LGR - The Sims 4 Island Living Review

Gameplay and overview of the seventh ̶g̶a̶m̶e̶ ̶p̶a̶c̶k̶ expansion pack for The Sims 4. Mermaids, diving, volcanoes, oh my! And how viable is off the grid living? Let's jump into it!
● LGR elsewhere on the internet:
/ lazygamereviews
/ lazygamereviews
/ lazygamereviews
● Check out my other Sims 4 reviews:
• The Sims 4 on LGR
● Download the sims shown in this video:
bit.ly/2AmFFRU (username 'LazyGameReviews' in The Gallery)
● My PC Specs:
www.lazygamerev...
● Music credits go to:
www.epidemicsou...
#LGR #TheSims4 #IslandLiving

[@mrskizzot]

The fact you cant make an underwater house as a mermaid is an oversight.

[@victoriasnead1662]

lol you beat me to it...

[@faepan]

That’s it, I need a completely Atlantis themed world ASAP where everything is underwater. How cool would that be?! People could get so creative with it. 😍

[@vanillabean7832]

It’s so weird there are MERMAIDS but we can only see them swimming on the surface of the water...

[@pump.queenz]

Pray we get a update

[@allyah180]

Also the fact that there is not a whole lot of things you can do with mermaids. They are just like normal Sims with a tail. I would’ve liked if they did with mermaids how they did with vampires. Too many oversights..

[@WatchWomanP-91]

I'm so disappointed there are no resorts/hotels. Personally my biggest let down.

[@gigiblack2231]

Megan W Same for me, I was looking forward to that the most. I played this pack for 2 days then got bored because there was nothing left for my sims to do. I’m shocked at how little content this expansion has. Hotel resorts would have been the biggest part of this game. They really should have centered this pack around hotel/resorts & not the conservationist career. What were they thinking.

[@___Robin___]

@@gigiblack2231 they were thinking made a lot of money with as little effort as possible. As long as people buy their game like you do they won't find the need to actually improve the game. Do as I do and stop supporting the sims 4.

[@WatchWomanP-91]

gigi black I agree 100%.

[@jibblejabble4599]

go play the sims 3 then

[@dr.funster1585]

Yes that was 1 of my complaints wit this pack...you would think they would've added that feature especially wit the Get to Work expansion....I RECOMMEND EVERY1 THAT HAVEN'T BOUGHT ISLAND LIVING PLEASE PLEASE W8 4 A Sale..this pack is not worthy of the typical price of a Sims 4 Expansion pack.

[@beastinthesuezcanal8315]

At this point, they could just slap on Sims 4 graphics to Sims 3 and everyone would be extremely ecstatic.

[@CalopsitaVanderbilt1911]

dork on the left lane exactly lol

[@mori5271]

Fuck, i would buy it instantly then. I only bought sims 4 for better graphics, because i like disaining alot, but gameplay is so dull

[@galaxychar]

That is not how it works, which is why TS3 has such shit graphics.

[@lilfairyprincess1o1]

I feel like I'm the only one who prefers ts3 graphics. Ts4 is beautiful yes, but in a cartoony artificial way. Ts4 maps look like 2D cartoons for 5year olds. Ts3 graphics are actually realistic and on high settings are amazing

[@tetsutetsutetsutetsu7968]

@@lilfairyprincess1o1 sims 3 actually has superior graphics just bad character designers. Literally the graphics are more advanced, things like HDR and stuff whereas sims 4 rendering is limited as fuk

[@aliceroared]

"Why aren't there any options for collecting rain water or using solar power?" Because they plan to charge you an extra $40 to get those 😂

[@cbjgirl23]

And the winner of what pack gets these features is..... *drumroll* eco lifestyle!

[@clairestar3611]

BRO THIS LITERALLY HAPPENED LMAO

[@martimramos5834]

eco lifestyle.... well...

[@user-bz7qg5xw6h]

I didn't buy eco cause it came out when covid was hot and I was like um. This is morbid. LOL

[@tonytins]

One Eco Lifestyle pack later...

[@CadeAid1]

How come the game infested with loading screens and fake 2D map screens can’t have underwater diving lots, but the game with a completely open world from 10 years ago can?

[@viktoria5310]

THAT is a very good question

[@candiegray4037]

A true mystery

[@becki324]

Frustr8d the sim supply did an interesting interview with the manager of the sims 4 which dives into this question! It’s a good watch!

[@MrDemomanman]

Because EA

[@sweetpjeb23]

@Axel Drans They're concerned with performance issues and their target demographic. A lot of sims players aren't hardcore gamers that are gonna have brand new computers with amazing specs. And having features like that will cause performance issues.

[@SobiTheRobot]

I feel like what the Sims needs at this point is market competition. Think about it - there aren't really any other games quite like it. Maybe if there was another life simulator that offered the same versatility and creativity, then maybe the Sims would step up its game. ...Or get upended by the competition, as was the case with Planet Coaster and Parkitect replacing Roller Coaster Tycoon.

[@theepurpletoaster]

The competition would need a fresh new angle. I don't want it to be "The Sims but by another company", however I don't want it to be "NOT The Sims" where they change everything. Maybe like weird aliens living on an interesting planet doing cool stuff? Or maybe something else...

[@SobiTheRobot]

@@theepurpletoaster You know, I considered doing it with aliens, with the premise being that they don't actually understand how humans work and that the game is their close approximation. But then that might be too alienating, ironically enough. Still, nonhumans acting human isn't a bad angle to approach it with.

[@KairuHakubi]

That actually sounds like a great idea Sobi. Basically 3rd Rock from the Sun the Game? it would justify all the ridiculous things you have to actually control them doing

[@SobiTheRobot]

@@KairuHakubi I'm actually not that familiar with 3rd Rock, but I'll give it a look. And yeah, that was basically the idea. The Sims have always been an exaggerated representation of daily human activity, why not take that to its logical conclusion and have actual aliens trying to replicate humanity? It's something I've thought a lot about and I actually have a character design that could work as a base for the aliens. (Less gleebleglorb grey aliens and more of a fleshed out alien race that accidentally picked up human tv and internet broadcasts through a wormhole.)

[@theepurpletoaster]

@@SobiTheRobot If you make that game I would defently play it.

[@matte5003]

What I don't like is how you can't go underwater anymore, why couldn't they have made it like a loading screen and then you show up underwater?

[@FlammableFlamingoooo]

Ooooh that would have been a great compromise

[@Dark-uk4oz]

Exactly! And there should have been some sort of secret Mermaid grotto too. This pack was a wasted opportunity.

[@ihatemyselfuwu3960]

because theyre lazy as fuck

[@prive7469]

like sixam and the other 3 secret worlds. they could have put a small underwater exploring world or a hidden world trough the cave at the wrecked ship. would have been so easy but no!

[@anonymous475]

That was my biggest disappointment in the expansion pack.

[@RyanRipley69]

when we say recycling is good for the planet, we didn't mean recycle previous sims expansion packs for almost AAA level prices and less content

[@itwasmeallalong4255]

little did they know eco living would shatter the recycling expectation by recycling recycled content

[@solairesunpraiser]

This comment has aged very well.

[@smokeytripod]

Can't wait for the "My First Island Paradise" pack to come out later that has more stuff that should have been included with this expansion.

[@alexdelaloire8739]

"My first island experience stuff" "scuba diving stuff pack" "mermaids powers stuff pack"😂😂😂

[@KisshuKisshuFUSION]

Smokeytripod Still waiting for my first rodent stuff and my first amphibian stuff, add-ons to my first pet stuff, an add-on to cats and dogs

[@katonnor]

@Axel Drans I would say they would never do that but as they have before you just never know what they will do for a quick cash grab

[@godzandheros]

"My First Island Vacation"

[@YAUUN]

Well, we didnt get that, but they made all the missing stuff from the ecologist & off the grid sides into an EP

[@joeballz40]

I always look forward to your Sims content reviews - brutally honest with no bells & whistles!

[@D0NU75]

i'd rather have brutal bells and brutal whistles, just like good ol' Doom

[@TheLicktysplitz]

Exactly

[@starkman78]

I always wait for LGR reviews because that way I know exactly what I'm getting when I buy new DLC. That said, I'm enjoying the game more than he is so I've bought every pack, but I had a hunch that he'd have some good things to say about this one. He's been putting new stuff in the gallery and I don't recall him doing that at all since I started following him.

[@pandabear1008]

Yup!

[@GodsChildJess]

CON.SOL me too lol his reviews are just that! The sims creators can’t stand it though lol

[@allisonfields3108]

At this point I'm only excited when sims 4 drops more content because it means we'll get another LGR review.

[@LulitaInPita]

Same... It's genuinely sad...

[@mirandataylor6385]

Same. I don't even play the game. It just seems dumb to not have an open world Sims game by 2019.

[@FerDeLance06]

Not for the Star Wars one though, unfortunately. Pity - I really wanted to see him rip into that. Maybe he'll change his mind.

[@erisenigma]

Me when I heard Cottage Living is releasing lol

[@shawnnesbit7314]

you must be poor

[@quantumwitcher9376]

Sims 3 Island Paradise did it better...but then again Sims 3 did everything better

[@noonenowhere877]

I disagree...musicians in The Sims 4 are excellent...shame we don't have bands to go with them though.

[@sexyjon589]

Except for vampires and celebrities, but everything else I agree

[@strxwberrymvlk]

Except for the ugly pudding face sims, besides that I agree with u.

[@sergiine]

@@strxwberrymvlk Custom Contents provided an easy fix for that.

[@heresfrankbetches921]

Truth

[@eltiletulf5049]

island living is basically a pack filled with missed opportunities

[@HadirUntukAnda]

Hello nozo stan

[@allyah180]

eltiletulf I also believe it is a glorified game pack that could’ve been an expansion pack had more content been added to it. A lot of oversights...

[@mettestark605]

Lmao. We should get a pack called "Missed Opportunities" which has everything that should've been included in various expansions. $40 xD

[@onlyabidoang]

Couldn't agree more. The features they're trying to offer are promising and the world is beautiful indeed, but the gameplay just felt too shallow especially with the $40 price tag. No new skills, no fully-fledged scuba diving, and a dumbed-down lifeguard career. Also, I really wish for them to focus much more on the traditions and culture of Sulani like what they did with Jungle Adventure so the world feels more unique. I even felt that this expansion pack is almost comparable to Jungle Adventure, which is a $20 game pack. Anyway, amazing reviews as always!

[@nidohime6233]

Sulani is a real place?

[@alexdelaloire8739]

I wanted so bad a hidden temple or a tomb where the elementals live; and we have to explore the cave and resolve something to be able to do so; also, I really wanted a secret mermaid grotto, or a place where they hang out, and the only way to reach it is max level scuba diving or being a mermaid! They could do so much with this pack but they just did nothing!

[@nidohime6233]

@@alexdelaloire8739 Like Atlantis?

[@starkman78]

But doesn’t all of that mean that a really good Sims Logic video is forthcoming???

[@rimabros98]

@@nidohime6233 it's portrayed by the Isle of Samoa.

[@dealwithitxoxo]

anyone else remember the golden ages and excitement of sims 3 expansions?

[@yvesheaven]

Sims 4 is one of the biggest disappointments in the world.

[@JessicaPancake2]

Honestly I feel like Sims 2 has significantly better gameplay than the Sins 3. Everything was so amazing and realistic in Sims 2. Remember having to trim the shrubs in your garden, getting food poisoning from off food and teens randomly getting pimples.

[@bookshelffury]

Sims 2 ultimate collection is the best imo.

[@KoreanMeatball]

I remember everyone complaining about how the Sims 3 wasn't as good as Sims 2.

[@ignaciomedina1037]

I used to be waiting for the launch day, and then going to buy them the release day... even at midnight, that was great and exciting!... Now, Sims 4 really disappoint me

[@Erinerbear]

I like how before Sims 4 came out they were hyping the fact that there was “no rabbit holes” when really it’s full of them

[@hashtheduck]

lol

[@FerDeLance06]

That's not all it's full of! :-D

[@naluzoniro]

No rabbit holes... Just no buildings at all, actually ! problem solved !

[@rachaelbecker1165]

I can't even lie - I am utterly DISAPPOINTED in the fact that we don't get to explore beneath the surface of the water like we got to in the Sims 3! That was one of the features I loved MOST about the expansion pack! :(

[@adaode3413]

They could've done so much with it too! Cleaning trash under water and finding hidden mermaid landscapes for example -- so many missed opportunities

[@desired2396]

Just go play the sims 3. This pack is nice for us who like it And us who can’t run the sims 3 well

[@Drstrange3000]

Wait for the "Explore Underwater" Gamepack 😉 Freaking EA...

[@rachaelbecker1165]

Oh I havent bought this pack yet. 😂 I'm just saying, it would have been nice to integrate more material into it since it is the "sims 4". But i do still play my sims 3 games 😊

[@Dark-uk4oz]

Sharon Sha The Sims 3 Island Paradies runs like a living hell. So choppy and horrible smh

[@ashbash2634]

Sims 3 island paradise had literally 3 times more gameplay content than this. I like it but im bored with it already lol

[@jaweiss34]

Ashton Beretta the towns the sims 3 added has more substance lol

[@veronicasmith7251]

sims3 in general is a million times better

[@SevenEllen]

@@jaweiss34 Not half! In many ways I wish that The Sims 4 had never existed and that The Sims 3 had just been continued to be expanded upon.

[@jw-vs7wh]

that is true, but island paradise barely functioned if you owned other packs. there was so much stuff to do that it became extremely laggy after a little bit of gameplay

[@SnowflakeIcing]

Yeah :// I was really excited for this because Island Paradise was so nonfunctional on my computer but I’m really let down with the features offered.

[@alexispapavasileiou342]

I remember my self never getting bored of the sims 3... it had so many mysteries and stories. Even the first expansion packs, the Sims 3 world adventures had such a huge inpact on my gameplay. So many mysteries to unravel. They need to focus more on the inside and not just the surface...To be honest I can't play a household for a long period of time cause I'm just getting tired and have nothing to do.

[@TanyaOwens]

I agree, boredom sets in quickly with Sims 4. I end up playing multiple house holds with different households focusing on different things to not get bored.

[@alexispapavasileiou342]

@@TanyaOwens exactly!

[@jasthfc352]

hello😍

[@cellochel1582]

Mummy’s curse was my favorite!

[@sydneymorgan1657]

They just need to remaster Sims 3 at this point

[@alectricalexia]

Sydney Morgan Exactly.

[@definitelyluigi]

Yep...

[@slvsh77]

There wouldn't be any hype over that sadly, and we all know EA is only in it for the money, not actually good content.

[@GeorgiaMarie98x]

Oh my god I would pay SO much money for Sims 3 remastered!

[@relaximatroll2118]

If remastering include the OPTIMIZATION, count me the fuck in!

[@TheLicktysplitz]

Oh my God I totally agree the off-grid stuff barely makes any sense and there should be a way you can use renewable energy. off-grid doesn't mean just living in misery. my Sims have an mood-lit where they're just tense or unhappy because they're getting a lukewarm showers and they still feel dirty, they should have a trait where you enjoy off grid.

[@Lankynibs]

Yeah also like...how come sims can't go get water from the ocean/waterfalls/etc in order to refill the laundry tub, or clean their toilets/sinks/off grid showers?! I was playing off grid and it was so frustrating that stuff had to get disgusting because "cleaning requires plumbing" 😒 Edit: just got to the part in the video where he says the same thing 😂

[@dawngrrrl]

Yeah they really should've balanced the lot trait better and reintroduced the eco-friendly trait from TS3. If they'd done that + given mermaids an actual skill to master it would definitely be worth $40.

[@ravenaroteros]

they'll be introducing a stuff/game pack for that lol bookmark me

[@renatamarques8610]

@@ravenaroteros for sure, i thought it was weird the off the grid lot trait was added in the patch. But also, I find it odd that the exp pack didn't add any new object for the off the grid trait, since it was marked as a feature for the pack. It's gonna be My First Pet Stuff all over again, things that should be in the expansion, but were taken off to milk more money. It just makes the expansion feel incomplete and definitely not worth the full price.

[@kzgaddis]

@@ravenaroteros i sincerely hope so. i was so excited for off the grid until i found out it's basically impossible to function because there are no alternatives to anything

[@jbrown5955]

I’ve literally checked his channel everyday to see this video.

[@jimiahsaunders6802]

same dude lol

[@personperson8953]

Same

[@EMSenseiMusic]

He only uploads on Fridays so next time you know not to check every day!

[@jimiahsaunders6802]

@@EMSenseiMusic thanks!!

[@Pugragger]

same

[@DaedaliusRE]

Personally, I'm dissapointed beyond belief. This should have been a game pack. NOT an expansion. As the latter it is just WAY too lackluster. I wouldn't be so dissapointed if the next expansion pack wasn't months away now. Island Living just took the slot away and now the waiting time for the next expansion will start anew. THAT is the worst part.

[@nugsboodlepoo]

I feel you. But I'm hoping the reason this expansion was so lackluster is because they are working on another expansion at the same time. I'm hoping university in fall?

[@marcodevries5001]

Probably not, Realm of Magic is coming this fall

[@FreckledFantasy]

Why is everything that the sims 4 offers just watered down sims 3 content? Makes me really sad.

[@beverlylee6357]

Remember when they promised us that the new engine could allow them to do more things that they could ever do?? LOL

[@jaweiss34]

Beverly Lee but they made that incredible ball pit!! 🤪

[@meioji]

Beverly Lee loooooool 😂😂

[@desired2396]

They can do so much more! The game quality is so much better. The loading screens and rabbit holes allows people with weaker pc’s to play the game. If it was 100% open world with the same mechanics and graphics anyone without a GOD pc couldn’t play.

[@Wakeupgrandowl]

Daniel K. Has drank the koolaid.

[@sadiewinterlord6908]

WakeupGrandOwl he's right though??

[@amorettique]

We badly need someone to make a replacement for The Sims, the way Cities Skylines replaced SimCity as the standard city simulator

[@alexdelaloire8739]

Cities skylines has become the best city simulator ever; planet coaster and soon planet zoo are imposing as the best park tycoon and zoo tycoon games; for now, the sims still reign as the best life simulation game but if they don't listen to their fans they won't be able to beat the upcoming rivals.

[@sweetpjeb23]

@@alexdelaloire8739 Well the same people that worked on Rollercoaster Tycoon also created Planet Coaster. After the last Rollercoaster Tycoon flopped they changed the name and created Planet Coaster.

[@alexdelaloire8739]

@@sweetpjeb23 yeah what I meant is either Maxis and EA do something and improve the sims or another company would take the lead!! two situations here: cities skyline situation or planet coaster situation! If the sims got improved even if it's just the pack contents and gameplays, they'll keep the monopole a little bit (so planet coaster situation) but if they stay like this they'll loose lots of customers (like with cities skylines)!

[@liquidmodernitytasteslikeu2855]

my dream would come true

[@gabrielandy9272]

i kinda disaagre with the planet coaster being better, because i still think roller coaster tycoon 3 had more cool stuff like water parks etc.... but yeah.... sims need another game to compete tho.

[@annevee]

finally someone made an actual HONEST review.

[@tomtalk24]

Every review is honest?!

[@Bre_96]

@@tomtalk24 I know this is 2 years old but sweetie...no

[@telishadixon8652]

I would have loved surfing that would have been such a nice touch.

[@ava-qx1vr]

I never buy a pack without watching your reviews!! They are so honest and accurate and I’ve loved every pack you have given a good review!! Thanks for this review!!

[@TheRealSmiley]

just buy the sims 3 instead

[@anonymousenzo]

same

[@matthewd3175]

TheRealSmiley In my opinion I love the sims 4 version better plus it actually works so you gotta try out both to really know

[@strider029]

I wish i can play Sims 3 properly on my PC without insane lags and crashes. I used to play it fine before, but my new equipment and new OS updates doesn't seem to like Sims 3 now.

[@ava-qx1vr]

TheRealSmiley I can’t play sims 3 because I have a mac and it doesn’t run on mac properly. It gives and error message. If I could I would though!!!

[@Her_Imperious_Condescension]

This is 100% just an overly expensive game pack.

[@WhyDoBabiesStareAtMe]

I got The Sims 4 for free about a month ago off Origin. I immediately learned why. You get 60% of a game. That 60% is pretty damned good. The other 40%, and all the additional content, is very, very expensive. $40 for the bigger expansions, $30 for the smaller ones, and $20 for stuff packs is way too much. Even sales don't bring those prices down much.

[@tsunderefandomer3425]

I agree, besides clothes and *chairs*. It’s just like the Vampires GP with a new world and occult type but with instead mermaids.

[@RockZombieIAm]

I agree it's the only Expansion Pack I didn't buy as soon as it came out. It seemed the least expansive to me immediately. I could do more with Get Together or City Living, you know?

[@elainal6847]

I honestly think people are buying the man hours spent working on expanding the capability of the engine that dictates what a sims DLC can do with the new job mechanic and the water redesign.

[@yopi_yopi]

Yeah this is why I never buy it full price tbh...

[@alexed8202]

I don’t pay for these packs, and I still feel like I wasted my money.

[@lordpetroollo6979]

i cracked them all and i feel like ea owe me money

[@androidgamer3739]

@@lordpetroollo6979 please tell me how to do

[@lordpetroollo6979]

@@androidgamer3739 Go to website called cs.rin create account and search for The Sims 4 click on first link made by Anadius and follow his instructions

[@Kenji_Endo]

Ikr

[@androidgamer3739]

@@lordpetroollo6979 , thanks sir for replying but sir can you give me a direct link

[@BeautiXo]

i mean it literally when i say i can’t play the Sims 4 for more than 2 hours. i used to play previous sims games for hours, would even fake my sickness just to stay home from school and play for all those 8 hours! lmao but what im trying to say is it gets boring.. you’d think with all these packs it wouldn’t be, right? wrong. things they add make the game fun & exciting for a couple of days but then it goes back to “ok, what now?” not to mention me waiting for everything to load makes me tired & not even want to play once it’s all loaded up, & also the reason why i hate leaving my sims house bc it takes foreeeeever to go to another lot for only like 4-5 sim hours & then loading back when going home... sigh. pls, we need to make the sims great again, it’s like a lot of the developers are in it just for our money..

[@T1544767]

$40??? Wicked Whims is a better "expansion pack" and it's free.

[@LeeDee5]

It sure does expand my pack.

[@gwenaey3703]

Dee Ca. this made me giggle way too hard and I don’t even know if it was intentional, haha

[@car1235219]

What’s Wicked Whims?

[@gwenaey3703]

Chris Tech it’s an 18+ mod for the Sims4

[@bridgetkv]

To be fair Wicked Whims isn’t allowed to be directly monetized due to legal reasons. But yeah I knew that I wasn’t dropping $40 on this once it was announced. Definitely picking it up 50% off at target.

[@Kairex]

After having played with this pack for awhile it feels more like a stuff pack than an expansion, we got A LOT of items but the gameplay feels lacking

[@jim.b0b]

It definitely feels like a game pack, if they’d have added more content like being able to manage your own hotel/resort, underwater lots that you can explore for the diving skill and more in depth mermaids etc I’d say sure, but really you’re just paying $40 for the world of Sulani and not much else. It’s a nice pack don’t get me wrong but I feel like there should be more on offer for it to be an expansion pack.

[@Kairex]

@@jim.b0b 100% agree, I would even settle for just more depth for the mermaids and underwater lots (even if that means a loading screen) I'm not as pressed for resorts as other people but yeah. It's definitely lacking

[@annmareeofoz]

Agreed, it's like "cool!" at first, but then you start playing and you realize there's not much happening to add to the gameplay.

[@izumi.yoshida7]

I agree entirely. It's a beautiful map with the best CaS and Build/Buy Items but outside of aesthetics there's just something missing when actually playing.

[@Silviecka]

@@Kairex true...i really hoped they would make mermaids like they did vampires with those special abilites (even if it was only few of them)

[@Jess-bt6eq]

SO DISAPPOINTING that they didn’t add an underwater part. Sims 4 is so lacking.. I love the visuals of sims 4 but man they need to up their game!

[@sadiewinterlord6908]

*sees old shipwreck* *plays sims 2 castaway again*

[@avrillove11m94]

Sadie Winterlord That was the best!!!

[@a_chosenGeneration]

I loved the sims castaway so fun

[@yzzy1966]

Jesus, it was an amazing game!!! 💓

[@3xlbeautybabe]

That was my favorite!!! I though this was gonna be like that :/

[@Creampuf1977]

How about~ Sims 3 Remastered ? I'll take an updated and optimized sims 3 over this new junk. Wouldn't that be easier for EA?

[@alexed8202]

This please. Screw sims 5. Cancel sims 4 . THIS.

[@hw0234]

Sims 3 had great content! But i love the build mode in sims 4. If they could mesh them together they'd have one amazing game.

[@heresfrankbetches921]

Sims 3 was the best

[@FatalFramer13]

Creampuf1977 Sims 2 was the best sims game in the franchise. It had so many things in it that even Sims 3 couldnt top that.

[@natpat4094]

@@FatalFramer13 sims 2 remastered + open world pls omg!!!

[@laraland9963]

This should have been a game pack, not an expansion.

[@LymphNode125]

Fun fact, someone accessed the Sims 4 website and saw the list of Game Packs and Expansion Packs. Suffice to say Island Living was in both of them. It's not a glitch, as the Game Pack label and design were in the cover. Meaning this used to be a game pack in the first place.

[@savannahwalker3504]

@@LymphNode125 I'm not suprised at all. I'm so tired of EA, I was so excited for this to come out but it's nothing more than a 40$ game pack. Sad :(

[@radwooah]

@@LymphNode125 Yeah and when it was leaked by the websites it had the color of a game pack.

[@radwooah]

@Squidward’s Flute Cats and Dogs is one of the worst packs if you compare it to the previous Pet packs. However the community is dumb and its always their 2nd or 1st favorite expansion

[@alexdelaloire8739]

@@radwooah they are like "I can't play wihout cats and dogs or seasons" I kinda understand for seasons even if I'm not a huge fan but cats and dogs and Island living...meh! Both are more huge stuff packs than gameplay packs!

[@thisissme]

Honestly I bought this, but I kinda regret it. There are no new skills, and there’s nothing to do on the island. Like legit nothing.

[@TanyaOwens]

really no new skills? That pretty much sucks. There should be a rule that all EPs require at a bare minimum certain things that GPs don't have, with skills being one of them

[@elvishh8036]

Ok I'm wondering. Should I get get famous or this????

[@thisissme]

hiitakephotos andidrinkpeachjuice definitely get “get famous” super fun pack!

[@Gaxriel]

@@elvishh8036 Get famous is a good pack

[@Rosaeart]

Same

[@wolfiewrites]

I wish Sulani had an underwater "world". Even if it was a place only merpeople could reach, I'd be pretty happy

[@VannaMae]

So Sims 4 is just like everything else in American entertainment nowadays: Beautiful visually but lacks substance and story.

[@fileflies]

Vanna Mae Yeah. I was seeing parallels between this and game of thrones season 8 reviews.

[@Szgerle]

Thats not true, sims 4 is not beautiful at all!

[@tximistarissole]

Plus environmentalist virtue signaling!

[@erectustesticulus3191]

Huh? American cities or entertainment is not beautiful 🤣🤣🤣

[@heresfrankbetches921]

It looks like 2005 game

[@crisperstorm]

This really makes me want to see a real Sims competitor that can either do things better or force the Sims to improve a bit more. Or to at least be an alternative to the expensive greedy claws of EA

[@elizabeth3555]

Apparently there’s a new indie life simulator that’s going to be coming out on Steam sometime soon. I think it’s called Paralives. Who knows, maybe it’ll give EA a run for their money

[@amb5019]

for real, i love simulation games like this. just not enough people try to make (decent) versions. ;//

[@freyafrettchen3808]

@@elizabeth3555 I don't think it will release sometime soon 'cause I remember hearing that it was in an early stage of developing 🤔 So it's good possible that it could release in two or five years for example.

[@elizabeth3555]

Unsichtbares Nachtara ah yeah, I wrote this before I knew much about the game

[@Nominaze]

Paralives:)

[@helloruan]

Such a shame since Island Paradise was my favorite expansion from the Sims 3.

[@rayafoxr3]

ruan ya me too. Shame about the glitching.

[@avaesthetics]

Yea the world was amazing and sulani is too but I wish you could go underwater especially with sims 4 graphics

[@Kadence_Hoffman]

Agreed.

[@Starlightean]

I created an insane amount of resorts and I still go back to Sims 3. Imo Sims 3 is still the best of all of them even based on the base game alone.

[@kurtcobain656]

Ughhhhhhhhh. Sims community, please heal my wounds. I usually only buy expansion packs when they're on sale.. but I friggin' fell for the hype this time and bought this shit. Played it for a couple or hours, and then I got bored as hell. Not until now the idea of a refund struck me, but guess what.. it has to be within 24 hours of the first launch. So now I spent 40 dollars on an expansion pack that I don't enjoy. And it is embarrassing because I work hard to earn my money and I am always careful to spend them on necessary things. I am so fucking mad at myself and on EA. Fuck this shit. Also, great review as always!

[@rosa-8663]

Kurt Cobain Its totally ok. You worked hard for those 40 bucks and you feel like you wasted it. But don’t be so hard on yourself and don’t feel guilty! Yeah the ep sucked but ya know what you got some new things in your game that you can enjoy now like build/buy items. You fell for a hype, nothing wrong with that (:

[@simsdiver5201]

Don't waste hours shortening your life over meaningless shit like this. Buy all the TS3 EPs and SPs when they go on Steam sale (which has all of this holiday week). Join the growing number of Simmers who've deleted Origin off their systems for good. Launch and play your TS3 game without intrusive spyware in peace from Steam. Makes for a FAR more stable game experience. aka no CTDs etc etc

[@ExtraordinaryFate]

@@simsdiver5201 I still wouldn't go back to The Sims 3. It's more quality gameplay, but the actual game is just too buggy and laggy.

[@simsdiver5201]

@@ExtraordinaryFate It wouldn't be if you installed Twallans (NRaas) mods. At least the top 4 aka Story Progression (superior to EAs in every way), Overwatch, Error Trap and Master Controller. All of which takes less than 5 mins to do. 100% of EAs buggy glitched mess from the vanilla game went away when I installed these 4 mods (and ultimately all of Twallan's mod suite). Also not sure what sort of hardware you're using. I have a top end system. But simmers with medium end systems never had game breaking issues running the base game plus all EPs/SPs. Especially with Nraas mods installed.

[@TanyaOwens]

The only pack I paid full price for is StrangerVille - it was the only pack that was so unique that I was ok paying full price for it. I was disappointed in how piss poor they created the residential and community lots, but the world is pretty, the secret lab is cool, the weather is funky, and infected sims are hilarious. It is great there are 11 lots, though I wish there were more fishing lots. But I don't regret buying it, like I do with Parenthood, which isn't fun, just makes my generations unnecessarily tedious. Generations in sims 3 was better. I miss the prom

[@oakisap]

Its really sad when you think about how lackluster the sims 4 really is. I have a lol the game packs besides spa day, and all the expansion packs besides this one, and it still feels empty. It’s really crazy compared to how I only have 5 expansions to the sims 3 and yet it’s way more fun

[@Blood-PawWerewolf]

Oakisap exactly! Plus EA pushed mods and CC more in the Sims 4 than what was in the Sims 3. So even when you don’t want to buy everything, you at least have CC Packs and mods to increase the experience even more!

[@matthewd3175]

I think 4 is more fun but that’s just my opinion they are both great games

[@Jessica-ne5pr]

Something really went wrong in early development, and now it doesn't feel like any level of expansion pack could make this feel like a complete game. Even without all expansions, S3 & S2 gameplay just lasts so much longer without becoming boring and feels like a complete experience.

[@methebee]

Started playing sims 2 again with packs,and it feels endless, I didn't know how big it is

[@oakisap]

xJesssicax also, sims 4 expansions aren’t expansion-y feeling. Like take the sims 3 pets, and the sims 4 cats and dogs. Cats and dogs adds cats and dogs... and they are really dumb too. Once I got my dog taken away because I wasn’t feeding it when it was standing right by it’s bowl. In the sims 3 pets, you get cats, dogs, raccoons (actual ones not pets), deer, horses, unicorns (both good side and bad side), and little animals like snakes and birds. Plus, the sims 3 pets is only 20 dollars. There are more expanples too like ambitions and get to work, but I’ll only touch the basis right now. Ambitions; a huge world. When your sim goes shopping or somewhere else like a laundry place, you can see them going there. You get 5 interactive jobs Get to work; you get the smallest world yet with 4 lots, 3 already being reatails, and 3 new jobs.

[@翠鳥]

Seems "The Sims 3" team are way more productive than "The Sims 4" team. It just took for 5~10 years ONLY. Thanks for inflation, products became more expensive and less quality & quantity.

[@lovelypuff9]

Actually the Sims 2 team was the most productive of them all.

[@thecryingsoul]

@@lovelypuff9 Actually, sims 1

[@user-ke7hp3gi9f]

An Actual Adult actually sims 0

[@bergino5000]

At one point, The Sims 3 had three studios working together at the same time. The Sims Studio, the original studio itself; Maxis Salt Lake, who developed Showtime, Supernatural, University Life, and Into the Future; and another team dedicated to producing TS3 Store Content. Three teams working together at the same time, while it is good for pumping out content, like I really doubt any future TS game can pass the amount of stuff that was produced for TS3, it also probably caused some coordination issues between teams which lead to the issues that TS3 has. For TS4, I think it is a complete joke nowadays compared to the other older entries but I don't really blame the current developers for it.

[@queencleopatra007]

It's hard to blame the team of developers when they're only doing what corporate tells them to. I'm sure they'd do more if corporate would allow it.

[@Demonic_Culture_Nut]

How long until The Sims 4: Island Culture*? *requires the Island Living expansion

[@societygarlic]

Imagine how lackluster University is gonna be... :(

[@whychandler]

if they ever even make a University pack lol. we've been asking for YEARS for that and this is the bs they give us. >:(

[@sophie9984]

I actually don't believe that University will ever come. Normally, it would be the move to release the base expansions first (Seasons, Pets, University, ...) and than fill the game with fun, but not necessary content, like Island Living and Stranger Ville and since they've moved to the fun-content, I actually don't believe that University will ever come around. Especially since they are releasing the Macig-pack next.

[@tomiekawakami1056]

University would take long to make. I mean what do you need it for.

[@finnickshade9289]

Don’t make me cry like this... please.. that’s all im holding on for..

[@XxBigDaddyDagothxX]

If we even get one lol

[@bambeeyejoy]

If there was an underwater world or resorts, it wouldve been worth 40$

[@matilda9787]

Joy Lou ye but they’d be half assed like always in sims 4

[@officesys355]

exactly! I think resorts was a really under appreciated piece of island living! it was really the only thing i repeatedly went back to

[@sweetpotato8032]

MatildaPlayz uv Tom

[@TripleEye_Josh]

Right, so half the work put into it at twice the price. Kinda the tagline for EA, isn't it?

[@loveaffect]

Triple Eye - Indie Gaming it used to be different 🤦🏽‍♀️its crazy how money hungry they are

[@strain42]

As someone who grew up in Hawaii there's definitely a charm to island life that I'll always enjoy, and this does seem like it has an absolutely lovely aesthetic, but maybe not for that price. Thanks for the review, LGR! Always look forward to your Sims coverage.

[@Barbie_All_The_Way]

You would think if the Sims 3 had underwater scenery, the the Sims 4 would have more in high def underwater scenery.

[@Jimboola]

A pack that seems half finished for twice the price! Seems only fair to wait for a 50% discount then! 😎👍😊

[@smallworldhaker7781]

exactly what I'm doing too

[@XxCOOKEExxMONSTARxX]

@@Amakawrites wtf it's $31 in usa

[@Dakota.Buckley]

@@XxCOOKEExxMONSTARxX £26 converts to about $33.

[@alexdelaloire8739]

@@XxCOOKEExxMONSTARxX it's 39.99€ for me!!

[@XxCOOKEExxMONSTARxX]

*head bangs*

[@03jalapeno]

Sims 4 has been this way since launch. Less content for more money!

[@allyah180]

FameKills The Sims 3 will forever be better than the Sims 4 content wise. The Sims 2 triumphs them all. Sis, we get that you like the Sims 4, and there is nothing wrong with that, but what you will not do is shit on its predecessors when they are obviously much better games.

[@byronmurphy9996]

@@allyah180 y'all shit on the Sims 4 and the people that like it so that's kinda hypocritical plus this review doesn't even provide all the aspects of the pack

[@spinoanimations1130]

@@jibblejabble4599 im a fan of both but which games has 14 stuff packs?

[@pyromania2280]

@@byronmurphy9996 the review is meant to be kinda sarcastic and not very serious

[@kentingz]

FameKills your so wrong sis. Tell me where University is. Oh I also forgot to mention we don’t actually have a proper story progression yet which in my opinion is THE MOST important aspect of a life simulation. Also remember those red people that come by when your house is on fire? I don’t either because firefighters aren’t in the fucking game yet. There are other things that have been cut out like CAW, Cars, there aren’t even relationships when when you load into a family’s life. And you think it’s worth it? 🤡🤡🤡 stop lying to yourself. Girl how long has she been out? 5 fucking years now. xD She literally progressed zero

[@KennethStokes]

The Sims are so lifeless looking and their emotions and animations are so out of date looking. It's not interesting anymore. I really Hope Sims 5 goes much deeper in the AI.

[@foxygrin]

a better bet would be a life simulator from another (indie) company coming out, starting off like the sims 1 once did

[@Gaxriel]

I think The Sims 5 will be a flop, Paralives is in development and so many people are mad at EA, because of The Sims 4

[@Gaxriel]

@@foxygrin Paralives

[@Gaxriel]

So, sales will go down at least 15%

[@KennethStokes]

Paralives don't have money like Maxis Sims team, that's my only concern with Paralives. I don't think there's gonna have much depth to the actual parafolks. Hopefully tho!

[@AshPuppy]

Every Sims 4 expansion have been watered down versions of Sims 3 packs. Get famous did offer something unique but was still weak.

[@simi.883]

get famous wasnt unique you could get famous in ts3

[@AshPuppy]

@@simi.883 If youre referencing to "Sims 3: Late Night" that was not the same. Yes, it had the reputation system in a similar way. But it didnt offer "content creator" as a job and video editing as a task you could do. It was quite unique, but still didnt go nearly as deep as I know they can (theyve gone far deeper with TS3 content) and as such its still not worth the money.

[@christmysaviour3585]

get famous would’ve been WAAAY more better in my opinion if the world wasn’t so fucking small

[@Notsbaby]

Sad to see the sims die like this, no one I know is spending 40$ for 10% of what we got in sims 3

[@sourdough3533]

Nah, this franchise has a lot of fans who will buy any slop that's put out, simply so they have a complete collection.

[@alexdelaloire8739]

Nah, I always buy the packs on sale, ok for city living I really could have paid full price as it is kinda having lots more features than I expected...but the rest of it I waited for promotions (except vampires)

[@miaa1762]

My mom bought it for me, and we both facepalmed when we realized what came in the pack for $40🤠

[@slyseal2091]

40 Kilogramms of spices and sugar seem like a bargain to me, 'specially when the anchors lifted and the crew out of sight

[@victoriab637]

Island paradise >>>

[@gagasluxury7458]

Another iconic review that we’ll watch for 20 times oh yes

[@queencleopatra007]

Yes! I still go back and re-watch all the sims 3 reviews even though I already own all the packs

[@mofadlson]

@@queencleopatra007 I do the same. I love them. Also LGR had so much more content to work with. Those EPs are so empty.

[@queencleopatra007]

@@mofadlson Yeah, plus it was nice to see him review packs that he enjoyed and looked forward to

[@marsha_love]

LGR's reviews are just so addicting to watch

[@madierin8525]

soooo true, even ones I already have I watch so often as I just love them

[@Fred.Xtreme]

Anyone else here bc of the 50% off sale on PS Store?

[@TonyDurante]

yeah idk which to get

[@Tigerstarr9]

I remember when a pack announcement made me feel like it was Christmas. When the sims 3 island paradise was announced, I swear I watched that trailer almost everyday. Sims 3 had me excited because I knew that there was going to be tons of stuff to explore. I’ve really tried giving sims 4 a chance, but when they announce stuff, I don’t feel excited at all.

[@majlordag1889]

Most packs feel like tasteless cake, such disappointment when you "take a bite" from it even if it looks tasty

[@SeddieWeddie]

Anyone else noticing the expansion packs are getting smaller? Get Together and City Living offered so much. Cats and Dogs got away with it because they offered animals but every other expansion is meh.

[@clemjm.c]

city living was the pack with the least objects and gameplay actually. with get famous having the biggest variety of build and buy. cats and dogs was an equal EP. seasons focused more on gameplay than cas and build n buy. ISLAND LIVING offered the second biggest variety of BUILD n BUY and the BIGGEST variety of CAS. idk what ure talking abt luv

[@LookingForFrogs]

@@clemjm.c What? I feel like Get together and Get to work were way weaker than packs like Cats and Dogs and expecially Seasons . What did get together even offer? Besides Windenburg world and clubs, I can't tell you what was in it.

[@jibblejabble4599]

are you dumb

[@sexyjon589]

@@clemjm.c who cares about build/buy and CAS items? This is an EP, not a stuff pack, we want new gameplay mechanics and new animations

[@eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee2040]

idk, get famous added a lot to the game in my opinion. fame, reputation, a lot of really nice build items etc etc. city living, i feel was a bit lacking. it introduced a lot of new things, sure but i dont agree that it offered as much as get together (build-mode wise, at least.)

[@DigiDestined55X]

I love that you made Ralph in game. I even love more that he's just as cute as his doll couterpart. 😄

[@blshouse]

I thought it was kind of ironic that Ralph was made with items from multiple stuff packs. ;-)

[@DigiDestined55X]

@@blshouse Haha! Very true. Did not catch that.

[@user-hardbrain]

Very awesome that he made Ralph into a Sim :D

[@Derkasnake]

Thanks for pointing this out, I thought it was Doug Walker?

[@maryk7262]

Ralph's memory will live on in the game that killed him. RIP

[@user-zn9my6hc7l]

I actually think it'll be nice if the sims 5 base game has seasons, pets and university. But that's not going to happen since EA will rush everything and makes it so empty. I think sims 5 will be more dissapointing than sims 4 but we'll see

[@asideofaioli4630]

I don't think they're rushing shit. I think they know they don't have to put any effort into the game, so they don't, and people still buy it. Then they purposefully leave stuff out from the base game and add-ons just to be able to make more money by selling features that should already be available, later in a diff pack.

[@erickarma8995]

facts

[@putdogdirectlyonbed]

they should of just made an HD remake for TS3 and its packs if they're gonna be releasing half-baked stuff like this for $40 bucks... honestly was looking forward to this pack but my hopes were too high :[

[@PorcelainVal]

I never buy Sims content without seeing your reviews first. Your videos always confirm my suspicions about the gameplay experience. Thanks for putting together the best and most interesting Sims reviews on KZbin.

[@that-possum-guy3209]

Not to mention honest. I don't trust Game Changers. Sorry, you guys.

[@Alunaanra]

Sims 3 Island Paradise (especially the diving) looks so much cooler...still can't be convinced that Sims 4 is better

[@JuliaMurphy2013]

Isla Paradiso looks so much worse than Sulani. It's a bunch of generic buildings that could fit into any town, surrounded by generic textures. If you can't run everything on max, it looks horrible, and if you can run everything on max, it looks worse than Sulani. not that I'd waste $40 for little more than a half completed world.

[@markurbanowicz6619]

Agree with you guys. This expansion needs more work and content.

[@megakaren2160]

@@JuliaMurphy2013 I wouldn't call the brightly-colored stucco buildings in TS3 Island Paradise generic.

[@sonotfetch]

Honestly, it's making me want to reinstall the Sims 3 just so I can play it all over again

[@radwooah]

@@JuliaMurphy2013 Sulani is nothing else but some palms, bridges over the ocean and orange skies. And for those of us who play on medium or low settings everything looks awful, especially the water...

[@deligracy]

Solid review LGR X

[@LGR]

Thank you!

[@moniemoon.]

That's a pack that really deserves an update, like they did with the spa day game pack... Such a beautiful world! They could add exploring underwater and a skill tree for mermaids.

[@MarvMarvensen]

I don't even play Sims, and don't plan to. But your videos are just entertaining and relaxing...

[@Game-Now]

You're doing yourself a favor. Do not get the game.

[@elementz4876]

Unless you get it for free of course.

[@kimirs16]

I still like Sims 3 [free]

[@SobiTheRobot]

@@Game-Now Unless you're getting any of the previous Sims games. But especially 3.

[@Game-Now]

@@SobiTheRobot Oh definitely. Any of them except The Sims 4.

[@IronSeagull]

Yay I've been excited to see this! Agreed on everything about off the grid. Was really hoping it would've won the community stuff pack vote and I'm glad we still got it anyway, but man it could be so much better. Hopefully they can easily expand it since it was put in a free update instead of restricted to Island Living

[@nickochioneantony9288]

players should taking this expansion packs selling more seriously... I mean $40 for recycled concept in every sims game, BUT with subpar or passionless contents. I think EA will make another Sims game simply because the players are easily-manipulated goldmine, not because they want to expand creativity to the franchise. You can always complain about your dissapoinment, but this expansions practice is too precious to let go for EA and you will always fall for it.

[@WesLewisMusic]

Everyone thought the downgraded graphics and load screens just meant they were gonna fill the game with LOADS of content and bring us back to The Sims 2's entertainment LOL. I really have no idea why people are still putting money into this game, it is literally the most downgraded lack luster version of the sims ever. The developers obviously don't care... I thought the sims 4 was cool at first but I stopped after "get to work"

[@heavenlystar292]

I got bored after less than an hour playing this and i feel bad for wasting my dads money 😔

[@littlelambproductions8979]

Same I didn’t look at this before buying this and I kinda regret doing it now...

[@TheoTheCoolest]

Spend your own money

[@MarineSimmer]

If they had added a skill tree to mermaids and added hotels and something to diving i'd be happier to pay full price... glad i went on a website and got a gamekey for much cheaper than the actual expansion pack

[@madstayy]

if they did something with the gameplay it wouldve probably been the best expansion pack but there is so many missed opportunities with this pack

[@namaste_charlei]

LGR "... And why aren't there any options for collecting rainwater, or using solar panels or anything?" Me: ::stares at Sims 4: Eco Lifestyle::

[@Kourkos1117]

I hate this expansion. I was soooo excited for the mermaid feature but I was let down a TON

[@silkisnothere]

I was about to buy this pack but then I saw your video; I am honestly very disappointed about the scuba diving and mermaid features. Thanks for saving me 40 bucks if you see this :’)

[@matthewd3175]

Mermaids are wayyy better than sims 3 tho

[@GBfanatic15]

@@matthewd3175 not really...in the sims 3 if the mermaids were evil they could get sharks to attack people

[@GBfanatic15]

I was so angry when I played scuba diving only to find out what it was....sims 3 scuba diving was fucking cool

[@tarastanojevic6054]

@@matthewd3175 maybe u like it cus of the animation and graphics, like look it is more fun to explore the underwater world and being a mermaid that is actually underwater

[@arty8703]

EA needs to stop copying TS3 content into TS4. It just makes it more obvious how much TS4 lacks in comparison.

[@user-xb5bz4fu9o]

But if they don't then fans complain

[@cheatexp]

@@user-xb5bz4fu9o and if they do they still complain

[@robynndoesstuff7495]

They just need to start doing it right imo, sims 3 was awesome but could use some upgrades. I'd pay for a mix between ts3 and ts4, mainly the open world aspects tho 😂

[@strxwberrymvlk]

No offence but this makes no sense. Sims 4 is supposed to be a SEQUEL in the Sims series so OBVIOUSLY it'll have the same stuff like the previous versions. I mean we can say that Sims 3 copied Sims 2 as well and the latter copied Sims 1, it's literally from the same company hence why it's called the SIMS.

[@carelletsopmo9366]

@@strxwberrymvlk we mean that they should be giving us something new, something fresh.

[@oni5153]

From the way things are going with The Sims 4, I think we'll only get hotels/resorts through yet another game pack. I can already see them releasing a Get to manage hotels GM of some sorts so they can milk the cow even more...

[@amaliateixeira8337]

I dunno... Resorts are very big places, so with such small lots...

[@kentaayashi9663]

And little did you know how right you were 💀💀💀

[@onome9305]

spot on lol

[@rain4423]

Agreed. This feels more like a game pack, and despite the pretty world it feels empty and less goal-oriented than other packs. If it was $20 I'd say it was well worth it, but at $40 I don't know.

[@caesar1512]

Imo, I feel like the Sims 4 dlcs are honestly overpriced, since the content that Maxis and EA gave us are very lacking, heres how they should price their DLCs: Expansions: 20 Game Pack: 10 Stuff Pack: 5 I don't think they'll be losing money the community is still somewhat big

[@ParasiteQueen1]

I agree with these prices.

[@iodine1169]

That's the most I'm willing to pay for them. Wait for sales or check out key resale shops instead.

[@avaesthetics]

I agree the prices are perfect

[@Spitsonyou]

they will never do that since people already showed they are willing to pay higher prices

[@laurav3798]

I only buy if there's a sale. And I mean a 50% off sale, not just 20% off.

[@RockZombieIAm]

Mermaids should've had more to them. Diving should be an active thing to do like in TS3 All the new careers should be active. There's literally no reason they're not. Like life guard... ocean swimming... why would it be a rabbit hole? I hate traits that are super tailored to the pack. I'll never use child of the ocean/island unless my sim lives in Sulani The world of Sulani is pretty but also lacking. I was so excited for this, and I'm really disappointed as someone who played the Island Paradise in TS4, they keep downgrading from the previous iterations that were great. I could've waited for this and not had a stuff pack. Or just have 2 game packs.

[@grillskillz7773]

"The gameplay can be bizarrely shallow." Yes, even when you are deep in water.

[@binimbap]

"It's a beautiful-looking world, but the gameplay can be bizarrely shallow" every sims 4 expansion pack up until now in a nutshell.

[@ianadams187]

My good friend made that mod! Been watching you for years and kinda fanboying that someone I know is in your video 😂

[@sebastianbenavidesmorales2274]

can you post the link to the mod pls

[@VesLuma]

😘

[@grimhavenz]

What mod?

[@BrightWulph]

It's almost as if the sims team learned from the criticism of the too linear storyline of Stranger Ville and totally over corrected in making it too simple. Either that or EA cut their budget or jumped the gun somewhere...

[@smallworldhaker7781]

definitely seems like EA rushed the team creating this pack to release it in time for the end of kids school year

[@alexdelaloire8739]

Yeah, either the team is lazy and doesn't take criticism or EA is pressuring the team to work faster.

[@BrightWulph]

@@alexdelaloire8739 My money is on EA rushing the team, as the sims team do seem passionate about making content.

[@BrightWulph]

@@smallworldhaker7781 That definitely seems like the case, Island Living was announced like what two weeks before it was set to release? Seems like EA was telling the sims team "Quick, get something out!" and having them cut a lot of content out of the pack.

[@maryk7262]

I remember when get together was originally announced, they ended up pushing back the release date by a few weeks. And that pack actually feels very fleshed out compared to the other ones

[@lbrokenvibel3100]

I love the way you do reviews you get to a realistic in depth video and I enjoy that you don’t skim past things like other youtubers

[@eryan1419]

It’s bizarre because they’re constantly interacting with fans but these issues just continue to happen...

[@bienlu]

yard syx i totally agree with you

[@renatopereira810]

its because they just pretend to listen. they just look it up to the ea game changers program and its followers that provide only good positive comments how TS4 is perfect. LOL One of the gurus even said that he prefers to see comments only on twitter and never read the forums because its full of negativity (probably because the major forum members are older simmers) The y have a new target and for them TS4 is amazing and old fans are completely ignored by them.

[@SoujiMonaru]

I'm a bit hesitant to say that they should just make Sims 5 already instead of beating this dead horse, but if they do such little effort for this game, then you can believe that The Sims 5 would be worse...great review anyway, Clint! ^_~

[@desired2396]

Souji Monaru the things people complain about will go to the sims 5 if they make it any time soon. The things people hate(rabbit holes, loading screens, ) those are the main 2 cause they annoy people so much. They added these to allow people with weaker pcs to play. I like some of this stuff cause it makes the game run smoother for me but I understand that people who would already run it fine get mad. Until there is a new age of computers are software they shouldn’t release the sims 5. I want the sims 5 to be a completely open world(like connecting towns and open oceans) like playing in a big world like Breath of the wild. This would require a new software and new computers to be able to run it.

[@matheusleite3864]

It looks like the sims 5 is already on the works, and now that they made the sims 4 entirely for "weak computers" I hope they make the sims 5 entirely for decent computers.

[@destinyn63]

Souji Monaru yep. The sims 4 was doomed from the start .

[@hanimallover1]

@@desired2396 There are computers that can run that. You just have to buy the parts. Even my pre-built PC ran Sims 3 just fine with all expansions and stuff packs. It's time the players invested into a better gaming computer.

[@Deandrax]

I spent too much money on sims 4...i think they definitely can improve it before just moving on

[@ellure]

yet all the sims stans will praise this half effort by EA

[@jibblejabble4599]

EA served again and you will deal

[@allyah180]

ellure Let’s just talk about how most people who like EA and their shitty packs are BUILDERS who hardly ever go into gameplay. The Sims team mostly caters to builders, and there is hardly a good patch for gameplay.

[@midnightsunrise44]

It says a lot though when we see someone like Deligracy express her disappointment with this expansion pack. She was honest instead of keeping quiet so she can keep getting games for free and going to events, lol.

[@gradientmapabuser9875]

*sims 4 stans,,, honestly i am never gonna budge from sims 3. i love the mods, open world, and possibility to be creative. ten years of playing and i'm still not bored

[@dr.funster1585]

Every1 except me...I've been telling all my fellow sims friends/players 2 w8 4 a sale on this pack

[@liekev.v.6356]

On the Sims 3 I ALWAYS made a family in the Isla Paradiso world because I loved it so darn much. I was so excited when I saw it was coming to the Sims 4, but this is just really dissapointing. There’s almost nothing new and they took away so many fun things. I always had a living boat and now they’re just gone! The lack of content usually made up to how amazing it looked, but this is just stupid. Anyways, awesome review! You gained a new sub! :D

[@Adorkablegamermsp]

your literally my favorite sims you-tuber like your reviews are iconic ♥

[@patrik9745]

The most important things i want in sims 5 (maybe you can make a video about it?) 1. open world 2. sims 4 gameplay, which means: moods, multitasking, the building mode 3. careers like in the sims 3 ambitions and jobs where you actually do something like firefighter or life guard (sims 3), architect, singer, magician, acrobat, etc... 4. cars! and car animations like in the sims 2 nightlife, where sims actually go inside the car and freaking drive it out of the garage or lot 5. festivals like in sims 4 6. CAS like in sims 4 7. more customization options, like in the sims 3 8. Resorts, you can own or just visit them , like sims 3 9. purchase properties (sims 3) 10. earning fame by performing or by making videos about your career, like, you're a singer, you upload videos on how you sing, or give sing tipps, you earn fame, same with performing on stages, you earn fame both ways! singing, acrobatics, movie director or actor, etc... 11. University 12. more careers where we can follow our sims to their job and help them do it, like in sims 4 get to work or sims 3 ambitions and more things this is just my oppinion, i honestly love all sims 3 expansions and i think that the sims 3 is in some aspects a much better game than sims 4 even tho sims 3 is "outdated" compared to the sims 4, but i enjoy playing the sims 3 more than the sims 4, in the sims 4 you just sometimes feel you are limited and because of the "closed world" and loading screens if you wanna to go to just your freaking neighbour, this just gets really annoying.

[@rodre0250]

Compare this to TS3's Island Paradise. Sims 4 is a disgrace for this franchise.

[@mofadlson]

I just rewatched Island Paradise review. I agree Sims 4 is a disgrace

[@liquidmodernitytasteslikeu2855]

what a beautiful comment, i'm glad not everyone on the "the sims" fanbase is stupid

[@sauldownbadman876]

Sims 4 isn't that bad

[@mofadlson]

@@sauldownbadman876 it's not that bad yes, but it is a huge step back. The game is just not engaging or complex enough. Until to this day I play Sims 3 and discover new things. This is how complex and well thought game it was. Sims 4 should have built on 3, fix all those technical issues and added more layer of complexity. Sims 4 is just too shallow.

[@mofadlson]

And repetitive. How many times did they reuse this chemistry beaker animation? How many times do they use regular conversation animation in a unique named interaction with another sim? A lot!! I miss the days where I would spend weeks exploring content in an EP. Now it would take me a day or two to see everything.

[@joshdepaola4002]

In my opinion I think they should stop production of Sims4 packs and just focus on the sims 5 and hopefully it can be better than the Sims3

[@joshdepaola4002]

@Labradoorr :(

[@tomiekawakami1056]

Josh DePaola how would the sims 5 be any better they will still have to make packs and people will still complain about stuff they can’t even do.

[@joshdepaola4002]

@@tomiekawakami1056 hopefully they expand on the base game and go for a more realistic approach like the sims 3 did the Sims4 was a step back in the series but it also made it more accessible to younger players it was a marketing decision and the hardcore sims fans suffered because of it.

[@lexiemariet]

I wish there was hotels like in the sims 3 :( that’s what made the sims 3 island paradise fun

[@annmareeofoz]

Yeah I felt let down by the pack and the cost. It definitely feels like they didn't flesh it out enough. Why didn't they have more events that could spawn around the islands, like City Living? I know they had the one Turtle hatching thing, which popped up unexpectedly and didn't allow for much pre-planning of your sim-day and seemed to be over fairly quickly. Why not also have other events you could start yourself (other than the Kava Party). The mermaid thing was cool as first but seemed too easy to become by just buying the kelp from your aspiration menu, and there was nothing 'special' about meeting one - and once you made your sim into a mermaid then it was like 'well now what'? You didn't really get anything much new to do interaction or skill wise that we can't already do with music, potions, voodoo dolls and cheats. I did enjoy the conservation career and odd jobs and such, and having it effect the island. I love how the world looks and the free-range open-ness of it. But there's nothing deeper there and I was left sorely disappointed throughout most of the gameplay.

[@candiegray4037]

The mermaid thing was so downplayed! When i noticed sims hid the fact that they are mermaids from you I got excited, I thought I could get the kelp that way or get some new interactions but no. Like everything sims 4 it ends in nothing even though it good potential.

[@dixoisme2601]

I waited on your review before buying because I know that your review is brutally honest.

[@personperson8953]

Same!

[@ExtraordinaryDork]

Unpopular opinion: Bring back Castaway

[@mmoboxs]

So Sims 4 is still just one big downgrade to it's predecessor