LIVE: MA v. Karen Read Day 3 - Killer Or Cover-Up Murder Trial | COURT TV

[@CourtTV]

00:00:00 MA v. Karen Read Day 3 00:20:08 STATE #6 -- ANTHONY FLEMATTI, FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC, CANTON FIRE DEPT. 02:23:59 STATE #7 -- MATTHEW KELLY, FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC, CANTON FIRE DEPT. 03:11:10 STATE #8 -- FRANCIS WALSH, LT. PARAMEDIC, CANTON FIRE DEPT. 03:33:09 STATE’S #9 -- KATIE MCLAUGHLIN, FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC, CANTON FIRE DEPT. #CourtTV Catch up on all the facts of the case against #KarenRead, Killer Or Cover-Up #MurderTrial. ⚖👇 MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/karen-read/?

[@justmom5318]

Isnt the judge supposed to be neutral? Why does she seem angry when defense is talking. Her breathing in the microphone is so annoying and rude. I've watched a few court cases and never heard judge do that.

[@SLO_6]

💯 Yes. The breathing is BEYOND annoying!

[@LynMiller-ft4ds]

My thoughts exactly. Welcome to "The Commonwealth. "

[@Larrydavey]

Since the beginning she is against the defense. Her day will be coming too.

[@kerrymedeiros509]

Can the judge mute her microphone?! I'm sick of hearing her sighs and grunts of annoyance. It's annoying us.

[@AllDayVapor]

The judge is disgusted. Because the defense has no merit and ridiculous! This isn't the 1960s. Some people are clueless! Cops are not framing a murder scene! Just wait till you see all the evidence! Especially when they show that her vehicle was traveling 60 ft in reverse at over 20 miles an hour. And John's hair was found in the tail lights. She's a psycho cop killer.

[@bellisimafedora8855]

It's annoying watching KR and her families sh** a** facial expressions.. "tough guys" is it her sister twin who looks so angry ?

[@81laurenjean]

Seriously! Her moans and groans could lead to a friggen mistrial IMO. absolutely unprofessional and obnoxious. I was watching a Canadian defense lawyer add commentary to day 2 and he was miffed by it too. When even Canada is saying, “wtf, judge” maybe the judge should start looking within lol

[@John-tj4up]

I like it

[@Ginam3939]

Why does this judge always sound wicked annoyed? Anyone else notice that or am I just crazy lol

[@lawrenceandcheryldoudiet5090]

When it comes to the defence, yes I notice it.

[@kimpatterson7171]

Her team is losing 😂😂.

[@Larrydavey]

Since pre-trial

[@lavine3532]

Day 3, it seems the judge continues to be annoyed with the defense and as everyone has said that breathing is going to drive me crazy!!

[@michaelcalland801]

So responding Paramedic claims he told ER staff that victim was hit by car yet the hospital made no record of that at all ? I find that hard to believe…l

[@pennicochrane8886]

The Prosecutor is so bad, he let's the defence go on and on and doesn't protect their witness! He doesn't reject!!!! Wish he would go back and hear what the Lawyers are saying about him. She is do guilty!

[@michaelcalland801]

@@pennicochrane8886 Wait until the defense puts on their case You’re going to hear that MK had an Apple Watch on & climbed a flight of stairs that night, you’re going to hear about the obvious dog bites on his arm & the Alberts aggressive German Sheppard who had bitten several people in the past. There’s also a library directly across the street from Karen Read with cameras but the video tape from that night is mysteriously missing, video that would’ve showed “ no broken taillight “. You’ll hear about MK, despite being allegedly run over, the only injuries he sustained were 2 black swollen eyes & a laceration to the back of the head You’ll hear about Brian Alberts 17 yo punk nephew being at the home that night who happens to live next door to MK. They also were having disputes over beer cans being thrown onto MKs property. An Eye witness places a Ford Edge parked exactly where MKs body was found at 3am. Albert, his brother & nephew all drive a Ford Edge. Why did the Alberts get rid of their dog ? Why did they rip up the basement floor ? Just wait until the defense puts on their case…. Dirty Cops covering for even Dirtier Cops !

[@Unhyphenated]

There's a lot of convenient misses in documenting in this case. 🤔

[@Sleeplessinsilverlakes]

The judge sighing is really disrespectful!! Wth

[@gretchensims6657]

These defense attorneys are so incredibly artful in their cross exam.

[@steveryan7786]

I’m keeping an open mind, but there’s something off the mark about many different aspects of this case

[@BlessedHotMess-p7b]

Everyone needs to contact the courts and find out how to complain about this judge. Its like she's inconvienced having to be there. FFS, get off the bench. And it's only when the defense is presenting.

[@Beckyyshaeee]

Right???? It’s like she has no patience for the defense at all like????

[@lorrainemithrush7962]

I agree. And how she cut defence lawyer off from asking more questions

[@lfc63]

Can you get a more boring prosecutor? I can't hear a word he says.

[@pennicochrane8886]

He may loose his case, dam it!

[@Cbreezzy]

@@pennicochrane8886 He should have.. it’s ok though, things will start to crumble for the DA soon

[@jenbabe1796]

And I don’t like this judge. She keeps huffing and puffing in the microphone like she’s annoyed she has to do her job. So unprofessional !

[@lyndahayes5958]

This judge is rightly defending the witnesses as they are being treated like liars from the defence attorneys. The poor family of the victim having to watch this behaviour thank god the judge is fighting to keep behaviour under check. She is doing her job as a judge she’s not doing anything wrong here. I don’t see any bias or favouring the prosecutor. She is respectful to the jury and she has questioned the prosecutor on the case hearing last week. These witnesses should not have to be treated the way they are from the defense attorneys. They are being called liars, questioned on every second on the stand. KR thinks she’s an attorney sitting trying to hear on judge/counsel discussions. Back off KR you are surrounded by the family of JOK. You’re laughing at this every time your attorneys sit down from destroying witnesses. Paramedics aren’t police so the far fetched conspiracy theories don’t stretch to them. Different from the police stop laughing at how they are being treated. Your sitting growling at everyone around you god help if they disagree with anything related to you. Like on the steps outside the court house when a journalist asked if you did it then others. Admit your guilt please and stop destroying other people’s life’s like they don’t matter.

[@jenbabe1796]

@@lyndahayes5958 the cops are lying and the paramedics are also lying. She is not guilty. I’m I’m glad to see the defense team is doing their job to the fullest.

[@Zenon2006]

​@@lyndahayes5958Treated like liars? They are called DEFENSE attorneys for a reason

[@Kimbo-y3s]

I know!!!!!

[@nursejones2]

I didn’t hear her growl. Did anyone hear her growl? IMO OFFICER John O’Keefe’s family is finally seeing the light. I think they are flabbergasted by the coverup created by people who “befriended” them.

[@wildmercuryfilms]

2:20:37 Listen to the tone of the Judge toward The Defense. She has A HORRIBLE TONE toward The Defense. She has THROUGHOUT. Very very very NEGATIVE TONE from The Judge to The Defense.

[@PJTYLER]

She is very bias. She has some very personal ties to Boston PD. and Canton PD

[@Maureen-q6w]

She also can be heard deeply ‘sighing’ as if the defense is insufferable to deal with.

[@GenerationXChick]

“I hit him I hit him”. Paramedic: I didn’t document that anywhere.

[@cyndiotwell2067]

If you don't write it down, It did not happen!!!!

[@John-tj4up]

​@@cyndiotwell2067are you this stupid when you're not posting absurd comments!

[@Marce44ful]

The witness is so evasive and the judge and the judge helps him out! The Defense did a good job at trying to hack away at his, “I don’t recalls…!

[@ajwysopal]

You're absolutely correct. He clearly has been told what to say. All these cops and medics are shady as hell. Liars. And when confronted on video they suddenly don't recall or can't tell what's on the video..... Like come on yall. This is ridiculous. This lady is being framed and set up by this shady ass department of cops and medics.

[@carlogambino924]

Facts ✔️

[@DesignRhythm]

Sure is funny how he remembers everything so well until it goes against the state narrative.

[@jo3608]

Yep! He actually embarrassed himself. What a shame.

[@PJTYLER]

Every time a witness states "I don't recall " They are saying, I am lying. The jury knows that.

[@butterflygirl2285]

IMO - The judge always seems annoyed with the defense team for some reason. Is that just my perception or do others agree with me?.

[@AllDayVapor]

The judge is disgusted. Because the defense has no merit and ridiculous! This isn't the 1960s. Some people are clueless! Cops are not framing a murder scene! Just wait till you see all the evidence! Especially when they show that her vehicle was traveling 60 ft in reverse at over 20 miles an hour. And John's hair was found in the tail lights. She's a psycho cop killer.

[@JAJJABLOG]

@@AllDayVaporwhere does the evidence show she was going 20 miles an hour? I’ve been watching this trial, did miss this? And, why all the effort & evidence from Blue to go out their way to cross their T’s & dot their I’s? FBI told the family that he didn’t get hit by a car. They’re just waiting to see how the trial plays out.

[@Juke582]

Because the defense is fake!

[@AllDayVapor]

@@Juke582 exactly! It shocks me that so many people actually believe she didn't do it, and the cops frame this whole murder. What a joke;😂

[@yvonnedeboer7535]

​@@AllDayVaporEven if she thinks that...she shouldn't breath so loud!

[@Kimbo-y3s]

This judge needs to be away from the microphone her breathing is horrendous!!!!!

[@kimpatterson7171]

I was thinking the same thing...who is that breathing so heavy 😂😂

[@marieamont3438]

😮‍💨😮‍💨😮‍💨😮‍💨😮‍💨😅 so annoying

[@AllDayVapor]

The judge is disgusted. Because the defense has no merit and ridiculous! This isn't the 1960s. Some people are clueless! Cops are not framing a murder scene! Just wait till you see all the evidence! Especially when they show that her vehicle was traveling 60 ft in reverse at over 20 miles an hour. And John's hair was found in the tail lights. She's a psycho cop killer.

[@jghoul2538]

I though whomever is on the witness stand needs to adjust the mic so we don't keep hearing the breathing. This is great coverage though.

[@LegendLength]

Sounds like my dog after a big run

[@miltonousland9324]

So defense is using the fact that the ambulance driver could clealry see the body and it had no snow ro show the people in the house were lying when they said they couldn't see him from the wondow. Then suddenly judge calls side bar twice

[@daffydill5590]

I'm trying to understand how he got those deep gashes on his arm wearing a long sleeved hoody. I would want to see the hoody if I was a juror. To see if it was slashed.

[@Ricsamg]

The defense will show it on the hospital floor. After that it was given to the detective who drove the clothes around for a couple weeks. Chain of custody of this evidence is awful.

[@carlogambino924]

​@@Ricsamg You aren't lying. It's amazing that the state feels they can gain a conviction from such lackluster police work, and all the evidence pointing to the fact that there are some major, major discrepancies in the facts here. Clearly this woman is being railroaded and framed for something she did not do. Shameful. May justice prevail for her. Her defense attorneys are excellent.

[@kimpatterson7171]

On another report I heard there was dog in the house & may have attached him. 😲😲

[@kimpatterson7171]

@@carlogambino924 they probably didn't think she could afford a good attorney, jokes on them. The people in the town are supporting her, instead of the officer who was killed. That speaks volumes, they got the wrong person on trial.

[@live4only472]

She's guilty but police fucked it up. Why would someone kill somebody for a dog attack lol!?

[@lolabear3230]

I dont like when there is an objection the judge saying ... he can have that one , she should say overruled and stop being bias

[@shieh.4743]

Agree. "He can have that one" suggests she is not ruling based on the law but on her feelings of generosity at the time.

[@tkx7]

Here are some facts of the case for you people still on the fence (no one disputes these): -Body found over 10 feet from curb with zero taillight glass or anything found in the area during initial reports (only ~1 inch of snow) -Body not seen by plow truck that did initial run down street at around 2AM (no snow at this time when body would have been there) -Body had zero torso/mid section injuries and had slashes/cuts on arm and both front and back of head gashes/wounds as well as hand/defense wounds -Body missing a shoe -Zero investigation/search of residence at property for evidence or clues -911 call placed by sister in law of a cop/first responder that LIVED at the property.. YET SHE DIDN't GET HIM/ALERT HIM (or tell 911 this) to perform possible life saving measures/assess what happened

[@michaelcalland801]

- Pieces of broken taillight were found only “ After” defendant’s vehicle was seized & in possession of LE the following day.

[@jo3608]

Thank you for stating the facts. As you mentioned, no one has disputed these facts. Sadly, many people do not care about the facts and rather make decisions based on emotions. I hope the jury considers only the facts when deliberating and I hope that the real murderer is convicted so that there is true justice for Officer O'Keefe.

[@stevenprice6957]

@@jo3608Yea let’s hope the real killer is convicted. Her name is Karen.

[@jo3608]

@@stevenprice6957 I don't think so. You should probably watch the trial and listen to the testimony of every witness, as it appears you haven't watched the trial or paid attention. Have a nice day.

[@stevenprice6957]

@@jo3608Yes every moment. Guilty and deadly dangerous. Lock her up before she kills another innocent man.

[@MFC7625]

Why would O'Keefe be standing on the side of the road? He would have started to make his way to the house and would have been hit from behind? She drove for 62 feet and back, and he stands there? Waiting on the side of the road, until she hit him?

[@klw3876]

Not inconsistent statements from the EMTs ,just some heard some things others didn't.

[@caseyvincent6817]

Ok so if she tells these paramedics I hit him why did nobody write it in any reports or tell anyone at the time? All this came out later. I think these paramedics are scared of the officers they are up against.

[@K9_Queen19]

Absolutely! They work alongside the police and other departments all the time. Which could affect their careers and personal lives horribly if they go against the PD!

[@BlessedHotMess-p7b]

Because that statement cannot be part of their report. The EMS report has to be about their arrival, what they found, patient care, interventions, VS, treatment etc. Now if infact she stated she hit him, He should of definitely asked her follow up questions. Such as what did u hit him with? That is a critical conversation that would have followed to provide the medic with Mechanism of injuries. And what type of injuries he most likely would have sustained. Big difference in injuries sustained with being struck with a hand and or a bat or a 6k lb vehicle!!

[@BlessedHotMess-p7b]

And that information would have been included on the report and it would have affected any secondary care enroute and at hospital.

[@TRACE317]

Possible pedestrian vs auto would be on the report verbal to er 'room' staff. We're asking that when the call comes to the er and as we all get to the room to prepare we ask what we're getting.

[@montanaparanormal]

And when did it become ok to object and the judge respond without even having to say wtf the objection is for?? If she’s found guilty I expect there will be a huge appeal. This is nuts.

[@emilygill3463]

It was a pre trial motion.

[@BamaMom26]

Judge needs to wear a cpap machine at night. She breathes so heavy it’s gross

[@JAJJABLOG]

😂 CAP MACHINE

[@stephaniegiordano5956]

You can tell the judge is for the other side. She’s out of control.

[@paulineannevazquez8233]

The judge is a piece of work

[@dman1177]

This case is obviously an inconvenience to the judge

[@AllDayVapor]

The judge is disgusted. Because the defense has no merit and ridiculous! This isn't the 1960s. Some people are clueless! Cops are not framing a murder scene! Just wait till you see all the evidence! Especially when they show that her vehicle was traveling 60 ft in reverse at over 20 miles an hour. And John's hair was found in the tail lights. She's a psycho cop killer.

[@EloTheCurious]

The worst part is that both sides asked for a continuance before the trial started to be able to probably tighten up, or finish pulling in the evidence they needed before starting all this. The judge denied it and made them start anyways. It makes the level of micromanaging that she’s done throughout this trial that much more disgusting imo.

[@SusanRidyard]

He's lying through his teeth. That judge, please can someone report her and get her out of that chair

[@stevenprice6957]

Only one person has truly lied. That’s deadly dangerous Karen

[@marjory642]

That judge hates the defense! My goodness!

[@81laurenjean]

I’m calling it. Judge Cannone is going to have a lot of PR problems coming up. I wonder if she’s already trying to get ahead of her unprofessional noise making. My guess is she’s so “untouchable” that she’ll continue to flaunt her heavy breathing, sighs and groans. Absolutely despicable. Someone is dead and another person is on trial for her life. Her groans are NOT IMPARTIAL.

[@supernova101010]

The scratches on his arm were not from a car in reverse at 24 mph with an inch of snow on the ground

[@abrahampadin6390]

Yea I was on the fence about her being guilty but after today I feel like they’re hiding something and trying to frame her. She’s def not guilty!

[@ajwysopal]

Shes absolutely being framed. This is tragic. The emt looks so scared today. Like he's possibly being threatened. All these cops and medics are shady as hell. Liars. And when confronted on video they suddenly don't recall or can't tell what's on the video..... Like come on yall. This is ridiculous. This lady is being framed and set up by this shady ass department of cops and medics.

[@ILoveWoolerbear]

She stated several times 'I hit him, I hit him'. Too bad most involved were so plastered, no one can even remember what happened. And drinking to excess and driving during a blizzard. What idiots and inconsiderate drunks !

[@caseyvincent6817]

She could have thought she did dont be naive. They kept telling her she hit him. She said "I left him" too several times. The people tried to get her to say she hit him but it was always a question she was asking. ​@ILoveWoolerbear

[@LegendLength]

@@ILoveWoolerbear Why didn't anyone inquire with her when she said "I hit him"? Don't you think any cop or fireman would at least say "Tell me more about it."?

[@lawrenceandcheryldoudiet5090]

@@LegendLengthif Karen Read had admitted to a police officer that she had hit him with her car, she would have been detained! Remember at this point in time, there were no fragments of tail light to be found. Figure that out.

[@genevievegreene1595]

This is so sad. She was freaking out that she must have knocked him down and driven off unaware. I would want to know what caused the scratches, and what makes the eyes bulge like that.

[@GenerationXChick]

Mr. Paramedic is being all shifty…I went into the ambulance. I may have been getting equipment. Jesus what is he hiding?

[@marandarose8012]

Interesting how all the paramedics/firefighters all recall different things Karen was screaming while they were on the scene.

[@Miriam-jy7tgz]

This first paramedic seems he got amnesia. "I don't recall" "I don't remember"

[@4RunnerGirl]

This judge should be fired regardless how anyone feels about the case. She is so unprofessional !!! She shows very clearly with her behavior is annoyed by the defense.

[@Unhyphenated]

I watch a lot of trials and I'm curious as to why the judge, independent of either cousel requesting them or their behavior requiring them, keeps having side bars. 🤔 I haven't seen this before.

[@Panda-r8n]

No matter what was said he was there to tend to the patient first and foremost

[@Usermemo8787]

Being possibly hit by a car is a huge detail that would ALWAYS be told to er staff. It determines where their treatment plan goes. It’s part of the turn over to staff. The blood bank needs the information too. He wasn’t hit by a car, especially if he didn’t indicate it in the report. It’s imperative information

[@JAJJABLOG]

@@Usermemo8787FACTS!

[@nursejones2]

Someone ran into the house behind the firefighter doing CPR

[@mariannerogers8003]

“What if anything” Prosecutors favorite phrase Sigh... Judges favorite phrase If I were a juror, neither side has proven to me beyond a reasonable doubt, that she is guilty or innocent. What happens when a juror can’t make a decision either way? Innocent or mistrial?

[@selmeb1291]

Only the prosecution has to prove beyond a reasonable doubt. Defense job is to poke holes.

[@beeslikesteve]

i think its a term used to counter objection to leading.

[@shieh.4743]

The juror should find her not guilty if the prosecution doesn't prove their case. If some jurors find not guilty and others guilty, there can be a mistrial

[@ashadecastro276]

The judge is so biased

[@Jessica-vz7sq]

She DEFINITELY is!!

[@HeatherBelle6]

Speech by judge at the beginning is fearful, defence team winning so far. It's already a slam dunk Karen was set up, lies from the first witness obvious.

[@Juke582]

No way!!!!! Her backing her car up fast 62 ft admitting to hitting John is murder by an angry drunk Karen the faker!

[@BlessedHotMess-p7b]

The only concern is this: both medics said Karen claimed that she hit him. And both their testimonies were very good!!

[@HeatherBelle6]

I am not convinced Anthony Flematti but Mathew Kelly sounded 100 percent honest.

[@PJTYLER]

They are all lying. Every time a witness says "I don't recall" they are lying by omitting.

[@kflo2011]

If she had not said “could I have hit him?” I wonder what narrative the guilty party could have come up with. Jen McCabe heard that & went with it. It was like a golden ticket had been handed to her. She went right into that house and told the Alberts & it went from there.

[@realbillwhite]

This judge is either bored or really put out be defence questions... you can hear her huffing and puffing, breathing heavy when counsel asks to approach a witness, etc.

[@edhebard8868]

The defense was very good today!

[@ji1072]

Very effective!

[@stevenprice6957]

Who cares who was good today. It’s not a contest. It’s trying to establish facts. I hit him. She’s guilty.

[@Meowmeowmeowing1]

@@stevenprice6957tell that to Casey Anthony

[@gregoryedwards7527]

⁠@@stevenprice6957no! She’s not guilty! The ONLY credible paramedic was/is Kelly. His story never changed the ENTIRE time! That is someone who is telling the TRUTH!

[@ajwysopal]

All these cops and medics are shady as hell. Liars. And when confronted on video they suddenly don't recall or can't tell what's on the video..... Like come on yall. This is ridiculous. This lady is being framed and set up by this shady ass department of cops and medics.

[@montanaparanormal]

This is the weirdest trial I’ve ever seen. I’ve never seen witnesses handed reports and be allowed to just read off of them directly versus “refreshing their memory” then actually testifying. Wtf is this.

[@Yo-pz1em]

johnny depp’s trial and jodi arias’s trial also did the same. however, theirs were electronic. canton court rooms seem outdated. i worked at harvard law ( in IT and library), those courtrooms were OUTSTANDING

[@bearpawsz]

This DA looks more stressed out as the days go😂😂

[@JAJJABLOG]

😂

[@kimpatterson7171]

He is definetly looking like a fool 😂😂😂

[@faithnfibro4708]

@JulieGrant attny Jackson did ask the firefighter name starting w/an F if he did write it down in the report! That's what was great bcuz that was the firefighter who said you have to document everything and yet he did not document that she said she hit him she hit him. Also something to note about the female firefighter and I'm watching DVR about an hour behind on the 3rd, shes claiming she said she hit him in front of cop but remember both cops said they didn't hear that!!

[@caitlinsanders1777]

The judge needs to stop sighing & moaning into the microphone. 😊

[@hannadowney]

She just looks so angry. You can’t fake that much anger. She is being set up.

[@Yo-pz1em]

it’s typical bostonian italian anger lol.

[@hugheffo]

During the recess I thought I was watching a onlyfans video 😃😃😃😃😁

[@mollykillarney2419]

Buh-dum-bump 🥁!!!

[@annievw5640]

Too funny 😂

[@Yo-pz1em]

onlyfan

[@edhebard8868]

There were a lot of discrepancy between the EMT's and the Firemen!

[@Nurse_Kathy]

I admit, I wouldn’t be able to remember every detail of a code that happened 2 years ago. After awhile they all blur together!

[@kimpatterson7171]

Since John was an officer, I would think more details would have been kept & recorder on the night of the accident.

[@TKE1009]

@@kimpatterson7171 exactly, but NOT if he was allegedly murdered by a group of fellow officers.

[@texelizabeth6969]

Consistent, I hit him! Ridiculous to think all these departments and people cover up conspiracy theory

[@lindafinch1520]

@@texelizabeth6969 Maybe there was a question mark on the end of Karen's "I hit him?" The women from that house could have been saying to Karen, "you must have hit him." Soooo Karen could have thought "oh no, did I hit him?"

[@selmeb1291]

Good thing they’re all firefighters, all their pants are on fire!

[@tonyawells570]

So tired of hearing "what if any". Lally is extremely boring.

[@MaryKateOBrien-zr7yc]

At 3:03 see the microexpression of Firefighter Kelly which clearly says ‘no’ to ‘the truth never changes.

[@MEMELIFEBABY]

States witnesses: “uh duh um I I um duh uh duh I don’t recall.” Defense: “nothing further your honor.”

[@ajwysopal]

All these cops and medics are shady as hell. Liars. And when confronted on video they suddenly don't recall or can't tell what's on the video..... Like come on yall. This is ridiculous. This lady is being framed and set up by this shady ass department of cops and medics.

[@MFC7625]

Where is the patch of grass where the body was found?

[@Teena-i3i]

Where ? @ another's Cop house @ a Party during the height of COVID and Karen Read wasn't invited nor was now deceased John O’Keefe, but he went anyway without her .... he was already very intoxicated.

[@Floridafanatic28]

@@Teena-i3i You didn't answer the question. Are YOU intoxicated?

[@DesignRhythm]

Wow that cross on the lead EMT was damning. He never mentions anything about "I hit her" to the doctors, police, in his report or to the grand jury. 🤔👀

[@Panda-r8n]

He isn't obliged to it's hear say

[@Panda-r8n]

I hit him and this paramedic answered correctly this is hear say he wasn't police at a crime and if the house was full of cops how come none of them came out to check the scene whilst the paramedics were there?

[@Panda-r8n]

It's hear say

[@lawrenceandcheryldoudiet5090]

@@Panda-r8nreally! 🤣

[@Mullaudek]

If the prosecutor knows the angle the defense is going to take with EVERY witness, why doesn’t he get in front of it?

[@JAJJABLOG]

2:12:08 pauses.. buying time- seconds - trying to think about what he LIED ABOUT!!

[@mominny12564]

Ever think she’s sending signals. I know it’s crazy but, I heard Lally object often when she made sounds. Just my observation.

[@lawrenceandcheryldoudiet5090]

I’ve wondered the same. If they miss her signal, she calls her own side bar. Auntie Bev is in bed with all the other criminals.

[@bellisimafedora8855]

The DA hmmmmm a tad bit weak just in my opinion

[@Cbreezzy]

I wouldn’t be surprised if the judge showed the witness the video while she took the “break” after seeing it the first time. And how she coached the witnessed while he testified is freaking wild!!!!!! That judge is absolutely DISGUSTING!!!

[@GenerationXChick]

The prosecutor has the same issues as the judge - lots of sighing

[@jenbabe1796]

Not guilty! This police dept is awful. Glad I don’t live there. Although mine isn’t any better to be honest cops are shady AF

[@christine6205]

I am still baffeld as of why the police would want to kill him they obviously got into an altercation but..why? Those marks on his arm look like dog bites

[@ajwysopal]

This stuff could be in a movie. This emt looks like he's scared. Maybe has been threatened. I hope this trial gets more attention cuz this is ridiculous. All these cops and medics are shady as hell. Liars. And when confronted on video they suddenly don't recall or can't tell what's on the video..... Like come on yall. This is ridiculous. This lady is being framed and set up by this shady ass department of cops and medics.

[@ajwysopal]

All these cops and medics are shady as hell. Liars. And when confronted on video they suddenly don't recall or can't tell what's on the video..... Like come on yall. This is ridiculous. This lady is being framed and set up by this shady ass department of cops and medics.

[@ajwysopal]

​@@christine6205why does anyone really kill someone? Never a great reason really. But too many shady stuff has been done by the state here. The Google searches.... Never searching inside the house where the body was found.... Because of course a cop lives there.... The ridiculous lies from emt... Cops on scene....video not backing up how they claimed it happens. Such as no video of the fmt speaking to her.. Then today he suddenly doesn't recall anything.... Lmao. Or he says nobody asked him details that just today he brings up..... My ass.. This is so sad. Poor lady being framed

[@Yo-pz1em]

i dated a cop from revere, ma. i will agree. shady AF and they do steroids, cheat, they’re angry all the time.

[@watchtonystube]

The intro could use some helicopter soundFX 🚁 😎

[@mariannerogers8003]

That fan is comical!

[@SLO_6]

Somebody wake me up when the prosecutor is done with questioning 😴 🥱

[@Sleeplessinsilverlakes]

If she’s presumed innocent I can imagine how many criminals will come out of the woodwork claiming to be “framed” by Boston PD 😳

[@K9_Queen19]

Honestly, MANY "normal" people have most likely been framed by lots of police departments around the country..

[@Slyredfox75]

This Judge and firefighter Flematti seem to have the worst attitudes

[@doreenhuston9623]

It is obvious that some of these people are lying. How can one person hear her say I hit him and the other not. Makes no sense.

[@MichelleFields-y3r]

What's up with scissor lips death stair towards the EMT. SO RIGHTEOUS and entitled. Not a good look for the jury. 😮😮😮😮😮

[@Panda-r8n]

I dont think she knocked him down i think he was already down in the snow not in the house party Karen was picking him up why would she bother? She could easily say she was waiting for bf to call This does stink of a police crime cover up

[@oliviashuii364]

WHAT IF ANY? Omg what a losing prosecution

[@JAJJABLOG]

I was here to say this! 🙄👌

[@lawrenceandcheryldoudiet5090]

Adam Lallygagger needs to go back to law school and freshen up on his skills.

[@JAJJABLOG]

@@lawrenceandcheryldoudiet5090 OMG.. YES!

[@MFC7625]

If she drove in reverse to hit him, she would have to go over the curb, at an angle, not parallel to the road. So, how come his body was parallel to the road? With the force of the car, his body would be projected at an angle?

[@TRACE317]

@MFC7625..plus his belt was gone..not sure how that happened, one shoe on..one missing, and where is his cap also? I keep trying to picture the states theory. Just can't work it out..then his injuries aren't matching.

[@MFC7625]

@trace317 Shoes fly during an accident, the cap was blown away by the wind. The belt is a massive issue though.

[@TRACE317]

@@MFC7625 agreed.

[@grngooseputter]

Not guilty

[@consciousmachine413]

What happened to the puffy coat?

[@SavannahMelanson]

Watching these court cases it’s clear to everyone watching the judge isn’t neutral. No matter what the defense has to say or ask the judge does not care. Evidence and the truth doesn’t matter to her. The witnesses you can tell who is being honest and who is not. Some are even hesitant to speak. I find it interesting that Lally has hardly any valuable experience. His questions are bland and he only seems to have anything to say when it came to his opening statement. I mean half of him talking is “What if any?” This case is being handled so inappropriately. It’s truly disgusting.

[@WilliamSchiskie]

Gee, I wish Officer Seral had the quality of windshield wipers we see of Officer Goode's vehicle!

[@Panda-r8n]

Judge do your job and shut this down.He is not in trial!!!!!

[@SLO_6]

Does anyone know if the missing shoe was ever found?

[@gretchensims6657]

I believe that I heard that the detective claimed to have found it in the yard 20 something days later. I could be wrong but I think that’s what I heard or read somewhere.

[@lawrenceandcheryldoudiet5090]

Adam Lallygagger needs to find the mic. What a waste of a prosecutor!

[@Lexi61689]

C'mon defense , you got this 💪

[@stevenprice6957]

Hopefully they don’t. Then you have a killer free to roam and damage other men.

[@Zenon2006]

@@stevenprice6957 a killer? LOL

[@Teena-i3i]

@@stevenprice6957 Hello Officer Nomar 🧦

[@caseyvincent6817]

​@@stevenprice6957you are a troll wanting attention It's pitiful.

[@stevenprice6957]

@@Teena-i3iHello Nurse Dripfed

[@MFC7625]

If KR said I hit him .... to McLaughlin, the 2 other paramedics lied as they were in the ambulance at the time. The way Mc Laughlin said it, was kind of a question, not a statement from KR. The 1st paramedic, who saw the puffy jacket, said the rigidity started, but the other one said he was "frozen" ..... Several said a kind of hoodie, only one said puffy jacket... Who to believe in all this? They're all paramedics, they have very little memories of the injuries and not a single one mentioned a laceration at the back of his head..... I find this incredible that when the defense start asking questions, they have constant losses of memory... And we have a cop falsifying a report.... Wow!..... A lot of them mention 2 women. Where is the McCab woman. He has been her friend for 10yrs, and she's nowhere to be seen??????

[@stevenprice6957]

She said it several times. Different occasions too. She’s a nut job and a killer.

[@drewc771]

I don't think our memories work as well as some people think they do, particularly not in stressful chaotic events, and particularly when there's a well-paid, experienced attorney amplifying any inconsistency he can find. All these witnesses appear pretty credible, imho. Any errors/inconsistency I've seen have been reasonable given the flawed nature of human memory, and there's also been a lot of consistency, as well. but of course, just my 2 cents.

[@yvonnedeboer7535]

​@@drewc771And it was 2 years ago!!

[@TeresaAnnAskew]

Karen Read is innocent, she’s been set up💞

[@MFC7625]

So, KR didn't trust Kerry Robert... Whitley seems to be offended by her comment, as he knows Kerry. His demeanor changed after that and seems to be vindictive.

[@ashadecastro276]

She’s being framed

[@ajwysopal]

1000000% frame job.All these cops and medics are shady as hell. Liars. And when confronted on video they suddenly don't recall or can't tell what's on the video..... Like come on yall. This is ridiculous. This lady is being framed and set up by this shady ass department of cops and medics.

[@Mommatukes1977]

Body language of the young EMT says he’s a wreck

[@ajwysopal]

Absolutely he's being told what to say. All these cops and medics are shady as hell. Liars. And when confronted on video they suddenly don't recall or can't tell what's on the video..... Like come on yall. This is ridiculous. This lady is being framed and set up by this shady ass department of cops and medics.

[@Teena-i3i]

@@ajwysopal True ... They all intermingle and marry into the cop families EMT's and nurses. They call them Badge bunnies and worse names also

[@Floridafanatic28]

@@Teena-i3i You have no clue what you are talking about. STFU.

[@C-cf9vl]

No tire tracks by the body?? Only see foot tracks from the house.

[@stevenprice6957]

There were no foot prints from the house. Haven’t you been watching. She smashed into him. He probably flew metres from impact. Also snow coming down as the hours pass. What tracks ? They’d be covered.

[@colleenfletcher2550]

Don't forget 6 drops of blood on top of the snow.

[@mamaweezer1979]

@@stevenprice6957he was 10 feet from the road. You honestly think that a body flew that far as bis as he was with a broken tail light as the evidence of impact? Pretty sure there should be a large dent somewhere on that car

[@pennicochrane8886]

​@@stevenprice6957 People outside in pink are commenting here also! People on Court TV, Lawyers? Say she's guilty

[@stevenprice6957]

@@mamaweezer1979She probably dragged him ? Who knows. He might not have been on the road. I’m sure he went distance unless he was sort of hit then dragged underneath and that’s where the arm scratches come from. Have you noticed the dog theory has been thrown out by the defence ? Why ? It was never there to begin with. That was a media trick. Just throw anything out to get the public behind her. It shouldn’t be allowed. The ark was tested and no animal DNA was found. Did puppy dog wipe up the crime scene ? Seriously. It’s a farce. She’s definitely guilty.

[@kayvee9094]

The defense attorney is now blaming the firefighters for John's death. Everyone knows, she hit him, she hit him, but the dance continues.

[@dianewilliams9729]

This is day three and logically, based upon the evidence so far, I see nothing to indicate a cover-up was even warranted. There is evidence from several that READ stated she hit him but nothing to indicate any other person was involved. I see her attorney trying to get people to hear and see things that are not clearly audible or visible so it appears his is the only attempt of covering up something…her actions.

[@MsPopeye65]

Thank goodness... I was beginning to think I had woken up post apocalypse.... alone ..😮 The voice of REASON... Trouble is... she's going to walk... not because she is innocent/framed.... but because of incompetent handling of the case...❤

[@dianewilliams9729]

@@MsPopeye65 LOL, I know that feeling! I can understand the discrepancy in what people heard Read say because she probably did make different comments to those standing closest to her. I am eager to see evidence about the scratch marks some suspect of being a dog’s doing. The marks do not appear to be dog bites unless the poor dog had only upper teeth. Hope they swabbed those areas for DNA!

[@hersheyssmith2104]

Terrorising the medics/firefighters won’t do you any good attorney bwahaha

[@kevingriffin1376]

01:28:00 dash cam video of Jen McCabe speaking to Ofc Saraf shortly before Googling.

[@Mommatukes1977]

What a LIAR

[@ajwysopal]

All these cops and medics are shady as hell. Liars. And when confronted on video they suddenly don't recall or can't tell what's on the video..... Like come on yall. This is ridiculous. This lady is being framed and set up by this shady ass department of cops and medics.

[@avajune6579]

She admitted she hit him at the scene.

[@stevenprice6957]

Yet people still believe in fairy stories.

[@carlogambino924]

​@@stevenprice6957 You're both gullible and aren't very attentive.

[@melodieshimon]

Many times to different people , jury will never get past that no matter what defence attorney does.

[@kristinbyrd278]

It was not a statement it was a question. Because someone said that so she questioned it

[@lindafinch1520]

Maybe there was a question mark on the end of Karen's "I hit him?" The women from that house could have been saying to Karen, "you must have hit him." Soooo Karen could have thought "oh no, did I hit him?"

[@nicenessispriceless2681]

Watch on law and crime if you don’t like commercials.

[@montanaparanormal]

Sounds like dude was strangled then left outside….

[@MrWeepies]

Dodgy judge?

[@donnabisbal9115]

This judge is the worst I've seen