Apple's Privacy Paradox (& Selling Out To Ads)

[@solaawodiya7360]

I'm finally happy that we have a video like this calling Apple out. Everyone is so quick to call out Google for their privacy issues but treat Apple like a Saint. Apple is not only guilty monetizing their customer data but also guilty of core anti competitive practices. Apple has always been a wolf in sheep clothing and I hope they're held accountable like Google.

[@spicychad55]

Anything closed source is inherently manipulative and untrustworthy. Apple just does what it wants to make money.

[@ElJosher]

Only ignorant people don’t recognize how bad all major tech companies are.

[@solaawodiya7360]

@@miko-ee They're all the same. They just have different ways of doing the same thing

[@A_ARAFAT]

@@spicychad55 Exactly

[@Jac0b22]

Nothing in this video suggested Apple has security issues. It’s still the safest device to use for your protection. They have implemented software based monetization but nothing that steals your identity and info and sells it

[@adambuss654]

The way the video loops from ads, to Apple as a company, back to ads is beautiful.

[@PhilipMurphyExtra]

No company is ever with privacy in mind these days.

[@TCKRDefense]

that's fucking wrong, If you meant Apple then yes i don't trust their privacy. But Their are good companies with privacy in mind.

[@PhilipMurphyExtra]

@@TCKRDefense Through it does seem like most companies don't care.

[@baoquoc3710]

@@TCKRDefense now you sounded like your "walled garden" is in danger huh

[@MilesProwerTailsFox]

My company does protect your data but I don't have enough clients to keep a constant production and my quality while being still better than apple products everyone just ends up destroying them and asking for free repair even tho the guarantee already expired

[@1bridge11]

3:12 You referred to him as Tim Apple. LOL

[@LogicallyAnswered]

Yeah hahaha

[@kylewilliams4691]

@@LogicallyAnswered Trump joke ?

[@jinxedpenguin]

@@LogicallyAnswered loved it; I reference that speech all the time

[@jestrada014]

I love the casualness of the joke!

[@Gwubby86]

I *always* took their privacy claims with a HUGE grain of salt.

[@Nur__]

you mean with a huge bucket of salt

[@Gwubby86]

@@Nur__ however much salt it takes!

[@anarkidaniel1196]

well said🤗

[@CazDesignStudios]

Salt bae amounts of salt

[@raandomplayer8589]

Comically huge

[@gaudam514]

Can we have a video looking at Apple product pricing? Reviewers are always praising them for keeping the prices the same but that’s only in the USA whereas the rest of the world are charged substantially more like here in the UK

[@LogicallyAnswered]

Ah yeah, that’s true. I have a video about European iPhone prices actually.

[@vfreeman3188]

That's true but you're still overpaying for inferior hardware.

[@juggsauce]

​@@vfreeman3188 Im an android guy but it's not 2014. Their hardware is arguably faster and more efficient than any android to date. The max has intimidating battery life and their processors blow away snapdragons away. It's the software and experience I can't stand personally. But saying their hardware is inferior is just factually wrong.

[@breechcomet9724]

​@@juggsauce not anymore the snapdragon chips are superior to A series atleast in GPU and mediatek is on the heels of Apple in CPU. As for efficiency Android is still behind and even displays as of late well atleast in terms of brightness.

[@juggsauce]

@@breechcomet9724 they are reeling in the difference, absolutely. But analysts have been speculating that the next bionic chip will be a jump. So we'll see if that's true. I mean we're at the point now where it's hard to tell the difference unless you're taking or editing video. I just want bad ass battery life and snappy performance and it's nice to see the gen 2 improve so much in heat/efficiency. The display thing is strange because Samsung manufactures the damn things 🤣. I guess maybe apple cut a deal to get first dibs on 2000 nit displays idk

[@rayoflight62]

Sadly, people are becoming allergic to the subscriptions. Virtually everything is becoming a subscription, and will not take much more before a generalised refusal will show up; especially in a climate of high inflation and cost of living, even the laziest person must go and check all the monthly payments going out of their bank account. Thank you for the video, Harry; it's truly appreciated. Greetings, Anthony

[@ShadowHazy]

I am also very allergic to subscriptions. If you don't let me own and download the thing I bought, at least let me have permanent access to it.

[@Moli05]

@@ShadowHazy in that case everyone would just pay once and never sub again

[@Moli05]

we have too many subscriptions now. they were great because they offered a ton of things for a cheap price. now i only have the necessary ones like icloud, PS Plus Premium, Apple Music and i share netflix with my parents. So i get a lot for like 120€/year

[@ruthlessrude6014]

I realised that long time ago. I don't subscrib or use iPhone in general. You watch KZbin ads. Everything ads. I use android. You can apk mod everything. Basically. You want something. You download an apk file. Ie. KZbin Vance for Android. Premium KZbin for free. You can play when the mobile is on standby/ background without opening the tab. No ads, skip and intros. See likes and dislike.

[@ShadowHazy]

@@Moli05 That's the point. Why would anyone want to rent something if it's equal to just buy it normally? And how can you know how long these companies will last? If you want to try things for once, go for it. I still think at that price, there are more selections.

[@kimjongun9414]

The Ask To Opt out is prevent third party tracking .

[@LogicallyAnswered]

Yep

[@kimjongun9414]

@@LogicallyAnswered so why its a big deal like apple is some sort of bad guy trying to cut revenue of other company's . The Apple Ad Service been out here for like decade and its only on apps like App store and book . i think almost some youtube creator is trying to bend the story to fit a certain perspective

[@irvanray1898]

@@kimjongun9414 It's not about apple being the bad guy by cutting other companies profit, but more about apple want to be the only one who serve ads on their devices imo, is that a bad thing? Maybe no but that's just mean they're being a hypocrite

[@nekrosis4431]

@@kimjongun9414 apple isn't the bad guy for the "opt out" feature. They're the bad guy for claiming to protect you from something (googleAds) while sliding in their own version of the exact same thing. They're also the bad guy for anti-competitive behavior. This is not Apple exclusive, but they are one of the most aggressive when it comes to forcing competitors out.

[@MilesProwerTailsFox]

To then sell the info driving the whole feature useless for you, but for apple it just generated em millions

[@youdontsay2529]

Lovely insight. I always had a cynical view to their whole "Privacy is important to us" philosophy.

[@Indubb]

I always figured their ask not to track feature was helping them more than it was helping me, but it was kinda a win-win scenario. The truth seems to be that apple gets a C while facebook gets an F.

[@nyanyamero]

It's like choosing the "lesser evil". 🤷🏻

[@sarthakbiswas6925]

You have a skill issue in technology... you think you know too much about cyber security and technology... but in reality you don't

[@JackieLombardi]

I've been binging your channel for like the past hour and it's crazy that I clicked back on your channel to see a new upload x3 Thanks for all of the amazing content ♥

[@LogicallyAnswered]

Hahaha, really appreciate you watching my videos Jackie!

[@spookwave4966]

Businesses never side with people with no catch. There is ALWAYS A CATCH.

[@npoaccount9154]

Imagine paying $1000 only to view ads, when my $150 rooted android phone has 3 layers of adblocking

[@bruxi78230]

In the App Store a person views the ads only if they really want to. The ads are very unobtrusive. In fact many people aren't even aware that Apple has been doing advertising for years because there are no flashing lights or animations that take over the screen. Just so you understand how smartphones work, people do 100s of other things besides viewing ads, but thanks a lot for your great spin job. Anybody who buys a $150 Android and roots it and installs 3 layers of adblocking is what one would call irrelevant because the number of people willing to do it is tiny. But hey, you do you.

[@Jac0b22]

Lmao because you’re the ad. That phone is a piece of shit and you know it

[@felman87]

I chuckled when you called him "Tim Apple".

[@baselkarkabee3870]

Amazing video and very well made 1 thing though can you lower the background sounds (Music)? I was wearing headphones while watching and it felt loud and if I turn my sound down your voice will be hard to hear other than that goddamn your videos are amazing keep going

[@LogicallyAnswered]

Really appreciate the constructive feedback Basel!

[@johnscarceforpresident1647]

Great editing but I think it was slightly overedited. Great video overall though!

[@Ducc-boii]

My questions about apple just got Answered, logically!

[@LogicallyAnswered]

Glad to hear that Declan

[@leonardorodrigues7387]

Common Apple L. Love the videos bro, keep it up! ❤

[@LogicallyAnswered]

Thank you Leonardo!

[@kimxgamer]

I dislike the gradual increase in prices of new devices over the years, it just makes me feel that they are greedy and want more 🤑🤑

[@blikje_in_de_water]

as long as an iphone 6,7" costs me more than 1200 euros I will never switch... Right now I've got a android phone with 120hz oled and fast processor, 300euros... galaxy watch 4 classic 170 euros and some xiaomi buds with noise canceling for 80euros... try buying that at apple...

[@vin.k.k]

We all saw this coming. Thank you for putting it all in one beautiful piece.

[@kevinbarry71]

As someone who has owned a series of iPhones starting in 2010; plus iPads; I have never paid Apple any services subscriptions. Only extra money I've given them is purchasing some movies and TV shows on iTunes. I have, however, cost apple a fair amount in warranty claims on several iPhones

[@cken27]

I am surprised end-to-end encryption is not mentioned here. 80% of this video basically says Apple is trying to enlarge their user base of their software products by offering more economical hardwares and user control privacy mechanism, which is a fair business strategy. The rest of the video is just the typical monopoly potential concern, where faithful users have to continue to use Apple product, in order to have their software compounded ecosystem and privacy protection. The concern is valid, but as long as not everyone like to use Apple products given their higher price premium, just like some of the comments here, I think Apple still needs to implement opt-out with privacy protected ads to maintain their reputation. So far, I am actually quite happy with Apple giving users privacy choice. Surely, the ads agency gonna get a huge cut from Apple just like what Apps store does to developers. However, all these should not be a problem with continuous competition from Google and Microsoft.

[@trentkhr]

kzbin.infoUgkxIj9p9M9EGV5fAPNYEne9DOzBLRd7OkOw?si=B-axan9fgNrTaldG

[@ghmasterjj]

the music in this video is so bombastic lmao, good script tho

[@LogicallyAnswered]

Appreciate the feedback Roy

[@Ryan-ul2xc]

Tim Apple! i spotted it lol awesome video!

[@DeathValleyDazed]

Yup, I heard that too and thought Hauri did that on purpose. Timmy Appleseed 😂

[@GoolagThemTube]

It's all about greed. Greed, greed and even more greed. It always turns out this way for all tech companies eventually, without exception.

[@mkac0036]

Great video. btw at 2:01 the text says 'FAILLING SALES' instead of 'FALLING SALES'

[@LogicallyAnswered]

Oops

[@alexanderhamilton0]

@@LogicallyAnswered *Dw I can save this* Yeah that was a play on words for their sales simultaneously failing and falling, completely intentional👀👍🏼

[@PerpetualPreponderer]

TBH I don’t really give a hoot as long as they make their devices affordable again. The prices of new iphones today are INSANE. It’s just a phone at the end of the day, absolutely ridiculous.

[@yashgulave8366]

3.14 '...if Tim Apple had done this...' Haha, I love the inside jokes so much 😂

[@peiqizhao8359]

This makes me wonder would apply get sued over monopoly

[@georg-hanisch]

Some feedback about the video: could you make the background music a little quieter? It feels kind of distracting, so that I actively need to listen, or I won't understand what you're saying.

[@souravraj]

I always wonder why Facebook couldn't have made it compulsory for users to accept tracking on iOS for continuing using app , I mean they lost 10 billion they could have made it compulsory and people would have opted in and avoided losing 10billion .

[@bluesnake3477]

countries have privacy laws

[@matticolo]

Love the music in this video! And finally someone that said the truth about Apple… maybe the privacy thing was real in the SJ era, but now it’s quite the opposite 😔

[@-_lIl_-]

wow, apple is really on a roll

[@Bhethar]

If they can come out with a more privacy focused ad system it might push other companies to do better. But yeah, this is still a sad development.

[@farazshaikh4967]

Amazing analysis of the Apple strategy. One of the best critical anaysis video framed in an entertaining way. Hats off!

[@colt5189]

I could never buy an Apple computer. Because you can't upgrade anything. Whereas computers are getting to that point anyway by not allowing you to upgrade the CPU much anymore. But with Apple, you can't even upgrade or replace the hard drive. Which I like keeping a spare hard drive with a clone of the OS around in case of a hard drive failure. Which means those Apple computers will go bad at some point as the solid state hard drives will wear out. Which will take out the whole computer instead of just the hard drive.

[@oferim11]

Apple can't compete in ads with Google (search engine) or Facebook (free social media). They can do an ad exchange, but this is much smaller and less profitable.

[@nickplays2022]

Isn’t Google doing the same? There was some new Privacy Sandbox thing

[@keshktayem]

First I love ur videos btw

[@LogicallyAnswered]

Thanks for being early Tayem!

[@hello-friend990]

Great video as always but the music is annoying AF

[@helloaftergoodbye3922]

If they really implement all of the privacy features for the ads, I will probably still be annoyed but tolerate ads if they are not too intrusive (like in the OS itself, not just native app). However, the anti-competitive Apple tax in the Apps Store and other BS has to stop. They can't be the game master and the player at the same time.

[@Avanne1]

Why not?

[@vracaze]

0:48 literally thought he said "might even convert some N-word users" while showing a black man. Im dead 💀💀💀

[@TheCrowReviewer]

Lmao 🤣

[@questionmaker3795]

Fantastic video, I just feel like the music was sometimes too loud compared to your voice. (Maybe just me, I know I live quiet documentaries.)

[@saadalarifi8211]

Awesome vid, please consider a better mic. Cheers

[@shahidjerk]

Did they say Tim Apple? Lol

[@sorushienx5414]

Your posts are very frequent. How big is your team. Good job

[@LogicallyAnswered]

Just me and 2 editors :)

[@PlaceboReiki]

@@LogicallyAnswered How do you make such qualitative content that small amount of people

[@PlaceboReiki]

Youre not supposed to answer that

[@overtherainbowxx8847]

@@PlaceboReiki why ?

[@dimitrihenri4085]

@@overtherainbowxx8847 rhetoric question 😅

[@peporgan]

It's a bit silly to say Apple transitioned from a hardware company to software- it was always a software company. MacOS was the core of their business from 1984.

[@ambyjkl]

yaas, another goated video

[@DeathValleyDazed]

Agreed, Hauri should reveal his face sporting a “goat-ee” 🐐

[@LeLeafBoi]

Your content on yt is really good binging material, as well as some good info. Good soup!!!

[@accountforcommenting]

Google is also planning trying ad business like this with no tracking to for ad

[@TCKRDefense]

Market capitalization of Alphabet (Google) (GOOG) Market cap: $1.226 Trillion As of March 2023 Alphabet (Google) has a market cap of $1.226 Trillion. This makes Alphabet (Google) the world's 4th most valuable company

[@harisgunasekaran4874]

You mean to say, data will be stored in encrypted form and advertisers would be able to access the that data? how Is it different from what google or meta is doing?

[@shreyasmididoddi2136]

You know apple already has all our data it just doesn't share it with third parties, it is mentioned in their privacy policy. Apple collcts your ( personal ) data but doesn't sell it ( yet ) that's it. Apple can take all the ads from the companies and distribute themselves based on its relevance to user that way they don't share the data to third parties but can still show targetted ads. This restricts third parties but they have no other choice

[@nxb00]

fed alert

[@caseychaffin5445]

If Apple moves to ads then I’m moving to rooted android to block ads

[@apolloaerospace7773]

600 $ "value" for an office Mac with too little RAM and storage to do anything intensive. The option with 16GB and 1TB respectively costs 1200$ with specs considered entry level on PC. But I will admit it probably works for getting people into the ecosystem and to bait the media.

[@QnjtGWonQNqVsbYyzjx4]

Another reason is the change of CEO or critical people due to massive change in philosophy this year like dynamic island instead of the trusted notch, plus in favour of the mini Tim Cook believed, MacBook don’t feature the iMac design and iOS 16 arbitrary limit software features in iPad. Tim Cook believed Privacy make the brand better, where the new CEO or critical people think sales is more important

[@SuperVratik]

These arguments not just flawed but downright wrong!

[@token3462]

Bro, you have to work on your sound mixing…. In the chapter 4 : Software Giant, the bg music is wayyyy tooo loud!

[@ross4]

Just a correction it's pronounced "iPhone 10" not "iPhone X."

[@pawe1]

Awesome video, content, editing, sound effects, story telling all are spot on. 💯🔥

[@DeathValleyDazed]

Just read all comments and so many negative about sound and errors. Wondering if you need to re-think the skill set of your editors? Your editors need to enhance your presence on KZbin, not detract. I hope they read this comment and step it up a couple of notches!

[@CazDesignStudios]

Apple. Apps cannot track you, BUT WE CAN

[@kevinneu]

the music doesnt fit/is distracting imo compared to your other videos, particulary 8:33

[@blastum]

(1) Your take that Apple isn't actually concerned about privacy is cynical and, I think, false; this being borne out by the design of encryption/decentralization/invisibility in all their services and such, the AirTags, and that weird child porn thing they haven't implemented yet. (2) the primary concern people have about ad tracking is aggregation across sites. People don't care if Facebook tracks your use of Facebook; they are concerned if Facebook knows of every other site you access. This would have been a useful point to add. (3) I doubt people will particularly mind targeted ads if the advertisers don't know to whom it is being sent to or why. That's infinitely preferable to Facebook analytics.

[@ejiro237]

You called the CEO Tim Apple 💀

[@theobserver3753]

How an option to opt out from apple ads

[@0Aether]

Me watching this on an Apple device: 😞

[@BlindMango]

Did he just call the iPhone 10 the “iPhone X”? Oh noooo I thought only old people did that lol

[@ashish4451]

Not first, but a fan

[@LogicallyAnswered]

Thanks for your support Ashish!

[@ashish4451]

@@LogicallyAnswered always there for you man

[@chadchey4049]

This is a waste of time. I thought there is an explicit information that Apple will pivot in terms of respecting privacy but apparently, those were all speculations, by the content creator, with no proof if these are correct.

[@markusklyver6277]

I hope they do not do the printer strategy

[@SamuelKarani]

the quality of your videos has jumped up suddenly like these new apple M-chips from intel

[@LogicallyAnswered]

Really appreciate that Samuel! Trying to up the quality!

[@IDarkCalibur]

11:24 until 14:11 is what you’re looking for in this vid

[@A1stardan]

Ads: worst enemy of humanity lol

[@nikyabodigital]

If they do ads then I feel sad for Zuckerberg

[@JemcyYT]

Logically Answered, you were featured on Scarce’s latest video (KZbin news channel)

[@LogicallyAnswered]

Yo really? That’s insane!

[@solembum78]

You make very good content with interesting information but you should do something either with your mic or your editing. Voice is hard to hear, especially if watching this in 1.5X speed. Some good compression and eq would improve quality of videos a lot. And for informational videos like this, voice is more important than video.

[@misaonthefly]

That is the same reasoning behind Google announcing they would be eliminating third party cookies from Chrome...

[@sonofage]

In my country, they have 30+% of iphone users . They act like their privacy is protected meanwhile they overshare on social media. Lol

[@fvs666]

same with android

[@itsmaxim01]

I mean I’m cool with Apple advertising as long as I can opt out with a subscription or smth

[@MrAgility888]

3:13 Lol, Tim Apple

[@SreejithKSGupta]

Step 1: create a video- complete.... Step 2: people actually watch,understand and accept...

[@yungifez]

My dude made a video telling us not to like it🤣🤣

[@OGLechaba]

Lol, so Tim Apple is officially his name

[@MsBen678]

3:13 You said "Tim Apple" instead of "Tim Cook"

[@X_mano]

What does subsciption to do with Jesus?? Is there a context I'm unaware of??? I'm curious, please someone answer!!!!

[@scarface5857]

whats with the sound in this video? it's weird

[@LogicallyAnswered]

Thanks for the feedback man

[@scarface5857]

@@LogicallyAnswered thank you for the great content! always cool videos :) just noticed the sound was a bit off on this one!

[@colt5189]

I do like Apple engaging in more privacy measures. But I never believed they were doing this on behalf of the user's interests. But were doing it as a way to compete against Google since their business model is different than Google. So while I like it, I'm not necessarily going to be giving Apple high fives. Plus, Apple has been found to be lying on what they collect on you.

[@RobVI]

Since when does Google drive cost money

[@eionthegod]

There’s a paid version that gives you more features and more storage

[@RobVI]

@@eionthegod oh I forgot about that

[@sircharlesross537]

13:44 is no one going to comment on how Logically answered literally just gave Apple the winning solution for their ad service?

[@taktungtuang9118]

This will become a problem when Apple enters the metaverse (you don't want the metaverse to be a closed and walled garden).

[@bruxi78230]

Metaverse is a Facebook/Meta term. It is a Facebookian concept. Apple with their reality products will not be using the term nor are they interested in the concept. Facebook has spent mega-bucks on a abject failure.

[@TCKRDefense]

Market capitalization of Apple (AAPL) Market cap: $2.422 Trillion As of March 2023 Apple has a market cap of $2.422 Trillion. This makes Apple the world's most valuable company

[@mike_gyver]

What can I say..... Logically Answered. I was not quite aware of the this. Great Video- thanks!

[@LogicallyAnswered]

Thank you Mike!

[@Hollowdude15]

I feel like apple did the right thing by creating the app tracking transparency and great video man :]

[@sarthakbiswas6925]

If Facebook and WhatsApp stop making iOS apps, people would switch to Android lol... They can beat Apple in their own game.

[@fvs666]

XD, nope, more people will just use telegram, or imessage which is already most used mess app in USA

[@cs1825]

Or they might get an alternative messaging client like Signal or Vibe. (But good luck convincing people to switch to switch to another messaging client)

[@accountforcommenting]

You should pronounce X as 10

[@JMusar795]

3:14 😂😂😂😂😂

[@FireFoxDestroyer]

I would guess to keep waste out of the water, we could have more subscription services instead of big investments

[@lamenwatch1877]

5:10 Don't you mean firmware?

[@ConorBurrow]

The 'X' in Apple's naming strategy isn't pronounced as the letter X but instead as the number 10, taking the X from Roman Numerals. Mac OS X followed Mac OS 9 for example. Always annoys me when its pronounced as a letter...

[@0volts157]

Apple's stupidity. Don't make folks switch between the two when branding a product. OS 10 would have worked just fine.