Let's Save the Sega Saturn!

  Рет қаралды 90,585

Sega Lord X

Sega Lord X

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 1 500
@ridiculous_gaming
@ridiculous_gaming Жыл бұрын
The biggest issue was Sega US vs Sega Japan. The rivalry here was the biggest nail in their coffin.
@atomicskull6405
@atomicskull6405 Жыл бұрын
Sega USA was approached by a group of former SGI engineers with a prototype console they had developed, it was significantly better than what Sega was working on (the Saturn). Sega Japan said no. Then they went to Nintendo and that prototype console became the N64.
@Nintenboy01
@Nintenboy01 Жыл бұрын
@@atomicskull6405 it's the CD-based N64 we never had
@Lord_Deimos
@Lord_Deimos Жыл бұрын
Yeah, good luck trying to convince the clowns of Sega Japan about anything.
@Kadamose
@Kadamose Жыл бұрын
@@atomicskull6405 The N64 was a pile of crap and Sega was 100% right to pass on the technology. Even with the Saturn's 3d short-comings, it was still a better console than the PS1 and the N64 by a mile.
@josephfrye7342
@josephfrye7342 Жыл бұрын
No shit I mean Jesus flipping Christ already.
@viewtifuljoe99
@viewtifuljoe99 Жыл бұрын
"It's the Sega Saturn, Marty! Somethings got to be done about Sonic Extreme!"
@gouto172
@gouto172 Жыл бұрын
The title it's enough for me, Saturn deserved so much
@FZuloaga
@FZuloaga Жыл бұрын
Dude goes back in time and doesn't stop world wars... dude rebuilds the Saturn. Yeap, that's one of my favorite youtubers.
@oxogood9018
@oxogood9018 8 ай бұрын
Hear hear
@vancityguy
@vancityguy 3 ай бұрын
If it wasn’t for two World Wars, Japan wouldn’t have the awesome game companies we’d love today. 💥💥
@francescosmith7859
@francescosmith7859 Жыл бұрын
Wow, I would have LOVED the Sega Gold Series idea!!! What a brilliant way to reward those who had the Sega CD while continuing to highlight some of the best late titles on the Genesis. This is a real shame Sega didn't think of this one.
@toronaldaris
@toronaldaris Жыл бұрын
They just didn't want to admit that Interactive Video wasn't the way to go for all of the CD Library.
@CarlosXPhone
@CarlosXPhone Жыл бұрын
​@@toronaldarisit sort of was, just not FMV games.
@Swordslinger-hb1ns
@Swordslinger-hb1ns Жыл бұрын
If you want a good port of Doom on the Sega Saturn keep John Carmack’s programming meddling away from Rage Software and let them use the custom made engine they intended to use that way it’ll run at full screen AND 60FPS.
@OrtemionQC
@OrtemionQC Жыл бұрын
Yeah, that guy has a great idea.
@RadikaRules
@RadikaRules 3 ай бұрын
As nice as the AGES 2500 line was on the PS2, this is simply much more cost effective. Experimentation and remakes can be left to something else
@loki.odinson
@loki.odinson Жыл бұрын
This is probably one of my favorite episodes you have ever done. I'd love to see you do another in the same vein, either as a Part 2 by building upon your ideas here, or make it it's own animal: Saving the Sega Dreamcast.
@Bristecom
@Bristecom Жыл бұрын
In my opinion, the Dreamcast was as near perfect as it could have been for the time. I just mentioned the reasons why in another post, but basically they made all the best decisions considering the time-frame and costs as a company who didn't own several component manufacturing plants like Sony. Their past mistakes and future competition was simply too much for them to handle. There was no way they could compete with Sony's affordable DVD player, Nintendo's name, and Microsoft's well designed high-tech console by 2002. As much as I loved Sega hardware, I think they made the right choice by ultimately going software multi-platform (although they unfortunately slowly fell apart from there).
@G.G.___162
@G.G.___162 Жыл бұрын
​@@BristecomI hear ya there; But I wonder: if the Saturn would have been more successful (like if it went as Sega Lord X planned it here, and no 32X), leading into a Dreamcast the way it was (with maybe a DVD player added in with the extra funds from the semi-succesful Saturn era), ultimately having more umph behind Sega by 1999 - 2000: Would Microsoft have ever even entered the console market? It seems like maybe Microsoft would have stuck with Sega, like they were in the beginning of the Dreamcast. If the Dreamcast was doing well, then maybe Microsoft wouldn't have seen the opening into the console market that they ended up taking. But I dk.. maybe Microsoft was going to enter the console market either way, and were always going to use their experience with Sega to better understand how to step in the market. It is kinda suspicious how Microsoft basically got a tour of how the console market works alongside Sega, then this random Peter Moore guy comes in and takes over Sega of America; He pushes for Sega to leave the hardware market, then conveniently all of the sudden becomes the president of the Xbox division of Microsoft lol Almost seems like an inside job lol
@Bristecom
@Bristecom Жыл бұрын
​@@G.G.___162 As I mentioned in another comment, I understand that the DVD drive was a major factor in the PS2's success, but I do not believe a DVD drive would have been a good choice for the Dreamcast. Something to keep in mind is that in 1998, DVD's were just starting to get out there, and the drives were very expensive and slow. Using a DVD drive in a game console would have made loading times abysmal at 2x speed instead of 12x speed of the GD-ROM, and the drive and MPEG2 decoders would have added at least $100 to the price, not to mention all the licensing fees. By 2000, DVD's were getting much more popular and Sony held the rights to DVD and manufactured the drives and decoders, plus the costs were coming down and speeds slightly increasing, so they were uniquely able to offer it in a feasible way. And considering how many combined home entertainment systems miserably failed in the 90's like the Philips CDi, I think Sega was rightfully scared of marketing it as such, and decided to stay in its corner as a dedicated game console, whereas it made much more sense for Sony to reach out into other markets with theirs. When it comes to Microsoft, the only role they had with Sega for the Dreamcast was enabling the ability to program in a Windows CE environment and with DirectX if a developer chose to. Very few games ended up using this feature because it was slower than Sega's API and not much easier unless they were only familiar with making Windows PC games. This was also done so that programmers could use Microsoft to develop for the Hitachi SuperH architecture in things like car infotainment systems. It sounds like some people at Microsoft wanted to make a console regardless of Sega. They wanted to improve gaming on Windows, and making a console was a way to accelerate that, and also enter into other markets to take even more share from competitors like Sony. I think Microsoft just happened to come out with Xbox at the right time when Sega was at their weakest, and they did a solid job of offering a powerful/high tech design that was also easy to program for.
@G.G.___162
@G.G.___162 Жыл бұрын
And bonus thought: they really should have made the Dreamcast controller with 6 face buttons; I mean it's basically the exact same controller as the 3D Saturn analog controller; but they took 2 buttons away.. why!?? lol And it desperately needed a 2nd analog stick; why they didn't do that is equally as dumb as taking away the C & Z buttons, as the dual analog PS1 controller clearly showed the direction that analog controls were going, and what more could be done with a 2nd analog stick. Sega really seriously went out of their way to drop the ball with those two decisions. With this in mind: I was looking at a list of canceled Dreamcast games on Wikipedia; although Wiki is notoriously often just incorrect when it comes to video game business history. Very interesting to see on this list, was: Halo! Just imagine what that could've done for the Dreamcast; however: with only 1 analog stick, that just wouldn't have worked out very well. Another one that I've heard many times was canceled, but was not on that list, was: Grand Theft Auto 3. Just imagine what that could've done for the Dreamcast as well! Aparrently there was no actual development done though, it was just a plan at one point. and while again, no second analog stick isn't good for that; it wouldn't be a deal breaker as it would be for Halo; Just look at the PSP GTA games; they played great with the 1 analog stick. And this one sounds a little more believable, as GTA 2 was on Dreamcast and they had a working relationship with Sega. Oh the would'a could'a should'as..
@Bristecom
@Bristecom Жыл бұрын
​@@G.G.___162 I agree that not having a second joystick was the biggest flaw of the Dreamcast design, although with that said, it wasn't as bad at the time coming from N64 but became clearly beneficial with newer games. I'm still not sure how I feel about having 6 buttons though. I had the Saturn 3D Control Pad and outside of arcade fighting games like Street fighter, which used all 6, it just ends up looking and feeling kind of awkward. I remember reading in an interview a long time ago that Sega decided to switch to a standard 4 button layout for simplicity as most of their developers preferred it. And obviously all other game controllers only use 4 buttons (with the exception of the odd black and white buttons on the original Xbox controller), so it was probably the right choice switching to 4 IMO. I would have loved to have seen some of the cancelled games on Dreamcast, particularly a lot of the early Sega games that went multi-platform like Gunvalkyrie and Virtua Fighter 4, and Super Monkey Ball and such. They were probably improved and better off on the other consoles but there's just something so charming and raw about Dreamcast games - Sonic Adventure on DC vs Sonic Adventure DX on GameCube for example - the GC version just looked a bit off with the "improved graphics."
@jeffb.6642
@jeffb.6642 Жыл бұрын
I think one of the biggest reasons for the Saturn's relative failure was Sega completely ignoring their established IPs that were beloved by so many Genesis fans. As any SLX viewer has heard him mention in several videos, there was NO mainline entry for ANY of their beloved IPs available for the Saturn at launch - or ever, in the case of some of them. It would be like a new Nintendo console launching without a Mario game, or one even on the horizon. The closest we ever got to that happening was the Gamecube launching with Luigi's mansion instead of a proper Mario title - and well, the GC didn't exactly shatter sales barriers compared to the competition. It needed the hook of a familiar IP.
@SegaLordX
@SegaLordX Жыл бұрын
Yup. It doesn't get said enough.
@maroon9273
@maroon9273 Жыл бұрын
Plus, they abandoned master systems ips as well. Infighting led to sega to abandon there franchise ips for new ones.
@Oysterblade84
@Oysterblade84 Жыл бұрын
@Jeffb.6642 Wasn't Super Mario Sunshine on the Gamecube and an original mainline Mario game or am I missing something?
@GreyMatterShades
@GreyMatterShades Жыл бұрын
@@Oysterblade84 Mario Sunshine was a mainline Mario game, but it didn't come out until almost a year after the Gamecube's launch.
@Memelord1117
@Memelord1117 Жыл бұрын
Hell, a properly done Knuckles Chaotix could've been the Saturn's Luigi's mansion. Even then, sega could've made up for that with shinobi and streets of rage, along with other established franchises.
@alisson1900
@alisson1900 Жыл бұрын
You fixed the past, man. Congratulations. Excellent video.
@sirprower
@sirprower Жыл бұрын
Saving the Saturn would also mean saving the Dreamcast!
@jeffb.6642
@jeffb.6642 Жыл бұрын
Yes, if only because the Dreamcast wouldn't have been shunned by all the Sega fans who got burned by the Saturn already.
@diegoarmando5489
@diegoarmando5489 Жыл бұрын
Nope. Saving the Saturn creates the possibility of saving the Dreamcast. Sega could have crushed the 32-Bit generation and still messed up afterwards.
@jeffb.6642
@jeffb.6642 Жыл бұрын
@@diegoarmando5489 Possibly - but I think burning so much of their fans goodwill with the 32X and the Saturn is what hurt the DC. There was no saving the DC without having fans willing to buy it.
@marcelosoares7148
@marcelosoares7148 Жыл бұрын
Probably. If the Saturn had sold better, they would probably have the funds to put a DVD drive in the Dreamcast instead of the GD ROM which would help the console agaisnt the competitors.
@Charlie-eq3dj
@Charlie-eq3dj Жыл бұрын
Sorry to say but Sega had no chance after the Dreamcast. Microsoft with its deep pockets would have forced either Sega or Nintendo out one way or another. Nintendo has enough capital in the bank to sustain many years of loss but Sega didn't. The market is big enough for 3 major console manufacturers (almost barely) but not for 4. Someone had to go one way or another with the introduction of Microsoft into the gaming arena and it wasn't going to be Sony.
@loganford3921
@loganford3921 Жыл бұрын
If we don't get a Saturn mini then Sega should do a Sega Saturn collection. They have done Sega Mega Drive collection so many times so it would be a nice surprising change if it did happen.
@blakejohnson4713
@blakejohnson4713 Жыл бұрын
If Nintendo is going to gatekeep Snes collections, Sega should go the opposite route and just keep pumping out Saturn and Dreamcast collections cross-platform. If I could pay $29.99 for a 50 Saturn game collection, that shiz would be bought yesterday.
@FlyingDuckMan360
@FlyingDuckMan360 Жыл бұрын
@loganford3921 The games I'd like to see in the Saturn collection or the Saturn Mini: * Baku Baku Animal * Bug! 1 & 2. * Clockwork Knight 1 & 2 * Daytona USA * Fighting Vipers * Nights into Dreams * Sega Rally Champsionship * Sonic 3D Blast * Virtua Fighter 2
@StrelokBoggard
@StrelokBoggard Жыл бұрын
For some reason this episode got me nostalgic AF, the Saturn was the last console before me and my friends finish high school and went our separate ways. Somehow I feel that if the Saturn would’ve had last longer so would that era before responsibilities took over. I miss those times
@DhinCardoso
@DhinCardoso Жыл бұрын
I miss it too... Saturn was the last console before the adulthood ate my life and was the goodbye for my friends...
@rampantmjolnir
@rampantmjolnir Жыл бұрын
With a late 1995 worldwide release, Sega would've had access to the Hitachi SH3 at 45MHz or 60MHz for the CPU, and could've gone with a single 4MB pool of shared memory to cut costs and simplify the architecture. Revised VDP would need to use triangles as primitives and the include a z-buffer. Even without costly texture filtering, a z-buffer would provide an image quality edge over the PS1. Throw in a 4x CD-Rom for faster load times, launch with the 3D analog controller in the box, increase the internal save memory to 256KB, and pack-in Virtua Fighter 2 (JP), Sega Rally (EU), or a 2.5D Sonic game (USA). That's a very competitive product at $399 in 1995, and then price-drop to $299 before the N64 launches.
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt Жыл бұрын
Texture filtering comes from free on the N64 , while z-buffer does not. Now just give me a palette with 3 lookups per cycle. ( must be the reason that N64 does not bilinear ) ( Jaguar can do two lookups ).
@keyboard_g
@keyboard_g Жыл бұрын
There were so many consoles coming out in the mid 90’s. Even without missteps it would have been a tough battle.
@CaptainCaveman1170
@CaptainCaveman1170 Жыл бұрын
Microsoft's intentions to bully their way into gaming was certain death for SEGA...no matter how much we could imagine changing things. MS had effectively infinite resources and the will to use them. Eliminate Microsoft's console ambitions and the conceivable scenarios for SEGA are numerous.
@PutlerHuyIo
@PutlerHuyIo Жыл бұрын
​@@CaptainCaveman1170MS would probably just buy Sega if Sega was in healthy state come Xbox release.
@CaptainCaveman1170
@CaptainCaveman1170 Жыл бұрын
@@PutlerHuyIo They certainly had the option to, but I think they saw the sad financial state SEGA was in and said, we'll just gently squeeze them out of the chair. That was probably the best PR option for Microsoft imo because had they outright purchased SEGA, they would be known as the bully and tyrant that killed SEGA by many retro fans (even though they effectively WERE the bully that bought their way into SEGA's seat at the table, which killed SEGA as a console maker anyway).
@Thor-Orion
@Thor-Orion Жыл бұрын
Sega could have survived, they were in a really good position in 93-94. The launch of the 32x at the end of 94 was the start of the downfall. If they had done things differently they definitely could have survived the same way Nintendo has. Sony and Microsoft have outspent Nintendo by truckloads, but Nintendo making smart decisions has kept them in the market. With proper management there’s definitely a possibility Sega could have survived.
@HouseOfFunQM
@HouseOfFunQM Жыл бұрын
If SEGA had just put INSANE hype into the Saturn as the proper successor to the Mega Drive, definitely in England it would've done WAY better. Everybody here had a Mega Drive, we absolutely loved it!
@MatSpeedle
@MatSpeedle Жыл бұрын
It's crazy that many of these idea's sound like common sense with the benefit of hindsight. I love the Saturn and it deserved a lot more, even so still a great console that I still love to play to this day. I think with this approach Sega would have had a much better chance of staying in the fight.
@leonkent1365
@leonkent1365 Жыл бұрын
I think Sony and Nintendo could not believe their luck when SOJ and SOA were fighting.
@RetroGamerBB
@RetroGamerBB Жыл бұрын
To save Saturn in the west, they would have had to have made the Genesis games playable on the Saturn from the start via cart adapter or just using the cart layout from the Genesis. 32x would had to have been sheved and never launched.
@ultimateman55
@ultimateman55 Жыл бұрын
The only thing I might add is something you've mentioned in the past: Sega not expanding on and adapting their arcade releases for the home market the way Namco did. I like the idea of packing VF1 & 2 together, but I think additional content should have been added. Unlockable characters or cars, CG rendered endings, and additional gameplay modes would have beefed up many of Sega's home arcade releases and given them more replay value. I'd have loved to see VF, Daytona, and Sega Rally get the same treatment as Tekken and Ridge Racer.
@Megageoe
@Megageoe Жыл бұрын
The Saturn started with strong sales in Japan, even outselling the PlayStation in November/December 1994. I don't remember 1996 sales, but it was doing relatively well until Final Fantasy VII was announced and released for the PlayStation. I remember also hearing rumors at the time of Enix considering a Dragon Quest on the Saturn. Things could have turned out differently, at least in Japan if either Final Fantasy or Dragon Quest were available on the Saturn.
@KrGsMrNKusinagi0
@KrGsMrNKusinagi0 Жыл бұрын
saturn was a success in japan.. Achieved all the goals i thought it would here in the states.. Living in japan finding all the games we missed was depressing
@Megageoe
@Megageoe Жыл бұрын
Most of my Saturn games from 95-99 were imports, so for me it might still be considered one of my favorite systems. @@KrGsMrNKusinagi0
@HajimeNoJMo
@HajimeNoJMo Жыл бұрын
@@KrGsMrNKusinagi0then again, a lot of Saturn’s exclusives in Japan were just “too Japanese” to succeed worldwide
@darinherrick9224
@darinherrick9224 Жыл бұрын
@@HajimeNoJMo sure. But nowhere near the amount that were Japanese exclusive. Policenauts, Hyper Duel, Elan Doree, Kingdom Grand Prix, Radiant Silvergun, Battle Garegga. There’s amazing games that never should have been Japan exclusives. When Saturn was at its peak the biggest fans were importing games from Japan. That’s a complete disaster. Those people could have been buying two or three games released in their own country instead. But U.S. got mostly crap.
@HajimeNoJMo
@HajimeNoJMo Жыл бұрын
@@darinherrick9224 Yeah, X-Men VS Street Fighter was inexcusably Japan exclusive, and yet the rest of the world got the shitty ass PS1 port.
@joshoshea3194
@joshoshea3194 Жыл бұрын
I've been a fan of your channel for many years now but it's episodes like this that really prove that you know what you're talking about and not just an opinion. Not that it was ever in doubt of course. You know way more than me and i don't mind admitting it 👍
@neilmclean1527
@neilmclean1527 Жыл бұрын
All great ideas. What I think the Saturn really missed was a well documented SDK. 3rd party developers were left in the dark about how to get started with Saturn never mind how to get the best from it.
@eponymous7910
@eponymous7910 Жыл бұрын
This. If 3rd party devs had access to software libraries from launch the Saturn would've fared a hell of a lot better. And by launch I mean September, not May or whenever it was back in '95. A more polished Daytona alongside VF Remix would've been a killer one-two punch
@luishenriques5089
@luishenriques5089 Жыл бұрын
Along with SGL being properly shared to third parties instead of being kept only in-house would have helped a lot to make the Saturn more acessible.
@HydefHyde
@HydefHyde Жыл бұрын
Interesting video. I think your plan is pretty much spot on. I would only change a couple of things. I think that investing resources into that 3D accelerator expansion cartridge for the Genesis is a similar mistake to what the 32x was: spreading resources that could be better spent elsewhere as well as fragmenting the potential customer base. Instead, I would incorporate those resources into native backwards compatibility for the Saturn by including the Genesis ASIC chip on the motherboard, and further sweeten the deal by allowing it access to the consolidated Saturn VDP that you proposed. This would result in games that can be played on either Genesis or Saturn as the 16 bit console enters its final year, but with additional enhancements when played on the new system. This would entice new customers as well as allow us to continue to sell software to the existing Genesis customer base for another year while the Saturn gets started. A killer launch line-up for the Saturn (like you proposed), showcasing the new and exciting games while being backed by 6 years of backwards compatibility for Genesis games would have been very appealing.
@Pegfoxx
@Pegfoxx Жыл бұрын
Yes that would be a good move. Backwards compatibility I like the sound of that!
@roberto1519
@roberto1519 Жыл бұрын
I thought the SVP cart idea was just a mini 32X, like you say, we also know now, as the documentation of SEGA's sales figures are open to the public and available over the internet that people were hardly buying Genesis games by 1995 unfortunately, retail stores had a rigid policy for games companies and their profits weren't great, they also had many headaches from returns from a huge amount of unsatisfied costumers, so supporting 16-bit at that point was basically useless.
@SegaLordX
@SegaLordX Жыл бұрын
You aren't spreading resources thin with the SVP cart because it enhances software we already have in development. It is not a 32X replacement. Something like Montana 95 could have had a polygon stadium for instance. Enhancement at an incredibly low cost. It's also important to understand the Sega leak some months back was not about the Genesis not selling games, but rather Sega of America producing too many of them for retail space.
@roberto1519
@roberto1519 Жыл бұрын
​@@SegaLordX In all honesty, while many people and myself included enjoyed the Sega CD, the only good adapter\addon Sega ever released was the cheap Power Base. The Sega CD didn't return any meaningful profits, so while the idea of expanding SVP to the Genesis circa late 1994 onwards would just keep creating yet the same consumer confusion both the Sega CD and 32X did, specially since it was parents who bought these expensive electronics and games to their kids, mostly, they wouldn't even get the appeal of it, much less want to buy more hardware. Let's take the SNES, in the long run it sold basically 10 million more units than the Mega Drive, no CD addons or 32X expansion, just solid library to back it up and enhanced cartridges, this is important, consumers were still buying ONE cartridge, they didn't have to buy extra hardware to play ONE game on ONE console, the caps is not screaming is just to highlight what I find important here. I know most of us enjoy technicalities and expansions, I do myself, but from a marketing perspective, this just hurts your success as a company. My brother and I enjoyed DOOM first on the SNES and there was nothing like it for a 16-bit console, no matter what elitists say about the port, it was and still is amazing. Now let's imagine a SVP cart for the Genesis with DOOM, instead of the consumer requiring the 32X addon AND the cart, now we're confused. I believe that a SVP DOOM would be much better than the SNES release and even than the rushed 32X, specially if they had a decent amount of time to develop the game.
@maroon9273
@maroon9273 Жыл бұрын
​​@@roberto1519Samsung license and manufacturing cost from the svp made it very expensive. Sega could've collab Hitachi released a 2nd revision of the chip with a custom made Coprocessor. Which will be cheaper than the svp chip. I don't think doom on the svp would've been better than the 32x However, it would've been playable than the snes version
@ps3inquisition441
@ps3inquisition441 Жыл бұрын
It needed a Sonic game at launch. It needed to be backwards compatible with Sega CD/Genesis/32X. And it needed to launch at $299. Probably impossible, but we can dream.
@sneshead3326
@sneshead3326 Жыл бұрын
SEGA shouldn’t have wasted so much money on the tower of power SEGA CD, 32X etc. they should have gone straight from the mega drive/Genesis to the Saturn and then they might have stood a chance
@DarDarBinks1986
@DarDarBinks1986 10 ай бұрын
If Sega had me around, they'd have done just that: Gone straight to the Saturn AND made it backward-compatible with the Genesis library. Make a cartridge adapter if need be! Ditto releasing a proper Sonic game for the Saturn. Not having a Sonic game for the Saturn at launch is like Nintendo releasing a new console without a Mario game at launch. I like the idea of streamlining the schematics for the Saturn and removing the internal save battery. Why make a console hard to develop games for when you can make the programmers' jobs easier?
@JAGO_Tech
@JAGO_Tech Жыл бұрын
Something that gets overlooked often is the PS1 $299 didn't include a game or save method. The apples to apples was more $380 to $399. Marketing worked for Sony. Good point on memory cards.
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt Жыл бұрын
You know how prices for electronics went down at the time. Postpone as much hardware purchase as much as possible. Dunno why no CD included though.
@ClexYoshi
@ClexYoshi Жыл бұрын
I am glad that you addressed the human factor in this in the preamble, because that's the real thing that would need to be overcome; Ego. There's so many paths to take; the one where Sega and Sony actually team up, make gangbusters, and maybe instead of Samy merging with Sega down the road, we get SegaSony or something of that ilk. There's the one you chose, the one where something wildly different happened to sabotage Sega's competition and the Saturn just barely manages to squeak by in a 90's based video game crash? It all comes down to the individuals who played their roles and put their hearts and souls into the hardware and the software, and the differences of vision that were irreconcilable. There's so many impossible moving parts; courting third parties that had their own things going on at the time, system architecture and getting everyone on the same page on how to best utilize VDP1 and VDP2, even getting consistent vision between Japan and Sega's overseas subsidiaries.
@jmartin1885
@jmartin1885 Жыл бұрын
Who in their right mind thinks, "We'll develop The Sega Saturn!!! Then decides to put the development of the 32X 'Smack' in the path of the Sega Saturn??? I was heavily invested in the Mega Drive and the Mega-CD... And to hear news of the Saturn, was amazing! Then to hear news of the 32x, and it reason for even existing, made Zero sense to me, even then! There was no way on earth, would I buy an 'Interim' console, until the Saturn arrived... I was perfectly happy with the Mega CD, and would sit-on my cash and wait!
@matthewponce1942
@matthewponce1942 Жыл бұрын
I always have this idea that, in an ideal world where Sega wouldn't mind to delay a game; maybe Sonic 3 (as a whole and not split into two) could be a groundbreaking launch title. I mean, S&K was launched just one month before the saturn in Japan.
@MacUser2-il2cx
@MacUser2-il2cx Жыл бұрын
But then you had all 4 games in a collection on one disc for Saturn. I like the idea of doing that for certain collections. Japan even got a collection for Disney games, Phantasy Star games, and even Columns.
@PutlerHuyIo
@PutlerHuyIo Жыл бұрын
Sonic 3 was too primitive for a 32 bit platform. Gaming journos would bombard Sega with critical pieces like "There's no reason to upgrade"
@MacUser2-il2cx
@MacUser2-il2cx Жыл бұрын
@@PutlerHuyIo It looked good for a 16 bit game. A lot of 32X games looked the same as Genesis games so that was a common thing to say.
@maroon9273
@maroon9273 Жыл бұрын
Sonic 3 and knuckles don't even need the svp chip. Just release both of them later in 1994 or just release the cancelled limited edition (one cart) for new genesis users the same time as sonic and knuckles lock-on cart.
@MacUser2-il2cx
@MacUser2-il2cx Жыл бұрын
@@maroon9273 Sonic 3 Complete was a great way to do it.
@bigedwerd
@bigedwerd Жыл бұрын
I'm going to jump ahead before watching the full video because I love this topic. The answer is very simple: let Tom Kalinske do his thing. He was in talks with Silicon Graphics to get their 64 bit chip that ended up instead going to Nintendo and he was trying to work with Sony to make a Sega/Sony system. People who were too stubborn to listen just got in the way. Imagine a 64 bit version of the ps1 and that's what the Saturn could have been. Instead of the N64 we probably would have gotten the Ultra Nintendo as a 32 bit cartridge based system and the Playstation wouldn't have been a thing other than architecture-wise going to the Saturn so all of the great titles Sony got would most likely have gone to Sega/Sony.
@retromacman620
@retromacman620 Жыл бұрын
Love this and I think your ideas are spot on. Of the Saturn had been easier to develop for and Sega hadn't wasted time and money on the 32x things might have been different.
@ShadowEl
@ShadowEl Жыл бұрын
The thumbnail really says it all. I understand SEGA letting Naka's Sonic Team division do whatever they wanted creatively...but given their name, they should have been mandated to produce a Sonic game FIRST, then move onto passion projects like NiGHTS and Burning Rangers. Never has the disconnect, if not full on rivalry between SEGA HQ and SEGA of America been more clear as SEGA's Japanese executives and creatives not deeming it absolutely necessary to have a proper flagship Sonic game ready within the first year of Saturn's life. I don't think a 2D Sonic a la Chaotix (which was prototyped as a Sonic game to begin with, with Mighty essentially being a Sonic reskin) would have done the job either. They needed 3D Sonic and they needed it before or around when Nintendo was unleashing Mario in 3D.
@JamesChessman
@JamesChessman Жыл бұрын
I think NiGHTS is the 3D Sonic game that Saturn needed but obviously it didn’t work out right for most people apparently
@speedyink
@speedyink Жыл бұрын
Did you stumble across the leaked documents from Sega from around the Saturns time period? The look into behind the scenes is so fascinating. They knew things were bad, but they just couldn't sort their shit
@UltimateGamerCC
@UltimateGamerCC Жыл бұрын
especially not when they were infighting, rather than the American and Japanese markets working in unison, they struggled and had conflicts with each other.
@protocetid
@protocetid Жыл бұрын
Had my fingers crossed those documents would be addressed in the video.
@GANGRELION
@GANGRELION Жыл бұрын
That was a nice thought exercise. Now you have to make part 2: "How would you have saved the Dreamcast". And then part 3: "What would've come next for Sega if the Dreamcast had succeeded". Looking forward for it! 👍
@burgerinabox6063
@burgerinabox6063 Жыл бұрын
For the Genesis, I think they should have pushed the Sega Channel for more areas/have more software, it was decently priced and if they added more games, got more subscribers, and maybe utilized your 3D Accelerator idea, they could have kept the Genesis busy with much fewer dedicated resources.
@GeomancerHT
@GeomancerHT Жыл бұрын
A 3D accelerator, like, the 32-X?
@djhenyo
@djhenyo Жыл бұрын
@@GeomancerHT No, that was a co-processor. Not a single piece of circuitry in the 32X was designed exclusively for computing textures, triangles, or anything else found in 3D graphics.
@burgerinabox6063
@burgerinabox6063 Жыл бұрын
@@toby2581 That is true, but maybe they could have made a bundle with phone companies to deliver SC with their help. All hypothetical though, and your answer would probably still stand no matter the "what if" scenario.
@UltimateGamerCC
@UltimateGamerCC Жыл бұрын
i still miss SEGA Channel, 3 years of memories.
@WhatsOnMyShelf
@WhatsOnMyShelf Жыл бұрын
Maybe, if they did something with AOL, that would help give Sega a first-movers advantage getting consoles online.
@matthewfunk6435
@matthewfunk6435 Жыл бұрын
I love the idea for this video. I think about this era a lot and what went wrong. Your timeline is both amazing and sad cause we won’t see it 😢. Sega lord your ideas are absolutely on point you clearly did your homework
@joshcurrie7781
@joshcurrie7781 Жыл бұрын
Eternal Champions 3D on the Saturn would be unbelievable. E.C. Challenge from the Darkside is my favorite 2D fighter!
@dnmstarsi
@dnmstarsi Жыл бұрын
Same. Sega of Japan should've tried to focus on more than one fighter even though E.C. was a Mortal Kombat klone.
@maroon9273
@maroon9273 Жыл бұрын
Saturn will have enough firepower to compete with battle toshiden and tekken.
@apollolux
@apollolux Жыл бұрын
The two most important decisions you propose in this video that I definitely agree with are Sega not competing with itself and making sure there's a proper Sonic game on the Saturn at or near launch. Almost everything else seems to be kind of "obvious-in-hindsight" decisions in comparison to those two, and in aggregate probably more important than having a launch Sonic or no 32X but nowhere near as important when taken individually.
@Abesteroni
@Abesteroni Жыл бұрын
I totally agree that Genesis backward compatibility should have been a must, as it was a no-brainer for other consoles that included this, such as the PS2 and Wii. As far as needing a Power Base 2 adapter goes, I don't know that it would be totally required if the cartridge slot were shaped properly and not a two edge connector split, and the processor configuration of the Saturn itself could do the job of a stand alone 315-5960 ASIC if it were configured differently, with backward compatibility factored in at the inception of development, further saving costs. Either that, or maybe a 315-5950 expansion card that adds backward compatibility and other specific chips to the Saturn via the rear expansion port. The same goes for the Sega CD, no reason not to be backward compatible with that as well. I also agree with the cancellation and shift of all 32X development, the Saturn as a standalone flagship going into the late 1990's should have been the move.
@Memelord1117
@Memelord1117 Жыл бұрын
The saturn could've been presented as a mix of the n64 and ps1, attracting BOTH CD players and the old cartridge players.
@Abesteroni
@Abesteroni Жыл бұрын
@@Memelord1117 indeed- if the Saturn was designed to be both forward thinking and deeply backward compatible all the way back to the Master System via Power Base converter (once again, by having a unified, non-split edge connector input to the main board itself) it would have been an absolute boon for Sega fans in the late 90's.
@Memelord1117
@Memelord1117 Жыл бұрын
@@Abesteroni What do you think the sales for the big 3 could've been in this alternate timeline? For me: PS1: 70-90 mil N64: 35-45 mil Sega Saturn: 35-50 mil
@Abesteroni
@Abesteroni Жыл бұрын
@@Memelord1117 I would imagine that the numbers would look something like that, since the winner of a given generation usually provides the path of least resistance to games people want to play. Even with different CPU/GPU tech under the hood, using CD's, low licensing fees, and a lower entry point to the consumer, they won the generation because all those latter factors were lucrative and attractive for both consumers and developers/publishers alike.
@projectmayhem6898
@projectmayhem6898 Жыл бұрын
Thanks!
@eversosleight
@eversosleight Жыл бұрын
I really hope they release the Saturn Mini 🤞 Great video!
@voteDC
@voteDC Жыл бұрын
A Saturn mini would be nice but it's not likely to happen at the price people expect to pay for the Mini consoles. Saturn emulation is pretty fantastic at this point but it's also quite resource demanding.
@PutlerHuyIo
@PutlerHuyIo Жыл бұрын
​@@voteDCRaspberry Pi 5 (a $60 device) can now emulate Saturn pretty well, unlike it's predecessor Pi 4. Not to mention Raspberry Pi Foundation will probably release a 2gb version for like $40 in near future (emulators don't give a fuck about RAM anyways, it's all about brute CPU power)
@shivasthong4924
@shivasthong4924 Жыл бұрын
@@PutlerHuyIo the fact a 30 year old console still isnt fully emulated.
@mrlaidback83
@mrlaidback83 Жыл бұрын
And a Dreamcast Mini as well.
@TheNameIsSR
@TheNameIsSR Жыл бұрын
​@@shivasthong4924it is, but it needs relatively powerful hardware
@klocks2543
@klocks2543 Жыл бұрын
This was a really fun video idea. All your knowledge of the hardware architecture and understanding of SEGA’s game development made it something special though!
@Charlie-eq3dj
@Charlie-eq3dj Жыл бұрын
1. Make the Saturn backwards compatible with the Genesis/Sega CD/ 32X. This allows 2 different generations of hardware to enjoy the same games expanding the customer base rather than diminishing it that has traditionally been done with each generation up until the PS2 changed that. 2. Release better development tools for the Saturn including the ability to do proper transparencies. 3. Do NOT release the Saturn during E3 which soured relationship with retailers. 4. Do not rush games and give customers a bang for their buck. No more games with 3-4 tracks or levels.
@feljerdm3021
@feljerdm3021 4 ай бұрын
Cries in ManxTT
@TheSeventhForce
@TheSeventhForce Жыл бұрын
Okay, that thumbnail is incredible. Great work as always!
@powerfulaura5166
@powerfulaura5166 Жыл бұрын
Really great video, but I would like to request that when you reference Crash Bandicoot in the future, please get capture of the PS1 originals rather than using footage of - & implicitly equating them w/ - the N. Sane Trilogy remakes like @ 15:15 & in your old _Saturn's Would-Be Mascots_ video.
@jomarsharpe958
@jomarsharpe958 Жыл бұрын
SLX, you are a genius my friend. The ideas and concepts you've presented put a smile on my face as if this couldve really happened. I LOVED my Sega Saturn when I got it and I chose it over the PS1 because I was a HARDCORE SEGA FAN!!!! Just imagine my disappointment to get this system and it tanked not too long after it was released. It put a bitter taste in my mouth with Sega and I jumped ship to Playstation, but I always had love for Sega from the 80s in the arcades, to the Genesis, to the Saturn. I didn't get a Dreamcast because of the history with the Saturn so needless to say I was still bitter years later. This is one of your best videos yet and it brings back the memories of playing my Saturn on Friday nights while everyone was asleep and I'm up to the wee hours of the morning. Same with the Genesis :) Keep the amazing videos coming
@frankflores6793
@frankflores6793 Жыл бұрын
You're 100 correct about it needing to be backwards compatible with the Genesis. That probably would have put it in the number one spot.
@Autotrope
@Autotrope Жыл бұрын
As soon as I invent the flux capacitor you're the first person im sending back in time. Cant wait to see what the dreamcast 2 and dreamcast 3 looked like and whether would have meant no xbox
@blubbntroet
@blubbntroet Жыл бұрын
Knowing how it all went I can imagine your steps could have made a differnece! Had a MegaDrive as a kid and wanted the Saturn so much but soon I learned about the N64. It’s just been the bigger brother that made the difference that’s been the PlayStation that our parents got us. Games looked better, friends already had the PSX and lets not forget the Saturn was more expensive 😕
@PrimeStarStudios
@PrimeStarStudios Жыл бұрын
You pretty much hit the nail on the head with this one, SLX. I wish that things were different back then, so Sega can continue to live on as a console manufacturer.
@jessicasretrolunacy
@jessicasretrolunacy Жыл бұрын
I think the Power Base 2 is brilliant. I'd have taken it a step further and made the Saturn backward compatible with Sega CD games. Those games were highly profitable compared to cartridges, Sega could've raked in extra software sales, extended goodwill to those who bought Sega CD hardware, and made it easy to upgrade Genesis titles to play on Saturn for those who didn't already own the big hits. What I would change from your strategy is the SVP chip; scrap the Genesis version and bring a version of it to the Saturn, with a massive RAM upgrade for near-perfect arcade ports. Having the CD quality sound of the PlayStation and the fast loading of the N64 by using an arcade RAM upgrade could've been a huge flex for Sega and made the Saturn more unique, instead of being seen more as a lesser PlayStation.
@atomicskull6405
@atomicskull6405 Жыл бұрын
Adding the Master System graphics modes to the Genesis's VDP are why they left out the originally planned sprite scaling and cut the color pallets in half to 4x16. They had enough space on the die for one or the other and chose backwards compatibility over making a better VDP. The Power Base convertor was just a slot adaptor the Genesis was hardware compatible with Master System games already, but at the cost of the afore mentioned sprite scaling and 8x16 color pallets as well as the extra 64k of VRAM. The VDP can actually use two 64K banks of VRAM which doubles the number of tiles as well as halving VRAM access speed because the VRAM is now twice as wide and the tiles are interleaved across both banks. The Z-80 and it's4k increased manufacturing costs to to make up for that they removed the second 64k bank of VRAM.
@jessicasretrolunacy
@jessicasretrolunacy Жыл бұрын
@@atomicskull6405 True, but that doesn't mean it had to be the same case of sacrifice with the Saturn playing Genesis games, especially were it streamlined and optimized in a way like SLX suggested.
@Sensei.shonuff
@Sensei.shonuff Жыл бұрын
This is probably the most creative concept ive seen in any video game channel
@gtocool99
@gtocool99 Жыл бұрын
On SVP chip idea you propose, i also proposed it to a friend group, because the success the Snes had implementing those chips on their last gen games. Had it been an cheap add on I could have waited a big longer that extra year.
@geneares5063
@geneares5063 Жыл бұрын
Excellent work! I am in total concurrence with your assessment. I've said this for years in conversations with my friend. Bravo and salute, good sir!
@MimosaSector
@MimosaSector Жыл бұрын
You nailed it. Great job SLX!
@Monacomaverick
@Monacomaverick Жыл бұрын
Complicated hardware or not, Sega really needed more 3rd party cross-platform games in 1997, like Tomb Raider 2, Formula 1, NFS 2, Road Rash 3D, and Wipeout XL in the US. It also should have had arcade perfect ports of Return of Death Adder and Outrunners. Many Japanese exclusives could have come to the US since they were already in English. The US Saturn library is laughable when compared to its home of origin. It needed more quality software.
@Des_Zee
@Des_Zee Жыл бұрын
Out of all the changes you listed, I think the backwards compatibility with the Genesis/Mega Drive would've been the most important game changer.
@thaneros
@thaneros Жыл бұрын
Bruh, I really think back compat would have done so much to the life of the Saturn. It would have been groundbreaking as it would have been the first modern console to do so.
@protocetid
@protocetid Жыл бұрын
@@thanerosIn an interview, a person who worked on the Saturn said part of Sega wanted to use a newer 68k processor to have backwards compatibility. As someone who isn’t adept at tech specs would that have been a good choice of CPU? Looks like you’re right about no home console having backwards compatibility back then, to no one’s surprise PC did. PC has always been the reigning champion for playing the games of the past.
@maxxdahl6062
@maxxdahl6062 Жыл бұрын
That would have priced the system out of competition sadly. And there was no reason to include the genesis hardware other than backwards compatibility, it wouldn't have run anything in the saturn architecture other than genesis games.
@protocetid
@protocetid Жыл бұрын
@@maxxdahl6062 Could’ve ran 32X games too no? Had they included Genesis/MD parts and the SH2 CPUs it has launched with wouldn’t it have been like a beefier 32X?
@maxxdahl6062
@maxxdahl6062 Жыл бұрын
@@protocetid But there was no reason for it to be there other than backwards compatibility, on a system that was already 100 bucks more expensive than the PS1, that would have shot the price up to 2 to 3 hundred more. No one would have chosen a saturn over a PS1 at that point, even 100 bucks more was a bit of a tall ask, but still doable.
@TheReviewRevolution
@TheReviewRevolution Жыл бұрын
I wouldn't have given up. In 1997 I would not have said "Saturn is not our future". Third parties were the king makers of the fifth generation. Coming out and all but admitting your system was dead means there was no hope of Saturn getting a rising from the ashes moment like the Genesis did when Sonic arrived. When we saw the fourth gen arms race with Nintendo really heat up. I always saw Sega as the scrappy underdog in the market, and loved them for it. I believe that if Sega got up from the dirt, dust themselves off, and hit back with a BIG solid marketing campaign, maybe an Arcade at Home pack in that included an exclusive set of Virtua games like Virtua SoR ( Street of Rage), Virtua Agent ( A light gun spy game) , and Virtua Hoops ( Streetball game for the sports fans) OR ATLEAST get ground breaking Sonic 2.5 platformer out. Something that says "The Saturn is hot! Third parties you want to want to be a part of this!' Maybe the Dreamcast didn't have to do what the Saturn couldn't.
@EastyyBlogspot
@EastyyBlogspot Жыл бұрын
When I look back I just think how different things would be with simple changes...like better 3d hardware and easier development with Saturn, ram bump for Psone, larger texture cache for N64
@dan_loup
@dan_loup Жыл бұрын
The N64 texture cache is twice as big as the PS1, but it's 10 times dumber. Just making it smarter would go a long way. Now another thing that would help the N64 immensely would be some sort of cache or arbitrer circuit between the GPU and the memory. As it is, the CPU and video chip (and parts of the video chip) are constantly fighting for the memory in a way it gets WAY slower than it should. The memory is quite fast at reading data sequentially, like address 1,2,3,4,5,6... because it has a internal memory counter that gets incremented on each read or write. however, as its a 32bit memory counter and the memory itself is 8bit, you have to make 4 writes to the memory every time you want to jump to another part of the memory, and its very easy to get in a situation where both the video chip and the CPU want to access completely different parts of the memory, and they end up doing an address war that dramatically reduce the memory speed. Now if you had something that went "now now, let it read a bit THEN you jump and read a bit", you would reduce this fight
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt Жыл бұрын
@@dan_loupI thought that every CPU insisted on the ability to write single bytes? Why would RDRAM have this 8 bit databus, but still insist on alignment like it was a Jaguar? And what is the problem with the shared RAM. In a typical game loop things run more or less sequentially. Anything else adds latency. CPU could do NPCs or streaming while RCP uses RAM.
@dan_loup
@dan_loup Жыл бұрын
​@@ArneChristianRosenfeldt First, the CPU mostly read and write and work from it's internal cache, so being able to do 8 or 32bits etc don't impact the RAM. Now the ram is 8bit because it is the whole point of the RDRAM. instead of having this wide 32bit bus operating at 133Mhz, you get this 8bit (9 actually) bus running at 500Mhz, so you need to use less pins in the PCB and chips at a cost of some latency. And finally, both the CPU filling the cache and most video operations are totally sequential, but the system let both happen at the same time, which makes it completely non-sequential as you get two devices trying to make sequential accesses in two different spots of the memory at the same time.
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt Жыл бұрын
@@dan_loup probably the blender has the same cacheline size as the CPU. The cache on a miss probably wants to load the whole line. The 9th bit is invisible to CPU, RSP, TMEM. It is such a waste. For only 9 bits the N64 has quite a lot of pins. I wonder if the CPU has to wait on its own cache before it can read elsewhere?
@dan_loup
@dan_loup Жыл бұрын
@@ArneChristianRosenfeldt You can and should make the CPU stay as much as possible in it's cache, but it's not mandatory.
@rayaspo4893
@rayaspo4893 Жыл бұрын
I remember trading in a ps1 for a sega saturn in 1996 because I so wanted to play sega rally. The look I got from the guy at electronics boutique was epic. I don’t regret that trade I found some absolute gems I would have never got to play. Good times
@Memelord1117
@Memelord1117 Жыл бұрын
What kind of look was it?
@rayaspo4893
@rayaspo4893 Жыл бұрын
@@Memelord1117 😂 like this guy is mental, I don’t think anyone else at that time even considered doing that trade as the Saturn was basically dead at that point.
@jongeo
@jongeo Жыл бұрын
You'd have to get in there in like 1993 to prevent the 32X from existing. The amount of unsold stock they had for consoles at the time the saturn launched was NUTS.
@SegaLordX
@SegaLordX Жыл бұрын
I was thinking this would have to start late 92, early 93 at the latest. The changes to the Saturn itself needed time.
@griffgames9538
@griffgames9538 Жыл бұрын
Think of all the Hitachi chips the 32X was cannibalizing from production volume for the Saturn. The 32X's existence literally made the Saturn harder to reasonably price at launch and during its first year, because chipset production volume cost reductions couldn't happen for Saturn while so many chips were being allocated to 32X. Ironic, considering the catastrophic losses Sega incurred on unsold 32X hardware within a year of its launch.
@jongeo
@jongeo Жыл бұрын
@@griffgames9538 Compared with Sony using their own chips at cost.
@maxxdahl6062
@maxxdahl6062 Жыл бұрын
@@griffgames9538 Weren't they different chips with different clock speeds?
@Evercade_Effect
@Evercade_Effect Жыл бұрын
This video was a lot of fun, and the changes you would make, I agree with 100%.
@parazels83
@parazels83 Жыл бұрын
They should have gotten together their best developers and ask them, how to build the next gen console. I read, Sega's internal R&D teams were very atomized, they didn't share their experience at all.
@IronicSonic83
@IronicSonic83 Жыл бұрын
Just a few teams at Sega could do 3D games. That's why Sega decided to go with 2D in the first place
@atomicskull6405
@atomicskull6405 Жыл бұрын
Sega was offered what would eventually become the N64, the group of SGI engineers that developed it went to Sega first and Sega turned them down.
@maroon9273
@maroon9273 Жыл бұрын
​@@atomicskull6405plus, they had a opportunity to wait and let yuzuki and Lockheed Martin or nvidia (nv2 project) design the saturn hardware.
@joshuasanderson7359
@joshuasanderson7359 Жыл бұрын
There is a cultural difference between developers in Japan and the West. Often features will be reimplemented and not shared and work and ideas not shared between programmers in Japanese titles. Not sure why it was that way, but it is changing as Japan is more internationally integrated
@registereduser
@registereduser Жыл бұрын
From a visual standpoint, even as a Nintendo fanboy back in the day, the double stack CD unit under the Genesis just looked so cool to me.
@keyboard_g
@keyboard_g Жыл бұрын
A beefier VDP would have been a tall order. Just remembering the marvel the N64 was to get the SGI technology into a console. They were leagues ahead of everyone.
@shiru8bit
@shiru8bit Жыл бұрын
And even with that, N64 architecture, while is really much streamlined compared to the Saturn's, is still a major headache to deal with. PS1 was much easier.
@blazingsoulhunter2862
@blazingsoulhunter2862 Жыл бұрын
I love what you have thought up for the Sega Saturn in an alternate universe. It won’t always be smooth sailing for Sega of course, even Sega will have it’s fair share of troubles. So, things are still not absolutely perfect, even in an alternate universe. But it’s fun to think about though for video games, movies/TV shows and books. And yes, there would be some things I’d like to see with the Saturn too. Like having Namco and SquareSoft supporting the Saturn and a few more titles being released until the early 2000’s.
@blazingsoulhunter2862
@blazingsoulhunter2862 Жыл бұрын
And yes, I agree the 32X should have been cancelled in favor of the Sega Saturn. That way, Sega won’t compete for itself.
@Dorelaxen
@Dorelaxen Жыл бұрын
Simply listening to what Tom Kalinske had to say about the Saturn in general would have gone a long way, that's for sure.
@midwestmonster9886
@midwestmonster9886 Жыл бұрын
"We do not want to compete with ourselves." That's the key difference. Sega defeated Sega.
@mikeclark4480
@mikeclark4480 Жыл бұрын
Loved your changes. Well thought out and could have been accomplished. A Saturn that competes with Sony might have been enough to keep MS out of the console market and would have pushed the Dreamcast out to 2000 or 2001. Everybody wins Great video and thank you again.
@denraimei32
@denraimei32 Жыл бұрын
And since Microsoft owns Windows, they would likely push for PC gaming instead.
@DarDarBinks1986
@DarDarBinks1986 10 ай бұрын
Speaking of the Dreamcast, Sega was nuts for not using DVDs for the games. That proprietary GD-ROM format was never necessary. It damn well didn't stop piracy, as the Dreamcast became one of the easiest consoles to pirate games for. And when the PS2 came around, anyone who bought it had both a game system and a DVD player in one convenient package. VHS was already on its way out and why have separate standalone game consoles and DVD players when you can have both for the price of one? Sega should have embraced DVDs if they wanted the Dreamcast to be more competitive.
@rsreston
@rsreston Жыл бұрын
I think this is one of your best episodes. And I was quite surprised at how bold you were. Great script, sharp delivery and commentary on games that's relevant for the fans :D
@SegaLordX
@SegaLordX Жыл бұрын
Glad you enjoyed it. It took me awhile to get it just right and it was really fun making it. Seems man would like a DC version of this fantasy. I might just try it.
@rsreston
@rsreston Жыл бұрын
@@SegaLordX I'd love to see that DC version! 💪🏻
@InitialDL84
@InitialDL84 Жыл бұрын
Love this video and your thoughts man, I agree with pretty much everything you mentioned. I'd even go as far as say that Sega could've done without the Sega CD as well, and just went with that 3D accelerator you mentioned, up until the release of the Saturn. Would love for you to do something similar for the Dreamcast!
@maroon9273
@maroon9273 Жыл бұрын
Even a scaler chip prior to the SVP Cart. Plus, publish and developed CD games for PC and Multimedia devices.😢
@willymagi9253
@willymagi9253 Жыл бұрын
You’re interview on Shiro was great! You’re story really resinated with me and is very much serving me as a source of inspiration! Thank you for being so honest, you definitely touched at least this guys life.
@SegaLordX
@SegaLordX Жыл бұрын
Glad you enjoyed it. Those are good people over there. I wish more would watch them.
@1515jet
@1515jet Жыл бұрын
Man, launching with a real Sonic game, Streets of rage 4 and Star Wars arcade would of been a game changer for Sega.
@shiru8bit
@shiru8bit Жыл бұрын
It likely would be a game changer even without any changes to the whole other story, with the same hardware etc.
@stevecain4497
@stevecain4497 Жыл бұрын
You've pretty much nailed it with this video! The only thing I would do differentl that I can think of would be to try to shoe horn in Mega CD / Sega CD compatibility as well as Mega Drive / Genesis into the Saturn. Then, reduce the price of the Sega CD software and you have an immediate line of "wallet friendly" priced titles ready to be sold along side the new software which would help Sega & retailers clear the old Sega CD game stock, while keeping new owners buying software during the early launch window when there aren't many new games coming to market.
@magiccardmaker3588
@magiccardmaker3588 Жыл бұрын
Image if SEGA had a crazy idea and rereleased their systems and games into the retro gaming market using this as a blueprint for the release.
@rancid_
@rancid_ Жыл бұрын
Omg, well-done! This was way better of a strategy, im sure some of these were discussed but have a feeling the conflicts between the two internal companies caused many stalemates.
@jsttv
@jsttv Жыл бұрын
All of your ideas are spot on. The Saturn would have lasted longer, and sold more. In addition, to your ideas: Have North America have all the Capcom 4MB ram cart games. X-Men vs Street Fighter ran rings around the Sony PlayStation version.
@octacores7878
@octacores7878 Жыл бұрын
Sega was always one step behind
@tidepoolclipper8657
@tidepoolclipper8657 Жыл бұрын
Nintendo tried to stubbornly stick with the NES, but the Genesis was easily outselling it. So for a short time, Sega was outdoing Nintendo.
@griffgames9538
@griffgames9538 Жыл бұрын
... they were always 5 steps ahead in the arcade.
@hammerheadms
@hammerheadms Жыл бұрын
You're hired. Now get in the Delorean and tell Tom Kalinske he's been replaced.
@luishenriques5089
@luishenriques5089 Жыл бұрын
Imagine if the Saturn had an Echo the Dolphin game with Nights into Dreams graphics, Eternal Champions with the VF2 engine but with gore, if we got the canceled Streets of Rage 4 by Core, Sonic Jam as a full 3D game released early on or at least in 96, 3D Vectorman that played similar to Burning Rangers as well, a proper single player 3D Phantasy Star game with the same graphics engine of Panzer Dragoon Saga (if released before, or around the same time of FF7 could have been a more direct competitor and a tremendous looker), 3D Altered Beast, Toejam and Earl, ESWAT... One can dream of that...
@LuSanification
@LuSanification Жыл бұрын
A 3D 32 bit Phantasy Star game would have been a dream at the time
@titantim
@titantim Жыл бұрын
I always felt that Sega shot itself in the foot by trying to be first to market. Genesis before the SNES, Saturn (and 32x) before the PS, Dreamcast before the PS2. It always came back to bite them in the butt, as the competition always had more power.
@kenterminateddq5311
@kenterminateddq5311 Жыл бұрын
Sega Lord, I can't wait for the "Let's Save The Sega Dreamcast!" video. :)
@dr.decker3623
@dr.decker3623 Жыл бұрын
This is it though,.. if the Saturn was saved, the Dreamcast would have followed suit... Too bad they wasted time and money with the 32X, Genesis rev3, Nomad, Game Gear, and the Sega CDX prior to the Saturn though...
@WhatsOnMyShelf
@WhatsOnMyShelf Жыл бұрын
Launching at $299 would mean an even bigger loss in what was spent on hardware, even foregoing the investment of the 32X entirely while stretching thin the support of Sega Genesis and Sega CD, especially with those pack-ins. Getting investors to continue taking a loss while building support for the Sega brand through another entire generation would be hopeful. Those investors would have to believe Sega would get the advantage in the gen following Saturn. It's a good plan that would make the consumer happy, but might stretch thin support from investors.
@retroblitz3533
@retroblitz3533 Жыл бұрын
Great video, I agree with everything and would only make one change. As part of the hardware changes, I'd make the cart slot compatible with MegaDrive software along with enabling the Saturn to play Mega CD games. When I first had my Saturn back in the day, I was surprised it wasn't back compatible. My brother still uses his MegaDrive to play his Master System games 😊.
@ericl7519
@ericl7519 Жыл бұрын
Best presentation I've seen in a long time.That blueprint would have definitely extended Sega's hardware ambitions.
@Funkysauce
@Funkysauce Жыл бұрын
As people have been saying, you have to do one of these videos for the Dreamcast! My Saturn experience is what led me to go with PSX but I was back on the Sega train big time with the Dreamcast.
@jeffreys431
@jeffreys431 Жыл бұрын
I really enjoyed this video, it was well thought out, some excellent ideas. One caveat, include backward compatibility with 16bit carts right out of the gate. That would have been VERY appealing for me. A huge library of games you can play on your new system day one.
@slashrose3287
@slashrose3287 Жыл бұрын
Various things to say, let's recap: 1) SVP cart was indeed planned (along with even Daytona USA!), then it was scrapped and a standalone VR cart was made instead; 2) Almost surely SS project was with a single SH2 with actual VDP1: after Sony PSX specs was announced, Sega "cleverly" thought was to added a second SH2 and a separate VDP2 --> surely a dual CPU was a bit off for that time (althought we should remember Model 1 & 2 arcade board got almost 10 CPUs/DSP each, so Sega was ready to develop on multi-processor board), the PROBLEM was/is the reduced bus size between CPU(s) and VDP1, which does NOT allow contemporary data flow from BOTH CPU due to being too small (it was, again, planned as a single CPU, NOT dual, BIG mistake); also, different VDPs got incompatibilities (VDP2 image "cover" VDP1 image, see famous Low Score Boy SS tech video for details) and FINALLY, choosing stretced QUAD texture instead of triangle wireframe rendering was a BAD situation from the start, just for the fact you cannot properly do specular 3D effects like alpha blending (I know recent XL2 work, but this situation mainly remains the same). "Fun" fact: Namco(T) was ACTUALLY developing 3D conversion for SS (see Cybersled SS prototype around on Ebay), then Sega rivaltry won (another stupid situation / mistake from Sega, again...) and they became first party PSX developer (well done Sega..).
@erwanlecainec3394
@erwanlecainec3394 Жыл бұрын
If the Saturn had been successful everywhere in the world, the quads wouldn't have been a problem and developers would have gone this way. Quads became a problem as soon as PlayStation was based on triangles and everyone, players like developers, decided to choose the Sony brand. PlayStation 2 was the least developer-friendly system of its generation, it has been the most successful system worldwide. If Saturn had taken a good lead at the beginning of their life spans, who knows what 3D development style could have won the favours of the industry ?
@maxxdahl6062
@maxxdahl6062 Жыл бұрын
The model 1 and 2 arcade hardware also ran on quads, so i can see why they went with that, that's what sega knew.
@MCSquishyTooshy
@MCSquishyTooshy Жыл бұрын
This was absolutely fantastic!!! It’s nice to see that you’re coming up with fresh ideas. Excellent video!!!
@jahdorose8659
@jahdorose8659 Жыл бұрын
I agree with everything u mentioned also having a new street of rage sequel and golden axe probably would of helped
@stephensheehan8107
@stephensheehan8107 Жыл бұрын
I think there is 1 thing they could have done. Buy Core Design…. As they had a very strong relationship. It would have kept them in the war
@jeffb.6642
@jeffb.6642 Жыл бұрын
Another missed opportunity was not having the Saturn be backwards compatible with Genesis/MD/32X and Sega CD games.
@griffgames9538
@griffgames9538 Жыл бұрын
Yes, especially for the US/European market where the Genesis/MD was a massive hit with many users having large game libraries -- the Saturn cartridge slot should've supported Genesis/MD carts in full backwards compatibility. That would have completely changed the Saturn's appeal with western audiences.
@jeffb.6642
@jeffb.6642 Жыл бұрын
@@griffgames9538 Yea I saw he briefly touched on it near the end of the video after I posted my comment. My idea for it would have meant no extra adapters or hardware required - just design the RAM Expansion slot to also accept Genesis games like you said and since it already had a CD drive, enabling it to play Sega CD games shouldn't have been difficult either.
@avalond1193
@avalond1193 Жыл бұрын
32x was not needed and waste of resources
@maxxdahl6062
@maxxdahl6062 Жыл бұрын
That would have priced the system out of competition that was already 100 bucks more expensive than PS1. at 2 or 3 hundred more than PS1 costs no one would have bought it.
@maxxdahl6062
@maxxdahl6062 Жыл бұрын
@@toby2581 That and most people like myself that were going to make the jump into the saturn in the mid-90's already had a genesis set up going. There's too little return on what the costs would have been.
@48hourrecordsteam45
@48hourrecordsteam45 Жыл бұрын
Your ideas would have definitely saved the Saturn . Because it all made sense
@thomaspleacher2735
@thomaspleacher2735 Жыл бұрын
11:35 In a recent interview with fans, Tom Kalinske said that Sega of America spoke with Nvidia and saw their work-in-progress 3D accelerator cards when the Saturn wasn't out yet. However, Sega of Japan said Nvidia's products were too costly, so they didn't pursue it. What are your views on this as it relates to redesigning the Saturn hardware to make it more 3D-capable and competitive against the Playstation?
@bizarroeddie1
@bizarroeddie1 Жыл бұрын
it was Silicon Graphics, no? It ended up being the technology used on the N64.
@maroon9273
@maroon9273 Жыл бұрын
​​​@@bizarroeddie1no nvidia was creating a Saturn NV2 console project before the saturn was released in NA.
@thomaspleacher2735
@thomaspleacher2735 Жыл бұрын
@@bizarroeddie1 Yeah something between Silicon Graphics and Sega was briefly considered, too. But Tom Kalinske specifically brought up an Nvidia-Sega thing in this interview I'm thinking of.
@erwanlecainec3394
@erwanlecainec3394 Жыл бұрын
@@thomaspleacher2735 A link for this interview ?
@GzegzolkaDA
@GzegzolkaDA Жыл бұрын
I have a minimal plan that could work: cancel 32x, cancel all bad sega America games, release Saturn as it was with no hardware changes, provide developers well written documentation how to use that hardware. I know it just another of those "what if" scenarios, but I find it very interesting to back in time with full knowledge we have nowadays.
@Cwiiis
@Cwiiis Жыл бұрын
The late additions theory has been debunked, hasn't it? They had a dual CPU design even in the 32X and the dual VDP design is very similar to their arcade boards and not at all dissimilar to contemporary console design. If I was making changes to the Saturn hardware, there are only a few things I'd change that I think would significantly boost the capabilities of the Saturn without being *too* major a design change (though likely still too major given the time-scale of these things); 1- A ~64K cache for the second SH2 - I think this is a pretty reasonable amount that lets you do useful things without increasing cost or complexity massively. Ideally we'd have more RAM separated or dual-port RAM to counteract bus contention, but I think that's likely a much bigger change. 2- Give VDP1 support for UV coordinates. A lot of the difficulty in porting from contemporary 3d platforms of the time was the whole quads/tris difference... But I think the really big difference is the lack of UV coordinate support on the Saturn. When you blit a transformed quad on the Saturn, the texture data is sampled from 0,0 to 1,1 - you see this with weird looking angled surfaces in all the Slavedriver engine games, for example. Being able to specify texture sample coordinates would've been a huge boon to the Saturn and saved on effort/memory to have things look good (and would've enabled lots more neat effects). 3- Give VDP1 a proper 50% blend capability. VDP1 does already have blend, but due to the way quads are drawn (using Bresnham algorithm lines), as soon as you transform it to be non-rectilinear, you get artifacts. I theorise that this was just a bug that they didn't have the time to work out. Working this out would've reduced the instance of mesh-transparencies and circumvented the whole 'Saturn can't do transparencies' fight that continues to this day. It still wouldn't have been as capable as the PS1 in this regard, but it would've been good enough. If I was going to pick even smaller and more realistic things that I think would've significantly changed the fortune of the Saturn, I'd say 1- Mega-drive/CD/32X backwards compatibility (even without 32X would probably be fine) and 2- a decent software SDK provided a year before launch.
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt Жыл бұрын
2. Quads with UV means that you would rasterise a “source” quad in texture space. Sure interesting. 3. You cannot blend quads nor can you bi or trilinear interpolate. They are a dead end. How would a z buffer even work if your texels never hit the center of a pixel?
@Cwiiis
@Cwiiis Жыл бұрын
@@ArneChristianRosenfeldt there are algorithms to rasterise filled quads without overdraw, which is what would be needed to blend - I never said anything about interpolation.
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt Жыл бұрын
@@CwiiisI just mean that you lose simplicity. You did not say interpolation, but it became default in 1996 with N64 and 3dfx. Sega hardware Knowledge became worthless. 1. Where do you put that cache? N64 and Jaguar cache were already stressing the yield. Of die cache was great in 1987 for RISC server. If money is unlimited. Why on earth would you put this in a volume toy?
@GamieCorporation
@GamieCorporation Жыл бұрын
This definitely has all the trappings of a Switch style console. Very smart and intricate video!
@billcook4768
@billcook4768 Жыл бұрын
One of Sega’s big obstacles was being in the arcade business. Competitors like Namco really made the PS1 a success while barely acknowledging the Saturn. How do you fix that?
@nattila7713
@nattila7713 Жыл бұрын
that you cannot fix :(
@marklechman2225
@marklechman2225 Жыл бұрын
If they had made that memory cart slot a Genesis cart slot, like we all thought it was going to be back in the day, they definitely would’ve sold more systems.
@steelcurtain187
@steelcurtain187 Жыл бұрын
These are some great ideas for sure 😎
@RarefoilB
@RarefoilB Жыл бұрын
This is one of my favorite videos of yours, mainly because it's just fun to hope into an alternative universe where Sega could have actually done the Saturn right. I do think often about what a more successful Saturn would have meant for the Dreamcast and the rest of the industry. Yeah, I do agree that a successful Saturn doesn't automatically mean a Dreamcast that doesn't die. But, if the Saturn did make it to around 20 million units... what would that mean for the PlayStation, exactly? Would that 102 million units sold be actually lower, because there were those that said "my Saturn is good enough"? Would PlayStation exclusives like Metal Gear Solid and Silent Hill actually come to Saturn, due to a healthier market that would actually buy the game in enough numbers to justify it? Okay, let's be realistic: the PlayStation would have still sold pretty damn well, and exclusives like Crash, Spyro, and FF7 were pretty locked in. But a drop in 5 or 7 million units feels at least somewhat possible. And what about the N64? I'll admit, the N64 was so different in markets and software from Sega's or Sony's offerings that it's hard to see it being affected. Still, the N64 wasn't in a complete vacuum, and it's hard for me to picture *zero* effect whatsoever. So, probably in the same ballpark of sales, or slightly lower. Maybe even higher because the butterfly kept flapping its wings. But now with a successful Saturn heading into 1998... okay, well the date would have to be moved up for the sixth gen successor, Saturn is still doing fine in all regions. But so is the PlayStation and the N64, at least on the same level as Sega. Now, this reality continues to be the case into 1999, but now everyone's at the very least announcing their sixth generation console. This could be the time to strike with the Dreamcast, if Sega wanted to get ahead of everyone else, but in this universe, having actual consumer trust and steady partnerships with third parties. Or... maybe, just maybe... with both companies being clearly part of a different time in video games, with both being dedicated video game makers, and both clearly struggling to compete against Sony's humongous conglomerate resources... Sega and Nintendo team up to make one Sega/Nintendo console with all of their games. Just like the proposed Sega/Sony console all those years ago. Now okay, this is extremely pie-in-the-sky thinking. Who knows how well that would have gone, what with the two companies having pretty different cultures and design philosophies, or even if this console would be more like the Dreamcast or the GameCube or a mash-up of both. But it would be an interesting universe to be in. And in either timeline... would Microsoft even be trying for an Xbox? Their main motivation for making it was Sony, which would probably still be the case no matter what, but they would be walking into a crowded market. Is there room for a forth guy? And if there isn't, do you have what it takes to crush the forth guy, whoever that is? Well, you're Microsoft so... maybe. And in the Sega/Nintendo console universe, would Xbox be able to weather being the third place option, selling that 24 million as compared to 31 million? (combining the Dreamcast and Gamecube sales and rounding up) Or would it sell even less? Would Microsoft even want to go forward with the 360 later on? Alright, these are some pretty wild theories at this point. While history would have been different to some extent, it is also very easy to see Sega's story ending pretty similarly too. I just wanted to throw my thoughts out there and offer more possibilities. Love the content, Sega Lord X! 👍
@davidblankenship7985
@davidblankenship7985 Жыл бұрын
A Saturn with a single, faster SH-2 would have gone a long way
@maroon9273
@maroon9273 Жыл бұрын
And a custom SH-2 Coprocessor (programmable friendly). Keeping the scu dsp.
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt Жыл бұрын
The SH-2 was already in stock. Single processor designs will have to compete with PC. More important would be symmetric multiprocessing where tasks are dispatched onto the next available code like today in mobile or on the PS3 .
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt Жыл бұрын
@@maroon9273the DSP does everything wrong what the SH-2 does well. Even MMX ( thought up in 1989 as a GPU design) makes more sense. PSX GTE shows how it is done. Jaguar MMULT is so okay.
@maroon9273
@maroon9273 Жыл бұрын
​@@ArneChristianRosenfeldtif that's the case SH3 or even power pc, MIPS or Risc NEC are better option than the sh2. Early to Mid 90s. Hitachi fastest cpu maxes to 28.6 MHz.
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt Жыл бұрын
@@maroon9273 SH-2 has the most compact code which is essential for the small cache at that time. It has half the transistor count of a 68k leaving the rest for cache. Shared memory access is only a problem on a cache miss. It is very difficult to for me to get hard facts on memory access for these consoles. Only the Jaguar uses well known DRAM and the well known 68k bus protocol. No fancy interleave or EDO. There it is easy to see how just every component on a chip would need at least a small cache which can absorb a burst of 64 bit words. Now I don’t understand why SEGA replicated Ataris mistakes on SegaCD ( Lynx), 32x (Jaguar), and then again on the Saturn.
Let's Save the Sega Dreamcast
28:42
Sega Lord X
Рет қаралды 66 М.
Let's Save the Sega CD!
17:13
Sega Lord X
Рет қаралды 52 М.
Сестра обхитрила!
00:17
Victoria Portfolio
Рет қаралды 958 М.
IL'HAN - Qalqam | Official Music Video
03:17
Ilhan Ihsanov
Рет қаралды 700 М.
Could Sonic Have Saved The Sega Saturn?
16:58
Sega Lord X
Рет қаралды 45 М.
Strengths & Weaknesses of the Sega Saturn
20:40
Sega Lord X
Рет қаралды 83 М.
Why the Sega Saturn was an Underrated Console
23:03
Kaisar
Рет қаралды 24 М.
Let's Save the Sega 32X!
23:19
Sega Lord X
Рет қаралды 57 М.
11 Facts About the Sega Saturn You Maybe Didnt Know
27:08
Inglebard Gaming
Рет қаралды 12 М.
Sega FY 1997 - The Slow Death of a Titan
1:07:03
PandaMonium Reviews Every U.S. Saturn Game
Рет қаралды 28 М.
The Sega Saturn - What Happened?
21:59
Matt McMuscles
Рет қаралды 478 М.
Sonic on Saturn: What Could Have Been
21:05
Webster
Рет қаралды 53 М.
The BIG Sega CD Video Compilation
3:42:19
Sega Lord X
Рет қаралды 73 М.
The Final Days of the Sega Saturn
17:48
Sega Lord X
Рет қаралды 165 М.