CRITIQUING MY VIEWERS' ART! #6 😲

[@Love2DrawManga]

*EDIT! Sorry I didn't know about Makima's eyes at the start of the video. I've never watched that anime. My critique would still apply, but I would add back in the yellow circles.* 🌸Use code "DRAWMANGA" to receive $5 off for your first #Sakuraco box through my link: team.sakura.co/love2drawmanga or your first #TokyoTreat box through my link: team.tokyotreat.com/love2drawmanga

[@MissRowynn]

I was thinking about that lol! You’re good!

[@popitsdiy5079]

One comment? Lemme fix that 19 likes? lemme fix that

[@danicathephoenixfoxhybrid]

Hiiiii. Hopefully you've seen my email with the critique

[@givekirigirilove]

You give me a lot of inspiration(also I was rushing to make a comment earlier bc I didn’t wanna miss the post lol)

[@danicathephoenixfoxhybrid]

@@givekirigirilove she gives me inspiration too 😁

[@EL-xt2fz]

I love how Rebekah is such an inspiration, even with the AI generated submission I love how she encouraged the artist to keep drawing instead of flaming then for trying to pass with AI. Thank you for helping so many people including me ^^^

[@legendofzeldalover44]

Yeah, true ^^

[@tsaraouth-4329]

yeah, although AI is really unethical, I personally think that a creator that teaches drawing should exactly do what she did.

[@naraku971]

@@tsaraouth-4329 Later builds are a lot more ethical seeing as they use stock imagery, such has been found to be the case of later builds of Midjourney and Stable Diffusion at least.

[@Basic_Cat]

@@naraku971oh cool

[@njnjco]

AI is a tool just like any other. If used too much it can become a crutch. That being said, I'm new at art, so don't listen to anything I say, lol.

[@Duskerlicious]

1:36 OMG THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR CRITIQUING MY ART!!! It's such an honor! Will definitely keep your tips in mind

[@dedadeda_]

Wait that's your art it's so good

[@Duskerlicious]

@@dedadeda_ Thank you!

[@AwesomeDoggy88]

Your art style is so cute! Really like the shading

[@small_and_dangerous2068]

Your art is so cute!! Good job with the improvement, I love it!! Your choice of color really made the piece feel unique and adorable 🥹❤️

[@kmdraws64]

Dude its so colorful and I absolutely love your style! Do you have an art instagram by any chance? :0

[@laughingraven8816]

Thank you for addressing the AI issue in such a positive encouraging way. With AI becoming more and more common in the art community, I think artists, especially younger artists, need to realize the value of their own unique styles and abilities. You said it so nicely. I love your videos, by the way. You're my favorite ArtTuber.

[@SaplingofSpunk]

I think you are such a cool person in general. You never tear anyone down and you're kind with almost everything you do! I appreciate how thoughtful you are, and your art is amazing. The world needs more people like you. :)

[@Love2DrawManga]

Aw! Thank you so much! ^u^

[@Archon_Of_Rizz]

Dude, did you draw your pfp? It's adorable!

[@SaplingofSpunk]

@@Archon_Of_Rizz Aw thank you! While I did draw it, it was a gender-bend panel redraw from a webtoon comic (High Class Homos if you were curious :P)

[@mrgee8447]

17:54 this is mine!!! Thank you so much! I totally forgot about the highlights lol anyways thank you again that was a big help for my improvement 💪💪❤

[@qtpwyo]

hoshino ai!!! 💕

[@wattlebu]

I love that drawing!! congrats on getting in the video 😆

[@Love2DrawManga]

Happy I can help. =D

[@IvyYillz]

ITS SO PRETTY WHAT???

[@chloellama9926]

Omg it’s so pretty! It’s better than my artwork of Ai haha

[@dedadeda_]

Bekah is such a nice person for not shaming this person for using AI to enhance their art like some people would just be making fun of this person I love that Bekah Ly!!

[@naraku971]

I try to keep up with the development of later builds of various AI programs, and think that AI is an excellent tool, and I think that especially people are overlooking that there are AI programs that have switched to using stock imagery, Like I know that's the case with I believe the latest stable diffusion build and some of the later builds of Midjourney are made primarily of stock photos from royalty free Stock photo sites such as Shutter Stock, but another thing that people don't take into consideration is that in general, there's people who seem to think that AI is going to replace artists, and that it's possible to somehow steal a style, which is stupid, and kinda narcissistic sounding, you can't have agency of something over something like art style, especially given that I've seen artists who don't know each other have similar art styles, also people are always going to value artists made by people more.

[@mango3441]

No AI can take away the happiness we feel when we finish a piece of art

[@floralets]

It’s very mature how you handled the AI experience! I’ve had a case where even though I submitted all my art proof and layers, the moderators of a discord art server still wouldn’t let me in cos they said my art looked like AI art style ^^” I didn’t know how to react or if I should be happy or not but AI ‘style’ is still inspired by real artists

[@moonarixx1587]

Ah, do you know their address?

[@floralets]

@@moonarixx1587 may I know what do you mean by that? ^^”

[@nvenvyvill3698]

​@@floralets I'm pretty sure they're asking for the discord moderator's address so that they could.... visit them 🙂🔪

[@Scoutsilver008]

19:09 OMG!!! My art got in again?? I'm surprised you managed to recognize my art style. XD Tysm for the critiques, I'll be sure to keep them in mind!

[@wattlebu]

LOL congrats on getting in twice

[@Scoutsilver008]

⁠@@wattlebu Lmao thank you, it still feels surreal oml 😭

[@IvyYillz]

SO PRETTYYY

[@randomperson-oe8ff]

I find it so awesome how Rebekah wasn't mean to the person who used ai and instead encouraged them to show their own art! She is so kind and sweet :))

[@hanin_gurl]

edit: thank you for continuing to encourage artists to draw art that is truly theirs!

[@just_vanille0064]

Your videos are basically a part of my weekly routine 😭🫶🏻

[@achiblitz_]

Same

[@AwesomeDoggy88]

Same

[@briteya_art]

2:40 thank you so much for the compliments! And thank you so much for your advice! I definitely struggle with lighting, it’s one of my art goals for this year. I’m so glad you think it’s cute 🥰

[@inumix4]

I have a tip I use for lighting, because I also have a struggle with lighting... I usually draw a circle in the side where the light is coming from, like an imaginary sun, and keep in mind to draw light on the side where it comes from, and shades on the opposite side

[@trademarkt]

your art is so cute!!!

[@briteya_art]

@@trademarkt oh my goodness thank you so much 🥺❤️✨

[@briteya_art]

@@inumix4 thank you for your tip ❤️❤️❤️

[@dxndelionxx]

4:50 Aaaaa I got chosen! :D Thanks for the critique! I find perspective hard and forget to check if it's correct but I'll try to keep perspective in mind from now on :)

[@anythingforstories]

Your characters look soooooooo good! I love your style!

[@choreocious]

3:45 i never noticed this until now! :O i always added heavy noise and chromatic abberation in my art because i assumed it made it look more interesting, but i never realized it took away from it. i'm so glad i watched this video :) tysm rebekah!

[@TCIdraws]

1:34 for this piece they are drawing a character from chainsaw man and her character has spirals in the eyes so I don’t think you should have taken that out because it’s a very character defining feature. (Also if you do this again how could I enter)❤

[@Luna-us]

Maybe rebekah didnt know😓

[@Dri3xA]

I have a feeling that she wouldn't watch Chainsaw Man so she wouldn't know about Makima

[@ii.sxlary8742]

She wrote in the description how you could enter

[@TCIdraws]

@@ii.sxlary8742 ok thank you!

[@Love2DrawManga]

Thanks for letting me know. I did not know that. 😅I've never watched chainsaw man. I tell how to enter in the description of the video. 😁

[@rennnrennnn]

i like how you don't change the style like other artists do. you improve it but still keep it stylized and don't just do the "you're style is wrong" thing a lot of people do

[@AwesomeDoggy88]

This video is super helpful! I never really understood vanishing points that well, but you explained it in such an easy to understand way that I feel like I can now apply it to my own art

[@Love2DrawManga]

Glad it was helpful! =D

[@Queen_Katt]

Even though I didn’t submit, I still got a lot of great advice so thank you!

[@raeraem0n]

6:00 very interesting! I really hate perspectives but since I've been mind blown to those tips and idea, I must give it a shot!

[@EllaBonbon]

I’ve never had the courage to draw backgrounds but that really helped my understanding of horizon lines! Also I sincerely appreciate her respect of peoples’ art styles while maintaining an objective point of view all the while. She’s really sweet c:

[@marli_the_cat]

hello! I was playing a mobile game called Kawaii home designer, where you can decorate cute rooms with many items. i thought it would make for a good video if you made a room in the game and then tried to draw it as a background? since i think you've mentioned struggling with backgrounds, it would be good practice as well. its just a suggestion :3

[@creepywaffles4783]

Ooo! That sounds like a good video idea I hope she sees this!

[@HopeIsADrug11037]

everyone's art is so nice :00 you always critique with such kindness and it's always really nice :DD

[@Noblesse_Sapphire]

This is such a fun way to learn, your voice is so calming and soothing, you're also so kind, encouraging, actually making art less intimidating for new artists 💙💙 and I love love love your accent, I think it's so cute 😭💙

[@Love2DrawManga]

Aw, thank you so much! 💕

[@technotoister]

i like how u didn't discriminate the artist who used AI, while i don't like AI "art" i can appreciate u being nice to them and encouraging them to keep drawing their own art

[@andreea_75]

I love how you aren't judging the art! You respect each style and you help make it look pleasing! I love your artstyle and I wish I could be you

[@Cloud_mv]

Watching your art critiqie videos help me a lot 😊

[@Love2DrawManga]

Happy they help! =D

[@Cloud_mv]

@@Love2DrawManga ❤️❤️❤️

[@lav-kitty]

3:15 I think the "shading" on the shoulder is actually more of like a blush? but yeah, it applies to the hand

[@gabrielnalom4930]

You handled the AI portion with a lot of class! Props to you!

[@Shadowxfheaven]

I love how you give actual advice and tips to help the artist. Most art tubers I see on youtube like to make fun of the art piece and lean towards being harsh rather than being a bit nicer to the artist and giving actual tips. I think some art tubers forget that these artists might be young and are still learning there ways. I just love how kind you are and gentle with the way you give advice.

[@leoartwork]

I have so much respect for you being so friendly and calm about the AI picture. I would have been super pissed if someone would send me this

[@EggoBeggo__]

I love how you don’t completely change the art style and how you give helpful tips, thank you for doing that!

[@Love2DrawManga]

🌸Use code "DRAWMANGA" to receive $5 off for your first #Sakuraco box through my link: team.sakura.co/love2drawmanga or your first #TokyoTreat box through my link: team.tokyotreat.com/love2drawmanga

[@IcyeFaethyvve]

You should make a playlist for the "Critiquing my viewers' art" series you have - first thing I did when I found this video was go back to try and find the other 5 :D

[@Love2DrawManga]

Oh! I didn't realize I didn't have them in a playlist. Thanks for letting me know! They are now in a playlist here: kzbin.info/aero/PLWp4kPwtWDF2D2EHzu1FiAw-sL_Y4b8np&si=WmXLCIZUaT8JX7R2

[@SUTAZZZ]

5:35 YOUR SO CUTE😭

[@GMisEpicYuh]

BRUH WHY WOULD SOMEONE SEND AI 'ART' smh Edit: L2DM handled this with so much kindness tbh props to her

[@amnesiacsandwich66]

I love you do this so we can learn from the best! Glad to see these kinds of videos. Have a great weekend everyone! How are you Rebekah?

[@Love2DrawManga]

I am doing very well. ^u^

[@sunnysketches]

All these drawings are amazing!!! I love all your videos:DDD I love how your never harsh to anyone, but encouraging! That’s one of the many things I love about you and your channel

[@Love2DrawManga]

Thank you so much! It is going well, things are coming together. =D

[@sunnysketches]

@@Love2DrawManga yay! :DDD

[@AnnaHiestand]

I love this series; I always learn so much, and I enjoy seeing everyone's art styles. And you do such a great job with the critiques. I'd love to see even more of these videos in the future. ❤

[@15_heidune72]

The internet needs more people like you.

[@_its_gl]

I love watching these videos, you give such good advice every time! I also love how you’re so encouraging and never shame anyone for any aspects of their art. It’s really uplifting, even if my art isn’t the art being critiqued!

[@starrz.x0x]

i love how she starts out every picture by complementing the art

[@mirai5451]

It's been a while since I last saw your videos ! I noticed how much you improved and you're helping others to improve too , you're such an inspiration to young and beginner artists ,specially me !

[@bangus4785]

1:35 her eyes before are her actual canon eyes noooo makima's eyes have those golden rings

[@Tree_boyy]

I love how you do this bc it not only helps the people who submit but also it helps the viewers

[@PloverTechOfficial]

All of the art looks so amazing! Your critique was wonderful to watch, Have a wonderful day as well!

[@NatTheRat2]

4:28 I add chronic abbrevation to a lot of my art and how I do it is I will dupe my character layer, add the abbrevation, and erase it where I don't want it 👍

[@squidtoldme1234]

7:47 This was my art and tysmmm this helped me so much ^u^

[@Love2DrawManga]

Yay! Happy I can help!

[@zerareota1560]

When I add finishing touches/affects I tend to erase lightly around high detail areas like the face or hands or anything meticulous so you can get the affect without making your art hard to look at

[@Mansixoxyt]

Rebekah in the first one the character's eyes were supposed to be spirals and it was fanart but your crituque was good.

[@pigleet]

woah i just found your channel and this video was really enjoyable to watch, you're so positive ;o and ill be sure to consider your tips in my drawings! keep up the amazing work

[@mismiserables]

That tip about how to place characters in perspective was really helpful. I never thought of doing that before.

[@antranettatillmanprivatele8665]

I learn sooo much from Rebekah I am improving my art too thanks to you🎉 thank you!❤

[@smartfoodpopcorn123]

Thank you so much for all your amazing work!, keep it up♥

[@Lyu_Angel]

12:33 The fact that Shenhe gets called unhuman in the game 💀

[@venti2569]

nah youre right 💀😭

[@spicypeache2704]

9:08 i feel like the blurred seaweed in the front was kind of making it hard for me to look at. i know i’m not the best drawer but yeah

[@pinkdiamond44400]

I love how you help with art. Especially the part about showing and character in perspective. I was wondering could you still use AI when you’re in a drawing slump? Sometimes I use it to come up with ideas.

[@fallabeaufaebelle]

Love your videos! You’re always so encouraging and do a great job building artists up

[@Nox_Atra]

Pretty sure that was not a shading on her shoulder on 3:31, it was more like a blush but with the rest you was right

[@Rosalie-z4w]

Thank you soo much for doing this format!!❤ It's really my favorite because I can learn so much out of this!!

[@copesupply]

17:14 The second image, even not img2img'd by AI, feels like it just has been ripped off from CharlesC's KDA Ahri fan art.

[@vampybyte7812]

I actually think you handled the AI situation very well and understanding. I like to pop my pieces in AI to see if theres any element it adds I would like to add myself. I honestly think there is nothing 100% wrong with using Ai, just becomes an issue when you try to pass it off as yours. I'm just one of those people that finds hating something like that with every fiber of my being exhausting , I got work and life to do that already, long as the person is really just using ai for inspiration or ideas I really see no issue. Over all I think you handled the situation very maturely and gave the person some sound advice.

[@blulsixl1004]

Be careful bc I've heard there are some AI generators that store the images you use in their AI systems

[@vampybyte7812]

@@blulsixl1004 I'm honestly not even that bothered about that because I generally use photos that aren't for any of my larger projects or experimental art regardless. I guess I just really don't have that mentality of "all my work can't be shared/ used" I haven't even found my true final style yet either and I've been drawing a long time, I guess that's why I'm really not too bothered or afraid of that? Ai is Ai and regardless if it did take elements of my style, it would be mashing it together with other elements as well. I don't condone those people who made ai specifically to copy other's styles though, that was clearly done out of malicious intent. I mostly use an app that generates anime like pictures anyway which is kind of my style but not truly because I am a gothic artist as well, it's still not a set mix of the two as i still got a lot to learn and grow.

[@Wisteriaaaaaaa]

the thing is most ai nowadays steals other artist's artworks to be able to generate more stylized and accurate prompts, so ai that steals art is definitely wrong and most ai does that

[@uGotCAGED]

really good job actually explaining why its ai art instead of just accusing them becuase it looks like it. im also an artist and didnt really notice these, im impressed

[@S0yB3ans]

Even though I didn't get picked it was still fun to see everyones submissions! The different types of artstyles are so cool to look at!

[@andysartz]

I love these critique videos, I always learn so much from them! Thank you for sharing, Bekka! After watching these videos, I always feel like drawing immediately, and that's precisely what I'm going to do, haha!

[@SUTAZZZ]

Your so kind when critiquing even to the AI one this is why i love watching your vids!😭💞

[@JellyFnaf]

This video really helped me! I can't wait for your next video!!

[@sakurasketches]

Your critiques are all rlly helpful!

[@zerareota1560]

I always draw mouths so low to the face but it’s more that I’m like averse to giving proper amounts of chin. I think part of it is that my rendering style is very flat and I don’t think abt the three dimensionality of the lips and chin until I draw a side profile

[@twillacatron7596]

im so glad you have critique videos

[@RedStarBoi416]

You have a nice critique on all of these artworks.

[@pawprint6134]

Omg I can't believe mine got in, it really brightened my day, especially cause I"m sick haha. I'll definitely keep your tips in mind, thank you so much for working so hard to help us!!

[@tempertenchi]

aww I love this video, youre so helpful and sweet! these tips actually helped me grasp a few things as well!

[@sobble.overlord]

17:31 | Bowser? Is that you? (/j)

[@sleepysloth8022]

The anatomy tips were the ones that helped me the most throughout! Def will probably remember for my art 😅

[@ArtofAmethystFable]

I learned some new tips too, these are such helpful videos for anyone!

[@LazyLizzy]

With the amount of comments on this video and how late I am, I doubt you’ll see this, Bekah, but a thought came to me that you could do a video/series of something along the lines of “critiquing your character designs”!! I can totally see it helping both the people who submitted the characters as well as the people watching, just like this “critiquing your art” series! It could be similar to this one, except instead of critiquing proportions and lighting and such, it would be the designs themselves? If that makes sense. Might be a bad idea but I wanted to throw this out there just in case!!

[@someoneovertheinternet4417]

6:20 How had I never thought of this!!!! I'm going to start using this technique

[@tsunih]

Your videos are the highlight of my weekend♥ Also, thank you somuch for that perspective tip. I always struggle so muh with that kind of things.

[@Brot-Watching]

Ok but I didn't notice the noise or the chromatic abrasion in the pictures at 4:12. To me the effects aren't that strong 🤔🤨

[@BisexuaLex]

I love ur art and your feedback! You’re so nice even when showing that someone used ai!

[@IgnoreThisChannelForNow]

Man, most people say that they started taking drawing more seriously a few years ago and their art looks really nice meanwhile I'm drawing most of my life and sure, I didn't draw masterpieces at 4 y/o but I can't even draw hair, faces nor anatomy... Actually, scratch that. I magically improved in drawing hands and some other things mostly by watching people like you draw and I hope the best for anyone reading this! Have a nice day or night

[@banji7612]

I would like to submit something too but I feel like my art (I know it sounds pretty cocky) would be very out of place here as I'm pretty advanced? Idk how to say it I don't even know if you can improve it as our styles are VERY different( my arstyle is more on the darker unsaturated semi realistic style) But I do know I'm not perfect and ofcourse I still learn as I still have my share of difficulties

[@legendofzeldalover44]

By the way, will there be another "I draw your OC" or "I draw your Gacha character" episode?

[@tbluemon6292]

Great video and I got to say that you are being really honest on people artwork so definitely they can learned a great or too.

[@zigglylikesslipknot]

MAKIMAS EYES 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@blinthepannkek6173]

Would definitely take these advices! Thank you so much!

[@AbdouAbdou-ks3jo]

I love so mutch your art and I’m a big fann❤❤

[@KittyOpikaz._0fficial]

I love how she is like ‘aw this drawing amazing’ the Kooleen is js like ‘what is this it’s a donkey’💀

[@Cult_of_Rosalina]

your videos are amazing just to lison to whilst drawing myself and to watch!

[@devonteedwards2093]

Really great critique on the art, they look really cool

[@Tootie-e2.0]

Amazing video!! I always get nice feedback on some skills that I hope to master better ✨💜

[@andriuwu4037]

I think on the second one, the shoulder had blush, not shading! It was the same color as the blush on the cheeks and the only part soft, the rest of the shading was sharp

[@TheVenomology]

1:11 oh you probably don't know about makima or chainsaw man. The eye is supposed to be like that with the circles and stuff

[@gints2766]

For the person being lit by the moon maybe they could put a reflection of the moon in their eyes. It would be stylized and not realistic but I think having a bit of moon in their eyes would be cool, also maybe cooler light

[@legendofzeldalover44]

Aw man. My art wasn't in this But I sent some pictures again, maybe for a new "episode" of this ^^

[@DesareeAlvarez]

14:07 The way she avoided saying the word “nipple”…

[@GryffindorDolls]

5:04 is that a scene from hunger games?

[@Himariix]

Hello there!! I’m kinda early :D your art is so good can’t wait to watch :> ❤ (Edit) I’m kinda disappointed that mine wasn’t there but maybe next time! The ones you did critique was really good too!