NM. v Alec Baldwin Day 1 - Opening Statements

Day 2 Stream: kzbin.infoSUEmcf4S2Nw
THE DOCKET
0:00 Welcome
3:30 The Hearing
7:30 Preliminary Jury Instructions
Opening Statements
19:16 Prosecution
45:55 Defense
1:33:05 Morning Break
1:35:30 Summary
1:39:25 Q&A
Prosecution Witness
1:59:00 Detective Nicholas Lefleur - Direct Examination
3:05:00 Cross Examination Continued
4:39:10 Re-Direct Examination
4:55:00 Lt. Timoteo Benavidez - Direct Examination
5:41:00 Cross Examination
5:57:15 Re-Direct Examination
6:02:40 Court Break
6:28:50 Deputy Joseph Lujan - Direct Examination
6:33:56 Cross Examination
6:35:05 Crime Scene Technician - Marissa Poppell - Direct Examination
7:43:40 Court Recess for the Day
7:48:00 Summary
7:54:45 Q&A
Get Our FREE App: www.lawnerdapp.com
Don’t miss our Email Alerts: www.LawNerdAlert.com
WHAT I USE TO STREAM - STREAMYARD: streamyard.com/emily
Proud Streamyard Partner!
Mailing Address: Emily D. Baker 2000 Mallory Ln. St. 130-185, Franklin Tn 37067
Business Inquiries: [e-mail]
LAW NERD MERCH!
www.LawNerdShop.com
Help with the shop: [e-mail]
LONG-FORM CONTENT / @theemilydbaker
The Emily Show Podcast on KZbin: emilydbaker.com/TheEmilyShowP...
Apple Podcasts: emilydbaker.com/AppleTheEmily...
Spotify Podcasts: emilydbaker.com/SpofityTheEmi...
On your favorite podcast player, Wednesdays
QUICK CONTENT?
Quick Bits Podcast: emilydbaker.com/quickbitsplay...
Apple Podcasts: emilydbaker.com/AppleQuickBits
Spotify Podcasts: emilydbaker.com/SpotifyQuickBits
Quick Bits Channel: / @emilydbakerquickbits
EMILY ON SOCIAL
Instagram: / theemilydbaker
Twitter: / theemilydbaker
Facebook: / theemilydbaker
This video is not legal advice; it is commentary for educational and entertainment purposes. Some links shared are affiliate links; all sponsorships are stated in the video. Videos are based on publicly available information unless otherwise noted. Sharing a resource is not an endorsement; it is a resource. Copyright 2020-2024 Baker Media, LLC

[@abbytrojanowski]

Replay crew!!!! Love having 8 hours of Emily to catch up on! Keeps me entertained!!

[@LisaThames17]

So true so nice not to have to be alone with my thoughts for eight hours hello law nerd friend

[@gewurztramina]

Hello!!

[@zm5668]

Her webcam audio is out of sync and this woman diverts every subject so she can talk about herself, over and over and over So frustrating, so bad.

[@stephanied6451]

Agreed. I had a low frustration, low anxiety day yesterday. It gets the endorphins flowing

[@shonabeggs4640]

​@zm5668 Well that was nasty. Do you require attention?

[@clynnadams32]

Thank you for this long video. I listen to you every night. My husband passed away 40 days ago and you've been the distraction I've needed. Depression has got me in it's grip but you're helping me. Thank you for that ❤

[@NatyMatos]

I'm sorry for your loss. Big hugs!😢

[@clynnadams32]

@@NatyMatos thank you

[@Miriela480]

I'm so sorry for your loss. If you need more Lawtube distraction, I would suggest checking out Lawyer Lee -- she's lovely and she recently lost her husband as well.

[@nzfilmnerd81]

A massive law nerd hug to you from me, here in New Zealand 💕 I won't pretend to know your pain but I hope being part of this community, provides a little comfort or distraction when you need it.

[@zm5668]

​@@nzfilmnerd81just can't help but powerlevel and say I'm from NZ - look at me! Notice and pay attention to ME! I want to tell you about ME!

[@Cassie-pt7mt]

Thanks for being with me while I clean out my 86-year-old mother's garage. I made it through and shredded an entire box of banking from '77 to '84. Ugh... They kept EVERYTHING!!! Tomorrow is banking from the 60's and late 80's taxes. Yippee! But, it'll be easy with EDB in my ear.

[@TheEmilyDBaker]

You’re doing amazing sweetie. 🥰

[@qwennnnn7192]

Sounds like you could have an epic bonfire night!! Good luck! 🤗

[@20thcenturyrelic]

You can take stuff like this to Office Depot and pay them to shred it. I believe they charge by the pound.

[@kateashby3066]

By “go through”, surely you mean light on fire and be done with it? 😂 you’re a good ‘kid’. I was cleaning a house today while listening. I love that my job allows me to listen to true crime all day 😂❤

[@molliwilson5639]

Yikes

[@chemistryflavored]

Replay crew… my work productivity is definitely not ready for another trial but I’m still incredibly excited! Here’s to losing sleep since I’ll be catching up every day after work.

[@English3Muffin]

You are not alone in that. 😂💜

[@wondergal4729]

☝️💯😂

[@VintageInkBlot]

I feel that! How can I watch 8 hours faster but not speed it up or fall asleep? 😂

[@alia_sarai]

Same here 😂

[@bloomunki6094]

Same!

[@andreacollins3204]

Replay crew. It’s past midnight in Ireland and I’m so excited to fall asleep to a new trial! I missed ye all ❤️🇮🇪

[@fractalfemale]

In Scotland, same 🤣

[@gotlandia1588]

Sweden also😂

[@laurasalmon706]

Same here in the UK

[@MsSparkles25]

Emily's looking as beautiful as always, this trial is going to be interesting ❤

[@EEST-Militia]

Not a good idea messing around Irish people drinking a Guiness.🤕👊

[@ViennaDarlingvd]

I gotta say, this is the first trial where I’m decently impressed by both sides from the opening statements (defense had some slips but otherwise still a decent outline). Pretty excited for the rest of this trial!

[@dd4850]

Carrie was right to allow someone else to open

[@Ike_of_pyke]

Defense seems to forget one of the people in the chain of custody they mention that ensures there's no violation of safety procedures and suppose to help address them is a producer on the film... Alec is a producer on the film and the star , even if you could somehow not fault him for the pulling of the trigger (which I believe he's gulity/at fault of due to the evidence we've seen and the footage of the day in question but leave it in the hands of the jury), you have to look at Alec as the producer and ask "what happened regarding safety on this set that several crew walked off?"

[@gunnybunny4081]

@@Ike_of_pykein the pretrial motion hearings the judge decided not to allow that he was a producer in at trial since he was a producer in name only as a courtesy which happens often with well known actors. The set had a producer who was actually in charge of everything including safety. Many attorneys have agreed this was the correct choice especially with the specific charges against him.

[@susanw9111]

@@Ike_of_pykeAlec Baldwin is not being tried as the producer, that’s a separate civil trial. Alec is being tried as himself as a person

[@Ike_of_pyke]

@@gunnybunny4081 I'd disagree with the lawyers on that since producing roles even if honorary do carry a responsibility on the set but that's not my call to make .

[@Jendrew6014]

Replay crew here! Let’s do it

[@ValthatBish]

yesssss

[@MsSparkles25]

Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿❤

[@Sidebarbie]

I love the judge in this case. She’s so no-nonsense. I here for it. So excited for your coverage on this case. I don’t hate Baldwin like a lot of people on here. I’m really interested to just evaluate the evidence without the bias.

[@beverlyb4256]

I think it's the Ukrainian war connected. Step back, look at all the facts, and think. I think Hannah is the patsy, Alec the fallguy, and we may never hear the truth. IMHO. 😢❤

[@anniehoon]

As it should be👏

[@emmablackwood2303]

Me too xx

[@lizzimmermann7164]

I was a swimmer in high school and college and I once got DQed for something I absolutely did not do and I may or may not have told the stroke judge that if he had one more eye he’d be a cyclops. I feel you EDB.

[@truecrimenut6696]

😂 lol. I was on a swim team too… this!👍😂

[@qwennnnn7192]

SUCH this

[@lawnerddownunder3461]

Omg that is fantastic. I'm a big fan of snark.

[@annap5421]

Oh this is brilliant, I'm adding that into my snark repertoire 😂

[@mellyluvsdawg1524]

I can't belive I use to watch trials by myself...(silent watcher) LOVE watching live with everyone and when I can't and I watch the replay (like now) I still feel like I'm not alone LOVE THIS CHANNEL 💕

[@itsjuliannajo]

Spent most of my life as a professional actress. The defense's opening was very effective. They showed an everyday moment on set. The director says, "Whip it out," and Alec responds, "Whip it out? Okay.' Whipping a gun out is always dangerous... unless you have safety guards in place. The big hole in the defense's argument is that there had already been misfires that day. How can I, as the actor, "Whip it out" safely? I can't. The only thing making that action "safe" is a bullet-free set, and the misfires make that impossible. That leads me right back to Alec's being responsible. He knew there was a danger and did it anyway. How he held it doesn't matter that much to me. He knew live rounds had found their way onto the set. If you continue to "whip" a gun around at that point, you're being reckless. Period.

[@origamikiddo2625]

Thanks for sharing your experience, I'm always looking for input from actors. My understanding was it was blanks fired when maybe it was supposed to be dummies or it was supposed to be blanks but the warnings weren't given and eat protection etc wasn't handed out. Horses startled etc. still dangerous and should have been something to make everyone go wait a minute, things need to be better or new armorer or something. I'm wondering what and where is the responsibility if the armorer and first AD are negligent in their responsibilities? Where is the check for that or do we just figure it out when someone is injured or killed??

[@Xtinamariee]

The special prosecutor Erlinda Ocampo Johnson is so inspiring to me as a Latina Lawnerd 🙌

[@maggieann1306]

100%

[@Mo_Ketchups]

_Chat: “Emily, are you easily distracted by food?”_ *EDB: Uhhh 😳 YEAHHH!! Snacks’re EVERYTHING!!* 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣😂🤣

[@SnowbankBeers]

Replay crew! Let's go!

[@trishnickles2236]

I really appreciate Ms. Popell's explanation of the different kinds of rounds, it's very clear.

[@stupidityensues]

I didn't watch Hannah's trial. And I'm totally shocked on how many live rounds were there

[@emjay221]

Honestly hearing how many there were and how they replaced all over the place just randomly, I almost feel like she did it on purpose so somebody would get hurt and somebody would take a fall and I don't know. It sounds like tin foil hat kind of thing but that's just not plausible that they could accidentally be in the truck, and Jensen's belt, and the gun, in the cart

[@stupidityensues]

@@emjay221 it is odd. I may have to go back and watch Hannah's trial. I really haven't been following any of this

[@Danix526]

@@stupidityensuesi really enjoyed watching it live, definitely recommend it! I’m sure there will be a decent amount of overlap with this trial too.

[@jenmck23]

Lol don't waste your time rewatching that whole trial. Just watch Emily's Quick Bits videos for the daily summaries lol much faster

[@melissaolson6917]

Kari Morrissey’s style is just so off putting. She talks to people like they are tiny children. The condescension gross

[@katieh193]

Linda comes across as more likeable and clear than Kari Morrissey.

[@sugarfree9921]

Linda is the first prosecutor I actually like. She seems very professional and an interesting person to talk to. Keri, on the other hand...

[@mostlyvoid.partiallystars]

100% agree. Morrissey gets on every nerve I have.

[@katieh193]

Yep, I just can't dig Kari's style.

[@dd4850]

Erlinda😊

[@victoriasommer3772]

I bet they’re holding Keri out until they think they need her. My guess is if Baldwin gets on the stand shes gonna be doing the cross just bc I know she pisses him off

[@memejmoon9716]

Emily, you’re Amazing thank you and thanks to the community

[@artgirlsreality]

Replay crew!! Excited to get this one started. EDB your hair is looking fabulous today, girrrrrl!!

[@BreannaDrummond]

i feel like erlinda was brought on as safety rails for the bowling ball that is Kari lol

[@shkrjam84]

Right. Erlinda set the jury up for a smooth ride, and here comes Kari… “I came in like a wrecking baaaaaaallllll!” 🤣

[@shkrjam84]

The state has a huge burden to convince me that AB is responsible. He’s not a great person, but I do not see him being criminally responsible based on the testimony of the armorer in HGR’s trial - the buck stops at the armorer. The actor is not required to perform safety checks, and it’s the armorer’s and AD’s responsibility to ensure that the actor can focus on their job and be able to do so confident in the safety of the prop they are handling. Per the state’s expert armorer, it’s the armorer’s responsibility to make sure the actors are following safe handling practices and paying attention during safety/handling lessons, regardless of the environment and attitudes of the actors and crew. It wasn’t until the end of HGR’s trial that I could see the responsibility HGR had. I was very much on the fence throughout, and felt that others interfering with her being able to do her job was a problem for proving she was criminally responsible. But after the presentation of all the evidence and her multitude of careless actions, I agreed with the jury’s verdict. I’m keeping an open mind in this trial, but if he’s being charged for what he did as an actor and not a producer, the state has to move the needle on the fact that as an actor, he should have been able to rely on the safety protocols to be able to do his own job safely. Unless there are industry standards for how actors should and shouldn’t handle guns, I am not convinced yet that during rehearsal/filming actors should be following the same general gun safety guidelines we expect. I want to hear the experts on this again in relation to the actors’ responsibilities.

[@australobuchia]

There are industry standards for how actors handle guns as I understand it. I'm really hoping that is brought in. I can't say I agree that anyone can be free of responsibility in high risk situations. HGR is definitely responsible and so was Dave Halls, but that doesn't absolve AB imo. To me he is only innocent in that I require the prosecution to prove the elements of the charges to the Jury. It *should* be easy for them. But we'll see.

[@shkrjam84]

@@australobuchiayes I haven’t looked into what those standards might be, so I’m interested to see that presented. That will greatly affect where I land on AB’s level of culpability. I think Hall getting a deal is a travesty. He should have faced same charges as HGR, imo.

[@jaspriest1997]

I agree, I’m no Baldwin fan but I think the buck fundamentally stops with the safety crew. Regardless of whether AB was being flippant with the gun or not, it was HGR and Halls job to make sure that wasn’t happening and that AB was never in a position to hurt anyone, and they failed at that job

[@molliwilson5639]

I totally disagree. We shall see

[@australobuchia]

@@shkrjam84 oh Hall getting a plea deal for unsupervised probation is absolutely insane. The prior prosecutor that did that is ... Just so ridiculous

[@GraceMusyoka]

Good morning. What a great morning. 8 hours of this; right before today's session. Wonderful

[@SamaraCee]

Did a grown man, an officer, just mumble through all the questioning and also say “my bad”? 🤦‍♀️ he’s giving Trooper Paul a run for his money.

[@Atalinay]

I *wish* Trooper Paul had even a sliver integrity to even utter 'my bad'. That dude felt totally justified in his bs 🤮

[@kateashby3066]

That first witness? Yeah I get the feeling he hates Carrie likes everyone else lol. He wasn’t even trying to be helpful in his answers. No doubt she treats him like sht on her shoe like everyone else.

[@judyannkiwi]

I wouldn’t want to be a part of this I would say I didn’t see anything

[@truecrimenut6696]

@@kateashby3066 I don’t know…but I had a strange feeling that the first young LE officer seemed also medicated. Real slow reaction time. I can’t imagine what this young man has been through…probably wishing he did ANYTHING else in the world except being LE THAT DAY.

[@truecrimenut6696]

Replay crew. Emily, you’re so right. With this added prosecutor, the courtroom seems much less tense, compared to HG’s trial. For sure…

[@molliwilson5639]

It’s refreshing to be in the members only chat you guys are great

[@shecat1964]

This is not just a members only chat dear.

[@cherylsHTX]

Replay crew - hello from Houston, Texas. Still recovering from Hurricane Beryl. Have not had power at my house since Monday and no hope of it coming back anytime soon. I took refuge at the office today and I was so excited that there is a new trial to watch with Emily. @emilydbaker thank you so much for all you do and for bringing comfort at such a difficult time.

[@kimberlymoriarity]

I hope things get better for y'all soon

[@NatyMatos]

Replay crew. I wasn't interested in watching this trial but i love watching trials with you and you got me into it.

[@Atalinay]

The introduction of evidence with Poppell is SO much more smoother. It makes a lot more sense, but i also have previous knowledge from last trial.

[@gklauserr]

It’s so strange to finally see that scene that changed the lives of so many. I can’t wait for both the prosecution and defence to prove their cases!

[@garykidson4489]

The defense don't have to prove anything.

[@lifes_a_journey]

I can't stand listening to Morrissey. I didn't like her in Hannah's case, still hate her condescending tone, like everyone is stupid but her. So unprofessional for an attorney in my opinion. The other prosecutor.. Love her. So likable.

[@lianpalmer84]

Whatever the outcome, how awful must Mr Baldwin feel, regardless of fault, to be the person holding gun, he will always be haunted by this.

[@barbiesergio7663]

After seeing this trial, I think the Karen Read trial could have been only 4 weeks if Lally cut his words in half.

[@ChristopherMichael180]

Not a fan of that defense opening. If I were on the jury I’d really have the impression he thought I was stupid-from all the “bang bang pew pew” sounds he made to simulate the firing of a prop gun. Erlinda, so far, is such a breath of fresh air.

[@kateashby3066]

Lmao that was so weird!

[@mangotango2399]

yeah the bang bang comments were just cringey. made it feel like he was talking to children

[@AnastasiaRoseDamrau]

His opening gave me the impression that he did not bother to do any research on guns and gun safety for this trial, and he's contemptuous of gun people in general and quite possibly the jury in particular. I am not a gun person (I have shot a gun on one single occasion in my life) and I was offended and disturbed. I hope they didn't let any gun owners on this jury or they're probably already having some feelings about the defense's case.

[@shkrjam84]

I didn’t get that vibe. I have been around guns and handled them pretty frequently growing up, my dad was a hunter. I got the feeling it more so infantilized the role of the actor, as it was probably intended to do. It demonstrated that the actor was playing make believe, just like he would if he was wearing a cape and pretending to fly. Just my thoughts. The state has a big burden given their own armorer expert in the HGR trial stated the actors are not required to do safety checks and the buck stops with the armorer, period. Imo, her conviction relied heavily on his expert opinion on her responsibility despite all of the rushing and distractions, and what she should have done and not done with the situations she was given. And that includes the rushing, not being on set and present during use of prop guns, actors mishandling the props and Baldwin not paying attention during training. Wouldn’t be surprised if the defense calls that expert (I don’t look at expert/witness lists in filings unless I see EDB go over it).

[@AnastasiaRoseDamrau]

@@shkrjam84 I'm surprised the prosecution is harping on Baldwin not being part of the safety check, because that was also what I got from that expert last time. To me, the problem is that he pointed the gun at people and had shit trigger discipline so he accidentally pulled the trigger. There's a video from that morning where Baldwin is handling the gun and you can hear the hammer clicking down on a dummy round. That video, in my opinion, is the whole case. Don't point a gun at someone you're not willing to shoot, and don't put your finger on the trigger of a gun (or even inside the trigger guard) unless you're ready to shoot.

[@intothemindshaft]

This is the first time I struggle to be neutral before the evidence. How can an actor be blamed for this - whatever kind of prick they may be. This is the head of safety and armourers and suppliers problem. Its not foreseeable that a live round would be in there I just don't get it. Doesn't matter if he points it and pulls a trigger - it should not have a live round in it.

[@jaspriest1997]

I’m at that point too. If an expert told him that it was 100% safe and it wasn’t, that’s got to be their mess up not his

[@kayemm1973]

He was fully trained not to do that though.

[@just_a_smalltowngirl585]

Sure do appreciate your live trial coverage. No one id rather watch! Thanks Emily 💜

[@lisap8547]

Can we add the “Hear ye, Hear ye!” On the sound bar please? Lol ❤

[@cANNabyss.]

Two trials in a row with BANG BANG?! How did we get so lucky?? 😂😂😂

[@kateashby3066]

If you’re here but didn’t watch the Hannah Gutierrez trial- see if you can muster up like 3-4 hours to watch the opening statements, closing arguments, verdict and sentencing. It’s worth it!! You’ll get fully “caught up” and have a full picture of what happened after the Baldwin trial AND sentencing was so sweet 😂 (Hannah’s jail calls doomed her!)

[@molliwilson5639]

Yes, I would recommend that as well because almost all of the questions asked were already answered at the Hannah G. Trial and people who did not watch that trial are getting distracted rather than focusing on Alec’s culpability.

[@mariagonzalez8919]

What did she say

[@elysemckenzie3334]

I'll wait till after. This is a whole separate trial and jury and I don't want any prior information distorting my view on this one. Want to see if they prove their case against him.

[@coffeestar62]

I must be sick lol. I just remembered that I can fast forward this hahaha 😂

[@PutinsFriendAlec]

Nobody tell the crime technician about the Solo party cups, she may have a stroke.

[@gardenfootfoot9037]

I’m surprised they didn’t put evidence in the solo cups.

[@annehamill9573]

Thank you Em!!!!! You Rock ❤

[@natcora7189]

Emily you are amazing! I’m glad I came across your page. Gratitude

[@Seas_the_day_]

Was watching live then had to pause so on replay crew yet again. 💜💜💜

[@theMinnieValentine]

Okay, but……. If the defense brings up the civil lawsuits, doesn’t that open the door for Alec being a producer??? They are not suing because he’s just an actor, but because he was a producer. Curious to see those witnesses come in.

[@TheSusieTom]

I agree

[@richiroproductions8262]

seeing the “hear ye hear yes bring the jury” bring EDB so much joy is such a treat to see. i had to replay those moments from day 1 they were so enjoyable lol. what a fucking STARK contrast from Read trial eh? From this new prosecutor Irlinda(?) - she is good. Morrissey just needs to sit down the rest of the trial. to the PD and investigators- SO professional and good at their jobs. a judge that manages a court room properly.

[@stephanied6451]

Glad you are back. Low anxiety, higher productivity days when I have you with a court case in my ear 😁

[@LinTrueCrimeProject]

If the argument is that Alec was in character and wasn't responsible for safety, then it's a great argument for actors never being able to serve as a producer. Conflict of interest, obviously. Can't have it both ways.

[@nishienish26]

Great point!

[@casa_de_dachshund9026]

Replay Crew 🙋🏻‍♀️ Trying to play catch up while working. Thanks for helping the day fly by ❤

[@ZenCarish]

I love you ❤ Thank you SO MUCH you’re my favorite law nerd ❤

[@origamikiddo2625]

Man, lawyers like Alan Jackson, Yanetti, Creighton Waters, Camille Vasquez, even Rottenborn have ruined me for trials! I was so looking forward to seeing these lawyers shut Morrisey down with her stuff but they aren't! Hopefully they are being smarter and playing to the jury who may also be annoyed, but it is very disruptive. Judge A and Newman also ruined us, i put a lot of blame on Judge Sommers. She has these super strict rules but doesn't them, which is why Kari does this stuff cuz she gets away with it. Judge is gonna take away their coffee. She needs a little more Judge Bev's jumping in.

[@tenurednurseinoh8569]

Replay crew, so gald to be back in court!

[@jodeekadous6918]

Wyoming is here for you! Love you EDB!🎉

[@paulettecolvert]

Thank you! Emily!

[@rebeccapayton2080]

Day behind replay crew!!❤❤❤

[@ReinaLovesLaw]

Replay...catching up. She is kicking ass with opening. I'm excited to watch her!

[@Bekah_Stolnicki]

Pretty sure Baldwin wrote a portion of his Defense’s opening statement…. When he starts referencing other movies, westerns ect; that were filmed at that ranch. It all feels so unauthentic 🤢

[@tinkataylor]

It seems to me the big question is why the hell was there a real bullet in the gun!?? 🧐🤯

[@kateashby3066]

That question was asked a million times at the last trial. The answer is- we don’t know.

[@tinkataylor]

@@kateashby3066 thank you for answering, I’m just catching up with this case and I missed the last trial. It just seems so weird! Is Hannah Gutierrez at least admitting to having put the real bullet in there? Is anyone admitting to putting the real bullet in the gun? And if so, no one has explained why?

[@carolynokraska2583]

@@tinkataylor seriously?!? That is wild.

[@kimberlymoriarity]

​​@@tinkataylorHannah admitted to loading the gun in her police interviews, yes. She also said she didn't check it enough, and wished she had checked it more. Her defense was basically she didn't know there were live bullets on set.

[@TeaWithTash_]

This is THE question. Many possible explanations and none of them is good.

[@leighannflores1754]

He should have hired Jackson. Not impressed with his attorneys at all.

[@crunchycousin5986]

This police officer is so different than the ones in the Read case. Just giving facts not defensive.

[@tinykitsune0387]

Is it bad after the last case that i want to applaud the officer for grabbing crime scene tape.

[@AndreaBooksAndBakes]

At the point where EDB is talking about Olvera Street and I can't explain how delightful it was to hear EDB pronounce it correctly. Olvera is my maiden (now middle) name and it is almost always mispronounced. Shout out to any other Olvera's out there!

[@bethlovesthings]

Replay crew 🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺 big bruh energy

[@ChristinaCooper-uc5tr]

Love the sound bite “FBI!”- funny!!

[@sharoncollier2750]

replay crew from my overnight shift of monitoring alerts! Beryl has caused a lot of mayhem

[@AmberRaymond]

Replay crew here let’s go

[@Johnny-ci8mw]

I need to hear from people in the industry about if it is normal for actors to point guns directly at the camera (and thus the cameraperson) and other actors. In my eyes, if the head of safety AND the armorer said the gun was safe, it’s reasonable to think the situation wasn’t dangerous. From the limited research I have done, I believe that actors do occasionally point firearms at others because THERE AREN’T SUPPOSED TO BE REAL BULLETS ON A MOVIE SET. There are different rules on a movie set.

[@KtWaffles]

Yes ok these are my thoughts exactly!I😩 like what is going on here lol

[@Gabriel-hf1yy]

Agree

[@anavictoria1809]

This is why I’m so confused about this case. Like even if he had checked it the armorer would have to have checked it again. Right?

[@sugarfree9921]

Same. I don't understand why he is on trial at all. If he had just picked up a weapon from a table or something and started messing with it and shot someone, sure, I can see how that would be accidental. But he was handed the gun after not one but two people supposedly checked and announced to a room full of people that the gun was safe, he did not load that gun or anything so how could it be his fault?

[@Gabriel-hf1yy]

@@anavictoria1809 yes that's right

[@AuntLALA]

I love when you tell us to leave the game and pay attention to certain parts 😂 bc I'm totally playing june's journey while I listen to you or shopping on Temu for my store lol

[@Danix526]

Personally I believe it is mostly Hannah’s fault. However, it may be my background with guns, but the fact that he pointed it at people, cocked it, AND pulled the trigger just churns my guts. I want more info from people in the industry on how normal pointing a firearm at crew is. I understand it MAY need to happen actor to actor to get a shot, but crew?? It feels icky, but I’m unsure on the legalness. I guess that’s what this trial is for!

[@TeaWithTash_]

For what I know, it was those type of shots that the actor is pointing at the camera which are quite common. But people that watched the other trial might know more than me.

[@dd4850]

If there weren’t live bullets on the set, this wouldn’t be an issue. There are movies where a real gun has been used to be cocked and pointed at the camera with people directly behind it and none of them are dead. Because bullets are never on the set of a movie… except the movie Hannah worked on… so… who is truly at fault?

[@kateashby3066]

He didn’t point it at HER, he pointed it right at the CAMERA. She was the cinematographer. That’s a photographer but for FILM. He the gun was at the camera and she was next to the camera and was sh0t as a result of being near the cam. That’s why. The BIGGEST issue for me is that the crew walked out bc g u n s we’re going off on set willy nilly and instead doing a hard reset, they continued to be sloppy. EVERYONE. That and how he pulled the trigger and the sh0t didn’t call for that. Then he lied about it and changed his story.

[@Xershade]

@@kateashby3066 They can't bring this up but he also didn't, as a producer, buy a replica of the gun that looks exactly the same as the one he was using, or buy a modified one that is literally a real gun but has been modified so if a bullet is set off the bullet physically can not fire out of the barrel. Those are the two guns you should have if you're needing to point it at ANYONE.

[@reneewoodside45]

Replay crew! Didn’t watch the other trial so coming into this pretty blind. Excited to be back in court with Emily!

[@nanner3200]

I failed day one. Fell asleep the last hour and a half. Will try again tomorrow. See you then!

[@uselessSam]

same 😞

[@kirstilynn5995]

Replay crew! Me waiting for the weekend to catch up on this… me on Friday seeing that it’s dismissed… well alrighty then

[@aarodriguez6]

I live in northern New Mexico, taking goes on EVERYTHING. There’s a restaurant here that makes a plate that has shrimp, cucumber, purple onions, tomato, avocados in Clamato and covered in tajin. It’s sooooo goood and perfect for lunch on a hot day.

[@sarasharesalot]

Replay crew! This is an interesting one for me. I have been a working actor since I was a kid and I completely understand the point of view Alec's team are presenting.

[@gettingstranger]

I am going into this trial looking at the situation like this: it's kind of like being sold a car that has been marketed as the safest car to ever exist. It very well might be. But it is still on you to ensure that it is a safe journey every single time. You are the one in control of it.

[@lawnerddownunder3461]

I love this analogy

[@garykidson4489]

That analogy doesn't work.

[@kjo1849]

That’s bullshit tho it’s simply not his job or responsibility to check the gunna third time there’s a reason it’s someone else’s job

[@marymaclaren9553]

I'm glad they brought in another prosecutor to temper Kerri's snark and tone, a little goes a long way. I do have my issues with Kerri, but all in all, dear god I do love her. Especially after weeks of Lally’s never ending drone. And if it is true that she is poking the bear, and I suspect it is, I am looking forward to her cross examination of him. I do hope the prosecution focuses their case. In my opinion this entire tragedy comes down to the fact that every safety measure utterly failed, and the ‘magic making’ actor not pointing the gun and not pulling the trigger at the camera during blocking was the final safety measure to fail. Other than the integrity of the fire arm, everything else is just noise and a waste of time. Unfortunately there are no set in stone regulations, every set has its' own rules. Hopefully this trial will lead to actual regulation on gun safety and how an armorer is to be qualified. There's a decent, albeit brief article on the subject by the BBC. An interesting note that the first two suggested rules are: 1) Blanks can k i l l. Treat all firearms as though they are loaded 2) Refrain from pointing a firearm at yourself or anyone else"

[@kateashby3066]

Hannah’s case also had Carrie and one other prosecutor. That was a man, so I guess he switched with this woman. Carrie didn’t do opening arguments for that case either if memory serves me correctly.

[@marymaclaren9553]

@@kateashby3066 Holy crap, you're right, I had to go back and look! Completely forgot about him. He's so pleasant! I guess "good cop, bad cop' is how they soften the edges.

[@springer585]

Can u imagine if jury questions were allowed in the Karen Read trial.? They would have been going back and forth all day

[@Karate208]

He is answering her line of questions on what the CAD report pulled from running everyone’s driver’s licenses much calmer than I would have been

[@vee_tinymoose]

Somewhere around 4 or 5 hours, while on replay crew, I migrained out, waking as the stream ended. Now I have no idea where I got to!

[@TR-IRL]

Great job as always EDB

[@J-EvansBookNerd]

The difference in questioning by the prosecution is fantastic!!!

[@ashleyrambo7581]

replay crew here. have to watch this before the newest update!

[@childensstorytime]

Watching on replay at 11.25am and also started to watched members podcast in Australia after around midday and it cut out. I am a member I feel robbed as I was enjoying it. Dammm

[@tinagaffney986]

I know I’m just starting to watch this, but I don’t believe he intended to harm anyone.

[@AuntLALA]

The prosecuter doesn't either. That's why the charge is similar to involuntary manslaughter.

[@sleslie6395]

7:42:16 I don't understand, where are all the red Solo cups that investigators use?? 😂😂😂

[@seanm777]

Today I learned “he goes bang bang in movies” is a legal defense

[@havermansfleur]

Replay crew - I LOVE Kari and Erlinda on the prosecution. Kari's such a mood and was really on it w defenses opening.

[@melissaowens6031]

Whoever commented that Keri M cross examine Jen Mc is a fucking GENIUS and we should make that happen stat!!!! Like, now, please!!!!! Omg yessss

[@johnmimist]

Emily. You said, “this church was dynamic, no wonder they wanted to film there”. This church was a set. The set designers, builders, etc made it like that.

[@emrainbow]

He’s going with the Johnny Depp courtroom style of not looking up during opposition. Not sure if pulls it off as well.

[@molliwilson5639]

Well JD is charming and it worked for him. I agree with you, it does not look well on Alec B.

[@lawnerddownunder3461]

​@@molliwilson5639he just looks pissed

[@emilyr123]

Emily, you got me to get some tajin and I am completely obsessed. I've been putting it on mango, pineapple, corn, so many good things! I literally drool when I see it in the cupboard! LOL!

[@TheEmilyDBaker]

It's so good! Happy to influence towards the delicious!!!

[@origamikiddo2625]

Man, would i love to see Alan Jackson vs Kari Morrisey. I feel like he would shut down her nonsense. I was really hoping these "big city" lawyers would shut down her tactics. It would be far more entertaining to see Poot vs. Morrisey, but we all would lose our minds and I'd feel bad for any clients/defendants. Maybe a civil trial.

[@mariagunnarsQ17]

The FBI! Cracked me up every time lol

[@jenmck23]

Hey was on and off listening today. 4:32:00 ish is back to court for replay crew and time stamps

[@ValthatBish]

when they explain the shot it just sounds so painful

[@kateashby3066]

And when we hear Joel 😢

[@ValthatBish]

@@kateashby3066 so sad

[@ERSwanger]

Thank you so much for saying "over the shoulder boulder holder" because its all i was thinking lol

[@coolmomvibes1394]

I absolutely hate the prosecutors tone while questioning.

[@Eihpos97]

Same, she’s so villainous, it’s off putting and patronising

[@molliwilson5639]

Which one? there are two prosecutors

[@Eihpos97]

@@molliwilson5639 Kerri, the newly appointed prosecutor is a breath of fresh air.

[@jaspriest1997]

Oh my god same- I totally miss her points because she’s so off putting. Very glad the other prosecutor did opening!

[@YIKESMF]

Hi Emily! Replay here! ❤

[@harmonydesroches]

Replay crew! 💜

[@paranrmlgrl]

4:00 - absolutely not! I’ve worked in multiple factories and, even if I am friends with my co-worker, I will always inspect my tools before I start/change positions with someone. It’s my responsibility to make sure that I (and everyone around me) is safe. I cannot rely on anyone but myself.

[@Xershade]

Yep, going to assume you also don't just randomly start playing with the dangerous tools while you're bored setting up for stuff. He should have NEVER touched that trigger or hammer for a blocking shot. And it's a gun that requires a two step process to fire, they don't just "accidentally" go off. He pulled the hammer, then the trigger, and was expecting it to not fire because "it wasn't loaded". That's literally negligence that caused a death. They literally have people disassemble guns brought into court they know are unloaded before it even gets into the court room to prove to everyone it's not loaded. The stuff Hollywood actors get away with, or try too, because "they're just actors" is rediculous.

[@cosacita]

Replay crew! So excited for another trial with Emily, despite just coming from the previous one 😂 But I look forward to how this will transpire after watching the Hannah Gutierrez trial. (My apologies if I butchered her name)

[@springer585]

Maybe Canton PD should watch the first witness when he explains why he grabs the crime scene tape. Maybe they'll learn something😅