Let's Find The Best Peanut Butter Whiskey!

[@kanofwhoopazz7852]

Screwball is the best hands down ! Usually like 30$ a bottle around me. But it’s delicious. Mix with a Vanilla Coke or Dr Pepper or just straight.

[@buckfumbler]

yeah we came to the same conclusion on my channel. They even said "it tastes like a better quality product." Maybe their taste buds were messed up from all the other bad ones. LOL

[@allthingstwizted4924]

Ole smoky peanut butter whiskey was voted as the best whiskey in the country.

[@buckfumbler]

@@allthingstwizted4924 I haven't tried that one, but they voted Bird dog better that it in this video. I know Ole Smokey won a bunch of awards in 2020.

[@allthingstwizted4924]

@@buckfumbler well I do know that when ole smoky first came out with the peanut butter whiskey, it got compared against every other brand of whiskey not just peanut butter whiskey and it won several gold and silver medals but ultimately it was awarded as the best whiskey in the country. I don't think it has a fruit taste at all. Taste more like an angry Reese's cup and it smells like you just popped open a jar of peanut butter.

[@buckfumbler]

@@allthingstwizted4924 well I'll be giving it a try anyways.

[@Lunarbutterflytarot]

SKREWBALL is the only hard liquor I've ever drank straight

[@ryanspring7649]

Came here hoping to get confirmation in my belief Bird Dog is hands down the best option and glad yall agreed. Factor in price and alcohol % and Bird Dog is the clear cut king

[@HipFlippinMamma-Kelly]

PBWHISKEY AND CHOCOLATE VODKA TASTE LIKE A REESE PEANUT BUTTER CUP

[@raidernation124]

Bird dog peanut butter is the best I love that stuff

[@CakeBanditJr]

Late to the party here, but you nailed it! Half the price and great tasting? Count me in! BD is really, really good across the board!

[@codycreager4428]

Probably because the abv is higher making it less syrupy

[@Frank-uf2vn]

Screwball ($27.99) is the most popular, you go into any tavern, and you will see a bottle back there. The Ole Smoky Peanut Butter is $19.99 & the Bird Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey is $18.99 they are all (along with several other peanut butter flavored whiskeys I have) good when mixed. The Bird Dog is the cheapest and really good! 🥃Cheers

[@geraldbrown6874]

Finally yall made this video!!! Screwball is my favorite though!

[@kybrewreview]

Lol this video took way more work than I thought.

[@reverendtattoo]

I’ve only had Screwball. It was a gift. Tried a bunch of mixers and so far grape soda is ok but really sweet. My favorite way to drink it has just been over ice. I’m starting to like it. Lol

[@Floydster76]

Personally I like screwball, ole Smokey peanut butter, rams point, and bird dog (not particularly in that order) I think they all taste delicious especially if you put them in the freezer and let them get nice and cold but that’s just my personal opinion because they all have there pros and cons wether it’s the price or the flavor or the aftertaste I like what I like and that’s ok

[@jimrudd1191]

Thanks guys, love all things peanut butter especially stouts, honestly not a big whiskey/ burbon guy. Really looking for something easy to sneak into the casinos up here in Detroit, in my flask, hey at 12 bucks a shot why not. I will pick up a bottle of the Bird Dog and try it out. Cheers and please keep up the good work. 🍻

[@Olugraphics]

Crazy idea: if you have any left make an "infinity bottle" of all the peanut butter whiskeys you tried 🤔

[@turboflutter9325]

Radar looked like he would rather have not drunken all that PB Whiskey lol

[@kybrewreview]

It sounded like a good idea last year lol

[@GroundhogClay]

For drinking straight or even mixing screwball is better. If you are just mixing the bird dog is the way to go because of the higher alcohol content and price. I literally keep both in stock

[@HipFlippinMamma-Kelly]

I drink PBwhiskey with a shot of water and a glass of ice, every night at bedtime. Yum

[@kybrewreview]

Peanut butter whiskey is great!

[@nerd-workshop]

I have had all those Peanut butter whiskies and Screwball is not the best. It is a super butterscotch flavor! Best one I have had was not on this panel... but I have only found it in Nashville TN. My go to is Sheep Dog hands down and as someone that drinks 2 bottles of peanut butter whiskey a week... I would buy sheep dog over all the others on this list. Helps that it is also the least expensive. Though Costco Screwball price makes it hard to argue!

[@ShanaynayGosby]

Ole Smoky where I'm from is 18 a fifth,and ngl its the best tasting one imo I got a few bottles cause it sell out so much

[@cosmiccalvin529]

By the end y’all sounded like kids in a candy store def all that peanut butter whiskey doing it’s work. I watched while trying screwball for first time & way to sweet for my liking 😂😂😂

[@rocksjoshua]

Just had Bird Dog peanut butter for the first time, one of the smoothest whiskeys I have ever had, it is very sweet but for the price ($20 give or take a little) and for 40% acv you can't really beat it. Definitely will be buying some more.

[@the_old_desperado]

I thought this was an awesome review, would love to see something like this again if you guys have time in the future!

[@kybrewreview]

we have plans to do a few this summer!

[@radodd5972]

What mixer do you prefer with peanut butter whiskey?

[@Voysh2Voysh69]

Do grape juice lol

[@kybrewreview]

Yoohoo works well, grape soda, apple juice and coke

[@Olugraphics]

May I suggest hot cocoa (those swiss miss packets do just fine)

[@Justin-bn9mr]

White Russian, just replace vodka with whiskey

[@halfsourlizard9319]

Real whiskey, lots of it ... need something to dilute the sugar and artificial-peanut flavour.

[@Oklaprepper]

I could have used this video yesterday. I’ve only tried Skrewball and Ole Smokey. My personal opinion, Ole Smokey is the better. But I do mix them in my Mules. Yesterday I could find Ole Smokey, but I saw several different ones I’d never seen. Bird Dog was one. Unfortunately, the employee recommended Texas Ranger Peanut Butter. Not a fan.

[@kybrewreview]

I've seen the Texas ranger around, we will probably skip it.

[@Oklaprepper]

@@kybrewreview i definitely don’t recommend it.

[@WreckFatal]

Any chance any of you guys gonna be in KC anytime soon? Amazing craft breweries here i'd love to buy y'all some beer to review but I can't ship it

[@kybrewreview]

Mingo on the show used to go there when he was dating a girl from there but right now we have no plans to go. but a road trip in the future is never out of the question.

[@Thefisherman-qf7zx]

#ChiefsKingdom!

[@seanjones2623]

I mean skrewball is alright. But I don’t get any peanut flavor out of it. More of maybe a caramel flavor

[@DT.2024]

If those taste like skewballs I want them all, they are so good with a marijuana blunt

[@droc207]

I like screwball and Sheep Dog

[@kyad1965]

I just bought Sheep Dog $30 compared to Skrewball at $55........I'll stick with the Sheep Dog! (Canadian)

[@bradj5642]

Screwball is the best.

[@williammckinney4188]

Very informative

[@larrykoroush6995]

I liked screwball, but price wise ..bird dog is the winner. My girlfriend likes mixing it with Grape juice. Like a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. I want to be a judge up there....

[@kybrewreview]

that sounds like a good mixer!

[@m-cicle-3517]

Bird dog defined tastes like a chic-o stick !

[@jerrylandy3666]

Requesting the new bud light next. Please!

[@kybrewreview]

We have been looking for it.

[@jerrylandy3666]

@Hooknose Shylock that’s what it seems like I’m definitely going to try it at some point myself. I really don’t like the design which usually doesn’t matter to me but that ones really bad for a beer

[@skipyou2870]

So skrewball won but bird dog is more accessible

[@weldlord2746]

good video

[@aaahhhchew8028]

Finally.

[@kybrewreview]

This video took 3 hours to shoot...

[@aaahhhchew8028]

@@kybrewreview Well it's an awesome video. Well done.

[@JAway-ls5oe]

Wish I watched this one before buying rams point

[@kybrewreview]

That one's not great

[@JAway-ls5oe]

@@kybrewreview it’s hardly,

[@halfsourlizard9319]

Skatterbrain is one of the worst-tasting substances that I've intentionally ingested.