Also, the trivias that you were trying to find were quite clear in the episodes. I have not even read the book and don’t need to. Dada jaan was an arrogant man with a young son he thought he had raised very well and when he was about to be deviated from a path of Allah he advised him wrong because as said he was a flawed man. it is not a woman or a man but a person himself who loses faith. I feel that Taha himself was not clear in his faith and nor in his trust for the love of his life. I want to remind that when Sultan brought momin to dadajaan he told him about Husnejahan’s trust in him to raise her son in the right. It made him realize how wrongly he had judged her or atleast given him some idea about it. Momin saw his mother but it seems that he never told anyone so how is dadajan or anyone supposed to know why he has such a view of women. All said that, he really should have shed light on her character to momin when he was so old and knew he would die soon. He could have given his good two pence because it wouldn’t have hurt husne jahan’s marriage anymore as she was already gone and the husband wasn’t around momin. So there he was neglectful I think.

[@toobakhaliq5935]

When Momina says " mera safar Abhi baki ha" it meant that she is still on that spiritual journey , when her journey will end she will meet him....that what the novel says...and Amna's interpretation if Dada's character is wrong....Dada said many times before to Momin that her mother is a good women but momin will remembers her mother as bad women due to those childhood memories

[@toobakhaliq5935]

Still*

[@sualehasiddiqui7586]

Sorry amna miss interprets dada character disappointed

[@jeeya2782]

Yes you are right

[@aishajawed6526]

You totally misunderstood the concept of Alif. And the concept of regret repent. Now the drama is over please read novel to clear your thoughts. Otherwise the concept of being judgemental and degrading others totally wasted. And dada was not pious because no one is perfect. Please read novel please

[@aimanshakeel1844]

Alif was just beautiful! I'm going to miss it a lot.😢

[@inm1337]

I was waiting for your reviews subah se but I am really disappointed by amna's review. I'm not biased towards Alif, yeah I really like it and I'm so against misogyny but Amna you were unable to understand dada's character and maybe novel main ziada insight thi Dada ke character per. But I think Hassan was being fair as he pointed out the bad things in dada's character but you were constantly bashing him and kept bringing the element of patriarchy and misogyny. I really feel like you should watch it again or read the novel to get a better understanding of his character. I'm not defending him but you were being so rude and kept repeating the same thing again and again I

[@MuhammadHassan-ih5yw]

Yes plz re watch Amina

[@sadiakhan2740]

IN M we should take it easy on Amna , she’s entitled to her opinion..she doesn’t understand Alif because she hasn’t read the novel.

[@inm1337]

@@sadiakhan2740 yeah she is and I completely understand where she's coming from. Just like she's entitled to her opinion I'm entitled to mine. I really like Amna it's just that it was getting a little annoying. Hassan was also against him(Dada) but his points were valid whereas amma was looking it from a specific angle.

[@zainabzaman55]

Same we depend on them and this is what they did that toooo on the last episode... Toooo superficial tooo shallow tooo disappointing

[@SkKhan-zi4ii]

Dad's character is beyond yr imagination.... He did best for both momin and husnejahan Read novel first

[@khadijamalik1038]

Hi amna I don’t whether you will be reading my comments or not but one thing I would like to say that your personality is inspirational and I have a strong suggestion to start some women sessions and talk for all the leading girls who are about to get married or starting any important agenda of thier lives. I would like to request you to provide your guidance and thoughts on how women should progress. I really want to hear because you are women with great wisdom. God bless you.

[@dhanjiro]

Also want to add please take all this criticism towards you today with lots of patience. Can’t please everyone. Everyone is going through Coronavirus effects and it’s affects on our mood/ mijaaz. Can you imagine being stuck at home with your crazy family 24/7 without break😳. We all love your reviews and your chemistry with Hassan. I first watch the dramas and then your reviews. You guys make my day 🤗🤗😘😘 Amna I was balling as well in ehde wafa. 😭.

[@iqraparveen3756]

alif ka review bilkul acha ni kya...alif was a masterpiece...

[@farwaakhtar4721]

1. Yeh dil mera 2. Kahin deep jalay 3.ruswai 4.thora sa haq

[@zohraaaa2007]

I cried the entire way of Saad’s scene 😭😭😭 the ending and entire play was phenomenal 👌🏼👏🏼 I’ve lived abroad my whole life but Ehd-e-Wafa drew a special sentiment to Pakistan and the patriotism of my eastern roots ❤️🇵🇰 Thank you Aamna and Hassan for having these dialogues in an intellectual, yet enjoyable way ☺️

[@user-sj1]

I so agree!!! I cried for hours and was depressed for days. I was happy he survived, but the stuff he went through.

[@msmehmood]

Amina, please get out of “mere pass tum ho” ‘s phase.

[@shahrukhahmed5051]

EXACTLY

[@qudsianaqqash5822]

True

[@sariasiddiqui]

Hhahhaa Amna feminist Hain so wo har Chez orat k khelaf jati mehsos karti Hain. Jab k Abdul aala shb na apney betey ki mohabat ma husan e Jahan say nafrat ki os k actress honay ya dancer honay par nhn.

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

@@sariasiddiqui What's wrong if Amna commended the strong characters of girls in ehde wafa and did not agree with some of the actions of dada in Alif. Ye feminism kahan se aa gia

[@shazhammad4361]

Master Ibrahim didn't know about husne jahan at the time of marriage..

[@SauteStylesUK]

I also disagreed with Amna's review about DADA, i assume there were 2 reasons why he get her married, 1- Dada took her as his daughter, and she was quite young, as a father, he wanted to fulfill his duty, 2- this drama is based on Islamic points, Dada shouldn't allow his Son's widow to live in his house by shariah,

[@samreenawan7956]

No Amna you misinterpret dadas character, I would advice you to read novel

[@saimasohail8240]

amna please re think about dada s personality ....1) dada s behaviour was really wrong at the time of taha n husne jahan wedding time but after taha s death he really realized his mitake 2) when husna e jahan sent momin to dada then already he had made some bad feeling about her mother regarding her profession n sultan about which dada didnt know 3) when husne jahan escped to turkey dada really want her to be remain happy with a loving husband and the choice of a good man was only master ibrahim and he has to compromise with this condition 4)the reason of this compromise is that the fact is that a man even good or a bad one very rarely except other s child and who accept it make the wife and the kid s lives miserable most of the time and daada want husne jahan to be in peace 2)dada always welcome husne jahan to come to his home but since momin from the younger age to the teenager never accepted her to meet him and disregard her which actually made her very sad but this is all because of momin s illusion not dada s planning 5) yes master ibrahim really felt now that if he didnt make such condition husn e jahan would be able to live with his son but here agaiin most important is whether as a growing child with a bad image of her mother would momin like to live with her even if dada didnt get her married or mastwr ibrahim accept the child rather i think he would become more rebellious while right now with dada s supervision he is not a rebellion

[@sidrailyas9655]

#Alif Master ibrahim didnt know about husna when momina gave him posters of husnejahan. Sorry amna ko ALIF ki bilkul samjh nhe lagi 😑 expect that dada was some kinda flued man i agree #ehdewafa Hassssannn I totally agree with youuuu why they did it with saad and dua 🤔 its werid 😲

[@iramharoon9100]

1)yeh dil mera. 2) kahin deep jalay. 3) ruswai. 4) pyar k sadqay. 5) thora sa haq.

[@shamsafarooqui9546]

After this review I'm not sure i wanna watch something haute anymore 🤔

[@teaisfantastic6340]

Same!!

[@aqsach7406]

Really disappointed

[@najmaqidwai2374]

Sameeeee

[@sumayrak5652]

Same 🙁🙁

[@parassiddiqui2796]

I was literally soo angry and disappointed when they didnt even show a single scene of saad and dua having an emotional/happy moment after saad's operation, like seriously?!! Chalo unhon nay saad k army operation pe janay se pehle koi unka emotional scene wagera ni daikha, kr diya maaf, but atleast ab to it was a must yaar. IT WAS A MUST. I am really unhappy about this.

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

Maybe the actress or her family is not comfortable with intimate scenes.

[@parassiddiqui2796]

@@mahnoorqureshi3281 well yeah maybe, but its not all about any intimate scene, just a good happy moment which they could have shared while holding hands or maybe without it as well like ahad's eyes really do the talking , they could have shown a cute romantic moment without any intimacy. I just wanted to see them together for one last time as the drama ended. I am still very upset about this.

[@statesman01]

I agree Paras. It was a very hurried ending. Stuffed in too much. Too preachy. Pak-India's 5-7 years of geo-political events when shown in 5 minutes is confusing. Holding hands or even touching a sick husband's forehead or hair is NOT intimate.

[@parassiddiqui2796]

@@statesman01 Exactly!! This is what i am saying. Yes everything happened so hurriedly, like they didnt even put shehriyar and masooma's love story to an end by not showing their marriage or kind of their happily ever after , neither did they show shariq's aur gulzar's marriage, but okay this is acceptable but not showing any saad and dua scene(which was very much needed) for me, its not acceptable. ( i think i am exaggerating lil now but i am actually very unhappy about it)

[@parassiddiqui2796]

@@statesman01 Yes, the army-political scenes were quite confusing, it did become preachy

[@mamabuiltalittlenestkainat2227]

No amina... Ap na thek trah sa review nahi kia na hi ap na drama ki intensity ko utna ghor sa dakha... I really think ap na drama dakhta hua us ko maghron utara ha 😅☹️ i really wish k ap drama dobara dakhain aik br phr sa

[@irumusman268]

Agree with u to a certain extent but from my perspective this story revolves around two exemplary women..the main protagonist of Alif was Husn e Jahan and transition of a woman from luv for worldly pleasures to ultimately finding self actualisation in spirituality... and I didn’t find the ego war as one sided, when Taha’s father rejected his son’s luv interest, Husn e Jahan also got determined to have Taha at any cost even if it meant to distance him from his father ( because defeat wasn’t a word in her dictionary) Momina and Suraiyya also depicted extremely inspirational women who knew how to stand up for what they believed in , and that too in a subtle and non evasive manner🙌 luv u guys and thank u for another interesting and entertaining review😘 ❤️

[@irnm1947]

Amna I really like and enjoy your reviews and the way you express everything. I also understand that everybody has a different opinion about everything. I also agree that Dada has made mistakes and he also had flaws like any other human being but I genuinely feel like you were being a little biased and when you're reviewing and maybe I read the novel and it was in detail so I understand dada's point of view and from where he's coming from and drama was wrapped up a little faster. But I feel like Har jaggah misogyny aur patriarchy ke element ko na lain. I understand your point of view but you're repeating that again and again. Maybe that was how you perceived it but it was a getting annoying that you were only watching it from a certain angle. Otherwise really enjoy watching your reviews and it feels great to hear your opinions on different things happening in our society.

[@momentwithaffan]

Agreed... She even said Dada ruined qalab e momin's life... Whereas his film was a hit and it was his own decision to go back to turkey.... I mean.... Is he not allowed to take his own decisions... Dada had nothing to do with that.... I love amina's reviews most of the time.... But she looked at it from an angle which was not very applicable here... Anyhow... Her channel... Her opinion.... But it was very biased and annoying "in my opinion"...

[@shahrukhahmed5051]

@@momentwithaffan She is sometimes a wanna -be feminist

[@aliyabawany2444]

@@shahrukhahmed5051 the moment you wanna be a feminist, you already are one. Your concept is erroneous.

[@user-io1cu3zl4g]

@@momentwithaffan True....and how does going to turkey and pursuing calligraphy would ruin Momin's life??? May be he will get way more from it than what he was getting from films... so u never know what is best for the other person... har insaan apny hisaab se apna decision laita hai jo us ko us time pe best lag rha ho...that's what momin did

[@nadarq]

Question: Momin reads a letter in the last episode - which is Husne Jahan's letter to Taha saying that his son is writing to Allah to ask for his father back. I was very confused about this. We saw one episode ago, that Sultan gave him a bunch of letters which were supposed to be letters from HeJ to Sultan that she wrote over the years when she was married, and lived with her son in Turkey. Reading those letters was supposed to make Momin understand his mom better and know the reality of what happened in Turkey. But they never showed him reading those letters. The letter he did read in the last episode - where did that come from? Was that given to him by his dada at some point along with the letter box? If so, why did they show him reading it now? Why would he not have read those letters earlier, at least as research for the movie script he was writing based on his mother's life? This was a big loophole for me. I'd love to hear from anyone who can explain this

[@SarahShakeelmic]

Yes Vaneeza k acting n emotions + Gulzar singing song both of theirs acting was superb n impeccable :D

[@soofiaqureshi1021]

Hassan bhai my outcome of the story was that dada was a pious man but husn e jahan was the main lady. She loved Allah so much that her love, her blind faith and trust helped momin to come back to Allah. It wasn't because momin's family was pious. It was the love and devotion of a muslim woman that momin was guided by Allah and husn e jahan and momina bith played a pivotal role in that ❤.

[@alishbaaymen8121]

Indeed Amna is female version of Khalil Ur Rehman having extreme thoughts abt a gender

[@humeraazeem9010]

No you got it wrong Amina when she goes back to Turkey Momin refuses to be with her and Dada does tell him that his mother is not a bad woman. Than she says what is she going to do and he gets her married. Then he again tells Momin to see his mother when she comes before her death. So it was not that dada was dictating her. Master Ibrahim was not aware she was an actress because he was not in Pakistan. He was not told because Dada wanted her to find happiness and start fresh.