Logic - The Incredible True Story ALBUM REVIEW

[@owenhardy7911]

City of Stars worst track??? I'm done with this melon

[@videospielesindkunst]

James Hardy Literally one of the best and most unique

[@RapCityco]

Fantano b wildin

[@gamingwithsandroboy6778]

I know, the fuck up with this unsliced watermelon head???

[@JAY-IGaming]

One of my favourite logic songs of all time

[@BigFishZo]

Same

[@jaylenscott1841]

Logic getting all these 6's....he's the true 6 God

[@vintage5952]

no thats drake

[@luther-masonumanzor5867]

+unethical loser drakes a fucking ghost writer and his music literally all sounds the same 😂

[@vintage5952]

luther-mason umanzor i dont think you know what he means when he says 6 god

[@jaylenscott1841]

unethical loser Guess you didn't get the joke

[@vintage5952]

Crim De La Crim i did, luther didnt get mine

[@HomemadeSubmarine]

Listening to Logic’s old music literally makes me mad to see what he could’ve been.

[@Noname-nk5kv]

I can relate

[@thraitor7819]

NEVER BEEN lol

[@Jdubayou]

Facts. It’s actually laughable how lazy his music seems now. I mean his lyricism fell off a cliff. He used to have to some really great bars like “I have not a single enemy, only evil entities that have somehow befriended me” Now he just says shit like “I’m high as a ceiling” lmfao

[@iamhexoronii]

sTn AnoMaLy that first bar isn’t that great to begin with lol

[@iamhexoronii]

sTn AnoMaLy he has way better shit than what you picked out lol

[@mackdad7837]

I don't see why the internet hates Logic, I fuck with him heavy

[@Blvnco717]

Most people who hate on logic either are Kendrick Dickriders or trap music and drill music fans. People who defend logic are mostly 13 year old white boys from suburbs it's sad because logics fan base is becoming like hopsins and odd future and I don't want it to become that.

[@BIGDRIP2]

+Greatest Ever so if i hate logic that automatically makes me a kendrick dickrider? nvermind the fact that he doesnt sound appealing and he just copies other artists...

[@Blvnco717]

How can you dislike logic????

[@DonCutty]

+Mack Dad Ive been saying the same thing. I love dudes flow and his instrumental selection.

[@BIGDRIP2]

Greatest Ever the same way i dislike country music, it doesnt appeal and interest to me. however u wont see me in logic's videos being a bitter hater

[@theneedledrop]

the new g-eazy song stinks.

[@feverray8307]

Generic-Eazy

[@JasonEXP]

Gay - Eazy.

[@gwkonyoutube]

fuk u g easy is the best #swag

[@callumtyler9699]

Which one?

[@thewhitecobra771]

+theneedledrop Random?

[@chrissheldron9511]

Lord willin,fade away, young Jesus, paradise, like woah, never been...all dope.

[@soggyleaf2064]

As well as stainless and incredible true story. This is such a great album

[@peoduction6068]

This album is great from beginning to end

[@Alckee6904]

@Keegan Key UP was better tbh.

[@nadavya2612]

@@peoduction6068 I am the greatest, young jesus, and upgrade are all meh.

[@peoduction6068]

@@nadavya2612 not young Jesus but I agree on the other 2

[@stevejobs2020]

this album aged like wine

[@phillytothemax]

Literally

[@christianhague7656]

I keep coming back to this review and I always think that Anthony is way harder on Logic than other artists. Edit: This didn’t age well. Every logic project after this I personally did not care for at all! Still like this album a lot tho!

[@edgarcmtz]

Nah, he was actually quite generous.

[@kevinhuang8916]

confessions of a dangerous mind leaves the chat

[@scarletdawnmusic]

Boy, a lot of these comments didn't age well.

[@nwordpenis4125]

He set the bar for himself high with under pressure

[@soggyleaf2064]

2 years late but I do agree with you. While it might just be a case of him not caring for logic, but it seems like he always points out the tiniest details to knit pick and he rates his best albums low scores

[@TitanX999AE]

if youre reading this its too late - 8/10 the incredible true story - 6/10 boi

[@Giancarlo5]

ifyrtitl is a masterpiece

[@MrPeanutthegreat]

+Carlo no no no no

[@Frosto29]

+fabian rodriguez No it had great production and bars for days, it's also drakes best album and shows why he's such a versatile artist

[@VedavyasMunugoor]

Yeah, your point? IYRTITL was solid with magnificent production and an aggressive, energetic, and charismatic Drake.

[@imaswedishplumber]

iyrtitl was great tho..... ..

[@jaidsalgado]

Things that Logic does/say/include in his work: 1. GOD DAMN 2. Yeah - yeah (ya-ya) 3. Spell out shit like names and cities/locations (B.I.G. L.E.N.B.O.) 4. Uses that " you, you, you, you" in the background a lot

[@DeadRedemtion111]

+jaidsalgado which song? listened to the album and didn't catch it and i REALLY dont feel like listening to it again

[@jaidsalgado]

+Dexter Morgan Hang on fam lemme find it real quick just for you

[@jaidsalgado]

+Dexter Morgan Shit actually I lied and I realized it wasn't a verse from a song on Under Pressure but a freestyle verse that he did on Tim Westwood. The song is called Stainless and it is the second verse if you wanna hear it and then look up "Logic freestyle on TimWestwood".

[@immajorlygaygayiam2899]

+jaidsalgado No the song is Young Jesus, and the first verse was a freestyle he spit on TimWestwood

[@jaidsalgado]

+The Incredible True Story Nah you're wrong fam, I just looked it up and heard the verse. I know I'm right this time

[@azc29103]

I loved City Of Stars, that is the song I feel was his most different creative song on the album, and really fit the whole Sci-Fi concept the album was trying to portray more than any other track!!! my fave song on the album !!!

[@cyberbron2077]

+Arran Chander definitely creative but it sounded like something off of 808s and heartbreak

[@azc29103]

jeramyleon that definitely inspired the song, so did Kid Cudi man on the moon, but I feel Logic made it his own !!!

[@snaretrap295]

+Arran Chander except Kid Cudi helped create 808s and heartbreak

[@azc29103]

YG Spoder 400 that has nothing to do with logic making it his own !!! lol

[@snaretrap295]

Lol hahaha hilarious. Yes it does you can't just play it off. No matter how good that sound logic made his own you can't take away from the people who invented the sound, and influenced logic. Kid Cudi and Kanye West created the sound you hear on 808s and Heartbreaks and on Man On The Moon: The End Of Day

[@Rozakx]

turn that 6 upside down its a 9 now

[@penguinusername2490]

69, nice

[@commander1suv492]

Lmao

[@jadenslife.5324]

He gave lil yachty a 7/10......... this guy is about taste than quality

[@prodfife]

He's a little of both. He definitely makes good objective points but at the end of the day, his scores are obviously very influenced by opinion. Not really that bad though, as he outright admits "Y'all know this is just my opinion, right?"

[@Minecraftdemon99]

it is music, it is all subjective at the end of the day. I think this album and lil boat got what they deserved

[@jissrapisardi9499]

Minecraftdemon99 You think Lil Boat is a 7/10?

[@staticxreset]

Jiss Rapisardi Why do you care so much if he thinks Lil Boat is a 7?

[@gf-nn4uw]

Jadens life. Uh, cause its his opinion.

[@AL3XXGARSK8]

Fun fact for ya logic didn't go to college and its innermisson not intermission

[@herdankness_3992]

He didn't write that song. Most songs you hear are written for other artist.... Another fact. Rihanna's "umbrella" is actually Brittney spears song.

[@fgh9359]

he didn't even finish high school

[@Superboy8545]

Of course Logic wrote that song himself. What are you talking about?

[@carstarsarstenstesenn]

Alex Garcia but he's smart as shit

[@redpunk9]

what are you talking about? logic doesnt right all his own shit.. no one does

[@ALOUD]

This guy fucking loves Kendrick Lamar....

[@ALOUD]

Another thing: Denoiser in premiere, use it.

[@dappunk1]

You would too if u could dissect music at a high level of understanding

[@retrofilth1414]

+dap he's saying his love of Kendrick overshadows other artists who are high caliber

[@chrishaugan8230]

So does Logic considering how hard he bites Kendricks flow

[@retrofilth1414]

Chris Jones how can you bite someone's flow

[@MizoraK]

Coming back to this: I have been a logic fan since the drop of under pressure. I went to his show in Indianapolis on his tour for this album. I’m not a fan of his recent work (although I’m really digging vinyl days) but this album is one of my favorite rap albums. Rap albums tend to lack concept and deep rooted themes now a days but this album is a trip from start to finish. The story helps to encapsulate the space theme and although it doesn’t relate to each song heavily, it sets the feel and precedent for the massively structured beats. The feel of each track is then related to an outer worldly experience that is felt throughout. It’s truly an album that flows so well track to track and does not feel like anything was forcefully added. I’ll forever love this album for the concept that it beautifully portrays in the mind when listened to front to back.

[@mr_j_official]

Feel the same way, although I think logic is 2/3 on recent projects and I’m excited for his next project

[@nas5858]

The Incredible True Story was amazing, truly a shame how people hated on logic so much

[@gusreynolds1185]

I love this album so much just because if you really listen I feel like not only does he use the space concept, I feel like most of the lyrics and song structures in this album boil down to doing what you love and following your dreams. Fantano missed on this one and I feel like if this album came out today with his new opinions on logic he would’ve given it a 8 or 9. Classic album

[@PtylerBeats]

I was at his Indianapolis show for the Incredible True Story tour

[@conserva-chan2735]

I loved his first two albums, old mixtapes, and the first 2 Bobby Tarantino tapes sooo much. But I couldn't stand Everybody or Confessions, and YSIV rubbed me wrong. However, NP and VD are pretty great records. He's super unique and fascinating but equally frustrating because he was the last pre-streaming rapper to make it really big, and his music's dramatically fluctuating quality reflects that weird limbo.

[@tendaiz150]

review Deez Nuts by Got Eem

[@tendaiz150]

got eem

[@edwinleon2477]

Holy shit you're so fucking funny. No one has made that joke before

[@RashaadJustice]

Feeling a decent "overused" on this one.

[@chrismcdonald5023]

"Deez Nutz" is actually a song from Dr.Dre

[@chriseflores5253]

+TenDaiZ Deezthony Nutstano

[@slackstarfish8133]

Nah this is a classic Logic album that even people outside of his fanbase like. Idk if he’ll ever make an album as good as this

[@reinaldomartinez13]

he already did with his doctor destruction joint and no pressure album

[@tubbin_2830]

@@reinaldomartinez13 definitely not, logic hasn’t even come close to this version of himself

[@drago_024]

he just did, 4 times actually.

[@seanbutler8740]

Im just being honest, I can see how he is somewhat emulating artists in his young sinatra mixtape and under pressure. Regardless, his lyricism is incredible on all of his projects so far. But, I could sort of understand your point on the other two reviews. But you are really stretching it on this album. "He's copying Kendrick and Drake" supposedly. When I heard this I truly didnt see it, so I listened to it again. And I really believe you have a preconceived view of Logic, because the musicality in this album was really great along with the skits and the music relating to the story line. I tried having an open mind and I think Kendrick is really great too but I don't think Logic is emulating him.

[@BabsW]

To be fair, "I Am The Greatest" sounds just like "Worst Behavior".

[@marquezesingleton7904]

BabsW ?

[@IncognitoSprax]

@@BabsW wat?

[@felojimenez9931]

Logic apparently just "copies" other rapper's styles, well in that case Logic is doing other rapper's styles better than those rappers he's allegedly "copying"

[@itsX2024]

Lmao no he's not. The fact his biting is so apparent to so many people proves how bad of job he's doing.

[@felojimenez9931]

+sXeJerichoHolic just my opinion, i dont like modern rap, i prefer the oldies, but logic is one of the few modern rappers i listen to

[@finsimple4396]

"Bad" Is fucking stupid. Go listen to your typical young thug, future, drake or should i say drakes ghost-writers music. Logic is fucking good he is lyrically talented and has one of the best flows in the game. His songs have meaning and has always made good music. such as in undeniable (mixtape), welcome to forever, under pressure, this and bobby tarantino. If you think his lyrics aint deep you to stupid to listen

[@itsX2024]

v Bocaj C'mon lad, why do you have to go the usual "Real Hip Hop" fuccboi rhetoric of you must listen to 'Drake' or 'Future' it's played out fam. I don't care for his lyricism especially when his delivery is carbon copy of Drake and Kendrick. That kill his music instantly for me. Also his production isn't really anything special that pulls me in. So there's 2 instant turns offs for his music.

[@finsimple4396]

Drake? You mean drakes ghost writers. I hear no drake in him. Sure i hear kendrick in him and maybe some j.cole with his song "never been" but i enjoy his own take on it.

[@elliotness981]

Logic isnt really trying to do anything new tho. He loves music, he loves movies. He makes music for fun and to pay homage to the things he loves, which is why it sounds so much like others

[@tm51411]

Did anyone realize that guy in the intro of the album sounded like the toonami dude or was it just me

[@PrismIsAPuck]

+Yung Waves i think its the same guy

[@tm51411]

+Prism I think so too its if its not they gotta sue

[@elbowjuice2627]

+Yung Waves Yeah. It's Steve Blum, the same guy who voiced the Toonami guy. He's also on the cover of the album.

[@PrismIsAPuck]

Yung Waves yeah i read a lot of comments saying it was but idk, but what did you think about the album overall?

[@HEARTMACHINEPLUSULTRA]

It's the same

[@LouMurk]

I rate this review a light to decent 4. Needs more Cal.

[@t-yindigo89]

+Lucid Dreamer word Lmaooo Kai was hilarious, And also what is your lucid dreaming technique ?

[@vash9898]

+Lucid Dreamer What's your best Lucid Dreaming Story?

[@jaidsalgado]

+Tyler Padmore Nigga King Kai is from Dragon Ball Z

[@t-yindigo89]

jaidsalgado Umm i guess you haven't listened to the album yet. The first man of the Aquarius 3 in charge of infantry (William Kai) is who i am referring to. Please go purchase Logic's album: the incredible true story.

[@NFLDRAFT2018]

+jaidsalgado lmfaoooo

[@slackstarfish8133]

He put City of Stars as his least favorite track. Can’t take this seriously. I love this album

[@nadavya2612]

I mean I can get how someone won't like the first part, and he calls the third verse the best on the album which is probably true.

[@phillytothemax]

I like logic and love this album but didn't like that song.

[@NIKOWOODYEAR]

7-8/10 lyrical, good production, funny storyline, movie-like album. logic is logic, the only time he sounded like anyone was the first 2 bars on I am the greatest and the rest is him.

[@kame99023]

+Niko woodyear Im a logic fan, i kinda disagree. Thought it was a strong 6

[@jadencarr8327]

-Logic fanboy

[@awesomecoolepicawesome]

+Jaden Carr what is your point?

[@NIKOWOODYEAR]

jujsteen7 i can see your second comparison to Kanye's flashing lights, "sounded like drakes worst behavior" Im not hearing it, and "run it sounds straight ripped from forest hills drive" explain please. Two completely different flows, topics energy and lyrics. i am sorry but only 1.25 out of your 3 points are valid.

[@cyberbron2077]

+Niko woodyear not really, city of stars sounds like 808s kanye

[@bobbob-xz1fg]

as a big logic fan I agree with most of what Anthony said and think this album had the potential to be really good but didn't live up to it I really hope logic comes into his own on the next project

[@Jexore]

What's that a year to three years? 😂😂

[@bobbob-xz1fg]

+Jexore what?

[@Jexore]

+bob bob The time it will take for his next Project...

[@NFLDRAFT2018]

Yea I agree, it was really blatant too, I'm not sure who's the nigga who said it but he said the key to creativity is hiding your sources.

[@bobbob-xz1fg]

+Jexore but why is that funny?

[@messisuarezneymar521]

the songs aren't supposed to relate to the space stuff because thats all just a metaphor.. what's ur paradise.. not literally another planet paradise, a metaphor to that.. 9.5/10.. not enough songs

[@xlord133]

14 not enough?

[@RashaadJustice]

Am I the only one who liked this more than Under Pressure?

[@devothedumbass7939]

Yeah

[@MyFavoriteSportsballTeam]

+jResonance Nope. I love it more because of the sound library. The beats are so diverse, and the concept is really dope and fun to get into. I'd say it's clearly better quality than UP. Maybe people wanted more lyrical content, idk, but it's a great album, and he rips it with a number of flows.

[@MindOFAlfie]

+jResonance I didn't like under pressure that much, i really liked this album though

[@flirtatiousturtle163]

I like it more, but not that much more

[@MyFavoriteSportsballTeam]

Flirtatious Turtle Agree with this. I still absolutely love Under Pressure.

[@joohnnykuz5327]

Logic just said the only difference between drake rapping about hoes and tupac rapping about hoes is the drum break. That's just false, it's like he forgot lyricism, flow, delivery and technique. Pac would rap about bitches but make it clever and exciting. Drake raps about bitches but his delivery, flow and lyricism is waay below average. Our issue with drake is NOT his subject matter, it''s the fact that he is bad a rapping.

[@cyberbron2077]

+jojo kyle he's not bad at rapping. the difference between drake and tupac is that drake randomly raps about hoes and stuff similar to that while tupac would base a whole song around that one idea.

[@jfriant]

Speak for yourself.

[@joohnnykuz5327]

jeramyleon Nah he is a below average rapper in my eyes and ears.

[@cyberbron2077]

jojo kyle who?

[@joohnnykuz5327]

jeramyleon drake, the only thing good about him is his beats, and if he can flow correctly which is like 25% of the time, i don't even have to focus on his sub par lyrics.

[@Trustytom62]

This album did change everything: Logic’s discography nose-dived in quality after this.

[@Ashh9]

No

[@grecco4037]

say that again 🤭

[@defnotisaiah3210]

it’s true, it was a gradual decrease but once bobby tarantino 2 dropped i couldn’t pick out any highlights. no pressure is good though

[@urayoangarriga]

AshfordX nah he’s right logic stopped caring about his writing after a while “I’d suck a dick to prove it ain’t that way” “i ain’t playin games less we talkin fortnite” 😐 come on bro that’s shitty writing

[@defnotisaiah3210]

Urayoan Garriga yeah he was releasing so much and i feel like he should’ve gone with quality over quantity

[@brianfrtz]

Is it just me, or does Contact sound like the instrumental to Amazing by Kanye West?

[@stulaws]

+Brian Fortiz well it samples that song so yeah

[@luke.6001]

+Brian Fortiz The same type of drums were used. Logic heard the drums on some anime and wanted to use them, he then remembered he heard them on Amazing and asked No I.D where he could get them from. His version has a higher bpm and a different pattern.

[@oddkhalifa]

and he had a simple from Travis Scott

[@brianfrtz]

Stuart Lawson Didn't know that..

[@luke.6001]

Stuart Lawson not a sample, read my comment

[@lakerfan722]

Still hating Big Sean, I see. "No no no no no no no."

[@ABrock777]

+Malik Howard because he's mediocre at best.

[@lakerfan722]

+ABrock777 lol that's none of my business. I found the Dark Sky Paradise review hilarious. 😂😂

[@OliDox]

+ABrock777 He's mediocre but Fantano would rather review Miley Cyrus and Chief Keef albums?

[@Izzylearning]

+ABrock777 big Sean bars must just go over your head every time

[@ABrock777]

+Chill.God nah just because i don't like your favorite rapper doesn't mean i don't get what he's saying just face it he's the most average rapper of the this new generation.

[@aydendunaway4740]

I think you focus on the wrong things a lot of the time...

[@prince4898]

he's a critic, it's what they do.

[@Minecraftdemon99]

"he should just focus him rapping fast and multis and not the fact that he does nothing different from those around him"

[@AlbanianRS]

Minecraftdemon99 stick to minecraft bud

[@jissrapisardi9499]

Minecraftdemon99 Well, yeah. Different rappers do different things. He gave Lil Boat a fucking 7/10, so I think he realizes this. He just doesn't always apply it.

[@loganknox7]

Well maybe the bad things outway the good things sometimes

[@psychologyenjoy]

Logic Stans think they know so much about rap 😂

[@fried7354]

they on the same level as hopsin fans

[@inyerd123]

+God Flow they're pretty bad, but not as bad as hopsin fan. and that's coming from a hopsin fan...

[@psychologyenjoy]

+God Flow haha true af

[@dominicakadc]

+Braeden Hysuick yeah. i was looking at his interview and he seems like a cool guy and his mindset seems like something i'd like to listen to, but he always ends up rapping like other people, or using instrumentals from other people too much. i just wish he wouldn't do that. he talked about not listening to critiques, but i was like noo. listen to them because your fans are so deep they won't tell you you suck ever. i mean he's not terrible, he's just average, but he has the skill to be better so idk why he settles.

[@MattDeezly]

+Braeden Hysuick seems you think the same about yourself bud... eh???? eh??????

[@jaybambi5441]

I lowkey kinda wanted you to rip this album apart (:

[@WheresUrThirdEye]

Damn lol

[@PrimaMusic]

+Joel Brambila Damn all these anti-logic fans were waiting for this lmayo @ them

[@joohnnykuz5327]

+Joel Brambila savagelooool

[@Joela393]

I see that we have a few things in common

[@tymin4636]

Logic needs to create his own sound or he won't last very long bruh, I swear he's been using the same flow since his 2nd mixtape, all his project sound the same

[@nathanthegamemaniac9214]

Anthony underrates Logic, he gave kids see ghost a fucking 10 and he rates logic like this after an amazing album with no shitty songs, I usually respect his views but he’s got some major biases towards kanye and Kendrick

[@adhyadhyaksa]

youre talking to the same guy who gave mbdtf a 6 and yeezus a 5

[@retnugnahte]

Kids See Ghosts was a great album. TPAB was a great album. But he also gave Kanye's masterpiece a 6 so there's that

[@R-H-B]

Maybe he just prefers them? What the fuck does bias got to do with this

[@ravanaRTT]

Anthony fantano, crushing my dreams since 2009

[@MoneyFolder]

I told you this was going to happen gg

[@ravanaRTT]

TheNerdyResponder Well damn 😂😂 gg Still a sick album tho

[@TreTalksMusic]

+Milo Hempel No it's not .

[@ravanaRTT]

Louie Rivers arn't opinions a bitch

[@thisisme5148]

😂😂😂

[@epicfail1526]

Gaah i just have to disagree, especially with the idea that Logic doesn't have his own style or sound. Thats something I would agree with back in the days of his first album, but The Incredible True Story is unique, and finally implements his own style in my opinion. But the thing is, I think i'm just looking at his style in a much more broad perspective. Instead of looking at each individual song, I look at The album as a whole through the perspective of a movie. And within that point of view lies his very clear and unique style. I think you need to look at the album as a whole; A connected auditory "film" from start to finish. The ebst way to describe it would be if Tarantino style Album about space, and the quest for paradise. The story he's telling is his style and signature. Not just the story, but the way he does it, with beautiful songs interlaced with witty dialogue. I get that if you take an individual song, it may song similar to another artist (which even then I would disagree, at least on this album but its at least debatable) But this album is different. Its meant to be looked at as a whole, not just divided into songs and analyzed. You wouldn't think of a movie as a film divided into scenes. We think of movies as whole entities, from start to finish, and thats what this album needs to be looked at as in my opinion.

[@YeahhDan]

55thebassman55 this

[@epicfail1526]

c: I've seen more videos of this guy, and I feel like he's too strict and analytical of music as a whole. Music is so subjective. SO much about music is about how it makes you feel, rather than if it's made correctly. So many times where artists purposely create dissonant sounds or create something that's murky, yet that's exactly the point because that's the emotion they're trying to capture. Jack White is a perfect example of that in my opinion as well as a bunch of other artists from decades ago. Zeppelin, The Doors, etc.

[@heelyBrah]

The concept of the album isn't even unique

[@aloetragedy1568]

VersaceCanOpener name one rapper who has done anything close to this concept lol you cant

[@heelyBrah]

AloE Tragedy lmao this was the plot to Kanye's graduation tour, so did deltron

[@Ethan-el6gl]

I fucking love this album I don't care about this dudes opinion.

[@drewcoomoo1515]

ethan bird K

[@CentinalxGaming]

ethan bird don't take this dude's reviews to heart. his standards for music are ridiculously high.

[@Ethan-el6gl]

Jeez guys calm down. Was b just stating my opinion

[@waltonr.9603]

ethan bird right bro!

[@MrTheyoyoer]

It's okay to not agree with him overall, but you can't not care about constructive criticism. When you don't pay attention to even constructive criticism, you've gotten to a point of bias that keeps you from seeing the truth.

[@MoneyFolder]

12 year old white boys that only play Call of Duty and only listen to "real hip hapz" like Eminem and MGK ( probably wear Vans too) are gonna dislike the hell out of this. EDIT: chill fam, I like Logic, and this comment was a joke lmao.

[@jaidsalgado]

"Probably wear vans too" LMAO

[@MoneyFolder]

+Simaz So? I was saying kids who only play COD. lmfao. You seem butthurt.

[@sultana123ish]

Although I'm not the kind of person you described or that big of a Logic fan, I disagree with Anthony's opinion but still respect it.

[@EpicShadow26]

Another person putting stereotypes on fans I see.

[@cdmxvii5614]

Why it gotta be white fam? Come on B

[@seanstroman6087]

Logic fans don't be mad it's the same score If U love it U love it these are just thought #respect

[@seanstroman6087]

I do feel The album is decent and logic has a lot of growing to do. I believe he'll definitely find his sound I just didn't think it would take this long but I hear to much of Ye, Drake, & Kdot in some instances. Hey It's marathon not a sprint Logic will figure it out.

[@seanstroman6087]

jesus pernia Hey I respect How U feel man He'll figure it out soon he just turn 25 and that's when most of these MCs get in there stride of notching that sound they want to be heard. Under pressure was nice start But he's in the big leagues now Gotta "Hit to all fields" and do it his way.

[@awesomecoolepicawesome]

You seem like a real cool dude, you're right, opinions are opinions.

[@seanstroman6087]

TheGusBus97 definitely man thanks

[@Manny-117]

true

[@theneedledrop]

THINKING OF REVIEWING THE NEW TY DOLLAR $SIGNGNSBNS ALBUM LET ME KNOW IF THAT PISSEDS U OFF I LOVE YOU!

[@dell.856]

do it it was a good review

[@mehmeh4830]

Review Turnover!

[@TheCrazykicks07]

Do jeezy's album

[@RackSimons]

review it! I thought it was ok

[@PurplePandaClock]

Yes, please review I'd only give it a 7 but I think it's a very interesting album worth talking about

[@mamelloraboroko3645]

I love everything about City of Stars, the production, the build, the late verse, his "singing".

[@littlesean93]

this got a 6/10! So its a little weird but all of my favorite albums Fantano reviews he gives a 6/10. Acidrap, 2014 Forest hills drive, Under pressure, 9005, and ect.... so this will probably be in constant rotation for the next year at least. thx Fantano!

[@eminemfan50098]

All of those I love except forest hills. That record has like 3 great song and 3 decent songs. Can't believe he gave acid rap or under pressure a 6 tho that's crazy.

[@kennym1216]

6/10 is still good! I would personally give it a 7 I think it’s close to being great, I think it’s really good

[@aroobism]

City of stars least favorite song? That’s just taking the piss

[@DaygoCarti]

It's a good album but after listening to this I feel like all the flaws pop out. Logic does not have his own style, what sets him apart from others. I feel like logic had a lot of passion but it was passion spewed all over the place. I still like the album, you gotta like what you like no matter what, but what Anthony said is true to a degree

[@MusicIsAWayOfLife123]

+Matthew Bareno Not really impressive if it's just copying others?

[@jakeh3809]

+MusicIsAWayOfLife123 You are very ignorant for saying that first off every rapper uses samples from other artists weather you know it or not shit the sample wasn't even from Kanye it was a type of drum used in another production and used it for amazing if you would have done some research. It's not like the dude is taking other people's lyrics or anything. There is multiply comparisons I could make about flow with other artist to everyone has influences and just about everyone uses them. Plus eventually there is going to be no more different flows because they'll all be used up and then every one will be coping one another. To me it's more about the music and my love for hip hop more than worrying about weather he copped kendricks flow or not. Probably just another dude hugging up on kendricks nut sac.

[@ransizzles]

+Diego Medellin I think its bullshitt that peple are criticizing Logic for not having his own sound. Travis Scott's sound is HEAVILY influenced by Kanye but I don't see people telling Travis Scott to get his own sound.

[@ransizzles]

That's BS. Travis Scott's sound is heavily influenced by Kanye all the way down to the ad lbs, Travis Scott is just a Trap Kanye

[@oPhenomenal]

+ransizzles No it's not lol. Kanye's Yeezus sound was modeled after Travis and Death crips sound lol. Absolutely none of kanye's previous work is similar to Travis's sound. You must be new to Kanye if you really think that

[@Cypherdiaz951]

I love Logic's last two albums and give this one a solid 8, I think it way better than a decent 6... Just my opinion, and entertaining review.

[@christianvasquez1845]

fans needs validation from melon to like their own artist lol

[@phoque022]

you gonna review that new G-Eazy album? I wanna see you rip that shit apart

[@persona3259]

+phoque022 Man I hope so him and his frat girl fanbase are annoying as hell.

[@EnigmaStudioHD]

+persona Jealous or what.

[@paxtonwaugh6312]

This comment made my day

[@BrianDePalmaII]

Honestly Kendrick and Logic are the best working rappers today

[@kungfukenny4718]

DON'T EVER COMPARE THE BEST MC OF OUR GEN WITH ANOTHER FAN

[@MrPeanutthegreat]

+King Kendrick Kendrick is dope definitely top 5 but not THE BEST MC OF OUR GENERATION.

[@MrPeanutthegreat]

+King Kendrick plus you're a fucking hater bro you've commented on almost every fucking compliment to logic calling logic a fucking shitty mc basically.

[@finsimple4396]

In my opinion 1. Kendrick 2. Logic 3. J.cole I know many will be mad for putting logic>cole but personally i fuck with logic over cole but i def accept cole over logic the only other reason is that cole last album was in 2014.

[@finsimple4396]

***** and that album had no features and went double platinum from a nobody. It was a great album and i see where you are coming from but you don't have to be fucking rude about it. I said kendrick as no 1 just as you so stfu. I think logic > cole anyway so what are you one about?

[@kaimarin3781]

Honestly one of my favorite rap albums ever, will always keep coming back to this album!

[@fernandocalderon6392]

least favorite track city of stars smh...

[@JoshTheGreat33]

City of stars is a musical masterpiece

[@theunseenghost]

That shit is just alternate version of Flashing Lights by Kanye.

[@prodfife]

Ghost Yeah, in title only. The beats and lyrics are totally different.

[@donttouchtheac8651]

Damon Llopiz he said that because of the beat what are you talking about...

[@TheTryhardBeast12]

Listen to Say You Will by Kanye, then listen to City Of Stars, then tell me it's not a copy

[@shishersh1712]

He made the album in the way he wanted it, and the way he thought it sounded best. It seems like the guy can't do anything without people jumping to calling him a copycat.

[@kelechic.jemelumba9981]

logic is a perfect example of a good rapper that can't make a good album

[@ABrock777]

+Christian 0000 just like king los.

[@kelechic.jemelumba9981]

ABrock777 yeah, he's freestyles are killer, but his albums are so lackluster

[@thedman05]

He just comes off as unoriginal as hell to me. He doesn't seem to come up with original shit much. Like Jesus man, are you that fucken scared of making new shit that you gotta copy god damn nearly everything Kendrick is doing lol? Watch, he's gonna make an album copying the fuck out of to pimp a butterfly next.

[@dell.856]

Danny Aleman where did copy kendrick 😂😂😂

[@emmanuelmondesir1314]

+Christian 0000 he's too afraid to stick to one flow

[@keos]

Make a DJ Khaled 'I Changed A Lot' album review plz

[@jenseliasjaarvik592]

+DatGuyKhaos brush that shit trash as fuck

[@keos]

lmao there is hella bangers wtf u talking about.

[@BerkesTheFirst]

& another one

[@jenseliasjaarvik592]

the fuck I’m talking bout that that album was hella trash. sure there are bangers, but those bangers on the album is trash, atone upon autotune upon autotune

[@CASSOBLVCK]

Nah Anthony will just play himself

[@booker4984]

I feel like logic needs to take a long hiatus and needs to stop releasing music so often. He’s running out of material and it’s getting stale. I feel like he can still get back to his prime he just needs some space

[@shanem6576]

Booker bro i just came back to this video being a huge logic fan going through the comments cause i’m bored. but thank you. you’re probably one of the most understanding and real person with his music. you’re 100% correct

[@nicholaskenneth113]

Excactly. No matter how good of a rap artist you are, you can't just keep making 2 albums a year and not expect any form of writers block

[@booker4984]

Mr. Clean Yeah I just miss the logics old quality of music and I want it back. I think he’s doing that. Though which is good

[@booker4984]

Nicholas Kenneth Exactly. I hope he doesn’t release another project for another year or so I want a good finished product. Hopefully he goes back to his old creative self. Because it wasn’t just the lyrics that declined. The flows the beats the overall quality of the songs declined with confused me. His first and Second album are light years better then anything he’s released since.

[@timmyburger2276]

How's indefinitely for u

[@mikeglock2071]

czarface still holds the crown for 2015

[@mykelc205]

Great album..What's your top 5?

[@erronking7783]

lie again.

[@nascr7_47]

yea okkk...aint nobody even kno who he is

[@nascr7_47]

yea okkk...aint nobody even kno who he is

[@djwarzone1]

yeah!!! Czarface aoty all day!

[@pullupthen5073]

Logic is so middle of the road it's not even funny

[@hkoperatorsunion_3395]

White hip-hop enthusiasts would disagree

[@pullupthen5073]

+Black_Ted Bundy (Black Ted Bundy) no kidding lol. He has talent but just hasn't put it fully together yet

[@xMsry7]

+Black_Ted Bundy (Black Ted Bundy) I'm a white hip hop enthusiast and I can't stand Logic

[@mykelc205]

But he's young like practically the age of today's Hip Hop fans (sighs) Doesn't that make him trendy? like part of the now? hhaa?

[@MyFavoriteSportsballTeam]

+Brandon Standifer lol what?

[@iamawesome1111111111]

and all the faze KZbinrs are crying

[@JoshTheGreat33]

+insigne all the faze members that stay at the faze house are horrible, the others ones I don't mind. Bloo and Jev are awesome lol

[@silent5353]

JoshTheGreat33 - y’all just broke boys

[@denylsonavila]

8/10 it's a I album for me

[@_Solum]

Denylson Avila definitely agree. The critic average rate is 7.3 tho. 8/10 for me as well

[@retlon3158]

Wat?

[@penguinusername2490]

10/10

[@rekuf]

His best album after all this time.

[@scizorbullet8185]

I never got what he was talking about with this album sounding like kendrick lamar or drake.

[@theneedledrop]

thanks for watching! you'e the best!

[@jaidsalgado]

We love you no matter what!

[@WifiParadise]

+jaidsalgado inb4 blvck lord guy

[@jaidsalgado]

+WifiParadise Lol hey nice to see you here! BLVCK LORD told me that he had nothing to say on the video Teach Me but that he did see it lol

[@WifiParadise]

+jaidsalgado yeah ik he saw it he is sees all when it comes to rap

[@jaidsalgado]

+WifiParadise lol

[@yendorsaphura]

In My Opinion: The Incredible True Story: Light To Decent 9/10 Fav Tracks: Contact, Fade Away, Upgrade, Like Woah, Young Jesus, Innermission, Lord Willin, City Of Stars, Paradise, Never Been, Run It, The Incredible True Story

[@retnugnahte]

I'm a Logic fan but I'd say it's an 8

[@yendorsaphura]

@@retnugnahte that's fair, but remember it's strictly my opinion

[@retnugnahte]

@@yendorsaphura very true. I'd give No Pressure a 8 or 9 as well. And Under Pressure ofc

[@nbizub]

Don't care what anyone says this album was straight fire, run it is insane

[@NotAGrabbaghoul]

I just need a Under Pressure 2

[@theunseen-00]

RJ Foyles It is on the way

[@carrascothag5172]

Its called NO PRESSURE

[@user-fs7zm6zc7s]

Except that TITS was better than UP

[@ashimghale3969]

@@user-fs7zm6zc7s your opinion bud

[@negativelm1079]

@@user-fs7zm6zc7s I love both lmao, I cant decide which I like more but Under Pressure do have a soft part in my heart

[@LolZ4LifE456]

Damn, you gave this the same rating as My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy? Must be an amazing album

[@notoriousnad4804]

Why would logic review his own album? 🤔🤔

[@GoodxJ]

10/10 Classic shit!!!! Respect to Logic!!!!!

[@sovietbby8401]

GoodxJ lmao this ain’t a classic bud

[@kashaniog7113]

nah this shit is my favorite album but under pressure was slap

[@swampnuts265]

under pressure>

[@zazoukarim6011]

10/10 for sure !

[@arthurdunn4594]

@@sovietbby8401 cringe. This album is truly a classic.

[@lilwaynesteeth7941]

Under Pressure seemed like a rip off Good Kid Mad City concept wise and this one is a rip off Big Krits Cadillactica he needs to find original concepts if he wants to do a concept album.

[@kevinj3274]

+Lil Wayne's Teeth so true

[@MyFavoriteSportsballTeam]

+Lil Wayne's Teeth Lol how is this a rip off? And how was under pressure a rip off? UP was about his life and the pressure of coming out with his first commercial album, and the concept of this was completely different than cadillactica. Just because it's about space doesn't mean it's exactly the same. Congrats on being really ignorant tho. Can't expect more from someone named "Lil wayne's teeth."

[@Wallescontent]

Lmao you are reaching.

[@Eramlc]

+Lil Wayne's Teeth Your youtube name is a rappers teeth, your opinion is irrelevant.

[@dominicakadc]

+Lil Wayne's Teeth i did not see the resemblance of GKMD on his first album that much, it was only the one song that fantano mentioned in that review. i don't think the concept was the same either, logic's life was actually completely different than kendrick's. but for this album i do see a lot of the flow resemblances. and idk why he does it. he honestly just needs to stop listening to other rappers. he can actually rapper and can do the flows, all he has to do is figure out a way to combine them and make them his own. but right now it just sounds like a mimic

[@conserva-chan2735]

Logic is the most annoyingly inconsistent rapper ever. Dude debuted with a classic mixtape series and was the last big pre-streaming datpiff era rapper, dropped two great high-concept albums, had another great pair of tapes (first two Tarantino tapes), only to sell out and have a wack third album that derailed his career followed by a great tape(BT2) mediocre tape(YSIV), and an embarrassing soundtrack release which was followed by an even shittier pop-rap album(Confessions). Since then, he's been struggling to stay relevant with a great album(NP), awful tape(BT3), and another great release(VD). Dude is square between two totally different eras of hip hop and his career and music is super fascinating and equally as frustrating.

[@SpeedBoostGamer]

City of stars was fire! Wtf! The only part i did not like in the song was the comparison with Drake and Tupac, that line made me cringe like tf.

[@ABrock777]

+SpeedBoostGamer it wasn't really a comparison more of showing how some hip hop fans are hypocrites.

[@SpeedBoostGamer]

+ABrock777 yeah but it was sorta inaccurate, yeah pac rapped about money and hoes but he heavily influenced hip-hop more than drake and spoke on important issues and wasn't afraid to speak out about the gov. And so on. Idk, i honestly don't think alot of ppl want drake to get shot, another inaccurate part, drake is so popular now

[@ABrock777]

+SpeedBoostGamer trust me i'm with on that but some of these hip hop fans are so fucking annoying it makes me want to drink bleach.

[@SpeedBoostGamer]

+ABrock777 lol yeah its just the radical ones

[@MrBeastknows]

+SpeedBoostGamer The point he was making was people like you would say "today rappers like Drake are shit because they only talk about bitches and hoes" but every rapper back in the day did the same thing. Of course now you're trying to say "yeah but Pac would make it interesting lyrically and blah blah" and get a hundred likes while missing the point but w.e we can all at least agree middle aged middle class white people are all horrible in general, right? I prefer today's rap more anyways. Much more artistic and musical than the basic rapping over a beat they had in the 90s, especially east coast.

[@NoThoughtAllFeels]

This album is a 8/10 at the LEAST

[@Tocinos]

8/100

[@ShyKxtty]

whats with the Drake and Kendrick comparisons, Logic's completely different hes the only rap artist I've ever heard incorperating old school type of jazz trumpets, strings, kinda vinyl classical type of sound. That comparison really pissed me off :/

[@deedizeldafreak]

listen to tpab, section .80 , surf , coloring book, Chance the rapper, common albums , etc.

[@chrisbentley898]

then you must not listen to much music..

[@Mr363078]

+DeeDiZeL chance sucks

[@deedizeldafreak]

+Strydx Didn't ask for your opinion

[@Mr363078]

+DeeDiZeL nobody asked for your suggestion

[@zeal8111]

imma add to the piles: “great ass album gets a 6” “least favorite song is actually the best song”

[@kingmarofficial]

easy 9/10... sometimes i think music reviewers try to look for problems too hard when they arent really there

[@gabrielmotta4757]

What a garbage review

[@SnoppleWopple]

Facts

[@Spectre0799]

Innermission sounds nothing like fucking tpab.

[@retnugnahte]

Did he say it did. The first Logic song I heard and still my favourite

[@Spectre0799]

@@retnugnahte He did wtf lmao

[@fm_232]

City of stars firsthalf was ehhh but YO THAT CLOSE OUT VERSE???? Come on Fantano. Hardest of his life

[@dennahouti]

Watch the review dude

[@UGGOGG]

+fm232 if you watch it he says that's a good verse but he isn't into the first half of the song

[@MrBeastknows]

+fm232 I like the first half of City Of Stars more. It's just nice to listen to. Kind of Drake/basically Kanye West. And that second half was pretty fire.

[@fm_232]

tux dog I was in the car homie, actually playing the album. Just wanted to get a grasp on what he thought. Watching it now

[@YeOldeTrey23]

pretty much, Logic is great at being good.

[@retlon3158]

Trevon Rochester which sucks

[@KendegohLucavi]

The lyrics werent really anything new, but not so bad that it kept the album from vibing hard. It was a great project.

[@MyFavoriteSportsballTeam]

+ZiggytheNinja I don't think this assclown even understands what "Vibing" is. He never thinks about that when reviewing albums. When your music creates an atmosphere that listeners feel like they enter when they listen to it, you're doing something right that not many artists can do.

[@KendegohLucavi]

+M. Mailloux Damn bro u salty?

[@MyFavoriteSportsballTeam]

ZiggytheNinja I've seen Anthony tear down so many albums I love, i don't even watch the videos anymore I just look at the score in the description haha. Is that salty? >.> Also I was agreeing with you if that wasn't clear. It's not groundbreaking lyrically but I'm amazed at the sound variation and listenability of this project.

[@KendegohLucavi]

+M. Mailloux Yeah I know you were agreeing with me. Still salty as fuck tho...Fantano doesn't "tear things down", he gives his honest opinion and backs his scores up with reason. He gave this album an above average score, sorry if it wasn't a perfect 10.

[@MyFavoriteSportsballTeam]

ZiggytheNinja LOL I never expect a perfect 10. He does actually tear things down because he picks on every little flaw that the average listener woud not give a shit about until they hear it from him. He has literally ruined albums for me that I liked until he uncovered a bunch of little flaws that really didn't matter and made me rethink my whole perspective. I prefer to enjoy music not to critique the hell out of it lol. Sorry that I completely disagree with Asstony's "opinion" pretty much every time he puts out a video.

[@MrhibyeTV]

Lmfao. Commander asks the AI to talk to Big Sean. "No no no no no no no no no."

[@phillytothemax]

So crazy watching this review because it was the album that changed everything. Its arguably his best album

[@killarafael7744]

I liked City of Stars...I think it was a good change from fast rapping to slow singing, with a very good beat.

[@sultana123ish]

10/10 imo and I ain't even a huge Logic fan or a cod 12 year old scrub. I really liked it tbh.

[@hectorn3360]

Lol he said decent lyricists he's one of the best lyricists out there definitely in the top 5 rn

[@clapthonyclaptano3922]

salt

[@hectorn3360]

moms spaget pepper

[@chrishaugan8230]

Hector Maldonado nah

[@abhiramgollapudi999]

earl lupe los logic doom no order

[@mcstreamer9]

Abhiram Gollapudi kendrick, locksmith, etc. Logic doesn't Crack top 5

[@amckeachie]

Did you guys know logic is biracial?

[@ianbartonjo2435]

what :o

[@abbyoffthewall1441]

I loved the album personally. It was a change from the repetitive lyrics he has done in the past. The beats are amazingly done. I love that the album has a storyline it shows more of logics creativity. Just really think overall it's good.

[@fxh1343]

I think 6 was a very harsh rating. i would've probably given it a 7 maybe 8 at a push but then you're talking about someone who know's who they are. i agree with you on the fact that logic is still trying to find who he is, but for a second official album i think this is an amazing step for him. again, i agree with you, he is yet to show off his prowess, but when he does the world better watch out because fire is going to come to a phone near you.

[@globebaby]

6 is not harsh, six means its a little above average, which is what logic basically is

[@RenaldyCalixte]

Panda - I agree I think mainstream hip hop is so watered down that above average is like Nas's Ether or Kendrick's Control verse to young hip hop fans.

[@georgeemerald4389]

He never actually did.

[@Frenblow]

FXH13 oof when you wrote this comment Everybody hasn’t dropped

[@TheTryhardBeast12]

this comment did NOT age well at all lmao

[@azer4931]

idc this album will always be a 10 for me but i do like seeing what other people think about it tho

[@keelodagreat4676]

Still one of my favorites albums to listen to from start to finish. - 2021 🔥🔥🔥 I love SciFi themed stuff.

[@MrDaryllv]

Fantano doesn't realize that this is the 'album that changed everything' for Logic. Not for the world or for Hip Hop.

[@peacelovenessab]

I had higher expectations on his sophomore album. I also noticed how drake like "I am the greatest" was & some lines he used reminded me of previous songs.

[@peacelovenessab]

Kelvin Brewington Sure you can lol ;)

[@theonlyone261]

+Kelvin Brewington careful, she might be a dude.

[@peacelovenessab]

Kelvin Brewington lmao did you see that comment xD ^

[@Kelvin_Eclectic]

Vanessa S Yea I +1'd it lol I thought sayin you're my gf would be too corny.

[@peacelovenessab]

+Kelvin Brewington hahaha 😂

[@Zenssei]

City of Stars is a great song idc what anyone say Its the track that fits the album the most

[@HumansFreshlyBorn]

10/10 for Steve Blum getting work

[@blueberrybeam]

anthony is chatting this a 9/10 imo

[@cyberbron2077]

dont play ya self

[@usctrojanfreak]

Hey man if you want it to be a 9, then it's a 9. Mkay? Mkay(:

[@holylemon98]

+Quentino J lol k

[@thedman05]

Ok so according to you this is as good as GKMC? Sorry bro but logic is just not there yet in terms of accolades. This ain't a nine. Maybe if he stopped copying fucken other people so much and used their shit to make his own style he'd breakthrough. It's like the saying goes, 'bad artists copy, good artists steal'. But until he does, a 6 seems fine as his due. Skill ain't enough. You have to bring something new to the table, for the same logic (no pun intended) you probably wouldn't enjoy a second helping of mashed potatoes from a batch done exactly the same as a first one. You already saw it. It doesn't come off as satisfying cause you already had it.

[@ishaanbansal3503]

I love the album because of the voice cast from Cowboy Bebop. YOU SHOULD have done your research and said that!

[@Sprite-cy8cp]

Legit the only reason why this album stuck out to me lmfao

[@reinaldomartinez13]

fr, this dude said pretty good voice acting as if Steve Blum isn't one of the best voice actors of all time

[@daj_music123]

0:13 Ok, this had no reason to be this funny 😂

[@unchartedisawesome]

This has to be the best intro to a video ever

[@fromspace1664]

i'm not a huge logic fan but i've always loved this album i'd give an 8 still